We hope everyone had a happy holiday! For episode 71 Samantha covers the mysterious unsolved disappearance of Tara Calico. Tell us your thoughts! What do you think happened to Tara?

With the holiday season upon us, we bring you one of our bonus episodes! Samantha covers the case of the most spoiled, entitled dumbass we have ever heard of! Please excuse the noise interruptions in this episode, Samantha's town apparently just couldn't cooperate with recording that day!

This week Krystal covers the steak obsessed Eyeball Killer, Charles Albright. We would love to hear y’all’s thoughts on if Albright was the killer, or if he was just a creepy weirdo that had a bunch of crazy coincidences making him look guilty.

After a series of unfortunate events with Samantha's computer, we're back! This week she tells us all about the murder Elizabeth “Betsy” Aardsma, a cold case from 1969. This is one of those cases that will have you forever wondering what happened. Special guest David Duchovny. Not really. But that would be cool.

We have a special guest cohost while Samantha is out working on finals. Special thanks to Shannon for joining/depressing me this week as she covers the terribleness that is the Lester Street Massacre.

This week Krystal covers possibly the most annoying serial killer Paul Michael Stephani aka the Weepy Voiced Killer aka Moaning Myrtle. For the record, definitely not Gwen Stefani’s father. Please don’t sue us…we’re poor 😂

This week Samantha covers the somewhat well known case of Rodney Alcala. Some know him as the Dating Game Killer, we know him as garbage.

Its's the most wonderful time of the year, so we're bringing you an extra long, spooky episode! First, Samantha covers the spooky case of the Smurl house haunting. Then Krystal tells us all about the legend of Black-eyed Kids. Happy Halloween, y'all!

This week you get another one of our Bonus episodes. Krystal fills your earholes with the tale of the most stubborn murder victim of all time, along with the worst murderers ever. Some know him as The Irish Rasputin, some know him as Iron Mike. This week we're talking about the insane murder of Michael Malloy.

This week we have a special guest! It’s a Shannon! Join us as our first serialholic covers the terrible tragic murder of Sylvia Likens.