The Partial Historians

The Partial Historians

By The Partial HistoriansSociety & CultureEducationHistory
Download on the App Store

All The Partial Historians episodes

  • Episode 114 – The Tale of Verginia

    CW: The accounts of Verginia include paedophilic desire, violence against women

    The story of Verginia is an achingly tragic tale central to understanding the Second Decemvirate. Both Livy and Dionysius of Halicarnassus go into some detail about what happens and how it unfolds and we'll explore both accounts to compare and contrast them.

    Episode 114 – The Tale of Verginia

    Reading our Sources on Verginia

    Dr Rad takes us through the complexities of thinking about Livy's context and how that might influence his presentation of the material. Dr G explores the connection between the Latin term virgo (virgin) and her name Verginia. There's plenty of parallels that will emerge between Verginia's story and the story of Lucretia, whose fate seals the demise of the Roman monarchy.

    What Horror…

    Verginia is the daughter of a well-known centurion who is fighting on one of Rome's frontiers. But conflict emerges when Appius Claudius decides that he wants her for himself. He seems heedless to reason or morality when it comes to Verginia and this leads him to engage in a set of behaviours that are appalling.

    What to listen out for

    Verginia's story is one that involves a number of strange and dangerous concepts:

    • Claiming people from the street as slaves
    • Convoluted plans to remove a young woman from her family
    • Legal arguments around the claim that someone is a slave
    • Arguments for how to protect women's virginity
    • What does it mean to be a citizen?
    • Official summons and strategies to foil summons
    • Groups of women akin to a tragic chorus
    • A butcher stand and the connection of Venus with the Cloaca Maxima
    Our PlayersDecemvirs
    • Appius Claudius. Ap. f. M. n. Crassus Inregillensis Sabinus Pat – Cos. 471, 451
    • Spurius Oppius Cornicen
    • Quintus Fabius M. f. M. n. Vibulanus Pat – Cos. 467, 465, 459
    • Quintus Poetelius Libo Visolus
    • Manius Rabuleius
    • Marcus Cornelius – f. Ser. n. Maluginenesis Pat
    • Lucius Minucius P. f. M. n. Esquilinus Augurinus Pat – Cos. 458
    • Marcus? Sergius Esquilinus Pat
    • Titus Antonius Merenda
    • Caeso Duillius Longus?
    Appius Claudius' client
    • Marcus Claudius
    The Verginii and Supporters
    • Verginia
    • Verginius – father of Verginia
    • Numitoria – mother of Verginia
    • Publius Numitorius – Verginia's maternal uncle
    • Lucius(?) Icilius – former tribune of the plebs and Verginia's betrothed
    Our Sources
    • Dr Rad reads Livy 3.44-48
    • Dr G reads Dionysius of Halicarnassus Rom. Ant. 11.28-37
    • Joshel, S. 2002. ‘The Body Female and the Body Politic: Livy’s Lucretia and Verginia.’ In Sexuality and gender in the classical world: readings and sources, edited by Sandra R. Joshel & Laura K. McClure, 163-190. Oxford: Blackwell.
    • Keegan, P. 2021. Livy’s Women. New York: Oxon.
    Sound Credits

    Additional music and sound in this episode includes an original composition for our podcast by the fabulous Bettina Joy de Guzman

    Heinrich Friedrich Fuger – The Death of Virginia.
    Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons user Jbribeiro1

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    1 hr 10 min
  • Special Episode – The Archaeology of Early Rome with Darius Arya

    In this very special episode we're joined by archaeologist Darius Arya. Darius has lived and worked as an archaeologist in Rome for over twenty years! 

    Special Episode – The Archaeology of Early Rome with Darius Arya

    We wanted to learn more about the archaeological record for the early period of Rome's history. While we've been focused on reading and interpreting the literary sources of Livy and Dionysius of Halicarnassus, there's a wealth of other evidence for the ancient past to consider. Archaeology is fundamental in revealing elements of the past that aren't written down. Even more interesting is that the archaeological remains can suggest new interpretations about the past that conflict or add complexity to the literary sources.

    You may have seen Darius on television. He's presented a number of documentaries on the ancient world and we are absolutely thrilled to explore Rome's early history with his expertise. Things to listen out for in this episode:

    • The importance of topography
    • The connections between the Etruscan peoples and the Romans
    • Discussion of how the Etruscans dominate the archaeological record compared Rome's other early neighbours, the Volscians and the Aequians
    • What we can say about the Sabine peoples
    • Key sites of interest when thinking about early Rome and her neighbours

    We recommend having a map handy to spot all the places that are touched on in this far-ranging and engaging conversation. The map below has some of places mentioned on it and also provides some guidance on the languages of the different regions. 

    The Linguistic Landscape of Central Italy at the beginning of Roman expansion.
    Courtesy of Susana Freixeiro~commonswiki via Wikimedia Commons

    Darius Arya can be found on social media, posting about Rome and the sites he's working on and the museums he's collaborating with. You can catch him on Twitter @DariusAryaDigs, Instagram @dariusaryadigs, and his limited series podcast Darius Arya Digs.He is the director of The American Institute for Roman Culture. Their mission “to preserve and protect Rome’s extraordinary and unique cultural legacy through education, outreach, and action.” He is also the director of Ancient Rome Live which is dedicated to providing free-to-access resources for learning about ancient Rome.

    Guide to Locations and Peoples

    Aequians – the Aequian peoples are an Italic group that inhabited the Apennine mountains east of Rome and to the south of the Sabines.

    Albano – in the Castelli Romani region to the south-east of Rome. There is a a lake and a hill named for Albano

    Anio, river – The Anio starts in the Apennines east of Rome and flows through Tivoli before joining the Tiber

    Antium – south of Rome and slightly east, a coastal city

    The Castelli Romani region (please note this is to the south-east not south-west of Rome!) – includes the modern towns which are also ancient sites: Albano, Castel Gandolfo, Frascati, Tusculum. Often associated with the Aequians in the literary sources for the early Republic.

    Castel Gandolfo – in the Castelli Romani region to the south-east of Rome. Most famous now as the location of the Pope's summer residence!

    Circeo (ancient Circeii) – South and east of Rome. A coastal site that is further south and further east than Antium. Modern San Felice Circeo, the site is known for its beach. In ancient Rome, this was where a treaty was signed between Carthage and Rome in 509 BCE!

    Frascati – in the Castelli Romani region to the south-east of Rome.

    Ostia – west of Rome, a port settlement at the mouth of the Tiber river.

    Sabines – a peoples living to the east of Rome and north of the river Anio in the mountainous Apennine region

    Sant'Omobono – an archaeological site in Rome next to the church of Sant'Omobono, at the junction of the modern via L. Petroselli and il Vico Jugario at the foot of the Campidoglio (the ancient Capitoline hill). This site contains altars and temples to Fortuna and Mater Matuta and is considered very important for understanding the development of urbanisation in Rome. 

    The Sant'Omobono archaeological site where temple remains date back to the 7th century BCE!
    Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons

    Tusculum– in the Castelli Romani region to the south-east of Rome. Famous in our written sources for the early Republic as a friend of Rome, but also later famous as where Cicero had a villa.

    Pomezia – directly south of Rome. The modern township on the ancient site of Lavinium and located in the Pontine marshes.

    Veii – about sixteen kilometres north of Rome. An Etruscan city built on a plateau of tuff and was considered to be in an extremely defensible and strategic location. Veii is the most significant southern city of Etruria.

    Volscians – the Volscian peoples are thought to be a group of Osco-Umbrian speakers who inhabited the area south of Rome, which is characterised by hills interspersed with marshes such as the Pontine marshes.

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    51 min
  • Episode 113 – Farewell to the Roman Achilles

    We are deep in the Second Decemvirate (c. 449-447 BCE) and Rome faces war on two fronts. The complications of this new political arrangement and the increasing pressure of armed conflict places the decemvirate under stress as they need to decide how to lead Rome while facing patrician opposition from the Senate. All the while, Rome's enemies head closer…

    Episode 113 – Farewell to the Roman Achilles

    Enter a Plebeian Hero!

    Into this fiery atmosphere, Lucius Siccius Dentatus re-enters the narratives of Livy and Dionysius. He is both well-known and well-loved and we find him serving with the decemvirs at the Sabine front. And its not long before he begins to voice his dissatisfaction with the decemvirs' approach to power. According to Livy he proposes succession…

    Murder Most Foul

    Our sources agree that Dentatus is murdered by his own and this episode is all about sifting through the details provided by Livy and Dionysius. Despite scholarly misgivings that Dentatus may be a fictionalised creation, there's no denying that his presence in a historical narrative adds a certain exciting sheen to proceedings.

    Things to tune in for:

    • Duelling accounts the murder of Dentatus
    • Murder investigations Roman style
    • The intriguing qualities of the legate
    • The amazing last stand of a plebeian hero

    Looking to relive the highlights of Siccius Dentatus' life? Check out our back catalogue:

    • Episode 105 – The Roman Achilles
    • Episode 106 – Spoiler Alert
    Our PlayersDecemvirs

    Two legions in Rome

    • Appius Claudius. Ap. f. M. n. Crassus Inregillensis Sabinus Pat – Cos. 471, 451
    • Spurius Oppius Cornicen

    Three legions against the Sabines

    • Quintus Fabius M. f. M. n. Vibulanus Pat – Cos. 467, 465, 459
    • Quintus Poetelius Libo Visolus
    • Manius Rabuleius

    Five legions against the Aequians

    • Marcus Cornelius – f. Ser. n. Maluginenesis Pat
    • Lucius Minucius P. f. M. n. Esquilinus Augurinus Pat – Cos. 458
    • Marcus? Sergius Esquilinus Pat
    • Titus Antonius Merenda
    • Caeso Duillius Longus?
    Hero of the People
    • Lucius Siccius Dentatus
    Our Sources
    • Dr Rad reads Livy 3.42-43
    • Dr G reads Dionysius of Halicarnassus Rom. Ant. 11.25-27
    Sound Credits

    Additional music and sound in this episode includes:

    • an original composition for our podcast by the fabulous Bettina Joy de Guzman
    • and additional sound effects from BBC Sound Effects Beta

    Aniello Falcone c. 1640. Roman soldiers in the circus. Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.
    Not a Roman battle or ambush, but a sense of Roman soldiers in movement to add to the story at hand.

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    39 min
  • Special Episode – Murder in Ancient Rome

    One of the funniest pieces of theatre set in Ancient Rome has to be A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum (1962). Now there is a book about murder in Ancient Rome that matches the title inspiration for comedy as well.

    We sat down to talk to historian and author Dr Emma Southon about her new book A Fatal Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum. Dr Southon is also one of the hosts of the podcast History is Sexy and author of Agrippina: Empress, Exile, Hustler, Whore. We were excited to discover that not only does Emma share our affection for Julio-Claudian women, but she is a fellow murderino and lover of Drag Race at heart.

    Special Episode – Murder in Ancient Rome with Dr Southon

    Why is there so much DEATH in Ancient Rome?

    Listeners of our podcast have probably already noticed just how many murders take place in Rome's mythology and history. The foundation myth about the twins Romulus and Remus has fratricide at its very core. The overthrow of the kings and the beginning of the Republic was triggered by a rape and the suicide of Lucretia. These moments are probably mythological, but the fact that the Romans chose to tell such stories about themselves says a lot about their culture.

    Oath of the Horatii (1784) by Jacques-Louis David.
    The tale of the Horatii is probably mythological. The three brothers volunteered to fight three brothers from one of Rome's enemy cities, one of whom happened to be engaged to their sister. All the combatants perished, except one of the Horatii, who thus secured victory for his city. Upon his return to Rome, his sister wept as she knew her betrothed was dead. Her brother promptly ran her through, and his father defended the murder as justified. You can learn more about this episode in Rome's early history in our Episode 38 – Tullus Hostilius.
    Image courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.

    To add to this rather blood-soaked mythology, the history of Rome is punctuated with murders that take place at what are now seen as pivotal historical moments. The rather graphic murder of the Gracchi brothers during disputes over land reform, the assassination of Julius Caesar, and then we get to the empire and there are almost too many to list! The assassination of Gaius (Caligula), the murder of the emperor Claudius by his wife (and niece!) Agrippina the Younger, the brutal end of the emperor Vitellius in the civil wars of 69 CE, and the memorable stabbing of the emperor Domitian (straight to the groin!).

    These are just the highlights, so it is clear why someone like Dr Emma Southon needed to sit down and think about just what all of this murder can tell us about Roman society.

    What is the difference between murder and homicide?

    Homicide is the act of killing another person, but murder is a social construct. With murder, you need to take the circumstances of the killing into account. Was there intent? Was it planned? Each modern country has different ways of constructing the crime of murder, but one thing that unites most nations in our world is that they do have a law about murder. That was not actually the case in Ancient Rome. Even though they were very proud of their first law code, The Twelve Tables, there was no legislation included regarding the killing of another human being. And they weren't in a rush to amend that either!

