The Nonlinear Library

The Nonlinear Library

By The Nonlinear FundEducation
Download on the App Store

All The Nonlinear Library episodes

  • EA - The FTX Situation: Wait for more information before proposing solutions by D0TheMath
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: The FTX Situation: Wait for more information before proposing solutions, published by D0TheMath on November 13, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Edit: Eli has a great comment on this which I suggest everyone read. He corrects me on a few things, and gives his far more informed takes.
    I'm slightly scared that EA will overcorrect in an irrelevant direction to the FTX situation in a way I think is net harmful, and I think a major reason for this fear is seeing lots of people espousing conclusions about solutions to problems without us actually knowing what the problems are yet.
    Some examples of this I've seen recently on the forum follow.
    Integrity
    It is uncertain whether SBF intentionally committed fraud, or just made a mistake, but people seem to be reacting as if the takeaway from this is that fraud is bad.
    These articles are mostly saying things of the form 'if FTX engaged in fraud, then EA needs to make sure people don't do more fraud in the service of utilitarianism.' from a worrying-about-group-think perspective, this is only a little less concerning than directly saying 'FTX engaged in fraud, so EA should make sure people don't do more fraud'.
    Even though these articles aren't literally saying that FTX engaged in fraud in the service of utilitarianism, I worry these articles will shift the narrative EA tells itself towards up-weighting hypotheses which say FTX engaged in fraud in the service of utilitarianism, especially in worlds where it turned out that FTX did commit fraud, but it was motivated by pride, or other selfish desires.
    Dating
    Some have claimed FTX's downfall happened as a result of everyone sleeping with each other, and this interpretation is not obviously unpopular on the forum. This seems quite unlikely compared to alternative explanations, and the post Women and Effective Altruism takes on a tone & content I find toxic to community epistemics[1], and anticipate wouldn't fly on the forum a week ago.
    I worry the reason we see this post now is that EA is confused, wants to do something, and is really searching for anything to blame for the FTX situation. If you are confused about what your problems are, you should not go searching for solutions! You should ask questions, make predictions, and try to understand what's going on. Then you should ask how you could have prevented or mitigated the bad events, and ask whether those prevention and mitigation efforts would be worth their costs.
    I think this problem is important to address, and am uncertain about whether this post is good or bad on net. The point is that I'm seeing a bunch of heated emotions on the forum right now, this is not like the forum I'm used to, and lots of these heated discussions seem to be directed towards pushing new EA policy proposals rather than trying to figure out what's going on.
    Vetting funding
    We could immediately launch a costly investigation to see who had knowledge of fraud that occurred before we actually know if fraud occured or why. In worlds where we’re wrong about whether or why fraud occurred this would be very costly. My suggestion: wait for information to costlessly come out, discuss what happened when not in the midst of the fog and emotions of current events, and then decide whether we should launch this costly investigation.
    Adjacently, some are arguing EA could have vetted FTX and Sam better, and averted this situation. This reeks of hindsight bias! Probably EA could not have done better than all the investors who originally vetted FTX before giving them a buttload of money!
    Maybe EA should investigate funders more, but arguments for this are orthogonal to recent events, unless CEA believes their comparative advantage in the wider market is high-quality vetting of corporations. If so, they could stand to make quite a bit of money selling this service,...
    4 min
  • EA - SBF, extreme risk-taking, expected value, and effective altruism by vipulnaik
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: SBF, extreme risk-taking, expected value, and effective altruism, published by vipulnaik on November 13, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    NOTE: I have some indirect associations with SBF and his companies, though probably less so than many of the others who've been posting and commenting on the forum. I don't expect anything I write here to meaningfully affect how things play out in the future for me, so I don't think this creates a conflict of interest, but feel free to discount what I say.
    NOTE 2: I'm publishing this post without having spent the level of effort polishing and refining it that I normally try to spend. This is due to the time-sensitive nature of the subject matter and because
    I expect to get more value from being corrected in the comments on the post than from refining the post myself. If errors are pointed out, I will try to correct them, but may not always be able to make timely corrections, so if you're reading the post, please also check the comments to check for flaws identified by comments.
