
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


Partisan wrangling over Russiagate continued over the weekend, with Democrats continuing harsh critiques of Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard and her release of documents about Russian interference from Barack Obama’s last presidential days. Connecticut congressman Jim Himes went on Face the Nation to say “when you start throwing around language like sedition and treason, somebody is going to get hurt,” adding, “The mouth-breathers on MAGA online are just going out of their minds based on a lie.”
Donald Trump responded last night with a Truth Social post that cast Russiagate as a V for Vendetta trailer, promising an upcoming political blockbuster. This president is a lot of things, but boring isn’t one of them.
In between all this, an important detail is being lost. Democrats are hammering an “apples and oranges” argument, saying documents showing intelligence officials planned a Presidential Daily Briefing on December 9th, 2016 that would say “Foreign adversaries did not use cyberattacks on election infrastructure to alter the US Presidential election outcome” and “We have no evidence of cyber manipulation of election infrastructure intended to alter results” were meaningless.
As Himes put it, the fact that “Russians could not use cyber tools to mess with the voting infrastructure, the machines that tally our votes” was “true then, and it is true now.” Two things about this statement, disingenuous in multiple ways:
Subscribe now
Public media can be a great thing, but the current iteration treats America like a foreign country
Narrated by Jared Moore
Art by Daniel Medina
Text published 07/16/25:
Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the free versions of Racket To Go on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts
Listen to the Full Episode
Book Club ScheduleThis Episode: Evelyn Waugh’s Scoop (Day 4/5*)
Monday Night: Evelyn Waugh’s Scoop (Day 5/5*)
Barack Obama entered national politics with a smile that looked like Hope and Change. Amid rumors of family discord and disarray within the political party he once led, his face has hardened. He lately looks bitter, resentful, exhausted by the act.
In the wake of reports released by fellow Hawaiian and former Democrat Tulsi Gabbard, he also has a new problem. It once seemed a lock that Obama would be remembered as the winsome hero of Shepard Fairey’s portrait, but Gabbard’s documents place him at the center of an unprecedented act of political sabotage, committed in his last Oval Office days as a humiliated lame-duck in the winter of 2016-2017. The new Director of National Intelligence is targeting Obama’s legacy and maybe even his freedom, detailing a “treasonous conspiracy committed by officials at the highest level of our government,” announcing that everyone involved “must be investigated and prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law.”
Ten days ago, news broke that Donald Trump’s Justice Department opened criminal investigations into two of Obama’s top deputies, former FBI chief James Comey and former CIA head John Brennan. Last Sunday, Gabbard’s ODNI hosted an “urgent” meeting to discuss “new information on Russiagate” with members of the Justice Department and the President’s Intelligence Advisory Board.
All week, Washington buzzed with rumors about imminent document releases, but what came out wasn’t what many expected. Gabbard’s documents show the Obama White House overruling months of reports downplaying Russian interference and ordering subordinates to set a time bomb of manipulated intelligence, with the aim of trying to, as Gabbard described it, “usurp” an incoming president. No longer a tertiary character, Obama is now “center square” in the Russiagate scam, as one source put it.
Mainstream press outlets like the New York Times and Politico have already run pieces quoting Democratic Party mouthpieces shrugging off Gabbard’s reports as “baseless” and an attempt to “change the subject,” but coverage may not matter, as the investigation into the Trump-Russia hoax is no longer about trying to change hearts and minds. Multiple sources say Gabbard’s team is focused on “accountability” by gathering evidence for court-ready cases. The matter may soon need a special prosecutor, putting Obama in the same position Trump occupied in the first two years of his presidency, on the run from a high-profile fox hunt.
The information from Gabbard’s office was not the only news on the Russiagate front. This investigation is not just about “ten-year-old news,” as has been a common talking point, but may also involve never-reported Biden-era issues. A source close to the investigation said yesterday that the DOJ is focusing on conspiracy charges and looking at conduct “from 2016 to 2024.” Another with ties to the administration said “President Trump’s national security team is looking at evidence that members of his 2024 campaign were spied on as well.”
All of that is yet to be determined. Until then, here’s a detailed review of what yesterday’s releases say, and why they signal a shift toward former president Obama:
Subscribe now
Gabbard’s office put out two files. One is a 114-page document titled, “Declassified evidence of Obama administration’s conspiracy to subvert Trump’s 2016 victory and presidency.” The other is an 11-page press release that highlights the same documents, in a timeline with commentary. Gabbard compressed the releases further in an email chain replete with flow charts:
The documents focus on emails to and from the office of then-Director of National Intelligence James Clapper, whose name was conspicuously absent when news about criminal investigations into other Obama-era intelligence chiefs broke. Clapper throughout the Trump-Russia affair has been more publicly reserved than Comey or especially Brennan, who in 2019 excitedly suggested Special Counsel Robert Mueller might deliver indictments on the “Ides of March.” In contrast, Clapper told Chuck Todd on Meet The Press at the outset of Russiagate mania that “we had no evidence of collusion” when he left office in January 2017:
Clapper even before Trump’s election argued against making broad claims about Russian interference, let alone interference on behalf of Donald Trump specifically. The first email in the release is from Clapper, and describes a meeting chaired by former Obama National Security Council chief Denis McDonough:
Yes; at the WH session today chaired by Denis, I brought up that I had asked my team to produce an NIE on cyber threats to our electoral infrastructure… this generated quite a bit of discussion.
