Series: Basic Bible Doctrine
Service: Wed Bible Study
Type: Bible Class
Speaker: Brian Messerli
Tonight we’ll be talking about the danger of falling away, but before we do, you may have noticed we haven’t really spent much time this quarter discussing false doctrines. And that’s for two reasons: 1) It’s much more efficient to learn the truth than to learn everything that’s false. If you learn the truth, then when you spot something that doesn’t align with the truth, you know it’s false. This is how bankers spot fake currency. They may not know all the new fangled ways counterfeiters try to print fake money, but they DO know the real currency inside and out. They know the weight, the feel, the color, the proper locations of the watermarks and serial numbers, so when they see anything that looks off, it’s a red flag. Here’s another way to illustrate this point:
John 10:1-3 - The doorkeeper and the sheep don’t need to train themselves to learn every person’s voice on the planet in order to protect themselves from robbers who seek to harm them. All they need to do is learn the shepherd’s voice, and any voice that’s not his is to be rejected.
2) It’s more edifying to learn the truth than to learn everything that’s false. While it might satisfy our curiosity to learn about false doctrines, it doesn’t help us very much spiritually. I mean, instead of the class on who Jesus really is and being amazed and encouraged by how He’s God in the flesh, we could have spent time talking about how Islam teaches He was just a prophet, but not really God’s son, and He didn’t really die for our sins, He was taken off the cross before His death. Well, that’s interesting to learn, but it leaves us completely empty spiritually and now there’s no longer any sacrifice for our sins and we’re back to having to earn our way to Heaven by our good works. No, it’s WAY better to spend our time immersing ourselves in what the Bible ACTUALLY teaches, and once you see the clear and true teachings of Scripture, then when Islam or Mormonism or Jehovah’s Witnesses or Catholicism or fill in the blank with any other religion comes along and says, “Actually THIS is what Jesus really taught,” we’ll be able to say, “No, sorry that’s not Jesus’ voice.”
Having said that though, it can be valuable to learn about false teaching when we’re trying to understand where our religious friends and neighbors are coming from. Tonight I want to talk about the danger of falling away from God, but many of our denominational friends and neighbors do not believe that’s even possible, and we might wonder, “How could that be? How can they believe such a thing?” and of course they wonder the same thing about us. But it’s helpful to know it’s because of the influence of a doctrinal system of belief called Calvinism advanced by a religious reformer named John Calvin in the 1500’s AD. Now, there’s no denomination called the Calvinist church, but Calvinism is a theological system that permeates many different denominations. A common term you might hear for it is reformed theology, and some denominations may even have the name reformed in their title. Calvinists are not terrible people and they’re not crazy; they genuinely love the Lord and their number 1 goal is for God to be glorified above all else, so we have common ground with them on that. But Calvinism can be summarized by the 5-part acronym TULIP, and all 5 parts stand or fall together, you can’t have one without the other, and if one is true, the rest are too. We won’t spend long on this, because again it’s much more productive focusing on true doctrine, but I think this is helpful to know.
1) Total Hereditary Depravity. We are born with the corruption of Adam’s sin in us, so all of our thinking, emotions, and even our choices are tainted by sin, which means it’s impossible for us to choose good. Even when we choose to do good things, it’s with ulterior, evil motives, so the good is tainted too. Since it’s in our fallen nature to choose evil, it is impossible for us to choose to follow God. We were dead in our sins, and dead people can’t choose to come to the Lord. (Verses they use: Psalm 58:3; 51:5; Ephesians 2:3. Response: Psalm 22:9-10; 1 Cor. 14:20; Ecc. 7:20)
2) Unconditional Election. Since we’re too evil and dead to choose God, He must choose and save us. He elects us and gives us faith as a gift because we can’t have faith on our own, we’re evil and dead. He gives us the faith and even gives us the DESIRE to be saved and come to Him. (Verses they use: Acts 13:48; Ephesians 1:11; John 6:44. Response: John 12:32; 2 Thessalonians 2:14)
A few classes ago, Gail asked why our religious friends and neighbors have such a hard time believing baptism is necessary for salvation. It’s largely because of the influence of Calvinism, which says God’s choosing of us to give us faith and salvation is unconditional, and if there are ANY conditions placed on us, like the need to be baptized, to them that would mean man plays a role in salvation, which undermines the sovereignty of God and detracts from His glory in saving us. However, if salvation is COMPLETELY based on His unconditional electing of us for salvation, then He gets all the glory.
