Reader, I Murdered Him

Reader, I Murdered Him

By The Stay At Home CreativeTrue Crime
Download on the App Store

Reader, I Murdered Him episodes

  • Haunted: Combe Carey Hall

    We all know England has a “Problem,” and with the proliferation of the spirits of the undead walking the streets there has been a surge in real life ghost stories and psychic crimes to report.

    But today, we’re going to tackle one of the most infamous of these haunted places. Combe Carey Hall, legendary home of the Satan worshiping monks who have been credited with driving multiple residents of the hall to insanity, or to their deaths.

    And that’s just for starters. From there, Combe Carey Hall has become the home to the dreaded Red Room and the Screaming Staircase, where the Red Baron supposedly lit the skulls of his victims as macabre luminaries to set the scene for his nightly debauchery. 

    But the Lockwood and Company psychic agency, a small start-up boasting only three young agents, would manage to take down each of these hauntings—and solve a decades old missing persons case while doing it.

    Today's episode is based on The Screaming Staircase by Johnathan Stroud, book one of the Lockwood & Co. series.


    Reader, I Murdered Him is a true crime podcast for people with too much anxiety to enjoy podcasts about actual crimes. Every week we’ll do a deep dive into a murder, cult, serial killer, or other noteworthy crime, but with a twist. The crimes on Reader, I Murdered Him aren’t ripped from the headlines. They’re ripped from the pages of newly released, noteworthy backlist, or timeless classic mystery, thriller, and horror novels.

    Want to get in touch? send a message to [email protected]

    Want to talk about today’s book? Join the bookclub! https://www.goodreads.com/group/show/1202965-reader-i-murdered-him-podcast-book-club

    Want to know what we’re reading next? Follow the newsletter: https://thestayathomecreative.substack.com

    Find Reader, I Murdered Him on Anchor: https://anchor.fm/readerimurderedhim

    30 min
  • Detective: Lila Macapagal

    Today's case takes us to Shady Palms, Illinois, a suburb about two hours outside of Chicago, where prodigal niece Lila Macapagal returns home to help her Tita Rosie in her restaurant that’s struggling to keep the lights on and the doors open. 

    But her plan to bring new life to her Aunt’s restaurant is put to a quick end when restaurant critic Derek Winter dies while eating lunch there—and Lila and her Aunt are suspects.

    The murder of Derek Winter brings us into the darker side of Shady Palms, from schemes and scams to drug trafficking and police informants.

    Today's episode is based on Arsenic and Adobo by Mia P. Manansala.


    Reader, I Murdered Him is a true crime podcast for people with too much anxiety to enjoy podcasts about actual crimes. Every week we’ll do a deep dive into a murder, cult, serial killer, or other noteworthy crime, but with a twist. The crimes on Reader, I Murdered Him aren’t ripped from the headlines. They’re ripped from the pages of newly released, noteworthy backlist, or timeless classic mystery, thriller, and horror novels.

    Want to get in touch? send a message to [email protected]

    Want to talk about today’s book? Join the bookclub! https://www.goodreads.com/group/show/1202965-reader-i-murdered-him-podcast-book-club

    Want to know what we’re reading next? Follow the newsletter: https://thestayathomecreative.substack.com

    Find Reader, I Murdered Him on Anchor: https://anchor.fm/readerimurderedhim

    27 min
  • Detective: Meg Langslow

    Today's case follows the murder of Jane Grover, a woman in her fifties who visited Yorkville, VA for the wedding of her late sister's husband. Or at least, that's why she told everyone she was there.

    But really, Jane Grover came out to her sister's old house to do some investigating of her own. Because her sister's sudden illness and death have never sat right with her. And all the family jewelry that was supposed to go to Jane to keep it in the family, seems to have disappeared. While Jane may have her suspicions, she's determined to find some hard evidence before her former brother-in-law gets remarried.

    When Jane Grover is found murdered just days after her arrival it raises some questions, but a struggling small town sheriff's department doesn't seem to have the resources or the experience to handle the case and Jane's murder is left with no evidence, no leads, and no strong suspects.

    Luckily amateur sleuth Meg Langslow adds the case to her many pre-wedding, maid-of-honor duties. And what she finds will end up solving not one, but two unsolved homicides.


    Today's episode is based on Murder with Peacocks by Donna Andrews.

