The Partial Historians

The Partial Historians

By The Partial HistoriansSociety & CultureEducationHistory
Download on the App Store

All The Partial Historians episodes

  • Episode 104 – Aventine, Aventine

    We return to the City of Rome in 456 BCE and follow the ongoing domestic struggles that Rome faces in defining herself in terms of transparency at law.

    Episode 104 – Aventine, Aventine

    With a new crop of tribunes come some important consequences. While in previous years the tribunes have focused on the goal of ensuring that there is a clear and public way for any Roman citizen to access the laws in order to understand them, with new tribunes comes a shift in thinking.

    A Return to Redistribution of Public Land

    After a long hiatus, the issue of public land returns to the tribunician agenda. It's safe to say that things are about to get messy in Rome.

    If there's one thing the patricians never seem to want to budge on, it's negotiating the fair use of public land.

    Ten Tribunes Means Twice the Representation!

    Not only are there new tribunes but there are now plenty more of them representing the plebeians. We'll get a taste of what can happen with a larger group of tribunes. That's a lot of bodies to protect the interests of citizens and we'll see how that magisterial privilege can be deployed.

    The Lex Icilia de Aventino Publicando

    We delve into the nitty gritty of the law passed in this year which is unusual for a number of reasons.

    The PlayersConsuls
    • Marcus Valerius M'. f. Volusi n. Maxumus Lactuca (pat)
    • Spurius Verginius A. f. A. n. Tricostus Caeliomontanus (pat)
    Tribunes
    • Lucius Icilius
    • Lucius Alienus
    Sources

    Dr Rad read Livy Ab Urbe Condita 3.31
    Dr G reads Dionysius of Halicarnassus Roman Antiquities 10.31-32

    J. M. W. Turner c.1820s-1836. Rome, from Mount Aventine.
    Finding a painting that could do justice to the early Republican Aventine was tough, so we opted for this gorgeous, though much later view back onto nineteenth century Rome instead.

    Sound Credits
    • Sound Effects courtesy of BBC Sound Effects (Beta), Pond5, and Lewi Pilgrim
    • Final credits: Excerpt from ‘Ancient Arcadian Harp’ by Cormi

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    40 min
  • Episode 103 – Ten Terrific Tribunes

    It's c. 457 BCE in Rome and in this episode we explore the state of affairs in the wake of Cincinnatus' dictatorship.

    Rome's affairs with her neighbours are not off to a good start. As the City lifts her gaze outward after recent troubles, nearby peoples have taken matters into their own hands. The Sabines and the Aequians are both making bold moves stretching Rome's attention both to the north and the south.

    Episode 103 – Ten Terrific Tribunes

    The Law About the Laws

    As Rome faces threats from a range of peoples, the usual patrician policy of fielding a citizen army through the levy comes about. We're in pretty familiar territory here as the levy has been a sore point for years according to our narrative tradition and we can reliably expect the tribunes of the people to request greater transparency in relation to the laws. The desire for a law code that is public and accessible is increasing.

    As tensions rise, the differing political aims of the Senate, the consuls, and the tribunes clash.

    Things to Look Forward to
    • Roman masculinity – how to define it and what it means from the perspective of a Greek writer
    • Cincinnatus makes a fantastically interesting speech!
    • Horatius tries to rally the people together for war while preserving the patrician position of privilege
    • A discussion of some of the intersections and conflicts that arise from gender and class narratives
    • A rhetorical exploration of age versus youth
    • A proposal to increase the number of plebeian tribunes to ten!
    • The senatorial back-and-forth regarding the pros and cons of increasing the number of the plebeian tribunes
    • Hints of when we recorded this piece – during the long Australian bushfire season, but prior to concerns about COVID-19
    Who's WhoConsuls
    • Quintus Minucius P.f. M. n. Esquilinus (pat.)
    • Marcus (Gaius?) Horatius M. f. M. n. Pulvillus (pat.) COS II
    Tribunes
    • Aulus Verginius
    • Volscius Fictor (?)
    • Two or three other tribunes unnamed in our sources
    Sources
    • Dr G reads Dionysius of Halicarnassus Roman Antiquities 10.26-30
    • Dr Rad reads Livy Ab Urbe Condita 3.29-30

    Jean Lemaire c. 1645-55 Roman Senators and Legates

    Sound Credits
    • Sound Effects courtesy of BBC Sound Effects (Beta), and John Stracke via Sound Bible
    • Final credits: Excerpt from ‘Ancient Arcadian Harp’ by Cormi

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    44 min
  • Special Episode – An Interview with Emeritus Professor Edwin Judge

    We had the very great pleasure to sit down with Emeritus Professor Edwin Judge to discuss his latest publication The Failure of Augustus: Essays on the Interpretation of a Paradox (2019).

