There is a common fallacy that the larger Christian faith is exposed as illegitimate through the failings of its leaders. Whenever a famous pastor, influential apologist, or chart-topping contemporary artist is revealed to be sinful, prideful, or deceitful, some critics are inspired to jump on the hypocrisy of these spiritual leaders. Suppose these people, who often espouse Christian moral attributes, are secretly living in secular sin. In that case, they claim, the Christian faith must be a false religion meant only to extract money and exert authority.
Sanctification and righteousness are undoubtedly crucial to any Christian, and especially for the Christian in a public or leadership position. Paul demands that church elders be above reproach or offer no cause to question their character (1 Timothy 3:2, Titus 1:7). James warns spiritual teachers because they are held to a higher standard due to their impact. (James 3:1) Indeed, righteousness is essential in validating our testimonies of Jesus as our true Lord and Savior.
Yet, God is not limited by our sinfulness or righteousness. He intends to work His plan, no matter our choices. God seems to revel in His ability to use stuttering killers (Moses), cowardly military leaders who tolerate paganism (Gideon), the imprisoned (Joseph), the adulterous plotter (David), those who may deny Him in weakness (Peter), and arrogant accomplices to murder (Paul) to accomplish His perfect will despite their imperfections. Imperfection is God’s only option beyond the perfect obedience of His Son, Jesus, from whom God asked the most.
So, we should not be surprised when another Christian leader falls. Disappointment is natural, but it does not—cannot—implicate the validity of the faith. To assign the failings of a fallen Christian leader to the faith is akin to blaming the US Constitution for a president’s poor job. In the latter case, the Constitution provides the framework by which we should judge or potentially remove a president. Similarly, our faith and the Word of the Bible provide the framework with which we correct, punish, and—yes—support the disgraced Christian. Neither source is responsible for the errant representative; in fact, the necessity for the source itself is validation because of the tendencies of our representatives to fail, whether politically or spiritually.
We see God work with terrible standards throughout the Bible, and ample evidence exists in the Book of Judges. One of the most famous, Samson, is known for his superhuman strength. It’s written that he tore a lion apart with his bare hands. He lifts and moves a massive city gate. This is Superman-type stuff.
Samson was a miracle baby given to a barren woman (Judges 13). As a part of this miracle birth, Samson’s father and mother vow to raise Samson as a Nazarite, a notably pious Jewish sect known for abstaining from wine and not cutting their hair. These lifelong offerings were intended to deepen the spiritual humility of the vowed Nazarite. Unfortunately, Samson is not a great example of adhering to this birthright prerequisite.
Samson’s first story involves his demand to marry a Philistine woman. While intercultural marriage is supported in our current Western culture, it was highly controversial then. More notably, it was against God’s law, for He hoped to avoid the negative consequences of spiritual intermingling. (Deuteronomy 7:3) Our first interaction with Samson is his demand to break God’s law.
This first story also includes the account of the lion. The lion attacks Samson, and Samson defends himself by killing the lion. A honeycomb later grows in the carcass, and Samson eats some of its honey. For Samson to eat food from the decaying carcass heavily violated kosher laws. (Leviticus 11) This is another instance of his unrighteousness.
The ensuing marriage celebration lasts for seven days. While the Bible does not record it, Samson’s track record indicates that he most likely drank wine at his wedding. This would have violated one of the Nazarite vows. Some may disagree with this interpretive liberality; however, we see future episodes of Samson’s uncontrolled rage and poor decisions with women while having no regard for his spiritual responsibilities. Such an accusation is not too difficult to imagine for a seven-day party.
Despite Samson’s many errors, God still uses Samson to accomplish His will. Samson resists the Philistinian occupiers. Samson is regularly endowed with the Lord’s Spirit to gain strength. Samson has a poor track record of obedience, yet the Lord remains faithful.
Only when Samson foolishly reveals the source of his strength to a later woman, Delilah, does he fall on hard times. Judges 16 tells us, “Having put him to sleep on her lap, she called a man to shave off the seven braids of his hair, and so began to subdue him. And his strength left him.” (Judges 16:19, NIV) Why was Samson’s hair the key to his strength and success? Because it was the last remnant of Samson’s vow still intact. Now that it is gone, Samson is left without.
The consequences are tragic; without his strength, Samson’s eyes are gouged out, and he is imprisoned. “But the hair on his head began to grow again after it had been shaved.” (Judges 16:22, NIV) Samson gets his revenge as he is paraded blindly in front of his enemies and asks the Lord to bless him one last time as he destroys the building they are all gathered in. This time, Samson recognizes where his power comes from and, in humility, achieves his God-ordained purpose.
Samson was God’s chosen champion for his time, but moral failings still marked him. We should not aspire to imitate Samson’s arc, but we can take solace that God remained with him throughout, especially by providing Samson another chance to fulfill his original purpose.
Christian leaders will fail, just like secular ones do. In fact, Christian leaders are larger spiritual targets and undoubtedly face even more temptation—it is how our enemy works. Our expectations should be high for such leaders because of their impact on the church, but we should be willing to extend a large portion of grace to them when they fail because God brings good things through failure. He brings good things through each of us.
The most blessed vow today is not to be a Nazarite but is, instead, our profession of faith in God’s Son, Jesus of Nazareth. So long as we can hold fast to that indestructible truth, our vow will stand, and our God will not leave us. Instead of condemning the faith for the failings of our Christian leaders, perhaps we should instead exalt the source of our faith, Jesus, for being all that we cannot be—that is, worthy of the position.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit prodigalsonline.substack.com