In this episode, the Creeps try the new Spiced Coca-Cola flavor.

Then, Kelsey tells the recent story of a (now former) Dairy Queen manager in Kentucky, who allegedly told employees to consume ice cream that had been contaminated with cleaning solution. There's a lot of swearing in this one.

They also talk about Arby's vs Rax, candle wax, the lengths Matt will go to for cherry dipped cones, buying discounted weird stuff in bulk, and other fast food facts Kelsey's never heard of...

This week, we try Blue Moose Coffee Shop, located at 248 Walnut St. Morgantown, WV. Open Sun-Tue 7:00AM-3:00PM, Wed 7:00AM-9:00PM, Thur-Sat 7:00AM-8:00PM. Here's what we tried: lavender matcha muffin, cheddar and scallion scone

In this episode, Kelsey delves deep into Part Two of her story on Tom Green (the infamous polygamist NOT the actor) who found himself in serious legal trouble after making gross incriminating remarks on national talk shows. Matt also goes into the story of his not so sacred Salt Lake excursion.

They also talk about spider guys, unused search engines, coffee creepin', good drip, and pastry side preference (top, bottom, end, middle). Note: the Creeps tried to keep the scone and not give the editor any, they failed

This week, we're diving into an entire bag of Mister Bee's chips, in a Tudor's Biscuit World themed sausage biscuits and gravy flavor. This variety was made so that a portion of sales benefits the local West Virginia Make-a-Wish foundation.

The Creeps also tried AriZona Extra Sweet Tropsicle Juice Cocktail to wash down those amazing chips.

Kelsey and Matt try to figure out how Mister Bee's keep making accurate delicious chip flavor concoctions, and demand that they (never) stop making chips this good.

Then, Matt tells a very new story about the Lincoln, Nebraska man that stole a skid loader from his boss, drove it to a big box store, and went on a rampage throughout the streets and their parking lot, in the winter of 2024.

The Creeps also talk about bomb pops and wanting to joyride work equipment.

This week, we try baked pastries from Durar Coffee, located at 300 High St. Morgantown, WV. Open Sun-Wed 7:00AM-10:00PM, Thur-Sat 7:00AM-Midnight. Here's what we tried:

Apple turnover, cherry Danish, pistachio cup

In this episode, Kelsey delves deep into Part One of her story on Tom Green (the infamous polygamist NOT the actor) who found himself in serious legal trouble after making gross incriminating remarks on national talk shows.

They also talk about springer, silent reading, big love, dumb friends, and sold out honey bread. Stay tuned for Part Two, where Matt promises to talk about his not-so-sacred trip to Salt Lake.

This week, the Creeps try Hanami Prawn flavored crackers, and then they get sad.

Kelsey gives us a brief story about cartels who had taken over a news station in Ecuador, as well as the rising crime in the region.

They also talk about golden girls, late night snacks, freedom of press/speech/media, and accidental bad chicken.

This week, we try Christmas 365 variety of tea from Rendezbrews, a coffee shop located at 76 W Main St, Grafton, WV. Open Mon-Fri 6:30 AM-5:00 PM, Sat 8:00 AM-12:30 PM.

They also share a tasting of homemade Angel Food cake made by Kelsey.

Then, Matt covers the story of actor Roscoe "Fatty" Arbuckle, who was arrested in the late 20s for the alleged murder of Virginia Rappe. This story is graphic in detail, content warning: domestic abuse, rape, medical injury, abortion. Discretion advised.

The creeps also talk about Christmas dudes, tea buddies, outdoor cats, and sprinkles.

This week, we try a fishy sort of snack mix, possibly coated in furikake, from Kasugai Snacks. The Creeps are pretty impressed by little balls. Then, Kelsey goes for a very serious and oddly funny story. A 30 year old man in Nevada, who was already being charged with battery, became irritated and attempted to attack his judge, by leaping over the very tall judge's bench.

They also talk about snacks, and interesting fast food, and sending weird things through the mail.

This week, our hosts try a the third coffee in our series of drinking Folk Hero Coffee, This roast is wonderfully Grafton Monster themed, gifted to us by the wonderful people at Folk Hero Coffee, from Buckhannon, WV, who can be reached at FolkHeroCoffee.com. Kelsey brewed up a flight, she used the techniques of pour over, French press, drip coffee pot, and her new moka pot.

In this episode, Matt tells Kelsey about the Bath School massacre, in which Andrew Kehoe attacked a school in the late 20's in Michigan. This case is very graphic and detailed, involving the deaths of multiple children, discretion advised.

You read that title right, Kelsey found new Snickerdoodle Pop-Tarts to try. Matt gets pretty excited about it.

Then, Matt shares a story of Ohio fugitive Donald "Chip" Pugh, a man wanted for dui, and person of interest in potential vandalism, who wanted a nicer angle on his mugshot, an improved image, a better look at his mug. So he sends in a selfie to police in Florida, because of course this happened in Florida. Ohio police already had the image and posted it to Facebook, because of course they did.

The Creeps also talk about untoasted pop-tart preference, and cinnamon levels. Kelsey shares a dark, long held, baking secret.

Note: Our editor would like to let listeners know, Britt is not the one underbaking cinnamon rolls, but she is the one eating underbaked brownies with a spoon along with Kelsey.

This week, our hosts try a themed John Brown coffee that was gifted to us by the wonderful people at Folk Hero Coffee, from Buckhannon, WV, who can be reached at FolkHeroCoffee.com. This is a continuation of our sampling of three different coffees. For this one, Kelsey brewed up a flight, she used the techniques of pour over, French press, drip coffee pot, and her new moka pot.

In this episode, Kelsey tells us the story Jaleayah Davis, whose 2011 death and closed case is the topic of debate in the Parkersburg, WV/Marietta, OH area. Her family has since started the Facebook page “Justice for Jaleayah” hoping to get her case reopened.

The Creeps also talk about being nosy, scones, buying coffee making supplies, and the history of noted abolitionist John Brown, Harpers Ferry, the catalyst that led to the American Civil War.

This episode contains graphic details of a case, discretion advised.