Sergeant James Lee Haynes, a decorated U.S. Army officer who went missing in 1963 while hitchhiking home for Christmas. His daughters, Linda and Brenda, share their family's long struggle for answers and justice. They recount the circumstances of their father's disappearance, the various theories surrounding it, and the impact on their family. We get into witness accounts, the ongoing search for their father's remains, as well as the broader context of other disappearances linked to the so-called 'mad butcher of West Virginia.'