The Dirty Verdict

In this riveting episode of the Dirty Verdict Podcast, hosts Peter Taaffe, Kyle Herbert and Bill Ogden are joined by special guest attorney Anna Greenberg for an in-depth discussion of high-stakes sexual assault litigation. The conversation spans groundbreaking cases—from the evolving legal battles against Massage Envy following recent changes in binding arbitration clauses, to a harrowing Hilton hotel case that culminated in a multi‐million dollar verdict, and a disturbing rideshare assault involving a Lyft driver. With frank insights into trial strategy, jury selection, and the challenges of holding powerful corporations accountable, this episode lays bare the systemic issues and safety failures that have left survivors fighting for justice. Whether you're a legal professional or simply curious about the intersection of corporate policy and personal safety, this episode offers a compelling look at the evolving landscape of sexual assault litigation.

Topics Discussed

• Massage Therapy Industry Cases: Litigation against Massage Envy and issues arising from previously enforced binding arbitration clauses.
• Federal Statute Changes: The 2022 law that renders binding arbitration clauses unenforceable in sexual assault or harassment cases.
• Franchisor Liability: Legal debates over the national franchise's duty to control local operations and ensure safe practices.
• Hilton Hotel Case: Detailed breakdown of a landmark sexual assault case at a Hilton property, including trial strategy, jury dynamics, and the $44.6M verdict.
• Trial Strategies & Jury Selection: Insights into courtroom tactics, the role of aggressive defense strategies, and jury questioning focused on the MeToo movement.
• Rideshare Safety Concerns: Discussion of a disturbing Lyft case involving kidnapping and assault, highlighting corporate safety failures and the legal responsibility of rideshare companies.
• Systemic Reform: Commentary on the need for tighter safety protocols, enhanced training, and stronger accountability from large organizations.
• Personal Legal Journeys: Anna Greenberg's background, her inspiration from her father's legacy in mass tort litigation, and her commitment to representing survivors.

Welcome back to another riveting edition of The Dirty Verdict Podcast! In this episode, hosts Peter Taaffe, trial lawyers Kyle Herbert and Bill Ogden, along with co-producer Amanda, sit down with acclaimed true crime author Kathryn Casey to explore some of the most complex and chilling cases in recent history. With over 100 episodes under their belt, the team delves into a detailed discussion about cases that blur the lines between legal intrigue and genuine human drama. Kathryn takes us deep into the notorious Celeste Beard case—with its twisted tale of financial ambition, betrayal, and a high-profile trial—and offers insights into the enigmatic stiletto case as well as the harrowing murder of Kari Baker, featured in her book Dirty Little Secrets. Discover how behind-the-scenes research, lengthy trial sessions, and the raw emotions of those involved have shaped some of the most talked-about true crime stories. Whether you're a legal professional, a true crime aficionado, or simply fascinated by the darker corners of human nature, this episode reveals why truth can indeed be stranger than fiction.

Show Notes

• Introduction & Hosts

◦ Welcome by mediator Peter Taaffe, joined by trial lawyers Kyle Herbert and Bill Ogden

◦ Special appearance by co-producer and PR director, Amanda

• Special Guest Spotlight

◦ Acclaimed true crime writer Kathryn Casey joins the discussion

◦ Highlights from her extensive career in true crime reporting and book writing

• The Celeste Beard Case

◦ Background: Celeste, a waitress at the Austin Country Club, and her financially motivated marriage to a wealthy founder

◦ The dramatic relationship with her husband and the involvement of Tracy Charlton

◦ Details of the murder plot, including the staged suicide threat and the subsequent trial

◦ Media frenzy: From the Nancy Grace tent outside the courthouse to live court TV coverage

◦ Testimonies from key witnesses, including the twin daughters

• Other Notable Cases Mentioned

◦ Brief discussion on the enigmatic stiletto case

◦ Overview of the Waco pastor case (last name Baker) and its intriguing twists

• Exploring Dirty Little Secrets: The Kari Baker Murder

◦ The tragic life of Kari Baker, a young mother with two daughters entangled in a relationship with a Baptist minister

◦ Investigation challenges: The missing autopsy, the dubious suicide note, and the exhumation that turned the case around

◦ Pivotal witness testimonies that broke the case open

• Kathryn Casey's Research Process & Trial Experiences

◦ Preparation: Reaching out to legal teams, interviewing witnesses, and attending lengthy trial sessions

◦ Behind-the-scenes anecdotes: Quirky personal stories and the emotional toll of covering high-profile cases

◦ Balancing the role of a journalist with the inherent dangers of true crime reporting

• True Crime in Today's Media Landscape

◦ Reflections on how true crime has evolved into mainstream documentaries and books

◦ The challenges and responsibilities of reporting on cases that touch so many lives

• Closing Thoughts & Call to Action

◦ Final reflections from Kathryn Casey on the nature of truth in true crime

◦ Reminder to follow The Dirty Verdict Podcast on YouTube, Spotify, iTunes, Instagram, and TikTok for more in-depth legal and true crime discussions

Join us for a deep dive into the murky world of true crime, where every case is a puzzle and every testimony a clue to understanding the human condition.