That Clapper called for an NIE or National Intelligence Assessment on cyber threats — a large, formal report comprising input from the entire intelligence community — is significant because other chiefs like Brennan urged a smaller ICA or Intelligence Community Assessment, a more informal document involving as few as three or four agencies. There is little chance unsubstantiated information from ex-spy Christopher Steele could have made it into an NIE. An ICA was a different matter.
The next documents in the chain show that not only Clapper’s office but others, including the FBI, were relatively unconcerned about Russian interference. Figures like Virginia Senator and key Russiagate figure Mark Warner are already dismissing Gabbard’s report as an attempt to “cook the books” by comparing “apples and oranges,” the apples being Russian efforts to attack “election infrastructure,” the oranges being “influence” operations. But emails dating back to September 2016 show a dismissive attitude toward both concepts, as well as a lack of conviction about Russia’s ability to impact or “disrupt” the election outcome in any way.
On September 5th, for instance, an FBI official asked for a change in the draft of a potential ICA on cyber threats, writing:
The way it currently reads, it would indicate that we have definitive information that Russia does intend to disrupt our elections and we are uncomfortable making that assessment at this point.
An official from an unnamed agency added:
I sort of understood the emphasis to be on Russia probably not having the capability to influence the election.
A DHS official wrote, “Russia probably is not (and will not) trying to influence the election by using cyber means to manipulate computer-enabled election infrastructure,” which might fall under Warner’s “apples” heading. That same official however added:
We assess that foreign adversaries, notably Russia, are more likely to focus their cyber operations on undermining credibility/public confidence… That assessment feeds directly into the influence operations, some cyber-enabled, that we’ve seen related to current and historic election cycles.
An official from Clapper’s ODNI hit the same note, suggesting that any influence operations would fit a normal historical pattern of “less sophisticated” propaganda:
Russia probably is not trying to going to be able to? influence the election by using cyber means to manipulate computer-enabled election infrastructure. Russia probably is using cyber means primarily to influence the election by stealing campaign party data and leaking select items, and it is also using public propaganda. This fits an historical pattern of Russia using less sophisticated propaganda and information operations to influence US elections.
By December 7th, 2016, Clapper’s office prepared text for a Presidential Daily Briefing headed ACTIVITY ON AND SINCE ELECTION DAY and reading:
By the next day, December 8th, officials had text prepared that read, “Russian and criminal actors did not impact recent US election results by conducting malicious cyber activities against election infrastructure.”
This wording was scheduled to be entered into the PDB — not a public report, but a confidential briefing to President Obama — the next day, December 9th. However, Comey’s FBI on the afternoon of the 8th unexpectedly withdrew from the PDB.
“FBI will be drafting a dissent this afternoon,” a Bureau official wrote at 3:48 p.m. “Please remove our seal and annotations of co-authorship.” About an hour later, at 4:53 p.m., an official from Clapper’s office axed the PDB for the time being. “Based on some new guidance, we are going to push back publication of the PDB,” the official wrote. “It will not run tomorrow and is not likely to run until next week.”
At that point, a meeting of Obama’s National Security Principals Committee was held. The list of attendees reads like an all-star collection of MSNBC green room visitors: John Kerry, Victoria Nuland, John Brennan, Avril Haines, Ben Rhodes, and Andrew McCabe, among others. One source told me to note the name Richard Ledgett from the National Security Agency, who “played a role in this”:
This is the group that the next day received a group email from Clapper’s office headed “POTUS Tasking on Russia Election Meddling,” asking them to “produce an assessment per the President’s request,” with a target release date of January 9th, 2017:
The IC is prepared to produce an assessment per the President’s request, that pulls together the information we have on the tools Moscow used and the actions it took to influence the 2016 election, an explanation of why Moscow directed these activities, and how Moscow’s approach has changed over time, going back to 2008 and 2012 as reference points.
In sum, just before Obama was to receive a briefing that contained no reference to significant Russian interference, the briefing was called off and a high-level meeting of White House security officials was convened, after which Obama himself tasked them with a new assessment that would lean toward a more aggressive conclusion. Although this new effort was to be directed by Clapper’s office, the critical job of divining Russia’s motives would be given to the CIA and Brennan:
ii. Why did Moscow direct these activities? What have the Russians hoped to accomplish? (CIA lead)
It’s suspicious that a Presidential Daily Briefing was postponed to make way for ICA ordered at Obama’s request, fishier yet that the evidence that Putin intended to help Trump came from a classified annex containing Steele dossier material, but the smoking gun is that these eventual conclusions leaked instantly — not one or two weeks after Obama ordered the ICA, but the same day, before any group work could possibly have been done.