    Special Episode – An Interview with Emeritus Professor Edwin Judge

    Judge has a long-reaching career, accepting his first junior lectureship in the 1950s and going on accept the inaugural History Chair at Macquarie University in Sydney. Dr G and Dr Rad met as undergraduate students at Macquarie so it is our extraordinary pleasure to sit down with Judge and have the chance to chat.

    Dr G (left) holding Cooley's Res Gestae, Emeritus Professor Edwin Judge (centre), and Dr Rad (right) holding Judge's The Failure of Augustus

    In this far reaching
    conversation we learn about Judge's evolving thoughts on Augustus
    over the course of his academic career, some of the salient
    connections between Augustus and Tiberius that emerge from
    considering Augustus' aims, the content of the Res Gestae
    Divi Augusti
    , and consideration
    of Augustus in terms of failure.

    Things to look forward to:
    • A
      consideration of the importance of understanding time as a means of
      approaching historical interpretation
    • The
      challenges that Tiberius faces in the wake of Augustus' death
    • The
      importance of the Res Gestae as a lens to Augustus' life and
      career
    • Key materials
      for approaching the subject of Augustus' failure.

    The cursus honorem of Augustus, as visualised by Edwin Judge. Used with permission of the author. This table appears on the cover of The Failure of Augustus and page 8 of the collection.

    Reading
    recommendations

    Cooley, Alison E. 2009. Res Gestae Divi Augusti: Text, Translation and Commentary

    Judge, E. A. 2019. The Failure of Augustus: Essays on the Interpretation of a Paradox

    Lintott, Andrew W. 1999. Violence in Republican Rome

    Ridley, Ronald T. 2003. The emperor's retrospect: Augustus' Res gestae in epigraphy, historiography and commentary

    Final credits: Excerpt from ‘Ancient Arcadian Harp’ by Cormi

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    1 hr 7 min
  • Episode 102 – Cincinnatus, Dictator

    It's c. 458 BCE and
    Rome's troubles culminate in the appointment of a dictator. In this
    episode we explore the context which leads to the appointment of this
    emergency position and trace Rome's progress as she attempts to face
    enemies on multiple fronts.

    Episode 102 – Cincinnatus, Dictator

    Not only are Roman forces squaring off against the Sabines and the Aequians, but there are ongoing issues on the home front. According to the narrative histories of Livy and Dionysius of Halicarnassus, the tribunes of the plebs continue to lobby for transparency regarding the laws. The struggle to pin down a public law code seems elusive. In this year it is also overshadowed by the troubles that Minucius' consular forces face in the south-east.

    The Aequians are currently led by Cloelius Gracchus and the Roman forces led by the consul Minucius have been trapped in a valley, while the other consul Nautius is campaigning against the Sabines.

    The Dictator

    Our sources are at pains to let us know that Cincinnatus was both unprepared for his appointment as dictator and not particularly pleased to have the role foist upon him. This is part of a larger trope established in Latin literature of the good leader whose fitness for the role is encapsulated by his lack of ambition for it.

    In this way, both Livy and Dionysius offer us a chance to see Cincinnatus—and indeed this era of patrician history—as one populated with brave, proud characters who understood the hierarchy and were staunchly traditional in their outlook.

    What does a dictator
    do?

    As the most significant magistrate in Roman society, the dictator has a superior legal capacity to make commands and can hold the position for up to six months. Despite his generally dissatisfaction with the situation, Cincinnatus jumps straight in. We'll be looking at how he goes about:

    • Raising an
      army
    • Organising
      troops
    • And getting
      on the march

    We explore what Cincinnatus gets up to in the role and how he contributes to supporting Minucius against the Aequians at Mount Algidus. Tune in to hear all about:

    • The military tactics Cincinnatus deploys
    • How Cincinnatus deals with requests for peace
    • Some rather unusual divisions of booty
    • Just what happens to the Aequian city of Corbio
    • A triumph!
    • The incredible virtus of Cincinnatus!

