The Nonlinear Library

The Nonlinear Library

By The Nonlinear FundEducation
Download on the App Store

All The Nonlinear Library episodes

  • EA - Who's at fault for FTX's wrongdoing by EliezerYudkowsky
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Who's at fault for FTX's wrongdoing, published by EliezerYudkowsky on November 16, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Caroline Ellison, co-CEO and later CEO of Alameda, had a now-deleted blog, "worldoptimization" on Tumblr. One does not usually post excerpts from deleted blogs - the Internet has, of course, saved it by now - but it looks like Caroline violated enough deontology to be less protected than usual in turn, and also I think it's important for people to see what signals are apparently not reliable signs of honesty and goodness.
    In a post on Oct 10 2022, Caroline Ellison crossposted her Goodreads review of The Golden Enclaves, book 3 of Scholomance by Naomi Novik. Caroline Ellison writes, including very light / abstract spoilers only:
    A pretty good conclusion to the series.Biggest pro was the resolution of mysteries/open questions from the first two books. It wrapped everything up in a way that felt very satisfying.Biggest con was . I think I felt less bought into the ethics of the story than I had for the previous two books?The first two books often have a vibe of “you can either do the thing that’s easy and safe or you can do the thing that’s hard and scary but right, and being a good person is doing the right thing.” And I’m super on board with that.Whereas if I had to sum up the moral message of the third book I might go with “there is no ethical consumption under late capitalism.”
    For someone like myself, this is a pretty shocking thing to hear somebody say, on a Tumblr blog not then associated with their main corporate persona, not in a way that sounds like the usual performativity, not like it's meant to impress anybody (because then you're probably not writing about anything as undignified as fantasy fiction in the first place). It sounds like - Caroline might have been under the impression, as late as Oct 10, that what she was doing at FTX was the thing that's hard and scary but right? That she was doing, even, what Naomi Novik would have told her to do?
    The Scholomance novels feature a protagonist, Galadriel Higgins, with unusually dark and scary powers, with a dark and scary prophecy about herself, trying to do the right thing anyways and being misinterpreted by her classmates, in an incredibly hostile environment.
    The line of causality seems clear - Naomi Novik, by telling her readers to do the right thing, probably contributed to Caroline Ellison doing what she thought was the right thing - misusing Alameda's customer deposits. Furthermore, the Scholomance novels romanticized people with dark and scary powers, and those people not just immediately killing themselves in the face of a prophecy that they'd do immense harm later, i.e., sending the message that it's okay for them to take huge risks with other people's interests.
    I expect this to be a very serious blow to Naomi Novik's reputation, possibly the reputation of fantasy fiction in general. The now-deleted Tumblr post is tantamount to a declaration that Caroline Ellison was doing this because she thought Naomi Novik told her to. We can infer that probably at least $30 of Scholomance sales are due to Caroline Ellison, and with the resources that Ellison commanded as co-CEO of Alameda, some unknown other fraction of Scholomance's entire revenues could have been due to phantom purchases that Ellison funded in order to channel customer deposits to her favorite author.
    My moral here? It can also be summed up in an old joke that goes as follows: "He has no right to make himself that small; he is not that great."
    The best summary of the FTX affair that I've read so is Milky Eggs's "What Happened at Alameda Research?" If you haven't read it already, and you're at all interested in this affair, I recommend that you go read it right now.
    Pieced together from various sources, including some alleged...
    10 min
  • EA - Assessing the case for population growth as a priority by Charlotte
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Assessing the case for population growth as a priority, published by Charlotte on November 15, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    We are assessing the case for population growth as a priority. Here is the Google Docs version if you prefer to read it as a document. Charlotte Siegmann and Luis Mota
    Summary
    Recently, population growth as a cause area has been receiving more attention (MacAskill, 2022, PWI, Jones, 2022a, Bricker and Ibbitson, 2019). We outline and discuss arguments making that case, and argue that population growth falls short of being a top cause area under the longtermism paradigm. But our main contribution may be to just outline and explain all considerations and arguments.
