Not Your Normal Murder

Episode #28 // The Murder of Rachel Winkler, Part 2

 

In 2012, Rachel Winkler had everything she had ever wanted: a beautiful home, beautiful children, and a husband. But the marriage was not happy, and she was planning on divorcing her husband to be with another man. She told her lover she was going home to separate from her husband once and for all. The next day, her husband would notify police he had killed her-- in self defense. What really happened to Rachel Winkler?

 

 

National Domestic Violence Hotline | Get Help Today | 1-800-799-7233

 

 

This episode may contain graphic details and strong language and may not be suitable for all listeners. Listener discretion is advised.

 

Disclaimer: Any verbal opinion by the hosts of any person’s involvement with a crime who has not been found guilty by a jury of peers is pure speculation and should not be considered as fact.

 

Make sure to comment and leave a review! Check out our Facebook page and Twitter and let us know what you thought of the episode. Also let us know what cases you would like us to cover in the future!

 

We are proudly part of the Oracl3 Network. Find their website here.

 

Facebook: @NYNMPodcast

 

Instagram: Not Your Normal Murder

 

Email: [email protected]

 

Twitter: @NYNMPodcast

 

For a full list of sources used for this episode please visit here.

 

This episode was researched, written, and recorded by Mary Kiesewetter and Deirdre Teichman. Editing by Kevin Kiesewetter. Music credits to DanoSongs and Rob Chrisman. All rights reserved.

Episode #27 // The Murder of Rachel Winkler, Part 1

 

In 2012, Rachel Winkler had everything she had ever wanted: a beautiful home, beautiful children, and a husband. But the marriage was not happy, and she was planning on divorcing her husband to be with another man. She told her lover she was going home to separate from her husband once and for all. The next day, her husband would notify police he had killed her-- in self defense. What really happened to Rachel Winkler?

 

 

National Domestic Violence Hotline | Get Help Today | 1-800-799-7233

 

 

This episode may contain graphic details and strong language and may not be suitable for all listeners. Listener discretion is advised.

 

Disclaimer: Any verbal opinion by the hosts of any person’s involvement with a crime who has not been found guilty by a jury of peers is pure speculation and should not be considered as fact.

 

Make sure to comment and leave a review! Check out our Facebook page and Twitter and let us know what you thought of the episode. Also let us know what cases you would like us to cover in the future!

 

We are proudly part of the Oracl3 Network. Find their website here.

 

Facebook: @NYNMPodcast

 

Instagram: Not Your Normal Murder

 

Email: [email protected]

 

Twitter: @NYNMPodcast

 

For a full list of sources used for this episode please visit here.

 

This episode was researched, written, and recorded by Mary Kiesewetter and Deirdre Teichman. Editing by Kevin Kiesewetter. Music credits to DanoSongs and Rob Chrisman. All rights reserved.

Episode #26 // The Murder of Cody Johnson

 

In 2013, Cody Johnson would mysteriously disappear just 8 days after marrying his wife. Immediately police would be suspicious when his wife Jordan was not the one to report him as missing. Then, she would be the one to find the body. She would eventually admit to pushing him off a cliff, but that is was an accident and self-defense. Why did Jordan kill her groom of 8 days? 

This episode may contain graphic details and strong language and may not be suitable for all listeners. Listener discretion is advised.

 

Disclaimer: Any verbal opinion by the hosts of any person’s involvement with a crime who has not been found guilty by a jury of peers is pure speculation and should not be considered as fact.

 

Make sure to comment and leave a review! Check out our Facebook page and Twitter and let us know what you thought of the episode. Also let us know what cases you would like us to cover in the future!

 

Facebook: @NYNMPodcast

 

Instagram: Not Your Normal Murder

 

Email: [email protected]

 

Twitter: @NYNMPodcast

 

For a full list of sources used for this episode please visit here.

 

This episode was researched, written, and recorded by Mary Kiesewetter and Deirdre Teichman. Editing by Kevin Kiesewetter. Music credits to DanoSongs and Rob Chrisman. All rights reserved.

Episode #25 // The Murder of Bill Whalen and the Case Against Don Whalen

In 1991, bar-owner Bill Whalen would be brutally murdered in his bar after closing on a Friday night. It did not appear to be a robbery, although money might have been taken. The police soon arrested Bill's own son, Don, who they believe had left a bloody handprint at the crime scene. But would the evidence support the prosecution's theory that Don had killed his own dad?