On December 9th, 2016, the New York Times ran “Russian Hackers Acted to Aid Trump in Election, U.S. Says.” This piece not only led with the full-blown Steele Dossier saw about Putin having acted to help Trump at Hillary Clinton’s expense, it followed with aggressive conclusions about Russian hacks of both Democratic and Republican party infrastructure. Also that day, the Washington Post ran a piece describing a “secret assessment” that Russia had worked to help Trump, even though the group assessment had only just been assigned:
Instant conclusion? Left, the New York Times on December 9th, 2016. Center, the Washington Post that same day. Right, memo assigning a new Russia assessment on… December 9th, 2016Washington Post reporter Greg Miller went on air with PBS to flog the paper’s “secret assessment” story and spoke of Russians having “weaponized” material:
It;s hard to square all of these instantaneous leaks with Obama’s alleged insistence that the ICA investigation be conducted “by the book,” as Obama’s National Security Adviser Susan Rice eventually documented in a letter to herself. Former CBS reporter Catherine Herridge, who reported on the letter, noted that Rice’s letter to herself takes on “new significance” in light of Gabbard’s documents.
On December 10, 2016, the Post ran another piece quoting senior intelligence officials claiming to be worried about their futures, noting the coming report could potentially pit “the entire U.S. intelligence community against a newly sworn-in president who has repeatedly denigrated their work.” Added another: “After Jan. 20… we’re in uncharted territory.” Remember at this point there’d been no evidence whatsoever linking Trump to Russia or even suggesting Russia sought to help Trump, apart from the bogus Steele material.
After that, leaks followed in rapid succession, on almost a daily basis. On Dec. 11, 2016, the Times ran “C.I.A. Judgment on Russia Built on Swell of Evidence,” claiming the “stunning new judgment” they’d just reported came from the CIA, but “does not appear to be the product of specific new intelligence obtained since the election.” Instead, “it was an analysis of what many believe is overwhelming circumstantial evidence — evidence that others feel does not support firm judgments — that the Russians put a thumb on the scale for Mr. Trump, and got their desired outcome.” The “stunning judgement” wasn’t based on new information, but a change in the political weather at the top of the administration allowing more aggressive “analysis.”
From there, officials built the Trump-Russia narrative brick by brick. On December 15th, the NSA’s Admiral Michael Rogers, who in private refused to upgrade his agency’s confidence level from “moderate” to “high,” told the Times there “shouldn’t be any doubt… This was a conscious effort by a nation-state to attempt to achieve a specific effect.” News that the FBI agreed ran the next day.
This is the process that led to the release of the much-discussed January 6th, 2017 Intelligence Community Assessment that concluded “[Vladimir] Putin and the Russian Government aspired to help President-elect Trump’s election chances when possible by discrediting Secretary Clinton.” When the report came out, via a pre-conceived format that involved a public document and private classified annexes, news of what was in the classified part leaked quickly.
The first outlet to break the big news was CNN, which reported on January 10th, 2017 that President-elect Trump had been presented “a two-page synopsis that was appended to a report on Russian interference in the 2016 election” that included claims from a “former British intelligence operative” that allegations that Russians “claim to have compromising personal and financial information about Mr. Trump.” The Times quickly followed, noting the “author of the memos is Christopher Steele, a former British intelligence officer with MI-6, who once served in Moscow,” and “Former C.I.A. officials described him as an expert on Russia who is well respected in the spy world.”
Some of this timeline was known, but the sudden ditching of a tepid PDB and ordering of a new report “per the President’s request,” with emails conspicuously invoking “POTUS tasking,” never surfaced before. There is a reason many of the news reports about Gabbard’s releases have Obama’s name in the headline, along with the term “treasonous conspiracy.” The former president’s role in directing the reworked ICA is clearly a focus of Gabbard’s team.
Also new is testimony from a whistleblower in Clapper’s office, who was asked to sign off on the claims about Russian intent without being shown the alleged intelligence supporting the claims. “As for the 2017 ICA’s judgement of a decisive Russian preference for then-candidate Donald Trump,” he told Gabbard’s group, “I could not concur in good conscience based on information available, and my professional analytic judgement.” That whistleblower’s 2019 efforts to obtain documents relevant to the Steele material by Freedom of Information Request are also in the new package.
Not everyone in Trumpworld is thrilled with the new developments. The failure of senior intelligence officials who served in Trump’s last term to find and/or release these documents has a number of high profile figures upset. “So much corruption,” said one disgusted former Trump official. Another expressed skepticism that anything of significance would come of these investigations, and pointed to Special Counsel John Durham’s ill-fated probe: “It’s always something.” Thanks to the investigation kicked off by this ICA and the subsequent probe by Special Counsel Robert Mueller, there are people who went to jail, fell ill, went through family crises, and dealt with other serious problems. As a result, there are a lot of eyes on this investigation, and high expectations. Failure for Gabbard’s team to deliver real consequences would bring heavy criticism from both sides.
Gabbard’s team seems to understand they will be judged on the “accountability” question, and remain determined to continue. More releases are expected, and we’ll keep Racket readers in the loop.
Listen to Episode 142
Matt Taibbi: Welcome to America This Week, I’m Matt Taibbi.
Walter Kirn: And I’m Walter Kirn.
Matt Taibbi: Walter, how’s it going? I see you’re in your secret lockdown location still, in the basement.
Walter Kirn: Yeah, I am.
Matt Taibbi: Limited egress.
