Sterling K. Brown does not disappoint, but Gordon's last appearance makes Noah sad this week, as Abigail, Noah, & guest Jesse have a lot of ideas about how "Fresh Blood" could be improved. Sam's critical thinking skills are in question, Gordon undergoes an unwilling transformation, John Winchester slander is a recurring theme, and Dean wins "most improved in terms of showing vulnerability.
Content warnings: Discussions of homophobia, racism, religious zeal, AIDS, and violence towards a black character.