
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


In this short, we taste flavored KitKats and discuss M. Night Shyamalan flicks. Matt tells the tale of a mysterious car in England. Early December, 2002, a call comes in to a small British police station regarding a car swerving off the road on the A3. What follows is a mystery that has turned into an urban legend.
Send us suggestions on weird foods, and send us odd flavor Kit Kats you think we'd like to try on the show!
This episode's food selection is from The Pizza Place
In this episode, the main creeps explain their love for "mall pizza" and the cast of Criminal Minds, and they both get on some soap boxes. Kelsey covers a local true crime story, one of serial killer James Childers. James confessed on a tape he sent to police, admitting to the killing of five people as well as committing four arsons. Childers buried four of the victims on a family farm, discarding the body of the fifth.
If you would like to donate to help with food and relief efforts in the Eastern Kentucky region during this terrible flooding, please go to https://mercychefs.com/ky-floods/
In this short appetizer, we try an interesting grape pop made in Alabama by Buffalo Rock. Kelsey then tries to burn Matt's taste buds. Matt attempts talking while eating the reaper Cheetos and it goes sort of well. Kelsey tells the story of Megan Hess, a funeral home operator in Colorado who was illegally selling body parts, and then giving mixed, or sometimes even fake ashes to clients.
This episode's food selection is from Minard's Spaghetti Inn
In this episode, Matt covers a cult group called The Church of Synanon, detailing their long history of violence and abuse towards members. This story is centered around how this cult affected the life of former football player Warren Wells, when he was forced into rehab with Synanon by the court.
Don't worry, pretty sure they liked the snack this time... We try Zapp's New Orleans Kettle Style Potato chips, in the interesting Cajun Dill Gator-tator flavor. Matt covers the story of an odd Jane Doe, a mysterious severed head that was found in the woods around Economy, Pennsylvania.
For more information on what Kelsey touched on, visit DoeNetwork.org for the International Center For Unidentified and Missing Persons. If you have any details you're able to give concerning this case, contact Economy Police Department: 724-869-7877.
This episode's food selection is from several places:
In this episode, Michael and Britt are guests again on this second part of our foodie trip to Charleston. We tried several goodies and also argue about poutine. Matt then covers an active missing persons case from Charleston, the disappearance of Mazie Mae Sigmon-Palmer, as well as the mysterious death of her boyfriend Jay Farley. Contact the Kanawha County Sheriff's Department if you have any information on this case.
In this short, Matt and Kelsey try the new Flamin' Hot flavor of Mountain Dew. They surprise themselves with spicy refreshment. Both also demand that the folks at Mountain Dew make more sugar free versions of their other flavors. Afterwards, Matt briefly talks about the Taj Mahal of West Virginia, also called New Vrindaban, located near Moundsville, WV.
This episode's food selection is from Dem 2 Brothers And A Grill
In this episode, Michael, Britt, and Mini Creep join us to travel on our first weekend trip to try foodie destinations in Charleston, West Virginia. Kelsey then covers the death of Lacey Fletcher, and the horrible story of how her parents allegedly kept her inside the house until her death. Trigger warning, this story is particularly gory, graphic, and details abuse. Listen at your own discretion.
In this short, Matt and Kelsey reluctantly smell and taste the Vlasic Dill Pickle flavored Slim Jim, giving their honest opinion of this convenience store meat snack. Afterwards, Kelsey tells the story of the recent murder of Jimmy Lee Barkley, which occurred in October of 2021. Jimmy's body was recovered around Eglon, Preston County, WV. Barkley was kidnapped, bound, and taken to a remote cabin, where he was shot to death.
This episode's food selection is from The Lunchbox Food Truck
In this episode Matt covers the death of Elva Zona Heaster, known in popular culture as the Greenbrier Ghost. This lady was killed in her 20s in the 1890s, allegedly by her husband, a blacksmith named Trout. This took place during the heyday of spiritualism, mediums, and seances of the turn of the century. The killing was alleged to be true with the given legal testimony of a ghost, where the ghost of Zona supposedly visited her mother and told her that Trout was the murderer. This led to Trout's conviction, the first time anything of this nature had occurred in a US court. Tune in to find out whether Zona was killed or stuck in an "everlasting faint"
From the publisher's feed