The Nonlinear Library

The Nonlinear Library

By The Nonlinear FundEducation
Download on the App Store

All The Nonlinear Library episodes

  • EA - Theories of Welfare and Welfare Range Estimates by Bob Fischer
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Theories of Welfare and Welfare Range Estimates, published by Bob Fischer on November 14, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Key Takeaways
    Many theories of welfare imply that there are probably differences in animals’ welfare ranges. However, these theories do not agree about the sizes of those differences.
    The Moral Weight Project assumes that hedonism is true. This post tries to estimate how different our welfare range estimates could be if we were to assume some other theory of welfare.
    We argue that even if hedonic goods and bads (i.e., pleasures and pains) aren't all of welfare, they’re a lot of it. So, probably, the choice of a theory of welfare will only have a modest (less than 10x) impact on the differences we estimate between humans' and nonhumans' welfare ranges.
    Introduction
    This is the third post in the Moral Weight Project Sequence. The aim of the sequence is to provide an overview of the research that Rethink Priorities conducted between May 2021 and October 2022 on interspecific cause prioritization. The aim of this post is to suggest a way to quantify the impact of assuming hedonism on welfare range estimates.
    Motivations
    Theories of welfare disagree about the determinants of welfare. According to hedonism, the determinants of welfare are positively and negatively valenced experiences. According to desire satisfaction theory, the determinants are satisfied and frustrated desires. According to a garden variety objective list theory, the determinants are something like knowledge, developing and maintaining friendships, engaging in meaningful activities, and so on. Now, some animals probably have more intense pains than others; some probably have richer, more complex desires; some are able to acquire more sophisticated knowledge of the world; others can make stronger, more complex relationships with others. If animals systematically vary with respect to their ability to realize the determinants of welfare, then they probably vary in their welfare ranges.
    That is, some of them can probably realize more positive welfare at a time than others; likewise, some of them can probably realize more negative welfare at a time than others. As a result, animals probably vary with respect to the differences between the best and worst welfare states they can realize. The upshot: many theories of welfare imply that there are probably differences in animals’ welfare ranges.
    However, theories of welfare do not obviously agree about the sizes of those differences. Consider a garden variety objective list theory on which the following things contribute positively to welfare: acting autonomously, gaining knowledge, having friends, being in a loving relationship, doing meaningful work, creating valuable institutions, experiencing pleasure, and so on. Now consider a simple version of hedonism (i.e., one that rejects the higher / lower pleasure distinction) on which just one thing contributes positively to welfare: experiencing pleasure. Presumably, while many nonhuman animals (henceforth, animals) can experience pleasure, they can’t realize many of the other things that matter according to the objective list theory. Given as much, it’s plausible that if the objective list theory is true, there will be larger differences in welfare ranges between many humans and animals than there will be if hedonism is true.
    For practical and theoretical reasons, the Moral Weight Project assumes that hedonism is true. On the practical side, we needed to make some assumptions to make any progress in the time we had available. On the theoretical side, there are powerful arguments for hedonism. Still, those who reject hedonism will rightly wonder about the impact of assuming hedonism. How different would our welfare range estimates be if we were to assume some other theory of welfare?
    In the ...
    16 min
  • EA - Jeff Bezos announces donation plans (in response to question) by david reinstein
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Jeff Bezos announces donation plans (in response to question), published by david reinstein on November 14, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    For a change, some good billionaire philanthropy news
    Caveats:
    It seems to have been in response to the question "Do you plan to give away the majority of your wealth in your lifetime?"; I don't know whether he encouraged them to ask this
    I suspect this is not entirely 'news'; iirc he has made noises like this in the past
    Amazon founder Jeff Bezos plans to give away the majority of his $124 billion net worth during his lifetime, telling CNN in an exclusive interview he will devote the bulk of his wealth to fighting climate change and supporting people who can unify humanity in the face of deep social and political divisions.
    This seems potentially promising: he seems to prioritize effectiveness.
    “The hard part is figuring out how to do it in a levered way,” he said, implying that even as he gives away his billions, he is still looking to maximize his return. “It’s not easy. Building Amazon was not easy. It took a lot of hard work, a bunch of very smart teammates, hard-working teammates, and I’m finding — and I think Lauren is finding the same thing — that charity, philanthropy, is very similar.” “There are a bunch of ways that I think you could do ineffective things, too,” he added. “So you have to think about it carefully and you have to have brilliant people on the team.”