    The collapse of Sam Bankman-Fried (SBF) and his companies FTX and
    Alameda Research is the topic du jour on the Effective Altruism Forum, and there have been several posts on the
    Forum discussing what happened and what we can learn from it. The post FTX
    FAQ provides a good summary of what we know as of the time I'm writing this post. I'm also funding work on a timeline of FTX collapse (still a work in progress, but with enough coverage already to be useful if you are starting with very little knowledge).
    Based on information so far, fraud and deception on the part of SBF
    (and/or others in FTX and/or Alameda Research) likely happened and were likely key to the way things played out and the extent of damage caused. The trigger seems to be the big loan that FTX provided to
    Alameda Research to bail it out, using customer funds for the purpose. If FTX hadn't bailed out Alameda, it's quite likely that the spectacular death of FTX we saw (with depositors losing all their money as well) wouldn't have happened. But it's also plausible that without the loan, the situation with Alameda Research was dire enough that Alameda Research, and then FTX, would have died due to the lack of funds. Hopefully that would have been a more graceful death with less pain to depositors. That is a very important difference. Nonetheless, I suspect that by the time of the bailout, we were already at a kind of endgame.
    In this post, I try to step back a bit from the endgame, and even get away from the specifics of FTX and Alameda Research (that I know very little about) and in fact even get away from the specifics of SBF's business practices (where again I know very little). Rather, I talk about SBF's overall philosophy around risk and expected value, as he has articulated himself, and has been approvingly amplified by several
    EA websites and groups. I think the philosophy was key to the overall way things played out. And I also discuss the relationship between the philosophy and the ideas of effective altruism, both in the abstract and as specifically championed by many leaders in effective altruism (including the team at 80,000 Hours). My goal is to encourage people to reassess the philosophy and make appropriate updates.
    I make two claims:
    Claim 1: SBF engages in extreme risk-taking that is a crude approximation to the idea of expected value maximization as perceived by him.
    Claim 2: At least part of the motivation for SBF's risk-taking comes from ideas in effective altruism, and in particular specific points made by EA leaders including people affiliated with 80,000
    Hours. While personality probably accounts for a lot of SBF's decisions, the role of EA ideas as a catalyst cannot be dismissed based on the evidence.
    Here are a few things I am not claiming (some of these are discussed ...
    36 min
  • LW - Weekly Roundup #5 by Zvi
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Weekly Roundup #5, published by Zvi on November 11, 2022 on LessWrong.
    A note about what isn’t in this roundup: Nothing about the midterms or crypto/FTX. I wrote about Twitter earlier this week. The midterms are better covered elsewhere, I do not have anything unique to say about them. As for the situation with FTX, it is rapidly developing and I do not yet feel I have sufficient handle on it that saying things would be net helpful. I continue to recommend starting on that topic by reading Matt Levine (both in general, and for this in particular).
    There were going to bea few additional things related to Twitter and Musk, but the section rapidly spiraled out of control as news came on top of news and I didn’t know if my statements were current, so I’m moving it to another draft and we’ll see if it ends up making it or not. For now, I will simply say that how badly and quickly you want to Find Out, which can only be done by Fing Around, is increasingly the question of our age.
    It is indeed weird to have so much going on and have that result in having less to say for the moment, while thoughts are gathered and things become clearer. Seems right, though, and also some background writing tasks got more urgent this week.
    Bad News
    More on the chess cheating scandals (via MR). My main contention continues to be that we are far too unwilling to punish competitors on the basis of statistical evidence in cheating cases. FIDE’s ‘99.999% sure’ policy, or whatever exactly it is, is Obvious Nonsense. No one is going to jail or being executed, and there are plenty of options well short of ‘can never again play competitive chess.’
    Where would I put the bar? I don’t think it is crazy to put it at 51% if your estimates are fair and well calibrated. Certainly if I thought someone was 50/50 to be a savage cheater, I would not invite them to join my Magic (or chess) team or play group, help promote them, or anything like that. If I was running an invitational chess tournament, I would consider even a 10% chance to be a rather severe demerit to the extent that I had the freedom to consider it. My guess is that in practice the right answer for Serious Official Punishments is in the 75%-90% range.
