At the Leagues Cup break we did a midseason episode breaking down how we thought each player did up to that point. But now that the 2025 Columbus Crew season is officially in the books it’s time for the end of the year grade cards! In this episode, we break down every Crew player’s performance from the 2025 MLS season, delivering each player their A+ to F report cards with full analysis on consistency, impact, injuries, and overall contribution. Who stepped up in the biggest moments? Who disappointed? And who still looks like a key piece for 2026 and beyond? This is your Columbus Crew individual player recap, player evaluation, and roster outlook heading into 2026.