About five years ago, there was a conversation between journalists who had done years of work under precarious conditions and the YouTubers who used that work to create monetized content that made them a ton of money. If someone spends ten years of their life covering a story, and then some 22-year-old reads a simplified version of that work to the camera while doing their make-up and makes 10x as much money for it, is this a fair distribution of resources?
Now the conversation is about YouTubers being pushed out and losing income because of AI. Science YouTuber (a word thoroughly lacking in elegance) Hank Green was caught using AI to help with research and note taking, and his audience is furious. In the content industry, the demand is for authenticity, originality, and endless productivity. And AI -- the solution to all these problems -- is the siren whose song must be resisted.
Jessa and Nico posit that in the future, the only job in the creative field will be feeding the machine. But what does the backlash say about creator anxiety?
Shownotes and references:
http://theculturewedeserve.substack.com