
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


In around 443 BCE Rome is navigating its relationships with its neighbours. Last time we caught up with Rome they became involved in the affairs of the nearby city of Ardea. The conflict seems to have centred around a very attractive plebeian woman whose name has not been recorded in the annals of history. It’s this meddling in Ardea which sets the scene for 442 BCE…
Episode 126 – How to Win Land and Influence Ardea
The challenges of 442 BCEThe consuls of 443 had such a great year that the incoming consuls for 442 BCE knew they had a lot to live up to. There’s a sense that the successes over Ardea were substantial but there are mixed feelings about how this all come about….
The complexity lies in the nature of the history of conflict with Ardea. The Romans sense that they have actually made some mistakes in how they have dealt with Ardea and the Rutilian people. The Rutilians are the people of this region and Ardea is their capital.
In order to determine how best to proceed they opt to form the triumviri coloniae deducendae “the group of three men for the commission of the settlement”. Their task to solve the problem of land allotment in relation to Ardea. A colony might just solve their concerns, but what should that colony look like? We explore the details!
Ardea, the central settlement of the Rutilians was south of Rome.
Rome and 441 BCEIt’s a brand new year and it’s time for some games, apparently. There are rumours that the decemvirs had promised the people a set of games, and it now seems to have fallen to the tribune of the plebs, Poetilius to get this event off the ground.
Beyond the issue of games at Rome, there’s some interesting rumblings far to the south of Italy in Magna Graecia that might also become important later on.
Polychromatic terracotta head of a woman with brown hair and pale skin. From Taranto (Magna Graecia) end of 4th century BCE. Antikenmuseum Basel und Sammlung Ludwig, Inv. Kuhn 35.
Image courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.
Thanks to BBC Sounds (Beta) for sound effects and the fabulous Bettina Joy de Guzman for our theme music.
Love our work? You can support us on PatreonWall painting – mistress and three maids – Herculaneum (insula orientalis II – palaestra – room III) – Napoli MAN 9022. While a much later artefact than the period this episode covers, this depiction of women helps reflect the world explored when it comes to women.
Image courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.
Provided by Otter AI
Dr Rad 0:01
Welcome to a brand new episode of The Partial Historians where we are tracing the journey of Rome and from the founding of this city. I am one of your hosts, Dr. Rad.
Dr G 0:13
And I am Dr. G. And boy, what a time we're in Roman history. It's the early republic. People are everywhere. Armies are in places, and the Romans they're a little bit all over the shop as well.
Dr Rad 0:28
They are, we are in around 443 BCE at the moment. And to give you a bit of a recap of what happened last episode, well, quite frankly, would not have been out of place on Keeping Up With The Kardashians. Dr. G.
Dr G 0:42
Well, you know, when you're a patrician, and you really like a girl, she has to be hot, doesn't she?
Dr Rad 0:48
Oh if she's a plebeian, hell yes. She has to be hot. I mean, what else does she bring into the relationship?
Dr G 0:53
Ouch.
Dr Rad 0:56
So we had this whole situation where Rome got involved in a civil conflict that had broken out in the nearby area of DIA. And it was between a patrician group and a probation group. And it is really interesting that even though our day out is seen as being culturally quite different to the Romans. There's apparently still patricians and plebeians running around…
Dr G 1:20
Look, I'm not going to lie. I don't believe Livy I don't, I don't think there's social –
Dr Rad 1:25
Now you mentioned it. God!
Dr G 1:27
I don't think their social structure is necessarily going to resemble that of the Romans at this point in time. We know that they come from a different language group.
Dr Rad 1:34
Yes.
Dr G 1:35
They seem pretty independent, and they certainly don't want Rome involved. What are the chances that their whole society is structured on the same premise as patricians and plebeians, that Livy and Dionysius of Halicarnassus really want us to believe other is the way that the Romans operated in this very early period of the Republic?
Dr Rad 1:53
I'll tell you why. Because Rome is the best and therefore everything they have everyone else wants. Anyway, so Rome ended up getting involved in this conflict over a very hot plebeian girl, which spilled out into civil war. Seems to happen an unnatural amount of times in the ancient world. And that ended up being really good for the Romans, actually.
Dr G 2:16
It did.
Dr Rad 2:17
Yeah.
