The guys discuss the fragile situation involving Caitlin Clark and the Indiana Fever and why the scrutiny could continue. Also, Daniel Jones looks on track for Week 1, Jake likes the upset in the NBA Finals, and Schultz loses the mustache.

Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Zaire (chicken)
Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Built To Last

Did we just witness the greatest Indianapolis 500 in modern history? The guys debate, plus comparing the 2025 Pacers to the 2026 Knicks, what the Eastern Conference playoffs this year tell us about next year's Pacers, hand out the rest of our annual Indy 500 awards, and Jake needs a bigger car.

Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Hoagie Balboa
Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Lima Ranchera (Mexican lager)

It's race week in Indianapolis! The guys get to their driver tiers and talk Indianapolis 500, but also get into the Colts' seemingly light slate for next Fall and why that could lead to a surprise (in a good way) season.

Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Hog Island
Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: 500 Miles High (American Lager)

Now that the NBA Draft lottery yielded the worst-case scenario result for the Pacers, do you reflect differently on last season's Ivica Zubac trade with the Clippers? Plus, a look at the shrinking NBA Playoff field, some early Indianapolis 500 takes, and investigating the origin of the term "balls to the wall".

Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: The 9th Street
Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: 500 Miles High (American lager)

The Colts don't want Anthony Richardson, Anthony Richardson doesn't want the Colts, but no one else wants Anthony Richardson (at least not via trade), so... what's next? The guys talk about next steps with the former top-five pick. Plus, a big week for the Pacers' future, whether or not you're watching the non-Indiana NBA Playoffs, and do you choose a barber or stylist?

Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Plain Turkey hoagie
Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Comfortably Numb (Pale Ale)

The guys discuss the Colts nabbing their new "green dot" in CJ Allen and a couple of other starters across the class. Also, the ongoing sports gambling issues involving players hits close to home, IU football loads up on draft picks, and Jake buys women's clothing on clearance.

Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Always Sunny
Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Blood on the Tracks (Blood Orange IPA)

We spent a good chunk of this week's show remembering the beloved and iconic Bob Kevoian, who passed away late last week. Also, a look at NFL Draft week for the Colts and Anthony Richardson's trade value (or lack thereof) and vehicle engineering developing an in-car toilet!

Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Keystone
Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Santeria (Mexican lager)

The Pacers wrapped up a miserable season, but the guys discuss why the short-term pain could lead to some big, long-term gain. Also, a discussion as to whether or not the Colts can find a few starters in next week's NFL Draft and Jake's favorite band makes the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame.

Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Market Street
Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Comfortably Numb (Pale Ale)

Dusty May and Michigan took home the crown, but Indianapolis shined the brightest (in the guys' non-biased opinions). Jake and Derek tie a bow on the college hoops season, what it means for the Big Ten to end a title drought, and they get hung up on the 1990 NBA Draft class for some reason.

Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Texas Tommy (bacon-wrapped hot dog!)
Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Built to Last (German pilsner)

It's Final Four week in Indianapolis and the guys dive into what it all means for the four participants. Also, where does Braylon Mullins' (Indiana Mr. Basketball) shot rank in all-time March Madness moments and how to evaluate Purdue's season after it ended in the regional final.

Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: The Shipyard 
Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Blood on the Tracks (Blood Orange IPA)