Racket News

Racket News

By Matt Taibbi
Download on the App Store

Racket News episodes

  • Fact-Checking Glenn Kessler

    Washington Post fact-checking icon Glenn Kessler doesn’t think much of Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard or her criticism of John Brennan, James Comey, and the rest of the Rectitude Avengers:

    Why did the intelligence community become more convinced that Putin directed the effort to swing the election to Trump, instead of just seeking to inject turmoil in the U.S. elections? As the news reports misquoted by Gabbard show — and as subsequent investigations confirmed — additional, credible intelligence showed that Putin decided to back Trump over Clinton. That’s not a conspiracy but a natural evolution from careful investigative work.

    Careful. Investigative. Work.

    Strictly speaking, “careful investigative work” isn’t a checkable phrase. It doesn’t contain a time or date, the length of an Ibex horn, even a pierceable superlative like “greatest economy in history.” But Kessler in the past has asserted the power to measure the mathematical velocity of human wrongness (“the Fact Checker database shows the dramatic escalation in the rate of Trump’s dishonesty over time…”), so we may as well take a whack. Did the intelligence community reach its fateful conclusion that Putin “aspired” to help Donald Trump, for whom he’d developed a “clear preference,” through “careful investigative work”?

    Of course, Kessler when he wrote that line didn’t have the benefit of the just-released House Intelligence Committee report on the 2017 Intelligence Community Assessment that’s at issue, but let’s review anyway:

    Subscribe now

    Read more

    0 min
  • Activism, Uncensored: Christopher Columbus and Stephen Colbert

    From Managing Editor Greg Collard:

    A little-noticed June 2020 tweet resurfaced this month in which Zohran Mamdani is flipping off a statue of Christopher Columbus. The caption reads: “Take it down.” The most notable thing to me was Mamdani flipping the bird with a plastic glove, presumably to protect himself from Covid. On brand, I thought.

    The tweet, however, received a lot of news coverage, and on Monday it was a hook for a protest where it was noted that Columbus is a “symbol of Italian-American pride and ancestry,” but Ford Fischer of News2Share also shows it was about more than saving a Columbus statue. It was about Mamdani’s policies if he ends up mayor of New York City.

    The dialogue between protesters and counter-protesters is entertaining. My favorite is the counter-protester yelling:

    “You mix your meats! You mix meats in your meatballs! You put raisins in your meatballs!”

    Fightin’ words for sure.

    Ford then pivoted to the Ed Sullivan Theatre, where there was a protest of CBS’ decision to ax Stephen Colbert and The Late Show next year. One speaker—wearing a miniature Ben and Jerry’s ice cream container as a hat—holds up a copy of 1984 and declares it’s time to speak up or “this [1984] will become our reality.”

    Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

    0 min
  • Russiagate Explained: The Sins of the 2017 Intelligence Community Assessment
    Former CIA Director John Brennan testifies before the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence on May 23, 2017. (Getty Images)

    A key part of the House Permanent Selection Committee on Intelligence (HPSCI) review is about then-CIA director John Brennan’s reliance on an obscure fragment to determine in the 2017 ICA that Putin “aspired to help Trump’s chances of victory when possible.”

    The fragment, which is in bold below, comes from a raw human source intelligence report, or HUMINT in intelligence-speak.

    “Putin had made this decision [to leak DNC emails) after he had come to believe t h a t the Democratic nominee had better odds of winning the U.S. presidential election, and that [candidate Trump], whose victory Putin was counting on, most likely would not be able to pull off a convincing victory.”

    You might think that means Putin wanted Trump to win. That’s one interpretation.

    But there were five different interpretations among the five people who wrote the ICA.

    A senior CIA operations officers remarked:

    “We don’t know what was meant by that,” and “five people read it five ways,” the HPSCI reports says.

    Usually that’s no problem, because as the Intelligence Community Directive standards (ICD 203) make clear, alternative interpretations should be included. Incredibly, the ICA failed to do that even though there was great disagreement on the fragment’s meaning.