    Reader, I Murdered Him is a true crime podcast for people with too much anxiety to enjoy podcasts about actual crimes. Every week we’ll do a deep dive into a murder, cult, serial killer, or other noteworthy crime, but with a twist. The crimes on Reader, I Murdered Him aren’t ripped from the headlines. They’re ripped from the pages of newly released, noteworthy backlist, or timeless classic mystery, thriller, and horror novels.

    Want to get in touch? send a message to [email protected]

    Want to talk about today’s book? Join the bookclub! https://www.goodreads.com/group/show/1202965-reader-i-murdered-him-podcast-book-club

    Want to know what we’re reading next? Follow the newsletter: https://thestayathomecreative.substack.com

    Find Reader, I Murdered Him on Anchor: https://anchor.fm/readerimurderedhim

    24 min
  • Serial Killer: The Angel Killer of Cook County

    Someone is stalking men in the back alleys of Chicago. And not just any men. The kind that harbor dark minds and darker desires. The kind of men that kill their wives, abandon their children, and abuse their secretaries. The kind of men that aren’t missed by the women in their lives.

    And there is no man in Chicago with darker thoughts than Dennis Ferry, who is already caught up in a potential corruption scandal currently under investigation by the state’s attorney. 

    Then State’s Attorney Newhouse is sent, unconscious, the hospital by a car bomb, and it seems the investigation into Dennis Ferry will be shelved—if not forgotten entirely—until his oldest daughter, Ruby Newhouse, a girl with a penchant and passion for the law herself, takes up her father’s work.

    But Ruby Newhouse isn’t the only woman with Dennis Ferry in her sights.

    The Angel Killer of Cook County wants a piece of him too.

    And while the Angel Killer isn’t the most prolific serial killer to ever walk the streets of Chicago, she is the most beloved. Although her identity remains a mystery as, to this day, she has yet to be caught.


    Today's episode is based on Murder for the Modern Girl by Kendall Kulper. Today's ad is based on You (the Netflix series, not the books).

    Reader, I Murdered Him is a true crime podcast for people with too much anxiety to enjoy podcasts about actual crimes. Every week we’ll do a deep dive into a murder, cult, serial killer, or other noteworthy crime, but with a twist. The crimes on Reader, I Murdered Him aren’t ripped from the headlines. They’re ripped from the pages of newly released, noteworthy backlist, or timeless classic mystery, thriller, and horror novels.

    Want to get in touch? send a message to [email protected]

    Want to talk about today’s book? Join the bookclub! https://www.goodreads.com/group/show/1202965-reader-i-murdered-him-podcast-book-club

    Want to know what we’re reading next? Follow the newsletter: https://thestayathomecreative.substack.com

    Find Reader, I Murdered Him on Anchor: https://anchor.fm/readerimurderedhim


    25 min
  • DETECTIVE: Flavia de Luce

    In the spirit of cozy mysteries, today’s episode doesn’t just do a deep dive into a murder, we’re going to meet one of England’s most premiere detectives of the 1950s. An eleven-year-old girl who lives in her family’s crumbling mansion, known as Buckshaw in the town of Bishop’s Lacey. She has a passion for poison’s and dreams of growing up to be a chemist. But in the meantime, she solves murders.

    And today we’ll be looking at the very first case this Sherlock-level savant ever solved.

    When Flavia de Luce finds a man murdered in her family’s cucumber patch, she knows she has to find out why. But when her father is wrongly arrested for the man’s murder, it becomes a matter of life and death.

    Flavia has to use every resource at her disposal, and all of her wits, to solve the case before the police wrongfully convict her father. But solving the murder means Flavia has to confront some difficult truths about her father—and the secret he’s been keeping from all three of his daughters.

    Today's episode is based on The Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie by Alan Bradley. Today's ad is based on Stephen King’s The Shining.



    Reader, I Murdered Him is a true crime podcast for people with too much anxiety to enjoy podcasts about actual crimes. Every week we’ll do a deep dive into a murder, cult, serial killer, or other noteworthy crime, but with a twist. The crimes on Reader, I Murdered Him aren’t ripped from the headlines. They’re ripped from the pages of newly released, noteworthy backlist, or timeless classic mystery, thriller, and horror novels.

