The mountains never forget.
In 1987, a man and his dog vanished into the wilderness near Silver Plume, Colorado. One year later, another man followed — never to return.
Join Amanda and Kori as they uncover the chilling mystery of Silver Plume’s disappearing residents, where the line between truth and legend fades into the fog.
️Mystery. Mountains. And a story that refuses to rest.

The mountains never forget. In 1987, a man and his dog vanished into the wilderness near Silver Plume, Colorado. One year later, another man followed — never to return. Join Amanda and Kori as they uncover the chilling mystery of Silver Plume’s disappearing residents, where the line between truth and legend fades into the fog. ️Mystery. Mountains. And a story that refuses to rest.

Spooky Season 25 Ep: 2- Mystery in the Mountains: The Legend of Silver Plume’s Disappearing Residents

Welcome to Colorado Crime, where two best friends turned “partners in crime” dig into the darkest stories from Colorado and beyond.

We bring you deep dives into true crime cases — from haunting unsolved mysteries to the infamous and the overlooked — all told with empathy, curiosity, and a dash of humor to keep things human. Every episode blends solid research, thoughtful storytelling, and the kind of banter that only comes from years of friendship (and maybe a few too many late-night coffee runs).

At the heart of every story are the victims — their lives, their voices, and the justice they deserve.

So grab your headphones and join us as we explore the darker side of the Rockies… one case at a time.

The crimes that we discuss are graphic and may be difficult for some listeners. Listener discretion is advised. 


Interested in supporting us?:
https://coloradocrimepod.castos.com/donate
 
Like hanging out with us every week? Be sure to subscribe, rate, share, and review.

Website: https://www.coloradocrimepodcast.com/
Instagram: @ColoradoCrimePod
Youtube: @ColoradoCrimePod
Facebook: @ColoradoCrimePod

Society & Culture

News

True Crime

Welcome to Colorado Crime, where two best friends turned “partners in crime” dig into the darkest stories from Colorado and beyond. We bring you deep dives into true crime cases — from haunting unsolved mysteries to the infamous and the overlooked — all told with empathy, curiosity, and a dash of humor to keep things human. Every episode blends solid research, thoughtful storytelling, and the kind of banter that only comes from years of friendship (and maybe a few too many late-night coffee runs). At the heart of every story are the victims — their lives, their voices, and the justice they deserve. So grab your headphones and join us as we explore the darker side of the Rockies… one case at a time. The crimes that we discuss are graphic and may be difficult for some listeners. Listener discretion is advised. Interested in supporting us?: https://coloradocrimepod.castos.com/donate Like hanging out with us every week? Be sure to subscribe, rate, share, and review. Website: https://www.coloradocrimepodcast.com/ Instagram: @ColoradoCrimePod Youtube: @ColoradoCrimePod Facebook: @ColoradoCrimePod

Share Spooky Season 25 Ep: 2- Mystery in the Mountains: The Legend of Silver Plume’s Disappearing Residents

Sign up to save your podcasts

Spooky Season 25 Ep: 2- Mystery in the Mountains: The Legend of Silver Plume’s Disappearing Residents

Spooky Season 25 Ep: 2- Mystery in the Mountains: The Legend of Silver Plume’s Disappearing Residents

More shows like Colorado Crime Podcast

Criminal

The Vanished Podcast

My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

20/20

True Crime Obsessed

Cold Case Files

Crime Junkie

Morbid

Dateline NBC

I Think Not!

Park Predators

Serialously with Annie Elise

The Megyn Kelly Show

The Deck

Nightmare Next Door