Dr G 2:17
Yeah. The consul of 443, Geganius, he manages to secure a triumph out of that.
Dr Rad 2:23
Yup.
Dr G 2:23
Incredible stuff, really.
Dr Rad 2:24
It is it is.
Dr G 2:25
And he has a girl to thank and her name has not been recorded. And frankly, that's not good enough.
Dr Rad 2:29
You know what you're right. And also, back at home, things had been peaceful domestically, with consuls in charge. Yes. And apparently a census. Yes, was the official position of sense or being created because quite frankly, it's just too much paperwork for the consuls and are interested. They're not down for it. The Romans are living in exciting time. I know. So that was our quick recap of 443 BCE. Now, Dr. G, I'm going to take you into 442. All right, Dr. J. So I know that you're going to be very attached to Libby today because Dionysius does not exist.
Dr G 3:09
Oh, yes. deines is a holocaust. This is sadly missing for 442 BC. But I'm happy to give you what little I have been able to throw together by the way of other material
Dr Rad 3:20
that I really appreciate yet.
Dr G 3:24
So I start with Bratton, yes, he and his co author created an E two volume, which then became a three volume set of magistrates of the Republic. And this is a great text, really, I mean, such good work and anyway, we have the consuls. Marcus Fabius, son of Quintus son, grandson of Marcus, Vibulanus, a patrician
Dr Rad 3:52
Of course. He's a Fabian,
Dr G 3:54
and then post rumours, a beauteous father unknown grandfather unknown over corny can
Dr Rad 4:02
That's an unusual last couple of names.
Dr G 4:05
It is. Yeah, the whole thing is a little bit unusual. And booty is how via corny can is also a patrician. But corny can just makes me think of corns and I'm sorry, but I don't really want my political leaders to have skin conditions like that.
Dr Rad 4:22
Well, okay. So this pair is also the pair that is in living, and they know that they're coming into a difficult position because the year before with Ganey is getting a tryout for so good. Yeah. Really good. And quick, just capital owners. I mean, to be honest, it doesn't seem like he actually does a lot. But everybody just loves him to pieces by this stage. Because he's older. He's been around the block a few times. They all know who he is. So they're following a class
Dr G 4:52
act. Yeah. And he's one of those silver fox consuls. Yeah.
Dr Rad 4:56
And they know that this therefore means that they've got a lot to To try and live up to because 443 had been a pretty goddamn good year as far as everyone was concerned in Rome. And also because not just how the consuls have personally conducted themselves, but the shame of that decision that had been made to steal the US territory when most vulnerable, we're just going to take it. Yeah, that stain has somewhat been lifted by the fact that the Romans had managed to successfully help them out with their civil war.
Dr G 5:30
I'm interested that Rome felt a sense of shame. I mean, it seems so unusual and out of keeping with how Rome conducts itself in the future. But we'll leave that for now. It's interesting that once once upon a time, a bit like Darth Vader once had a soul.
Dr Rad 5:45
Well, you know, look, if I'm being very cynical, Dr. G, which, you know, is someone like me. I feel like this really is part of the class conflict story, because the people made that decision. When dad came to room with this border dispute issue. Seems like years ago now. It had been the people that had made that decision. Yeah, the wetlands should be out. Yeah, the patricians slash senators who are however you want to designate them. They've never been on board. With doing that they thought it was dishonourable, because it wasn't what they were asked. They were asked to settle a border dispute, not hey, do you want this land?
Dr G 6:27
But what if those borders were Roman?
Dr Rad 6:30
Well, exactly. And so I feel like this is just a constant dig at how the people don't make good political decisions.
Dr G 6:40
Yes. And I think this is part of the way that we can tell that we're in a very rhetorical presentation of history. Yes. And this is something that historians are always aware of is that and maybe Dionysius of Halicarnassus and Livi, are aware of this to a certain extent, as well. But historians are constructing a narrative. Yeah, from the available evidence. There are some things which might be considered facts. But not everything is effect. Yeah. And sometimes facts are only relevant to the extent to which they help you understand what might be going on somewhere. And you have to pick and choose, there are always too many things happening, or conversely, as a historian, not enough records. Yeah, to be sure. So you've either got too much information, and you have to decide what you leave out. Well, you don't have enough information. And you've got to try and fill in the gaps. And live in dinosaurs of how it can ask us I'm very much trying to fill in gaps,
Dr Rad 7:35
massively. I mean, earlier and public, I don't know what they use. I mean, I do, but I don't think there's sources would have been very detailed.