    Want to get in touch? send a message to [email protected]

    Want to talk about today’s book? Join the bookclub! https://www.goodreads.com/group/show/1202965-reader-i-murdered-him-podcast-book-club

    Want to know what we’re reading next? Follow the newsletter: https://thestayathomecreative.substack.com

    Find Reader, I Murdered Him on Anchor: https://anchor.fm/readerimurderedhim


    22 min
  • CULT: The Mad Scientists of Sundial, Arizona

    Twin sisters Rob and Jack had an unusual upbringing. Instead of going to school and making friends their own age, they lived on a ranch lovingly nicknamed Sundial in the middle of the Arizona desert, surrounded by their parents Falcon and Mia and an ever-changing group of scientist grad students who came to the ranch to work in Falcon's lab.

    Falcon was a former government scientist who left his prestigious job on the East Coast to come to Arizona and start a lab with no limitations, a lab where scientists with big ideas could see those ideas become actualized experiments.

    And until their seventeenth birthday, Rob and Jack are both happy with their unconventional upbringing. But then Jack starts to suffer from hallucinations and violent outbreaks. And Falcon and Mia start to have discussions about the twins they don't want Rob to overhear. And on her eighteenth birthday Rob decides she's had enough, and she leaves Sundial--hoping it will be for good.

    It isn't until Rob's daughter, Callie, begins hallucinating and exhibiting her own strange behavior that Rob is forced to confront what really happened at Sundial, and what that might mean for her and her own daughters.


    This is the story of Rob and Jack, and the mad scientists of Sundial, Arizona.


    Today's episode is based on Sundial by Catriona Ward. Today's ad is based on the 2017 movie I Don't Feel At Home In This World Anymore.


    To get in touch, send a message to [email protected]

    Follow the newsletter: https://thestayathomecreative.substack.com

    Join the bookclub: https://www.goodreads.com/group/show/1202965-reader-i-murdered-him-podcast-book-club

    Find Reader, I Murdered Him on Anchor: https://anchor.fm/readerimurderedhim

    27 min
  • CULT: The Army of the Changing World

    The Army of the Changing World is infamous for it's 1986 shooting of Martin Queller at the Oslo economic summit, and then it's successful bombing attack of the Chicago Mercantile Exchange. But what, exactly, the Army of the Changing World wanted, has never been as clear. While all the members of this group--now classified officially as a cult--seem to show strong devotion and loyalty, it's not to any particular manifesto. It's to a man, Nick Harp, who seemed to have a stranglehold over their lives, and pasts, which caused them to serve him and his whims with unwavering obedience.


    Until one woman, Jane Queller, found herself pregnant with Nick's child, and the reality of motherhood opened her eyes to the reality of Nick.


    Today, we'll be looking at the cult The Army of the Changing World, and the woman that brought them to justice.


    Today's episode is based on Pieces of Her by Karen Slaughter. Today's ad is based on the show The Patient, streaming on Hulu.

    To get in touch, send a message to [email protected]

    Follow the newsletter: https://thestayathomecreative.substack.com

    Join the bookclub: https://www.goodreads.com/group/show/1202965-reader-i-murdered-him-podcast-book-club

    Find Reader, I Murdered Him on Anchor: https://anchor.fm/readerimurderedhim

    23 min
  • SERIAL KILLER: Francis Crowder

    Have you ever wondered what happens to a town when it finds out that it has unknowingly been housing a serial killer?

    Or what about the businesses that employed them?
    The children who have to grow up balancing the love they have for the parent they knew with the terror they have of the person that parent has been revealed to be.
    We see some of this in fiction, the shows Prodigal Son and Dexter: New Blood focus on the aftermath of a serial killer’s crimes on his children. Stephen King’s “A Good Marriage” and Riley Sager’s “The House Across the Lake” look at what happens when a woman discovers her husband is so far from the man she thought he was it has terrifying consequences.
    But Vera Crowder isn’t a fictional character. She is a very real girl who, at age 13, watched her father get arrested for and confess to the murders of multiple men. One of whom was her best friend’s father.

    You can imagine the kind of adolescence Vera had after her father was convicted of murder and sentenced to life in prison. This man Vera had loved and admired, who she’d seen in the best parts of herself, was—in the court of public opinion—objectively and unforgivably evil.