    Alexander Cabanel 1843. Cincinnatus receives the ambassadors of Rome

    Our players458 BCE

    Dictator

    • L. Quinctius
      L. f. L. n. Cincinnatus

    Master of the Horse

    • L. Tarquitius
      L. f. Flaccus

    Consuls

    • C. Nautius
      Sp. f. Sp. n. Rutilus – cos II
    • L. Minucius
      P. f. M. n Esquilinus Augurinus

    Prefect of the City

    • Q. Fabius
      Vibulanus

    Tribunes

    • Aulus
      Verginius
    • Marcus
      Volscius Fictor (it's not certain whether Volscius holds the
      tribunianship in 459 BCE)

    Aequian Leader

    • Cloelius
      Gracchus

    Dictator's wife

    • Racilia

    ‘Freedom of the
    City'

    • L.
      Mamilius the
      Tusculan
    Sources

    Dr Rad explores Livy 3.26-29

    Dr G is considering Dionysius of Halicarnassus Roman Antiquities 10.23-25

    Sound Credits

    Sound Effects courtesy of BBC Sound Effects (Beta) and Free SFX
    Final credits: Excerpt from ‘Ancient Arcadian Harp' by Cormi

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    52 min
  • A Tribute to Kirk Douglas

    Join Dr Rad as she reminiscences about one of her film favourites and pays tribute to the man that has unwittingly dominated her life for over a decade.

    Special Episode – A Tribute to Kirk Douglas

    2020 has been on my radar for a while, listeners, as it marks sixty years since the iconic movie Spartacus was released. However, just a few days before the Oscars, the star of this film has passed away at the age of 103. Given the helicopter crash, the strokes, it is amazing that he lived this long, but I still feel very melancholy that a film star of his stature is no more.

    The Chin Dimple that COULD launch a thousand ships. Kirk Douglas' magnificent face-acting during the famous ‘I'm Spartacus' scene. Image courtesy of https://hollywoodrevue.wordpress.com/2016/12/11/simpson-sunday-cartoon-without-pity/

    I have a strong affinity for Issur Danielovitch (Kirk Douglas) and not just because I grew up watching his movies (which I did). Loyal listeners will be aware that I ended up studying the production of Spartacus (1960), the historical film based on the famous slave revolt against Rome. As the titular hero, but more importantly as the producer of this film, Douglas played a key role in shaping the representation of the rebellious gladiator.

    Indeed, it was quite an accomplishment that this movie made it to the screen at all, as film star/producer Yul Brynner was also championing a Spartacus project at the same time. On top of this rivalry, Douglas' project was plagued with personality clashes and squabbles about the overall vision for the film. This led to constant changes to the script, and Douglas did little to contain this, earning the nickname ‘General Mixmaster' on set.

    Douglas in costume on set talking to his young, and not particularly well-known, director Stanley Kubrick. The men had worked together previously on Paths of Glory, but the tensions over Spartacus would cause a rift to open between them. Image courtesy of https://www.rapportoconfidenziale.org/?p=36320

    However, it is undeniable that Douglas' drive is one of the most important factors that led to the completion and success of this film in 1960.

    The movie is largely remembered these days for the iconic ‘I'm Spartacus' scene and its' status as the film that finally broke the blacklist (in America at least). The real story about the breaking of the blacklist is a little more complicated, which you can read about here.

    During this dark time in America, screenwriters were some of the only professionals in this environment who could potentially evade the restrictions placed on their employment. One such blacklistee, Dalton Trumbo, had been hired by Bryna (Douglas' production company). Trumbo had been working tirelessly to see his name restored to the credits by the time he started writing the Spartacus script. Douglas probably did not intend to grant this desire during the early days, but he had changed his mind by the time of the premiere.

