Michael's son creates a second dad who lets him do whatever he wants.

Sarah's husband deals with the aftereffects of enjoying a small-town gas station tuna fish sandwich.

Josiah goes swimming on a vacant beach and finds out why it's vacant.

Dealing with depression and the loss of a friend.

Norman's frenemy uses pee-soaked napkins as a weapon. Michelle has a dumb dog.

Drake decides to spin his cat around and make it dizzy.

Stephen does NOT enjoy his first haunted hayride, plus so many more spooky/funny stories. Get your free bonus content at patreon.com/thatstoryshow

James' fat half falls out of the boat on a whitewater rafting trip. Jennifer Kennison guest hosts.

SecretNinjaGurl gets stuck under a train! Clementine wants to color with "potato sticks"!

Christy's nose doesn't warn her that her dog's been skunked! James owns a ROGUE!