Jake opens the show by asking whether or not it's a bad thing that the Browns aren't exactly giving into Myles Garrett's requests and if it could hurt the relationship once again. Jake then goes around what we heard from the station's guests today with Station Buzz.

Darius Garland underwent surgery on Monday for his toe injury that was originally described as a sprain -- The All-Star received significant backlash during the post-season regarding the injury and not being tough enough, which could have been avoided according to Spencer Davies from Cavs on SI if the org was honest about the injury. Davies explains how the injury could effect his trade value and what the Cavs think of Garland.

Nick Chubb is offically headed to the Texans for 2.5 million dollars. How do Browns fans move forward as far as cheering for Chubb and why couldn't the Browns keep him on the roster for that price? Spencer Davies joins the show to discuss the surprising Darius Garland surgery.

The Cleveland Cavaliers announced that Darius Garland underwent surgery on his big toe, the same toe that kept him sidelined for the last two regular season games and four playoff matchups. Is the hate Garland received unfair now knowing the severity of the injury? Can we rethink what we want to do with Garland this off-season now?

Aaron Rodgers signing means it's make or break for Mike Tomlin+Jeff Hathhorn: Aaron Rodgers is the best QB Steelers got since Ben Roethselberger; ceiling now a playoff win+Jake wouldn't be that mad if Browns decided to tank this season out

Jeff Hathhorn of 93.7 The Fan in Pittsburgh joins Overtime with Jake Vulinec to break down the Aaron Rodgers signing and what it means for the 2025 season. He thinks their ceiling is now a playoff win, but asks what that does for the franchise.

Cavs need to learn from Finals, find structure in their team+Cavs biggest need is filling out the rotational players+Station Buzz

The full show of "Overtime on The Fan" for Thursday, June 5th, 2025.

In the third hour of "Overtime on The Fan," Jake Vulinec tells many across the sports world to "Get A Grip," Camryn Justice of NEws Channel 5 joins the show talking OTA observations for the Browns, and postgame reaction to the Guardians losing to the Yankees 4-0 on the road.

In the second hour of "Overtime on the Fan," Danny Cunningham joins the show, talking all things Cavs. Plus, are Cavs fans watching the finals this year? And what should the team do this summer with moves in free agency and trades?