Please open https://hotaudiobook.com ONLY on your standard browser Safari, Chrome, Microsoft or Firefox to download full audiobooks of your choice for free.
Title: What Mr. Mattero Did
Author: Priscilla Cummings
Narrator: Eve Bianco
Format: Unabridged
Length: 5 hrs and 4 mins
Language: English
Release date: 03-28-08
Publisher: Penguin Group USA and Audible
Ratings: 3 of 5 out of 14 votes
Genres: Teens, Ages 11-13
Publisher's Summary:
Told from two points of view, Claire's and Melody's, this novel takes readers into their private middle-school worlds as the girls struggle to discover the truth.
Critic Reviews:
"The book provides a great deal of high-interest suspense, and, when the issue of what Mr. Mattero did is finally resolved, readers get an ending that's both satisfying and realistic." (School Library Journal)
"An age-appropriate introduction to a difficult topic." (Booklist)
Members Reviews:
The impact of a sexual abuse report on a family and community
Grade: B+
Claire and her two seventh grade friends report that their teacher, Mr Mattero, molested them, setting off a series of events they never expected. His daughter, Melody, an eighth grader at their middle school feels that impact hardest. But what really happened in that music room, and are the girls telling the truth.
Told in both Claire and Melody's POVs, WHAT MR MATTERO DID is s thoughtful look at friendship, peer pressure, family, and sexual abuse. Although Claire clearly made some awful decisions, she was more troubled than bad. At home she was lost in the shuffle between her special needs brother and toddler sister. She lacked confidence, had an eating disorder and followed her dominating friend into trouble. Melody was less complex of a character, purer in her feelings and actions. Her POV of the devastation the accusations had on the entire Mattero felt raw and honest.
Priscilla Cummings created a great preteen voice in Claire and Melody, unfortunately the voices were the same for both girls. I did enjoy Cummings' writing. I'm not sure where she came up with the statistics that 20% of sexual abuse allegations are false, all the statistics I've read have the number much lower. Yes, it happens, but far more minors, mostly girls, are molested than report. Many cases can't be proven because only about 30% of cases have DNA linked to a perp because of delays in reporting, certain acts don't create DNA. I wonder wherever Cummings got her stats included cases that couldn't be proven in the number. I'd hate for tweens to get the wrong idea about victims and believability.
THEMES: sexual abuse, friendship, family, peer pressure, eating disorders
Sexually Abused Nymphets?
In What Mr. Mattero Did by Priscilla Cummings, three seventh-grade girls, Jenna, Suzanne, and Claire, told their middle-school principal that Mr. Mattero, the music teacher, had molested them.
I was immediately suspicious of the girl's claims, because most victims of sexual abuse never report being harmed. They may mention it to a friend, but rarely to their parents or to the authorities. However, victims are more likely to report abuse once another victim's wrong has been exposed. Moreover, according to Joan J. Johnson in her book Teen Prostitution, in most cases, sexually abused nymphets are victims of incest. In other words, nymphets are most commonly molested their fathers or step-fathers, but in some cases the brother, uncle or cousin is the abuser.
That is exactly what happened in What Mr. Mattero Did. Phoebe, another seventh grader, confessed to Claire that she was sexually abused by her step-father. Phoebe confessed to Claire, because she thought that Claire was a victim of sexual abuse as well.
"You're the only person I've told," Phoebe said. "'Cause you've been through it, Claire.