    Dr Emma Southon takes us on a hair-curling journey through a variety of killings in the Roman world.

    What to expect in this episode?
    • Murder by and of the elite
    • Murder in the imperial family
    • Murdering emperors
    • Murder in the family
    • Murder in a marriage
    • Murder by magic
    • Murder by the state
    • Murder of and by slaves

    An view of the Flavian Amphitheatre (or Colosseum).
    The Romans were big believers in capital punishment – who has the time or resources for rehabilitation? A criminal had done something to make Rome suffer, and so their death would also involve suffering. Executions were something that crowds of people would watch for amusement in theatres like this one, although they were often far less popular than beast hunts and gladiatorial shows… both of which also involved death and murder!
    Image by Davi Pimentel from Pexels

    What becomes disturbingly clear is just how much murder there must have been in the Roman world, some real and some imagined. Given how little material has survived from the ancient world, to have a picture like this emerge is quite shocking. Even more sickening is how clearly Roman society valued certain lives far above others. The study of murder highlights how little your death mattered without the ‘right' connections and status. The fact that modern societies are still wrestling with these issues is perhaps the most sobering take-away.

    We highly recommend picking up a copy of Emma's book to get the full scoop on all of these topics. And if all of this doesn't give you your true crime fix for the day, then you should probably consider seeking professional help!

    If you have the chance, we recommend supporting independent booksellers:

    • For readers in Australia
    • For US readers
    • For UK readers
    • For readers in Spain

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    1 hr 21 min
  • Episode 112 – The Disastrous Decemvirs

    We pick up the action straight from the dramatic senate meeting from the previous episode in which was marked by conflict:

    • Lucius Valerius Potitus and Marcus Horatius Barbatus opposed the decemvirs and faced violent intimidation
    • and lead decemvir Appius Claudius faced off against his uncle Gaius Claudius.

    Episode 112 – The Disastrous Decemvirs

    The Conflict Continues

    Once again, we see clear division between the members of the senate. Speaking in favour of the decemvirs is Lucius Cornelius Maluginensis, who just happens to be the brother of one of the decemvirs. He emphasises the need to deal with the external threat from the Sabines and the Aequians, rather than stirring up opposition to their leaders. Cornelius' views win some support, but Lucius Valerius Potitus is determined to speak as well. Valerius feels the need to highlight how dire the political situation is in Rome. Will these decemvirs ever give up their power? What is to be done?

    Taking on the Enemy

    As there is no right of appeal against the decemvirs, the levy is held to raise an army. The decemvirs divide the commands between them, with some sent against the Sabines, some are off to deal with the Aequians, and Appius Claudius and Spurius Oppius intend to hold the fort in Rome itself. If they were thinking that this was their time to shine, they are sadly mistaken as they face defeat across the board. Support for this regime, such as it was, is evaporating quickly and the decemvirs start taking ever more drastic measures to maintain their grip on power.

    Things to Come
    • Patrician versus patrician conflict
    • People fleeing the city
    • Military defeats on every front
    • Murder and mayhem
    • The popularity of the decemvirs sinks lower still
    Our PlayersThe Second Decemvirate
    • Appius Claudius. Ap. f. M. n. Crassus Inregillensis Sabinus Pat – Cos. 471, 451
    • Marcus Cornelius – f. Ser. n. Maluginenesis Pat
    • Marcus? Sergius Esquilinus Pat
    • Lucius Minucius P. f. M. n. Esquilinus Augurinus Pat – Cos. 458
    • Quintus Fabius M. f. M. n. Vibulanus Pat – Cos. 467, 465, 459
    • Quintus Poetelius Libo Visolus
    • Titus Antonius Merenda
    • Caeso Duillius Longus?
    • Spurius. Oppius Cornicen
    • Manius Rabuleius
    The Senators
    • Lucius Cornelius Maluginensis (brother of decemvir Marcus Cornelius)
    • Lucius Valerius Potitus
    • Marcus Horatius Barbatus
    • Gaius Claudius (uncle of Appius Claudius)
    Our Sources
    • Dr Rad reads Livy Ab Urbe Condita 3.39-40
    • Dr G reads Dionysius of Halicarnassus Roman History 11.16-24
    Sound Credits

    Additional music and sound in this episode includes:

    • an original composition for our podcast by the incredible Bettina Joy de Guzman
    • and additional sound effects from BBC Sound Effects Beta, Orange Free Sounds, Sound Bible and Fesilyan Studios

    A picture of the Roman forum as it can be seen today including the Curia Julia (senate house). The Curia Julia was not where our decemvirs would have met as this curia was built in 44 BCE by Julius Caesar. Caesar's curia replaced the Curia Cornelia which was itself a replacement for the Curia Hostilia. This image is courtesy of Rachel Claire via Pexels.

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    47 min
  • Special Episode – Disability in Ancient Greece

    There are many groups that are often overlooked in both ancient and modern societies. One of those are people with disabilities, and we were fortunate to talk to expert Dr Debby Sneed about her work on impairment in antiquity. Dr Sneed has examined a range of sources about this topic, including human remains, temples and textual evidence.

    Her focus has mostly been on physical impairments that leave a trace in human remains. Sneed's focus is ancient Greece, but we couldn’t resist bringing Rome into the conversation every now and then! 

    In order to make this episode as accessible as possible, a full transcript will be provided for this episode.

    Special Episode – Disability in Ancient Greece with Dr Debby Sneed

    What's up for discussion?

    In this conversation we delve into a number of questions, including:

    • How do you classify a disability in this line of research?
    • How many people in the ancient world would have had a disability?
    • What kinds of sources are available for studying disability in the ancient world?
    • What would life have been like for people with disabilities in the ancient world?

    Topics that come up in the conversation:

    • Artistic representations of disability in Greece and Rome
    • The Panhellenic Sanctuary of Asklepios at Epidauros with its eleven ramps!
    • The practice of infanticide in ancient Greece
    • Disability and impairment among the elite including King Agesilaus II of Sparta, Philip II of Macedon, father of Alexander the Great, and the Roman Emperor Claudius
    • Welfare systems in ancient Athens, as highlighted by Lysias 24, For The Disabled Man.  

    If you enjoyed this episode, be sure to check out some of the suggested readings. This is a huge topic, and we did not get the chance to discuss issues that leave less of a physical trace, such as blindness or muteness, nor did we touch on disabilities that might have arisen from disease or mental illness.

    You can also follow Dr Sneed on Twitter @debscavator and track her research at Academic.edu.

    This vase by the ‘Clinic Painter' is one of Dr Debby Sneed's favourites.
    It may show two men in a courtship pose, but this is still debated by scholars. One of the men is a dwarf or little person.
    Photograph by Maria Daniels, courtesy of the Musée du Louvre, January 1992.

    Transcript

    [00:00:00] 

    Dr Rad 

    Hello, there! You are in for a treat and you're going to be hearing a special episode from The Partial Historians. Today we're going to be talking to Dr. Debby Sneed. Dr. Debby Sneed is a lecturer in Classics at California State University. She has a PhD in Archaeology from UCLA. And a MA in Classics from the University of Colorado, at Boulder, as well as a BA in English and History from the University of Wyoming. She has worked on archaeological projects in Greece, Italy, Ethiopia, and the American Southwest.

    [00:00:46] And she's currently working on a monograph about disability accommodations in ancient Greece. She's got some publications that are also forthcoming. So keep your eyes peeled for that. But in the meantime, here is our episode with Dr. Debby Sneed.

    [00:01:09]

    Welcome to a special edition of The Partial Historians. I am one of your hosts, Dr. Rad. 

    Dr G

    And I'm Dr. G. And we are super excited today to be sitting down with Dr. Debby Sneed. And we're going to be looking at disability in ancient Greece, and potentially also, as a side note, a little bit of ancient Rome coming from us.

    [00:01:31] 

    Dr Rad

    Absolutely. You know, we can't resist that and I must admit, this is a topic that, I'm going to admit full disclosure. I apologize to both of you. I have never really thought that much about disability in the ancient world, which is actually doubly shameful because, on a personal note, I'm just going to throw it out there. I actually have a condition which means that I'm gradually losing my hearing. And I've actually lost quite a lot. I wear hearing aids now. And so, I suppose, I have a very mild disability, which, I'm really lucky, it doesn't affect my life too much at this point in time. But it's something that I suppose has been coming more and more into my life as I lose more hearing.

    [00:02:08] So I'm really fascinated to get talking about disability in the ancient world and what that entails. 

    Dr G

    Yeah, so it's fantastic to have you here, Debby, thank you so much for joining us.

    Dr Debby Sneed

    Yeah, thank you for having me. I'm glad to be here to talk about this. 

    Dr Rad

    So like dive straight in with, uh, with one of our first questions, which is exactly how do you define or classify a disability in your research?

    Dr Debby Sneed

    [00:02:30] This is a really difficult question for a lot of reasons. And one of them has to do with a lot of the attitudes that people bring to the topic of disability in the modern period. Um, but for me, in my research, I focus specifically on physical disabilities. My work is primarily interdisciplinary, which means I look at material and evidence from a lot of different fields and reconcile them in various ways.

    [00:02:52] So I look at not just literary evidence and artistic evidence, but also physical remains. So I studied human remains as well. And so in [00:03:00] order to do this correctly, I tried to look at things that could potentially be archaeologically recovered, uh, in that is specifically physical disabilities. So I look at things like cleft palate, missing limbs, short stature, stuff like that.

    Dr Rad

    [00:03:16] Maybe just building on that. Can you tell us a little bit about this, the sites that you've looked at in your research when you've been looking at the human remains or do you, or do they – the human remains – come to you?

    Dr Debby Sneed

    Well, the human remains come to me. I am not a bio-archaeologist, so I rely on the work and the reports that are filed by people who are skeletal archaeologists, osteoarchaeologist, bio-archaeologists.

    [00:03:38] And so I am beholden to who's doing work where. And so I have used things like, uh, there's a lot of great work done from cemeteries in Northern Greece, specifically Pydna, for example, Amphipolis, um, a lot of great work being done from cemeteries and deposits in Athens. But also in places like, Thebes.

    [00:03:58] Um, and so it just sort [00:04:00] of depends on what's available and who's doing the analysis. And if they're asking the kinds of questions that will help me in identifying who is potentially disabled and what we can say about it. 

    Dr Rad

    Absolutely. And so roughly how many people do you think would have been classified as disabled in the ancient world?

    Dr Debby Sneed

    [00:04:20] It's kind of an impossible question for a lot of reasons. Uh, first of all, there's not really a category of the disabled in ancient Greece. So now we have sort of legal definitions as included, as well as societal definitions of what is disability, who is disabled, but that just didn't exist in the ancient world.

    [00:04:38] So even if the ancient Greeks did keep, sort of records of things like this, they wouldn't have used disability as a category for keeping track of the population. Second of all, disability is, it's really fluid as a concept, right? So you can be disabled for a period of time and then become cured or well, or something like that.

    [00:04:57] Um, you could also be non-disabled for most of [00:05:00] your life and then become disabled. You could be involved in a battle, for example, where you become injured and it leads to a permanent disability, old age leads to disability. So right now, the World Health Organization estimates that about 15% of the world's population is disabled. 

    In the United States [00:05:18] the estimates are somewhere between 20 to 25% of the population. Uh, it's actually the largest minority group in the United States. So these are modern statistics and it's not possible to sort of import those to the ancient world. The reasons that people are disabled, how people become disabled, and how we classify disability would have been quite different.

    [00:05:37] But we can probably guess, based on a variety of evidence, that a great number of people in the ancient world either lived with a disability from birth or became disabled or interacted on a very close basis, either as a family member or a close community member with somebody who was disabled. 

    Dr Rad

    Yeah, it's actually something that I suddenly realized how horrifying it [00:06:00] really was. [00:06:00] How many people must have had to live in discomfort or just with constant inconvenience in the ancient world. Because when you think about it, when I was looking at the research, I really liked this idea that, you could really only classify someone as having a disability, if the society they live in doesn't really help them out anyway. [00:06:20] And it doesn't meet their needs in some ways. So for example, I wouldn't classify myself as having a disability per se, because I have access to hearing aids because I live in a society and I have a job where I can afford them. But in a different context, I might be, I might be classified that way because I wouldn't have access to an aid, which allows me to do my work.

    [00:06:39] And when you think about the lack of technology and all that kind of stuff available in the ancient world, it is really quite staggering, isn't it? 

    Dr Debby Sneed

    So, what you're describing there is actually called the social model of disability. So people who are engaged in studies of disability in the past and present, people involved in disability activism, operate – at least tend to operate – according to different models of disability. [00:07:00] And the social model of disability is one that is very prevalent in disability studies, but it’s specifically organized against what's called the medical model of disability. 