 This episode may contain graphic details and strong language and may not be suitable for all listeners. Listener discretion is advised.

 

Disclaimer: Any verbal opinion by the hosts of any person’s involvement with a crime who has not been found guilty by a jury of peers is pure speculation and should not be considered as fact.

 

Make sure to comment and leave a review! Check out our Facebook page and Twitter and let us know what you thought of the episode. Also let us know what cases you would like us to cover in the future!

 

Facebook: @NYNMPodcast

 

Instagram: Not Your Normal Murder

 

Email: [email protected]

 

Twitter: @NYNMPodcast

 

For a full list of sources used for this episode please visit here.

 

This episode was researched, written, and recorded by Mary Kiesewetter and Deirdre Teichman. Editing by Kevin Kiesewetter. Music credits to DanoSongs and Rob Chrisman. All rights reserved.

Episode #24 // The Murder of Peggy Nadell

 

In 2014, Peggy Nadell's daughter would find her dead, at the bottom of her staircase. Police would be immediately suspicious of her daughter, who reported it as an accident, even though signs showed homicide. Would the suspicions be right, or was someone else involved?

 

This episode may contain graphic details and strong language and may not be suitable for all listeners. Listener discretion is advised.

 

Disclaimer: Any verbal opinion by the hosts of any person’s involvement with a crime who has not been found guilty by a jury of peers is pure speculation and should not be considered as fact.

 

Make sure to comment and leave a review! Check out our Facebook page and Twitter and let us know what you thought of the episode. Also let us know what cases you would like us to cover in the future!

 

Facebook: @NYNMPodcast

 

Instagram: Not Your Normal Murder

 

Email: [email protected]

 

Twitter: @NYNMPodcast

 

For a full list of sources used for this episode please visit here.

 

This episode was researched, written, and recorded by Mary Kiesewetter and Deirdre Teichman. Editing by Kevin Kiesewetter. Music credits to DanoSongs and Rob Chrisman. All rights reserved.

Episode #23 // The Disappearance of Sarah Stern

 

In 2016, 19-year-old Sarah Stern would take a large sum of money out of her bank, and her car would be found abandoned on a bridge. She would never be seen again. Police would think she either ran away, or killed herself. But then a tip would come in, suggesting an even more sinister outcome. What really happened to Sarah Stern?

 

National Suicide Hotline # 1800-273-8255

 

 

This episode may contain graphic details and strong language and may not be suitable for all listeners. Listener discretion is advised.

 

Disclaimer: Any verbal opinion by the hosts of any person’s involvement with a crime who has not been found guilty by a jury of peers is pure speculation and should not be considered as fact.

 

Make sure to comment and leave a review! Check out our Facebook page and Twitter and let us know what you thought of the episode. Also let us know what cases you would like us to cover in the future!

 

Facebook: @NYNMPodcast

 

Instagram: Not Your Normal Murder

 

Email: [email protected]

 

Twitter: @NYNMPodcast

 

For a full list of sources used for this episode please visit here.

 

This episode was researched, written, and recorded by Mary Kiesewetter and Deirdre Teichman. Editing by Kevin Kiesewetter. Music credits to DanoSongs and Rob Chrisman. All rights reserved.

Episode #22 // The Mysterious Death of Michele MacNeil

 

In 2007, Michele MacNeil would be found dead in her bathtub. Her death was found to be natural causes, but soon, her children would start to suspect she was murdered by the last person they would ever expect-- their own father. Did he have anything to do with her death?

 

National Suicide Hotline # 1800-273-8255

 

National Domestic Violence Hotline | Get Help Today | 1-800-799-7233

 

 

This episode may contain graphic details and strong language and may not be suitable for all listeners. Listener discretion is advised.

 

Disclaimer: Any verbal opinion by the hosts of any person’s involvement with a crime who has not been found guilty by a jury of peers is pure speculation and should not be considered as fact.

 

Make sure to comment and leave a review! Check out our Facebook page and Twitter and let us know what you thought of the episode. Also let us know what cases you would like us to cover in the future!

 

Facebook: @NYNMPodcast

 

Instagram: Not Your Normal Murder

 

Email: [email protected]

 

Twitter: @NYNMPodcast

 

For a full list of sources used for this episode please visit here.

 

This episode was researched, written, and recorded by Mary Kiesewetter and Deirdre Teichman. Editing by Kevin Kiesewetter. Music credits to DanoSongs and Rob Chrisman. All rights reserved.

