Could you give up Castaway Cay? Or sacrifice Pirate Night? This week, we play One Has to Go: Disney Cruise Edition—and the choices get tough!

🎙️ Rope Drop On Deck 117: One Has To Go with DCL Cruising Dad

On this episode of Rope Drop On Deck, Doug is joined by Chris, The DCL Cruising Dad, for a game that puts Disney Cruise Line favorites head-to-head. We take four beloved experiences—shows, dining rooms, ports, and ship amenities—and ask the impossible question: if one has to go forever, which would you choose?

We’ll cover:

• Disney Cruise Line shows — which Broadway-style production gets cut? (Beauty and the Beast, Frozen, Aladdin, Tangled)

• Rotational dining rooms — which dining experience is the weakest link? (Animator’s Palate, Tiana’s, Rapunzel’s, Arendelle)

• Ports of call — Castaway Cay or Lookout Cay, which private island would you give up?

• Ship amenities — Quiet Cove, Oceaneer Club, AquaDuck/AquaMouse, or Pirate Night… one has to go!

• Rapid-fire lightning round — Palo vs. Remy, fireworks vs. sail away, concierge vs. verandah vs. inside staterooms

It’s all fun debate, Disney Cruise trivia, and some surprising choices that even we didn’t see coming.

Follow Chris on all the social media platforms that can be found on his website www.dclcruisingdad.com

✨ Play along with us and let us know on Instagram or Facebook: which Disney Cruise Line experience would YOU cut?

 

Cruise News Update – Brought to you by BackToTheMouse.com, your source for cruise deals and sailing tips.

             - The Adventure is delayed!

📱 Follow Rope Drop On Deck:

• Instagram: @RopeDropOnDeck

• Facebook: Rope Drop On Deck

• Threads: @RopeDropOnDeck

• Twitter/X: @RopeDropOnDeck

Stay in the loop for bonus cruise content, updates, and behind-the-scenes fun.

More of Michelle

More of Doug

If you want to book a cruise reach out to Michelle at [email protected]

🎧 Also check out our sister podcast: Rope Drop Radio – your source for Disney Parks planning tips and reviews!

Thanks for sailing with us—until next time, happy cruising! ⚓🌊