The Nonlinear Library

The Nonlinear Library

By The Nonlinear FundEducation
Download on the App Store

All The Nonlinear Library episodes

  • LW - Noting an unsubstantiated communal belief about the FTX disaster by Yitz
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Noting an unsubstantiated communal belief about the FTX disaster, published by Yitz on November 13, 2022 on LessWrong.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    1 min
  • EA - FTX FAQ by Hamish Doodles
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: FTX FAQ, published by Hamish Doodles on November 13, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    What is this?
    There's a lot of information flying around at the moment, and I'm going to try and organise it into an FAQ.
    I expect I have made a lot of mistakes, so please don't assume any specific claim here is true. This is definitely not legal or financial advice or anything like that.
    Please let me know if anything is wrong/unclear/misleading.
    Please suggest quesetions and/or answers in the comments.
    Update: actually, I would advise against wading into the comments.
    I'm erring on the side of brevity, so if you need more information follow the links.
    What is FTX?
    FTX is a Cryptocurrency Derivatives Exchange. It is now bankrupt.
    Who is Sam Bankman-Fried (SBF)?
    The founder of FTX. He was recently a billionaire and the richest person under 30.
    How is FTX connected to effective altruism?
    In the last couple of years, effective altruism received millions of dollars of funding from SBF and FTX via the Future Fund.
    SBF was following a strategy of "make tons of money to give it to charity." This is called "earning to give", and it's an idea that was spread by EA in early-to-mid 2010s. SBF was definitely encouraged onto his current path by engaging with EA.
    SBF was something of a "golden boy" to EA. For example, this.
    How did FTX go bankrupt?
    FTX gambled with user deposits rather than keeping them in reserve.
    Binance, a competitor, triggered a run on the bank where depositors attempted to get their money out.
    It looked like Binance was going to acquire FTX at one point, but they pulled out after due diligence.
    Now FTX and SBF are bunkrupt, and SBF will likely be convicted of felony.
    Source
    How bad is this?
    "It is therefore very likely to lead to the loss of deposits which will hurt the lives of 10,000s of people eg here"
    SBF will likely be convicted of felony.
    Source
    Did SBF definitely do something illegal and/or immoral?
    The vibe I'm reading is "very likely, but not yet certain."
    Does EA still have funding?
    Yes.
    Before FTX there was Open Philanthropy (OP), which is mostly funded by Dustin Muskovitz and Cari Tuna. None of this is connected to FTX, and OP's funding is unaffected.
    Is Open Philanthropy funding impacted?
    Global health and wellbeing funding will continue as normal.
    Because the total pool of funding to longtermism has shrunk, Open Philanthropy will have to raise the bar on longtermist grant making.
    Thus, Open Philanthropy is "pausing most new longtermist funding commitments" (longtermism includes AI, Biosecurity, and Community Growth) for a couple of months to recalibrate.
    Source
    If you got money from FTX, do you have to give it back?
    It's possible, but we don't know.
    What if you've already spent money from FTX?
    It's still possible that you may have to give it back. Again, we don't know.
    If you got money from FTX, should you give it back?
    You probably shouldn't, at least for the moment. If you gave the money back, there's the possibility that because it wasn't done through the proper legal channels you end up having to give the money back again.
    If you got money from FTX, should you spend it?
    Probably not. At least for the next few days. You may have to give it back.
    I feel terrible about having FTX money.
    Reading this may help.
    What if I'm still expecting FTX money?
    The board of the FTX future fund has all resigned, but "grantees may email [email protected]."
    How can I get support/help?
    "Here’s the best place to reach us if you’d like to talk. I know a form isn’t the warmest, but a real person will get back to you soon." (source)
    Some mental health advice here.
    How are people reacting?
    Will MacAskill: "If there was deception and misuse of funds, I am outraged, and I don’t know which emotion is stronger: my utter rage at Sam (and others?) for causing such ha...
    6 min
  • LW - Covid 11/10/22: Into the Background by Zvi
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Covid 11/10/22: Into the Background, published by Zvi on November 10, 2022 on LessWrong.
    There was a lot of news this week.
    Elon Musk continued to Do Things at Twitter.
    America had midterm elections. The polls were roughly accurate, with ‘candidate quality’ mattering more than expected especially on the Republican side.
    FTX imploded. For now I am letting Matt Levine handle coverage of what happened.
    None of it had anything directly to do with Covid. So this will be short.