Welcome to another gripping episode of the Dirty Verdict podcast, the "No Sneeze, Dark Edition." Join hosts Peter Taaffe, Kyle Herbert, and Bill Ogden, along with frequent guest and criminal defense expert Anthony Osso, as they dive into the chilling true crime case of David Temple. In 1999, Temple, a former college football player turned high school coach, was convicted of murdering his pregnant wife in their Katy, Texas home. The case, filled with twists, prosecutorial misconduct, and appeals, raises questions about circumstantial evidence, legal ethics, and the complexities of the justice system. Tune in for a detailed breakdown, expert insights, and lively discussion on this infamous case.

Show Notes:

• Introduction (00:00:41 - 00:01:15)
• Hosts Peter, Kyle, and Bill introduce the episode.
• Frequent guest Anthony, a criminal defense expert, joins the show to discuss true crime.

• Case Overview: David Temple Murder Case (00:01:15 - 00:04:13)
• In 1999, David Temple's pregnant wife, a fellow teacher, was found shot dead in their closet in Katy, Texas.
• Temple claimed it was a break-in, but police later suspected him due to inconsistencies in his story.
• Temple was indicted years later, convicted, and sentenced to life imprisonment.

• Legal Proceedings and Appeals (00:04:13 - 00:06:17)
• Temple's defense attorney, Dick DeGuerin, and prosecutor Kelly Siegler were key figures in the trial.
• Appeals revealed 36 instances of prosecutorial misconduct, including Brady violations (failure to disclose exculpatory evidence).
• The Michael Morton Act in Texas enhanced disclosure requirements.
• Temple was retried, reconvicted, but the jury deadlocked on sentencing, leading to a new sentencing phase with life imprisonment upheld.

• Key Discussion Points (00:06:17 - 00:50:25)
• Legal Advice and Police Interaction:
• Anthony advises having a lawyer present during police questioning, especially in serious cases.
• Discussion on Miranda rights and when they are triggered (detention vs. arrest).

• Circumstantial Evidence:
• No murder weapon was found, and the case relied on timeline inconsistencies, affair evidence, and motive.
• Temple's affair with a fellow teacher and his remarriage during the investigation were highlighted.
• Alternative suspect theory: a neighbor with a motive and access to a shotgun was not fully disclosed (Brady violation).

• Prosecutorial Ethics and Brady Violations:
• Debate on why prosecutors might withhold evidence and the impact of the Michael Morton Act.
• Penalties for intentional Brady violations include dismissal of cases, suppression of evidence, or criminal prosecution.

• Sentencing and Appeals:
• Temple's incarceration history: jailed from 2007 to 2016, released on bond, reconvicted in 2019, and back in prison.
• Life sentence means parole eligibility after 30 years or half the sentence, whichever is earlier.
• Current appeal status unclear, but conviction likely to stand based on prior rulings.

• Key Takeaways (00:50:25 - 00:51:35)

• Divorce is a better alternative to murder.
• Get a lawyer if you suspect you are a suspect.
• Prosecutors should err on the side of disclosure to ensure justice.

• Closing (00:51:35 - 00:54:18)
• Thanks to Anthony for his insights and expertise.
• Contact Anthony at Cogdell Law Firm for criminal defense needs.

Follow Dirty Verdict on YouTube, Instagram, Spotify, Apple Podcasts, TikTok, and X for more episodes.

Stay tuned for next week's episode!

In this episode of The Dirty Verdict, we sit down with renowned headshot photographer and former attorney, Chris Gillett. Chris shares his journey from a 19-year career in commercial litigation to becoming one of the most sought-after photographers for legal professionals. We discuss the importance of headshots in legal marketing, the psychology behind facial expressions, and why so many professional photos miss the mark. Along the way, Chris critiques our own headshots, offers invaluable tips for looking your best in photos, and even shares some of the strangest client requests he's encountered. If you've ever wondered what makes a great professional headshot—or if you're just here for the banter—this is an episode you won't want to miss!

