Send us a text

Imagine the horror of discovering an entire family has vanished without a trace. This chilling reality is the focus of our latest episode, where we explore the McStay family disappearance and the eerie chain of events that followed. Unravel the web of tension between Joseph McStay and his business partner, Daniel Kavanaugh, as we delve into their disputes and a mysterious $3,000 payment. But that's just the tip of the iceberg - join us as we investigate other suspects and the heartbreaking discovery of the family's remains.

What could drive someone to confess to such a heinous crime? Our journey into this tragic case reveals the shocking allegations against Dan Kavanaugh, his relationship with Tracy, and her statement to the police about his alleged confession. Furthermore, we examine the strange actions of Chase Merritt, Joseph's last phone contact, who wrote himself $23,000 worth of checks from Joseph's QuickBooks account. This twisted tale is filled with unexpected turns and sinister motives - don't miss it.

In the thrilling conclusion of this haunting episode, we analyze the puzzling evidence and contradictory statements. We discuss the security footage used as evidence and the intriguing testimony from Chase Merritt's sister. As we put the pieces together, prepare to be left with lingering questions and a chilling sense of unease. Join us on this captivating journey into the McStay family disappearance.

Support the show

If you’re interested in receiving bonus episodes, early release dates, an everything scary sticker and ‘thank you’ as well as a shout out on our regular feed! Please join at Patreon//everythingscarypod571