Amy Bradley Is Missing
Ruha and Bekah are finally back in the virtual recording room after a long break, and the reunion energy is strong. Between catching up on life updates — including Ruha’s TikTok glow‑up and Bekah gearing up for her medical billing and coding class — the episode settles into that cozy, familiar Midnight Cheesecake rhythm. The vibe is warm, a little chaotic, and full of the kind of laughter that only happens when besties haven’t talked in way too long.
Today’s main topic: the Netflix documentary “Amy, Amy Bradley Is Missing.” The case pulls them straight into the mystery of Amy Bradley’s 1998 disappearance from a cruise ship — a story filled with unsettling details, emotional interviews, and theories that leave you questioning everything. They walk through the timeline, the family’s heartbreak, the eerie Barbados sightings, and the confusing witness accounts that still haunt the case.
Along the way, they connect the story to their own lives — from travel anxieties to family dynamics to the universal “why do bad things happen when you’re just trying to relax on vacation” feeling. There may or may not be a moment where they spiral into the existential dread of cruise ship safety… but in a very Midnight Cheesecake way.
Ruha does mention her high school friend, the ethereal, appropriately named and very much missing, Tiffany Heaven Daniels, who is never far from her thoughts. If you have any tips, please report them here: https://www.facebook.com/findtiffany
They wrap things up with reflections on staying vigilant, supporting families of missing persons, and the importance of community awareness. And of course, they end on that signature cozy note — because catching up with your besties always feels like coming home.
Mentioned in Today’s Episode🍰
Ghirardelli Sea Salt Almond Dark Chocolate Squares (“Bekah's well‑earned treat of the day — the kind of chocolate that makes you close your eyes for a second.”):https://www.ghirardelli.com/dark-chocolate-sea-salt-almond-squares-61308-p
‘Amy, Amy Bradley Is Missing’ on Netflix (“The documentary that sent us down a rabbit hole of theories, emotions, and cruise‑ship paranoia.”):https://www.netflix.com/
Find Ruha and Bekah Around These Parts
INSTAGRAM: https://www.instagram.com/midnightcheesecake FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/people/Midnight-Cheesecake-Podcast/61577976430527 TIKTOK: https://www.tiktok.com/@midnightcheesecak (that dang "e" wouldn't fit)EMAIL US: [email protected]
Chapters
0:05 — Welcome to Midnight Cheesecake Podcast3:59 — Midwest Culture and Animal Videos11:35 — Diving into Amy Bradley43:10 — Lessons from the Amy Bradley Case51:16 — Wrapping Up and Listener Comments