Walter Kirn: I didn’t tell anybody why I’m here because I got kicked out of another hotel, and I’ll tell you why. I had a hotel reservation for a week. I go to my room and I relax and use the lavatory only to discover after having used it that it doesn’t flush. The handle just jiggles loose. So being a home plumber, I take the lid off the toilet and I see that there is literally no chain attaching the flushing handle to the flapper. It’s not that it’s broken or it’s fallen off, it doesn’t exist. It’s not lying on the bottom of the tank. It doesn’t exist. So I go downstairs to the young clerk and I say, “Hey, I found out unfortunately too late that my toilet has no chain between the handle and the flapper.” “Okay, we’ve noted your complaint.” “Well, listen, I’ve got the room for a week. Could you come fix it?” “We’ve noted your complaint.”
Matt Taibbi: What?
Walter Kirn: Dude. “Well, why don’t you call a plumber? When are you calling a plumber?” “Have you heard us? We noted your complaint.” Now this is something that happens a lot these days, these poor young people who have been trained to recognize microaggressions, but not to call a plumber, get a little testy with you. I go back up to my room and I get a call. It’s the last room in the hotel, and they say, “We’d like you to leave.” I said, “Could you...” “We have called another hotel and they have room for you.” I said-
Matt Taibbi: What?
Walter Kirn: I said, “You can just call a plumber.” And they said, “We have called another hotel and we would like you to leave.” So I drag my damn suitcase across town and I get a basement room at the nearest place. So the service industry collapse is just happening as we speak, it’s a total implosion. I see it here every day when you’re traveling and you have to eat in restaurants and go to stores for things you’ve forgotten and so on. You are more in contact with, what is it? Gen Z?
Matt Taibbi: Right. I guess or whatever comes after Gen X. Yeah.
Walter Kirn: Besides being mildly high most of them, they have been trained to give you corporate speak as a response. And they give it to you verbatim, probably because they have cameras on them, above the desks.
Matt Taibbi: Mm-hmm.
Walter Kirn: In any hotel chain or anything like that, they do. And it’s become maddening, so...
Matt Taibbi: That is pretty bad. Yeah. I’m sure that drives... it does wonders for your psyche too, having to say the same thing over and over again, but come on, you can’t have a hotel where you can’t go to the bathroom.
Walter Kirn: I said, “It’s not broken. It’s missing the integral part that causes the flushing to happen. Okay.” “We’ve noted your complaint.”
Matt Taibbi: Could I have a bucket so that I could hand flush it? Anyway, that is unfortunate. I’m sorry to hear that, Walter.
Walter Kirn: Well, there was one other problem. There was very loud music playing directly underneath it. And I thought, “Gosh, is there a club downstairs? What’s going on?” And I went down and it was the kitchen. The kitchen needs to play loud music, I was told, in order to function. And I said, “That’s fine, but the kitchen doesn’t need to have a hotel room over it.” Only one can win, however, and I lost to the kitchen.
Matt Taibbi: The customer is always wrong.
Walter Kirn: Right.
Matt Taibbi: That’s unbelievable.
Walter Kirn: That’s literally what happened.
Matt Taibbi: And you’re in the cradle of the hotel management industry too, right? This is some of the most famous schools in the world are in that region.
Walter Kirn: Yes, hospitality, they would call it. Yes.
Matt Taibbi: Hospitality. Yeah.
Walter Kirn: And I live-
Matt Taibbi: Cornell in one direction, Johnson & Wales in the other direction, and right in the middle, there’s-
Walter Kirn: Right near your old school, Bard.
Matt Taibbi: Yep, CIA. Yep. Mm-hmm.
Walter Kirn: But I will tell you this. Though the Hudson Valley is a caring, gentle place, with all the right bumper stickers, the customer service sucks.
Matt Taibbi: Wow. That is not a flattering story about an area of the country that is near and dear to my heart, the Hudson River Valley-
Walter Kirn: And beautiful.
Matt Taibbi: And very beautiful. And normally, the people are, if they’re not wonderful, they’re usually eccentric, which is fine with me. I think eccentric is good, but that doesn’t sound good. So I’m sorry to hear that.
Walter Kirn: No, I’ve found the right places, I’ve found the good people. I’m a little afraid of Lyme disease, however, because I’ve met a few people who’ve contracted it recently.
Matt Taibbi: Well, you’re right in the strike zone for Lyme disease too, unfortunately. I’m sorry, I can’t lie to you on that front.
Walter Kirn: Yeah.
Matt Taibbi: So we have a lot of stuff to go through today. We also have to play an excerpt from your excellent appearance on The Tucker Carlson Show, which we’ll do later. Congratulations on that.
Walter Kirn: Thank you.
Matt Taibbi: But just first, we’re going to talk a little bit today about the maybe passing of PBS and NPR. There was a vote last night, and we’ll get to that in a moment, which looks like it may be the final death knell for federal funding of public media for a little while, anyway. But before we get to that, there was a story that terrified both of us that just came out in The New York Times that we wanted to discuss, at least briefly. It was called Elite Colleges Have Found a New Virtue for Applicants to Fake. And Walter, do you want to summarize what the story says?