    Executive Summary
    I hear there were midterms.
    And that FTX imploded.
    Covid death number down a lot, presumably not a real effect.
    Let’s run the numbers.
    The Numbers
    Predictions
    Predictions from Last Week: 255k cases (+7%) and 2,600 deaths (-1%)
    Results: 242k cases (+1%) and 1,993 deaths (-24%!).
    Predictions for Next Week: 250k cases (+4%) and 2,400 deaths (+20%).
    That death number is super weird. At first I thought ‘what, they can count votes or they can count deaths but not both at the same time?’ or ‘election day isn’t actually a holiday is it?’ Then the case number came in flat even in the South, although Alabama didn’t report any cases at all (which wasn’t a big enough effect for me to adjust).
    Some of the drop is that last week had a spike of about 250 deaths in North Carolina. Still leaves the majority of the gap unexplained. I don’t know. I don’t see how there could have been a large real drop in deaths, and if it was a reporting issue we would have seen a decline in cases. Also, in the regions where we see a decline in deaths, West and South, we don’t see relatively few cases. So the reporting explanations don’t make that much sense here, and it seems unlikely cases actually rose a lot while being underreported or anything like that.
    It does raise uncertainty in deaths a lot for next week, and to some extent also for cases, in the usual ‘was this real or was it both fake and in need of reversal’ dilemma. We shall see.
    The good news is that there is not much practical impact on decision making, unless this is all hiding a tidal wave of new infections. That is possible. I would still not expect anything like last year’s wave, and for things not go on too long before stabilizing, but the timing between weather and sub-variants would make some sense.
    Deaths
    Cases
    Booster Boosting and Variants
    Nothing.
    Physical World Modeling
    Babies born during lockdown more often miss developmental milestones (study).
    I doubt this leads to that much in the way of permanent impacts. It still seems rather not good, the effect sizes here are quite large.
    Study finds that Paxlovid reduces risk of Long Covid. Would be weird if it didn’t.
    China
    Via MR, Nucleic Acid Testing ‘now accounts for 1.3% of China’s GDP.’ Zero Covid is a rather large drag on China’s economy that will be cumulative over time. From the comments, which also interestingly feature massive negative votes everywhere:
    I’m a teacher in China and EVERYONE gets tested at least THREE times per week. It is such a waste of time and money.
    Meanwhile full surface paranoia continues. The Zero Covid principle and the constant testing would not be my approach, but I understand. The surfaces obsession is something different. Everyone has to know at this point that it doesn’t do anything.
    China reiterates Covid Zero Policy (Bloomberg), calls for more targeted and also ‘more decisive’ measures. No signs they will abandon surface paranoia. This seems like it likely gets worse before it gets better.
    And Now An Important Message
    An SNL sketch, best of the season by far. If you haven’t yet, watch it.
    Long Covid
    Article from Yale on chronic disease in general and how Long Covid may help us get a better understanding of what it is and how to deal with it. Does not provide much new. Mostly it is the same old ‘now that we have an Official Recognition for a chronic disease m...
    8 min
  • EA - In favour of compassion, and against bandwagons of outrage by Emrik
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: In favour of compassion, and against bandwagons of outrage, published by Emrik on November 13, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    I hate to add to the number of FTX posts on the forum, but after some (imo) inappropriate and unkind memes and comments in the Dank EA Memes fb group and elsewhere, I wanted to push back against what seems like a bandwagon of anger and ridicule spiralling too far, and I wish to call attention to it.
    But first, I should point out that I personally, at this time, know not nearly enough to make confident conclusions regarding what's happened at FTX. That means I will not make any morally relevant judgments. I will especially not insinuate them without sufficient evidence. That just amounts to irresponsibly fuelling the bandwagon while maintaining plausible deniability, which is arguably worse.
    You are not required to pretend to know more than you do just so you can empathise with the outrage of your friends. That shouldn't be how friendship works.
    This topic is not without nuance. There's a good case to be made for why ridicule can be pro-social, and I think Alex makes it here:
    "Ridicule makes clear our commitment to punishing ultimately harmful behavior, in a tit-for-tat sense; we are not the government so we cannot lock up wrongdoers, and acting as a vigilante assassin is precluded by other issues, so our top utility-realizing option is to meme harmful behavior out of the sphere of social acceptability."
