
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


📍Orlando, Florida.
🎧 Chapter 7: The Final Trace of Michelle Parker
Hey True Crimers! Mckenzie is on vacation this week, but I didn't want the week to go by without bringing you your True Crime fix! So today, I’m bringing you a quick hit — a bite-sized case that’s just as chilling as our longer episodes, but short enough to squeeze into your morning commute!
Michelle Parker, a 33-year‑old Orlando mom of three, vanished on November 17, 2011—just hours after appearing on The People’s Court with her ex‑fiancé, Dale Smith. That afternoon, she dropped off her three‑year‑old twins at his condo and reportedly planned to run errands in her Hummer before heading to work—but she never showed up. The next day, her SUV was found abandoned; weeks later, her iPhone was discovered in a nearby lake. Orlando police named Smith the sole suspect, yet no charges have ever been filed. More than a decade later, her family still clings to hope—and the search continues.
🔗 Sources & Further Reading
• WESH Orlando – “Orlando mother disappeared… thirteen years later she still has not been found”
👉 https://www.wesh.com/article/orlando-mothers-case-still-unsolved-13-years-after-disappearance/62929947
• People Magazine – “Fla. Mom Appeared on ‘The People’s Court’, Then Vanished…”
👉 https://people.com/michelle-parker-missing-vanished-peoples-court-8747439
• Chip Chick – “She Vanished After Appearing on a Reality TV Show with Her Ex-Fiancé”
👉 https://www.chipchick.com/2024/11/she-vanished-after-appearing-on-a-reality-tv-show-with-her-ex-fiance
• Reddit Community Discussion
👉 https://www.reddit.com/r/TrueCrime/comments/u4zgth/after_appearing_on_the_peoples_court_in_2011
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
📍Great Bend, Kansas.
🎧 Chapter 6: The Final Trace at the Dolly Madison Bakery
On a quiet Sunday in 2002, 24-year-old Mandi Alexander arrived to open the Dolly Madison Bakery in Great Bend, Kansas. It was a simple routine—unlock the doors, start the coffee, prep for the day. But later that day., 79 year-old Mary Drake walked in, a customer, just there to buy a treat before heading home.
They never left the bakery.
That evening, a delivery driver would spot something that didn’t feel right: the bakery was locked—but Mary’s purse was sitting on the counter. Inside, police would uncover a crime scene that stunned the small town. Both women had been brutally murdered.
But more than two decades later, there’s still no suspect. No motive. No arrest. Just silence—and a case frozen in time.
What happened inside that bakery has never been uncovered.
🎙️ Listen to The Final Trace: The Dolly Madison Bakery — Streaming now on all Platforms
📰 News & Official Sources
1. Kansas Bureau of Investigation (KBI) Press Releases & Public Statements
• KBI DNA update & reward increase (November 2022)
• Reward: $17,000
• kbi.ks.gov
2. KAKE News
• “KBI releases new information in 2002 Great Bend double homicide”
• Includes statements from Mandi’s sister, reward info, and DNA details
• https://www.kake.com
3. Hutchinson News / Great Bend Tribune
• Early reporting on the murders and witness descriptions (2002–2003)
• Details of the composite sketch and investigation timelines
4. KWCH 12 News
• “Reward offered for information in Great Bend double murder” (2022)
• Interview excerpts with friends and family
• https://www.kwch.com
5. The Wichita Eagle
• Archival coverage from the early 2000s related to the case, including investigative delays and family pleas
6. Fox Kansas / KSNT
• “20 Years Later: The murders of Mandi Alexander and Mary Drake” (2022)
• Features quotes from Desiree Werth and KBI officials
• https://www.ksnt.com
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
📍 Columbia, South Carolina.
🎧 Chapter 5: The Final Trace of Zelig Williams
Zelig Williams was a force. A dancer. A teacher. A light in every room.
But on a quiet October morning in 2024… something shifted.
An SOS pinged to friends in New York.
His phone, wallet, and keys were later found inside his car—abandoned near a trailhead.
Zelig was nowhere to be found.
There were no signs of struggle. No goodbye. Just… silence.
🩰 He lit up the stage… and then vanished into the shadows.
🎧 Episode 5: The Final Trace of Zelig Williams — now streaming on all platforms
📚 Zelig Williams – Source Links
1. People Magazine – Former Hamilton Dancer Missing After SOS Alert
🔗 https://people.com/former-hamilton-dancer-missing-suspicious-sos-alert-8725585
2. People Magazine – Hugh Jackman Speaks Out on Zelig’s Disappearance
🔗 https://people.com/hugh-jackman-prays-safe-return-missing-broadway-dancer-zelig-williams-8727222
3. WYFF News – Zelig’s Mother Makes Emotional Plea
🔗 https://www.wyff4.com/article/search-missing-broadway-dancer-south-carolina/62627166
4. FITSNews – Detailed Breakdown of the Case and Location Conflicts
🔗 https://www.fitsnews.com/2024/10/22/unsolved-carolinas-zelig-williams-family-offers-reward/
5. ABC News – Kathy Williams’ Statement and Family History
🔗 https://abcnews.go.com/US/mom-missing-broadway-dancer-breaks-emotional-plea-return/story?id=114849317
6. WACH Fox – Press Conference: “He’s All I Got”
🔗 https://wach.com/news/local/zelig-williams-mother-pleads-for-help-in-search-for-missing-son
7. Broadway Dance Center – Zelig Williams Faculty Bio
🔗 https://www.stepsnyc.com/faculty/zelig-williams/
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
📍 Jackson, Mississippi.