Walter Kirn: Well, it almost defies summary because it’s such a novel idea that it doesn’t sink in with me, but here’s the notion. A bunch of elite colleges, truly elite, Columbia, Northwestern, the University of Chicago, Vanderbilt, et cetera, have signed on to some strange plan to use a software program at Schoolhouse.world. I didn’t know that .world was a suffix for internet addresses, but I guess things are evolving. And so students are going to all log on to a Zoom call. For what reasons? It’s unclear. And then with a peer tutor there, they’re going to debate topics like immigration or Israel-Palestine and rate one another, I’m reading now, on traits like empathy, curiosity or kindness. And the Schoolhouse.world site offers a scorecard. The more sessions, sessions-
As has been rumored all week, Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard began releasing documents this afternoon related to intelligence community shenanigans committed in the waning days of Barack Obama’s presidency, before and after the 2016 presidential election. It’s damning stuff that exposes the Trump-Russia hysteria as a complete and utter fake, and should obliterate the reputation of the commercial news media. There is no answer to these documents.
To take one example, intelligence officials on December 8th, 2016 were prepared to release a Presidential Daily Briefing concluding that “Russian and criminal actors did not impact recent US election results by conducting malicious cyber activities against election infrastructure”:
That “did not impact” memo — exactly the opposite of what the Obama White House would claim a month later — never reached the public, thanks to the intervention of a senior official in Director of National Intelligence James Clapper’s office:
On the following day, December 9th, 2016, members of Obama’s National Security Principals Committee — including Clapper, CIA director John Brennan, Susan Rice, John Kerry, Brian McKeon, Loretta Lynch, Andrew McCabe, and Avril Haines — gathered for a meeting, after which each received an email titled, “POTUS Tasking on Russia Election Meddling.” The email tasked the members with the creation of a new “assessment per the President’s request.”
From that moment forward, intelligence officials began leaking “blatantly false” information about a nonexistent “secret assessment” that Russia intervened to influence the “outcome of the election.” This leaking continued unabated until January 6th, when a new, hastily-crafted Intelligence Community Assessment was released, triggering a series of developments that led to the publication of the Steele Dossier and an explosion of media stories linking Trump and Russia in an unprecedented scandal.
The material is bolstered throughout by explanations of a whistleblower from then-Director of National Intelligence James Clapper’s office. Just this handful of documents holds explosive implications, implicating a much bigger pool of White House officials than previously understood, including Obama himself, in what appears to be a top-down effort to create a false narrative about Russia meddling to help Donald Trump. If there’s an analog in American history, I can’t think of it.
This is a major action taken by Tulsi Gabbard, whose office was earlier reported by Paul Sperry of RealClear Investigations to have hosted an “urgent” meeting in a secure facility last Sunday. They met to discuss “new Russiagate information” with Trump’s Presidential Intelligence Advisory Board as well as officials from the Department of Justice. With this material, she and the rest of this team are taking on a long list of powerful predecessors, and it’s expected she’ll be made the focus of an all-out negative publicity campaign. “Will be a wild ride,” is how one source put it tonight.
More material is coming. I was working on a different part of this story, about plans for possible charges, when these documents came out this afternoon, so I’ve had to start over. More will be out beginning in the morning. It’s a fascinating moment, and we’ll make sure Racket readers are kept in the loop as new material comes out. Have a good night, everyone.
It was reported this past Monday that Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs and Wells Fargo will pay a combined $120 million to settle a lawsuit that claimed they hid conflicts of interest while they sold millions of shares of ViacomCBS due to their involvement in Bill Hwang's $36 billion Archegos Capital Management fiasco in 2021.
This settlement marks a rather boring end to one of the greatest and darkly comical incidents to take place on Wall Street, one that inflicted more than $10 billion total in losses for the banks Credit Suisse, Nomura, UBS and Mitsubishi UFG. Morgan Stanley, Wells Fargo, Goldman Sachs, and Deutsche Bank were also caught up in the scandal.
Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To support our work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
The Archegos saga exploded on Friday, March 26, 2021. The stock prices of nine major U.S. and Chinese stocks plummeted on tremendous volume. For example, one stock, Viacom, dropped over 27% on an insane volume of more than 216 million shares, more than 10 times the stock’s average daily volume! In one day, $35 billion of market value in these nine stocks evaporated. Michel Keusch, portfolio manager at Bellevue Asset Management AG in Switzerland, told Bloomberg News he had “never seen something of this magnitude in my 25-year career.”
The next day, as many were scratching their heads trying to figure out what the hell happened, Bloomberg News reported:
Goldman Sachs sold $6.6 billion worth of shares of Baidu Inc., Tencent Music Entertainment Group and Vipshop Holdings Ltd. before the market opened in the U.S., according to an email to clients seen by Bloomberg News. That move was followed by the sale of $3.9 billion of shares in Viacom CBS Inc., Discovery Inc., Farfetch Ltd., iQiyi Inc. and GSX Techedu Inc.
Morgan Stanley, Credit Suisse and Nomura Securities were also identified as large block sellers as the weekend wore on. Nomura stated that it may incur up to $2 billion in losses due to one client. Credit Suisse also reported that they expected significant losses due to the same client.
By Sunday, the client was identified as Bill Hwang and his family office, an industry term for super wealthy families that only manage their own money. Archegos Capital Management. How the hell could one guy do all that to eight of the biggest securities firms on the planet, at the same time?
With his family office exploding, Hwang managed to complete a career hat trick of:
Destroying investor wealth (Including his own)
Getting busted for insider trading
Blowing massive holes in Wall Street banks’ balance sheets, including Credit Suisse for whom this fiasco was perhaps the last nail in its coffin. The storied Swiss bank hobbled its way toward oblivion two years later.
