It's Katie's birthday. Joe walks us through his gift giving process. He needs to do better than last year. Katie wants to have a gender reveal party for the new puppy. Rob is a little perturbed with Robby over some Die Laughing Productions flyers. Joe lies to his soon-to-be neighbor's contractor. And then double, triple and quadruples down on it. A friend of Joe's wants a Rod Stewart concert ticket hookup. Did Joe sabotage a wedding proposal? Did Joe's nephew call him a piece of shit on the air? The fellas all loved Peacemaker. Is John Cena more talented than The Rock? And the new Bill Cosby documentary is discussed.