    The significance of this fragment to the ICA case that Putin "aspired" for candidate Trump to win cannot be overstated. The major "high confidence" judgment of the ICA rests on one opinion about a text fragment with uncertain meaning, that may be a garble, and for which it is not clear how it was obtained. This text-which would not have been published without DCIA's orders to do so—is cited using only one interpretation of its meaning and without considering alternative interpretations.

    The HPSCI gives some examples of alternative interpretations for “whose victory Putin was counting on.” Since the information was acquired in July 2016, it could have meant Putin “expected” a Trump victory at the upcoming Republican National Convention. The HPSCI notes that the convention’s outcome “was still uncertain to do active efforts to deny Trump a majority of convention delegates. This was a headline issue for the US political media at the time, though many pundits nonetheless expected — or ‘counted on’ — a Trump victory.”

    I encourage you to read the declassified HPSCI report for yourself. In the meantime, some other findings from the report are listed below. There are enough findings that make clear the ICA reeks to make even a roach turn away. Unfortunately, too many pols in the Adam Schiff mold have lower standards.

    • Three of the 15 HUMIT reports the ICA relied on contained flawed information, yet “these three became foundational sources the ICA cited to claim Putin aspired to help Trump win.”

    • The three reports were published “on DCIA (then-CIA director John Brennan) orders, despite veteran CIA officer judgments that they contained substandard information that was unclear, of uncertain origin, potentially biased, implausible, or in the words of senior operations officers, ‘odd'.’”

    • “The original report does not directly say, as the ICA implies, that Putin launched lead operations to help Trump win.”

    • “The ICA omits critical report context which, had it been made available to the reader, would show the report to be implausible—if not ridiculous—and missing so many key details as to be impossible.”

    • “The ICA selectively excluded information from reliable intelligence sources that senior Russian officials had serious reservation about how a potential Trump

      administration could be bad for Moscow and complicate repairing relations with Washington.”

    • “Far from showing a consensus ‘clear preference for Trump’, the

      evidence indicates Putin and Russian officials saw downsides to a potential Trump administration. The intelligence also showed, that regardless of who won, Moscow expected a prolonged struggle to repair strained relations with Washington.”

    Citing intelligence findings that don’t exist

    The ICA report says, “We assess that Russian leaders never entirely abandoned hope for a defeat of Secretary Clinton.” However, the intelligences the ICA cites to make that conclusion report does not say that. The raw intelligence, the HPSCI report says:

    • Does not state— not does it infer—that Russian leaders "never abandoned hope" for defeating Clinton, nor does it even use the word "hope" or similar phrasing.

    • Does not in any way describe the aspirations, plans or intentions of Putin or other Russian leaders.

    • Does not describe Putin's "aspiration to help Trump's chances of victory" nor does it propose contrasting Clinton unfavorably to Trump.

    The SVR’s “Derogatory Information” on Hillary Clinton

    The HPSCI report says that “Putin's decision not to leak additional derogatory information on Secretary Clinton as the polls narrowed undermine the ICA's claim that he ‘aspired’ to help Trump win and “never entirely abandoned hope for a defeat of Secretary Clinton.”

    Racket has asked Clinton to comment on the below “derogatory information” that SVR compiled. We haven’t heard back from her office. It’s important to clarify the assertions about Clinton may be important without being true. Even if it was bad intelligence, it existed, and the ICA chose not to include it. Meanwhile, it ignored the multitude of problems with the intelligence relied on to denigrate Trump.

    The HPSCI report says the “generic description of the material Putin held back makes the reader unaware of significant information available to Moscow to denigrate Secretary Clinton. This violated ICD 203 directives that analysis ‘be informed by all relevant information available’ given that documents leaked during the election were far less damaging to Secretary Clinton than those Putin chose not to leak.” Examples of the derogatory information held back:

    • “As of September 2016, the Russian Foreign Intelligence Service (SVR) had Democratic National Committee (DNC) information that President Obama and party leaders found the state of Secretary Clinton's health to

      be ‘extraordinarily alarming’ and felt it could have ‘serious negative impact’ on

      her election prospects. Her health information was being kept in ‘strictest

      secrecy’ and even close advisors were not being fully informed.”

