Racket News

Racket News

By Matt Taibbi
Download on the App Store

Racket News episodes

  • ATW Livestream Today at 4 PM ET/3 PM CT

    Join Walter and Matt for another episode of ATW Live. They’ll dive into the events from over the weekend and continue reading Evelyn Waugh’s Scoop.

    Tune in at 4:00 PM ET on Substack, Rumble, and YouTube:

    Or visit Matt or Walter on X.

    See you soon!

    0 min
  • ATW Bookclub: "Scoop" Part 2
    Illustrated by Daniel Medina

    Full Episode Here

    Book Club Schedule

    This Episode: Evelyn Waugh’s Scoop (Day 2/4)

    Monday Night: Evelyn Waugh’s Scoop (Day 2/4)

    Read more

    0 min
  • Transcript - America This Week, The Case Against Brennan and Comey: Walter discovers source of Newspeak

    Listen to Episode 141

    Matt Taibbi: Welcome to America This Week. I’m Matt Taibbi.

    Walter Kirn: I’m Walter Kirn.

    Matt Taibbi: How’s it going, Walter?

    Walter Kirn: It’s going well. For some reason, I wake up early to do this show out here in the West, and I’m having a little harder time waking up this morning than usual because I’ve been working on a book all hours.

    Matt Taibbi: Oh, I thought you were dying. Okay, go ahead.

    Walter Kirn: No, no, no. Not dying. Not yet.

    Matt Taibbi: Okay.

    Walter Kirn: I’ll make sure to tell the audience because that’s ratings.

    Matt Taibbi: Exactly.

    Walter Kirn: But yeah, I’m doing well and I’m ready to dig into some news. Finally, a show where we have objective, reportable, on the record, some off the record news you can use.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah. And this is even one that I’m a little bit in the middle of.

    Walter Kirn: Right.

    Matt Taibbi: So I can get into some things that maybe aren’t out there in the public domain yet.

    Walter Kirn: Good.

    Matt Taibbi: So the big story, and we talked about this last week when CIA Director, John Ratcliffe released an eight-page memorandum that had an odd title. I forget what it was called. We’ll have to take a look at it. It has some verbose tradecraft something or other misgivings or-

    Walter Kirn: Mistakes were made.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah, mistakes were made, whatever it was, and it listed... As we discussed, it offered some concrete CIA note. That’s right.

    Walter Kirn: Right.

    Matt Taibbi: And it listed a number of things, including some new facts and new quotes from emails that we hadn’t heard before. Now, a lot of this stuff had been reported on, as I mentioned, by people like Aaron Montes, Dan Bongino, Margot Cleveland, Paul Sperry. I’m sure I’m leaving somebody out, but there were a number of other folks-

    Walter Kirn: The bad news bearers of Russiagate.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah, exactly. Then Michael Shellenberger and I and Alex Gutentag last year also did a big story on this exact same stuff, the essence of which was the Intelligence Community Assessment of 2017 that came out on January 6th, 2017, just as Donald Trump, president elect, was about to take office. They released this big report that essentially assessed that Russia had interfered or had conducted influence operations to help Donald Trump and to hurt Hillary Clinton. And the reason this is important, and this is something that I think people who... Not so much people who follow this and are Trump supporters and already know what this story’s about need to listen to, but let’s address the folks on the other side for a moment, the people who are MSNBC watchers and who have followed this from Rachel Maddow for years.

    The reason this is important, this January 6th, 2017 Intelligence Community Assessment, is that it has a summary at the top that says that thing about Russia interfering to help specifically Trump and to hurt Hillary Clinton. They could not have done that had they not included material from the Steele dossier. They did not have enough intelligence to support that conclusion. There was a great deal of intramural argument about this. If you go down a little further, assessing Russian activities and intentions in recent US elections, it’s the third paragraph is the money paragraph. “We also assess Putin and the Russian government aspired to help President-elect Trump’s election chances when possible by discrediting Secretary Clinton and publicly contrasting her unfavorably to him.” So that, “aspired,” line is the key line in the whole thing. Without that, there’s no Russiagate, there’s no nothing, but they couldn’t have done it. They did not have intelligence to support that. In fact, they had analysis going in the other direction that they suppressed. They couldn’t have done it without the Steele stuff.