Show Notes:

00:00 - Introduction to the episode and guest, Chris Gillett 00:41 - Co-hosts Bill, Peter, and Kyle introduce Chris and talk about their own legal headshot experiences 02:08 - Chris shares his background as a former attorney and how he transitioned to photography 03:27 - The business of legal headshots: How Chris built his brand and why lawyers need great photos 04:47 - The psychology behind headshots: Confidence vs. likability in professional photos 08:14 - The worst headshots lawyers take and common mistakes to avoid 12:36 - Chris critiques the hosts' headshots (and Peter's questionable yellow tie) 16:05 - The impact of AI-generated headshots: Are they worth it? 20:31 - Weirdest client requests and horror stories from the studio 24:46 - Why lighting, camera angles, and posture are more important than the camera itself 29:55 - Leaving the law: Chris talks about the challenges and rewards of switching careers 35:10 - Advice for lawyers looking to improve their online presence 40:06 - Closing thoughts and how to book a session with Chris 42:30 - Outro and where to follow The Dirty Verdict for more episodes

Guest Links: 📸 Chris Gillett's Website: LikeTheRazor.com 📷 Instagram: @6illett

Follow The Dirty Verdict: 🎙️ YouTube: Subscribe Here 🎧 Spotify & Apple Podcasts 📱 Instagram, TikTok, Facebook

Don't forget to like, follow, and subscribe for more candid legal industry conversations with top professionals!

Dive into another compelling episode of the Dirty Verdict podcast where hosts Peter Taaffe and Bill Ogden, and Kyle Herbert, tackle a range of hot-button legal issues. This episode unpacks the intricate web of lawsuits involving big names like Jay-Z and Tony Buzbee, explores bizarre legal battles over marital aids, and shines a light on various court cases that stretch from coast to coast. With a mix of in-depth analysis and offbeat banter, our hosts take you behind the legal curtain to reveal the dynamics of high-profile litigations, corporate legal strategies, and the oddities of the law that don't make the headlines.

Show Notes:

1. Main Legal Discussions:
   • Jay-Z and Tony Buzbee Litigation: Insights into the ongoing high-profile legal battle, including recent developments and social media implications.
   • Obscure Legal Battle Over Marital Aids: A look into a Texas bill aiming to restrict sales of so-called obscene devices, highlighting the quirks and challenges of legislative language.
   • Corporate Legal Strategies: Analysis of lawsuits involving major corporations like Amazon and discussions on antitrust issues with large landlords.
2. Spotlight Cases:
   • Amazon Employee Litigation: Discussion on the allegations against Amazon for failing to protect an employee, leading to a serious legal and ethical dilemma.
   • Landry vs. Landry: A deep dive into the trademark dispute between a small distiller and a major corporate entity, exploring the implications of using one's own name in business.
3. Offbeat Legal Stories:
   • Bizarre case where a Texas man claims wrongful termination over his wife's adult videos.
   • Reflecting on the impact of celebrity-themed restaurants on legal practices and public safety.
4. Q&A Session:
   • The hosts answer listener-submitted questions, offering their insights and opinions on lesser-known legal issues.

Welcome to The Dirty Verdict Podcast - Season 3, Episode 1. In this episode, hosts Peter Taaffe, Kyle Herbert, and Bill Ogden dive deep into the critical issue of human trafficking with their special guest, Jennifer Hohman. Jennifer is an experienced advocate and former tech professional with a powerful passion for ending human trafficking. With her unique perspective on the intersection of law, advocacy, and technology, Jennifer shares her journey from oil and gas to fighting for victims of exploitation, highlighting the challenges and legal hurdles along the way. This episode is both informative and engaging, as Jennifer offers insight into the complex world of trafficking and provides invaluable advice for parents and communities working to protect the vulnerable.

Show Notes:

• 0:00 - Introduction to Hosts: Meet Peter Taaffe, mediator; Kyle Herbert, plaintiff attorney; and Bill Ogden, nationally awarded traveler and partner at Fair and Ball.
• 2:00 - Guest Introduction: Jennifer Hohman shares her background in IT and tech, her transition to anti-human trafficking advocacy, and her deep commitment to legislative change.
• 5:00 - Human Trafficking Awareness: Jennifer opens up about the shocking real-life stories of human trafficking in Texas, discussing how young victims are often groomed online.
• 8:00 - Grooming and Exploitation: Understanding the insidious tactics traffickers use, including social media platforms like Snapchat and Instagram, and how young people are vulnerable to exploitation.
• 13:00 - The Role of Technology: A discussion on the evolving role of technology in both facilitating and combating trafficking, from AI-driven algorithms to monitoring social media.
• 18:00 - Legislative Advocacy: Insight into the bills Jennifer has worked on to combat trafficking and support victims, including the "FOSTA-SESTA" bill and local efforts in Texas.
• 24:00 - The Fight for Victims: Jennifer talks about the challenges of securing restorative care and therapeutic services for trafficking survivors, especially in a state with limited resources.
• 30:00 - Tips for Parents: Key advice for parents on how to protect their children from falling prey to traffickers, including monitoring social media and having open conversations.
• 35:00 - How You Can Help: Jennifer shares how individuals can get involved, support organizations, and advocate for legislative changes that protect victims and prevent trafficking.