🎧 Chapter 4: The Final Trace of Annie Hearin
In the summer of 1988, Annie Hearin — a 72-year-old philanthropist and beloved wife of a Mississippi millionaire — vanished from her home without a sound.
Her purse was still in the hallway.
Her shoes and glasses, untouched.
And by the front door… a typewritten ransom note,
full of spelling errors and veiled threats.
But this wasn’t a demand for money.
It was a demand for justice.
The names of twelve men were listed in the letter — all of them connected to a bitter business feud with Annie’s husband. The FBI would spend years unraveling what happened that day… and who might’ve held the grudge long enough to strike back.
Was it revenge?
A solo operation?
Or something even darker?
This is the chilling story of a Southern disappearance that was never meant to be solved the usual way —
because the person who paid the price…
was never the one being targeted.
-Stream Now -
🔎 Sources & Further Reading
1. Unsolved Mysteries Wiki – Annie Laurie Hearin
https://unsolvedmysteries.fandom.com/wiki/Annie_Hearin
2. WLBT – 3 On Your Side Investigates: The Disappearance of Annie Laurie Hearin
https://www.wlbt.com/story/35976670/3-on-your-side-investigates-cold-case-mystery-the-disappearance-of-annie-laurie-hearin/
3. Doe Network Case File #505DFMS – Annie Laurie Hearin
https://www.doenetwork.org/cases/505dfms.html
4. Justia – United States v. Winn (5th Cir. 1990)
https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/F2/915/1445/228172/
5. UPI Archives – Heiress Still Missing One Year After Kidnapping (1989)
https://www.upi.com/Archives/1989/07/26/Heiress-still-missing-one-year-after-kidnapping/3802617428800/
6. Los Angeles Times – Robert Hearin Dies Without Learning Fate of Kidnapped Wife
https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1990-12-09-mn-8472-story.html
📺 Additional/Corroborative Sources
• Reddit / TrueCrime thread – Local recollections of Annie’s case and the unresolved mystery
• Simpson County News “30-year-old mystery” – Reflective coverage on the enduring Cold Case ()
• Deseret News – Notes on his wealth, return of ransom checks, and ongoing trial developments ()
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
📍 Vincennes, Indiana.
🎧 Chapter 3: The Final Trace of Brent Brand
In the summer of 1986, 18-year-old Brent Brand attended a party in Vincennes, Indiana — and never made it home.
Eight days later, his body was found face down in a drainage ditch across state lines. No visible injuries. No clear cause of death.
A Priest had the answers... But would he talk?
What followed wasn’t just an investigation… it became a witch hunt. Over 30 witnesses were named — including police officers. Brent’s mother spent the rest of her life fighting for answers she never got.This is the case that haunts a town.And the silence still speaks volumes.
🎧 Listen now
📚 Sources for “The Final Trace: Brent Brand”
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
📍Sullivan, Indiana.
🎧 Chapter 2: The Final Trace of Rick Whitehead
He seemed to have it all - money, success a growing business. But just 2 months after finalizing a 5 million dollar life insurance policy... Rick Whitehead was murdered.
A man dead.
A fortune at stake.
And a trail of lies that would take years to unfold.
In this episode we follow the money trail, uncover what was happening behind the scenes and examine weather his death was a suicide, murder... or something far more sinister.
This is The Final Trace... of Rick Whitehead.
🔎 Sources for The Final Trace: Rick Whitehead
**Los Angeles Times Feature (July 1997)**
. 🔗 Read the LA Times piece
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
📍Los Angeles, California.
🎧 Chapter 1: The Final Trace of Michael Negrete
Michael William Negrete was 18 years old - a UCLA freshman, a talented musician, and by all accounts full of life. He played an online video game with a friend. Sent a quick email to his mom. Walked back to his dorm room down the hall and then... disappeared.
No sign of foul play. No cries for help. It was like he slipped through the cracks of reality - into thin air.
Some say he wandered off. Others believe he was taken. But in the 25 years since Michael vanished. Not a single clue has brought us closer to the truth.
This is the Final Trace... of Michael Negrete.
📝 Sources Used in The Final Trace of Michael NegreteDaily Bruin – “Nightly Bruin: The Unsolved Disappearance of Michael Negrete” (Dec 2024)
.
📎 Link: https://dailybruin.com/2024/12/12/nightly-bruin-the-unsolved-disappearance-of-michael-negrete-25-years-later
—
📎 Link: https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2001-apr-16-me-51723-story.html
📎 Link: https://www.reddit.com/r/UnresolvedMysteries/comments/180xok5/michael_negrete_question/
Los Angeles Times (April 2001) – “Missing Adults Leave Few Traces”Reddit (r/UnresolvedMysteries)
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
🎙️ Disappearances. Unsolved deaths. Cases that were technically “closed”… but never felt truly answered.
The Final Trace is a weekly true crime podcast that dives into the eerie, the unresolved, and the stories that still linger.
Hosted by Hopper Dailey and McKenzie, each episode explores a case that never quite left us — told with curiosity, empathy, and just the right amount of chills.
If you like quiet mysteries, haunting details, and a human voice behind every headline — you’re in the right place.
🎧 Subscribe now, and don’t miss the stories that won’t let go.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
From the publisher's feed
Ranked by our users in the last 21 days