Dr G 7:42
The trouble is that they're using the fastI. So they're using controller lists, which is fine and dandy. And it's something that has existed that the Romans have looked after. And they're like, these are our lists. And the Romans love lists. We've seen this before. Hello, censorship. But they're also relying on some really early historiography that has been written by others, which unfortunately for us now no longer survives. Yeah, as far as we're aware, unless somebody turns up an amazing treasure. We still hold out hope always
Unknown Speaker 8:14
find it. Very interesting.
Dr G 8:18
So we've got Aeneas as an early source Fabius picked or as an earlier source, leukemias, Mesa who came up a couple of episodes ago is an important source as well for these guys. So we do know that there are other writers who have written histories previous to live in Dionysius, but how much they've got to add and where they're getting their material from? It's also open question.
Dr Rad 8:40
Absolutely. So essentially, these new consuls, no, they want to make an impression. They don't want to be overshadowed by this dynamic duo. This, you know, bad boys, a lot of them are really bad boys. Too good. To be honest. They don't want to be overshadowed by this
Dr G 8:56
Batman and Robin, these two who did everything right in their consulship. Absolutely.
Dr Rad 9:01
So they decide, look, we've somewhat atoned for what happened with our data? A couple of years ago, however, let's push that further. Oh, I have some details. Okay. All right. So the idea of pushing it further, obviously would be that this would truly force everyone to forget that Rome ever made a bad decision.
Dr G 9:22
We can wipe the slate clean and begin again. Yeah, I'm assuming correct me if I'm wrong, that you're referring to the trim weary colon a colon nine, a De qu Dindi.
Dr Rad 9:37
Like I wasn't gonna put it like that. Yes, that is what I'm talking about.
Dr G 9:41
This is the group of three men brought together basically for the commission of the settlement. So trying to figure out the land in respect to our day are you once and for
Dr Rad 9:55
all? Absolutely. So they forced through a decree that as The population of our day had been completely decimated by what had just happened that bizarre private conflict that started a civil war over a marriage, that Rome would therefore be setting up a colony in our data. Oh,
Dr G 10:16
yeah, I don't think this solves their shame issue at all.
Dr Rad 10:20
Wait, but wait, there is a very clever aspect to this. So obviously, they're going to need people to enrol in the colony, because they don't want our data to fall prey to the moleskin. So as we highlighted in the previous episode, very close to our data, and an enemy of Rome. So they don't want that happening. And our data used to be on good terms with room they want to maintain that all that sort of thing. So they set up the decree in this very particular way. So that it seems as though what they're doing is introducing something new, rather than overturning a decision made by the people, and assisted by the tribune of the plebs, I suppose, like, they don't want to be seen that they're going back on the decision of the people. Okay. But the senators privately get together. And that's never a good sign. But actually, in this case, it is they are actually for once doing something good, it's kind of shocking. So they decided that they're going to enrol as many colonists as they possibly can. Who are people from this culture, like from the culture associated with idea are going to be the colonists? Okay,
Dr G 11:32
Romans, they're going to give a dance back their land, in creating in our day and colony, yeah, populated by our dance.
Dr Rad 11:42
Yeah, so the only land that will be distributed to colonists will be the land that the Romans took, in this bad judgement, this border land area. So that's the land that they're splitting up amongst colonists. And they are not going to give any Roman person any of this land until all the they call them reptilians in this sense, but that that's just referring to the people from this culture ideas, the capital for these particular people. Those are the people who are going to be prioritised. So it's a very sneaky way of essentially handing the land back to the people of idea.
Dr G 12:21
So does this mean that our day from this point onwards is going to be technically classified as a Roman colony? Whilst being mostly populated by its native people? Yes. In her restaurant it is.
Dr Rad 12:34
And this is when those triangles that you were talking about the three men of course, right is they are appointed to help set up this colony. Yeah, and I have some names, but I suspect that this might be something that you also have.
Dr G 12:49
Well, I mean, that would be ideal, I suppose.
Dr Rad 12:53
Okay, so they are Agrippa Menenius, Titus Cloelius Siculus, Marcus Aebutius Helva.