3) Limited Atonement. Since God has already planned ahead of time who will be elected for salvation, that means Jesus’ blood shed on the cross was only for the elect, not for the whole world. (Verses they use: John 10:14-15; 17:9; Ephesians 5:25. Response: 1 John 2:2; 2 Corinthians 5:19; Acts 17:30)
4) Irresistible Grace. Since God has unconditionally elected you to be saved from before time began, and since Jesus’ blood was shed for you to be saved, that means the elect WILL be saved no matter what. If God wants you to be saved, there’s nothing you can do to resist Him. His saving grace is irresistible. (Verses they use: Ezekiel 11:19; Ephesians 2:5. Response: Luke 7:30; Acts 13:46)
5) Perseverance of the Saints. Since God elected you unconditionally, Jesus’ blood was shed to save you, and God’s grace is irresistible, that means you WILL be in Heaven no matter what. Once you're saved, you're always saved and you can never lose your position in God’s kingdom. Since your position in God’s kingdom had nothing to do with you in the first place and everything to do with God, then there’s nothing you can do to lose your position in God’s kingdom either. (Verses they use: 1 Peter 1:5; Philippians 1:6. Response: Galatians 5:4; 2 Peter 2:20-21; Hebrews 6:4-6)
And this is why our Calvinistic friends reject the teaching that a Christian can actually fall away from the Lord and be lost. And if you accept the previous 4 parts of the system, the TULI, then the P makes perfect sense. But of course those 4 parts just aren’t Biblical, and as we’ll see in our study tonight, the P just does not square with what the Bible teaches on the subject.
Questions/Comments?
Losing Salvation vs. Falling Away
- At the risk of sounding like I’m splitting hairs, I’m not a big fan of saying we can “lose our salvation.” It’s true we can lose our salvation, I just don’t like that wording because it makes it sound like it was an accident or like it was arbitrary, like when we lose our keys. That’s an accident, and it was kind of random and arbitrary. We had no plans to lose our keys, it just happened.
- John 10:27-29 - Jesus would never allow us to be lost like a set of keys. He’s protecting us, He’s keeping us saved, even when we don’t always live right. I wanted to talk about this in our class on grace but I didn’t have time, but do you remember when I said one of our biggest problems as Christians is that we tend to treat the new covenant like a two-way covenant instead of a one-way covenant? Instead of trusting in God’s promises for our salvation, we tend to trust way too much in our own performance. Well, when we do that, it can lead us to feel like we’re constantly bouncing in and out of the kingdom. Or, like we’re constantly losing and then re-gaining our salvation.
- If we have a bad week and give in to temptation, now we feel like we’ve lost our salvation and we need to make sure to really step up our performance next week to get it back. Then if we have a really good week, we can rest easy because we know we still have our salvation.
- But do you see how that’s a reliance on our own power to keep ourselves saved, rather than relying on Jesus’ power to keep us saved? Jesus says HE is the one giving us eternal life and HE will make sure no one snatches us out of His hand.
- 1 Peter 1:4-5 - This should give us SO much confidence that we’re not just going to be living our lives as Christians, doing our best to live by faith, but then all the sudden we wake up one morning to find that Jesus let us get snatched away and now we’ve lost our salvation. That’s not the way the Bible pictures it.
Instead, the Bible pictures it this way:
Hebrews 3:12 - The Bible never pictures Christians as losing their salvation for not doing enough good works, but rather as falling away from Christ in unbelief. And actually, right before this verse, the writer of Hebrews quotes from Psalm 95 and uses the Israelites in the wilderness to help us understand what he means.
Hebrews 3:8-11 - Now, notice Hebrews is making a parallel between the rest found in the Old Testament Promised Land of Canaan and the New Testament Promised Land of Heaven. Just as the Israelites were traveling through the wilderness, enduring trials and temptations along the way, so too are we journeying through the wilderness of this life, longing for the day when we finally find rest in the new heavens and new earth.