    Kirk Douglas spent hours trying to get his scene on the cross just right. Whilst he may have been one of the causes of confusion on set, no one could question his dedication to Spartacus. Image courtesy of https://www.nieuwsblad.be/cnt/dmf20161208_02615140

    There were a variety of external pressures that went into this decision (cough cough Otto Preminger), and we shouldn't imagine that after Spartacus, the blacklist vanished. Really, this was a sign that change was ahead. The blacklist lingered painfully into the 1960s, but the rebel gladiator had once again struck a blow for freedom.

    Although there's a lot more to the end of the blacklist than this one film, Douglas does indeed deserve a large share of the credit for making what was a bold decision for the time, and one that could have had unfortunate consequences for himself, Bryna Productions or Universal-International.

    Farewell, Kirk Douglas, you charismatic egomaniac. Like Spartacus, you will not be soon forgotten.

    If you enjoy learning about the 1950s in Hollywood, check out our previous episode on Spartacus and the blacklist series of You Must Remember This.

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    22 min
  • Episode 101 – Talk to the Tree

    It can be quite insulting to be told to ‘talk to the hand' and, for the Romans, it would seem that being told to ‘talk to the tree' is just as problematic. In this episode, we explore the tail end of 459 BCE and enter 458 BCE. It's fair to say that some mud is being flung between Rome and her neighbours…

    Episode 101 – Talk to the Tree

    The Trouble with
    Murder…

    Livy and Dr Rad have some excellent details to offer about the ongoing and troubling ambiguity surrounding the plebeian push for the ‘the law about the laws'. This ongoing issues between patrician interests and the tribunes fighting for greater transparency is soon waylaid, however, by concerns pertaining to the recent accusation of murder! Dr Rad delves into the murky narrative and Livy's account of the affair.

    New Year, Same
    Tribunes

    Intrigues and law cases regarding potentially spurious accusations of murder give way to new elections and we find ourselves in c. 458 BCE. Both Verginius and Volscius make it back it into the tribuneship!

    Listen out for Dr G forgetting Volscius (awkward for everyone) and temporarily being unable to read a map (to clarify, the Sabines and the Aequians are both East of Rome, North and South respectively).

    Trouble in the South

    It isn't long before Rome learns of Aequian incursions into Tusculum, which is a huge surprise given the peace treaty concluded between Rome and the Aequians just the year before. Listen in to find out how:

    • Rome reacts to threats from the south
    • the fetiales get involved
    • and oak trees take on an important cameo role

    While Dionysius of
    Halicarnassus gets swept up in the military narrative, Livy seeks to
    balance the challenges the Rome faces externally and internally…

    Our Players459 BCE

    Consuls

    • Q. Fabius M.
      f. K. Vibulanus
    • L. Cornelius
      Ser. f. P. n. Maluginensis Uritinus

    Prefect of the City

    • Lucius
      Lucretius (Tricipitinus)

    Tribunes

    • Aulus Verginius
    • Marcus Volscius Fictor (maybe a tribune)

    Quaestors

    • Aulus
      Cornelius
    • Quintus
      Servilius (Structus Priscus?)

    Patrician

    • Kaeso
      Quinctius

    458 BCE

    Consuls

    • C. Nautius
      Sp. f. Sp. n. Rutilus – cos II
    • L. Minucius
      P. f. M. n Esquilinus Augurinus

    Prefect of the City

    • Q. Fabius
      Vibulanus

    Tribunes

    • Aulus Verginius
    • Marcus Volscius Fictor

    Quaestor

    • M. Valerius
      M'. f. Volusi Maximus
    • T. Quintius
      Capitolinus Barbatus

    Roman Embassy

    • Q. Fabius
      Vibulanus (also Prefect of the City)
    • P. Volumnius
      Amintinus Gallus
    • A. Postumius
      Albus Regillensis

    Aequian Leader

    • Cloelius
      Gracchus

    Claude Lorrain 1682 Ascanius Shooting the Stag of Sylvia, chosen for its artful arrangement of trees, which are quite pertinent to this episode. The story of Ascanius we'll save for another time.

    Additional sounds in this episode: BBC and WolframTones

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    50 min
  • Episode 100 – The Consulship

    We've reached a huge
    milestone! One hundred episodes is quite something and we're super
    chuffed to have made it this far. To celebrate we've put together a
    very special episode for you on the consulship.