    We consider three value propositions of population growth, and argue that:
    Long-run population size is likely determined by factors apart from biological population growth rates. More
    Biological reproduction will be replaced if the future is to be large, which should nullify the effects of population growth in timescales larger than a thousand years.
    Assuming biological reproduction continues, long-run population size is only influenced by current population growth in particular scenarios.
    Population size may impact economic growth, but its long-run effects are comparatively small. More
    Population is one of the current drivers of economic growth.
    We argue that the probability and long-term harms of economic stagnation, such as moral regress, are overstated.
    We argue that the effects of economic growth on extinction risk are small.
    Population size has negligible effects on humanity’s resilience to catastrophes. More
    We think that the most compelling case for intervening on population growth comes from its effects on economic growth. Overall, while we think that increasing population growth rates is positive, the scale of its benefits appears to be orders of magnitude smaller than those of top cause areas.
    Introduction
    Today is the Day of Eight Billion, a day projected by the UN to be roughly the one in which the world human population reaches 8 billion people. The last time the world population increased by a round billion was 11 years ago, and the UN projection suggests that the world population will reach the 9 billion mark in 2037, and the 10 billion mark in the mid-2050s. This projection never gets to 11 billion, as it peaks at 10.4 billion during the 2080s and slowly declines throughout the last decades of this century. Other population projections predict an even earlier peak in the human population, which would happen before there are 10 billion of us (Lutz et al. 2018, Vollset et al. 2020).
    There is a reasonable amount of uncertainty about whether the peak will happen by the end of this century. In the UN projection, with a 5% probability, the population size will be larger than 12 billion by 2100. But fertility trends indicate that a peak will eventually happen. The world fertility rate has been declining since the 1960s and is expected to decline to the replacement level of 2.1 children per woman by the mid-century. Once it is below that point, growth would only be due to population momentum. This transition to below replacement levels of fertility is already on its way, as more than half of the world population lives in a country where fertility is already below the replacement rate.
    The expectation of a population decline raises the question: should population growth be a priority for actors wanting to do the most good? For one, a higher population might be desirable on its own. For example, according to the total view in population ethics, creating lives with positive wellbeing is good, all else equal. Moreover, population growth may also affect other variables of moral importance, such as economic growth (Jones, 2022b) and social and political norms (MacAskill 2022,...
    44 min
  • EA - Why didn't the FTX Foundation secure its bag? by Greg Colbourn
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Why didn't the FTX Foundation secure its bag?, published by Greg Colbourn on November 15, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    “Asked whether he had set up any kind of endowment for his giving, Mr. Bankman-Fried said in the Times interview last month: “It’s more of a pay-as-we-go thing, and the reason for that, frankly, is I’m not liquid enough for it to make sense to do an endowment right now.”” (Source (a))
    Quite apart from the fact that in hindsight, the above quote should’ve been ringing alarm bells, I think a big lesson here is that foundations should "secure their bags" – aka secure assets/their endowment – early. The fact that the FTX Foundation didn't do this is a massive loss - for the world, EA, and FTX creditors. It's not even just about fraud or bankruptcy risk. Basic risk management would suggest that it should be done to hedge against the possibility of the major donors' wealth diminishing for any reason.
    This is a massive risk management failure from the high level EA community point of view of doing good with the money. Equity, or crypto, should've been donated to the foundation, and sold for cash by it. And the foundation should've been controlled by people who weren't FTX/Alameda! As a community, we put way too much faith and trust in those who owned/controlled FTX/Alameda, and insufficient effort into pressing for commitments to be secured. Trust, but verify.
    As I understand it, OpenPhil has a few $B that is theirs, under independent legal control (i.e. separate from Moskovitz and Tuna, who, whilst being board members, do not have unilateral control of the funds; they make up ⅖ of the board).