    The medical model is something that situates the problem of disability in the body of the disabled person. It says you are the problem. [00:07:17] And in order to overcome your disability, you need to overcome your own body, right? And so this is where treatments and cures and rehabilitation specifically focus on correcting the person with the disability so that they can function in a quote unquote, “normal” society. Right. 

    The social model of disability is kind of the opposite of that, right? [00:07:37] So what the social model of disability does is, sort of like what early feminist scholarship did with sex and gender where sex is considered sort of a biological fact and gender was something that was imposed on to sex, right? So the social model of disability does something like that with impairment and disability.

    [00:07:56] Impairment being so the biological reality of a body [00:08:00], so missing limbs, loss of hearing, deafness, uh, vision impairments, things like that. And disability is something that's imposed externally on the impaired body. So disability is then a problem of society and not a problem of the individual and correcting disability means disability accommodations.

    [00:08:19] It means creating an environment that allows the impaired people to survive. Not just survive, but exist and thrive and participate in society. 

    Dr G

    If we're thinking about ancient Greece and how these models might be playing out, because obviously even though ancient Greek people themselves might not be thinking in terms of these models, they might still be useful ways of looking and thinking about the evidence that's left behind.

    [00:08:45] How would you say that you see these kinds of models present in the evidence from the ancient world? 

    Dr Debby Sneed

    Well, some of these models are in my own research, keeping in mind that, for example, the social model of disability is not without its problems. So there's [00:09:00] some really great work done by, for example, Tom Shakespeare, on the problems of the social model of disability, talking about how it kind of treats the impairment as if it's irrelevant, right? [00:09:08] Um, but that's actually not the reality for a lot of people with disabilities; that, while there are problems that are created by society, impairment in and of itself is not neutral, right? It is something that they live with. It is something that affects their experience of the world, their interactions with people.

    [00:09:25] And so, um, there's a lot of movement away from the social model, not just to amend the social model, but actually to take a completely different approach. One of the things that I really like about the social model of disability is its emphasis on contingency. And what that means is that, um, what is considered disabling, what impairments are considered disabling is going to change depending on the context.

    [00:09:47] And so what I do in my research is I try to look at accommodations for disability, so ways that I can see that society changed to account for the fact of impairment, um, and [00:10:00] use that as a kind of metric for understanding how the ancient Greeks thought about people with disabilities. So, um, not just looking at the instances in myth or in tragedy, for example, where we might have comments about people who are disabled, but looking instead at the structures of society to see how they changed or didn't change depending on the needs of the population.

    [00:10:20] It's specifically focused on, um, things that were intended or could have benefited people with disabilities. 

    Dr Rad

    It's been really fascinating actually, to look at some of your work. I believe that you've done quite a lot of study on the use of, uh, ramps to try and help people access temples or sanctuaries and that sort of thing [00:10:39] in ancient Greece, if they had some sort of mobility impairment. 

    Dr Debby Sneed

    Yeah, definitely. So this is an article that, that I wrote on ramps specifically, focused on ramps and healing sanctuaries in ancient Greece. So ramps are a kind of feature that we're really familiar with, especially in a type of Greek architecture called Doric architecture, [00:11:00] which we primarily situated in the Peloponnese, even though it's not completely confined to the Peloponnese.

    [00:11:06] So we don't really see a lot of ramps. I think a recent study of – a sort of catalogue of ramps in the ancient Greek world – found fewer than twenty, like total ramps on temple buildings, specifically in the Greek world. So that is not a lot of ramps or a lot more temples than twenty. And so when I was looking at the distribution, however, of those ramps, um, and looking at not just temple buildings, but also secondary and subsidiary buildings at sanctuaries, the healing sanctuary of Asclepius at Epidaurus has eleven built ramps.

    [00:11:37] So if I consider the fact –

    Dr G

    Oh wow

    Dr Debby Sneed

    – yeah. If you consider that most sanctuaries have no ramps or one ramp, the fact that this one sanctuary has eleven ramps needs to be explained in some way. And so I moved to then to think, okay, how could we explain this? 

    So the traditional explanations for ramps are having to do with animals. [00:11:57] You know, that this would be an easier way, uh, [00:12:00] for animals to enter the buildings. Except that animals didn't enter the buildings. And so that doesn't really work as an explanation. Animals that were sacrificed were sacrificed outside of the temple. And you can't really imagine bringing a bowl, for example, into a temple with all of this, the furniture, all of the dedications that were housed in there.

    [00:12:19] Uh, other explanations, um, include, uh, sort of wheeling dedications in and out. So if you imagine people dedicate stone statues, for example, or marble statues, those are very heavy. So maybe you would want to use a ramp so that you could wheel it in and out. 

    However, there are specific treasury buildings in ancient Greek sanctuaries. [00:12:38] We can think of the treasuries at Delphi, for example, or at Olympia. And the explicit function of these very small buildings was to house really expensive and heavy dedications. And these buildings never have ramps. And so if ramps facilitated the movement of these heavy dedications, we would expect them to be on buildings whose only job was to hold these dedications.

    Dr G

    [00:13:00] Yeah, the last thing you'd want to do is, like, wheel something in there and then make it really easy for somebody to wheel it back out again. 

    Dr Debby Sneed

    Yeah, exactly. So possibly they had sort of temporary ramps for those purposes. I have no idea. And so when you look at the fact that most of the explanations that have been [00:13:17] put forth for ramps at sanctuaries just don't work, right. And then also look at how many ramps there are at healing sanctuaries, which were specifically marketed to people with disabilities. It just sort of fits together into this really great picture of a sort of intentional purpose, an intentional building of these ramps to assist the pilgrims who came to the healing sanctuaries in search of healing.

    Dr Rad

    [00:13:40] So I’m really curious to ask, exactly what do you think – from your studies – life would have been like for people with the kind of disabilities that you study in the ancient world? because, I mean, I know that's a massive question because there's just a huge amount, as you mentioned before, of conditions and just, you know, [00:14:00] factors like age that could be what's causing someone to have some sort of mobility impairment. But can you tell us anything about what you think life would've been like from what you've looked at?

    Dr Debby Sneed

    [00:14:10] Yeah, sure. I don't think that it's, it's another kind of impossible question. Um, life in the ancient world for anybody disabled or not disabled was difficult, right? So we tend to think about ancient Greek life, we think about philosophers, Aristotle and Plato. We think about generals. Uh, we think about the names of people that we can think of. [00:14:31] And, uh, those were not the typical people who are living in ancient Greece. These are very privileged, very elite men. And so, for the most part, people are engaged in subsistence agriculture, right? They're sort of living harvest to harvest. Life was just difficult in general. People worked all the time. They were constantly engaged in all sorts of things.

    [00:14:51] Um, so this idea of a sort of easy life in the ancient world is based on a very small segment of the population. But even when you're thinking about that, [00:15:00] we have evidence for people with disabilities in both classes of people. So among elite men, as well as among the more general population. 

    And it's impossible to say what life was like. [00:15:09] It really depended on somebody's status on their gender, on their wealth, et cetera. But we have evidence for disabled slaves. We have evidence for disabled generals. We have evidence for disabled Kings, disabled women, women who sort of gave birth to Kings, right? Who were themselves, the women were themselves disabled.

    [00:15:28] So you can't really pinpoint a specific thing because there's something that Martha Rose has talked a lot. She's a big, big person in the study of disability in ancient Greece. One of the things that she's really emphasized is what she calls the community model of disability. Where it didn't really depend on the sort of functional limitations of your body, but instead on your functional ability within the community. [00:15:49] And so everything was negotiated on a sort of individual basis. What could you do? What couldn't you do? Could that be accommodated? Who are you? Are you expected to be contributing in one way and you [00:16:00] can't et cetera? It just depends on so many different factors that, um, it's really not possible to say what life would have been like in the generic sense for somebody with a disability.

    Dr G

    [00:16:10] And that's really interesting as well, if we're thinking about just how many ramps are associated with that sanctuary to Asclepius as well, because it seems like that feeds into a bigger idea about, well, how do we go about looking after the people in our community who potentially are suffering from disabilities? [00:16:30] How do we negotiate that and how do we come together as a community to try and solve that problem? 

    Dr Debby Sneed

    Yeah, this is one of the, there was a lot of interesting feedback that I got about that article. And a lot of it was just incredulity at the idea that the ancient Greeks would have given conscious thought to people with disabilities.

    [00:16:48] But I find that to be a very surprising reaction. Ancient Greeks had a God of healing. It's not objectively true that every society will have a God of healing. So the Greeks [00:17:00] had a God, Asclepius, who was dedicated to healing other gods focused on healing as well, okay. So it's not, it's not a given that they'll have a God of healing.

    [00:17:07] It's then not a given that they will build elaborate sanctuaries to that God. Okay, so this is another step of sort of cultural or societal choice that they're making. And once you make the choice that you want to have a sanctuary, that people who are ill, people who are disabled, people who are injured, that they can come here to seek healing. [00:17:28] Once you've made that decision, it's not a big leap to assume that the ancient Greeks would have considered what would make that effective to that purpose. 

    So in much the same way that the sanctuary of Zeus at Olympia, which hosted these huge athletic games every four years – and sort of original Olympics – had athletic facilities, right? [00:17:45] So it had gyms. It had places for people to stay who came for the games. It had all sorts of athletic facilities because they hosted the athletic games. Sanctuaries where they did ritual dining, where dining was a really important function of your ritual practice [00:18:00], they had dining rooms. Sanctuaries where water played an important element, were built near water sources, right?

    [00:18:07] It's not, it's not sort of radical to think that if they built a sanctuary specifically intended to serve people with disabilities, that they would consider what would actually be effective for that purpose. It's more of a practical decision, um, than an ideological one. 

    So we tend to think about disability accommodations, ideologically, that we are this progressive society, that we care about people who are vulnerable, et cetera. [00:18:32] So we gray up to the privilege of accommodation, but for the Greeks, I think it was really just a practical choice. 

    Dr Rad

    Yeah. I think looking at the literature and thinking about, as we said before, how, how much people must have either experienced disability themselves in varying ways, or have had close contact with someone who had a disability. [00:18:54] It seems that they – people with disabilities – must have been fairly [00:19:00] integrated into society. It's not like they were necessarily, you know, shunned or anything like that. And, as you say, I mean, you look at Philip the Second of Macedon, you look at the emperor Claudius, there were people of high status as well who had, um, various impairments. [00:19:13] Although we can't always be sure with Claudius exactly what the, you know, what was going on there. But yeah, there's definitely a level of integration and practicality to the fact that these people, they are still working and they are getting married and they still have families. Some of them need families in order to have someone to help look after them and to help them maneuver the world.

    Dr G

    [00:19:34] And this seems to run counter to, like, one of the big sort of assumptions that people make about ancient Greece, which is that they just abandoned children on the side of the road. And this is something that gets repeated a lot. And, and the assumption being that children who were born, who didn't fit the criteria of normalcy in ancient Greece would have been left to die. [00:19:56] And this would have reduced the percentage of people potentially with disability [00:20:00] in society at large. 

    I'm wondering if you could speak to that a little bit. 

    Dr Debby Sneed

    Yeah, I definitely can. I have an article coming out on this topic this year, actually in the journal Hesperia. Yeah. So it's interesting because if you open any textbook, if you Google the topic, you'll see very confidently stated that the ancient Greeks killed infants who were born with, [00:20:20] uh, noticeable physical deformities or disabilities. And this is based on, like almost no evidence, which is really interesting. It's, it's a myth, right? 

    So I present this in my article that I think that this is just a false, a false thing. And not only do the evidence that people put forth, does it not work to support this argument, but we also have a lot of evidence that argues against this, right? [00:20:43] That demonstrates people giving extraordinary care to infants who had more needs than other infants. So infants already require a great deal of care, right? So this is already, they need a lot of attention. They already need more care than an adult does, for example. 

    And [00:21:00] so. Um, you know, this is one of the things to keep in mind, right, this idea of sort of an intersectional approach to disability, that how old someone is really affects how they're regarded in terms of disability, right? So we don't expect adults to require a lot of care. And so somebody who does require a lot of care, deviates more from what's expected or what's typical, than an infant who already requires a lot of care and a disabled infant who might require a little bit more care.

    [00:21:27] The gap between those things is much smaller than it would necessarily be for an adult, for example. Um, and so the evidence that people have for this practice of infanticide is, uh, primarily Plutarch, and Plutarch is a Roman author. And he says that the Spartan King Lycurgus instituted a law where parents brought their infants to a council of elders who evaluated the children and decided which ones should be raised and which ones should be killed.

    [00:21:56] And it specifically mentioned that infants who are disabled are deformed as [00:22:00] specifically the word should be put out or exposed. Um, there's no other evidence for this practice. So we have a bunch of other sources closer to the time of Lycurgus, if he was even real. People like Xenaphon, who were talking about the Spartans, were discussing Spartan law who were specifically talking about Lycurgus and no one else mentions this law.