    Uber tests using push notifications to deliver ads. I am trying to imagine a world where this is a good business decision and failing.
    Are falling retirement ages good or bad for people?
    Joe’s question also raises the question of, if we are or become importantly poorer than we used to be, we should progressively raise the age to collect full benefits.
    On reflection, I continue to think that this is an area where people are going to make decisions poorly, in both directions. Some people will retire far too early, either run out of funds or grow bored and lonely and have their health degenerate faster than it otherwise would have. Those that realize this is happening will then mostly have few good options to undo what was done. Others will refuse to retire for too long, although I expect this group to be smaller. My guess is that of those who keep working too long at their job, a lot of them would benefit from changing jobs and actively doing something else more than they would benefit from full retirement.
    Do I plan to retire? My basic answer is no, at least not until very late in the game when I am unable to meaningfully work. I do not see such a decision improving my life. My hope is that I can fully retire from having to do work for or because of the money while continuing to do plenty of work. I don’t want to be keeping up quite this pace of work indefinitely, I likely should be taking more time to relax than I am as it is. I’m working on that.
    In Magic: The Gathering, Aaron Forsythe asks why the Standard format is dying and gets a lot of answers, including this one by Brian Kowal. Standard was ...
    10 min
  • LW - The Alignment Community Is Culturally Broken by sudo -i
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: The Alignment Community Is Culturally Broken, published by sudo -i on November 13, 2022 on LessWrong.
    Disclaimer: These are entirely my thoughts. I'm posting this before it's fully polished because it never will be.
    Epistemic status: Moderately confident. Deliberately provocative title.
    Apparently, the Bay Area rationalist community has a burnout problem. I have no idea if it's worse than base rate, but I've been told it's pretty bad. I suspect that the way burnout manifests in the rationalist community is uniquely screwed up.
    I was crying the other night because our light cone is about to get ripped to shreds. I'm gonna do everything I can to do battle against the forces that threaten to destroy us. You've heard this story before. Short timelines. Tick. Tick. I've been taking alignment seriously for about a year now, and I'm ready to get serious. I've thought hard about what my strengths are. I've thought hard about what I'm capable of. I'm dropping out of Stanford, I've got something that looks like a plan, I've got the rocky theme song playing, and I'm ready to do this.
    A few days later, I saw this post. And it reminded me of everything that bothers me about the EA community. Habryka covered the object level problems pretty well, but I need to communicate something a little more... delicate.
    I understand that everyone is totally depressed because qualia is doomed. I understand that we really want to creatively reprioritize. I completely sympathize with this.
    I want to address the central flaw of Akash+Olivia+Thomas's argument in the Buying Time post, which is that actually, people can improve at things.
    There's something deeply discouraging about being told "you're an X% researcher, and if X>Y, then you should stay in alignment. Otherwise, do a different intervention." No other effective/productive community does this. I don't know how to put this, but the vibes are deeply off.
    The appropriate level of confidence to have about a statement like "I can tell how good of an alignment researcher you will be after a year of you doing alignment research" feels like it should be pretty low. At a year, there's almost certainly ways to improve that haven't been tried. Especially in a community so mimetically allergic to the idea of malleable human potential.
    Here's a hypothesis. I in no way mean to imply that this is the only mechanism by which burnout happens in our community, but I think it's probably a pretty big one. It's not nice to be in a community that constantly hints that you might just not be good enough and that you can't get good enough.
    Our community seems to love treating people like mass-produced automatons with a fixed and easily assessable "ability" attribute. (Maybe you flippantly read that sentence and went "yeah it's called g factor lulz." In that case, maybe reflect on good of a correlate g is in absolute terms for the things you care about.).
    If we want to actually accomplish anything, we need to encourage people to make bigger bets, and to stop stacking up credentials so that fellow EAs think they have a chance. It's not hubris to believe in yourself.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    4 min
  • LW - What's the Alternative to Independence? by jefftk
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: What's the Alternative to Independence?, published by jefftk on November 13, 2022 on LessWrong.
    When I
    talk about
    teaching my kids
    to be independent, trying to get them to where they can do more on their own, one response I often get is, paraphrasing:
    I like spending time with my kids and don't see it as a burden. Bringing them to school, playing with them, making their food: these are all chances to connect and enjoy being together. They'll be old enough not to need me soon enough, and in the meantime I enjoy bringing them to the playground.