The Wall Street Journal had a pretty funny description of Hwang
“Behind the enormous losses was Mr. Hwang, a 57-year-old Korean-born investor, devout Christian and protégé of famous hedge fund veteran Julian Robertson. Mr. Hwang built his fortune swinging for the fences, often focusing his investments in just a few stocks, paying little attention to hedging his positions while borrowing large amounts of money to boost his returns.”
That doesn’t exactly sound like the guy you want to literally bet the bank on!
In 2008, when Hwang was managing other people’s money at his hedge fund, he was supposed to be trading Asian equities, his expertise. Instead, his investors were quite upset to find that Hwang had gotten them into what was the “GameStop” short squeeze of the 2000s —,Volkswagen — which ended in disaster. VW skyrocketed over 350% in value in two days as Porsche announced it was amassing a 75% stake in the company, crushing short sellers.
Then in 2012, Hwang and his hedge fund, Tiger Asia Management, reached a $44 million settlement with the SEC on claims of insider trading. After this, Hwang started Archegos to manage his own fortune.
Archego Goes All InArchegos, according to the SEC complaint, had exposure to more than 50% of VicacomCBS, 60% of Discovery Class A stock, and even 70% of a Chinese online education company. But these and other companies had no idea because his exposure to the stocks were through derivative transactions known as Total Return Swaps (TRS).
TRS have been around for a long time. The transaction essentially replicates for the client (usually hedge funds) the profile of being long or short a specific asset or basket of assets. The derivative dealer — usually Wall Street banks — puts the asset in question on their balance sheet and structure the transaction as follows.
1. The dealer acquires the asset, in this case a stock like Viacom, and puts it on its balance sheet.
2. The hedge fund, in this case Archegos, posts liquid collateral as initial margin with the dealer.
3. The dealer pays Archegos if the price of Viacom increases.
4. Archegos pays the dealer if the price of Viacom goes down.
5. Archegos pays the dealer a funding charge since the Viacom stock resides on the dealer’s balance sheet used to hedge the dealer on the TRS
6. Based on the value of Viacom, Archegos may have to post additional margin if Viacom’s value drops.
Say there’s a TRS on 20 million shares of Viacom, and Archegos posted the value of 10 million shares as margin. It would still have exposure to $20 million. It would be the same as if Archegos purchased 10 million shares of Viacom and borrowed from the dealer to purchase the remaining 10 million shares. That is the leverage TRS provide.
Why did Archegos use derivatives?Archegos used TRS for leverage and, perhaps more importantly, to stay under the radar. The TRS allowed Archegos to have huge stakes in companies without filing required filings with the SEC. Instead, the banks he was doing the swaps with show up as the owners of the stock. For instance, for the first quarter of 2021, Credit Suisse and Nomura were the fifth and sixth largest holders of Viacom stock. Nearly all of that was on these banks’ balance sheets. If you combined the Viacom holdings of Credit Suisse, Nomura, Morgan Stanley, UBS and Goldman Sachs during the first quarter of 2021, they would be the largest common stock holder of a multi-billion dollar corporation.
Perhaps something could have been done to stop the insanity if the companies and investors had known that a guy with a history of rule-breaking and careless risk-taking used massive leverage to buy more than half a company’s stock
It appears that Archegos and the dealers began amassing his stake in the companies in early 2021. Meanwhile, Viacom’s share price nearly doubled from February 1 to March 22. Viacom was so pleased that it announced plans to issue $3 billion in new stock. Viacom shares dropped sharply on the news and then plummeted as the Archegos’ highly leveraged positions generated margin calls that he could not meet and hence, the unprecedented selling of what were now the dealer’s positions on Friday, March 26th. Essentially, it only took one big loser to wipe out the entire book of TRS, which is exactly what happened.
Now comes the dark comedy of this tale. The dealers who fueled Archegos’ insane risk taking seemingly did not know that they were all in the same trades together with Archegos! According to the SEC complaint, Archegos routinely lied to the various bank counterparties as to what their Net Asset Value’s (“NAV”) real exposure was to one of the nine stocks they had massive exposure to. The complaint cites a question that an employee of CP4 — another bank that Archego had a TRS with — raised with Archegos’ trader about shares in a company called GSX.. The trader, Tomita, would only say that Archego was not a “disclosed holder” of GSX.
The CP4 employee expressed concern that if Archegos held similarly-sized positions in GSX across its Counterparties as it did with CP4, then Archegos might cumulatively be the beneficial owner of almost 20% of GSX’s outstanding shares.
In response, Tomita misled the individual into believing that it must have been other entities’ SBS positions that caused those reported positions, not Archegos, when in fact (as Tomita knew) it was Archegos, which at the time had exposure to about 59% of GSX’s outstanding shares through SBSs.
Archegos lied and the Wall Street banks, despite their correct concern that there was a problem, believed them. They then provided Archegos even more exposure, which the complaint explains happened time and time again nearly to the end.
The week leading up to the March 26, 2021, blowup, the SEC apparently got wind that that something funky was going on and called on the dealers involved. This is when Goldman, Morgan Stanley, Credit Suisse, Nomura, UBS, Deutsche Bank and the rest realized, seemingly for the first time, that Archegos had done the same trades with all of them!