    The point I'm making here is bigger than just the loss of current promised grants. It's about making sure that money is secured when pledges are made, to minimise the risks of losing it. Otherwise the pledges don't count for much (as we can see here). If Moskovitz and Tuna went down now, OpenPhil would still have $Bs at its disposal. Sure, funds might be frozen for some amount of time (if the donors went bankrupt), but it is very unlikely that they would be lost.
    For a much smaller example, I can attest that with CEEALAR (the org I founded), we set up a charity, for which I only control ⅓ (i.e. the other two Trustees could out vote me), and I have donated the building to the charity. It can go on without me.
    Regarding any moral/PR risks of the FTX Foundation spending money now were it to have it; suppose the FTX Foundation was set-up like OpenPhil so it had at least $1B in assets that weren't under the control of SBF and his cronies. And suppose that money was made in a non-fraudulent way (which seems likely if it were to have been given last year, significantly before all the financial trouble started at FTX/Alameda). We would be in a much better position now even from the point of view of wanting (or being compelled) to use the money to pay back FTX creditors (i.e. there would be significantly more money for the creditors).
    In practice, maybe securing significant assets wasn’t really possible with the FTX Foundation, given the likely illiquid nature of any sizable assets that FTX/Alameda could’ve donated (e.g. FTT or FTX stock), which have now collapsed in value. But it still would’ve been a step in the right direction. Did anyone at the FTX Foundation or Future Fund, or others in advisory roles, press for this? A side benefit might’ve also been uncovering the fraud earlier and perhaps mitigating it somewhat.
    Although note that I can’t seem to find any public reference to the original source of the quote from “last month”.
    To use a phrase that is popular in crypto.
    See penultimate paragraph.
    I can imagine SBF saying something like the max-EV thing to do is keeping all the funds in the for-profit companies to maximise their growth, and the FTX Foundation / F...
    5 min
  • EA - Some research ideas in forecasting by Jaime Sevilla
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Some research ideas in forecasting, published by Jaime Sevilla on November 15, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    In the past, I have researched how we can effectively pool the predictions of many experts. For the most part, I am now focusing on directing Epoch and AI forecasting.
    However, I have accumulated a log of research projects related to forecasting. I have the vague intention of working on them at some point, but this will likely be months or years, and meanwhile I would be elated if someone else takes my ideas and develops them.
    And with the Million Predictions Hackathon by Metaculus looming, now seems a particularly good moment to write down some of these project ideas.
    Compare different aggregation methods
    Difficulty: easy
    The ultimate arbiter of what aggregation works is what performs best in practice.
    Redoing a comparison of forecast aggregation methods on metaculus / INFER / etc questions would be helpful data for that purpose.
    For example, here is a script I wrote to compare some aggregation methods, and the results I obtained:
    MethodWeightedBrier-logQuestionsNeyman aggregate (p=0.36)Yes0.1060.340899Extremized mean of logodds (d=1.55)Yes0.1110.350899Neyman aggregate (p=0.5)Yes0.1110.351899Extremized mean of probabilities (d=1.60)Yes0.1120.355899Metaculus predictionYes0.1110.361774Mean of logoddsYes0.1160.370899Neyman aggregate (p=0.36)No0.1200.377899MedianYes0.1210.381899Extremized mean of logodds (d=1.50)No0.1260.391899Mean of probabilitiesYes0.1220.392899Neyman aggregate (o=1.00)No0.1260.393899Extremized mean of probabilities (d=1.60)No0.1270.399899Mean of logoddsNo0.1300.410899MedianNo0.1340.418899Mean of probabilitiesNo0.1380.439899Baseline (p = 0.36)N/A0.2300.652899
    It would be straightforward to extend this analysis with new questions that resolved since then, other dataset or new techniques.
    Literature review of weight aggregation
    Difficulty: easy
    When aggregating forecast, we usually resort to formulas like ∑iailogo1, where oi are the individual predictions (expressed in odds) and ai the weights assigned to each prediction.
    Right now I have a lot of uncertainty about what are the best theoretical and empirical approaches to assigning weights to predictions. These could be based on factors like the date of the prediction, the track record of the forecaster or other factors.
