It was Superbowl Sunday 2004, when most were talking about Janet Jacksons "accidental" nip slip, Sarasota Florida was jolted into panic looking for missing 11 year old Carlie Brucia.  

Although the truth came to light rather quickly all things considered, Justice would take a while. 

Candy , had a great meet cute story of how she met her new boyfriend Jovan Collier. That would be the highlight of the entire relationship. Listen in as secrets get uncovered and learn how second chances are not always the best. 

Katelyn Markham, was about to graduate college and had plans to move out of state with her boyfriend of 6 years John Carter. Just weeks before graduation, Katelyn was reported missing. It would take more than a decade to get some form of justice.  

Poem/Diary entry noted in episode: 

Deep down I love her. 

you want to kill her. 

but I love her. 

she must die. 

I can't kill her. 

yes you can. 

no. 

yes. 

how do you talk me into all these things. 

I'm just that good. 

but you're bad. 

I know. 

how do I kill you. 

you can't. 

you're right. 

about what. 

nothing. 

Levi King makes you wonder whether his murder spree was a result of nature or nurture. Was he born to be a killer or was it his upbringing and his surroundings that molded him to be a monster. 

SKIP to minute 18 to skip chit-chat :) 

Allyzibeth Lamont (Ally) was born and raised in Gloversville, NY.  When she was in her early 20's she had just ended a toxic relationship and was starting to rebuild her life. While working at a local sandwich shop she made friends with coworkers and was saving towards a new apartment.  

2 nights before Halloween, Ally was suddenly missing.  

Detectives followed every lead and it wasn't til the second interview with a particular person that they found out what really happened to her. 

Sam Herr had found strength in his previous criminal run ins and went on to have a successful military career and was now attending college. While at college he made friends like Julie Kibuishi and everything was going well for him. Little did he know how far someone near him would be willing to go to fund their dream wedding and honeymoon.  

Marna and Sharnelle were living in their dorms at Stella enjoying being with each other again since they were childhood friends. Young love quickly tainted their relationship and the left Sharnelle on an island. 

On the morning on May 26th, 2018, everyone was woken up with the news of both girls taking their lives. The details of the events leading up this morning soon revealed something more sinister. 

Riley and Breezy were young teenagers in love and during Christmas time 2017 they took a road trip to visit both sides of the family and old friends. One of these visits would unknowingly be their last. 

The Doolin family was set to enjoy their oldest sons football game when the unimaginable happened. Gabbi Doolin was 7 years old and left her moms side to go play hide and seek with friends. 

When they couldn't find her, panic set in.  

In a small town, the rumor wheel started turning and the perpetrator was quickly apprehended. 

Jack Rains wore lots of hats through different seasons of life. In his laters years he took on extra hobbies, some with extra business partners.  

One of these business partners and friends was Tina Williamson, who ended up being the same person that would call into 911 when she walked into the crime scene.