Now, when you think back to the Israelites on that wilderness journey, would you say that most of them were trying their absolute best to serve God by faith, but they just kept stumbling in sin. Then when they sinned, they’d offer sacrifices and make things right, but then they’d stumble again, and God got angry at them because they stumbled one too many times? No, that’s NOT why God was angry with them and why they missed out on the Promised Land of rest.
They missed out because of consistent refusal to believe in God’s promises. They tested God constantly with the underlying attitude that we don’t think God is really with us or that He has our best interest at heart or that He’s ever going to make good on His promise to bring us into the Promised Land. They constantly complained and grumbled, they made a golden calf right after God told them not to make any graven image or worship any other god, they constantly rebelled against Moses’ leadership, and then of course the final straw was when they reached the very edge of the Promised Land and God was about to give it to them, and the majority of them said, “No, there are giants in the land, there’s no way God’s going to give this to us, we’ll all be killed.” And that’s when God sentenced them to 40 years of wandering in the wilderness until that entire unfaithful generation died.
These were not people who had faith in God, stumbled in sin and gave into their weaknesses at times, then repented and determined to do better next time. These were people who, at the core of their hearts, did not trust or love God. And this is another parallel for us because…
Hebrews 6:13-14 - Typically when we swear an oath, we swear by someone greater than ourselves to confirm it, but since there’s no one greater than God, He swore by Himself to bless Abraham’s descendants by multiplying them and giving them the Promised Land. Well, WE as Christians are Abraham’s descendants by faith, and therefore those promises were made to US!
Hebrews 6:19-20a - Just as the Israelites should have had absolutely confidence to believe God would keep His promise to bring them to the Promised Land of Canaan, so too should we have absolutely confidence God will keep His promise to bring us to the new heavens and new earth. Remember this is a one way covenant based on God’s promises, not our performance, and the reason the Israelites lost out on the Promised Land wasn’t because they didn’t perform well enough, but because they didn’t believe God’s promise! So too, we don’t bounce in and out of the kingdom and lose our salvation one week and gain it back the next based on how many good deeds we did or how few evil deeds we did. No, our place in the kingdom is secure AS LONG AS we continue to live by faith in Him and believe in His promises.
Questions/Comments?
Question: Why is turning away from the Lord so serious? Even MORE serious, in fact, than the Israelites turning away from God in unbelief in the wilderness?
Now, I’ll put a couple Scriptures up that give us the answer, but just so it doesn’t feel like 3rd grade when you’re just reading back to me what it says, maybe you can just elaborate on it a little or put it in your own words. You might even have an answer for this that’s not listed in these verses.
Hebrews 6:4-6; 10:28-29
1) As a Christian, we’ve been blessed with the heavenly gift, which could be a reference to Jesus and His sacrifice on our behalf, or perhaps to all the spiritual blessings He brought with Him like forgiveness, hope, purpose, a church family. 2) We’ve been given the Holy Spirit and have therefore been adopted by God as His child, we’ve been given life, character change, the presence of God, the power of God, the revelation of God by the Spirit through the apostles. 3) We’ve tasted the powers of the age to come! Remember the timeline I showed you all? How Jesus came to bring all the powers of the Heavenly age to come with Him into this present age? That’s what the kingdom is, the place where the powers of Heaven invade this world to liberate us from Satan’s kingdom of darkness. And this would have been even MORE obvious to first century Christians since the Holy Spirit gave many of them powers to perform miracles through spiritual gifts. Plus they would have seen the signs and wonders of the apostles up close and personal!
Acts 2:43 - We may not see those signs anymore, but our spiritual resurrection in Christ is a power of the age to come, our direct access to God’s presence, our victory over sin, the newfound courage we have, our new purpose, the fruits of the Holy Spirit in our lives. 4) To experience all those things and then still fall away from Christ is to crucify Him all over again!
Even though there are parallels between us and the Israelites, we as Christians have advantages they didn’t have. They were led by Moses, but we’re led by Christ! They had animal sacrifices, but we have the one true sacrifice for sins. They had priestly mediators, but we can go directly God. They had the Spirit traveling alongside them, we have the Spirit traveling WITHIN us!
