On The Island - A Podcast Mostly About 'Survivor'

Taylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons convene to build big fires — and to discuss the Season 42 finale of "Survivor." They do some classic bits, including questioning whether viewers can trust the jury, debating why the show feels worse than it used to be even when it's pretty good, comparing the show to sports a bunch, and much, much more.

Apple Podcasts

Spotify

Twitter

Taylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons return to break down the rise of a new Season 42 contender in this finale preview episode! They discuss how two players (unintentionally) orchestrated a classic “Survivor” moment, the formation of a stacked jury, what’s going on in Ty’s life (and with his fantasy “Survivor” team), and the entire […]

Taylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons are back to shatter the hour glass and break down everything that’s happened so far in “Survivor” Season 42! They discuss the most likely winners, the lack of a standout power player, the greatest athletic performer in “Survivor” history, the absence of an overarching theme, and much, much more. […]

Taylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons RETURN from a multi-year slumber to preview a brand-new “Survivor” season. They look back on what they’ve missed, pay their respects to an all-time great, and set up the season the only way they know how: draft style! Many may listen, but only one will prevail. Season 42 debuts […]

Subscribe to Taylor’s new podcast, Comedy Joke, wherever you listen. This episode — with special guest Annie Scott — features the formation of Banana Land, a father with a penchant for metaphor, a grad student trying to solve the big problems and Peyton Manning’s extended family. Christian has a bone to pick with the “Midwest,” […]

This episode features frat guys attempting improv comedy, a jingoistic car dealership and Scraggles the Zombie Cat. Sophia discusses “Islamic residuals,” Christian talks about buying two cars welded together, and Taylor unveils ‘The Hollywood Development Game’ — which quickly makes him lose his mind. Instagram Twitter

Taylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons are joined by their other co-host, Michelle Schubert, to take stock of an all-time "Survivor" season. They talk about Tony's potential GOAT status, Sarah's showcase, Michele's survival, the "Edge" advantage, and so, so much more. Michelle (with two "Ls") also shares some insights into returning home from "Survivor" and rice portions.

Stay tuned until the end for an announcement about the future of the podcast.

Apple Podcasts

Spotify

Twitter

Taylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons prepare for the final battle in "Winners at War," dissecting the strangely anticlimactic penultimate episode, the purpose of fire tokens, what "Survivor" has gained and lost over the years, and much more. They also rank the remaining contestants in their final Power Rankings.

Apple Podcasts

Spotify

Twitter

Taylor Gaines and Tyler B. Commons return to make sense of a chaotic episode of "Winners at War." They try to figure out how the vote shook out the way it did, what Jeff finds interesting about the show and how badly they want some peanut butter. They also break down each of the seven remaining castaways.

Apple Podcasts

Spotify

Taylor Gaines returns with a vengeance, bringing his family along for the fight. They break down Tony's controlled chaos and long-term prospects, Sophie's rapid downfall, Jeremy's intuition and what a "quiet day" means on Survivor.

Apple Podcasts

Spotify

Twitter