    • “The SVR possessed DNC communications that Clinton was suffering from ‘intensified psycho-emotional problems, including uncontrolled fits of anger, aggression, and cheerfulness.’ Clinton was placed on a daily regimen of ‘heavy tranquilizers’ and while afraid of losing, she remained ‘obsessed with a thirst for power.’”

    • “The SVR also had information that Clinton suffered from ‘Type 2 diabetes, Ischemic heart disease, deep vein thrombosis, and chronic

      obstructive pulmonary disease.’ “

    • “The SVR possessed a campaign email discussing a plan approved by Secretary Clinton to link Putin and Russian hackers to candidate Trump in order to ‘distract the [American] public’ from the Clinton email server scandal.”

    • “The Russian Federal Security Service (FSB) in August had details of secret meetings with multiple named US religious organizations, in which US State Department representatives offered - in exchange for supporting Secretary Clinton-‘significant increases in financing’ from Department funds and "the patronage" of State in dealing with ‘post-Soviet’ countries.

    The Steele Dossier
    • The ICA referred to the dossier as "Russian plans and intentions," falsely implying to high-level US policymakers that the dossier had intelligence value for

      understanding Moscow's influence operations.

    • Two senior CIA officers-one from Russia operations and the other from

      Russia analysis—argued with DCIA that the dossier should not be included at all in the ICA, because it failed to meet basic tradecraft standards, according to a

      senior officer present at the meeting.

    • The same officer said that DCIA refused to remove it, and when confronted with the dossier’s many flaws, responded, “Yes, but doesn’t it ring true?”

    • CIA veterans noted that they could not imagine any previous director allowing such information in a formal CIA product, much less one intended for two Presidents, and then overriding the objections of experienced senior officers to do so. (emphasis HPSCI)

    This list is far from complete, as you’ll see from the HPSCI report listed below and Matt’s story, “In Brutal Disclosure, Russia Hoax Finally Revealed.”

    Many of these findings will come as no surprise to a lot of people, although it might be still be eye-opening to them and maybe others who haven’t reached a conclusion on the merits of the ICA. For sure, there will also be people who remain convinced that nothing untoward occurred. Nonetheless, it appears the highest levels of government during the final days of the Obama administration orchestrated a deception designed to deceive us all.

    Oversight Investigation And Referral9.21MB ∙ PDF fileDownloadDownload

    0 min
  • In Brutal Document Release, the Russia Hoax is Finally Exposed
    Confronted with the Steele Dossier’s flaws, CIA Director John Brennan reportedly said, “Yes, but doesn’t it ring true?”

    It was worse than we thought.

    The January 6, 2017 Intelligence Community Assessment concluding that Russian President Vladimir Putin “developed a clear preference” for Donald Trump and “aspired to help his chances of victory” is revealed in a report released this morning by Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard to have been based on four pieces of evidence. One was the Steele Dossier. The surprise is that the other three were even less credible, each included over objections of the report’s CIA authors.

    The first item was a “scant, unclear, and unverifiable fragment” of one sentence that the report’s five CIA authors read “five ways” and initially left out, only to have Director John Brennan order it back in. The second item was an email with “no date, no identified sender, no clear recipient, and no classification.” The third was supposedly backed by “liaison,” diplomatic, and press reporting, as well as signals intelligence (SIGINT), except the “SIGINT” didn’t mention Trump, the “liaison reporting” didn’t mention Trump and was from 2014, and the “diplomatic and media” reporting was a post-election review by a U.S. Ambassador citing a Russian pundit who said Putin and Trump should “work together like businessmen.” This was “evidence” that Putin “developed a clear preference” for Trump.

    All three reports weren’t just unsourced and unreliable, but discarded fictions pulled out of the CIA’s trash heap. “They manipulated the manipulations,” is how ODNI Deputy Chief of Staff Alexa Henning put it.

    The Assessment was written by just five CIA analysts hand-picked by Brennan, but even these most favored lieutenants couldn’t accept the key pieces of evidence. Two of the five went to Brennan to say, “We don’t have direct information that Putin wanted to get Trump elected,” only to be overruled. The same thing happened when members of the group objected to the Steele material, saying it didn’t meet even “basic tradecraft standards.” When confronted on this point, Brennan reportedly said, “Yes, but doesn’t it ring true?”