Dr G 13:02
Hmm. Aebutius Helva sounds a little bit familiar.
Dr Rad 13:07
A lot of those names, I think sounds really like Menenius. Again, is, you know, is a name that we have heard before. So these are all people whose names we've we've heard before. And they're going to be in a difficult situation, because they have to tread lightly, okay, in this situation, because they don't want to be upsetting the plebeians in any way in terms of this whole land issue, because the people had decided that they wanted to take this land for themselves. And apparently, the politicians are also unimpressed that these other men that were chosen, I kind of get the impression that they're just not schmoozing as much as they should be or something. But they feel like they haven't somehow earned anyone's good graces. I don't really know what he's trying to get out with this. But they're basically not very popular with anybody.
Dr G 14:01
Okay, this is really interesting. I mean, I don't have much to add to the names or the politics that's going on here. Yes. What I will say is that having very little information, I spent time looking into what what does this tree Onvia group do? Yeah, actually. And so they're created by a senatorial resolution, apparently. Yeah. So the fact that people within the patrician class seem to be upset about the choices seems a bit odd.
Dr Rad 14:30
Well, I don't know if they're upset with a choice at first, or whether it's once their choice. Maybe it's not really very clear, but definitely I agree with you that they are set up by Senators, yes, totally a senatorial decision. This
Dr G 14:43
is a senatorial decision, and there is really strict limitations on the power that can be exercised. So basically, what happens is, the area for which land distribution is to happen is staked out in the sense that like, they're like This is only for this area that you're doing this thing in. And once that task has been completed, that group of three dissolves, right, so they don't get to continue on in their power. And this might be a bit of a consequence of the Romans feeling a little bit uneasy with people deciding that their job hadn't been finished and continuing on and then turning into a whole gang of a December it which, which continues to try and manipulate everybody for their own sake. So things will be dissolved, there is a, an endpoint to this work, and it only involves a very specific geography. Yes, for sure.
Dr Rad 15:37
So, the tri MD is are summoned eventually by the tribune of the plebs to trial for what they are doing. And this again, seems to be because even though the senators have been all like, gooey, super clever, and will have all these secret meetings, so beings have seen through this mean, like, but you're not giving us the letter, yes, that appears to have been a shroud that nobody's falling for eventually. But in order to avoid this prosecution, they're just like, you know, what, we're just gonna stay here, we'll just stand at our no problems. That way. We can't be called to trial.
Dr G 16:14
I guess I just live over here now.
Dr Rad 16:15
Yeah, I guess I just live in this area, you know, it's not so bad. We're pretty similar. And because of doing this, they are therefore not put on trial. And eventually, people respect them, because they reveal that even though they're apparently quite unpopular at first, they're actually very fair and just fan. And this is where Liberty chooses to envy.
Dr G 16:37
Oh, look, that I mean, that doesn't make a lot of sense. I'm not going to pretend that Livia is making sense, you know, there seems to be some missing information. And maybe Libby doesn't know what to do it. Dionysius of Halicarnassus because we don't have him. Yeah, I don't know what he said about it, clearly wrote about it, but it's missing. The only other piece of evidence that I have for this year comes from Diodorus Siculus, who yet again, focuses mostly on Athenian history and what's going on Sure, with the Greeks versus everybody else in the gym. And then, in one final sentence. Note that in Italy, the Roman sent colonists to idea and portioned out the land in allotments, which is true. To a certain extent, we don't get any more detail than that. So the the suggestion in Diodorus seems to be that definitely some Romans get sent to our data.
Dr Rad 17:33
This is actually a really good point, I suppose to highlight how reading a range of sources is so important. And also, as you were saying previously, about, you know, choices that historians make about what to include and what to exclude and how it shapes their account, because technically what Diodorus Siculus has said is true. But technically, if you look at the extra data that levy provides whilst is obviously hugely problematic, because it's clearly not making a whole lot of sense. There is a whole lot more potentially going on here than just that.