Join us as we explore the hard truths of trafficking, the legal complexities, and how we can all take action to end this crime.

Dive into an enthralling episode of the Dirty Dirty Podcast where hosts Peter Taaffe, Bill Ogden and Kyle Herbert are joined by former Bachelor contestant Erica Rose Sanders and her husband Chuck Sanders. This episode seamlessly blends the worlds of legal battles and reality TV stardom, offering unique insights into the intersection of media, law, and personal anecdotes. From serious legal discussions to light-hearted banter about reality TV experiences, this episode covers a broad spectrum of topics with engaging dynamism.

Show Notes & Timestamps

• [00:00:32] Introduction to the episode's theme and guests.
• [00:03:21] Meet the hosts: Peter Taaffe, Bill Ogden and Kyle Herbert, their backgrounds in litigation and their views on the current episode.
• [00:05:20] Guests Erica Rose Sanders and Chuck Sanders share their journey from reality TV to law.
• [00:10:45] Discussion on the influence of media exposure on professional careers in law.
• [00:15:30] Insights into combining legal careers with reality TV fame.
• [00:20:50] The personal side of being a lawyer and reality TV star.
• [00:25:10] Chuck and Erica talk about family dynamics and balancing professional life with parenthood.
• [00:30:55] Experiences from specific cases handled by the Sanders in personal injury and family law.
• [00:40:40] The implications of reality TV on personal and professional lives.
• [00:45:55] Future aspirations in law and potential media appearances.
• [00:50:30] Closing thoughts and where to find more about the Rose Sanders Law Firm.

Guest Contact

Website: Rose Sanders Law Firm

Connect with Us

• Instagram: @DirtyDirtyPodcast
• Youtube, Spotify & Apple Podcasts: The Dirty Dirty Podcast

This episode offers a compelling look at how personal experiences shape professional life and vice versa, enriched with humorous anecdotes and serious reflections alike.

This episode features a riveting interview with Chris Tritico, a lawyer whose remarkable career and personal stories intersect with some of the most high-profile legal battles in American history. From his early days working with iconic criminal defense attorneys to handling landmark cases and personal tragedy, Tritico shares insights and reflections on a lifetime in law.

Show Notes

1. Introduction to Chris Tritico:
   • Background in law, influenced by legendary figures in the field.
   • His decision to become a lawyer shaped by early experiences and mentors.
2. Major Cases and Legal Career Highlights:
   • Details of significant cases Chris has worked on, including his representation of high-profile clients and involvement in notorious legal battles.
   • Discussion on the defamation case he recently filed, exploring the complexities of such lawsuits.
3. Impact of Personal Experiences on Professional Life:
   • Chris recounts how personal encounters and tragedies, including the death of his daughter, have influenced his legal philosophy and advocacy for justice.
4. Educational and Career Development:
   • Chris's journey through law school and his rapid ascent in the legal world.
   • Insights into his educational background and early career decisions.
5. Legal Strategies and Philosophy:
   • An in-depth look at Chris's approach to law, including his strategies in high-stakes trials and his views on the constitutional rights of the accused.
6. Contributions to Education and Law:
   • Chris's work with teacher unions and his significant contributions to educational law.
   • Discussion on the administrative and legal challenges faced by educators and how Chris has addressed them.
7. Charitable Efforts and Community Engagement:
   • Introduction to the Maria Tritico Project, a charity founded in memory of his daughter, focusing on the causes she cared about.
   • Chris's involvement in community and charitable activities as a way to honor his daughter's legacy.
8. Reflections and Future Outlook:
   • Chris reflects on the evolution of the legal field, the impact of technology on practice, and his future plans in law and advocacy.
9. Q&A Segment:
   • The hosts field listener questions about Chris's career, high-profile cases, and legal opinions.
10. Closing Remarks:
    • Summary of key points discussed and a teaser for upcoming episodes focusing on other legends in the legal field.