Episode #21 // The Murder of Elizabeth Sullivan

 

Elizabeth Sullivan would seemingly vanish into thin air in 2014. Soon, her estranged husband would move on with a new girlfriend. Years later, Elizabeth's body would be found under suspicious circumstances, and her husband would be charged. Did he have anything to do with Elizabeth's disappearance?

 

 

National Domestic Violence Hotline | Get Help Today | 1-800-799-7233

 

 

This episode may contain graphic details and strong language and may not be suitable for all listeners. Listener discretion is advised.

 

Disclaimer: Any verbal opinion by the hosts of any person’s involvement with a crime who has not been found guilty by a jury of peers is pure speculation and should not be considered as fact.

 

Make sure to comment and leave a review! Check out our Facebook page and Twitter and let us know what you thought of the episode. Also let us know what cases you would like us to cover in the future!

 

Facebook: @NYNMPodcast

 

Instagram: Not Your Normal Murder

 

Email: [email protected]

 

Twitter: @NYNMPodcast

 

For a full list of sources used for this episode please visit here.

 

This episode was researched, written, and recorded by Mary Kiesewetter and Deirdre Teichman. Editing by Kevin Kiesewetter. Music credits to DanoSongs and Rob Chrisman. All rights reserved.

Episode #20 // Dalia Dippolito and the attempted murder of Michael Dippolito

 

In August 2009, Dalia Dippolito's worst nightmare would come true. On that morning, she had gone to the gym, but she got a message from a weird number. She listened to the voicemail. It was man’s voice, telling her something was wrong at her condo and she needed to get home right away. Soon after, Dalia would arrive home. The condo was surrounded by police cars, and police tape, and investigators combing the area. Dalia tried to get inside her condo, but police wouldn’t let her inside. They broke the news to her that they’re had been a shooting, and her husband hadn’t made it. Dalia immediately broke into hysterics. Police were unable to console her, so they just lead her to a car, and take her down to the station to get her statement. But there at the police station, Dalia would not be able to believe her eyes, when she sees Michael, alive and well. Dalia would be charged with the murder for hire of her husband of less than 6 months.

 

 

National Domestic Violence Hotline | Get Help Today | 1-800-799-7233

 

 

This episode may contain graphic details and strong language and may not be suitable for all listeners. Listener discretion is advised.

 

Disclaimer: Any verbal opinion by the hosts of any person’s involvement with a crime who has not been found guilty by a jury of peers is pure speculation and should not be considered as fact.

 

Make sure to comment and leave a review! Check out our Facebook page and Twitter and let us know what you thought of the episode. Also let us know what cases you would like us to cover in the future!

 

Facebook: @NYNMPodcast

 

Instagram: Not Your Normal Murder

 

Email: [email protected]

 

Twitter: @NYNMPodcast

 

For a full list of sources used for this episode please visit here.

 

This episode was researched, written, and recorded by Mary Kiesewetter and Deirdre Teichman. Editing by Kevin Kiesewetter. Music credits to DanoSongs and Rob Chrisman. All rights reserved.

Episode #19 // The Murder of Holly Cassano

 

On November 1st, 2009, Holly Cassano worked a late shift at her job as a cashier at Meijer, a grocery store in Champaign, Illinois. Her mother was watching her 17-month-old daughter for her. Toni Cassano, Holly’s mother, would bring the toddler to Meijer to see her mom before bedtime. Toni and her granddaughter had no idea this was the last time they would ever see Holly alive.

 

National Domestic Violence Hotline | Get Help Today | 1-800-799-7233

 

 

This episode may contain graphic details and strong language and may not be suitable for all listeners. Listener discretion is advised.

 

Disclaimer: Any verbal opinion by the hosts of any person’s involvement with a crime who has not been found guilty by a jury of peers is pure speculation and should not be considered as fact.

 

Make sure to comment and leave a review! Check out our Facebook page and Twitter and let us know what you thought of the episode. Also let us know what cases you would like us to cover in the future!

 

Facebook: @NYNMPodcast

 

Instagram: Not Your Normal Murder

 

Email: [email protected]

 

Twitter: @NYNMPodcast

 

For a full list of sources used for this episode please visit here.

 

This episode was researched, written, and recorded by Mary Kiesewetter and Deirdre Teichman. Editing by Kevin Kiesewetter. Music credits to DanoSongs and Rob Chrisman. All rights reserved.