    KILL SHOT: John Brennan, apprised of the Steele dossier’s evidentiary failings, reportedly said, “Yes, but doesn’t it ring true?”

    Similarly, when FBI agents tasked with preparing source material were asked about use of the Steele reports, one replied, “Our instructions were that anything we had was to be used,” and that “We were to push this.” The analyst added, about the Steele material, that FBI leadership had decided it was “the right thing to do,” but “we were not able to verify it.” Use of the dossier was debated but ultimately insisted upon by Brennan and FBI Director James Comey, who wrote, “I thought it very important that it be included.”

    The information comes from a secret review conducted by a team of House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence (HPSCI) investigators who worked “mostly at CIA Headquarters” and “spent over 2,300 hours reviewing the ICA and its source reports,” confirming what Racket and Public reported last year. A long list of other reporters, from Lee Smith to Aaron Maté to Paul Sperry to Ray McGovern to Margot Cleveland of The Federalist to Glenn Greenwald and the Internet sleuthing group “The Corner,” previously reported on the existence of this HPSCI report, which has been “locked in a vault” and “held hostage” at Langley since 2018, as current HPSCI chair Rick Crawford put it. Only after Donald Trump interceded in early July was this report returned to the Hill, and Gabbard’s ODNI has been working to declassify it ever since.

    “The most egregious weaponization and politicization of intelligence in American history,” is how Gabbard described it today.

    “Amazing,” is how former Judiciary Committee Chief Counsel Jason Foster describes the report. “It takes apart the ICA piece by piece.”

    A staffer from the House intelligence Committee under Devin Nunes, who assigned the report in question, commented: “You don’t have to read much past the first page before it becomes crystal clear why the IC spent years trying to bury this report.”

    Details about the poverty of the primary evidence linking Putin to Trump were not the only shock in the report. There were many, many more:

    Subscribe now

    In addition to battering the “manipulated manipulations” used to undergird the notion that Putin acted to help Donald Trump, the report zeroes in on the real information the intelligence community had, but suppressed because it contradicted desired claims. In one section, it describes “significant intelligence” from an important human source, a “known confidant” of Putin who reported that “Putin told him he did not care who won the election,” that “Putin had often outlined the weaknesses of both major candidates,” and asserted that, in either case, “Russia was strategically placed to outmaneuver either one.”

    The omission of a major real piece of human intelligence speaking to Putin’s thinking exposes the Brennan/Comey/Obama Intelligence Assessment as a joke. “The ICA selectively omitted quotes from key HUMINT and SIGINT reports that contradicted the judgments on Putin’s intentions,” the report noted, “while conversely it included quotes — from those same HUMINT and SIGINT reports — that supported the ICA thesis.” The investigators added: “This was done multiple times.”

    The most damning items in today’s release are the “three substandard CIA HUMINT reports,” meaning the three pieces of alleged human intelligence used in addition to the Steele dossier to support the idea that Putin “aspired” to help Trump after developing a “clear preference” for him. Each of these Three Deformed Bears of intelligence is more embarrassing upon closer inspection. In order:

    THE “FRAGMENT”

    The Intelligence Assessment was pieced together from fifteen CIA reports overall, of which only three involved the question of Putin preferring Trump. “Most of the 15 [reports] were unremarkable,” the investigators wrote, “but three contained flawed information, and these three became foundational sources… cited to claim Putin aspired to help Trump win.”

    The sole source for the line that Putin “aspired to help” Trump came from a “scant, unclear, and unverifiable fragment of a sentence,” bolded below:

    Putin had made this decision [to leak DNC emails] after he had come to believe that the Democratic nominee had better odds of winning the U.S. presidential election, and that [Trump], whose victory Putin was counting on, most likely would not be able to pull off a convincing victory.