    I don't disagree with condemning someone for having behaved unethically. It's a necessary part of maintaining civil society, and it enables people to cooperate and trade in good faith. But if you accuse someone of having ill-advisedly forsaken ethics in the (putative) service of the greater good, then retaliating by forsaking compassion in the service of unchecked mockery can't possibly make anything better.
    Why bother with compassion, you might ask? After all, compassion is superfluous for positive-sum cooperation. What we really need for essential social institutions to work at all is widespread trust in the basic ethics of people we trade with. So when a public figure gets caught depreciating that trust, it's imperative that we send a strong signal that this is completely unacceptable.
    This I all agree with. Judicious punishments are essential for safeguarding prevailing social institutions. Plain fact. But what if prevailing social institutions are unjust? When we jump on a bandwagon for humiliating the accused transgressor after their life has already fallen apart, we are exercising our instincts for mob justice, and we are indirectly strengthening the norm for coercing deviants more generally.
    Advocating punitive attitudes trades off against advocating for compassion to some extent. Especially if the way you're trying to advocate for punishments is by means of gleefwly inflicting harm.
    In a society where most people are all too eager to join in when they see their in-group massing against deviants, and where groups have wildly different opinions on who the deviants are in the first place, we need an alternative set of principles.
    Compassion is a corrective on unjust social norms. It lets us see more clearly where prevailing ethics strays from what's kind and good. In essence, that's the whole purpose of effective altruism: to do better than the unquestioned norms that's been handed down to us.
    Hence why I hope we can outgrow--or at least lend nuance to--our reflexive instinct to punish, and instead cultivate whatever embers of compassion we can find. Let that be our cultural contribution, because the alternative, advocating punitive sentiments, just isn't a neglected cause area.
    example, example, example, and example.
    comment
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    4 min
  • EA - Ways to buy time by Akash
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Ways to buy time, published by Akash on November 12, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    1 min
  • EA - Women and Effective Altruism by Keerthana Gopalakrishnan
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Women and Effective Altruism, published by Keerthana Gopalakrishnan on November 12, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    A lot has been talked about SBF/FTX/EA but this coverage reminds me that is time to talk about the toxicity of the culture within EA communities, especially as it relates to women.
    EA circles, much like the group house in Bahamas, are widely incestous where people mix their work life (in EA cause areas), their often polyamorous love life and social life in one amalgomous mix without strict separations. This is the default status quo. This means that if you’re a reasonably attractive woman entering an EA community, you get a ton of sexual requests to join polycules, often from poly and partnered men. Some of these men control funding for projects and enjoy high status in EA communities and that means there are real downsides to refusing their sexual advances and pressure to say yes, especially if your career is in an EA cause area or is funded by them. There are also upsides, as reported by CoinDesk on Caroline Ellison. From experience it appears that, a ‘no’ once said is not enough for many men in EA.
    Having to keep replenishing that ‘no’ becomes annoying very fast, and becomes harder to give informed consent when socializing in the presence of alcohol/psychedelics. It puts your safety at risk. From experience, EA as a community, has very little respect for monogamy and many men, often competing with each other, will persuade you to join polyamory using LessWrong style jedi mindtricks while they stand to benefit from the erosion of your boundaries. (Edit: I have personally experienced this more than three times in less than one year of attending EA events and that is far too many times. )
    So how do these men maintain polycules and find sexual novelty? EA meet ups of course. Several EA communities are grounds for predatory men in search of their nth polycule partner and to fill their “dancecards”. I have seen this in NYC EA circles, I have seen this in SF. I decided to stop socializing in EA circles a couple months ago due to this toxicity, the benefits are not worth the uncovered downside risk. I also am lucky enough to not work for an EA aligned organization / cause area and socially diversified enough to take that hit. The power enjoyed by men who are predatory, the rate of occurrence and a lack of visible push back equals to a tacit and somewhat widespread backing for this behaviour. My experience resonates with a few other women in SF I have spoken to. They have also met red pilled, exploitative men in EA/rationalist circles. EA/rationalism and redpill fit like yin and yang.
    Akin to how EA is an optimization of altruism with “suboptimal” human tendencies like morality and empathy stripped from it, red pill is an optimized sexual strategy with the humanity of women stripped from it. You’ll also, surprisingly, encounter many women who are redpilled and manifest internalized misogyny in EA. How to check if you’re one: if terms like SMV, hypergamy etc are part of your everyday vocabulary and thought processes, you might be affected. You’ll also encounter many women who are unhappy participants in polygamous relationships; some of them really smart women who agree to be unhappy (dump him, sis). And if you're a lucky woman who hasn't experienced this in EA, great, and your experience does not need to negate those of others.