    The Ratcliffe memo that we went over last week detailed how John Brennan overrode not only some of his senior analysts, but people whose job it was specifically to warn him off bad intelligence. Told him that he couldn’t include this stuff under any circumstances because it didn’t meet even the lowest level of tradecraft or something like that. And so that’s why this is important. Without this, there’s no Russiagate. There’s no three years of anything. It all would’ve died at that moment.

    And there was some intramural strife about this last week when you and I, Walter, were talking about this. There were some people who are Trump supporters, who are longtime followers of this material who were upset that this CIA note by John Ratcliffe didn’t delve into the meat of the corruption. Specifically Rick Crawford, the new Head of the House Intelligence Committee, sent a very angry letter to Donald Trump on January 2nd. And if we can look at the last part here of that letter.

    Walter Kirn: You mean July 2nd?

    Matt Taibbi: July 2nd, I’m sorry. Yes. It says, “I am disappointed that the agency was permitted to whitewash the full extent of their problems,” and he’s talking about the ICA. Crawford also complains that the House Intelligence Committee, that their work has been held hostage at the CIA and has not been returned, and most people don’t know what that’s about. That’s because the biggest investigation into all this stuff was done by the House Intelligence Committee in 2017 and 2018 in the 115th Congress when Devin Nunes was the Chairman of the Committee, and Kash Patel was the lead investigator. But all of that stuff has been locked in a vault at Langley since 2018 and has not been returned, and Crawford is complaining about this in this letter. He’s saying, “Our stuff is being held hostage and you left out all the important stuff.”

    Well, after this letter, Trump interceded, this is my understanding, Trump interceded, Ratcliffe returned the House Intelligence stuff to Congress, and then the next day, Crawford tweeted a note of thanks. “Thanks for the swift response,” he says, and, “All is well.” And I talked to a bunch of people close to the House Intelligence Committee investigation, the original one yesterday, and they were upset and puzzled last week. Now they’re cautiously optimistic. Some of them are happy because of this new news, Walter, that criminal investigations have been opened into John Brennan and James Comey, the former FBI Director. So what do you think of this news, first of all, Walter? It could be nothing, right? We’ve all gotten jaded by now because nothing ever happens, but...

    Walter Kirn: I’m not that jaded. I think things do happen. They happen very slowly and they have to push their way through endless strata of bureaucratic inertia and endangered and cautious personnel and other things. I guess you’re asking me what do I think about the supposed targeting? Well, let’s see it. Let’s get it on. I can’t think of any more interesting, as a journalist or important as a citizen, investigation other than that of the president himself than that of the two, let’s say Intelligence Chiefs of America, domestic FBI, and foreign, supposedly CIA, in an attempt what to prevent a president from taking office, to prevent him from being effective once in office, perhaps to get him out of office rather promptly after he takes it. If there is evidence of this and it can’t be looked at, then what the heck are we doing? Just standing outside the Kremlin in the snow wondering what goes on in there? No, that’s not supposed to be how it is. I think it’s time.

    Matt Taibbi: Yeah. And there were some people who were upset that the crimes being looked at are perjury and conspiracy.

    Walter Kirn: Well, what are the crimes supposed to be?

    Read more

    0 min
  • One More Wafer Thin Mint?
    Illustration by Daniel Medina

    Back in the “good old days” of subprime mortgage-mania, the business of making loans and securitizing them took on the appearance of the proverbial tail wagging the dog. The participants in the business of making the loans, securitizing them, selling them and managing them could not care less who was actually getting the loan. There seemed to be an endless supply of global capital that “needed” to be put to work in subprime. Wall Street was making billions and the only thing that mattered was creating a loan, no matter how ridiculous, to feed the subprime structured-product market.

