A high school baseball dilemma sparks debate as West Nassau had a playoff game scheduled the same night as prom—leading several seniors, including their top pitcher, to choose prom over the postseason. The team went on to lose 12-1, and Joe says it’s a no-brainer—they should’ve played. That sets off a fun and honest conversation with Hollywood, as they reflect on their own prom nights, what they would’ve done in that situation, and the real motivations behind the decision. Was it about once-in-a-lifetime memories… or trying to get lucky on prom night? The guys debate what the right call really was.