    So, first, I also like spending time with my kids! We do a lot of things together, and I'm happy about that. But it's also common that they'll want to do things that I can't do with them:
    One wants to go to the park and the other wants to stay home.
    One of them is ready to go to school and wants to get there early to play with friends, but the other isn't ready yet.
    With a third child now this comes up even more. At times:
    The older two want to go over to a friend's house, but the baby is napping.
    I'm still feeding the baby breakfast when it's time for school.
    The best time for the baby's afternoon nap conflicts with school pickup.
    The alternative to doing things on their own is typically not us doing the same things together. Instead, it's at least one kid needing to accept doing something they like much less, and typically a lot more indoor time.
    I do think there is some truth in the original point, though. There are times when the alternative to "they go to the park" is just "I take them to the park". Sometimes that's fine (they want to play with friends, I want to write), other times less so (they want to play monster and I don't have anything that's actually more important). With this approach you do need to be thoughtful about making sure you're spending an amount of time with them that you all are, and will be, happy with.
    Comment via: facebook, mastodon
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    2 min
  • EA - Announcing Nonlinear Emergency Funding by Kat Woods
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Announcing Nonlinear Emergency Funding, published by Kat Woods on November 13, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Like most of you, we at Nonlinear are horrified and saddened by recent events concerning FTX. Some of you counting on Future Fund grants are suddenly finding yourselves facing an existential financial crisis, so, inspired by the Covid Fast Grants program, we’re trying something similar for EA. If you are a Future Fund grantee and <$10,000 of bridge funding would be of substantial help to you, fill out this short form (<10 mins) and we’ll get back to you ASAP.
    We have a small budget, so if you’re a funder and would like to help, please reach out: [email protected]
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    1 min
  • EA - Thoughts on legal concerns surrounding the FTX situation by Molly
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Thoughts on legal concerns surrounding the FTX situation, published by Molly on November 13, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    As Open Phil’s managing counsel, and as a member of the EA community, I’ve received an onslaught of questions relating to the FTX fiasco in the last few days. Unfortunately, I’ve been unable to answer most of them either because I don’t have the relevant legal expertise, or because I can’t provide legal advice to non-clients (and Open Philanthropy is my only client in this situation), or because the facts I’d need to answer the questions just aren’t available yet.
    The biggest topic of concern is something along the lines of: if I received FTX-related grant money, what am I supposed to do? Will it be clawed back? This post aims to provide legal context on this topic; it doesn’t address ethical or other practical perspectives on the topic.
    Before diving into that, I want to offer this context: this is the first few days of what is going to be a multi-year legal process. It will be drawn out and tedious. We cannot will the information we want into existence, so we can’t be as strategic as we’d like.
    But there’s an upside to that. Emotions are high and many people are probably not in a great mental place to make big decisions. This externally-imposed waiting period can be put to good use as a time to process.
    I understand that for some people who received FTX-related grant money, waiting doesn’t feel like an option; people need to know whether they can pay rent, or if their organization still exists. I hope some of the information below will provide a little more context for individual situations and decisions.
    I also committed to putting out an explainer on clawbacks. That is here, though I think the information in this post is more useful.
    Bankruptcy and Clawbacks
    Background
    The information in this section is based on publicly available information and general conversations with bankruptcy lawyers. I do not have access to any nonpublic information about this case. None of this should be taken as legal advice to you.
    FTX filed for bankruptcy on Friday (November 11th, 2022). More specifically, Alameda Research Ltd. filed a voluntary petition for bankruptcy under Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code, by filing a standard form in the United States Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware. The filing includes 134 “debtor entities” (listed as Annex I); it looks like this covers the full FTX corporate group.
    This means that the full FTX group is now under the protection of the bankruptcy court, and over the coming months, all of the assets in the debtor group will be administered for the benefit of FTX’s creditors. By filing under Chapter 11 (instead of Chapter 7), FTX has preserved the option of emerging out of the bankruptcy proceeding and continuing to operate in some capacity. You can read a useful explainer on the bankruptcy process here.
