The long-time religion editor of Publisher’s Weekly, Phyllis Tickle, wrote in her book The Great Emergence that every five hundred years or so, the Christian faith holds a “rummage sale.” The church sifts and sorts through beliefs and practices that have grown old, decayed, or died, to make space for what wants to emerge. That’s every five hundred years. This sifting and sorting process occurred with the Great Collapse of the Roman Empire (around year 500 ce), the Great Schism between the Eastern and Western Churches (around year 1000), and the Great Reformation (around year 1500). Now, she proposed, we are in the Great Emergence. What is emerging? This is a crucial question when it comes to our topic for this evening – Teaching, Baptizing, and Nurturing Believers – not only because it is “politic” to know our constituency; it is also a faithful response to the work of God’s Spirit, whom Jesus says will teach us everything and remind us of all that [Jesus] said to us.”[i] What are we being taught and reminded through God’s Spirit, and where do we look?
One place to which we cannot look solelyis to the Bible, and for two reasons. For one, the Bible is not universally credible, and, at the very least, is interpreted in very different waysby practicing Christians, don’t we know. A recent Gallup poll shows about 75% of Americans believe the Bible is in some way connected to God, but how the Bible is connected ranges a wide gamut; and about 20% of Americans now view the Bible as ancient fables, legends, history written not by God but by biased, sometimes ill-informed humans.[ii] Secondly, we cannot look to the Bible alone for the Spirit’s leading because the Bible “offers us no clear categories for many of our most significant and vexing socio-ethical questions.” I’m quoting here from the author and post-evangelical pastor Brian McLaren, writing about A New Kind of Christianity.[iii] McLaren says that, in the Bible, “We find no explicit mention, for example, of abortion, capitalism, communism, socialism, schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder, autism, systemic racism, affirmative action, human rights, nationalism, sexual orientation, pornography, global climate change, imprisonment, extinction of species, energy efficiency, environmental sustainability, genetic engineering, space travel, and so on – not to mention nuclear weapons, biological warfare, and just-war theory.” That’s what is missing from the Bible.
So we can’t look just to the Bible. We need to seek out God’s Spirit, whom Jesus says is “like the wind that blows wherever it chooses.”[iv] The Anglican formula for discerning the leading of God’s Spirit today is a kind of faithful, expectant synergy: a kind of dialogue between:
the Bible;
and then tradition, i.e., how people were led by the Spirit in the past. The early Church survived and thrived for about 200 years before there was what we call the New Testament, the New Testament Canon of Scripture.
and then use our reason, because we have been created in the image of God with minds and memories. We are not robots; we are not blank tablets.
and then, lastly, we draw on our experience. What is my experience of God? What is your experience of God? It’s a crucial question, not just so we bequeath dignity to one another – which is important – but also because we understand that God’s Spirit doesn’t just work around us and through others, but within us, in our own life’s experience.
And I’m saying “us.” This isn’t about me; this is about us. There is no private faith in Jesus; it is always a public faith: personal yet public. Jesus always worked with groups. He spoke to groups, he fed groups, ate with groups, healed people in groups. When we read he encountered individuals, they were representatives of a group, or he sent these individuals back to groups. Saint Paul said these groups of Jesus’ followers were like a body: very diverse parts – a foot is very different from an [...]