Boom!
The banks got together on a call before the fateful Friday in an attempt to manage the dumpster fire. Credit Suisse and Nomura suggested that the banks work together to slowly and quietly unwind the mess. It seems that while nodding their heads, Goldman, Morgan Stanley and Deutsche Bank ran to the exits and pulled the rip cord, selling millions of shares of the nine companies. Credit Suisse, Nomura and UBS were left holding the bag and took the majority of the losses associated with the Archegos unwind.
Interestingly, Credit Suisse commissioned a report for its board of directors to try and explain how it managed to lose $5.5 billion.
The Archegos default exposed several significant deficiencies in CS’s risk culture, revealing a Prime Services business with a lackadaisical attitude towards risk and risk discipline; a lack of accountability for risk failures; risk systems that identified acute risks, which were systematically ignored by business and risk personnel; and a cultural unwillingness to engage in challenging discussions or to escalate matters posing grave economic and reputational risk. The Archegos matter directly calls into question the competence of the business and risk personnel who had all the information necessary to appreciate the magnitude and urgency of the Archegos risks, but failed at multiple junctures to take decisive and urgent action to address them.
In 2024, Credit Suisse had to do the Geneva Walk of Shame and let themselves be absorbed by their hated rival UBS, while Bill Hwang was sentenced to 18 years in prison. Archegos Chief Financial Officer Patrick Halligan was sentenced to eight years.
The Archegos saga yet again confirms that when it comes to making lots of money, people in positions of authority do incredibly stupid and greedy things. Once again, the “smartest guys in the room” really weren’t that smart at all.
Racket News is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Link Here: Listen to subscriber-only audio in your podcast app
Share the Free Previews of America This Week:
Watch ATW on YouTube below:
Greg Collard and I were joking before the last America This Week that the show needed an onscreen “Big Bird Counter,” to highlight the inevitably enormous number of Sesame Street references in media this week, while the fate of NPR and PBS is debated.
From the New York Times op-ed page today:
For most of its history, PBS and the Corporation for Public Broadcasting have been a combined net plus for American citizens. They produced pioneering programs ranging from NOVA to This Old House to Frontline, and introduced Americans to cool foreign programs like Doctor Who, Monty Python’s Flying Circus, and I, Claudius. The quintessential PBS show was informative and quirky without pulling ideological threads, even if its Masterpiece roster sometimes over-scratched the upscale viewer’s costume-drama itch. From nature shows to comedy to documentaries, PBS was a sound counterweight to the boobs-and-car-chase lineups on commercial TV, providing the most remote communities with quality programming.
It should have run forever. National Public Radio ruined the enterprise, turning the country’s signature public news shows into an endless partisan therapy session, a Nine Perfect Strangers retreat for high-income audiences micro-dosing on Marx and Kendi. Forget conservatives, NPR’s trademark half-whispered stylings linking diets to rape culture or denouncing white teeth as a hangover of colonialism began in recent years to feel like physical punishment to the most apolitical listeners, like having a blind librarian hacksaw your forehead. Even today’s New York Times piece couldn’t argue the bias issue, instead offering a mathematical deflection:
Subscribe now
Republicans complain, not always wrongly, that public media reflects left-leaning assumptions and biases. And they can fairly tell NPR and PBS to do a better job of reflecting the citizenry that is subsidizing them. Yet the “national” part of NPR (or National Public Radio, as it used to call itself) that chafes conservatives may well be just fine without federal funds. Only about 2 percent of its budget comes directly from the federal government, and it may have an easier time raising money from its many dedicated listeners if Congress punishes it.
Is this an argument for or against public funding of NPR? If listeners can make up the shortfall, why don’t we just do that and be done with the controversy? One reason is that the Times is doing what most outlets do in covering this story, skipping the inconvenient detail that NPR derives a significant chunk of its revenue from member stations using public funds to purchase its programs. That’s still a federal subsidy, only less direct, and not as easily made up by “dedicated listeners.”
More interesting is that while NPR and its supporters mostly recognize the station has a bias issue, they’ve abandoned the idea that this needs fixing. Earlier this year, CEO Katherine Maher tiptoed in the direction of concessions, saying she regretted calling Trump the rare fascist-racist-sociopath trifecta (“a fascist and deranged racist sociopath”) and addressing whistleblower Uri Berliner’s concerns by noting NPR could have covered the Hunter Biden laptop story “more aggressively or sooner.” However, when NPR sued to counter a Trump executive order canceling funding, Maher took a different tone. In a defiant statement, she pointed out that Trump’s Order, “Ending Taxpayer Subsidization of Biased Media,” likely violated the First Amendment on viewpoint discrimination grounds by promising to “cease indirect funding.” In other words, even if NPR is biased, the White House can’t tell member stations not to buy it.
Which is true! However, Maher missed that in making a winning legal argument, she conceded the core political complaint of bias, likely sealing its fate in Congress. There’s something indescribably odd in the station’s new orientation. Donald Trump’s issue with NPR, which he calls “worse than CNN & MSNDC put together,” is obvious and tied to the station’s humorously relentless anti-Trump editorial line (“ICE Goes After Renters, a Big Beautiful Jolt To Your Electric Bill” is typical fare). Many journalists however would say the point of the CPB setup was to create public media that would be legally empowered to criticize a sitting administration. I agree. If NPR editors really believe in their reporting, they should be free to run it without fear of losing funding. Unfortunately, that’s not really what’s at issue.
