The shorthanded Colts lost Alec Pierce early but had a chance to pull off a huge win in Kansas City before letting it slip away late. The guys discuss Shane Steichen's handling of the playcalling in overtime and where the 0-2 Colts go from here. Also, possible fallout from the Alec Pierce injury, the Fever go down to the wire and Schultz's Rose Bowl/L.A. trip recap!

Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Keystone
Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Landslide (Peach IPA)

0:00 Show rundown / Hoagie Eating Contest recap! 
2:50 Colts brass out of "almosts"
6:07 AFC South still stinks 
8:50 Awful defensive start
14:02 Gotta play to win 
20:27 Missed opportunity in OT 
25:50 Hoagie and Brew of the Week (and quick cat adoption plug)
30:09 Hero: Ole Miss
32:35 Jake is Lane Kiffin 
37:30 Getting to know Darius Slayton 
39:47 Alec Pierce injury reaction
47:10 Biggie hit scene / Schultz is East Coast
51:35 Quick Hits
55:26 Schultz L.A. trip recap 
1:01:16 Buy it or BullSchultz

After getting thoroughly destroyed in the season opener by the Ravens, what are the major red flags the Colts need to address moving forward? We discuss that and whether or not Indy's debut changes our outlook for the season. Also, a Big Ten shakeup in college football and Jake gets in a fight on the internet.

Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Hog Island
Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Team Builder (Grapefruit Radler)
0:00 Colts sold continuity then did... *that*
4:51 Steichen, coaching staff looked incompetent
7:32 Blaming Ballard 
10:31 Recalibrate Daniel Jones expectations
13:27 Sense of urgency????
16:00 Awkward Jonathan Taylor pep talk 
17:39 Colts pushed all-in
20:29 Jake's fight with a stranger on the internet 
25:05 Hoagie & Brew of the Week!
29:14 Hero: John Harbaugh 
30:43 Hero: Kristina at Hoagies & Hops
35:32 Great sponsors... great people! 
36:57 Colts' Red Flags
39:06 CJ Allen and LB concerns 
42:08 Special Teams awful
43:53 Jake needs a powerwasher
47:40 Oregon over IU was/is dumb
49:19 Naming the 8 Pac-12 teams (?) 
51:03 Quick college football talk: Texas and more
55:05 Schultz going to L.A. this weekend
58:17 Wrestling weight class 
1:00:13 Buy it or BullSchultz

With Chris Ballard in a contract year and Shane Steichen entering a crucial fourth season, jobs may be on the line - so, what's good enough for the 2026 Colts season to be considered a success? The guys discuss, plus jumping into the Michigan Clock Fiasco (and all of its tangled tentacles) and a look back on generational flashbulb moments with this week's somber milestone marking the 9/11 tragedy. Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Market Street Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Oktoberfest (Marzen-style Lager)

0:00 Open / Rundown
1:07 Great sports week!
3:09 Colts' concerns 
7:07 Weird toilet paper analogy
9:59 Linebacker doesn't matter
13:10 What does success look like? 
18:39 Carlie's mindset
22:11 Truth serum time!
26:16 Brew & Hoagie of the Week
28:41 Hero: UMass Football 
35:30 Michigan Clock Fiasco!
43:65 LSU sitch
45:56 Dabo... oof
48:00 IU first impression
50:54 Purdue first impression
52:43 ND first impression 
55:57 Quick Hits: NFL rapid fire
59:02 Quick hits: Defending TJ McConnell
1:00:58 Flashbulb, generational moments
1:05:50 Buy it or BullSchultz

With the preseason wrapping, the guys project the 2026 Colts and react to Chris Ballard's media availability. They also talk about how they're feeling about this year's squad, why the roster doesn't stack up to contention, and a creep from the show's past re-emerges in the news (oh no...).

Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Shipyard
Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Comfortably Numb (Pale Ale - American)
0:00 Bowling a 300-game
1:38 Show intro
3:09 Special packages for Anthony Richardson?
6:52 How Richardson situation has been handled
10:54 Ballard press conference checklist!
13:02 Jaylahn Tuimoloau
15:23 Ranking Colts' roster
21:09 Jake's botched Price is Right analogy
23:06 Down on the Colts
25:30 Flock cameras
27:38 Back into the Colts predictions
29:37 Ballard's nine (ten!) lives
35:13 Hoagie and Brew of the Week!
36:36 Quick Boo cameo
37:48 Hero: Pato O'Ward
44:43 Jake's RB favorite cut
47:17 Keenan Allen WILL play
49:03 Quick Hits - IU familiar face
52:20 Quick Hits - IU/ND/PU outlook
54:35 Quick Hits - Sox-Yanks controversy
57:16 Quick Hits - Creeper is back
1:03:04 Buy it or BullSchultz

In the Season 6 finale, the guys debate whether or not they're coming back on the Anthony Richardson bandwagon as he appears closer to securing the QB2 role behind Daniel Jones. Also, the Pacers continue to get disrespected across the board and Schultz fights through a gnarly cold.

Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Always Sunny
Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Built To Last (German Pilsner)

The Colts finally added to their wide receiver depth with the addition of veteran Keenan Allen. The guys discuss his potential impact and share their thoughts on what it may mean for Alec Pierce's ankle injury. Also, the latest on the red-hot Fever and one of Jake's old 1990s scams is no more!

Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Brotherly Love
Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Loose Juicy (Pale Ale)

The guys react to Stephanie White's impassioned pregame speech following another Fever-involved controversy that blew up the WNBA discourse over the weekend. Plus, the Colts gear up for their preseason opener without star Alec Pierce - will they finally sign another wide receiver to fill out their depth chart - and why we're likely seeing the last days of Anthony Richardson as a Colt.

Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: 9th Street 
Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Lima Ranchera (Mexican Lager)

Do the Colts have a wide receiver depth problem, even with a healthy Alec Pierce? The guys discuss and also talk about the possibility of an even better Daniel Jones in year two, IU being too low in the opening college football polls and more!

Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Meadowbrook Farm cheese hoagie
Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Santeria (Cerveza Especial)

The guys discuss the good (mostly) and bad news of the Colts' camp injury updates and get into what Chris Ballard had to say about Anthony Richardson. Plus, another dive into the "how to fix the Brickyard 400" discourse and is Jake finally on-board with using AI?

Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Hoagie Balboa
Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Landslide (New England IPA)

Just one week from the start of Colts Training Camp, what are some of the biggest questions facing the team in what seems to be a make-or-break season for Shane Steichen and Chris Ballard? Also, the guys discuss Caitlin Clark's historic performance, the unfortunate lettuce issue, and give their final World Cup thoughts.

Hoagies & Hops Hoagie of the Week: Meadow Brook Farm Cheese Hoagie (new!)
Chilly Water Brewing Co. Brew of the Week: Blood on the Tracks (Blood Orange IPA)