    Despite this culture, EA as a philosophy has a lot of good in it and they should fix this bug with some introspection. Now mind you, this is not a criticism of polyamory itself. If polyamorous love happens between consenting adults without favoritism in professional settings, all is well and good. But EA is an organization and community focused on a mission of altruism, enjoy huge swathes of donor money and exert socio-political ...
    6 min
  • EA - Internalizing the damage of bad-acting partners creates incentives for due diligence by tailcalled
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Internalizing the damage of bad-acting partners creates incentives for due diligence, published by tailcalled on November 11, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    1 min
  • EA - After recent FTX events, what are alternative sources of funding for longtermist projects? by CarolineJ
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: After recent FTX events, what are alternative sources of funding for longtermist projects?, published by CarolineJ on November 12, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    Now that we know "that it looks likely that there are many committed grants that the Future Fund will be unable to honor" according to the former team of FTX Future Funds, it would be useful for a number of us to have alternatives.
    Current large funders are re-considering their grant strategy (such as OpenPhil). These donors are going to be extremely busy in the next few weeks. If you're not too funding-constrained, it seems like a good and pro-social strategy is to wait until after the storm and let others who have urgent and important grants figure things out.
    However, it seems that this may not be true if you are very funding-restrained right now, or if some grants or fellowships have deadlines coming up soon that it may be useful to have on your radar.
    So, what are good places to apply for funding now? (and in the future too)
    To start, the FLI AI Existential Safety PhD Fellowship has a deadline on November 15.
    The Vitalik Buterin PhD Fellowship in AI Existential Safety is for PhD students who plan to work on AI existential safety research, or for existing PhD students who would not otherwise have funding to work on AI existential safety research. It will fund students for 5 years of their PhD, with extension funding possible. At universities in the US, UK, or Canada, annual funding will cover tuition, fees, and the stipend of the student's PhD program up to $40,000, as well as a fund of $10,000 that can be used for research-related expenses such as travel and computing. At universities not in the US, UK or Canada, the stipend amount will be adjusted to match local conditions. Fellows will also be invited to workshops where they will be able to interact with other researchers in the field.
    Applicants who are short-listed for the Fellowship will be reimbursed for application fees for up to 5 PhD programs, and will be invited to an information session about research groups that can serve as good homes for AI existential safety research.
    More about the fellowship here.
    What are other options?
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    3 min
  • LW - Rudeness, a useful coordination mechanic by Raemon
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Rudeness, a useful coordination mechanic, published by Raemon on November 11, 2022 on LessWrong.
    I think the concept of "rudeness" is underappreciated. (Or, if people are appreciating it, they're doing so quietly where I can't find out about it)
    I think a lot of coordination-social-tech relies on there being some kind of karmic balance. A lot of actions aren't expressly illegal, and not even blatantly all-the-time socially sanctioned. But if you do them a bit, it's considered rude, and if you're rude all the time, you get a reputation for being rude, and this comes with some consequences (i.e. not invited to as many parties).
    The-concept-of-rudeness gives you a tool to softly shape your culture, and have some kind of standards, without having to be really rigid about it.
    [Edit to add:]I'm writing this post because I was writing another coordination/epistemic-norms post, and I found myself wanting to write the sentence "If you do [X thing], it should be considered a bit rude. If you do [X' worse version of X thing], it's more rude." And then I realized this was resting on some underlying assumptions about coordination-culture that might not be obvious to everyone. (i.e. that it's good to have some things be considered "rude")
    I come from a game-design background. In many games, there are multiple resources, and there are multiple game-mechanics for spending those resources, or having them interact with each other. You might have life-points, you might have some kind of "money" (which can store value and then be spent in arbitrary quantities), or renewable resources (like grains that grow back every year, and spoil if you leave them too long).
    Many good games have rich mechanics that you can fine-tune, to shape the player's experience. A flexible mechanic gives you knobs-to-turn, to make some actions more expensive or cheaper.
    The invention of "money" in real life was a useful coordination mechanic.
    The invention of "vague social capital that you accumulate doing high status respectable things, and which you can lose by doing low status unrespectable things" predates money by a long time, and is still sometimes useful in ways that money is not.
    A feeling-of-rudeness is one particular flavor of what "spending-down social capital" can feel like, from the inside of a social interaction.