    The first step would be to a literature review of schemes to weigh the predictions of experts when aggregating, and compare them using Metaculus data.
    Comparing methods for predicting base rates
    Difficulty: medium
    Using historical data is always a must when forecasting.
    While one can rely on intuition to extract lessons from the past, it is often convenient to have some rules of thumb that inform how to translate historical frquencies to baserate probabilities.
    The classical method in this situation is Laplace's rule of succession. However, we showed that this method gives inconsistent results when trying to apply it to observations over a time period, and we proposed a fix here.
    Number of observed successes S during time TProbability of no successes during t timeS=0(1+tT)−1S>0
    (1+tT)−S if the sampling time period is variable
    (1+tT)−(S+1) if the sampling time period is fixed
    While theoretically appealing, we did not show that employing this fix actually improves performance, so there is a good research opportunity for someone to collect data and investigate this.
    Decay of predictions
    Difficulty: medium
    Imagine I predict that no earthquakes will happen in Chile before 2024 with 60% probability today. Then in April 2023, if no earthquakes have happened, my implied probability should be lower than 60%.
    Theoretically, we should be derive the implied probabability under some mild assumptions that the probability was uniform over time, maybe following a framework like the time-...
    9 min
  • EA - Selective truth-telling: concerns about EA leadership communication. by tcelferact
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Selective truth-telling: concerns about EA leadership communication., published by tcelferact on November 15, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Intro
    I have had concerns about EA leadership communication as long as I've known about EA, and the FTX meltdown has persuaded me I should have taken them more seriously.
    (By leadership I mean well-known public-facing EAs and organizations.)
    This post attempts to explain why I'm concerned by listing some of the experiences that have made me uncomfortable. tl;dr: EA leadership has a history of being selective in the information they share in a way that increases their appeal, and this raises doubts for me over what was and wasn't known about FTX.
    I do not think I'm sharing any major transgressions here, and I suspect some readers will find all these points pretty minor.
    I'm sharing them anyway because I'm increasingly involved in EA (two EAGs and exploring funding for an EA non-profit) and I've lost confidence in leadership of the movement. A reflection on why I've lost confidence and what would help me regain it seems like useful feedback, and it may also resonate with others.
    i.e. This is intended to be a personal account of why I'm lacking confidence, not an argument for why you, the reader, should also lack confidence.
    2014: 80K promotional event in Oxford.
    I really wish I could find/remember more concrete information on this event, and if anyone recognizes what I'm talking about and has access to the original promotional material then please share it.
    In 2014 I was an undergraduate at Oxford and had a vague awareness of EA and 80,000 hours as orgs that cared about highly data-driven charitable interventions. At the time this was not something that interested me, I was really focussed on art!
    I saw a flyer for an event with a title something like 'How to be an artist and help improve the world!' I don't remember any mention of 80K or EA, and the impression it left on me was 'this is an event on how to be a less pretentious version of Bono from U2'. (I'm happy to walk all of this back if someone from 80K still has the flyer somewhere and can share it, but this is at least the impression it left on me.)
    So I went to the event, and it was an 80K event with Ben Todd and Will MacAskill. The keynote speaker was an art dealer (I cannot remember his name) who talked about his own career, donating large chunks of his income, and encouraging others to do the same. He also did a stump speech for 80K and announced ~£180K of donations he was making to the org.
    This was a great event with a great speaker! It was also not remotely the event I had signed up for. Talking to Ben after the event didn't help: his answers to my questions felt similar to the marketing for the event itself, i.e. say what you need to say to get me in the door. (Two rough questions I remember: Q: Is your approach utilitarian? A: It's utilitarian flavoured. Q: What would you say to someone who e.g. really cares about art and doesn't want to earn to give? A: Will is actually a great example of someone I think shouldn't earn to give (he intended to at the time) as we need him doing philosophical analysis of the best ways to donate instead.)
