Chat By The Pitch

“More Than a Club, It’s a Culture” — Jason Carney on Fixing U.S. Youth Soccer


Listen Later

In this eye-opening episode, Jason Carney—former pro coach and current Director of Coaching at FC Portland—breaks down what's really wrong with youth soccer in the U.S. We dig into his brutally honest book, US Grassroots Soccer: Great on Paper S**t on Grass, and explore how the adult obsession with results is crushing kids’ development.

From game models and coaching culture to what parents should actually be asking clubs before joining, Jason delivers truth bombs every minute. If you’re a soccer parent, this episode will challenge your thinking and leave you better equipped to support your player’s journey.


Key Talking Points:

  • ​ Why most youth clubs don’t actually have a real development plan
  • ​ How a long-term culture beats short-term wins
  • ​ Why jumping clubs every year is hurting your child more than helping
  • ​ The real damage of helicopter parenting in sports
  • ​ What it means to build a game model—and why most clubs fake it
  • ​ Parent behavior and its impact on referee retention
  • ​ Why coaching made Jason a better player—after he stopped playing
  • ​ The truth about talent vs. character and mental toughness
  • ​ Creating a culture where kids navigate their sports experience
  • ​ Why clubs need to show, not just say, they’re developing players


🎧 Tune In to Learn:

  • ​ What questions you should be asking before joining a club
  • ​ How to support your child without living through them
  • ​ The vital difference between talent and teachability
  • ​ Why a game model is more than a playbook—it's a culture commitment
  • ​ What accountability in youth soccer really looks like


🔥 Quotes from Jason Carney:

"Society is fighting back against what I believe in, but I’ll keep banging on the door of long-term development."

"It's not just parents—it's all adults who ruin the game for kids."

"You wouldn’t enroll your child in a school with no curriculum. Why do it with a soccer club?"

"If your child’s been at a club for 8 years and still doesn’t understand the game, something’s wrong."

"A coach’s life can be very lonely in a win-at-all-costs culture."

"No player will ever be cut from my team after a year with me—because they'll be better than when I got them."

"We talk a lot about game models, but the hardest part is executing them."

"Helicopter parenting won’t help your kid reach the top. It does the opposite."

"Every decision we make starts with our culture. Not just the game model—the people."

"We love our kids too much. We solve problems before they’ve even tried to."


Connect with Jason Carney:

  • ​ Website: www.FCPortland.org
  • ​ LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/jason-carney-56876636
  • ​ Book: US Grassroots Soccer: Great on Paper S**t on Grass → on Amazon- https://a.co/d/75SSywU


Follow Chat By The Pitch:

  • ​ X: @ChatByThePitch
  • ​ Instagram: @ChatByThePitch
  • ​ Facebook: Chat By The Pitch

🎧 Subscribe & Leave a Review: Your feedback helps us reach more parents ready to change youth soccer for the better.

#ChatByThePitch #YouthSoccer #PlayerDevelopment #SoccerCulture #LongTermDevelopment #ParentEducation #FCPortland #GrassrootsSoccer #SoccerParenting #USSoccer

...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Chat By The PitchBy Ian Babcock

  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8
  • 4.8

4.8

5 ratings


More shows like Chat By The Pitch

View all
The Joe Rogan Experience by Joe Rogan

The Joe Rogan Experience

223,887 Listeners

Alexi Lalas’ State of the Union Podcast by FOX Sports

Alexi Lalas’ State of the Union Podcast

1,086 Listeners

Pivot by New York Magazine

Pivot

8,859 Listeners

3four3 FM by 3four3

3four3 FM

203 Listeners

Youth Soccer Coaching Player Development Podcast by MyFootballCoach

Youth Soccer Coaching Player Development Podcast

78 Listeners

Way of Champions Podcast by John O'Sullivan

Way of Champions Podcast

271 Listeners

Modern Soccer Coach Podcast by Gary Curneen

Modern Soccer Coach Podcast

258 Listeners

Today, Explained by Vox

Today, Explained

10,054 Listeners

Inside College Soccer by Inside College Soccer

Inside College Soccer

18 Listeners

The Inside Scoop with Anytime Soccer Training - Discussing Youth Soccer from Around the World by Neil Crawford

The Inside Scoop with Anytime Soccer Training - Discussing Youth Soccer from Around the World

20 Listeners

Breaking the Line: The ECNL Podcast by Elite Clubs National League

Breaking the Line: The ECNL Podcast

22 Listeners

Call It What You Want: A CBS Sports Golazo Network Podcast by CBS Sports, USMNT, U.S. Soccer, MLS, World Cup, UCL, Americans Abroad

Call It What You Want: A CBS Sports Golazo Network Podcast

305 Listeners

THE Soccer Dad-Pod by Gaslight Studio STL

THE Soccer Dad-Pod

68 Listeners

How To Play College Soccer with Collegesoccerguy by Zev

How To Play College Soccer with Collegesoccerguy

44 Listeners

Unfiltered Soccer with Landon Donovan and Tim Howard by Landon Donovan, Tim Howard

Unfiltered Soccer with Landon Donovan and Tim Howard

165 Listeners