Dr G 18:10
Yeah. And it does seem that there is perhaps a broader strategy that the Romans are attempting to apply here even if they fail to do so with good grace and yeah, but that's that's also all I have
Dr Rad 18:24
yet but on the whole have been quite a peaceful you. Yeah, and that's what Livy kind of finishes up with. So that means that Dr. G, I feel like we need to go into 441 BC Yeah, forget
Dr G 18:35
442 It's done. It's dusted a day out the land has been a lot of nobodies returned 41
Dr Rad 18:43
It is doo doo doo doo. Now this also is going to be a very short year because once again, it's quite peaceful in terms of really a lack of external conflict and also not a hell of a lot going on inside a room either.
Dr G 18:56
I have some exciting things. Okay.
Dr Rad 18:58
Let's start with the consuls. Shall we? The consuls? Okay,
Dr G 19:01
it's 441 BCE. Who shall the consuls be? Gaius Furius, father unknown grandfather unknown. Pacilus Fusus. Oh, yeah, it's got a few names. patrician did you do? And Manius or perhaps Marcus, there's some some dispute over the praenomen Yeah. Papirius father unknown grandfather unknown Crassus. Sound familiar? That family is gonna have a long and illustrious history,
Dr Rad 19:35
although not necessarily attached to this particular line. No, that's not gonna sound like that's suddenly just occurred to me that that's not quite the right connection. But anyway, I do also have those names, although, as you say, there's that dispute over who's who but anyway, apparently, back in the days of the decimal years, they had pledged some games after the whole secession of The plebs thing had happened. And they decide that this is now the appropriate time for those games to finally take place. Remember those games? I actually went back, and I read through all of the second decemvirate.
Dr G 20:13
I don't remember those games being announced at all.
Dr Rad 20:17
I could not find a record of these games being mentioned. I mean, admittedly, it was very late at night. It's possible that in the haze of what was 449 that I somehow did not find it because I was tired, but I actually do not recollect this at all.
Dr G 20:32
Look, maybe there was some pamphlets up around Rome and somebody saw 100 faded quite severely by now. They're like, Wait a minute.
Dr Rad 20:39
Yeah. Okay. Good. Yeah. Now I do also have attributed of the polar bears being names. Yes, portfolios. A name I quite like, but unfortunately, not a person to be like strategy. Oh, yeah. Typical Tribune, which means he wants to stir up trouble.
Dr G 20:57
I love a good. I love a good troublemaker.
Dr Rad 21:00
Yeah. So this guy was tribune of the plebs. Maybe for the second time, he may have actually been one of the tribunes from the previous year. He also had been elected on the promise that these games would be carried out this year.
Dr G 21:17
Wow. Somebody's reputation is riding on these games pretty hard. Now. I'm
Unknown Speaker 21:21
like, what games wouldn't it?
Dr G 21:24
Look? It's been a tough few years. You know, we could use some games.
Dr Rad 21:27
Yeah. Now Portelli is decides that well, okay, if the consuls have stolen my thunder by talking about the games, I know what I'll do. I'll say that the consuls need to put forward a proposal where the plebs are gonna get some land. Oh, boy,
Dr G 21:43
we've come full circle.
Dr Rad 21:45
I'm just like, Oh, my God, I land with you. I agree with you. But this seems a bit out of left field after everything. We've been dealing with land
Dr G 21:52
rights have been off the agenda for a little while. Until maybe like last year. Yeah.
Dr Rad 21:57
They're always gonna be on the agenda until there is a quality. Yeah, yeah, true. Anyway, so naturally, the patricians respond, no, there will be no land for you. Thank you very much. Then per Tullius is like, Okay, gotta take another strategy. Instead, I'm going to try really hard to get a vote from the Senate about whether we're going to have these military tribute ins with continental authority, or whether there are going to be consuls voted for in the next election.
Dr G 22:27
Oh, okay. He's bringing out the big guns, isn't it? Yes.
Dr Rad 22:31
And again, this goes for consuls.
Dr G 22:34
Wow.
Dr Rad 22:36
Poetilius then says, Alright, fine. Have your consuls, but I'll tell you what's going to happen. I'm going to disturb the levy. And do you know what their responses from the patricians?
Unknown Speaker 22:52
Levy. Whoa, you idiot. Go ahead. Most of the Livi see weekend. Good one.
Dr Rad 23:00
Wow. And that's all I have.