    This all left me highly suspicious of EA, and as a result I didn't pay much attention to them after that for years. I started engaging again in 2017, and more deeply in 2021, when I figured everyone involved had been young, they had only been minorly dishonest (if I was even remembering things correctly), and I should just give them a pass.
    Philosophy, but also not Philosophy?: Underemphasizing risk on the 80K website
    My undergraduate degree was in philosophy, and when I started thinking about EA involvement more seriously I took a look at global priorities research. It was one of five top-recommended career paths on 80K's web...
    9 min
  • EA - Why you’re not hearing as much from EA orgs as you’d like by Shakeel Hashim
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Why you’re not hearing as much from EA orgs as you’d like, published by Shakeel Hashim on November 15, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Hi everyone — I wanted to update you about the sorts of communication you’ll expect to hear from EA leadership and EA organisations, and why this will probably be an intensely frustrating situation for all involved. For those that don’t know, I’m head of communications at CEA, and am working on Effective Ventures’ response to the current situation.
    In particular, I expect that in the short term you’ll get a lot less communication about things than you’d want. This is for a few reasons:
    Legal risk. It’s likely that there will be extensive legal proceedings around FTX that will drag on for a very long time. This means that anything that is said by anyone who is even tangentially involved is at risk of being scrutinised and multiply interpreted by dozens of people, including people whose role (rightly) is to advocate for their clients or those they represent.
    Lack of information. Everything has happened very quickly, and everyone is still trying to gather facts and figure out what’s going on. We don’t even fully know what we don’t know. So we’re figuring out things as we go, and don’t want to share information that might later turn out to be inaccurate.
    This is compounded by the fact that everyone is incredibly busy and dealing with a ton of different things (legal, financial, operational, management) all at once.
    This sucks. I really want to be saying everything on my mind right now, and I would love for other people at EA orgs to do the same. I also want to try to make sure people don’t say things they’ll regret in the years to come. But these are hard tradeoffs, and I’m not sure we’ll always get them right.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    2 min
  • EA - Friendship Forever (new EA cause area?) by rogersbacon1
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Friendship Forever (new EA cause area?), published by rogersbacon1 on November 15, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    I.
    I was surprised to learn recently that it was common for men in western cultures to hold hands throughout the 19th century, and that friendship for both men and women was generally valued much more highly than it is today, a time when people say things like “No New Friends” and this:
    Contrast this to:
    From the Civil War through the 1920′s, it was very common for male friends to visit a photographer's studio together to have a portrait done as a memento of their love and loyalty. Sometimes the men would act out scenes; sometimes they'd simply sit side-by-side; sometimes they'd sit on each other's laps or hold hands. The men's very comfortable and familiar poses and body language might make the men look like gay lovers to the modern eye — and they could very well have been — but that was not the message they were sending at the time... Because homosexuality, even if thought of as a practice rather than an identity, was not something publicly expressed, these men were not knowingly outing themselves in these shots; their poses were common, and simply reflected the intimacy and intensity of male friendships at the time — none of these photos would have caused their contemporaries to bat an eye.
    “Bosom Buddies: a Photo History of Male Affection”
    Photos of men with their wives, an often functional arrangement not rendered from romantic love, are often much less affectionate or loving. Women, too, thought of their best friends as more than what a husband could ever offer: loyal, supportive, sympathetic, clever, and funny. Same sex friendships were often considered the best relationships one had in life outside of one’s parents.
    “Men Holding Hands? Friendship in the 19th Century Was Quite Different”
    I'm not really sure why I was surprised that the friendship was regarded very different in the past—it seems obvious that romantic relationships have evolved considerably over time, for example. Maybe it’s just my personal ignorance (probably), but I have a suspicion that something deeper is going on here, a kind of blind spot that we have surrounding friendship, a under-appreciation for its importance in our lives that leads to a broader under-representation in the arts, politics, philosophy, and culture writ large.
    For instance, how often do we reflect on the fact that 65% of children up to the age of 7 have imaginary friends (“There is little research about the concept of imaginary friends in children's imaginations” according to Wikipedia,), or that adults, if desperate enough, will befriend inanimate objects such as volleyballs?