    The rules in the Bankruptcy Code are ultimately trying to ensure a fair outcome for creditors. This includes capturing certain payment transactions that occurred in the past. Basically, the debtor can reach back in time to undo deals it made and recoup monies it paid; this money comes back into the estate through clawbacks and gets redistributed to creditors according to the bankruptcy rules.
    Clawbacks
    There are two main types of clawback processes. The first and most common (called a “preference claim”) target transactions that happened in the 90 days prior to the bankruptcy filing. Essentially, if you received money from an FTX entity in the debtor group anytime on or after approximately August 11, 2022, the bankruptcy process will probably ask you, at some point, to pay all or part of that money back. It’s almost impossible to say right now whether any specific grant or contract will be subject to clawb...
    8 min
  • EA - Hubris and coldness within EA (my experience) by James Gough
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Hubris and coldness within EA (my experience), published by James Gough on November 13, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Hi all.
    Like a lot of people that have had a connection to EA I am appalled by the close connection between the FTX scandal and EA. But not surprised.
    The EA community events I attended totally killed my passion for EA. I attended an EA global conference in London and left feeling really really sad. Before the conference I was told I was not important enough or not worth the time to get career advice. One person I'd met before at local EA events made it clear that he didn't want to waste time talking to me (this was in the guide btw to make it clear if you don't think someone is worth your time). Well it certainly made me unconfident and uncomfortable to approach anyone else. I found the whole thing miserable. Everyone went out to take photo for the conference and I didn't bother. I don't want to be part of a community that I didn't feel happy in.
    On a less personal level, I overheard some unpleasant conversations about how EA should only be reserved for the intellectual elite (whatever the fuck that is) and how diversity didn't really matter. How they were annoyed that women got talks just for being women.
    Honestly, the whole place just reeked of hubris - everyone was so sure they were right, people had no interest in you as a person. I have never experienced more unfriendly, self-important, uncompassionate people in my life (I am 31 now). It was of course the last time I was ever involved with anything EA related.
    Maybe you read this and can dismiss it with yeah but issues are too important to waste time with petty small talk or showing interest in others. Or your subjective experience doesn't matter. Or we talk about rationality and complex ideas here , not personal opinions.
    But that is the whole point I'm trying to make. When you take away the human element, when you're so focused on grandiose ideas and certain of your perfect rationality, you end up dismissing the fast thinking necessary to make good ethical decisions. Anyone that values human kindness would run a mile from someone that doesn't have the respect to listen to someone talking to them and makes clear that their video game is valued above that person. Similarly to the long history of Musk's contempt for ordinary people.
    EA just seems so focused on being ethical that it forgot how to be nice. In my opinion, a new more inclusive organisation with a focus on making a positive impact needs to be created - with a better name.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    3 min
  • EA - In favour of ‘personal policies’ by Michelle Hutchinson
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: In favour of ‘personal policies’, published by Michelle Hutchinson on November 13, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    I’m pretty sad this week and isolating due to having covid. I thought I’d try to have something positive come out of that, and write up a blog post I’ve had in the back of my mind for a while.
    I wanted to share my positive experience with setting ‘policies’ for myself. They’re basically heuristics I use to avoid having to make as many decisions (particular about things that are somewhat stressful). I got the idea, and suggestions for ways to implement it, from Brenton Mayer (thank you!).
    What are personal policies?
    There are various classes of decisions I make periodically, for which I’d like to have an answer in advance rather than deciding in individual cases. Those are the kinds of cases in which I try to make a ‘policy decision’ going forward.
    This is the kind of thing we do all the time for particular types of actions. For example, someone might decide to be a vegetarian. From then, they no longer consider in each individual instance whether they should eat some dish with meat in, they’ve made a blanket rule not to do so in any individual case.
    There are a number of things like ‘being a vegetarian’ which we’re used to. We’re less likely to make up our own of these ‘rules I plan to live by’. A way we might frame it when we do is as ‘getting into a habit’. I sometimes prefer the framing of ‘policy’ in that it’s instantaneous (whereas something can’t really be a habit until you’ve done it a few times) and it sounds like a clear decision you’re acting on.