    [/edit]
    Different cultures have different conceptions of "what is rude." Some of that is silly/meaningless, or actively harmful. Some of it is arbitrary (but maybe the arbitrariness is doing some secret social cohesion that's not obvious and autists should learn to respect anyway). In some cultures belching at a meal is rude, in others not belching at a meal is rude. I think there's probably value in having shared scripts for showing respect.
    Epistemic cultures have their own uses for "the rudeness mechanic."
    You might consider it rude to loudly assert people should agree with you, without putting forth evidence to support your claim.
    You might consider it rude to make a strong claim without being willing to make concrete bets based on it. Or, you might consider it rude to demand people to make bets on topics that are fuzzy and aren't actually amenable to forecasting.
    Rudeness depends on circumstance
    Different domains might warrant different kinds of conceptions-of-rudeness. In the military, I suspect "being rude to your superiors" is actually an important thing to discourage, so that decisions can get made quickly. But it can be actively harmful in innovation driven industries.
    An individual norm of "rudeness" can be context-dependent and depend on other norms. According to this Quora article, in Japan it's normally rude to tell your boss he's wrong, but also you're supposed to go out drinking with your boss where it's more okay to say rude things under the cover of alcohol.
    Problems with...
    5 min
  • EA - A personal statement on FTX by William MacAskill
    Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: A personal statement on FTX, published by William MacAskill on November 12, 2022 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
    This is a repost from a Twitter thread I made last night. It reads a little oddly when presented as a Forum post, but I wanted to have the content shared here for those not on Twitter.
    This is a thread of my thoughts and feelings about the actions that led to FTX’s bankruptcy, and the enormous harm that was caused as a result, involving the likely loss of many thousands of innocent people’s savings.
    Based on publicly available information, it seems to me more likely than not that senior leadership at FTX used customer deposits to bail out Alameda, despite terms of service prohibiting this, and a (later deleted) tweet from Sam claiming customer deposits are never invested.
    Some places making the case for this view include this article from Wall Street Journal, this tweet from jonwu.eth, this article from Bloomberg (and follow on articles).
    I am not certain that this is what happened. I haven’t been in contact with anyone at FTX (other than those at Future Fund), except a short email to resign from my unpaid advisor role at Future Fund. If new information vindicates FTX, I will change my view and offer an apology.
    But if there was deception and misuse of funds, I am outraged, and I don’t know which emotion is stronger: my utter rage at Sam (and others?) for causing such harm to so many people, or my sadness and self-hatred for falling for this deception.
    I want to make it utterly clear: if those involved deceived others and engaged in fraud (whether illegal or not) that may cost many thousands of people their savings, they entirely abandoned the principles of the effective altruism community.
    If this is what happened, then I cannot in words convey how strongly I condemn what they did. I had put my trust in Sam, and if he lied and misused customer funds he betrayed me, just as he betrayed his customers, his employees, his investors, & the communities he was a part of.
    For years, the EA community has emphasised the importance of integrity, honesty, and the respect of common-sense moral constraints. If customer funds were misused, then Sam did not listen; he must have thought he was above such considerations.
    A clear-thinking EA should strongly oppose “ends justify the means” reasoning. I hope to write more soon about this. In the meantime, here are some links to writings produced over the years.
    These are some relevant sections from What We Owe The Future:
    Here is Toby Ord in The Precipice:
    Here is Holden Karnofsky:
    Here are the Centre for Effective Altruism’s Guiding Principles:
    If FTX misused customer funds, then I personally will have much to reflect on. Sam and FTX had a lot of goodwill – and some of that goodwill was the result of association with ideas I have spent my career promoting. If that goodwill laundered fraud, I am ashamed.
    As a community, too, we will need to reflect on what has happened, and how we could reduce the chance of anything like this from happening again. Yes, we want to make the world better, and yes, we should be ambitious in the pursuit of that.
    But that in no way justifies fraud. If you think that you’re the exception, you’re duping yourself.
    We must make clear that we do not see ourselves as above common-sense ethical norms, and must engage criticism with humility.
    I know that others from inside and outside of the community have worried about the misuse of EA ideas in ways that could cause harm. I used to think these worries, though worth taking seriously, seemed speculative and unlikely.
    I was probably wrong. I will be reflecting on this in the days and months to come, and thinking through what should change.
    Thanks for listening. To help us out with The Nonlinear Library or to learn more, please visit nonlinear.org.
    4 min