Illustration: If I disrespect one of my teachers in school and openly defy their authority, that’s pretty serious, and I deserve whatever punishment I get for that. But if I disrespect my parents and openly defy THEIR authority, that’s WAY worse because they gave me life, they raised me from birth, they spend hundreds of thousands of dollars on food for me over the years, they worked hard and made sacrifices to keep a roof over my head, they loved me and took care of me when I was sick. So to defy THEM isn’t just an act of rebellion like defying my teacher, it’s a slap in the face and a sign of extreme ingratitude in a way defying my teacher doesn’t even come close to.
Luke 12:48a - God isn’t just our teacher; He’s our Father who gave us life and made the ULTIMATE sacrifice of His Son in order to do so. If it’s the case that the one to whom much is given, much will be required, we’ve been given more than anyone else in history! We’ve been given Jesus and the Holy Spirit! Which is why to fall away and reject faith in Jesus is pictured as trampling Him under our feet, nailing Him to the cross all over again, spitting on Him, treating His blood as unclean, and insulting the Holy Spirit of grace.
Questions/Comments?
Note: Calvinism is completely incompatible with the book of Hebrews. The whole book of Hebrews is about Jewish Christians who decided they would stay Jewish, but abandon their faith in Christ, and the whole book is a warning to them that if you fall away from Christ, you will absolutely miss out on the blessings of the Heavenly age to come.
Calvinists respond by saying, “If it’s the case that a Christian falls away from Christ, then their conversion wasn’t genuine in the first place.” But the Bible never says that. How can someone be enlightened and become a partaker in the Holy Spirit without being converted? No, the conversion is genuine, but unfortunately over time they fall away and abandon the faith in Christ.
Question: What are some things that might lead a Christian to abandon faith in Christ?
1) Discouragement from trials. We may be persecuted for our faith, or we may find that we’re having to make sacrifices to take up our cross to follow Jesus, and we get tired of sacrificing and may decide it’s not worth it. It’s interesting that there aren’t any verses with the specific wording of warning us not to lose our salvation, but there are a lot of verses warning us not to lose heart. Because losing heart can absolutely lead us to give up our faith in Jesus. Trials can make us feel like maybe God doesn’t care about us or that He’s abandoned us and won’t keep His promises. 2) Temptation to go back to our old life.
Luke 9:62 - Another thing the Israelites did was constantly look back to Egypt longing to go back. God was trying to move them forward, but they were living in a romanticized past. They remembered all the food they had, but they didn’t remember the harsh slavery, and that happens to us. We might remember all the partying we did before becoming Christians, all the “fun” we had, and we only remember the pleasure but don’t remember the pain, the emptiness, the loneliness, guilt, and shame. And I love how Jesus describes joining the kingdom as grabbing a plow, because there’s work to do to co-rule with God by cultivating life in this new Heavenly garden on earth. It points back to the kingdom prophecy in Isaiah 2 about turning our swords into plowshares, and it’s really hard to move forward with our work while looking back. Next time you’re out mowing your lawn, try to turn your body and head around so you’re looking behind you, and then see how hard it is to keep walking forward.
3) Self-reliance/Pride. Instead of connecting to the vine, we live as practical atheists. We say we believe, but then we live like there is no God, we’re act like we’re totally self-sufficient and don’t really need God’s help or wisdom, because we can be good enough for Heaven based on our own performance. 4) We turn to idols. Instead of trusting God to satisfy our souls, we turn to people, possessions, and pleasures to fill the void in our heart. 5) Seduced by the ways of this world. The comfort, the pleasure, the riches and fame can pull our hearts away from Jesus and we can fall in love with all the flashy things of this world.
2 Timothy 4:9-10
6) Neglect. Hebrews 2:1. CS Lewis once said, “Indeed the safest road to Hell is the gradual one — the gentle slope, soft underfoot, without sudden turnings, without milestones, without signposts.” This can happen in marriage where you just gradually stop spending time together, stop talking and sharing life together, and you drift apart to the point where eventually you don’t even recognize each other anymore.
Now I realize that’s a little depressing, but Sunday we’ll talk about the good news that God has set safeguards in place to help keep us from falling away.