In this episode we dive into the two most puzzling pieces of the Nicholas Cordova case. First, we examine the odd forensic clues—cash envelopes, phones, and a potato used as a makeshift silencer—found in the 300‑page police report, and the mysterious internal surveillance footage that the department has kept under lock and key. Then we follow Alysha Cordova’s relentless “Noise for Nick” campaign, from phone‑tree rallies to town‑council pleas, as the family keeps the case alive and the reward climbs to $20,000. Listeners learn why the suspects’ identities remain hidden, what the evidence may reveal about a possible hired‑gun operation, and how the Cordova family is demanding answers five years after the fatal FaceTime call.

In this deep‑dive, we follow the harrowing journey of Sheila and Katherine Lyon—from their innocent walk to a Maryland mall, through weeks of hidden captivity in a Hyattsville basement, to their brutal murders and the charred remains scattered on Virginia’s Taylor’s Mountain. Using never‑before‑heard police interviews, forensic discoveries, and the relentless work of a cold‑case unit, the episode unpacks how investigators finally secured a conviction against Lloyd Lee Welch Jr. despite never recovering the girls’ bodies, shedding new light on one of America’s most enduring true‑crime mysteries.

In this deep‑dive episode we peel back the layers of Ellen Rae Greenberg’s 2011 death, dissecting the forensic evidence that challenges the police’s “locked‑door suicide” narrative. From impossible self‑inflicted stab wounds and post‑mortem injuries to the contested latch mechanism, expert testimony, and the family’s relentless 14‑year fight for truth, we explore why the suicide ruling feels more like a cover‑up than a conclusion. Join us as we follow the trail of new DNA, neuropathology, and legal battles that have finally forced a re‑examination of the case, leaving listeners to ask: Who really killed Ellen Greenberg?

In this episode of The Evidence Locker, we trace the chilling 1927 kidnapping and murder of 12‑year‑old Marion Parker. From the deceptive “messenger” who lured her from school, through the grotesque ransom‑note game played by the kidnapper “The Fox,” to the macabre reconstruction of her body and the massive manhunt that ended with William Edward Hickman’s capture, trial, and execution, we examine how this case reshaped police procedures, school security, and even inspired early commentary from Ayn Rand. The story unfolds as a stark reminder of how a single crime can alter an entire city’s sense of safety.

In this deep‑dive episode of The Evidence Locker, we travel back to the chilling winter of 1976‑77 in Oakland County, Michigan, where four pre‑teen children were abducted, held captive, and brutally murdered. Through meticulous reconstruction of each victim’s case—Mark Stebbins, Jill Robinson, Kristine Mihelich, and Timothy King—we explore the forensic clues, the massive multi‑agency task force, and the early investigative missteps that still haunt the investigation. Listeners will meet the most prominent suspects—Arch Sloan, Christopher Busch, James Gunnels, and the enigmatic “Jeff/Bob”—and hear the unsettling theories of a pedophile ring, a possible ritual motive, and claims of a cover‑up. We also hear from the families who have fought for justice for decades, the impact the murders had on an entire community, and why modern DNA genealogy could finally break the case.

In this inaugural “Solved Saturday” episode of The Evidence Locker, we trace the rise and fall of every theory that swirled around the 2009 disappearance of 17‑year‑old Brittanee Drexel—from runaway speculation and a sensational “stash‑house” tale to the wrongful accusation of Timothy Taylor. We follow the relentless work of her mother Dawn, the false leads generated by a jailhouse informant, and the media frenzy that turned a missing‑person case into a myth. Then we dive into the forensic turning point: renewed analysis of Brittanee’s cell‑phone pings, surveillance footage, and the identification of a 1998 Ford Explorer that led investigators back to registered sex offender Raymond Moody.

In this episode of The Evidence Locker we travel back to July 1874, when four‑year‑old Charley Ross vanished from his Philadelphia front yard after being lured into a buggy with candy and fireworks. What follows is America’s first nationwide kidnapping‑for‑ransom case—a story that sparked a massive Pinkerton‑led manhunt, the birth of the “don’t take candy from strangers” warning, and the first legal reforms that made kidnapping a felony.

In this 40‑minute deep‑dive, we retrace the frantic hours of December 26 1996—JonBenét Ramsey’s missing‑child call, the baffling ransom note, the compromised crime scene, and the shocking autopsy that revealed strangulation, a skull fracture, and a mysterious pineapple fragment. From there we untangle the four most compelling suspect theories that have haunted investigators for three decades.

We weigh the forensic clues, the psychological profiles, and the lingering “what‑ifs” that keep the case alive, while highlighting why each theory still feels both plausible and incomplete. Tune in for a balanced, evidence‑driven look at one of America’s most enduring true‑crime mysteries.

Leave us a review and let us know what unsolved or unresolved case you want us to cover next.

In this deep‑dive episode, we unravel the baffling seven‑year saga of nurse Cindy James—her relentless reports of stalking, mysterious attacks, fires, dead cats, and a final discovery that left investigators baffled. From the countless harassing phone calls and the gruesome hog‑tied body found in an abandoned lot, to the conflicting theories of suicide, murder, and a tragic self‑staging gone wrong, we examine every clue, every suspect, and every twist that has kept this case unsolved for over three decades. Join us as we explore the victims, the police, the private investigator, and the lingering “unknown event” that still haunts true‑crime fans—and why Cindy’s story matters today.

Open as Note

On a sweltering June afternoon in 1983, fifteen‑year‑old Emanuela Orlandi stepped out of her Vatican City apartment for a flute lesson and never returned. What began as a missing‑person case spiraled into a maze of terrorist ransom demands, mafia intrigue, secret Vatican dossiers, alleged sex‑party abductions, and a mysterious London letter that still haunts investigators. In this hour‑long deep‑dive, we trace every lead, explore every theory, and hear from the relentless Orlandi family, journalists, and experts who have kept the mystery alive for four decades. Join us as we pull back the heavy curtains of the Holy See to ask the question that still echoes through Rome’s streets: What really happened to Emanuela Orlandi?