    Bezos’ methodical approach to giving stands in sharp contrast to that of his ex-wife, the philanthropist MacKenzie Scott, who recently gave away nearly $4 billion to 465 organizations in the span of less than a year.
    In terms of specifics, the Earth Fund seems relatively good, to me:
    Bezos has committed $10 billion over 10 years, or about 8% of his current net worth, to the Bezos Earth Fund, which Sánchez co-chairs. Among its priorities are reducing the carbon footprint of construction-grade cement and steel; pushing financial regulators to consider climate-related risks; advancing data and mapping technologies to monitor carbon emissions; and building natural, plant-based carbon sinks on a large scale.
    I’m less enthusiastic about the “Bezos Courage and Civility Award” which seems celebrity-driven (as much as I love Dolly Parton) and perhaps less likely to target global priorities/effectiveness.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    3 min
  • EA - Effective Peer Support Network in FTX crisis (Update) by Emily
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Effective Peer Support Network in FTX crisis (Update), published by Emily on November 14, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Are you going through a rough patch due to the FTX crisis?Or do you want to help EA peers who are?
    Following up on our post from last Friday, 'Get and Give Mental Health Support During These Hard Times', we [Rethink Wellbeing and the Mental Health Navigator] set up a support network to react to the many people in our community affected by the FTX crisis. The number of people who have joined is growing! These are the two modes of action:
    (1) In this table, you can find experienced supporters.
    These supporters want to help (for free), and you can just contact them. The community health team, as well as a growing number of coaches and therapists that are informed about EA and the FTX crisis, are already listed.
    If you have experience in supporting others and would like to dedicate >=1 hour in the next few weeks to support one or more EA peers that are having a hard time, you can take 1 min to add your details to the table. We likely need more support to take care of this situation. Consultants might be helpful, too.
    (2) You can join our new Peer Support Network Slack here.People can share and discuss their issues, get together in groups and 1:1, as well as get support from the trained helpers as well as peers:
    It enables you to chat with a trained helper anonymously—if you use a Nickname and an email address that doesn't contain your name.
    You can create closed sub-channels here for a small group of people with similar issues that want to support each other more closely.
    One can tackle specific topics in sub-channels, e.g., dealing with loss, future worries, or personal crises.
    Feel free to send this to anyone who might need or wish to provide help!Rethink Wellbeing was supposed to receive FTX funding to implement Effective Peer Support. Finding an alternative funding source (USD 25-63k), we could also provide a simple first version of mental health support groups and 1:1s to people affected by the FTX crisis quickly. Let us know if you'd like to make that possible. Around 300 EAs have signed up to participate in Effective Peer Support already, mainly after our post in October.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    3 min
  • EA - The FTX crisis highlights a deeper cultural problem within EA - we don't sufficiently value good governance by Fods12
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: The FTX crisis highlights a deeper cultural problem within EA - we don't sufficiently value good governance, published by Fods12 on November 14, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Introduction
    In this piece, I will explain why I don't think the collapse of FTX and resulting fallout for Future Fund and EA community in general is a one-off or 'black swan' event as some have argued on this forum. Rather, I think that what happened was part of a broader pattern of failures and oversights that have been persistent within EA and EA-adjacent organisations since the beginning of the movement.
    As a disclaimer, I do not have any inside knowledge or special expertise about FTX or any of the other organisations I will mention in this post. I speak simply as a long-standing and concerned member of the EA community.
    Weak Norms of Governance
    The essential point I want to make in this post is that the EA community has not been very successful in fostering norms of transparency, accountability, and institutionalisation of decision-making. Many EA organisations began as ad hoc collections of like-minded individuals with very ambitions goals but relatively little career experience. This has often led to inadequate organisational structures and procedures being established for proper management of personal, financial oversight, external auditing, or accountability to stakeholders. Let me illustrate my point with some major examples I am aware of from EA and EA-adjacent organisations:
    Weak governance structures and financial oversight at the Singularity Institute, leading to the theft of over $100,000 in 2009.
    Inadequate record keeping, rapid executive turnover, and insufficient board oversight at the Centre for Effective Altruism over the period 2016-2019.
