Say what again Billy?

Located on the southern edge of Lake George, Fort William Henry is one of New York’s most historic — and haunted — sites. Built in the mid-1700s during the French and Indian War, it was the scene of a brutal siege and massacre that left hundreds dead.

In this episode, Billy and Joey dive into the fort’s chilling past, from the bloody history of its battles to the lingering spirits said to roam the grounds today. Visitors and staff have reported phantom gunfire, the echo of drums, and the ghostly figure of a young girl wandering near the lake’s edge. Could these hauntings be the echoes of that tragic history?

Join us as we uncover the history, legends, and paranormal evidence that make Fort William Henry one of the most haunted places in New York.

Billy, Bobby, and Joey journey to one of the world’s most haunted places — Poveglia Island off the coast of Venice, Italy.

Once used as a quarantine zone during the Black Plague, the island became a mass grave where thousands of infected souls took their final breaths. Centuries later, it was converted into a psychiatric hospital — a place shrouded in horror and cruelty. Rumors tell of a sadistic doctor who performed barbaric lobotomies on helpless patients before meeting a grim fate himself, said to have fallen — or been thrown — from the island’s bell tower.

From the island’s cursed soil to its dark legends, SWAB tells all about Italy’s most haunted and forbidden island — as spooky season continues here on The Say What Again Billy Podcast.

In this Side Talk, Billy sits down with Rick Garner—a founding member of Unexplained Cases, the hit paranormal research team known across YouTube, TikTok, and beyond. Rick’s roots are in news and media, a path that led him straight into the strange and unexplainable. Today, he and his team document hauntings, oddities, and deep-dive investigations—and Rick also hosts a weekly TikTok mini-series exploring how paranormal phenomena and faith intersect.

Together, Billy and Rick tackle the big questions: Can faith and the paranormal truly coexist? Where do they overlap—and where do they split? If your beliefs say one thing but your experiences suggest another, how do you reconcile the two? This thought-provoking conversation is for anyone wrestling with the mystery of the unknown and what it means for their spiritual life.

Join Billy and Joey as they explore the mysterious and haunted world of Appalachia in this spooky season edition of the Say What Again Billy? Podcast! From eerie tales along the Appalachian Trail to chilling mountain legends and centuries-old Native American folklore, this episode dives into why many believe this region is one of the most haunted stretches of land in the United States.

Cryptids, ghost stories, and Appalachian myths — Billy and Joey cover it all. Whether you’re a fan of paranormal investigations, dark history, or spooky campfire tales, this episode is packed with eerie vibes perfect for spooky season.

Tune in, get comfy, and let’s talk about the haunted Appalachia.

In this Side Talk episode, Billy dives into the mysterious Bayside Mall Alien Incident — a strange event that took place in January 2024 at Miami’s Bayside Marketplace. Witnesses flooded TikTok and X claiming to see glowing, 8–10-foot beings as over 50 police units swarmed the scene. Then, almost overnight, the story vanished from headlines and social media.

Was it chaos caused by teenagers and fireworks — or something the authorities didn’t want getting out? Billy breaks down the theories, footage, and why this strange Miami incident became the story the news forgot.

On this episode of the SWAB Podcast, Billy and Joey dive into one of Tennessee’s most chilling legends — the Bell Witch. The story centers on the Bell family, who in the early 1800s experienced one of the most terrifying hauntings ever recorded in American folklore.

Was the Bell family tormented by a witch’s curse, or was it something far darker — perhaps demonic? Join the boys from the SWAB Podcast as they explore the full story and uncover one of Tennessee’s most infamous paranormal cases.

Join Billy in this spooky season episode as he interviews Leo, the owner of How Ya Brewing Café in Tuckahoe, New York. With Leo’s deep curiosity about the paranormal, this conversation proves that strange encounters aren’t limited to ghost hunters and investigators—even small business owners in quiet towns experience the unexplained.

Leo shares some of his own chilling stories, including one from the famously haunted Stanley Hotel—one of the most notorious paranormal hotspots in the United States. Don’t miss this eerie and engaging conversation, perfect to get you in the spirit of spooky season!

In this special Side Talk episode of the Say What Again Billy? Podcast, Billy is joined by his father for a heartfelt conversation about the origins of his paranormal journey. Together, they revisit the night in 1995 when their family witnessed a UFO over Janelle’s Towers in the Bronx — the moment that turned Billy into a believer.

They share stories of family trips to haunted hotspots like Gettysburg and Salem, and Billy’s father recounts first-hand experiences standing side-by-side with him during investigations. The two open up about their personal beliefs in the supernatural in this one-of-a-kind father-and-son episode you won’t want to miss.

Built in the 1800s and tucked away in rural Hinsdale, NY, this house has become one of the most talked-about paranormal hotspots in the state. From the terrifying experiences of the Dandy family in the 1970s — including poltergeist activity, shadow figures, and strange chanting from the surrounding woods — to decades of paranormal investigations, the Hinsdale House has earned its reputation as one of the most haunted places in New York.

In this episode, Billy and Joey dig into the missing pieces of its history, share their theories on why the house remains so active, and talk about their plans to visit in person to conduct their own investigation.

Spooky season is in full swing — catch this episode of the Say What Again Billy Podcast and kick off your season of scares the right way!

In this episode of the Say What Again Billy Podcast, we’re back and getting you ready for everything creepy and paranormal this October. From the terrifying legend of the Bell Witch to the haunted halls of the Winchester Mystery Mansion, we’re setting the stage for what’s to come.

Plus, Bobby fills in for Joey with a personal story on how he first became intrigued — and fascinated — by the world of the paranormal.