    [00:22:20] So Plutarch is the only one. It’s very weak evidence, especially because Plutarch's starts his, his sort of biography of Lycurgus by saying, uh, something like concerning Lycurgus the law-giver there is, it's not possible to say something that is undisputed, right? And so, um, it's pretty shaky evidence to use.

    [00:22:41] And then we also have a couple of prescriptions by Plato and Aristotle, the fourth century BCE philosophers, where they say that, um, they have these sort of utopian texts and they outline what their ideal society would look like. And both of them specifically mentioned disabled infants and about how they should either be sort of hidden away [00:23:00] or exposed.

    [00:23:01] But these are utopian texts, right? Utopia is not real life. And so it just doesn't really work to use that. So, there's a modern philosopher named Peter Singer, who is probably one of the most famous philosophers and who is hated among the disability community, because he is similarly eugenicist in his thoughts, right.

    [00:23:20] This idea that, um, we should just like, sort of erase disability if we could. Um, it would be like taking Peter Singer and using him as evidence for modern sort of American society, right. And saying like, “Oh look, this very famous philosopher thinks that this should happen. Therefore it was happening,” right. [00:23:38] When we know in reality, it's not happening. 

    Dr G

    And indeed there's a lot of systems in place in order to facilitate the support of people, uh, who have a disability or an impairment of some kind. And so the idea that somehow to erase that out of existence, um, it's almost offensive at that point.

    Dr Rad

    And I think also looking at the [00:24:00] evidence, um, from the Roman world as well as the Greek world. And I think you kind of mentioned this as well, uh, in some of your other responses, uh, some of the disabilities that people suffered from were things that they didn't necessarily have at birth. So obviously, as you say, life was really tough in the ancient world. And so people developed forms of disability because they didn't have enough nutrition as children, or because they were forced to perform heavy labour from a very young age.

    [00:24:29] People also get injured. People get hurt in battle. People age and, therefore, just develop disabilities. I mean, there, there are certain things that you couldn't erase, even if you wanted to at birth. You know, lots of these children were probably born healthy and then became disabled or impaired later on.

    Dr Debby Sneed

    [00:24:48] Yeah, definitely. And we have plenty of evidence even for disabled infants. So there are medical texts, there's one Hippocratic treatise, uh, data to the late fifth or fourth century BCE, it's called On Joints. [00:25:00] And that author talks about a few things. He talks, for example, about infants who were born with clubfoot and, uh, this is a very common. [00:25:07] Very common. It's not an uncommon disability or impairment, sort of congenital impairment in the modern period. Um, and he has lengthy treatments that he outlines for how to, and he says, you know, it's not a problem, right. And he outlines the treatment for clubfoot, how you can sort of correct it. And regardless he says, there are special shoes that people with this can use that provide additional support to that foot.

    [00:25:30] He talks about infants who were born with what he calls a weasel arms. Um, so I don't know if you've seen a weasel, they'd have very short arms relative to their body size. And so this is infants who are born with something like a shrunken arm. It could be any number of conditions, right. And he says, it's no problem.

    [00:25:46] He said, he lists the tools that these people can use when they grow older. Um, he says they perform equally well sometimes. Almost as well with their sort of affected arm as they do with their unaffected arm. He [00:26:00] explicitly says, this is no problem whatsoever for people who are born with this congenital deformity.

    [00:26:06] Um, we have things like these feeding models from the ancient Greek world. There are these really cute little cups that are sort of small. They’re kind of globular with a handle on one side and then a really narrow spout coming out of it. And there's a lot of, um, a lot of speculation about what these cups are used for.

    [00:26:23] And, in my article, I discuss what I think is convincingly that these cups were used to assist infants who were born with things like cleft palate, other oral facial deformities, um, or were just who were just so sick, um, or weak that they couldn't suckle, right, at the breast. And so these are active accommodations for infants who required additional care. 

    Breastfeeding was the norm. [00:26:49] And so I think that these cups provided additional levels of support for infants who needed it, right. 

    Dr Rad

    Yeah. Well, I think it's, I think it is just so fascinating that [00:27:00] once you start looking, you just, you just find all these pieces of evidence that I had no idea until I started thinking about it, just how much there actually was.

    [00:27:10] And, um, I was looking at some evidence for Rome about some four skeletons that were found near the Via Collatina. And the fact that these, uh, you know, three out of the four people in this particular burial site had had the care of a burial, and like not a flash one, and you know, it wasn't amazing, but some of these people had extraordinary issues to deal with, you know, some spine curvatures. 

    And one of the skeletons [00:27:36] was a woman who only had one tooth. And she must have had someone helping her or looking after her in some way. And then someone who saw to her burial. Um, and so it's just, it's just so fascinating that when you start looking for the evidence, these various pieces come out of the woodwork.

    Dr Debby Sneed

    [00:27:52] Yeah, it's an interesting phenomenon, uh, even in the modern period. So I think it's very difficult to find, for example, a novel, any [00:28:00] novel, just pick up something and read it and not find disability in there, right? So a lot of people, if you challenge them, they say, you know, well, disability just doesn't show up in things.

    [00:28:10] If you challenge them to think about their favourite movie or their favourite book, right, it starts to become apparent that there's disability everywhere. And the same is true in the ancient world. I don't think that I have come across a single genre of literature where disability does not feature – sometimes quite prominently – in the ancient world.

    [00:28:27] There's even a type of poetry that is disabled in the sense that, um, it's called choliambic verse, and that's a “limping” verse. So the word “choliambic” comes from the word χωλός in Greek, which means “lame” or “limping”. So where that's often applied to Hephaestus, for example. And so it has to do with the type of meter.

    [00:28:47] And it was actually referred to in the ancient world as this kind of “limping meter” because of the way that it was so heavy across the page, right. And so you see it everywhere and it's in the archaeological evidence, it's in the literary evidence, it’s in the iconographical evidence. It's everywhere.

    [00:29:01] And so, the next question becomes, well, if the evidence is everywhere, why hasn't other – why haven’t other people – talked about this, right? And I think that that has to do with, just sort of the, the modern makeup of the field. So who are scholars? What is acceptable to study in the ancient world? 

    This is why, sort of, as a part of sort of an adjunct of my work [00:29:23], um,  I tried to get more people with disabilities involved in the study of classics, in the study of archaeology. And part of that is doing things like this podcast, right? Trying to tell people: this is a thing. You're allowed to study it. You're allowed to ask questions about it. You're allowed to look for evidence for it.

    [00:29:40] Um, this is a perfectly acceptable field of study because, you're right, the evidence is everywhere. 

    Dr G

    Yeah, and I think from the reading that I've been doing around this subject, in the lead up to this conversation, um, it seems that, like, part of what has been a real boon to this kind of study is the ability for us to use [00:30:00] searchable databases and being able to do keyword searches and [00:30:05] trying to draw out, um, the way in which ancient languages talk about disability and impairment, and then trying to filter that through the systems that we now have for being able to look at evidence. Because one of the things that tends to happen to students when you're going through the standard model for being taught classics and ancient history is you're given a text and you have to read it quite closely.

    [00:30:29] But actually what we're looking for is really broad – and maybe really quite slim – mentions of things about everyday life, which, for a lot of people, they're not reading the right texts or they're coming into contact with myth and higher literature, but they're not coming into contact with things that might give them a sense of the every day.

    [00:30:48] And, I think that element of the way that we study history is actually changing the nature of the sorts of things that we can get out of it as well. 

    Dr Debby Sneed

    Yeah, definitely. But even [00:31:00] that has limitations, right? So when you form a database, I think specifically, for example, if the Beasley Archive – the pottery database that you can find online and sort of search the corpus of Greek vase painting – one of the things that's really difficult is the search terms that are available are the ones that the creators of the database decided were relevant.

    [00:31:19] So, for example, you can't search for crutches. “Crutch” is not an acceptable search term. And so you have to think of synonyms that other people might have used in order to categorize these objects. And so it makes it really difficult sometimes to use those databases because they're created by people and it depends on what they thought was relevant in their creation of that database.

    Dr Rad

    [00:31:43] I actually think that's quite interesting. Just thinking about the, as you said, the vase painting and the artistic representations, because when I was doing a bit of reading about Greece and Rome, it seems that that might be one of the areas of difference with these two societies. In that, whilst the Romans do certainly have, [00:32:00] obviously, you know, you can look at the bodies from Pompeii and Herculaneum and you know, there are skeletons, and you can also look at textual references to various types of impairments. [00:32:09] Uh, when it comes to artistic representation, the Romans tend to be quite realistic with someone's face, but then have quite idealized bodies. Whereas, I believe, if you look at the Greek record, there are, I think it's a bit more common to have artistic representations of disabilities due to the kind that you study with like the lower limbs and that kind of thing.

    Dr Debby Sneed

    [00:32:31] Um, I think it depends. So, um, there's some really great studies on this. So Lisa Trentin, for example, has a book on hunchbacks and Hellenistic and Roman art. It's really interesting. There is Véronique Dasen, who has a book on dwarves in Egypt and Greece, but she talks a little bit about what would be sort of more Hellenistic depictions of dwarves.

    [00:32:51] And I guess you're right.. But the Greeks have their own idealizations. So if you look at Greek statues, we have a very, idealized version. And a [00:33:00] lot of vase painting, um, is similarly idealized, but I think you're right that the vase painting as a specific medium offers opportunities for visualization, that we just don't see in Rome. [00:33:11] Um, so we do see a lot of depictions of things like that. 

    One of my favourites is, uh, this little vase by what's called the Clinic Painter. So I actually had a reproduction of this vase made when I finished my PhD – 

    Dr Rad

    Oh amazing!

    Dr Debby Sneed

    – Uh, yeah, it was in the ancient Corinth, there was an artist in who does sort of reproductions. [00:33:29] And so I commissioned him to make one. It shows what's traditionally interpreted as a doctor's clinic, which is why this artist is called the Clinic Painter, and it has a bunch of men on it. Some of them are being, uh, sort of, you know, given treatments by a doctor who’s seated. But then there's also this really weird scene of a man, an adult man, he's bearded, he's standing, he's clothed, he's leaning on his staff and he's in a sort of romantic pose with another figure [00:33:54] who's a dwarf, a little person. He was also an adult man, and it's in a sort of [00:34:00] courtship pose. But we have some issues. I don't know how to interpret this vase at all. I just like looking at it because it just is so interesting the way that this gets depicted as a sort of courtship scene in this otherwise doctor's office, right. [00:34:13] It's just sort of a really weird scene.

    Dr Rad 

    That does sound very interesting and confusing. 

    Dr G

    It sounds like it's got a lot of potential for interpretation. This might drive your research until you can find a way into what is the interpretation of the scene. 

    Dr Rad

    And well it actually, has actually raised one of my, one of my other questions that came up when I was looking at some research.

    [00:34:33] So I know that in some of the Roman depictions that we do have of people with disabilities, it seems as though – although we can obviously never be sure with artistic representation – it seems as though some of the artwork we do have, which shows people with the kinds of impairments that might be intended to shock or even make people laugh.

    [00:34:55] And certainly one of the most famous texts about someone with very well-known [00:35:00] disabilities is, of course, Seneca's work about the emperor. Claudius. And how he's made fun of when he tries to join the rest of the gods after his death. Can you speak at all to the way that people might be treated cruelly or might be made the butt of jokes [00:35:15] if they have some sort of impairment in the ancient world? 

    Dr Debby Sneed

    Yeah, definitely. And you will definitely see more of that in Rome. So the way that disability in Greece versus Rome is treated is very different. And I don't think, um, I personally don't think that it's useful to discuss them together except comparatively. In Rome you see a lot of what I would call fetishization of disability.

    [00:35:36] So it is treated, uh, with shock with awe, uh, I mean that sexually as well. So it was sort of sexual fetishization as well. Um, we have stories about, uh, Uh, what is it called? Like a monster market, right? Where slaves with physical disabilities would bring a higher price. Right, so we have all of this in Rome in a way that I just find, [00:36:00] so, um, I don't know how to word it. So different than what we see in Greece. 

    So in Greece, people get made fun of for things all the time, right. But disability doesn't seem to be a category. So an individual might be made fun of, for aspects of his physical appearance. We can think of all this sympotic poetry where people are, uh, making fun of each other for being ugly or, you know, having sort of non-ideal bodies, et cetera.

    [00:36:24] But in Rome, it's just a completely different beast, where it's just something that ends up being the focus. And then other things are sort of put on top of that, right. So the sort of physical disability is used in a way to explain other aspects of somebody's personality or character, which is what I think you have going on in things like Seneca. That the disability is used almost metaphorically to refer to other aspects. This is why Claudius so difficult is because it's hard to separate what is the real – whatever is actually real – um, with the sort of metaphoric uses of disability in Roman literature.