    In a detail not previously known, the ICA was written by just five CIA analysts. Regarding the above line, “whose victory Putin was counting on,” one senior CIA official said, “Five people read it five ways.” It was uncorroborated, with “uncertain meaning,” may have been a “garble,” and “would not have been published without [Brennan’s] orders.” Also, “it is not clear how it was obtained,” and at least one of the analysts who worked on the ICA thought the “victory” Putin was counting on involved Trump winning the nomination at the upcoming Republican convention.

    The report added inferences that were not there. From “whose victory Putin was counting on,” which meant different things to everyone involved, Brennan and the ICA authors concluded that Putin “developed a preference for Trump” and ordered intelligence services to “assist Trump’s chances of victory when possible.”

    The “fragment” was such junk that the ICA authors initially tried not to use it, but the DCIA — Director of the CIA John Brennan — corrected their manners:

    Experienced CIA officers responsible for Russia reporting — evaluating raw intelligence and ensuring that HUMINT reporting meets the threshold for publication — initially omitted the confusing fragment from the first version of the report, which was published on 20 December 2016. DCIA countermanded their decision, however, and ordered that the fragment be included so that it could be cited in the ICA. A revised report was published on 28 December 2016.

    It was “deviating from their own IC standards over and over, all in the service of one narrative,” says Foster.

    The “Fragment” was likely not the worst of the three reports, however. That honor likely belongs to the next:

    “IMPLAUSIBLE — IF NOT RIDICULOUS”

    When the Intelligence Community Assessment was published in January of 2017, the first bullet point supporting the idea of a “clear preference” for Trump read:

    As early as February 2016, a Russian political expert possessed a plan that recommended engagement with [Trump's] team because of the prospects for improved US-Russian relations, according to reporting from service.

    Even the intelligence professionals later tasked with reviewing the ICA could not let this slide without editorial comment. The passage, they wrote, “omits critical report context which, had it been made available to the reader, would show the report to be implausible — if not ridiculous — and missing so many key details as to be unusable.”

    Why unusable? Because “‘the plan’ was just an email with no date, no identified sender, no clear recipient, and no classification. CIA could not vouch for the ultimate source’s vetting, validation, or access.”

    John Brennan pulled from the trash a 10-month-old “anonymous email proposal” by an unknown person to place “a well-known pro-Kremlin official” on Trump’s “election team” in order to “formulate a mutually acceptable agenda between Trump and Putin.” It appears that this “idea” came not from Russia but perhaps another foreign service, perhaps Ukraine’s. Hilariously, the identity of the country of origin for this email was redacted from everyone’s eyes, including Barack Obama’s. Noted investigators:

    There was no security justification for obscuring the identity of the service, as the ICA was written for the President, who is cleared for everything.

    The “implausible — if not ridiculous” report was so cringeworthy, Brennan had to hide it even from the man who ordered it.

    One last piece remained:

    “NO EUPHORIA”

    Another bullet supporting the notion that Putin had a “clear preference” for Trump was supposedly corroborated by “liaison, diplomatic, and press reporting, as well as sensitive signals intelligence (SIGINT).” But “in following-up every citation, none were found to corroborate the ICA claims.”

    The “cited liaison reporting didn’t mention Trump at all, and was from 2014, before Trump was a candidate.” The diplomatic report was a “post-election overview of Moscow from the US Ambassador” that referenced a Russian pundit suggesting Trump and Putin should “work together like businessmen.” As the report noted, this was not exactly powerful evidence.

    Moreover, that same Embassy cable quoted then-Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov as saying of Trump’s election, “We do not feel any euphoria,” citing a “bipartisan anti-Russian consensus,” which, the report noted, “contradicted the ICА judgment that the Russians preferred Trump.”

    Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Rybakov wasn’t euphoric when Trump won

    In sum, corroboration for the assertion that Putin developed a “clear preference” for Trump before the election included one item that was backdated and too early, one that was post-election and too late (and meaningless nonsense besides), and not one that was just right. If there’s such a thing as a no-hitter in intelligence, Brennan’s team was on the losing end of one in this ICA, which failed to produce one reliable fact supporting the idea of Putin “aspiring” to help Trump out of a “clear preference.”

