Leigh Marine Occhi was a 13-year-old girl who vanished from her home in Tupelo, Mississippi, in August 1992 at the start of Hurricane Andrew. Blood was left behind in her home, indicating that a sinister series of events had led to Leigh’s disappearance. At the center of the suspect list are multiple individuals Leigh knew, which leaves the unsettling question: What really happened to Leigh Occhi?

Send us a text

Patrick Warren and David Spencer were best friends who vanished in 1996 from Birmingham, England. Boxing Day was the last time the eleven and thirteen-year-old boys were seen, after stopping at a petrol station. But they never made it home that night. Even more chilling is that a serial child predator lived in the area. Join us as we dive into the evidence and theories of Patrick and David’s fate. 

Send us a text

Brian Shaffer was a 27-year-old medical student at Ohio State University when he vanished without a trace after a night out at the Ugly Tuna Saloona bar. The circumstances of his disappearance are baffling as no one can determine how Brian went missing from the bar. To this day what happened to Brian remains a mystery. 

Send us a text

On Thanksgiving Day, 1991, what was supposed to be a day filled with family and yummy food, instead turned into a nightmare when Omaima Nelson brutally murdered her husband, Bill Nelson. She dismembered his body and attempted to dispose of the remains in horrifying ways. Tune in to hear the full, unnerving details of what Omaima Nelson did on that fateful Thanksgiving day. 

Send us a text

Luis Garavito was one of the most prolific serial killers in history. Known as 'La Bistia' or 'The Beast,' Garavito's reign of terror spanned decades, during which he tortured, raped, and murdered nearly 200 children in Colombia. Listener discretion is strongly advised due to graphic content.

Send us a text

Lisa Au was a 19-year-old hairdresser from Oahu, Hawaii, who disappeared in January 1982. She was driving home in the rain after meeting with her boyfriend, Doug Holmes. By the next day, she had not returned home, and her car was found abandoned on the road home. Ten days later her body was discovered, and police looked into various suspects, including Doug and one of their own. Join us as we dive into the different suspects and theorize how Lisa was kidnapped from her car. 

Send us a text

In this episode we look into the chilling true crime story of Ken Rex McElroy. On July 10, 1981, McElroy was shot dead in broad daylight in Skidmore, Missouri, with sixty witnesses to his murder, yet the perpetrator remains unknown to this day. Uncover the sinister life of McElroy, a notorious local tyrant and criminal who intimidated an entire town for decades. Learn about his countless felonies, his bizarre and violent behavior following a head injury, and the community's ultimate decision to take justice into their own hands. Despite the involvement of law enforcement and the FBI, the town's residents have kept a steadfast silence about the killer's identity, creating a legacy shrouded in mystery and fear. Listen to all the shocking details and untold truths about a town united by their fear of one man.

Send us a text

On Halloween night in 1974, 8-year-old Timothy O’Bryan went trick or treating with a group of family and friends. But Timothy wouldn’t survive the night. His trick-or-treating would prove fatal after consuming a Pixy Stix before bed. This led police on a chase to find the person responsible for poisoning Timothy’s Pixy Stix, which we dive into on this Halloween special episode.

Send us a text

The baffling 1986 disappearance of 10-year-old Juan Pedro Martinez Gomez in Spain is considered by Interpol as one of the strangest disappearance cases in Europe. It begins with a horrific truck accident involving sulphuric acid in the remote Somosierra Mountain Pass but quickly spirals into a maze of unanswered questions and eerie theories. From suspicious sightings of a mysterious foreign couple in a white Nissan van to trace amounts of heroin found in the truck, each clue adds another layer to this enduring enigma. Eyewitness accounts, potential drug smuggling, and possible abductions are meticulously examined, with investigators retracing the family's last steps and exploring every twist. Tune in to uncover the chilling details and conflicting reports that continue to perplex investigators and the public decades later.

Send us a text

In 1991 at an Austin, Texas Frozen Yogurt Shop, 4 teenage girls were killed. The yogurt shop was then set on fire, and their bodies burned with it. The deaths of Amy Ayers, Eliza Thomas, Jennifer Harbison, and Sarah Harbison led to decades of baffling details and unanswered questions despite the FBI’s involvement. This case is full of investigative flaws and demonstrates organized behavior by the suspects. Despite breakthroughs in DNA testing, this chilling case still remains unsolved. 

Send us a text