    Dr Rad

    [00:36:59] Yeah, I think you're absolutely right. There is an element, uh, that seems to be coming through, um, philosophical works like from the Stoics where you wouldn't necessarily make fun of someone just because they have an impairment. But if that impairment is the result of “bad choices” and a “disreputable lifestyle”, then it's open season.

    [00:37:20] And Claudius, of course, with his wives and freedmen and his love of drink and food and all that kind of stuff. It's his lifestyle, which they seem to be having a problem with. And so he's kind of fair game. 

    Dr G

    But it's certainly the case that in ancient Rome, they sort of see an intimate connection between the physicality of the person and the character of the person.

    Dr Rad

    [00:37:40] Definitely. 

    Dr G

    And that, and it sounds to me, Debby, that what you're saying is that this union is less the case when we're looking at ancient Greek evidence. 

    Dr Debby Sneed

    Yeah, of course it's not absent entirely, but it is very different the way that disability is treated. We see a lot of different ways. So, you know, it's not irrelevant that one of the twelve Olympian [00:38:00] gods, Hephaestus, is disabled in ancient Greece, so that when he gets to Rome, when he's Vulcan, his disability is almost entirely erased.

    [00:38:07] You know, I think Greece has just a very different situation. They're treating things differently. Their culture is different, right. This is that sort of contingency of disability. And this is, this is why – so a lot of people will think about disability in the past, and they just sort of lump everything in the pre-modern period together. [00:38:22] That life was hard, therefore, it must've been harder for people with disabilities. There's this kind of – we think that people with disabilities don't have any inherent value. And that they're only given value in a modern society, where we’re rich enough to afford, and we've got these high moral values that will grant, you know, rights to people with disabilities.

    [00:38:42] So we just assume that if you were to rewind the clock, that that wouldn't be the case in the past, but in fact, it's not necessarily, not the case. It's not necessarily the case. It's just a different situation and deserves its own treatment. And so some of our earliest studies of disability in the ancient period in the ancient [00:39:00] Mediterranean sort of looked at sort of the Greco-Roman understanding of disability.

    [00:39:04] But I think that if you were to distinguish them, I think it would be an excellent case study for how exactly the Greeks Romans are different. It would be a great way of explaining the differences in the cultures so that people stopped just eliding them into the same thing. 

    Dr Rad

    That's true. I mean, I actually hadn't, again, I'd never really stopped to think about this before, but the Roman naming system where they got, you know, the, the three barrel name, at least, sometimes more.

    [00:39:28] I never stopped to think about the fact, even though we often talk about the meaning of some of those names, um, how many of them actually refer to some sort of physical defect. Apparently 44% of Roman cognominia refer to physical defects of some kind, which is just amazing. And it's built right into, you know, their naming system.

    [00:39:49] It just blew my mind when I saw exactly how high that was. 

    Dr Debby Sneed

    Yeah. It's really just such an interesting part of the Roman conception of disability, how it's just sort of there [00:40:00] and ever present and can be used in this way. It's one of the reasons that I actually really struggle to talk about disability in Rome is because I feel like [00:40:09], uh, it just requires such an intimate knowledge of Roman society. One that I just don't have coming from the Greek, like studying the Greek world. That even though I know a lot about disability and how to study disability, um, just looking at statistics like that, looking at the stories that we have, looking at figures like Claudius, it just makes it so difficult to understand, unless you can situate it appropriately in the context of Roman history.

    [00:40:34] I don't think that the same person can do both, if that makes sense. 

    Dr Rad

    No, I completely hear you in terms of the level of expertise that must be required. So let's bring it back to ancient Greece as we move towards the end. Just before we finish up, I'd love to hear about some of the particular bodies or cases that you have looked at in your career.

    [00:40:53] Can you tell us about some of the most interesting cases that you've come across? 

    Dr Debby Sneed

    Definitely. The one that I love. You know, I [00:41:00] don't have answers for a lot of these figures that I'd bring up. I'm still struggling with exactly how to situate them. But one of my favourites is the speaker. We don't have his name, but he's a speaker and a law court speech by the orator Lysius. Lysius is a very well-known logographer, I guess, from the fourth century BCE, he wrote speeches for people.

    [00:41:20] He was a metic, so he was a sort of a resident of Athens, but not a citizen. And, so he wrote speeches for other people. And in one of them, it is for a man who has been accused of welfare fraud, essentially. So Athens had a pension system for people with disabilities. And what's interesting about this pension system is that it wasn't just for people with disabilities.

    [00:41:44] It was for people who were so disabled that they couldn't work, which does a couple of things. First of all, it presumes that there are people with disabilities who could work, right? Who could. Perform and, you know, perform within the sort of labour market bringing enough money. 

    [00:42:00] And so we have this guy who has been accused of receiving it fraudulently. And so this speech is his defense and what's interesting is that he's disabled. He talks about how he walks with two crutches. And so the argument isn't that he's not disabled, it's that he's lying about his financial need. And so, you just get this really great characterization of somebody, sort of in his own words, quote unquote, it was written by Lysias, right.

    [00:42:26] So it's kind of hard to say whose words we have here. And there are a lot of open questions about this speech. But you get this great characterization of somebody who is disabled and we get a great understanding of what disability might have meant. He talks about how, you know, yes, he owns a shop.

    [00:42:43] So he doesn't tell us what kind of business this shop is, which is one of the big questions, right? It seems a little shady that he's not telling us what his business is. But he says, you know, but it's not enough money to bring anyone in. He says, I don't have a slave to help me with my work. I don't have children who can care for me in my old age.

    [00:42:59] And I'm just getting older. So my disabilities are compounding. And he talks about all of this. He talks about how, you know, he has to borrow other people's horses to get around. So when his distances are too great for his crutches to take him there, you know, he has to take a sort of equine transport in order to do it.

    [00:43:16] Um, so it's just this really great speech. And I think that it is Lysias 24, if anyone wants to read it. It's such a great way to start thinking about this topic of disability in ancient Greece, because this is probably the closest that we get hearing the words of somebody who identifies as disabled.

    Dr G

    [00:43:34] Mmm, I think this is a fascinating piece of evidence actually. And the fact that we can glean from this, that there is, uh, a system set up of support, uh, for people who fall within a particular category of disability as well, I think is fascinating. And speaks to something really particular about the structure of ancient Greek society that, perhaps a lot of people coming to the ancient world [00:44:00] and haven't considered at all.

    Dr Debby Sneed

    Yeah, and I mean, this is specifically Athens, right. We can't say what anyone else would have thought about this exactly. And we have it in other evidence. So we know that at least this man was eligible for it. Uh, he has some sort of mobility impairment.

    [00:44:14] We have another speech, um, by, I forget who right now, but we have another speech where somebody is blind. And receives the payments, right? So he's an older man who is blind and the payment is also listed in The Athenian Constitution that sort of pseudo-Aristotelian text, uh, sometimes referred to as the AthPol, it's a abbreviation, a reference to this pension.

    [00:44:38] So it's pretty secure, right, that this is a real thing, uh, that at least in the fourth century, there was this pension system. Not charity exactly. I mean, there's some really great work by Matthew Dillon on this, I think, where he talks about how, you know, it's not specifically, uh, it's not charity, right. It's an attempt to avoid patronage in Athens, [00:45:00] right. To prevent people with disabilities who couldn't work from relying on the financial support of an individual and therefore developing a sort of allegiance to that individual instead feeling allied to the state. 

    Dr Rad

    Absolutely. So we're getting towards the end of our time. [00:45:15] But before we finish up, I thought I would like to give you a chance to talk a little bit about some of the difficulties of this area of study. Obviously, I'm sure you face the usual problems, so, you know, not having enough source material, you know, you obviously love to have more always from the ancient world. But I imagine that looking at this particular area, there's also issues with, um, you know, sensitive language and that sort of thing as well.

    [00:45:40] So would you care to speak to some of the difficulties that you've encountered in this particular area? 

    Dr Debby Sneed

    Yeah, definitely. So, uh, in terms of source material, I actually think that there's a lot. Especially relative to some of the other, uh, topics that you can study in the ancient world. I think that there's a lot of evidence for disability. I, in fact, I find it almost too much to grapple with, and I hope that [00:46:00], sort of, future directions of this study, um, I sort of try to grapple with all of it together and try to reconcile the different pictures that we get from different kinds of evidence. Um, but what I would like is, what I prefer is, if people who are specialized in these different areas, in ancient warfare, in ancient children and childhood, et cetera, actually looked at disability in a theoretically engaged way, so that we have specialists [00:46:24] on these different topics, actually looking at the topic in a sensitive way. 

    The use of language is a difficult one. Um, you know, even if you just look at my dissertation, two recent articles to the way I discuss now, right. My terminology has changed. And part of that is, as I learned more, but part of it is also just that language is constantly developing.

    [00:46:45] So “able-bodied” was a term that I think was preferred, you know, even a few years ago, but now the term for somebody who is not disabled, the preferred term is “non-disabled”, right. And so, you know, you do want to be sensitive? Uh, you'll find plenty of evidence in the [00:47:00] scholarship of people not being sensitive to terminology.

    [00:47:03] So it can actually be very difficult to read some of the work on disability in the ancient Greek world. Um, because you could read a lot of, sort of ableist bias into the way that people discuss it. Um, but one of the most difficult things that I find about this subject has nothing to do with the ancient world, but actually all to do with the modern world.

    [00:47:20] I get a lot of pushback on this topic. A lot of skepticism. And what's interesting about it is that the skepticism that I receive is not based in evidence, it's based on people's impressions. They just don't believe that people with disabilities in ancient Greece could have been treated with anything except disgust or disdain or pity.

    [00:47:41] And so it's really difficult to convince people even based directly in the evidence that that is not the case. So when people bring up Sparta, for example, and about how, you know, Spartans had no place in their society for somebody who is disabled. And I say, well, we have this fourth century BCE [00:48:00] King Agesilaus, the Second, who is disabled.

    [00:48:03] And they just excuse that example. I'm like, okay, well, I mean, there's a Spartan who was disabled, so, okay. And so the more that you bring up examples, they all get explained away as opposed to, uh, just sort of reconciling them and accepting that this is a feature and then questioning from there, what that means.

    [00:48:23] So a good example is the ramps. You know, there are eleven at this healing sanctuary, whether it's a regional phenomenon is irrelevant. You still have to explain why there are eleven ramps at this one sanctuary when other ones have no ramps or just one ramp. 

    So you have to explain these things, but I find it really difficult to [00:48:44], sort of, get over people's initial inclination to reject the idea. 

    Dr Rad 

    Yeah, no, look, I must admit doing reading for this, I'm very grateful to have had you on the show. Not just because you've been wonderful to talk to, but it encouraged me to do reading that I wouldn't have [00:49:00] otherwise done. And a lot of the time I was looking at material that I've encountered before, like looking at the remains from Pompeii and Herculaneum, thinking about people like Claudius, thinking about, you know, philosophers like Seneca, looking at people like, you know, Philip of Macedon, and even the Twelve Tables.

    [00:49:17] We've actually just done an episode on the Twelve Tables, where we had mentioned the fact that they built into that law code in Rome, the fact that if people couldn't physically get to the court, there had to be provision for them to be carried there. And I'd never stopped to think about it. And I've never really stopped to think about just how much evidence there really was in this world for people who had a variety of conditions [00:49:41], which would have made life different for them in some way. 

    So I am so grateful to have had you on the show to discuss this topic. 

    Dr G

    And I think it's very revealing as well in terms of – just to jump in with a little piece of evidence that I quite like that I've encountered through this. Because one of the areas that I'm very interested in is the [00:50:00] rise of Augustus.

    [00:50:00] And he institutes this law of the three children and we get a whole commentary from Ulpian on this, about what constitutes “the three children”. And it seems that at law, the decision is made that – even if the child is considered “monstrous”, and so we're not sure to what extent that means in terms of disability, but it seems like there's some sort of birth deformity at play [00:50:25] – that the mother is not to be held responsible for this and the child still counts towards the three in the eyes of the law. And that's just a little aspect of a much bigger part of history that is part of my studies that I am now thinking about because of these kinds of discussions that are happening.

    [00:50:44] So I think the work that you're doing, Debby, is really important and significant for the way we approach evidence in the ancient world, across the board. 

    Dr Rad

    And of course, Dr. G,  is a Vestal fanatic. And of course, to be a Vestal at this time –

    Dr G

    Oh yes!

    Dr Rad

    as well, you [00:51:00] also have to have –

    Dr G

    You have to have no speech impediment to be a Vestal Virgin.

    [00:51:04] That is one of the core tenants. Um, young women would not get chosen for the role if they had a speech impediment. 

    Dr Debby Sneed

    Yeah, definitely, right. So religious ritual is all about repeating things in the exact appropriate way. Uh, so this is something that, um, it's not really surprising, I guess, about the Vestal Virgins and the Ulpian thing is really interesting.