    Inadequate financial record keeping at 80,000 Hours during 2018.
    Insufficient oversight, unhealthy power dynamics, and other harmful practices reported at MIRI/CFAR during 2015-2017.
    Similar problems reported at the EA-adjacent organisation Leverage Research during 2017-2019.
    'Loose norms around board of directors and conflicts of interests between funding orgs and grantees' at FTX and the Future Fund from 2021-2022.
    While these specific issues are somewhat diverse, I think what they have in common is an insufficient emphasis on principles of good organisational governance. This ranges from the most basic such as clear objectives and good record keeping, to more complex issues such as external auditing, good systems of accountability, transparency of the organisation to its stakeholders, avoiding conflicts of interest, and ensuring that systems exist to protect participants in asymmetric power relationships. I believe that these aspects of good governance and robust institution building have not been very highly valued in the broader EA community. In my experience, EAs like to talk about philosophy, outreach, career choice, and other nerdy stuff. Discussing best practise of organisational governance and systems of accountability doesn't seem very high status or 'sexy' in the EA space.
    There has been some discussion of such issues on this forum (e.g. this thoughtful post), but overall EA culture seems to have failed to properly absorb these lessons.
    EA projects are often run by small groups of young idealistic people who have similar educational and social backgrounds, who often socialise together, and (in many cases) participate in romantic relationships with one another - The case of Sam Bankman-Fried and Caroline Ellison is certainly not the only such example in the EA community. The EA culture seems to be heavily influenced by start-up culture and entrepreneurialism, with a focus on moving quickly and relying on finding highly-skilled and highly-aligned people and then providing them funding and space to work with minimal oversi...
    8 min
  • EA - Lessons from taking group members to an EAGx conference by Irene H
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Lessons from taking group members to an EAGx conference, published by Irene H on November 14, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    We (Irene and Jelle) run the EA Eindhoven university group and went to EAGxRotterdam (4-6 November 2022) with 16 of our members.
    Our members told us they really enjoyed the conference and have plans for how they want to pursue their EA journeys. We are excited that almost all Dutch universities have EA groups now and felt EAGxRotterdam was the capstone of this year in which the Dutch EA community has really taken off.
    These are some of the lessons we learned and best practices we discovered in our preparation for the conference as well as what we did during the conference itself. We hope other group organizers can benefit from these lessons too. We of course hope to visit many more EA conferences in the future and grow as community builders, which means this guide is a work in progress. We are also excited to learn about the best practices of other community builders and welcome their suggestions. Feel free to place comments!
    Some things to keep in mind when reading this
    Circumstance-specific things that were the case for us:
    Our group is only a few months old, our members all became engaged with EA only recently (most of them through our Introduction Fellowship) and our two organizers were the only people who had ever attended an EA conference before. This is why we put quite a lot of effort into encouraging members to apply and helping them prepare.
    Rotterdam is only a 1-hour train ride from Eindhoven, so it was relatively easy for us to convince members to attend. Some of our members stayed with friends or traveled back and forth every day.
    The conference was on the weekend between two exam weeks at our university and a few of our members cited this as a reason for not applying. One of our members got accepted but never showed up to the conference in order to work on a class assignment. We really regret these things but do not know what we could have done about them.
    Because this conference in the Netherlands was such a rare event, we also advised some members to apply even though we were not 100% sure if they were engaged enough in EA. We would probably be stricter with our advice to them about this for conferences that are further away.
    For members who had not done an Introduction Fellowship (or equivalent), we made it clear that the conference was not going to be useful if they did not do some kind of preparation. We agreed with them that they would go over the EA Handbook and scheduled a 1-on-1 to discuss the preparation. In the end, all people who were interested were willing to do this preparation and carried it out. We spoke to them after to conference and they told us they found the conference interesting and returned with new ideas.
    We had 3 people show up at our collective application night, which is not a lot, but they all applied. We had approximately 10 people in total show up at our preparation evenings (we hosted 2 in a student café on our campus).
    We were both volunteers at EAGxRotterdam, had a lot of 1-on-1s scheduled and Jelle was also a speaker. Irene also met a community builder at the conference who was mainly there to guide his members, but in our case, that was not our only priority.
