What would you do if your entire board game collection disappeared overnight?

In this episode of The Gateway Gamers Podcast, I tackle one of the toughest questions in the hobby: Which five board games would I buy first if I had to rebuild my collection from scratch?

These aren't simply the highest ranked board games or the hottest new releases. They're the games that have proven their value through replayability, unforgettable gaming experiences, and lasting memories. I break down why each game earned its place, what makes it a must own, and why I'd choose it over thousands of other great games.

Whether you're looking for the best board game recommendations, building your first collection, searching for essential gateway games, or wondering which games offer the most long term value, this episode has plenty to discuss.

After listening, let me know: Which game would you buy first if you had to start over?