    One last note:

    The report says Russia’s Foreign Intelligence Service (SVR) had an “arsenal” of “extraordinarily alarming” information on Hillary Clinton, potentially far more damaging than the information already leaked by Wikileaks. The SVR supposedly “possessed DNC communications that Clinton was suffering from ‘intensified psychoemotional problems, including uncontrolled fits of anger, aggression, and cheerfulness,’” and was “placed on a daily regimen of ‘heavy tranquilizers.’”

    Worse, the report says the FSB had details of “secret meetings with multiple named US religious organizations, in which US State Department representatives offered — in exchange for supporting Secretary Clinton — ‘significant increases in financing’ from Department funds and ‘the patronage’ of State in dealing with ‘post-Soviet’ countries.”

    Racket tried to seek comment from Clinton. There’s been no reply.

    The report claims “Putin held back significant derogatory material that he had on Secretary Clinton,” material that in some cases Russia appeared to have acquired well before the reported “hack” of the Democratic National Committee.

    It says “the SVR reported in January 2016 that it had information taken from a US think tank indicating that a high ranking official in the Democratic National Committee (DNC) knew about the application of political pressure on the FBI in the Clinton email investigation by a high ranking official of the US Department of Justice,” an apparent reference to correspondence from then-head of the DNC Debbie Wasserman Schultz about then-Attorney General Loretta Lynch.

    The report released today notes Comey testified to the House Intelligence Committee in August 2016 that the SVR had emails in which Wasserman Schultz “was telling people that [former Attorney General Lynch] was working to control me, and keeping a named member of the Clinton campaign informed on what the FBI was doing in the [Clinton] email investigation.”

    Comey testified that the head of the DNC “was telling people that [Attorney General Loretta] Lynch was working to control me

    Though Comey and the FBI officially deemed the rumor not credible, Comey was concerned enough to tell Department of Justice Inspector General Michael Horowitz that the existence of these emails was a factor in his decision to announce the completion of the Clinton email investigation early, on July 5, 2016. If they affected Comey’s decisions, that’s a strong indication that the emails both exist and were in Russia’s possession, and might have been released by Putin if he wanted to do more damage to Clinton in that campaign. As today’s report notes, he did not do so, even after being advised by army intelligence (GRU) that Trump would not win absent an intervention of “remarkable” derogatory information, which they apparently had.

    “Not only did he hold it back,” the report reads, “he did so when it mattered most, in the closing weeks of the campaign as the polls narrowed.”

    A reason not to dismiss these claims entirely comes from the last major surprise in the report: the “arsenal” of negative information on Clinton came from the same trove of purloined material a source called “T1” had earlier provided to the FBI in the course of the Hillary Clinton email investigation. Ironically, it’s the same material written about in Racket yesterday, in conjunction with the seemingly unrelated declassification of part of an Inspector General report on the FBI’s Midyear Exam probe. In other words, while Gabbard’s release may be the closing word on the legitimacy of the ICA, she may have opened a new vein of questions at the intersection of Russiagate and the Clinton Email investigation. All that is in the future, however.

    For now, this is a massive repudiation of the Trump-Russia narrative, and a near- perfect repeat of 2002-2003, when some of the same people helped package bunk evidence to bring America to war with Iraq. James Clapper later wrote a book called Facts and Fears in which he described being ordered by Dick Cheney to “find the WMD sites,” then boasted that the images he provided as head of the National Imagery and Mapping Agency “carried the day” when Colin Powell used them in his infamous speech to the UN in support of war. In hindsight, Clapper described who was to blame for the WMD fiasco that followed. The failure, he said, belongs:

    Squarely on the shoulders of the administration members who were pushing a narrative of a rogue WMD program in Iraq and on the intelligence officers, including me, who were so eager to help that we found what wasn’t really there.

    The material that was leaked to newspapers and television stations with such fanfare on December 9th, 2016 was the same trick of finding things that weren’t “really there,” with intelligence officials ordered to “push this” because “doesn’t it ring true?” It’s the same scam, except aimed at an incoming president instead of Saddam Hussein.