    The dynamic of friendship is almost always underestimated as a constant force in human life. A diminishing circle of friends is the first terrible diagnostic of a life in deep trouble: of overwork, of too much emphasis on a professional identity, of forgetting who will be there when our armoured personalities run into the inevitable natural disasters and vulnerabilities found in even the most average existence.
    David Whyte
    I suppose there is no a priori expectation for how much romantically-themed art there should be relative to friendship-themed art, but it’s hard not feel like there is a paucity of the latter (how many popular friendship songs can you think of besides this masterpiece?). The paucity of friendship-themed work may be even greater in “serious” intellectual domains; as one example, there is effectively no discussion of friendship amongst effective altruists (google it or search the effective altruism forum to see what I mean; what discussion does exist focuses on friendship as a tool for community building within EA, not as something that EA should focus on promoting in and of itself).
    Is it not strange that a phi...
    21 min
  • EA - Training for Good - Update & Plans for 2023 by Cillian Crosson
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Training for Good - Update & Plans for 2023, published by Cillian Crosson on November 15, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Summary
    Training for Good will now focus exclusively on programmes that enable talented and altruistic early-career professionals to directly enter the first stage of high impact careers.
    Concretely, we will only run the following programmes in Sep 2022 - Aug 2023:
    1. EU Tech Policy Fellowship.
    2. Tarbell Fellowship (journalism)
    3. An unannounced 3rd programme which is still under development
    Applications for the 2023 EU Tech Policy Fellowship are open until December 11. Apply here.
    In year 1, we experimented with ~7 different programmes, 6 of which have now been discontinued. This is largely because we believe that focus is important & wanted to double-down on the most promising programme we had identified thus far (the EU Tech Policy Fellowship which successfully placed 7 fellows in relevant European think tanks focused on emerging technology policy).
    We plan to have an external review of Training for Good conducted between July 2023 - December 2023. We will default to sharing this publicly.
    Introduction
    Training for Good is an impact-focused training organisation, incubated by Charity Entrepreneurship in 2021.
    Quite a lot has changed since our launch in September 2021. We considered our first year to be an exploratory period in which we ran many, many different projects. We’ve now discontinued the majority of these programmes and have narrowed our focus to running fellowships that directly place early-career individuals in impactful careers.
    Now that TFG has a clearer focus, we're writing this post to update others in the EA community on our activities and the scope of our organisation.
    What we do
    Training for Good runs fellowships that place talented professionals in impactful careers in policy, journalism & other areas. We do this by providing a combination of stipends, mentorship from experienced professionals, training and placements in relevant organisations.
    Between Sep 2022 - Aug 2023 (i.e. year 2), we plan to only run the following programmes:
    EU Tech Policy Fellowship
    Tarbell Fellowship
    An unannounced 3rd programme which is still under development
    Why this might be important
    Many high impact career paths are neglected by talented and altruistic people, often because they lack clear pathways for entry. This is limiting progress on some of the world’s most important problems: reducing existential risk, ending factory farming and tackling global poverty.
    TFG seeks to provide concrete opportunities for early-career professionals to gain entry level roles in impactful career paths that are difficult to enter. Building these talent pipelines could be important because:
    Direct progress on problems: Talented individuals in these career paths can directly contribute to progress on solving the world’s most important problems
    Closer towards the “ideal portfolio”: We mostly take a portfolio approach to doing good. One could imagine an optimal distribution of talent within the effective altruism community, which might involve people pursuing a variety of different career paths. With our fellowships, we are attempting to move the effective altruism community closer towards this ideal allocation by enabling people to pursue paths that we believe are currently underrepresented (and expect to remain so) within this community’s portfolio. We believe that thinking in these terms is particularly useful partly due to:
    Diminishing returns from certain career paths
    Epistemic uncertainty about which career paths are best (and the associated information value from reducing this uncertainty somewhat)
    Differing personal fit for individuals across different career paths
    Concrete opportunities: The number of people interested in effective altruism has been g...