Dr G 23:04
This year is bonkers. All right. So yeah, I have none of those kinds of details. All I've got is Diodorus Siculus. Right. Do this is booked Well, section 35. Okay. And he names the consuls. Yes. The consuls names Correct. Right. Incredible stuff. Yes. So he has a source. But he also talks about what is happening in Italy to the south. So we're talking about Magna Grecia. Okay, essentially, yeah, this might become of interest later. So I'm gonna mention it now. So we're not in Rome anymore. We're talking about the inhabitants of three i Okay. Now, three, I heard
Dr Rad 23:42
of this place, because Spartacus ends up. Yeah, capturing the chance. Sorry.
Dr G 23:49
Three, it is apparently founded in and around this period, right, essentially in 443. Yeah. And so, you know, we're a couple of years away from that. But it is on the Gulf of Tarentum. So if you're thinking about Italy today, that is the Gulf of Toronto, right? It's in Calabria and it's considered to be the arch if you like of the boot. Acute spot, really nice spot. And they've got a situation where they're like, Well, what is our foundation story? Who are we really where did we come from?
Dr Rad 24:22
Let's get creative. Yeah, let's
Dr G 24:24
let's explore our feelings about that. I've
Dr Rad 24:27
got an idea. A virgin gives birth to do twin boys.
Dr G 24:33
If I spent some time thinking about it, and they send somebody out to Delphi to help them with it, because it kind of Yeah, because magnet raesha they're Greek by extraction. Yes. So the three is probably not Italian people that probably have Greek background, right? And they're like, Okay, let's ask the oracle at Delphi for help with our foundation story. And they come back and they're like, It's Apollo. Everybody. Apollo is our founder. Fellas and so that's great. And everybody settles down to enjoy their newfound sense of self within that so the three i Nothing really is happening in this year, but they're feeling themselves. Okay. Okay, feeling that vibe feeling that Apollo bonus. You know, we've got a bit of a connection to music and sense of the sun. You know, no wonder
Dr Rad 25:22
it's appealing to this then yeah. Wow. Okay, what a diverse group of facts. We have such a random year. I think they're having covered two years now. Dr. G, it is time for the partial pick
Dr G 25:44
Ah, yes, Rome, Rome, Rome. Can you succeed in winning 50 Gold eagles. I feel like as a caveat on the slight information we've been able to glean from the last two years that the chances are probably pretty low.
Dr Rad 25:58
A Yeah, I'm not having good feelings. Even though we're doing two years in one episode, two
Dr G 26:03
years worth of information, two years of Rome being able to excel and assert herself in some profound way. Will they come out on top? No. All right. First category military cloud?
Dr Rad 26:18
No.
Dr G 26:21
Just a straight up. No, definitely. No. All right. So zero straight off the bat. You use nothing to show for it. Yeah. Oh, ft. Diplomacy.
Dr Rad 26:31
Okay. I feel like there is something going on here at least in 442. In terms of what's happening with our day Are
Dr G 26:41
they are trying to figure something out? I mean, I don't know if it's exactly
Dr Rad 26:45
diplomacy, but they are trying to be diplomatic. Like they're handling the situation, it would
Dr G 26:51
see if we're reading Livi straight, which I mean, we could do. It's an idea is that idea Yeah. that the Romans are actually trying to make up for what has happened in the past and give a day and something back as part of this settlement, colonising thing that they're doing right now. Yeah, I suppose you could see that as diplomatic.
Dr Rad 27:17
Exactly. So I feel like maybe I don't know for
Dr G 27:23
sure, why not? Before, I don't feel very invested in what's happening in our day. But it's because I have no source material.
Dr Rad 27:31
At least we're finally getting to an end. And in my God, even though I know I did say at the time, like this is going to be a thing that comes back. But I really can't actually believe that we're still talking about it. So many episodes.
Dr G 27:44
just keeps going and going. Alright, so that's diplomacy. The next category is expansion. Definitely no, well, okay, hang on. Well, technically, if they're if they're trying to find a way to filter some Roman citizens into that Borderlands area over do get some colonists in there under the guise and ages that they're also trying to support the Danes to get back into that area.
Dr Rad 28:08
very crafty. Move. And technically, yes, you're right. I mean, it is now a Roman colonies. So
Dr G 28:14
technically, that's a little bit of an expansion. It
Dr Rad 28:18
is actually so I guess maybe, I don't know. Maybe another four. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. Or is that too much? I mean, it's not like it's a huge error.