The new iteration of NPR doesn’t see a problem with taking funds from a huge plurality or even a majority of citizens and pursuing a nakedly politicized, ear-splitting propaganda project in opposition to the views of those people. NPR is the vegetables we refuse to eat, administered up a different entrance for our own good. Maher cast the mission as informational hygiene: “NPR’s programming and services are core to the overall health of American public radio.” NPR has been transformed into domestic Voice of America, a bullhorn of Rightthink beamed into the homes of all those Christians, MAGAts, political agnostics, and other captives of unenlightened America who’ve been deceived into supporting the national project. NPR’s programming sounds exactly like the Radio Free Europe broadcasts I used to hear streaming into Leningrad, only the target is American rather than Soviet patriotism. The station’s take on the “nation” it covers is almost like the Zucker Brothers spoof where an East German mentions having an uncle who lived in the U.S., but “he managed to escape in a balloon during the Jimmy Carter presidency.” That’s NPR’s view of America all the time.
Just this past weekend, on Bastille Day, NPR re-ran the hilariously titled segment, “The price you pay for being smart,” which featured a Yale professor explaining why the humanities are so important. “The humanities allow you to talk about anything. And that’s a threat… Particularly, you can challenge the nation’s greatness.” Challenging my nation’s greatness isn’t the first thing that comes to mind when I hear the word humanities, but it apparently is for NPR. The agony of the station’s producers is never more obvious than on the Fourth of July, which is basically covered in two ways.
Lane one: the pre-American roots of barbecue! “Barbecue as we know it has the same origins — stretching back to before Europeans set foot in the U.S.,” offered one of this year’s entries, adding: “An early encounter between Spanish conquerors and Indigenous Caribbeans that brought us the actual word barbecue…” Lane two: “Frederick Douglass' descendants read ‘What to the Slave Is the Fourth of July?’” Definitely thought-provoking the first time you hear it, but the story is run every year, often in tandem with “I’ve never heard a black family hail July 4th as Independence Day”-type features, which again would be interesting if other themes were explored even occasionally.
A search for the word “patriotism” on the site is always amusing, turning up stories like “Black Patriotism: When Love Of Country Means Holding It Accountable,” or “As America Turns A Year Older, Poll Finds Patriotism Has Slipped A Bit,” or my personal favorite, “Greatness Is Not A Given: ‘America The Beautiful’ Asks How We Can Do Better.” The latter was a think piece about Katherine Lee Bates, author of the “America the Beautiful” poem, which she wrote at a moment of inspiration at the top of Pikes Peak. NPR, however, apparently wanted to make sure audiences knew America The Beautiful isn’t all happiness and sunshine, not triumphant claptrap about a still-waving flag like the national anthem. “Rather, this young feminist poet, who had just emerged from a deep depression,” the story reads, “is asking if the nation… can ever live up to its high ideals.” Maybe, with time and enough bummerific features like this, we can get 7th inning crowds everywhere singing America, Do Better…
NPR was never a Lee Greenwood or Wayne Newton concert, but its tradition for decades was to gently flex a patriotic muscle every now and then, as if humbly celebrating its own small contribution to the American experience. For instance, it used to have an annual reading of the Declaration of Independence, but ditched it in a two-stage splashdown after the Summer of Floyd. In 2021, staff read it after an introductory segment about the Declaration’s “flaws and deeply ingrained hypocrisies.” The following year, the segment was replaced with “two Pulitzer Prize-winning historians” holding a discussion: “On this July 4th, what does equality mean?” After that, zilch. The old Declaration readings are still online, but now feature a trigger warning at the top about Jefferson’s “merciless Indian savages” line: “This story quotes the U.S. Declaration of Independence — a document that contains offensive language about Native Americans, including a racial slur.”
NPR’s last reading of the Declaration of IndependenceIf you’ve reached the stage of calling the Declaration of Independence “a document that contains offensive language,” you probably shouldn’t be working as a guardian of “national” public radio. If a private outlet feels the need to go there, mazel tov, but the federal government shouldn’t be issuing Surgeon General’s warnings for its foundational ideas. If it is doing that, it’s probably appropriate to wonder what’s behind that messaging imperative.
I’m not a particularly patriotic person — I doubt there’s a flag in my house — but I don’t think taxpayers should be funding an endless hit piece on the national experiment, either, especially one that sounds like a word-for-word replay of old Soviet campaigns (“Five Shames on the Conscience of America!”). Where is this coming from? Why are so many people in positions of influence in a superpower suddenly so keen on letting the air out of the national tires? Whatever it is, NPR is its most visible symbol, and needs to take a rest for a while, at least until the government settles on a formula for producing media without didactic political instruction. Good night, Big Bird. It was fun while it lasted.
Watch the recording here on Substack, Rumble, and YouTube:
Or visit Matt or Walter on X.
Get more from Matt Taibbi in the Substack appAvailable for iOS and AndroidGet the appFrom the publisher's feed