“Remarkably Bright Creatures” by Shelby Van Pelt is a quiet novel with a giant heart and an octopus who might be the wisest character of them all. Set in a small coastal town, the story follows a grieving widow and an unlikely friendship that slowly untangles a long-buried mystery. Is it a charming crowd-pleaser or a sentimental stretch? Subtle or slow? Hosts Kacy and Tyler dive into the characters, the twists, and yes, the octopus, to help you decide if “Remarkably Bright Creatures” deserves a spot on your nightstand.