    18 min
  • EA - Delay, Detect, Defend: Preparing for a Future in which Thousands Can Release New Pandemics by Kevin Esvelt by Jeremy
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Delay, Detect, Defend: Preparing for a Future in which Thousands Can Release New Pandemics by Kevin Esvelt, published by Jeremy on November 15, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    At EAGxBoston in April, I attended his talk of the same name (embedded below for those who prefer video format). I found it to be a great introduction to the current state of pandemic preparedness/GCBR. It has now been published as a paper by the Geneva Centre for Security Policy. I had some trouble finding it even on their website, so it seemed worth linkposting here. Executive summary and key takeaways are reproduced below.
    Executive summary
    The world is demonstrably vulnerable to the introduction of a single pandemic virus with a comparatively low case fatality rate. The deliberate and simultaneous release of many pandemic viruses across travel hubs could threaten the stability of civilisation. Current trends suggest that within a decade, tens of thousands of skilled individuals will be able to access the information required for them to single-handedly cause new pandemics. Safeguarding civilisation from the catastrophic misuse of biotechnology requires delaying the development and misuse of pandemic-class agents while building systems capable of reliably detecting threats and preventing nearly all infections.
    Key takeaways
    Background
    We don't yet know of any credible viruses that could cause new pandemics, but ongoing research projects aim to publicly identify them.
    Identifying a sequenced virus as pandemic-capable will allow >1,000 individuals to assemble it.
    One person with a list of such viruses could simultaneously ignite multiple pandemics.
    Viruses can spread faster than vaccines or antivirals can be distributed.
    Pandemic agents are more lethal than nuclear devices and will be accessible to terrorists.
    Delay
    A pandemic test-ban treaty will delay proliferation without slowing beneficial advances.
    Liability and insurance for catastrophic outcomes will compensate for negative externalities.
    Secure and universal DNA synthesis screening can reduce unauthorised access by >100-fold.
    Detect
    Untargeted sequencing can reliably detect all exponentially spreading biological threats
    Defend
    Goal: eliminate the virus while providing food, water, power, lawenforcement, and healthcare
    Develop and distribute pandemic-proof protective equipment for all essential workers
    Comfortable, stylish, durable powered respirators must be proven to work reliably
    Foster resilient supply chains, local production, and behavioural outbreak control
    Strengthen systems and offer individualised early warning to block transmission
    Develop and install germicidal low-wavelength lights, which appear to be harmless to humans
    Overhead fixtures can reduce airborne and surface pathogens by >90 per cent in seconds
    Read the Full PDF.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    4 min
  • EA - If FTX is liquidated, who ends up controlling Anthropic? by ofer
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: If FTX is liquidated, who ends up controlling Anthropic?, published by ofer on November 15, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    [EDIT: The original title of this question was: "If FTX/Alameda currently control Anthropic, who will end up controlling it?". Based on the comments so far, it does not seem likely that FTX/Alameda currently control Anthropic.]
    If I understand correctly, FTX/Alameda have seemingly invested $500M in Anthropic, according to a Bloomberg article:
    FTX/Alameda were funneling customer money into effective altruism. Bankman-Fried seems to have generously funded a lot of effective altruism charities, artificial-intelligence and pandemic research, Democratic political candidates, etc. One $500 million entry on the desperation balance sheet is “Anthropic,” a venture investment in an AI safety company. [...]
    That seems consistent with the following excerpts from this page on Anthropic's website:
    Anthropic, an AI safety and research company, has raised $580 million in a Series B.
    The Series B follows the company raising $124 million in a Series A round in 2021. The Series B round was led by Sam Bankman-Fried, CEO of FTX. The round also included participation from Caroline Ellison, Jim McClave, Nishad Singh, Jaan Tallinn, and the Center for Emerging Risk Research (CERR).
    Is it likely that FTX/Alameda currently have >50% voting power over Anthropic? If they do, who will end up having control over Anthropic?
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    2 min