    The litmus test now will involve waiting to see if any of the principals of the story, like Clapper or Brennan or Comey or even Obama, come up with alternative explanations for how they came to their key conclusion. “Don’t hold your breath,” one source advised.

    The fight to get this material out is becoming an notable subtext. On July 14th, at the Turning Point convention, Gabbard told audiences, “The Deep State is fighting us every step of the way.” There have been internecine disputes throughout, over everything from today’s HPSCI report to the testimony of the former DNI whistleblower referenced in last weekend’s release by Gabbard. There are factions within Donald Trump’s own government who are opposed to this material’s release. Thankfully, for now, he’s ignoring them.

    More to come.

    0 min
  • Listen to This Article: Barack Obama Now Squarely in Russiagate Crosshairs

    New disclosures from a Tulsi Gabbard-led working group point directly to the top, as the legacy of "Hope and Change" begins a plunge to the ocean floor

    Narrated by Jared Moore

    Art by Daniel Medina

    Text published 07/19/25:

    Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app

    Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts

    Read more

    3 min
  • Debating Russiagate With Michael Isikoff

    Last night I was invited on NewsNation with Chris Cuomo to discuss Tulsi Gabbard’s Trump-Russia documents. Just before going on, I learned Chris planned to argue against Tulsi’s report as “dangerous” and a “conflation” and I’d be sharing the segment with Michael Isikoff, a central (if sometimes penitent) player in the Trump-Russia deception. At Yahoo! in September of 2016 Michael ran “U.S. intel officials probe ties between Trump adviser and Kremlin,” the first major story tied to the “well-placed Western intelligence source,” eventually revealed to be British ex-spy Christopher Steele. The piece, which called former Trump aide Carter Page a “possible back channel” to the Kremlin in September 2016, would eventually be used in a fraudulent FBI warrant application to obtain FISA authority on Page. That wasn’t Michael’s fault, but it wasn’t a proud moment, either.

    There’s nothing unethical about springing a surprise like this on a guest. Such confrontations often make good TV. I’ve no ill will to Chris. But I didn’t know I’d be debating two people, and naturally felt annoyance before being introduced. I started by explaining that the core story behind Tulsi Gabbard’s documents is that the Obama administration at the 11th hour threw its weight behind paid, bogus opposition research of Steele, a source, I made sure to point out, my fellow guest Isikoff knew all too well to be unreliable. Isikoff, virtually alone among Russiagate journalists, took some responsibility for having his chain yanked by Steele in tales like the Page story, eventually saying on MSNBC: “[Steele’s Dossier] was endorsed multiple times on this network, people saying, ‘It’s more and more proving to be true.’ And it wasn’t.”

    Now however he was brought in to chuckle at Gabbard’s claims, and say there was overwelming evidence that Russia was trying to help Trump, in the form of the DNC hack that by the way was never conclusively linked to Russia (or even proven to be a hack at all), and the absurd $100,000 worth of Facebook ads that supposedly turned an election. Then, when he pooh-poohed the idea thay the 2017 Intelligence Community Assessment was based on “manufactured” or “made up” evidence, I began losing it. What the hell is the Steele Dossier if not “manufactured intelligence?” Hadn’t the country obsessed for 30 months over blatant lies about pee and a “well developed conspiracy” of at least five years? “It was all bull. It’s a lie. And it dominated American politics for years,” I said. When I pointed out to Michael that he shared some responsibility for this, he snickered and said, “Or I blew the whistle on some of it.”

    I went ape. Blew the whistle? Michael and co-author David Corn wrote a quickie book, Russian Roulette, that was significantly based on Steele material, and presented him in chapter after chapter as an avenging angel (“Surely, Steele believed, that was more than a coincidence” or “On such matters, Steele was the man to see” are typical excerpts). Steele wasn’t exposed as a paid Clinton researcher until October, 2017, and the information only came out because a combination of Senate Judiciary and House Intelligence Committee investigations pried the fact loose. It certainly didn’t come from Michael or David Corn. It threw me for a moment, figuring the sheer stones it takes to claim to be a Steele whistleblower while authoring Russian Roulette.