    We know how all that turned out.

    I get the strong feeling this is what has been happening in the Private Market (Private Equity and Private Credit) investment sector.

    Let’s focus on Private Credit, a rapidly growing asset class.

    Private Credit (PC) represents direct lending to private companies, many of whom are owned in PE portfolios from Non-Bank Lenders (NBLs). Many of the same investment management companies who are big players in Private Equity (PE), such as Blackstone, Apollo, Ares and KKR are also NBL managers of PC funds. These managers, as well as many others, have been rapidly raising capital to grow their PC funds as investors such as life insurers, pension funds and foreign sovereign wealth funds clamor to invest heavily. Many of the nation’s large banks have been rapidly increasing their lending to PC funds. Morgan Stanley reported last year that PC had a market size of approximately $1.5 trillion, with the potential to be $2.8 trillion by 2028.

    Private credit can very well be a good thing by providing liquidity to underbanked businesses. But with its rapid growth, has PC become just another way to feed Wall Street’s Private Market deal beast and overload the economy with debt?

    Last week Bloomberg News reported:

    Bankruptcies by mid-sized private US companies hit their highest level since 2010 last year as high interest rates and costs squeezed profits… and so far 2025 looks poised for another record, according to a report from Marblegate Asset Management and RapidRatings. Expensive debt and higher costs are leaving firms barely able to cover their debt payments and more than a fifth of analyzed companies in 2024 had interest coverage ratios of less than 1, meaning that they’re unable to generate enough earnings to cover interest payments, the firms said in the report. The average interest coverage ratio was 1.26 times last year, as shrinking earnings, more leverage and higher rates have “eroded solvency” for many companies, they said.

    The Marblegate report “analyzed more than 1,200 private companies with revenue between $100 million and $750 million, and compared them to about 1,700 publicly traded companies with revenue of $750 million or less in the Russell 3000. The private companies have seen a measure of their income — earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization — fall 23% since 2019. At larger public corporations, EBITDA rose 16% over the same period.”

    The trend does not seem to be our friend here with regard to loading more private companies with more debt. Yet with all the capital pouring into the PC sector, we seem to be doubling down on it. It is important to remember that we are seeing the deterioration noted by Marblegate while the economy is doing reasonably well. What happens in a recession, or worse, what happens if we have a recession combined with inflation — stagflation?

    According to a report from the Federal Reserve this past May about the nation’s banking sector,

    Committed credit lines by the largest U.S. banks to private credit vehicles (PD funds and BDCs) have increased significantly over the past five years (about 145 percent, equivalently to an annualized growth rate of about 19.5 percent), reaching about $95 billion as of 2024-Q4.

    In 2025 we can see that banks have continued to increase their exposure to PC funds. For example, this past February JP Morgan announced they were increasing their $10 billion commitment to PC to $50 billion.

    The Fed’s report went on to say,

    The bulk of bank loans to NBFIs (non-bank financial institutions) are rated investment grade, exhibit very low delinquency rates and tend to be of shorter maturity than loans to nonfinancial corporations.

    Remember how we relied on our great ratings agencies, S&P and Moody’s, for their discernment of subprime securities?

    The report continued (emphasis mine):

    “While immediate risks from private credit vehicles appear limited due to their moderate use of leverage and long-term capital lockups, the lack of transparency and understanding of the interconnectedness between private credit and the rest of the financial system makes it difficult to assess the implications for systemic vulnerabilities.”

    That last bit doesn’t exactly give a warm and fuzzy feeling.

    Then there’s JP Morgan struggling mightily to create a secondary trading market for PC loans, Bloomberg News reported last month:

    Private credit managers have a message for the JPMorgan Chase traders who have been trying to establish a secondary market for the industry: no thanks.