    Episode 100 – The Consulship

    While our narrative history of Rome is still very much in the early republic, the consul is a position that many aficionados of ancient Rome are familiar with. But how much do we know about the consul especially in the early years of the republic? We're here to sift through the evidence!

    After the Kings

    After the expulsion of the Tarquins, Rome is left facing a crisis of governance. How best to restructure the state in the wake of the collapse of monarchy?

    The Romans innovative solution was to divide the powers of the rex between two men, thereby saving the populace from the tyranny of a sole ruler. But to claim that the Romans came to this decision cleanly, and with a clarity of what this would really look like, is to miss the fascinating complexities of the way the role developed over time.

    What
    Makes a Consul?

    In this special episode we'll trace the some of the key features of the consulship and explore what the position entailed in the early republic, the late republic, and the early empire. There's plenty to enjoy here including:

    • a return to the relationship between magistracies and assemblies;
    • the role of consuls in war;
    • and the consuls' relationship with the gods.

    Alexandre Jacovleff ‘Ancient Roman Senators' illustration for The General History Edited by Satyricon (1911)

    Sources

    Interested in learning more about the consulship? These are the major sources we consulted in preparation for this episode and we definitely recommend them for getting a handle on the subject!

    Beck, H., Duplá, A., Jehne, M., & Pino Polo, F. 2011. ‘The republic and its highest office: some introductory remarks on the Roman consulate’ in Beck, H., Duplá, A., Jehne, M., Pina Polo, F. (eds) Consuls and Res Publica: Holding High Office in the Roman Republic (Cambridge University Press), 1-15.

    ‘Consul' in Pauly's Realencyclopadie der classischen Altumsumswissenschaft Band IV, 1, col. 1112-1138 (1900).

    Eck, W. 2019. ‘Suffect consul‘ in Cancik, H., Schneider, H., Salazar, C. F. (eds) Brill's New Pauly (Last accessed 29/9/2019)

    Drogula, F. K. 2015. Commanders and Command in the Roman Republic and Early Empire (University of North Carolina Press)

    Gizewski, C. 2019. ‘Consul(es)' in Cancik, H., Schneider, H., Salazar, C. F. (eds) Brill's New Pauly (Last accessed 29/9/2019)

    Hölkeskamp, K. 2011. ‘The Roman republic as theatre of power: the consuls as leading actors’ in Beck, H., Duplá, A., Jehne, M., Pina Polo, F. (eds) Consuls and Res Publica: Holding High Office in the Roman Republic (Cambridge University Press), 161-181.

    Hurlet, F. 2011. ‘Consulship and consuls under Augustus’ in Beck, H., Duplá, A., Jehne, M., Pina Polo, F. (eds) Consuls and Res Publica: Holding High Office in the Roman Republic (Cambridge University Press), 319-35.

    Malik, S.; Davenport, C., ‘Mythbusting Ancient Rome – Caligula’s Horse’ (4/5/2017), The Conversation (Last accessed on 5/10/2019)

    Scullard, H. H. 1982. From the Gracchi to Nero (Routledge, London)

    Smith, C. 2011. ‘The magistrates of the early Republic’, in Beck, H., Duplá, A., Jehne, M., Pina Polo, F. (eds) Consuls and Res Publica: Holding High Office in the Roman Republic (Cambridge University Press), 19-40.

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    58 min
  • Episode 99 – Tusculum and Antium

    It is c. 459 BCE and Rome faces the consequences of the Capitol having been seized and a consul killed in the previous year. The challenges come on two fronts: Tusculum and Antium.

    Episode 99 – Tusculum and Antium

    Consuls
    • Quintus Fabius M. f. K. n. Vibulanus cos. III
    • Lucius Cornelius Ser. f. P. n. Maluginensus Uritnus
    Trouble at the Margins

    The Latins and
    Hernicians (Rome's allies) come to Rome to report that the Volscians
    and the Aequians are still causing trouble at the edges of allied
    territory. Rome sends some troops to Antium.

    The Aequians
    surprise attack Rome's friend Tusculum. According to Dionysius this
    involves enslaving many of the women but leaving many of the men
    untouched. The Romans are pretty upset by this turn of events and
    throw themselves into action.

