The Evidence Locker examines two of Massachusetts’ most haunting unsolved murders. First, we trace the disappearance, discovery, and lingering mystery surrounding 16‑year‑old lifeguard Molly Bish, whose 2000 abduction sparked the state’s biggest search and an enduring fight for justice. Next, we uncover the tragic 1993 case of 10‑year‑old Holly Piirainen, whose body was found weeks later and whose unsolved killing still haunts the community. Finally, we explore the unsettling overlap between the two cases—similar locations, timelines, and suspects—including the men who have been investigated for both crimes.

In this episode of The Evidence Locker, we travel back to May 25,  1979, the day six‑year‑old Etan Patz vanished from a Manhattan sidewalk and sparked a national movement. We trace the frantic early search, the rise of milk‑carton alerts, the decades‑long hunt for a killer, the controversial confession and conviction of Pedro Hernández, and the recent appellate reversal that has thrown the case back into legal limbo. Along the way, we explore how Etan’s disappearance reshaped law‑enforcement protocols, inspired the founding of the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children, and forever altered the way America protects its children—while his family still seeks closure.

In December 1964, the quiet suburb of Garfield Heights, Ohio, was shattered by the brutal murder of 16-year-old Beverly Ann Jarosz, a sophisticated student with a passion for Shakespeare and classical music. Found stabbed approximately 40 times and strangled in her own bedroom, Beverly's case quickly became one of Northeast Ohio's most enduring mysteries.

This episode dives into the original investigation, revealing the bizarre clues: threatening gifts from a secret admirer, loud rock music heard over frantic thumps, and conflicting timelines surrounding the discovery of the body. We examine the early suspects, including a former boyfriend who passed a questionable polygraph, a neighbor who died by suicide just two weeks later, and the chilling, unverified jailhouse confession that pointed to a lost murder weapon.

This episode delves into the profoundly tragic and unsolved murder of Wilma June Nissen, a case that spanned nearly three decades before the victim was even identified, now, five decades after her mother, Krissi Atkinson is pushing for answers.

This two-part investigative episode delves into the mysterious disappearances of two young Indigenous girls whose cases share striking and tragic similarities, becoming painful symbols of unsolved violence across North America.

Part One: Anthonette Cayedito (New Mexico, 1986)On an April night in 1986, nine-year-old Anthonette Cayedito vanished from her Gallup, New Mexico home. While authorities treated the case as an immediate abduction, the investigation quickly centered on the chaos and inconsistencies surrounding the adults in the house. We explore the terrifying 40-second phone call allegedly made by Anthonette a year later, the suspicious polygraph failure of her mother, and the decades of uncertainty that followed.

Part Two: Tamra Keepness (Saskatchewan, 2004)Eighteen years later, five-year-old Tamra Keepness vanished from her Regina, Saskatchewan home after a night marked by fighting and confusing timelines. Her disappearance triggered the largest search in the city's history and placed intense police scrutiny on the three adults present. We examine the details of the chaotic home environment, the mother's enduring pain and criticism of the initial police response, and why investigators remain convinced that someone close to Tamra holds the key to her fate.This episode explores the agonizing parallels between these two cases, highlighting the overwhelming burden of grief and the ongoing quest for justice in cases linked to the crisis of missing and murdered Indigenous women and girls.

In February 1989, 20-year-old University of Florida student Tiffany Sessions went for an evening walk and vanished without a trace . For 25 years, her family searched for answers while the case grew cold, leaving investigators with a thousand dead-end leads and no suspect . The puzzle of Tiffany's disappearance seemed impossible to solve. But the key was hiding in a different cold case file.