    Bloomberg reported that the PC managers have a strong motivation to say no to JP’s efforts because of “the fear that if JPMorgan, or any of the other banks following in its footsteps, is successful in creating a vibrant trading market for the loans, it could shatter the perception—or mirage, as critics would argue—of price stability that they’ve spent years selling to investors. The value of the loans, the pitch goes, won't ever get whipsawed around, and dragged down, by the vagaries of the broader markets because they are privately held assets. But if they trade regularly, price levels get marked, day after day, and private credit suddenly doesn't look all that different than its public market counterparts.”

    I guess the “vagaries of the broader markets” include fundamental analyses that show a particular borrower’s or an entire industry’s ability to service their debt is quickly deteriorating? As an investor, that is something they might want to know, right?

    Is all of this really necessary or is it just another gigantic payday for Wall Street, where if it all blows up and tanks the nation, they just walk away with the billions they already made and move on to the next big thing?

    Do we really need “one more wafer-thin mint?”

    0 min
  • Brennan, MSNBC Can't Stop Lying About Trump and Russia

    Last evening, former CIA director John Brennan made his first public comments since news broke that the FBI under Kash Patel has opened a criminal investigation into his conduct in the Trump-Russia investigation. He was interviewed on MSNBC, where he is a paid contributor. The one piece of salient information host and former Bush administration spokesperson Nicolle Wallace didn’t leave out is that Brennan is a “Senior national security and intelligence analyst right here at MSNBC.”

    This was after Wallace interviewed former Hillary Clinton lawyer Marc Elias, who in 2016 was the point man responsible for hiring the “research” firm Fusion-GPS, which in turn hired former British spy Christopher Steele to compile reports on Donald Trump. Elias in other words paid the firm that shopped bogus reports to virtually every news agency in America, along with the FBI and politicians like John McCain, in an effort to kick-start a political investigation of a political rival.

    What did Elias have to say about investigations into Brennan and Comey? Abandoning all self-respect, humorously hoping no one would remember his entire political raison d’être has been leveraging iffy information into legal trouble for antagonists, he said, “Like honestly, I’m just imploring the media, do NOT report” the news of the investigations. Priceless:

    The amusing Elias video means people like the former Clinton lawyer are worried that not only conservatives, but friendly audiences at places like MSNBC might begin exploring what actually happened in 2016-2019. If those audiences put even minimal effort into learning the basics of these cases, it’s possible mainstream public opinion will finally turn — not on Trump, but on the concocted Trump-Russia mania of those years, which deserves a place in history next to or even above the WMD scandal as the biggest intelligence fiasco of our time.

    The Wallace interview with Brennan was similarly comic. A summary of the segment is included for those who believe he’s innocent. This article isn’t paywalled, so Racket readers can circulate it to anyone who they feel may still be holdouts on Trump-Russia island. If that describes you, the MSNBC segment below is a small, jewel-like example of how you’ve been lied to by media and by officials like Brennan:

    Note that Wallace early on says “exactly what conduct is being investigated is not clear.” That’s not strictly true. It’s been reported in multiple places (including here) that the FBI is looking at perjury and conspiracy charges. Wallace does say investigations are in connection with Brennan’s handling of a January 6th, 2017 Intelligence Community Assessment, but she doesn’t tell you why this is important.

    Nor does the New York Times, whose headline read, “Administration Takes Steps to Target 2 Officials Who Investigated Trump,” as if the gravestone modifiers for Comey or Brennan might be, THEY INVESTIGATED TRUMP. The Times, like Elias, is going with a “misuse, abuse, [and] authoritarian takeover” theme, insisting these investigations signal only that “Trump’s appointees intend to follow through on his campaign to exact retribution against his perceived enemies.” The Washington Post used the same construction, highlighting Trump’s campaign-trail promise to “exact retribution against many of his political enemies.”

    It’s probably true Trump is anxious for payback — he denounced Comey and Brennan as “very dishonest people” in the wake of the investigation news and suggested there may be a “price to pay” — but that doesn’t mean these goofs have no real exposure. Mainstream press audiences just haven’t been told what both men did, and specifically how both benefited from an illegal leak of material from their January 2017 Intelligence Assessment, material that was both bogus and classified.

