Part 2 of our conversation on what happened to Brian Shaffer, a medical student who disappeared from a bar in Columbus, Ohio in 2006. What was Brian talking about with two women on camera at 1:57 AM? Why did Brian's phone ring one night in September 2006, nearly 6 months after he vanished seemingly without a trace? We discuss all of that, our theories, and more. 

Special thanks to my guest, Elaine Erickson. 

Follow the podcast on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/143mysteries/

View sources and submit a case suggestion: http://143mysteries.com