    Well into my fourth decade in journalism, I can’t remember a time when the business wasn’t dominated by a big lie. It’s been my bad luck to be in the middle of some of the worst episodes, with many of them coalescing in this idiotic Russia story that won’t die. Or maybe it’s better to say, it won’t die easy. As I learned again last night, it’s going to be fought to the bitter end.

    0 min
  • Classified Report on Hillary Clinton, Loretta Lynch, and James Comey Finally Released
    DECLASSIFIED ALL-STARS: Clockwise from top left, James Comey, Loretta Lynch, Andrew McCabe, and Hillary Clinton

    The hits keep coming. Amid controversies surrounding Jeffrey Epstein and Tulsi Gabbard’s Trump-Russia investigation, an odd new window was thrown open Monday into the FBI’s ill-fated “Midyear Exam” investigation of Hillary Clinton’s private email server. Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) announced the declassification of a classified appendix to Justice Department Inspector General Michael Horowitz’s 2018 report into the FBI’s handling of the email probe.

    It’s a long-awaited release of 35 pages of curious-to-alarming classified details from the Clinton email investigation.* There will be groans that this is another rehash of “But her emails!”, but the IG annex is a significant new angle, and about a lot of things, not just Hilary Clinton.

    The report focuses on a previously-undisclosed inquiry into eight thumb drives of material from a source called “T1.” This source delivered reams of correspondence from American officials purloined by a foreign (likely Russian) intelligence service, as well as analytical documents in Russian. Horowitz was circumspect about their provenance:

    Beginning in [redacted], the FBI obtained [redacted] thumb drives from a source known as T1… These thumb drives primarily contain data exfiltrated by [redacted] from various U.S. victims, including the Executive Office of the President (EoP), the State Department, the U.S. House of Representatives, other federal agencies, and private sector and federal institutions…

    The FBI’s apparent failure to investigate a serious breach of official correspondence, all the way up to the President’s office, seems the most important revelation. Former Grassley aide and chief counsel to the Judiciary Committee Jason Foster, now of Empower Oversight, said these releases compared the FBI’s handling of Midyear Exam to a foundering ship.

    “They’re not just ignoring the hole in the hull,” Foster said. “They’re on purpose looking in the other direction, not even investigating how much water is coming in.”

    One element to the T1 documents whose relevance Horowitz did explain had to do with a Russian-language document summarizing, as he put it, “purported communications between Congresswoman Debbie Wasserman-Schultz… and two different individuals from the Open Society Foundation” of George Soros.

    This document, which Comey and the FBI said they deemed not credible, nonetheless contained analysis of the stolen American correspondence with an eyebrow-raising piece of gossip: that “the political director of the Hillary Clinton staff, Amanda Renteria, regularly receives information from Loretta Lynch of the Department of Justice, on the plans and intentions of the FBI”:

    Whether or not the rumors were true is immaterial. They were still important, as their existence apparently motivated Comey to issue his much-ballyhooed July 5th, 2016 announcement wrapping up the Clinton investigation.

    “Not that I believe in them,” Comey said, referencing the documents, but “I could picture emails rocketing around the Internet of… someone at the Atlantic Council saying, ‘I just had lunch with Debbie Wasserman Schultz. She told me Loretta Lynch is controlling Jim Comey’”:

    Much of the material in this new declassified annex describes the IG’s efforts to understand how the FBI investigated the Lynch angle. It shows even officials now considered fanatical Democratic Party partisans, like Andrew McCabe, speaking in exasperated or puzzled tones about Lynch, and includes other exchanges involving other officials that are head-scratching or comical. To wit:

    Subscribe now

    Read more

    0 min
  • ATW Livestream Today at 4 PM ET/3 PM CT

    Join Walter and Matt for another episode of ATW Live. They’ll dive into the events from over the weekend and conclude Evelyn Waugh’s Scoop.

    Tune in at 4:00 PM ET on Substack, Rumble, and YouTube:

    Or visit Matt or Walter on X.

    See you soon!

    0 min

About Racket News

From the publisher's feed

Regular news and features by award-winning author and investigative reporter, Matt Taibbi.