    In early 2017, it wasn’t inevitable that President-Elect Donald Trump was going to face years of exhaustive Russia investigations. Contrary to popular legend, as of January 6th, 2017, neither the FBI nor the CIA had developed intelligence supporting a conclusion that Vladimir Putin “aspired” to interfere with our presidential election specifically to help Trump. In fact, there was evidence in the opposite direction, suggesting Russia and Putin were less than thrilled by the prospect of a White House run by the “unreliable” Trump, and may have seen Clinton as “manageable and reflecting continuity.” However, the Democratic Party by the end of 2016 already committed publicly to the idea that Putin aided Trump’s win. On December 16, 2016, for instsance, Hillary Clinton blamed her loss on Putin’s “personal grudge” against her.

    There was no reason government officials had to co-sign this conclusion in the Intelligence Assessment Barack Obama commissioned, but they did. To get there, they had to use material from Steele, who had already been dismissed as a source by the FBI on November 1st, 2016, after he leaked reports for a Mother Jones story by David Corn.

    Without Steele material, there would have been no pre-inauguration report saying “Putin and the Russian Government aspired to help President-elect Trump’s election chances when possible by discrediting Secretary Clinton.” In order to keep that storyline, the FBI had to take seriously Steele’s assertions about the existence of a “well-developed conspiracy of cooperation” between him and Russia. With Trump about to enter the White House and FBI investigations into Carter Page, Michael Flynn, and Trump stalling, this “Assessment” was the whole ballgame, the last chance to keep Trump-Russia going. Two actions were crucial: the controversial internal decision to include the Steele stuff, and the near-immediate leak of the report’s classified contents to the public before Trump was sworn in.

    Here’s how first Wallace, then Brennan handled this:

    1. Nicolle Wallace (at 2:22 above):

      “But the report or the Note doesn’t dispute the conclusion of the intelligence community. And that conclusion is that Russia interfered.”

      This is a silly mischaracterization of John Ratcliffe’s “Note,” which didn’t even look at the question of whether or not Russia “interfered.” Ratcliffe and the CIA instead “focused particular attention on the ICA’s most debated judgment— that Russian President Vladimir Putin ‘aspired’ to help then-candidate Donald Trump win the election.” Ratcliffe did “dispute” that conclusion, repeatedly.

      The CIA chief said that “placing a reference to the [Steele] material” as a “supporting bullet for the judgment that Putin ‘aspired’ to help Trump… elevated unsubstantiated claims to the status of credible supporting evidence.”

      He also noted the CIA and FBI should not have said they had “high” confidence in the notion that Russia aspired to help Trump, given that multiple quality sources are required for “high” confidence, and they didn’t have those. As reported last year, the ICA authors — like the authors of the original WMD report — also suppressed “credibly sourced reporting” that “suggested Putin was more ambivalent about which candidate won the election.”

    2. Nicolle Wallace (at 4:34 above).

      “In fact, a report authored in part by Donald Trump's current secretary of state and current national security advisor, then-Acting Chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee, Marco Rubio, actually did look into the process of how the intelligence community came to this conclusion that Russia interfered in the 2016 election. And that report… says this: “Every witness interviewed by the committee stated that he or she saw no attempt, no attempt to pressure or politicize the findings.”

      Wallace is describing a five-part Senate Intelligence Committee Report on the 2016 election. She’s right that it’s odd Marco Rubio took part in a report concluding Russia engaged in an “extensive” campaign to meddle for Trump. What Wallace didn’t mention is that the Senate relied on different evidence than the CIA/FBI’s 2017 Assessment to come to the same conclusion, a transparent indictment of the 2017 report.

