This week Eden tells us a story where there are two Nicoles, but neither is as great as our Nicole. Later, Nicole tells us about a haunted park that may have inspired the movie Poltergeist. We’re not sure but the rumor keeps popping up…much like the bodies! These are the stories of Shanann Watts and Cheesman Park!

In this week’s episode Nicole tells us about a couple of jokesters who clearly didn’t understand how diamond mining worked (and neither did their investors). Later, Eden tells us about the inspiration for Sia’s “Chandelier.” These are the stories of The Great Diamond Hoax and Wyoming Frontier Prison!

In this week’s episode, Eden tells us about a bad teacher who isn’t Cameron Diaz and Nicole tells us about your new favorite drinking buddy if you love whiskey! These are the stories of John Trover and The Jackalope!

In this week’s episode we learn that it takes more than squirrel meat to win the heart of your kidnapping victim and that you can never have something good in a place called Piss Alley.  These are the stories of Kari Swenson and The Dumas Brothel!

In this week’s episode, Eden tells us about a man who knows how to hide a body but not a lot else. Later, Nicole talks about steep roads and the ghosts who want a ride off them. These are the stories of Brad Brisbin and MacDonald Pass.

This week Nicole tells us about a murderer who lies more than a Karen being recorded and Eden tells us about a Catholic Hospital where you definitely won’t be able to eat your pudding cup in peace. These are the stories of Angila Wilder and St. Joseph’s Hospital!

Due to scheduling we could not record and edit an episode in time but we didn’t want to just put out nothing so we’re giving you a little taste of something completely different we’ve been sitting on. I (Eden) was given a word that wasn’t particularly scary and told to make a scary story out of it. The result, along with Nicole’s amazing post-recording work, is a chilling work of fiction you won’t want to miss!  I call this story The Little Girl.

In this week’s episode Eden tells us about a guy who loves money almost as much as he loves being a complete asshole and Nicole blurs the lines between true crime and haunted houses. These are the stories of James Henrikson and the Harvey Public Library!

In this week’s episode Nicole tells the story of a family that either has the worst luck ever or someone got away with murder and Eden tells the story of an island that’s probably being haunted for a good reason. These are the stories of John Mathis and Laframboise island!

This week Eden tells two cold cases that will probably make you think twice about visiting Sioux Falls and Nicole tells the story of a man who hates humming but loves his mustache. These are the tales of Clara Olson, Baby Andrew Doe, and the haunted hotels of Deadwood!