The Mental Matchup

This week on The Mental Matchup, we’re joined by Lysander Rehnstrom, a former walk-on at George Mason to Navy Men's Basketball Captain, and U.S. Marine Corps Ground Officer in training. Lysander shares his deeply personal journey with mental health: from growing up under pressure, navigating a life-threatening injury in high school, walking on at George Mason, and ultimately transferring to the Naval Academy.

He opens up about the mental toll of early expectations, the value of vulnerability, and the moments that nearly made him quit the sport he loves. Now a trained Peer Advisor and advocate, Lysander uses his platform to share that athletes are more than their stats — and that asking for help is a sign of strength.

We talk about:

Mental health challenges in high-performance environments

Impact of coaching and injury on athlete identity

The power of peer support in recovery

Connect with Morgan’s Message here
Follow Morgan’s Message on IG here

#168: In this episode of The Mental Matchup, we’re joined by Alex Heishman, a former DIII women’s lacrosse player, campus liaison for Morgan’s Message, and now a licensed social worker. Alex opens up about her 4+ year journey with Morgan’s Message and her own experience navigating mental health challenges as a student-athlete.

From battling self-criticism and panic attacks to a difficult coaching relationship that made her fall out of love with lacrosse, Alex shares her path to rediscovering joy, purpose, and identity — both on and off the field. Now working as a middle school counselor, she reflects on the importance of vulnerability, mental health advocacy, and the ongoing impact of Morgan’s Message.

Topics covered:

Mental health and sport performance

Navigating negative coaching relationships

Athlete burnout & recovery

Finding identity post-graduation

The power of sharing your story

Follow Morgan’s Message on IG here
Learn more about Morgan’s Message here

Catie-Reagan King, Ed.D., is the Director of Mental Health Education at the Cameron K. Gallagher Foundation. She joins The Mental Matchup to discuss the foundation and its resources, including free digital toolkits designed to support individuals and organizations focused on mental health. These toolkits offer practical strategies for starting conversations, coping with challenges, and creating supportive environments for those who are struggling.

Find out more about the CKG Foundation here

Find out more about the digital toolkits here

Follow the CKG Foundation on IG here

Find out more about Morgan's Message and submit your story here

Follow Morgan's Message on IG here

This week's guest is Lindsey Wilson, a mindset and mental performance coach best known as The Sports Hypnotist. With a professional basketball career spanning close to a decade, Lindsey took her knowledge of the mental game to work with collegiate athletes, professional athletes from Olympians and players in the NFL and WNBA all the way to youth athletes. 

She is the founder of Positive Performance and The Mindset Coach Academy where she helps aspiring mental performance coaches start their dream business and impact lives.  She’s also the author of the upcoming book Think Like an Athlete which teaches the critical and undertrained skill of belief and how to build it to be successful on the playing field and off.

Lindsey believes in the transformative power of sports and that coaches and athletes need simple, effective mental performance training tools that don’t take a lot of time. Her mission is to teach these tools so that coaches can have a massive impact on athletes performance, enjoyment of competing and life. 

On today's episode we discuss the power of the brain, visualization, goal setting and Lindsey's passion for helping athletes succeed. Listen to Episode 166 on Spotify and Apple Podcasts now!

Connect with Lindsey on IG here
Learn more about Positive Performance Training here
Connect with Morgan’s Message on IG here
Learn more about Morgan’s Message here

Redefining Strength: Megan Shaver on Recovery, Rowing & Changing the Culture

In this episode of The Mental Matchup, Kat chats with Megan Shawver, a former collegiate rower and current graduate student studying Nutrition and Dietetics. Megan shares her personal journey with disordered eating, her experience navigating mental health challenges as a student-athlete, and how finding supportive communities like Morgan’s Message helped shape her recovery.

From rowing at Franklin Pierce to pursuing a career in nutrition, Megan opens up about the realities athletes face, the connection between sport and disordered eating, and why it’s so important to challenge outdated cultural norms in athletics.

Find out more about Morgan’s Message here
Follow Morgan’s Message here

Catholic University field hockey player Mary Rojack joins us to talk about her journey with mental health, being part of the Morgan’s Message community, and the impact of building support both on and off campus. 💙

From New Jersey to Catholic U, Mary’s passion for advocacy and connection shines through. Tune in to hear her story!

Find out more about Morgan’s Message here
Follow Morgan’s Message here

In this episode, Kat chats with Clare Kehoe, the Director of Education and one of the co-founders of Morgan’s Message. Clare opens up about her friendship with Morgan Rodgers—the memories they shared, the support she tried to offer, and the heartbreak of losing someone you love to suicide. She shares what drove her to help launch Morgan’s Message and how that loss forever changed the direction of her life.

Through grief, Clare has built something deeply meaningful: a movement that empowers student-athletes to speak up, support one another, and normalize conversations around mental health. We dive into how the Ambassador Program was created, how it’s grown to over 1,500 campuses, and the role it plays in changing culture—one conversation at a time.

Learn more about Morgan’s Message here

Follow @morgansmessage on IG here

Apply to join or start an Ambassador Program at your school here

Marina Paul is the founder of SPRHRA, a women's sportswear brand built on real female athlete data. A former Division 1 soccer player and All-American at Georgetown University, Marina overcame significant challenges—depression, eating disorders, and ACL injuries—to become the program’s first-ever three-time captain, leading her team to the first-ever College Cup Final Four. Through SPRHRA and her advocacy, she is dedicated to empowering female athletes.

You can shop the SPRHRA x MM Short here

Find SPRHRA on IG here

Interested in Team Uniforms? You can find out more here

Connect with Morgan's Message on IG here

Learn more about Morgan's Message here

In this episode of The Mental Matchup, we sit down with Emma Kilbride, co-founder of Here for You Clothing, to talk about her lifelong journey with anxiety, depression, and tic disorder, and how stepping away from college became the turning point in her healing. Emma shares her raw and honest story of hitting pause on life as she knew it, doing the inner work through therapy and reflection, and ultimately rediscovering her purpose in mental health advocacy. Now, through Here For You Clothing, Emma is building community and connection through powerful storytelling and wearable reminders that no one is ever alone.

We discuss:

The reality of living with anxiety, depression, and tics

Why leaving college became a critical act of self-care

The healing power of therapy and community

How Emma turned pain into purpose through Here For You Clothing

Shop Here For You Clothing at hereforyouclothing.com
Use code MENTALMATCHUP for 20% off your order!
You can find here for you at @hereforyouclothing

Follow Morgan's Message at @morgansmessage
Learn more about Morgan's Message here

This week on The Mental Matchup, we sit down with Ben Redlener, a sophomore lacrosse player at Emerson College, to talk about the pressures that come with being a student-athlete—and the quiet battles that often go unseen.

Ben opens up about his mental health journey, reflecting on how constantly comparing himself to other athletes and peers impacted his confidence, academic life, and athletic performance. Through vulnerability and growth, Ben has found strength in accepting his own path and is now using his voice to support others doing the same.

In this episode, we cover:

The weight of comparison in athletics and life

The impact of self-doubt on performance and progress

Redefining success and self-worth as a student-athlete

Finding power in vulnerability and community

Listen to Ben's podcast Attolo here

Find out more about Morgan's Message here

Follow Morgan's Message on IG here