      If Brennan and Comey got it right in 2017, why was a second report with all-new evidence necessary? The Senate report was a repair job, designed to replace Comey and Brennan’s car-wreck of a 2017 paper with a Senate product whose chief assertions — particularly around former Paul Manafort aide Konstantin Kilimnik, whose tie to Trump they said posed a “grave” intelligence threat — were not even reviewable, since lines like “Konstantin Kilimnik is a Russian intelligence officer” were not backed by visible evidence.

    3. John Brennan (at 10:27)

      “But you’re supposed to be interviewing the people involved in this to try to get a better understanding of the context for a lot of the actions that were taken.”

      Brennan’s unintentionally hilarious complaint is that John Ratcliffe didn’t bother interviewing him for the 8-page note released last week.

      This is the same Brennan who included an explosive “annex” of classified material from ex-spy Christopher Steele that upended American politics for years without interviewing Steele, his “Primary Sub-Source” Igor Danchenko of the Brookings Institute, or any of the Russian sources who ostensibly provided the pillars of Steele’s reports: tales of Trump “employing a number of prostitutes to perform a ‘golden showers’ (urination) show,” the “well-developed conspiracy” between Trump and Russia, and the notion that “Russian authorities had been cultivating and supporting… Donald Trump, for at least five years.”

      When Justice Department Inspector General Michael Horowitz put out his review of these issues in 2019, he pointed out that nobody interviewed Steele’s “Primary Sub-Source” until January of 2017, i.e. after the Assessment was released. When the FBI finally did talk to Steele’s sources, they disavowed almost every key point of Steele’s: the prostitute romps (“rumor and speculation,” the sub-source said), the “well-developed conspiracy” (there was “nothing bad” in communications between the Kremlin and Trump, per the source), and the notion that Trump and Page had been offered “the brokerage of up to a 19 percent (privatized) stake in Rosneft” in exchange for lifting sanctions (the sub-source “never stated that [Rosneft] had offered a brokerage interest”). Beyond that, no American official during this entire process ever picked up the phone to call key players/suspects like Julian Assange or Konstantin Kilimnik. It’s rich for Brennan complain no one interviewed him.

    4. John Brennan (10:40).

      “That’s why we went to extraordinary lengths to protect the sensitive intelligence that really undergirded the assessment that was extensively footnoted in the assessment. But also, as I said, to protect individuals involved, including Donald Trump. To make sure that none of this intelligence that could have been seen as inflammatory and as something that was, you know, very damning, would get out. And so that’s why we wanted to make sure it was done in a very appropriate and meticulous and diligent manner...”

      In a wounded tone, Brennan notes that he and James Comey went to extraordinary lengths to “protect the sensitive intelligence that really undergirded the assessessment” and “also… to protect individuals involved, including Donald Trump.”

      The timeline on this: Brennan, Comey, Director of National Intelligence James Clapper, and NSA chief Michael Rogers decided to present a 2-page summary of the classified Steele material to Trump on January 6th, 2017. It was decided Comey would tell Trump the bad news that “Russians allegedly had tapes of him and prostitutes” at the Ritz-Carlton in 2013.

      “I said media like CNN had them and were looking for a news hook,” Comey explained. “I said it was important not to give them an excuse to say the FBI has the material or [redacted] and that we were keeping it very close-hold.”

      Four of the nation’s most senior intelligence chiefs gave a briefing of classified information to the President-Elect of the United States on January 6th, 2017. One might expect that experienced intelligence officials handling classified information might be able to keep a lid on for at least a week.

      No luck. The whole story was on every front page and every TV station within four days. Here’s the CNN headline from January 10:

      The lede of the CNN piece contained details only someone with advanced knowledge of the meeting would know. “Classified documents presented last week,” the four CNN writers said, included “allegations that Russian operatives claim to have compromising personal and financial information about Mr. Trump” and that “there was a continuing exchange of information during the campaign between Trump surrogates and intermediaries for the Russian government.” Material was presented in “a two-page synopsis that was appended to a report on Russian interference in the 2016 election,” and “came, in part, from memos compiled by a former British intelligence operative.”