    A way I like to think of this is: For tricky repeating decisions, make them only once.
    Having said that, for long run policies, it’s likely you’ll want to have periodic re-examinations of them to check you still endorse them. I keep a list of my policies, both to make them easier to remember and to come back and re-evaluate them.
    Use cases and benefits
    Make faster decisions
    Having a policy for some type of decision means you don’t have to spend time making a decision in each specific case.
    One of my friends has the policy of always running for a train if there’s one she wants to be on which looks about to leave. This is the kind of situation where we’re often unsure what to do - is it impossible to make the train however fast I am? Do I have plenty of time because it’s not about to leave? Time spent dithering increases the chance you miss the train even if you then choose to run for it. So having made the decision in advance means over the long run you’ll catch more trains than you otherwise would have. (And given the downside is basically some extra cardio, this seems easily worth it.)
    Make better decisions
    More thoughtful decisions: Even aside from cases where you don’t have enough time to think much about a decision (like catching a train), it’s worth putting more time into a blanket policy than an individual decision. Rather than half-thinking through a type of decision a number of times, you might act better if you make a careful/thorough decision once and then act on that repeatedly (When the decisions are relevantly similar.).
    More objective decisions: In some cases, individual decision points are emotionally laden in a way that will bias your decision. In cases like that, you might make a more objective decision in advance than you would in the moment. For example, you might find it hard not to donate to a charity that’s raising money on the street if you have to decide whether to do that on the spur of the moment. You might feel your decision will be more objective if you think beforehand about the circumstances under which you do and don’t want to donate to charities when you pass fundraisers for them (eg yes for particular interventions, no for others).
    Help from others: I often find i...
    12 min
  • EA - Noting an unsubstantiated belief about the FTX disaster by Yitz
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Noting an unsubstantiated belief about the FTX disaster, published by Yitz on November 13, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    There is a narrative about the FTX collapse that I have noticed emerging as a commonly-held belief, despite little concrete evidence for or against it. The belief goes something like this:
    Sam Bankman Fried did what he did primarily for the sake of "Effective Altruism," as he understood it. Even though from a purely utilitarian perspective his actions were negative in expectation, he justified the fraud to himself because it was "for the greater good." As such, poor messaging on our part may be partially at fault for his downfall.
    This take may be more or less plausible, but it is also unsubstantiated. As Astrid Wilde noted on Twitter, there is a distinct possibility that the causality of the situation may have run the other way, with SBF as a conman taking advantage of the EA community's high-trust environment to boost himself. Alternatively (or additionally), it also seems quite plausible to me that the downfall of FTX had something to do with the social dynamics of the company, much as Enron's downfall can be traced back to [insert your favorite theory for why Enron collapsed here]. We do not, and to some degree cannot, know what SBF's internal monologue has been, and if we are to update our actions responsibly in order to avoid future mistakes of this magnitude (which we absolutely should do), we must deal with the facts as they most likely are, not as we would like or fear them to be.
    All of this said, I strongly suspect that in ten years from now, conventional wisdom will hold the above belief as being basically cannon, regardless of further evidence in either direction. This is because it presents an intrinsically interesting, almost Hollywood villain-esque narrative, one that will surely evoke endless "hot takes" which journalists, bloggers, etc. will have a hard time passing over. Expect this to become the default understanding of what happened (from outsiders at least), and prepare accordingly. At the same time, be cautious when updating your internal beliefs so as not to assume automatically that this story must be the truth of the matter.
    We need to carefully examine where our focus in self-improvement should lie moving forward, and it may not be the case that a revamping of our internal messaging is necessary (though it may very well be in the end; I certainly do not feel qualified to make that final call, only to point out what I recognize from experience as a temptingly powerful story beat which may influence it).
    Primarily on the Effective Altruism forum, but also on Twitter.
    See e.g. "pro fanaticism" messaging from some community factions, though it should be noted that this has always been a minority position.
    With roughly 80% confidence, conditional on 1.) No obviously true alternative story coming out about FTX that totally accounts for all their misdeeds somehow, and 2.) This post (or one containing the same observation), not becoming widely cited (since feedback loops can get complex and I don't want to bother accounting for that).
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    4 min