Follow-Up: The podcast encourages listeners to follow their YouTube, Instagram, and Spotify pages for more insightful discussions and updates on future episodes.

Welcome to another lively episode of the Dirty Verdict Podcast! This week, Peter Taaffe, Kyle Herbert, and Bill Ogden tackle an array of intriguing legal stories with their signature mix of insight and humor. Joined by PR expert Amanda, the crew dives deep into the intersection of civil and criminal law, celebrity lawsuits, and fascinating cases making waves in the legal world. From Sean "P Diddy" Combs' ongoing legal battles to flaming cocktails causing disasters, this episode has something for everyone. Don't forget to follow us on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and wherever you get your podcasts!

Show Notes:

1. Introduction (0:00 - 4:00)
   • Kicking off the episode with introductions and setting the stage for legal discussions.
   • Special guest Amanda joins to provide her PR expertise.
2. Sean "P Diddy" Combs Legal Troubles (4:01 - 15:30)
   • Discussion on criminal and civil allegations against P Diddy.
   • Insight into Tony Buzbee's role and his high-profile representation of multiple claimants.
   • Speculations about unnamed celebrities potentially implicated.
3. The Flaming Pineapple Lawsuit (15:31 - 25:00)
   • Details of a Dallas couple suing a bar over burns caused by a flaming cocktail.
   • Discussion about bar liability and safe practices in serving novelty drinks.
4. Helicopter Crash Lawsuit (25:01 - 30:00)
   • Updates on a tragic helicopter crash in East Downtown Houston.
   • Lawsuits filed by prominent law firms Randy Sorrels and Benny Agosto.
5. McIntyre's Wrongful Death Suit (30:01 - 40:00)
   • Analysis of a wrongful death case involving a patron over-served at a Heights bar and found in the Ship Channel days later.
   • Challenges of proving causation and bar responsibilities.
6. Celebrity Legal Drama (40:01 - 50:00)
   • Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie's vineyard dispute.
   • Parol evidence rule and its application in oral agreements.
7. Election Results and Local Legal Updates (50:01 - 60:00)
   • Reflection on recent election results and success stories of Dirty Verdict Podcast guests.
   • Updates on Christian Menefee's work tackling price gouging and title fraud cases.
8. Twitter's Forum Selection Clause (60:01 - 65:00)
   • Discussion on X/Twitter's updated forum selection clause and potential motivations.
9. Final Thoughts and Farewell (65:01 - 70:00)
   • Recap of major topics discussed.
   • Light-hearted banter and closing remarks.
   • Reminders to follow and subscribe on all platforms.

In this powerful and deeply personal episode, Peter, Kyle, and Bill welcome attorney Michelle Acosta to share her extraordinary journey. From advocating for others as a personal injury lawyer to becoming a plaintiff herself, Michelle's story highlights resilience, the fight for justice, and navigating a legal system that sometimes falls short.

Michelle recounts her harrowing experiences, including a shocking courthouse incident involving another attorney, and the challenges she faced in holding him accountable. Her determination to stand up for herself—motivated by her role as a mother and attorney—led to a landmark civil trial that resulted in a $5 million jury award for mental anguish.

Join us as we delve into Michelle's journey, the support she received from her legal team, and her message for other women in the legal profession. Michelle's story is a testament to courage, persistence, and the power of using the civil justice system to demand accountability.

Show Notes

In This Episode:

• [00:00] Introductions: Hosts Peter Taaffe, Kyle Herbert, and Bill Ogden kick off the episode.
• [03:20] Guest Introduction: Michelle Acosta, personal injury attorney and advocate from Houston, Texas.
• [10:15] Michelle's background: From a diplomat's daughter to a lawyer and mother of two.
• [25:40] The courthouse incident: Michelle's shocking first experience as an attorney representing her brother.
• [42:50] Taking a stand: Reporting the incident and the legal challenges faced in the aftermath.
• [55:30] The civil trial: Facing defamation claims, discovery battles, and securing a jury award.
• [1:12:10] Lessons learned: Using personal experiences to connect with clients and advocate for justice.
• [1:25:00] Advice for others: Michelle shares insights for women in law and how to stand up against misconduct.

Key Takeaways:

• Michelle's reflections on navigating the legal system as both an attorney and plaintiff.
• Insights into the challenges of addressing misconduct in the legal profession.
• The importance of support networks and allies in fighting for justice.

Connect with Us:

• Follow Michelle Acosta at Amaro Law Firm.
• Listen to more episodes of The Dirty Verdict Podcast on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and other platforms.
• Stay updated on Instagram @DirtyVerdictPodcast and Twitter @DirtyVerdict.