    These tussles lead to military actions in Algidum and Ecetra, both of which are near the territory of the Aequians and the latter is described by Dionysius as the “most prominent city of the Volscian nation” (Dion. Hal. Ant. Rom. 10.21.3).

    How Do You Solve a
    Problem Like Antium?

    Rome has been raiding Antium for the past few years and recently converted the city into a Roman colony. None of these measures can be considered wholly successful.

    As news of the seizure of Rome's Capitol reaches south, it seems like a good time to revolt. This is spearheaded by the Volscians, which makes perfect sense as Antium is part of their historical sphere of influence.

    Livy and Dionysius of Haliarnassus disagree on a range of details about how this conflict unfolds so it's fair to say that we're less than impressed with our narrative sources right now! Nevertheless, what they do tell us is very interesting:

    • Livy has Rome heading in with a force made up of Romans and allies and devastating the Volscian camp by surprising them.
    • Dionysius offers us a tale of Rome turning Antium into a camp by surrounding it with palisades!
    Who's Doing The
    Fighting Anyway?

    Despite Rome facing
    a war on two fronts this year, Livy suggests that when the forces are
    drawn up, they are mostly comprised on allied troops, with only a
    third of the manpower offered by Rome herself. Is this a sign of
    Rome's growing hegemony over her immediate neighbours?

    Join us for some
    very conflicting accounts from Livy and Dionysius of Halicarnassus as
    we delve into the complicated relationships between the Romans,
    Volscians, Aequians, Tusculans, Latins, and Hernicians!

    P.S. Be on the listen for our podcat Hamish who makes a guest appearance!

    An artistic impression of what early Republican soliders may have looked like (right). If you know the artist, please let us know so we can credit them appropriately.

    Our Sources:

    • Dr G is
      reading Dionysius of Halicarnassus Roman Antiquities 10.20-21
    • Dr
      R is reading Livy Ab
      Urbe
      Condita 3.22-24

    Selected Secondary Sources:

    • Broughton, T. R. S. 1951. The Magistrates of the Roman
      Republic,
      Volume I (American Philological Association)
    • Lomas, K. 2017. The Rise of Rome: from the Iron Age to
      the Punic Wars
      (1000-264 BC) (Profile Books)

    Sound Credits:

    Additional sounds were provided by:

    • Fesliyan Studios
    • Pond5

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    42 min
  • *Special Episode* What Does Your Toga Say About You?

    Dr Amy Place from the University of Leicester sits down with Dr Rad to discuss the humble Roman toga, fashion and social identity, and everyday life in late imperial Roman North Africa!

    On a recent tour to Australia, Place presented a paper for the SPQR Roman History Forum at Macquarie University on the representation of fashions in Late Roman North Africa. The Partial Historians we lucky enough to grab the chance to chat.

    *Special Episode* – What Does Your Toga Say About You?

    Late Roman North Africa is a time period and an area that is understudied, but just as fascinating as Italy. Place is particularly interested in how clothing is represented and how it was used to express social identity.

    Dominus Julius Mosaic from Carthage, Bardo Museum. Copyright credit: Sean Leatherbury/Manar al-Athar

    When are we talking?

    Dr Place’s research focuses on 200-550 CE. The late Roman empire is full of intrigue and was a time of great change. While there was some stability under the emperor Septimius Severus, who ruled from 193-211 CE, with his death and the succession of his son Caracalla, a century of turmoil began.

    Amidst the political chaos that characterised much of this century, the Christians rose in prominence. By the beginning of the fourth century, Rome would have its first Christian emperor, Constantine I. This emerging system would rapidly became established as the exclusive religion of the empire as Rome entered the fifth century.

    Where are we talking?    

    The focus of Place’s research has been the coastal regions of North Africa, examining an area that spans Namibia to Morocco. Parts of North Africa began to be acquired by Rome in the 2nd century BCE with the end of the Third Punic War. Roman influence continued to expand in this region throughout the late Republic and into the Empire.

    What is the source material like for fashion and togas?