    [00:51:22] One of the things that is great, and that makes it difficult to study this, especially – I'm a non-disabled person, uh, which is a really important thing to bring up and I should have brought it up sooner, um, because I'm studying this as a non-disabled person. 

    Um, and I would like it if I was not the one, right [00:51:41], who was sort of doing this work. You know, I hope that we can get more people with disabilities involved in research, doing this research, asking these questions because, um, you know, we've known about the ramps. So back to the ramps. We've known about these forever, right? 

    However long we could have known that there were ramps. We've known [00:52:00] that there were ramps at some of these sanctuaries. But I think that non-disabled people, so, which includes many archaeologists, right, we sort of take for granted aspects of mobility. We don't ask how people get into buildings because we never consciously think about it. We just walk into them.

    [00:52:16] Whatever's there we use. If there are stairs, we use stairs. If there is a ramp, we use a ramp. If the stairs are really tall, we just use them, right. So we just don't really think about it. And I think that if we had had more people with disabilities involved in some of these studies, I think that the question would have been asked a lot sooner.

    [00:52:34] And, um, just because, you know, it's just something that people with mobility impairments are consciously aware of. And so even if disability is not the answer, it's worth asking the question and it's just something that we don't get, right. When you have only one type of person asking questions.

    And this is one of – there's this really great interpretation of Oedipus.

    [00:52:56] So Oedpius, the King of Thebes. So, you know, very [00:53:00] famously killed his father and married his mother. And he also solves the riddle of the Sphinx. And the riddle of the Sphinx is, you know, “what walks on four legs in the morning, two legs at midday and three legs in the evening?” And it's of course humans.

    [00:53:15] So, you know, crawling as an infant, walking on two legs and then when you're an adult, and then using three legs, so two legs, plus a crutch or a cane, in old age. And there's one really interesting suggestion by David Mitchell and Sharon Snyder, who are both disability studies scholars, that Oedipus is able to answer this question because he has a mobility impairment, because when his parents sort of exposed him at birth in order to avoid his fulfillment of this prophecy, that they actually intentionally mutilated him.

    [00:53:46] So they had his heels, sort of, clipped or something like that. And that, because he has this mobility impairment, when he reaches the riddle of the Sphinx, this riddle that nobody before had ever been able to answer, right. That he was uniquely [00:54:00] situated to answer that question because he was uniquely positioned to think about mobility constantly.

    [00:54:06] And so, I think that this is a really important thing, is, based on, not just my non-disabled status, but based on all other aspects of my identity, I individually have limited in the kinds of things that I can come up with. The questions that I can ask the interpretations that I can come up with. 

    And so, one of the challenges that I have is that there just aren't people asking these questions. And so, uh, we just need a lot more people asking them and thinking about them and offering solutions, not just disabled people, right. So they don't have, it's not like these are their ancestors or something like that, but they just have this other perspective that just hasn't really been sort of appreciated in an academic context.

    Dr Rad

    [00:54:35] No, I think you're absolutely right. As I say, my experience is extremely limited. And as I say, I consider myself to be an extremely fortunate human being, but certainly the way that I interact with the world and things that I'm aware of, that other people aren't aware of, because I've become extremely hard of hearing.

    It's really changed particularly over the last ten years. Yet, you know, just things like going out to restaurants and also I'm a teacher. [00:55:00] The kinds of rooms that I can teach in effectively. I become much more aware of sound qualities and various things like that than other people are just because I struggled so much more to understand people, even with hearing aids.

    [00:55:13] Um, and it does, it does allow me to say a little bit of what you're talking about, in that, unless you've got that lived experience, you sometimes won't think of certain angles of investigations. 

    Dr Debby Sneed

    [00:55:25] And this is true of other things as well. I don't know if this is true, but I read something about, sort of this, uh, neolithic or paleolithic find that somebody found a bone and it had notches on it.

    [00:55:38] So something like twenty-eight notches on it. And there were all of these interpretations about what these notches meant: why twenty-eight, you know, et cetera, et cetera. And it was a bunch of men asking the question. And that none of them had considered, of course, menstrual cycles, right, and whether that could be a relevant interpretation, because why would they think of menstruation being twenty-eight days?

    [00:56:00] And so it's just demonstrates like the importance of being like, well, here's a suggestion, right? From somebody who has a lived experience of something it's not going to mean, it's not that a man could never have come up with that. It's just, it's not going to be at the forefront of their mind.

    [00:56:18] And it's going to take a lot more work for them to consciously think about something. Whereas for a woman, you might more naturally think of this interpretation. 

    Dr G

    On that note, I'm wondering if there are any scholars that you're aware of who are working in this field, who are bringing their disability to their study of the ancient world, [00:56:39] we might also consider and consult. And when we're thinking about this topic in the future. 

    Dr Debby Sneed

    [00:56:44] I don't personally, so. There are some, right. A lot of graduate students. For example, I have a [00:56:50] colleague Mason Schrader, who's currently a graduate student at Texas Tech, who is disabled and he's working in classical archaeology.

    [00:56:56] Um, and I have an article co-authored with him that will be coming out hopefully next year about disability and archaeology and how to make our field schools more accessible. And there's this really great group called Crip Antiquity. You can look them up on Twitter, but also they have a website, and it is a collective of people with disabilities and also allies of people with disabilities working in classical antiquity.

    [00:57:20] And so if you're specifically looking for somebody, that's what I would recommend that you start is with the group Crip Antiquity. To look at the work that they're doing, the advocacy that they're doing, and suggestions that they have specifically for this. But, you know, there are some great books. Um, I just, I don't know, for example, so you're looking for a book length study on this Martha L Roses, The Staff of Oedipus: Transforming Disability in ancient Greece is where I would start.

    [00:57:44] You know, I have my dissertation, but if you're looking for an actual book, The Staff of Oedipus is where I would start. I think it's a very sensitive, it's a theoretically engaged study of the subject. She looks at a very limited range of disabilities. She looks at, uh, stuttering, deafness [00:58:00], muteness, and blindness, I think is what she limits her study to, you know. But I think it's a really fantastic place to start. [00:58:08] Her bibliography is really solid. Um, but then there are a lot of article length treatments of this subject as well. Of course my article on ramps, my article soon coming out this year on disability and infanticide. And hopefully, uh, whenever I finish my book, I will recommend that one. 

    Dr Rad

    Oh, we'll have to have you back on once you have finished your book. [00:58:27] Because I mean, as I say, you've just opened my mind to all these things, which I've seen before. I mean, Everything from Tutankhamun to the stories of Jesus healing, people in the Bible. I'm just like, “Oh my god, I can't believe I've never thought about this before!” So you've definitely opened up our mind to, to looking at the sources in a completely different way.

    [00:58:42] Um, if people do want to access your work, what's the best way to follow you and what you're, what you're up to? 

    Dr Debby Sneed

    Probably on Twitter. Yeah, so I have a Twitter. I, you know, I don't know if I'll have it forever, but right now that's a great place to find me. I'm @debscavator D E B S C A V A T O R. 

    A great way to follow me is on Twitter. [00:59:02] I post about the work that I'm doing, but anyone who's looking to study this topic in addition to Crip Antiquity, there's also Christian Laes. I think that's how you say his last name. He actually maintains a bibliography on disability history in the ancient world, which is limited, uh, which has sort of 3000 BCE to 700 CE and the ancient world confined mostly to the Mediterranean, but broadly [00:59:27] defined within the ancient Mediterranean. So looking at disability in the Bible, disability and Judaic and Islamic, early Islamic context, right; in ancient Greece and ancient Rome. And I think at present, it is seventy-one pages long of articles and books, uh, just, and you can find that online, if you just Google the website is Disability History and the Ancient World.

    [00:59:52] Um, and you'll find this entire bibliography that he updates on a regular basis is constantly taking suggestions for it. Um, so anybody looking to study this, this is a great place to start. Even if the bibliography is kind of difficultly organized. 

    Dr G

    Oh, fantastic. Well, thank you so much for coming and chatting with us. [01:00:12] We really appreciate it. 

    Dr Debby Sneed

    [01:00:14] No this has been really great. You know, I'm always happy to talk about this work. So thank you for having me and giving me the opportunity to sort of spread the idea of disability and lead ancient world questions that people can be asking and hopefully to encourage people to consider these in their own studies, to return to familiar things that they've read from the ancient world or vases that they've seen or [01:00:31] Sites that they've visited and consider what they might have overlooked.

    Dr Rad

    [01:00:54] Thank you for listening to this special episode of The Partial Historians. And of course, if you're one of our patrons and you've got to listen to it a little bit before everyone else. If you're keen to also get early access to all of our bonus content, then please subscribe and become a Patreon. We really value your support. It helps keep the show going.

    Philip II of Macedon had his right eye surgically removed after sustaining an injury.
    This artwork imagines what he may have looked like after the injury.
    Image courtesy of panaiotis.deviantart.com

    Our Sources

    Below are materials recommended by Dr Sneed during the episode or sources that we consulted in preparation for the interview.

    • Dasen, V. Dwarfs in Ancient Egypt and Greece. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013.
    • Dillon, M. ‘Legal (and Customary?) Approaches to the Disabled in Ancient Greece.’ In Disability in Antiquity, ed. Christian Laes, 167-181. New York: Routledge, 2017.  
    • Fischer, J. ‘Behinderung und Gesellschaft im klassischen Athen. Bemerkungen zur 24. Rede des Lysias.’ In ed. Rupert Breitwieser, Behinderungen und Beeintraechtigungen/Disability and Impairment in Antiquity. British Archaeological Reports, 2012.
    • Gaveart, B. ‘Perfect Roman bodies.’ In Disability in Antiquity, ed. Christian Laes, 213-221. New York: Routledge, 2017.
    • Laes, C. Disabilities and the disabled in the Roman world: a social and cultural history. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2018.
    • Mitchell, D. T.; Snyder, S. L. Narrative Prosthesis: Disability and the Dependencies of Discourse. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 2000
    • Pudsey, A. ‘Disability and infirmitas in the ancient world.’ In Disability in Antiquity, ed. Christian Laes, 22-34. New York: Routledge, 2017.   
    • Rose, M. L. The Staff of Oedipus: Transforming Disability in Ancient Greece. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 2003  
    • Sneed, D. ‘The architecture of access: ramps at ancient Greek healing sanctuaries.’ Antiquity 94, 376 (2020), 1015-1029.
    • Trentin, L. The hunchback in Hellenistic and Roman art. New York: Bloomsbury Academic, 2015
    • Trentin, L. ‘The ‘other’ Romans.’ In Disability in Antiquity, ed. Christian Laes, 233-247. New York: Routledge, 2017.
    • If you are interested in exploring this topic in greater depth, you may want to consult this bibliography on disability in antiquity that is primarily curated by Christian Laes
    • You may also like to check out the work of CripAntiquity @cripantiquity
    • If you enjoyed listening to Dr Debby Sneed, you can follow her on Twitter @debscavator and Academic.edu
    Sound Credits

    Original music: Bettina Joy De Guzman

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    1 hr 2 min
  • The Partial Recap – the 450s BCE

    It's our second episode in The Partial Recap series. This is a short, sharp, scripted overview of all the big events that defined the 450s BCE. If you're inspired to delve into more details, all the episodes from this decade can be found in our Foundation of Rome series.

    Let's jump into the refresher! It's the Partial Recap of the 450s BCE!

    The Partial Recap – the 450s BCE

    A view to the East over the Roman Forum with the Temple of Saturn on the left and the Palatine Hill on the right, showing the Temple of Castor and Pollux, the Arch of Titus, Santa Francesca Romana, and the Colosseum. Detail from the photograph by Nicholas Hartmann, June 1976. Image Source: Wikimedia Commons. Used under license.

    TranscriptIntroduction

    FR – Welcome to the Partial Recap for the 450s BC!

    PG – I’m Dr G 

    FR – and I’m Dr Rad

    PG – and this is our highlights edition of the 450s in Rome. We’ll take you through from 459 to 450 in an epitome of our normal episodes.

    FR – Perfect for those mornings when you don’t want some lengthy rhetoric with your coffee

    PG – Get ready for a recappuccino. 

    459 BCE

    In 459 BCE, the consuls were Lucius Cornelius Maluginensus Uritnus and Quinctus Fabius Vibulanus, an old-hand in his third consulship. 