    Encourage and help members to apply
    Plan other programs (especially the Introduction Fellowship) so that they finish in time to still have space for promoting the conference and giving members the time to apply.
    Pitch the conference during your programs and events
    Host a collective application night
    Guide for Collective application night by the EAGxRotterdam team that we used
    Focus on members you think would benefit most from the conference
    Members who have already done at least an Introduction Fellowship (or equivalent)
    Have 1-on-1...
    9 min
  • EA - AI Safety Microgrant Round by Chris Leong
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: AI Safety Microgrant Round, published by Chris Leong on November 14, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    We are pleased to announce an AI Safety Microgrants Round, which will provide micro-grants to field-building projects and other initiatives that can be done with less.
    We believe there are projects and individuals in the AI Safety space who lack funding but have high agency and potential. We think individuals helping to fund projects will be particularly important given recent changes in the availability of funding. For this reason, we decided to experiment with a small micro-grant round as a test and demonstration of this concept.
    To keep the evaluation simple, we’re focusing on field-building projects rather than projects that would require complex evaluation (we expect that most technical projects would be much more difficult to evaluate).
    We are offering microgrants up to $2,000 USD with the total size of this round being $6,000 USD (we know that this is a tiny round, but we are running this as a proof-of-concept). One possible way this could pan out would be two grants of $2000 and two of $1000, although we aren’t wedded and we are fine with request for less. We want to fund grant requests of this size where EA funds possibly has a bit too much overhead.
    The process is as follows:
    Fill out this form at microgrant.ai (<15 min).
    Shortlisted applications receive a follow-up call within two weeks after the applications close
    We may also send an email with follow-up questions if we need more information. We would expect a reply within a few days so that we could confirm the grant within a week
    To inspire applicants, here are some examples of projects where a microgrant would have been helpful:
    Chris recently received a grant through an Australian-based organisation to hire two facilitators at $1,000 each for running a local version of the AGI safety fundamentals course. Intro fellowships have proven to be a great way of engaging people and we would be excited about funding this if it would help kickstart a new local AI safety group rather than just being an isolated project.
    We might have funded something like the AI safety nudge competition to help people overcome their procrastination, and are excited about the potential to motivate a large number of people to accelerate their AI safety journeys and about experimenting with a potentially scalable intervention.
    The Sydney AI Safety Fellowship was originally going to be funded with three people each throwing in $2000, which would have been enough for a coworking space, weekly lunches and some socials for a few participants. We would be excited about funding a similar project if they were likely to attract good candidates - especially in communities and countries where this is currently nonexistent.
    We are open to smaller grant applications, but in a lot of cases, small grants don't make much of a counterfactual difference, however here are two examples of the kinds of grants we would be excited about:
    One of us thinks there should be a logo for AI safety just like EA has the light bulb. This may be considered for a microgrant.
    One of us recently granted $200 to half subsidise ten maths lessons. This allowed the grantee to build up evidence to subsequently get a grant to half-subsidise their lessons. We are excited about grants that assist someone in testing their fit. One of us had also granted $100 to someone in a low and middle-income country to get them a device for self-study so they could upskill themselves.
    In contrast, here are the kinds of grants we wouldn't be very excited about:
    Any project with significant downside risk
    $2000 towards a project which requires $8,000 which hasn't been obtained yet
    Funding to add one more fellow to a program that already has ten fellows. These kind of grants could be imp...
    5 min
  • EA - NY Times on the FTX implosion's impact on EA by AllAmericanBreakfast
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: NY Times on the FTX implosion's impact on EA, published by AllAmericanBreakfast on November 14, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    The impact of the FTX scandal on EA is starting to hit the news. The coverage in this NY Times article seems fair to me. I also think that the FTX Future Fund leadership decision to jointly resign both was the right thing to do, and comes across that way in the article. Will MacAskill, I think, is continuing to show leadership interfacing with the media - it's a big transition from his book tour not long ago to giving quotes to the press about FTX's implosion.
    The article focuses on the impact this has had on EA:
    [The collapse of FTX] has also dealt a significant blow to the corner of philanthropy known as effective altruism, a philosophy that advocates applying data and evidence to doing the most good for the many and that is deeply tied to Mr. Bankman-Fried, one of its leading proponents and donors. Now nonprofits are scrambling to replace millions in grant commitments from Mr. Bankman-Fried’s charitable vehicles, and members of the effective altruism community are asking themselves whether they might have helped burnish his reputation...
