Episode 19: The Prom Night Murders - Lakeville, Indiana Pt. 2

This is the second part of the 3 part series of the Pelley Family murders, or "The Prom Night Murders" In this second part, Ashlee discusses odd "evidence," shoddy police work, and mysterious links across state lines. After all of this... it won't be hard to see why Jeff was granted the evidentiary hearing. Only time will tell if this will lead him to a new trial or exoneration. 

Additional source: The blog by catiejobug titled ,"Normal Nevermore: The Prom Night Murders".

Video podcasting will be available soon through YouTube and Spotify.

Merch available now!: https://murdnerds-merch.creator-spring.com/

To check out the other podcasts within the Golden Mojo Entertainment:

Episode 18: SURVIVAL Anita Wooldridge - Kokomo, Indiana

21-year-old Anita Wooldridge was working her way through college and living with her parents in Kokomo, Indiana. On June 25th, 1998, Anita had plans to be picked up by her boyfriend and go out to lunch with her parents. But when her boyfriend arrived, Anita wasn't there. No one could locate her; it was almost as if she disappeared into thin air. Join Alicia on this week's episode as she retells the incredible survival story of Anita, as we dissect who did this, why, and what happened to Anita. 

Tell us what you think! Email us at: [email protected] or contact us via social media.

Video podcasting will be available soon through YouTube and Spotify.

Merch available now!: https://murdnerds-merch.creator-spring.com/

Episode 17: The Prom Night Murders - Lakeville, Indiana Pt. 1

The Sunday after the town's prom, April 30th, 1989, Reverend Robert Pelley didn't attend to his morning service as usual... and neither did his wife or children. Upon further inspection, the pastor, his wife, and two of their five children were found shot inside their home; parsonage connected to the church. The Pelley's lived a quiet, quaint life in Lakeville after moving there not many years before from Florida. They seemed to be well-liked in the community. Who could have possibly done something to the entire family? Where were the three other children? What could the motive be? 

Join Ashlee as she tells us the story of the Pelleys in this multi-part story. 

Tell us what you think! Email us at: [email protected] or contact us via social media.

Merch available now!: https://murdnerds-merch.creator-spring.com/

Episode 14: Brandie Peltz - Argos, Indiana

On December 11th, 1986, while everyone in Argos, Indiana, was still at work or school, a man driving past discovered smoke coming from the home of one of his neighbors. The discovery of the fire led to an even grimmer discovery; the body of 11-year-old Brandie Peltz. Brandie's murder is still unsolved to this day, but it's not slim of theories, rumor, and small-town speculation. Who took Brandie's life from her and why? Join Alicia has she retells a case that's been stuck in her mind for years.

Any tips that could help solve this case can be given to:

Tell us what you think! Email us at [email protected] or message us on social media:

Video podcasting will be available soon for Youtube and Spotify!

Please give our producer and editor’s page a like on their Facebook page:

MurdNerds is available wherever you enjoy listening to podcasts. Like, Subscribe, rate, and review!

Hosted by Ashlee Lippert and Alicia Cauffman

Episode 13: Amanda Lee Van Scyoc - Boonville, Indiana

Amanda Van Scyoc was a sweet girl with a rocky past she was actively trying to fix. At just 18-years-old, her body was found under strange circumstances. As of today there have been no arrests for her murder. Who would have wanted to take Amanda's life? Why was her body found where it was when Amanda was doing better? There are many contradictions in this case. Take the journey of Amanda's life as Ashlee tells the story of Amanda Van Scyoc and her untimely and mysterious unsolved murder.

If you have any information that can help solve Amanda's case please contact the Indiana State Police District Investigative Commander at 1-812-867-2079 or 1-800-852-3970.

Tell us what you think! Email us at [email protected] or message us on social media:

Video podcasting will be available soon for Youtube and Spotify!

Please give our producer and editor’s page a like on their Facebook page:

MurdNerds is available wherever you enjoy listening to podcasts. Like, Subscribe, rate, and review!

Hosted by Ashlee Lippert and Alicia Cauffman