      That’s what Brennan means by going to “extraordinary lengths” to protect information. The CNN story in one swoop outed classified intelligence, blew its source (all of Washington knew which “former British intelligence operative” CNN meant, which is why Buzzfeed could publish Steele’s dossier within hours) and betrayed the target, Trump. That’s a rare trifecta of incompetence. A coked-up Tourette’s patient would have done a better job guarding information. Are there really people left who believe these people?

    0 min
  • Note On the Brennan and Comey Investigations

    One additional note on the news that the FBI has opened criminal investigations into former FBI Director James Comey and former CIA chief John Brennan. Many are speculating on social media that FBI Director Kash Patel dropped a hint when he appeared on the Joe Rogan Experience a month ago, on June 6th:

    PATEL: Think about this: me, as the director of the FBI, the former Russiagate guy, when I first got to the Bureau, found a room that Comey and others hid from the world in the Hoover building, full of documents and computer hard drives that no one had ever seen or heard of. Locked the key and hid access and just said, “No one’s ever going to find this place.”

    ROGAN: Wha-a-a-t?

    PATEL: Yeah. So my guys are going through that right now.

    ROGAN: What’s in there?

    PATEL: A lot of stuff!

    Patel was indeed referring to this investigation, according to my sources, which tells us a few things. For one, the idea that the Brennan and Comey probes were opened as a PR gambit after the Jeffrey Epstein mud-bath is a non-starter. It’s not excluded that the timing of the Fox story breaking the news is germane to Epstein, but the FBI and the CIA have both been working on Russiagate for months.

    The story about a room of documents and hard drives at the old FBI headquarters in the J. Edgar Hoover building is noteworthy. When Patel became Director, a problem he had was that materials from the investigation he oversaw under Devin Nunes were located at CIA headquarters. As noted before, reporters gleaned bits of the Langley material over the years, but what might have been found by karmic accident when the FBI decided to move out of the Hoover building is unknown. Could be something, could be nothing, but interesting either way. Incidentally, I’m told Brennan and Comey may not be the FBI’s only investigative targets. As depressing as the Epstein story is, there seems to be real momentum behind this matter. Only, how much?

    0 min
  • At Last: John Brennan and James Comey Under Criminal Investigation for Russiagate
    Above, former FBI Director James Comey testifies to the Senate Intelligence Committee in June, 2017. Below, former CIA chief John Brennan testifies to the same committee in January, 2017. Both figures are now being investigated for perjury

    What a roller-coaster the last week has been.

    On the heels of the devastating, embarrassing announcement by Donald Trump’s Justice Department that there would be no new document releases in the Jeffrey Epstein case, there is real — if confusing — progress in an equally explosive investigation. In a story first broken by Fox News, reported further by Margot Cleveland at The Federalist, Miranda Devine at the New York Post, and Paul Sperry at RealClear Investigations, and bolstered now by our own sources at Racket, it’s confirmed: FBI Director Kash Patel has opened criminal investigations into former CIA chief John Brennan and former FBI Director James Comey, for offenses related to the Trump-Russia scandal colloquially known as “Russiagate.”

    The opening of criminal probes into two of the most powerful enforcement chiefs of the Trump era marks the first steps toward consequences for the elaborate and historically unprecedented intelligence fraud that for years consumed American politics. The Bureau will look at possible perjury and conspiracy offenses for both, focusing initially on how Brennan’s CIA and Comey’s FBI worked to produce the infamous “Intelligence Community Assessment” of January 6th, 2017.