    ... For a relatively young movement that was already wrestling over its growth and focus, such a high-profile scandal implicating one of the group’s most famous proponents represents a significant setback.
    The article mentions the FTX Future Fund joint resignation, focusing on the grants that will not be able to be honored and what those might have helped.
    The article talks about Will MacAskill inspiring SBF to switch his career plans to pursue earning to give, but doesn't try to blame the fraud on utilitarianism or on EA. This is my opinion, but I'm just confused by people's eagerness to blame this on utilitarianism or the EA movement. The common-sense American lens to view these sorts of outcomes is a framework of personal responsibility. If SBF committed fraud, that is indicative of a problem with his personal character, not the moral philosophy he claims to subscribe to.
    His connection to the movement in fact predates the vast fortune he won and lost in the cryptocurrency field. Over lunch a decade ago while he was still in college, Mr. Bankman-Fried told Mr. MacAskill, the philosopher, that he wanted to work on animal-welfare issues. Mr. MacAskill suggested the young man could do more good earning large sums of money and donating the bulk of it to good causes instead.
    Mr. Bankman-Fried went into finance with the stated intention of making a fortune that he could then give away. In an interview with The New York Times last month about effective altruism, Mr. Bankman-Fried said he planned to give away a vast majority of his fortune in the next 10 to 20 years to effective altruist causes. He did not respond to a request for comment for this article.
    Contrary to my expectation, the article was pretty straightforward in describing the global health/longtermism aspects of EA:
    Effective altruism focuses on the question of how individuals can do as much good as possible with the money and time available to them. Historically, the community focused on low-cost medical interventions, such as insecticide-treated bed nets to prevent mosquitoes from giving people malaria.
    More recently many members of the movement have focused on issues that could have a greater impact on the future, like pandemic prevention and nuclear nonproliferation as well as preventing artificial intelligence from running amok and sending people to distant planets to increase our chances of survival as a species.
    Probably the most critical aspect of the article was this:
    Benjamin Soskis, senior research associate in the Center on Nonprofits and Philanthropy at the Urban Institute, said that the issues raised by Mr. Bankman-Fried’s rev...
    5 min
  • EA - Wrong lessons from the FTX catastrophe by burner
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Wrong lessons from the FTX catastrophe, published by burner on November 14, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    There remains a large amount of uncertainty about what exactly happened inside FTX and Alameda. I do not offer any new takes on what occurred. However, there are the inklings of some "lessons" from the situation that are incorrect regardless of how the details flesh out. Pointing these out now may seem in poor taste while many are still coming to terms with what happened, but it important to do so before they become the canonical lessons.
    1. Ambition was a mistake
    There have been a number of calls for EA to "go back to bed nets." It is notable that this refrain conflates the alleged illegal and unethical behavior from FTX/Alameda with the philosophical position of longtermism. Rather than evaluating the two issues as distinct, the call seems to assume both were born out of the same runaway ambition.
    Logically, this is obviously not the case. Longtermism grew in popularity during SBFs rise, and Future Fund did focus on longtermist projects, but FTX/Alameda situation has no bearing on the truth of longtermism and associated project's prioritization.
    To the extent that both becoming incredibly rich and affecting the longterm trajectory of humanity are "ambitious" goals, ambition is not the problem. Committing financial crimes is a problem. Longtermism has problems, like knowing how to act given uncertainty about the future. But an enlightened understanding of ambition accommodates these problems: We should be ambitious in our goals while understanding our limitations in solving them.
    There is an uncomfortable reality that SBF symbolized a new level of ambition for EA. That sense of ambition should be retained. His malfeasance should not be.
    This is not to say that there may be lessons to learn about transparency, overconfidence, centralized power, trusting leaders, etc from these events. But all of these are distinct from a lesson about ambition, which depends more on vague allusions to Icarus than argument.
    2. No more earning to give
    I am not sure that this is being learned as a "lesson" or if this situation simply "leaves a bad taste" in EA's mouths about earning to give. The alleged actions of the FTX/Alameda team in no way suggest that earning money to donate to effective causes is a poor career path.