    Place's research is based in part on literary sources but is supplemented with mosaics. She highlights the difficulties that come with using textual evidence to understand something that was visual. The terms used in the sources are not always easily matched to a surviving representation and it is extremely rare for any actual samples of clothing to survive to the modern day.  

    Matron at her Toilette Mosaic from Sidi Ghrib, Bardo. Copyright credit: Sean Leatherbury/Manar al-Athar.

    How did people in North Africa use clothing to construct and express their identity?

    Place’s research focuses on the impact that the growth of Christianity had on dress and identity. A particularly important author was Tertullian, a Christian writer who made some very vocal criticism of female dress in this region.

    Although Roman writers had been critical of women dressing too provocatively before the advent of Christianity, for Tertullian there was an extra moral imperative for women to dress modestly and plainly. Austerity was a means of advertising one’s commitment to the new religion, most especially if one was wealthy enough to have a choice.

    We see a stark contrast between words and deeds, however, when we consider the mosaics from the region. As Place notes, these don’t often show people have taken Tertullian’s advice – quite the opposite!

    Tune in to hear all Place's insights into the local trends for women and men and the place of the toga.

    Tomb cover for Victoria, originally from Tabarka, now in the Bardo. Copyright credit: Sean Leatherbury/Manar al-Athar.

    Interested in learning more about this fascinating topic? You can consider more of Dr Amy Place's work at Academia.edu

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    31 min
  • Episode 98 – Cincinnatus, Suffect Consul

    It's c. 460 BCE and
    this hectic year in Roman history continues! In this episode we
    consider Rome in the wake of the sneak attack on the Capitol by
    Herdonius' disaffected Sabines. During the challenges of wrestling
    control back, the Romans lose one of their own. The consul Publius
    Valerius Pubicola falls in battle. This is a tragic loss and opens
    the way for Lucius Cincinnatus to return to the narrative.

    Episode 98 – Cincinnatus, Suffect Consul

    Looking to catch up on the narrative before diving into this episode? You can find out more about the earlier events of this year here.

    Who's WhoConsuls
    • Publius
      Valerius P. f. Volusi n. Publicola (cos II)
    • Gaius
      Claudius Ap. f. M. n. Inrigillensis (or Regillensis) Sabinus
    Suffect Consul
    • Lucius Quinctius Cincinnatus
    Tribune of the Plebs
    • Aulus
      Verginius
    • Marcus
      Volscius Fictor
    A Man of the Land

    There's nothing
    quite like a man who farms. For fans of men of the land, Cincinnatus
    is here for you. We explore the important symbolism of Cincinnatus
    working the land and his reaction to learning about his election as
    suffect consul.

    A New Political
    Strategy

    Cincinnatus takes
    the opportunity to lead in a new way. With much rhetorical flourish,
    our new consul lays forth a plan that spells trouble for the
    plebeians and the ambitions of the tribunes. We dig into the
    discrepancies between our sources – Livy and Dionysius of
    Halicarnassus have different takes on the essential narrative. This
    is very revealing in terms of thinking about the aims of our written
    sources for this period.

    Things to Look
    Forward To
    • a taking of
      auspices
    • a desire for
      a dictator
    • some
      senatorial love for our man Cincinnatus
    Alexandre Cabanel 1843. Cincinnatus receiving the ambassadors of Rome. Image Source: Wikimedia CommonsOur SourcesPrimary sources
    • Dr G is
      reading Dionysius of Halicarnassus Roman Antiquities
      10.17-19
    • Dr
      R is reading Livy 3.19.1-3
    Secondary
    sources
    • Broughton,
      T. R. S. 1951. The Magistrates of the Roman Republic,
      Volume I
      (American Philological Association)
    • Eck,
      W. (Colonge) ‘Suffect Consul' Brill's New Pauly,
      Cancik, H. Schneider, H., Salazar, C. F. (eds.), accessed online
      29-9-2019
    • Lomas,
      K. 2017. The Rise
      of Rome: from the Iron Age to the Punic Wars
      (1000-264
      BC) (Profile Books)
    • Müller,
      C. (Bochum) ‘Q. Cincinnatus, L.'
      Brill's New Pauly
      ,
      Cancik, H. Schneider, H., Salazar, C. F. (eds.), accessed online
      29-9-2019

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    39 min