Can homeschoolers actually play college sports? If your athlete has ever said "I want to play in college," there is a separate process running alongside college admissions that most homeschool families never hear about until it's too late. Homeschool expert Christy-Faith sits down with Natalie Mack, M.Ed., to walk through exactly how NCAA eligibility works when you're the one wearing the guidance counselor hat.
🎁 Free Resource: My Curriculum Recommendations
I spill the tea! No paid sponsorship placements! Grab the list, by subject, of the most reputable homeschool programs on the market (in my opinion).
👉 Free Download
In this episode, you'll learn:
- Whether homeschool students can compete in NCAA athletics just like traditionally schooled students
- Where to find the NCAA Eligibility Center's homeschool toolkit and why it's the document to follow
- How the 16 core courses and the 10/7 rule actually work
- What a Core Course Worksheet (CCW) is and when a parent has to fill one out
- When the eligibility clock starts and why 9th grade is already late to begin planning
- How dual enrollment, co-op classes, and online courses count toward eligibility
- The real difference between Division 1, Division 2, and Division 3 requirements
- The most common mistakes that quietly create eligibility problems for homeschool athletes
Sponsors:
BJU Press Homeschool
✔ Flexible curriculum to fit your family's needs
✔ Biblical worldview and critical thinking built in
✔ Hands-on learning for every grade level
👉 View Samples
CTC Math
✔ Get 50% off my favorite online math program
✔ Adaptive lessons so kids build confidence at their own pace
✔ Teaching, grading, and testing — all done for you!
👉 Free Trial
👉 Get 50% Off
LearningRx
✔ Backed by 35 years of research
✔ Real long-term help with ADHD and dyslexia
✔ Strengthens attention, memory, reading, writing, and math
👉 Get $50 Off Your Cognitive Skills Assessment — use code HOME50
Summit Healthshare
✔ Save 40–60% vs. traditional health insurance
✔ See any doctor — no networks, no permission slips
✔ Free labs, office visits, prescriptions on select plans
👉 View Health Plans & Savings
Resources mentioned:
- Natalie Mack's website — free high school planning checklist for grades 9–12, the high school decisions workshop, and her homeschool courses
- High School Decisions Bootcamp — use code CHRISTY for a listener discount
- Natalie's homeschool courses — cross-cultural American literature and model diplomacy global affairs simulation
- 101 Tips for Homeschoolers — Natalie's book
- The Impact of Homeschooling — Natalie's TEDx talk
- The Christy-Faith List — Find homeschool-friendly providers: christy-faiths-list.com
- Thrive Homeschool Community: christy-faith.com/thrive
⭐ This is Part 2 of a 4-part series with Natalie Mack on homeschooling high school.
Part 1 — How to Homeschool High School With Confidence
Part 3 — the college-bound path, including community college and dual enrollment
Part 4 — from homeschool to military service: enlistment, ROTC, and service academies
About our guest:
Natalie Mack, M.Ed., is the founder of Homeschool Natalie Mack, and a homeschool consultant, TEDx speaker, and author of 101 Tips for Homeschoolers. With more than 23 years of homeschooling experience, she helps families confidently navigate high school, transcripts, college admissions, military service, and other postsecondary pathways. Natalie is passionate about equipping parents with practical guidance so they can make informed decisions.
👉 natalie-mack.com
Connect with Christy-Faith:
- Instagram: @christy_faith_
- TikTok: @christy_faith
- Website: christy-faith.com
- Book: Homeschool Rising
🎧 Love the show? Follow, subscribe, and leave a review wherever you listen — it helps more homeschool families find us!
- (00:00) - Introduction and why this series got split into four episodes
(02:30) - Natalie's daughter and the road to Division 1 soccer(06:16) - Can homeschoolers compete in NCAA athletics?(09:20) - The NCAA Eligibility Center and the homeschool toolkit(10:55) - The 16 core courses and the 10/7 rule(12:28) - Core Course Worksheets for parent-taught classes(16:46) - When the clock starts: planning before 9th grade(19:24) - What athletic scholarship money really looks like(20:59) - Division 1 vs. Division 2 vs. Division 3(22:33) - What the NCAA counts as a homeschool course(24:54) - The mistakes that create eligibility problems(28:37) - "Why not just send them to brick-and-mortar?"(33:28) - Dual enrollment, co-ops, and outside instructors(38:52) - What to do while your student is still in middle school(41:06) - The broken leg question every family should ask(43:26) - When a kid's identity gets wrapped up in performance(50:46) - Why one thing should never be everything(53:24) - What's coming next in the series and how to find Natalie