    Certain employees of FTX/Alameda seem to have been doing distinctly unethical work, such as grossly mismanaging client funds. One of the only arguments for why one might be open to working a possibly unethical job like trading crypto currency is because an ethically motivated actor would do that job in a more ethical way than the next person would (from Todd and MacAskill). Earning to give never asked EAs to pursue unethical work, and encouraged them to pursue any line of work in an ethically upstanding way.
    (I emphasize Todd and MacAskill conclude in their 2017 post: "We believe that in the vast majority of cases, it’s a mistake to pursue a career in which the direct effects of the work are seriously harmful").
    Earning to give in the way it has always been advised-by doing work that is basically ethical-continues to be a highly promising route to impact. This is especially true when total EA assets have significantly depreciated.
    There is a risk that EAs do not continue to pursue earning to give, thinking either that it is icky post-FTX or that someone else has it covered. This is a poor strategy. It is imperative that some EAs who are well suited for founding companies shift their careers into entrepreneurship as soon as possible.
    3. General FUD from nefarious actors
    As the EA community reals from the FTX/Alameda blow up, a number of actors with histories of hating EA have chimed in with threads about how this catastrophe is in line with X thing they alre...
    7 min
  • EA - How the FTX crash damaged the Altruistic Agency by Markus Amalthea Magnuson
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: How the FTX crash damaged the Altruistic Agency, published by Markus Amalthea Magnuson on November 13, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Introduction
    First, I’d like to express my deepest sympathies to everyone affected by the FTX breakdown. A lot of people have lost their life savings and are suffering terribly, something I do not wish to diminish in any way. Many are affected in far worse ways than I can even imagine, and I hope as many of those as possible will be able to find the support they need to get through these challenging times.
    I got confirmation this week on Wednesday (Nov 9) that payouts from the FTX Future Fund had stopped. Since I had an outstanding grant with them, this was of great concern to me personally. The days following that, and what is still unravelling minute by minute, it seems, was the complete meltdown of FTX and all related entities, including the Future Fund. You are all following these events in other places, so I won’t go into that much, but I wanted to offer a perspective from a Future Fund grantee and the specific ways something like this can do damage.
    This post is also a call for support since all funding for my next year of operations has suddenly evaporated entirely. Specifically, if you or someone you know is a grantmaker or donor to EA meta/infrastructure/operations projects and would be interested in funding a new organisation with a good track record, please get in touch. I’d be happy to share much more details and data on the proven value so far, my grant application to the Future Fund, and anything else that might be of interest.
    I will also mention the benefits of being vigilant about organisational structure and how it can save your organisation in the long run, even though it might be an upfront and ongoing cost of time and money.
    Background
    I founded the Altruistic Agency in January this year. The idea was to apply my knowledge and experience from 15+ years as a full-stack developer to help organisations and others in the EA community with tech expertise. I hypothesised that the kind of work I had done mostly in a commercial context for most of my professional life is also highly valuable to nonprofits/charities and others doing high-impact work within EA cause areas. I have always been fond of meta projects, and this seemed like something that could greatly increase productivity (like technology does), especially by saving people lots of time that they could instead spend on their core mission.
    Thanks to a grant from the EA Infrastructure Fund, I was able to test this hypothesis full-time and spent the first half of this year providing free tech support to many EA organisations and individuals. During that time, I worked with around 45 of them in areas such as existential risk, animal advocacy, climate, legal research, mental health, and effective fundraising. The work ranged from small tasks, such as improving email deliverability, fixing website bugs, and making software recommendations, to larger tasks, such as building websites, doing security audits, and software integration.
    The response from the community was overwhelmingly positive, and the data from the January–June pilot phase of the Altruistic Agency indicates high value. I solved issues (on median) in a fifth of the time it would have taken organisations themselves. The data indicates just one person doing this work for six months saved EA organisations at least 900 hours of work. Additionally, many respondents said they learned a lot from working with me, both about their own systems and setups and about tech in general. Not least, increased awareness of security issues in code and systems, which will only become more crucial over time, and can be significantly harmful if not dealt with properly.
    Insights from the pilot phase told me two important t...
    11 min
  • LW - Announcing Nonlinear Emergency Funding by KatWoods
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Announcing Nonlinear Emergency Funding, published by KatWoods on November 13, 2022 on LessWrong.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    1 min