    • Rome is picking up the pieces after the recent invasion. A census is carried out. Rome has 117 319 citizens. Lustral sacrifices are needed to cleanse the city.
    • Livy and Dionysius don’t really agree on the exact course of events. Perhaps Rome is trying to restore its rep after the military humiliation of the previous year?
    • What seems clear from both accounts is that the Volscians and Aequians are up to something and the Romans set off to deal with it.
    • They are particularly keen to help out the Tusculans who are under attack from the Aequains – or is this just a method for the Romans to restore their reputation after the invasion. 
    • Under Fabius, the Romans defeat the Aequians decisively. 
    • The consuls meet up and target the lands of both the Volscians and the Aequians. 
    • Antium, in Volscian territory, is a particular hotspot. It seems like there is a revolt going on in this territory, only recently captured by the Romans. After a messy battle, Antium is retaken and some locals and colonists are publicly scourged and beheaded. Now there’s an example no one will want to follow. 
    • Back at home, there is agitation for the law about the laws, but the Prefect of the City, Lucius Lucretius Tricipitinus, says that nothing can take place when consuls are away.
    • The quaestors, Aulus Cornelius & Quintus Servilius, try to pursue Volscius for the charge of committing perjury about Caeso Quinctius being responsible for his brother’s murder – and it seems like they have a genuine case. The tribunes hold them off – after all, the consuls are away, right?
    • Once the consuls return, it’s triumph time! Almost as though the invasion of 460 never happened…
    458 BCE

    In 458 BCE, the consuls were Lucius Minucius Esquilinus Augurinus and Caius Nautius was consul for the second time.

    • Rome is facing war on many fronts, so both of the consuls are need out in the field. 
    • Ex-consul, Quinctius Fabius Vibulanus, is made Prefect of the City – probably to keep an eye on the tribunes as well as the enemies of Rome.
    • The exact order of events is different in Livy and Dionysius, but external wars constitute the main events of the year. 
    • The Aequians are back in action in spite of making peace the year before. The Aequians feel that they are not violating the deal as they are attacking the Latins – Rome’s allies, not Rome itself.
    • The Romans send an embassy to talk to the Aequian’s leader, Cloelius Gracchus, Quinctius Fabius Vibulanus, Publius Volumnius Amintinus Gallus and Aulus Postumius Albus Regillensis 
    • Cloelius tells the distinguished ROmans to talk to the tree, because he ain’t listening
    • And it’s on like Donkey Kong
    • Minucius does not take a bold approach against the Aequian forces, which gives them confidence. Nautius has to be sent for as back-up. 
    • The tribunes pull their classic move of trying to prevent the levy of forces, and they almost won, but the Sabines then attack ROman territory, terrifying everyone.
    • Nautius enjoys success against the Sabines, before being summoned by Minucius. 
    • However, they are going to need more help. What they need is a silver fox with enough virtus to choke an elephant. They need a dictator and they need Cincinnatus, father of the exiled Caeso. 
    • At least, the patricians do – they plebs aren’t thrilled at first. 
    • Cincinnatus whips the citizens into action and devises a strategy that wins the day against the Aequians. Cincinnatus demands the city of Corbio and Gracchus is brought to him in chains – YOU talk to the tree, smart-ass! 
    • Cincinnatus is now free to rescue the Tusculans.
    • Minunius steps down from the consulship but remains in Cincinnatus’ service – he’s just so amazing! The army is in the best shape ever and all because of him. He is awarded an elaborate gift and a triumph.
    • Because he is Cincinnatus, he is prepared to give up his power now that the external threat has passed…. But only after he finishes the case against his son’s accuser, the tribune Volscius. 
    • Between Cincinnatus and the Quaestors Marcus Valerius Volusi Maximus and Titus Quintius Capitolinus Barbatus, Volscius is found guilty and exiled.  
    • Cincinnatus can now return to his life as a private citizen on his farm. 
    457 BCE

    In 457 BCE, the consuls were Quintus Minucius Esquilinus and Marcus Horatius Pulvilius in his second consulship.

    • In this year, the Sabines become a problem once more, attacking ROman territory. 
    • The tribunes are undeterred, demanding the codification of the laws. Give us the law!
    • The consuls want to ignore this issue and conduct the levy.
    • Cincinnatus shames people into enlisting by making appeals to ROman masculinity and pride – if no one fights, the ROmans will lose their empire! The patricians will fight – but will the plebs?
    • An assembly is called, and the consul Horatius openly admits that the patricians will not give up their privileges. He brings out the old patricians to shame the plebeians and again questions their masculinity.
    • The tribune Verginius counters as he can see the crowd is being affected by these theatrics. No one is betraying anyone here – they just want some concessions.
    • Horatius will entertain any reasonable requests, so the tribunes ask for their number to be doubled.
    • Cincinnatus and Claudius are in favour of making this deal – more tribunes means a greater possibility for them to be divided into factions. 
    • The tribune election takes place immediately – the plebs know they need to get the money up front now!
    • The levy can now proceed and Minucius is sent to deal with the Sabines, who retreat and allow their lands to be pillaged.
    • Horatius defeats the Aequians and razes Corbio to the ground. 
    456 BCE

    In 456 BCE, the consuls were Marcus Valerius Volusi Maxumus Lactuca and Spurius Verginius Tricosus Caeliomontanus. 

    • The tribunes for the year were Lucius Icilius and Lucius Alienus.
    • Icilius is keen to meet with consuls, but they are ghosting him. When he tries to force the issue,  Icilius’ attendants are driven away by the consuls’ lictors.
    • In retaliation, the tribunes seize one of the lictors and decide to throw him off the Tarpeain Rock.  
    • The consuls are distressed, but helpless to fight off the tribunes. Luckily for them, the tribunes decide to release the hapless lictor. 
    • Icilius instead pursues a law about the use of public land. This law would mean that land that has been taken by force or fraud would be given over to the populace, the occupiers reimbursed and the rest to be divided up amongst the public  
    • The Senate agreed, except for Gaius Claudius, and this law was unusually named after Icilius. 
    455 BCE

    In 455 BCE, the consuls were Titus Romilius Rocus Vaticanus and Gaius Veturius Cicurinus. 

    • Once again, two of the tribunes were Lucius Icilius and Lucius Alienus. 
    • This is a tricky year, as the accounts of Livy and Dionysius diverged. 
    • In Livy, the tribunes were all feeling very ashamed as they felt they had not accomplished much – especially with ten of them working for the people. They are pushing hard to get the law about the laws through. 
    • Unfortunately for them, the Aequians were on the loose and attacking the Tusculans. No Roman can resist an adorable Tusculan in distress!
    • The consuls were despatched and killed 7000 Aequians in battle. The remainder of the Aequians fled, leaving lots of booty behind for the Romans. The consuls decided to sell the spoils as the treasury needed to be replenished.
    • The army is furious and the tribunes see their opportunity to impeach the consuls once they are out of office. 
    • In Dionysius, the consuls decide on war as they need to distract people from the law about the laws. Some of the people are reluctant to enlist, so the consuls start arresting the culprits.
    • The tribunes denounce the consuls, especially as they are arresting people who are appealing to their protection. The tribunes claim that they are able to release people from the levy, and when that didn’t work, they try to physically stop the levy.
    • A fight breaks out between the young patricians and the tribunes and their supporters. The patricians win the day, but the tribunes put out the call for more plebeians to join them, and soon the patricians were outnumbered. 
    • The tribunes demand that the consuls join their assembly and they don’t show up, the tribunes head to the senate. They confront the consuls about their behaviour, but the consuls think the tribunes are the problem. The Senate reaches no decision about how to act.
    • The tribunes call a meeting and propose that the plebs secede, but not everyone is ready for this dramatic a step. It doesn’t help that some of the tribunes have been won over the senate!
    • After much discussion, the tribunes decide to fine the consuls.
    • They call an assembly and tell the people that they are going to fight for land allotment and equality before the law. It’s time to get more than just part of the Aventine Hill. The tribunes call on plebs in the audience to come forward and speak about their experiences. 
    • The crowd goes wild, but they haven’t seen anything yet. Lucius Siccius Dentatus steps up the rostra. He is an eloquent solider with extensive military experience and too many honours to name. Who deserves land more Siccius? How can someone who has given so much have so little?
    • Everyone goes nuts for Siccius, but Icilius says they need to hear from others.
    • The consuls are desperate to block the tribune’s plans, so they make sure that they stake out the forum early. When people arrive to speak, they make their approval or disapproval known. 
    • The tension rises between the tribunes and consuls. 
    • When it is time for the vote to take place regarding the law, the patricians disrupt the process and push people off the bridge they need to cross to cast their vote. Needless to say the law does not get passed, largely thanks to the work of three patrician families – the Postumii, the Cloelii and the Sempronii. 
    • The tribunes will not take this offence lying down. They decide to go after the patrician families responsible – after all, this is an offence against the gods.
    • The patrician estates are confiscated and dedicated to Ceres – except that their friends buy their estates back for them. At least the tribunes made some money out of the deal!
    • It is at this point that the Tusculans arrive with news of an Aequian attack, and both consuls are sent to the rescue – very unusual, but that is how special the Tusculans are.
    • Although the tribunes object to the levy, the consuls have a secret weapon – an appeal to the gods. They declare that those who sign up for the campaign will please the gods – and you know what will happen to those who don’t. Most people are too scared to refuse.
    • Siccius, always one to do his duty, arrives with his own legion of veterans.
    • When the Romans engage with the Aequains in battle. Limited progress is made because both armies are so evenly matched.
    • Romilius devises a plan for Siccius and his men to try and attack the Aequians from behind whilst the attacks from the front. Siccius knows that this is a suicide mission, but Romilius refuses to back down. 
    • No one gets rid of Siccius that easily. He comes up with a cunning plan to find a different path to reach the Aequians. His men capture a local farmer and he informs them that there is just such a path. 
    • The Aequains are defeated and Siccius’ men love him more than ever for saving their lives whilst securing a victory. 
    • Now it’s time for revenge on Romilius. Siccius and his men destroy all the spoils in the Aequian camp before marching directly to Rome and telling everyone that the consuls forced him to do this. 
    • The consuls are in serious trouble – no triumphs for you!
    454 BCE

    In 454 BCE, the consuls were Spurius Tarpeius Montanus and Aulus Terminius or Aternius Varus Fontinalis.

    • Once more, there was quite a lot of difference between Livy and Dionysius.
    • Dionysius is still following the career of the Roman Achilles – Siccius. 
    • Lucius Siccius Dentatus, now a tribune, pursued a trial against Romilius for injuring the state.  
    • Siccius brought out numerous witnesses about Romilius’ callous attitude to himself and his men. The tears shed by the audience don’t bode well for Romilius. 
    • Romilius remained a haughty patrician to the last, claiming that he did what he had to do as commander. Every tribe voted to condemn him and Romilius was fined 10 000 asses. 
    • Meanwhile, former tribune and now Aedile of the plebs, Lucius Alienus, prosecuted the other former consul, Veturius, and he was fined 15 000 asses.  
    • With this unpleasantness out of the way, once again the law about the laws comes up for discussion.
    • Romilius surprisingly was in support of the codification. Although he was a staunch patrician and had always despised the plebs, his recent trial taught him a valuable lesson. The patricians were not powerful enough to protect him and all those other persecuted patricians (cough cough) like Caeso, so something needed to change.
    • Romilius suggested seeking advice from other states that are running smoothly – like somewhere in Greece! This connection to Greece has been seen as an attempt to associate Rome with the fame of Athens and the law code of Solon. After all, if the Romans wanted to learn about Greek laws, they could have have just headed south. 
    • The consuls supported Romilius’ proposal and Siccius praised him for placing the public good first. In tribute to Romilius, Siccius suggested cancelling the fine. 
    • All of this information about the fines issued to the ex-consuls seems to be related to the Lex Aternia Tarpeia, which set a maximum penalty on the fines that could be applied for offences involving illegal attempts to gain authority and disrespect. 
    • In Livy, the trip to Athens comes up after the tribunes pursue the law about the laws with the new consuls. The tribunes assure the consuls that they are prepared to be reasonable.
    • They suggest that patricians and plebeians should just get together and chat about their priorities and how to devise a law code. They agree, but only if the chat is patricians only – no plebs allowed!
    • The tribunes just want some progress, so they agree. It is after this that the educational foray to Greece is planned. 
    453 BCE

    In 453 BCE, the consuls were Publius Curiatus Fistus Trigeminius and Sextus Quinctilius 

    • The suffect consul Spurius Furius Medullinus Fusus 
    • This was one of the lowest points of the decade. A terrible pestilence broke out and caused a huge amount of suffering and death in all social classes and even the animals. 
    • We cannot be sure of the numbers, but it seems that half of the citizen population were wiped out and most of the slaves. 
    • One of the consuls was struck down, and tragically, so was his replacement – Spurius Furius. 
    • So many people were affected that the fields were neglected and famine ensued, adding to the misery of the Romans. 
    • The Aequians considered taking advantage of Rome’s weakness, but they became infected by the pestilence when they tried to attack and had to retreat. 
    452 BCE

    In 452 BCE, the consuls were Menenius Agrippa (his praenomen could have been Gaius, Lucius, or Titus) and Publius Sestius 