    As soon as she’s able, Vera leaves home. So when her mother, Daphne, calls her back home because she’s dying, it is the last place Vera wants to go back to. 

    But when she does, she is forced to confront—as an adult—her father’s crimes. And while many true crime authors have mined Francis Crowder’s life for content, most notable Hammet Duvall, who built his career on a tell-all true crime book on Francis Crowder’s murders, this is the first time we have Vera’s perspective on what it was to grow up as the daughter of a serial killer, and who that man was, as a father.


    Today's episode explores Francis Crowder and the Crowder House Murders.


    Reader, I Murdered Him is a real podcast about fake crimes. Each episode features a fictional crime from a fabulous book, but it's not spoiler free, so listen at your own risk.

    Today's episode is based on Just Like Home by Sarah Gailey.

    To get in touch, send a message to [email protected]

    Follow the newsletter: https://thestayathomecreative.substack.com

    Join the bookclub: https://www.goodreads.com/group/show/1202965-reader-i-murdered-him-podcast-book-club

    Find Reader, I Murdered Him on Anchor: https://anchor.fm/readerimurderedhim

    32 min
  • SERIAL KILLER: Daphne Vann

    Have you ever stood in a dark bathroom, closing your eyes, and whispering the name Bloody Mary three times before blinking your eyes open and experiencing that thrill of hoping to see her ghostly silhouette in the mirror while, at the same time, relieved when there’s nothing there after you turn on the bathroom lights?
    Ever played light as a feather, stiff as a board with a gaggle of chanting preteens in a basement rec room at a sleepover or a tent during summer camp, long after all the chaperones and parents have gone to sleep and told you that this is, seriously, the last call for lights out?

    Or maybe these particular urban legends don’t mean anything to you. Maybe you’ve left offerings for the fey so deep in the woods you had a moment where your heart beat a little faster as you spun around thinking, for just a moment, that you were lost—or some force beyond the known universe was trying to keep you deep in the forest’s heart.

    Maybe you’ve heard the cry of La Llorona late at night? The footsteps of the Windigo? The whispers of ghosts in Kuldhara? 

    It doesn’t matter where you live or where you grew up. There’s at least one story that, at some point in your life, filled you with fear and excitement and a need to seek out the forbidden. 

    Just like the girls of the Samhattan high school basketball team.

    And in any other world, this story would have stayed a story. The sleepover would have stayed a team building exercise.

    Instead, within weeks there would be no more girls basketball team at Samhattan high school. One by one, Daphne would come for them all.


    Today's episode is the story of Daphne Vann, Samhattan serial killer and urban legend.


    Reader, I Murdered Him is a real podcast about fake crimes. Each episode features a fictional crime from a fabulous book, but it's not spoiler free, so listen at your own risk.


    Today's episode is based on the book Daphne by Josh Malerman.

    To get in touch, send a message to [email protected]

    Follow the newsletter: https://thestayathomecreative.substack.com

    Join the bookclub: https://www.goodreads.com/group/show/1202965-reader-i-murdered-him-podcast-book-club

    Find Reader, I Murdered Him on Anchor: https://anchor.fm/readerimurderedhim

    32 min
  • MISSING: ELEANOR WALSH

    Eleanor Walsh is a #girlboss the way only a woman starting up a coworking space for other women to start their start ups in the 2020s can be. And she's getting rich off of her exclusive HERd spaces and instagram worthy offices. So when she doesn't show up on the night of a major company announcement, the HERders know something must be wrong. And when a trip to Eleanor's apartment shows that her bed was never slept in, and her hairdresser calls to say Eleanor was a no show for their appointment, the women of the HERd begin to fear the worst.

    What happened to Eleanor Walsh?

    Reader, I Murdered Him is a real podcast about fake crimes. Each episode features a fictional crime from a fabulous book, but it's not spoiler free, so listen at your own risk.

    Today's episode is exclusively The Herd by Andrea Bartz.

    To get in touch, send a message to [email protected]

    Follow the newsletter: https://thestayathomecreative.substack.com

    Join the bookclub: https://www.goodreads.com/group/show/1202965-reader-i-murdered-him-podcast-book-club

    Find Reader, I Murdered Him on Anchor: https://anchor.fm/readerimurderedhim

    30 min

About Reader, I Murdered Him

From the publisher's feed

A real podcast about fake crimes for book lovers!