    The public portion of that report included a summary that said that the agencies assessed that “[Vladimir] Putin and the Russian Government aspired to help President-elect Trump’s election chances when possible by discrediting Secretary Clinton.” This narrative — that Russia not only “influenced” the 2016 election but “aspired” to help Donald Trump at Hillary Clinton’s expense — quickly became conventional wisdom in media, then snowballed into a political scandal and a Special Counsel investigation that for some time seemed destined to topple the first Trump presidency:

    The crucial “key judgments” section of the 2017 Intelligence Community Assessment

    As ambitious as that caper was, the scope of the new Brennan-Comey probes appears limited to process issues raised in an 8-page report on Russiagate’s origins released by CIA director John Ratcliffe. This has been a source of concern to some who were hoping for a heavier wallop. House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence (HPSCI) chair Rick Crawford, for instance, sent Trump an angry letter last week expressing disappointment that Ratcliffe’s CIA was “permitted to whitewash” the Intelligence Community’s role in manufacturing Russiagate.

    Crawford’s letter reflected intramural GOP strife about the investigations into Brennan and Comey. While the predicate for the new FBI probes technically is a criminal referral from Ratcliffe and the CIA, most of the actual digging into the origins of what Crawford calls the “Russia collusion hoax” was performed across an exhaustive, 3,000-hour investigation conducted by teams working under former HPSCI chief Devin Nunes in the 115th congress, in 2017 and 2018. Racket and Public reported on the details of that investigation last February. Those HPSCI investigators were led by current FBI chief Kash Patel and split into two teams, one of which worked out of a “small office in Langley.” That team working at CIA headquarters had wide access to raw intelligence surrounding the Trump-Russia investigation, including dissenting analyses and emails from officials questioning the 2017 ICA.

    Unsurprisingly, that final HPSCI report was “significantly worse” and described far more corruption than Ratcliffe’s 8-page brief, as The Federalist’s Cleveland put it. We described some of what was “worse” in Racket and Public last February:

    Brennan and the ICA authors “embellished” their conclusion by upgrading unreliable sources to reliable. Investigators found “3-4 instances” in which they couldn’t find a “credible historic reporting line” for sources in the ICA report, and found the “source rating” had been changed. Dissent, even within Brennan’s group of 24 “hand-picked” analysts — not from 17 agencies but just three — was overruled… The HPSCI investigators “looked at the report and the sourcing they used to evaluate the sourcing… When we dug further to look at the data available to them that they didn’t use, and it overwhelmingly contradicted their conclusions that Russia supported Trump.”

    The HPSCI report has remained classified and “in a vault at the CIA” for seven long years. This followed the same pattern as the WMD episode, where the CIA did not release its full 93-page National Intelligence Estimate* on Iraq until 2015, thirteen years after a redacted version was released to the public to sell the invasion. The full document, hidden from the American public before the war, determined there was no operational tie between Saddam Hussein and al Qaeda.

    HPSCI investigators who hoped the new Trump administration would aggressively pursue the leads Kash Patel’s team dug up in 2017 and 2018 were both puzzled by the release of Ratcliffe’s relatively tamer report last week, and upset that their more hard-hitting work remained locked up. After Crawford sent his letter, however, Trump interceded and Ratcliffe returned the original HPSCI report to Crawford on the Hill. The HPSCI material remains classified, but at least it’s no longer being “held hostage” at Langley, as Crawford put it, in a public note of thanks tweeted last Thursday.

    The news that the FBI is now opening criminal investigations into Brennan and Comey seems to have mollified some of those close to the original HPSCI investigation. “I don’t know how the fuck they got here, but I’m happy they did,” laughed one source familiar with the full HPSCI report.

    The same source was not disappointed that the FBI is “only” looking at charges like perjury or conspiracy. “You have to understand, there’s no statute that really fits what these people did,” the source said. “But there is one against lying to Congress, and given that that’s what they have to work with, the Ratcliffe report makes more sense to me now.”

    Although some had concerns about statutes of limitations (for perjury, six years) and others worried about the prospects of obtaining convictions against prominent, blue-leaning politicians in the District of Columbia, sources I spoke with believe the evidence for perjury is compelling in the cases of both Brennan and Comey. To wit:

    Subscribe now

    Read more

    0 min

About Racket News

From the publisher's feed

Regular news and features by award-winning author and investigative reporter, Matt Taibbi.