    • The pestilence has passed, but there are still food shortages in Rome and the consuls need to buy corn to address the grain crisis. 
    • The delegation that had been sent to Athens to study the laws of Solon return, full of ideas for the Roman law code. 
    • The Romans are getting serious about the codification of their laws and start to discuss the best way to proceed.
    • The idea for a decemvirate, a group of ten magistrates, is suggested. These men would take the place of all the normal offices and there would be no right of appeal. This could not take place immediately, as there were already consuls in office who needed to serve their full term. 
    • Whilst having a mixture of plebeian and patrician magistrates is discussed, the patricians are quick to squash those dreams – it will be patricians only or nothing. 
    • This sends up some red flags for the plebeians, who are only willing to agree to this system if they are assured that the tribunes and land allocation on the Aventine will be protected and restored once the decemvirate is over.  
    • A slight hitch is that there are already some consul-designates who have been chosen to serve in 451 – Titus Genucius and Appius Claudius.
    • Appius addresses the senate about the importance of the law code and volunteers to give up his chance to be consul so that the decemvirate can go ahead. What a guy! No wonder he is chosen to serve as decemvir.  
    451 BCE
    • The first decemvirate begins, and it is a big success. 
    • The decemvirs get along remarkably well and they aren’t flaunting their power or status. 
    • They produce the Ten Tables, which are approved after consultation with the populace.
    • Confusingly, the laws do not seem to address many issues that have been concerning the plebeians, but they do provide some insight into life in Rome at this time.  
    • Whilst everyone is satisfied, there is general agreement that a few more laws are needed and it is decided that the Romans need a second decemvirate. 
    • Elections are set, and Appius Claudius campaigns hard. He is determined to hang on to his position, so he starts getting friendly with the plebs and tribunes – even badmouthing the patricians. 
    • His colleagues are suspicious of his behaviour but they refrain from calling him out on his behaviour. 
    • Appius manages to get re-elected, along with some of his friends. 
    • Unusually, some plebeians seem to be chosen as well. What is going on? 
    450 BCE
    • As soon as he has secured his position, Appius reveals his true self. He becomes cruel and arrogant, and encourages his other decemvirs to aim for tyranny.
    • They start meeting in secret and vow never to give up their power. 
    • Each man has his own fasces and is attended by lictors in public.
    • Everyone, patrician and plebeian, is dismayed by their behaviour, but their power is absolute and there seems to be little that anyone can do. 
    • The decemvirs add two tables to the law code, making it The Twelve Tables, including a controversial ban on intermarriage between the plebeians and patricians.
    • True to their secret evil plan, the decemvirs remain in office, even though their business is seemingly now complete. 
    • As we slide into the 440s, the situation in Rome continues to deteriorate. The decemvirs start using the young patricians to bully the populace. Citizens are scourged with rods, their property can be confiscated and some are even murdered. 
    Conclusion

    FR – And that was the 450s in Ancient Rome… or was it? 

    PG – Remember, this has just been the highlights from the ancient sources, so if you want to delve into the complexities of the different evidence from this period, check out our narrative episodes. 

    FR – Thanks for joining us for this Partial Recap!

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    25 min
  • Episode 111 – Decemvirs in the Senate

    The Second Decemvirate is hotting up and it's not surprising to learn that Appius Claudius is somehow at the centre of things. We trace Rome through a precarious time, one that our sources have trouble dating – is it one year, two, three? It's c. 437 BCE; the magistracies are in disarray and the decemvirs hold sway. The situation takes a turn as Rome's neighbours sense an opportunity to invade…

    Episode 111 – Decemvirs in the Senate

    The Meeting of the Senate

    It is perhaps a measure of how the Second Decemvirate is going that we're not sure how much time has passed before the decemvirs seek a meeting with the senate. There's a haziness around dates that indicates we could be looking at up to three years of decemvirate rule!

    Appius Claudius speaks first in the Senate ostensibly to discuss how Rome will navigate the threats to her territory. But the Senate, having finally been called together under the rule of the decemvirs, have a lot of things they'd like to talk about! And boy do they have criticism to level. One very important point is that the decemvirs are operating outside the terms of their special magistracy and they are by consequence corrupting the nature of the republic.

    Looking to catch up on the action so far? Episode 109 – The First Decemvirate and Episode 110 – The Mask Comes Off are just what you need!

    The Power of Family

    The real thorn in Appius' side while in the senate meeting is the presence of his uncle, Gaius Claudius. The patriarchal structures dictate that Appius show respect for Gaius' opinion and this opens the way for some power speechifying.

    Livy and Dionysius of Halicarnassus differ in their accounts of how this moment unfolds, but the significance of a familial connection in the senate is retained by both writers. We'll explore the similarities and differences of these sources.

    There's some explosive details with Gaius Claudius touching on everything from what makes an honourable patrician, to his personal take on Appius' character flaws, to a savage endictment as to what can happen when you ignore relatives.

    The Distraction Factor

    Livy shifts from speeches to explore the politicking in the senate including a possible interregum and calls for the decemvirs to give up office by the Ides of May. Meanwhile Dionysius of Halicarnassus continues to explore the rhetorical potential of a large-scale senatorial debate!

    Things to Come
    • A patrician call for a tribune to represent them and protect them from the decemvirate!
    • The accusation that the decemvirs are the ‘Ten Tarquins' – ouch!
    • Intimidation in the senate!
    • Appius Claudius faces some heated criticism from his uncle Gaius…
    • Concerns about how Rome will raise an army
    • Has Rome been abandoned by her citizens?
    • Gaius Claudius offers Appius a way to salvage his reputation with the people
    • The possibility of an interrex
    • A Sabine defection!
    Our PlayersThe Decemvirs (named in this episode)
    • Appius Claudius
    • Quintus Fabius Vibulanus (cos. 467, 465, 459 BCE)
    • Marcus Cornelius – f. Ser. n. Maluginensis
    The Senators
    • Lucius Valerius Potitus
    • Marcus Horatius Barbatus
    • Lucius Cornelius – f. Ser. n. Maluginensis (brother of the decemvir Marcus)
    • Lucius Quintius Cincinnatus
    • Titus Quinctius Capitolinus
    • Lucius Lucretius
    Appius Claudius' Family
    • Gaius Claudius (Appius' uncle)
    Our Sources
    • Dr Rad reads Livy Ab Urbe Condita 3.39-40
    • Dr G reads Dionysius of Halicarnassus Roman History 11.4-15
    Sound Credits

    Additional music and sound in this episode includes:

    • a piece called ‘Ancient Tragedies' by 13NHarri
    • an original composition for our podcast by the incredible Bettina Joy de Guzman
    • and additional sound effects from BBC Sound Effects Beta

    The Roman Senate in action. Image via wallpaperaccess.com

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    47 min
  • Special Episode – The Reception of Cleopatra

    Cleopatra looms large in the imagination, but her legacy is often overshadowed by the western cultural tradition. It turns out that there are many ways to understand the last Pharaoh of Egypt.

    Special Episode – The Reception of Cleopatra with Yentl Love

    We were thrilled to sit down with Yentl Love to discuss the Islamic reception of Cleopatra. Love is known for her work in making ancient history and classics accessible through her blog the The Queer Classicist. Love has been studying Ancient History and Classics for a number of years and is now bringing the ancient world to life for readers across the globe.

    Egypt's last pharaoh has a rather negative reputation in the western tradition. A classic example is the characterisation of her as a poisoner.
    Alexander Cabanel, Cleopatra Testing Poisons on Condemned Prisoners, between circa 1845 and circa 1887. Wikimedia Commons

    Rethinking Cleopatra  

    Cleopatra VII was the last Pharaoh to rule Egypt. She was part of the Ptolemaic dynasty, descendants of one of Alexander the Great’s generals. She experienced her fair share of family drama. One of her sisters was executed for seizing the throne from their father! It may not have been a relaxing childhood, but it did prepare her for a political career when she became pharaoh at just eighteen, alongside her younger brother, Ptolemy XIII.

    In this episode, we discuss Cleopatra’s journey and her encounters with some of the most famous Romans in history, including Julius Caesar, Mark Antony and Octavian (later Augustus!), and how these relationships would impact the way she was represented in the surviving sources.

    There are many Greco-Roman sources that refer to Cleopatra, and these include histories, biographies, poems and letters. One factor that they have in common is the negative portrayal of the Egyptian Pharaoh. This is in contrast to the archaeological record, such as coins, statues and buildings.

    One of the most arresting portraits is by Artemisia Gentileschi, Death of Cleopatra, 1613 or 1621-1622. Here we see a woman in middle age, stripped bare of all the insignia of power in her final moment of defiance.

    Cleopatra the Scholar

    We explore some of the reasons behind the differing portraits that have survived of Cleopatra, before delving into the Islamic source tradition. Produced much later than the Greco-Roman sources or the archaeological material, the Islamic sources provide a distinct portrayal of Egypt's last queen; one that is not bound up in her relationships with men or her appearance.

    Cleopatra the scholar? Elizabeth Taylor in the title role of the 1963 film with writing implement in hand!
    Image courtesy of www.mediafactory.com.au

    Join us for this episode about the historiography of Egypt's last pharaoh; a woman whose fame deserves to include more than just her Roman lovers.

    Select Bibliography

    Ashton, S. Cleopatra and Egypt. Malden: Blackwell Publishing, 2008.

    El-Daly, O. Egyptology: The Missing Millenium: Ancient Egypt in Medieval Arabic Writings. London & New York: Routledge, 2016.

    Gillett, M. “Goddess, Whore, Queen and Scholar.” Teaching History 51, no. 1 (March 2017): 19-23.

    Hughes-Hallet, L. Cleopatra: histories, dreams and distortions. London: Pimlico, 1997.

    Welch, K. “Cleopatra as Pharaoh?” Teaching History 53, no. 1 (March 2019): 10-15.

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    55 min
  • Episode 110 – The Mask Comes Off

    The First Decemvirate was a big success, so much so that Rome opts for a Second Decemvirate!

    The decemvirs were popular figures in Rome and during 451 BCE they produced the Ten Tables. This initial set of law codes was positively received by the population, but there was something missing… MORE LAWS!

    But it isn't too long before some red flags appear…

    Episode 110 – The Mask Comes Off

    Wait a Second… Decemvirate

    Appius Claudius campaigns hard to get himself re-elected, along with some of his patrician buddies. There are also some new and unusual names that appear in the list for the Second Decemvirate – we might have some plebeian magistrates on the team. Gasp!

    As soon as they are confirmed in their positions, the charismatic, approachable and charming Appius reveals his true self and his real intentions. Tyranny!

    Life in Rome quickly becomes extremely unpleasant for everyone as the decemvirs and their thugs flex their muscles, but it's especially tough if you are one of the less privileged persons in the populace. This a dark time for Rome. Join us to find out how they deal with the infamous Second Decemvirate!

    The Cancelleria relief, frieze B.
    This piece is a relief from the rule of Domitian so far ahead of where we are in the narrative, but it does include a lictor carries the fasces with the axe.
    The first complete figure from the right is a lictor holding the fasces in his left hand.

    Our PlayersThe Second Decemvirate
    • Appius Claudius. Ap. f. M. n. Crassus Inregillensis Sabinus Pat – Cos. 471, 451
    • Marcus Cornelius – f. Ser. n. Maluginenesis Pat
    • Marcus? Sergius Esquilinus Pat
    • Lucius Minucius P. f. M. n. Esquilinus Augurinus Pat – Cos. 458
    • Quintus Fabius M. f. M. n. Vibulanus Pat – Cos. 467, 465, 459
    • Quintus Poetelius Libo Visolus
    • Titus Antonius Merenda
    • Caeso Duillius Longus?
    • Spurius. Oppius Cornicen
    • Manius Rabuleius
    Our Sources
    • Cornell, T. J. 1995. The Beginnings of Rome
    • Eder, W. 2005. ‘The Political Significance of the Codification of Law in Archaic Societies: An Unconventional Hypothesis’ in K. Raaflaub (ed) Social Struggles in Archaic Rome: New Perspectives on the Conflict of the Orders
    • Forsythe, G. 2005. A Critical History of Early Rome
    • Momigliano, A. 2005. ‘The Rise of the Plebs in the Archaic Age of Rome’ in K. Raaflaub (ed) Social Struggles in Archaic Rome: New Perspectives on the Conflict of the Orders
    • Perello, C. F. A. 2020. ‘The Twelve Tables and the leges regiae; A Problem of Validity’ in S. W. Bell & P. J. du Pleissis (eds) Roman Law Before the Twelve Tables: An Interdisciplinary Approach
    • Raaflaub, K. 2005. ‘From Protection and Defense to Offense and Participation: Stages in the Conflict of the Orders’ in K. Raaflaub (ed) Social Struggles in Archaic Rome: New Perspectives on the Conflict of the Orders
    • Scullard, H. H. 1935. A History of the Roman World 753-146 BC
    Sound Credits

    Sound Effects: Fesliyan Studios, Sound Bible, BBC.

    Original Music: the fantastic Bettina Joy de Guzman

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    43 min