Dr G 28:27
Well, it's not a huge area, but it is quite strategic. So you think about it. Ostia is the port that Rome has that's attached at the end of the Tiber. Yes, but it is maybe useful to have other ports. Oh, sure. Yeah. So another day or is a port city it is on the coast. So in that sense, it maybe has a higher value.
Dr Rad 28:52
Okay. All right. So four, four, okay, for it is not too bad so far.
Dr G 28:58
We're twos.
Dr Rad 29:01
I don't feel like anybody's doing anything that extraordinary in this episode. No standouts? I don't think so. What about
Dr G 29:08
your friend, the tribune of the plebs.
Dr Rad 29:11
He's giving it everything he's got. If he hadn't said anything that year, maybe would have absolutely nothing to talk about.
Dr G 29:20
Does seem for bungled most things that he's been involved in, though. So poor man.
Dr Rad 29:24
Yeah. I mean, I you right. He's trying very hard, but
Dr G 29:30
I don't think it constitutes weird choices. You don't get to pull it off.
Dr Rad 29:33
It feels more like self interest or something like he's just trying to make a name for himself. goofed. Yeah. All
Dr G 29:39
right. So no, we're toast. No. All right, citizens score.
Dr Rad 29:42
Well, the reason why we've managed to fit two years into one episode, which is very uncharacteristic for us is because it's very peaceful, in Rome and outside of Rome, which can only really be a good thing for the citizens.
Dr G 29:57
Yeah, there's not a lot of conflict. And so we'd have to suspect that things are going all right, because we'd be we'd certainly hear about it if things were going wrong. Yes. And potel alias would have something meaningful to do with his role as tribune of the plebs. Yeah, perhaps if there was real conflict to be encountered.
Dr Rad 30:15
Yeah, like, sure put in and still have an issue with land. But that's been the case for like, decades.
Dr G 30:22
And technically, they've gained some land tax. Why recently tax so well, land rights is a discussion that's continuing to happen. Yeah, some people would have been given some land quite recently around our data.
Dr Rad 30:34
That's true. All right. So I actually think maybe we have to go for five like it's not.
Dr G 30:40
They haven't gone backwards, maybe even a six because some of them may have been included in this colony land.
Dr Rad 30:47
They did say that they weren't going to put Romans in until they ran out of reptilians, which would imply that there might be some Romans there. So yes, yeah. All right. That's six. So that means that we have a grand total of 14 Golden Boy, not great when you can see this is two years, but actually not as bad as I was thinking I was actually like, oh, my god, is this gonna be another zero?
Dr G 31:11
Not another zero? No, no, they've done quite well. I think if they get over 10. At this point, they're doing all right for themselves. It's a tough time this century.
Dr Rad 31:18
Yes, it is. All right. Well, thank you so much for joining me, Dr. G. I have to say a bit of foreshadowing here. The next couple of years are going to be far more dramatic.
Dr G 31:28
Look, I'm very excited because Dionysius of Halicarnassus kicks back in somewhere really soon. I'll have something to say. All right. Until then, farewell.
For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/
Support the show
Patreon
Ko-Fi
Read our books
Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome
Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
We were absolutely delighted to sit down recently with Professor Liv Yarrow to talk all about ancient Roman coinage from the republican period.
Special Episode – Roman Republican Coinage with Professor Liv Yarrow
Liv Yarrow is a professor at the City University of New York (CUNY). She holds a BA from the George Washington University and an MPhil and DPhil from the University of Oxford. Her scholarship spans the areas of ancient historiography and numismatics. In 2006 she published Historiography at the End of the Republic: Provincial Perspectives on Roman Rule (Oxford 2006) and in 2020 her book The Republic to 49 BCE: Using Coins as Sources came out with Cambridge University Press. She is also a co-director of the Roman Republican Die Project with the American Numismatic Society.
What's Coming up with Roman Coins!In this conversation we explore a range of topics, including:
Yarrow weaves a number of coin issues into the conversation, here's some examples that we discuss:
Denarius of Sulla. ANS 1944.100.1502. Obverse: L·MANLI [PRO]·Q – Helmeted head of Roma right. Border of dots. Reverse: L·SVLLA·IM – Triumphator, crowned by flying Victory, in quadriga right, holding reins in left hand and caduceus in right hand. Border of dots.
Silver tetradrachm of Mithradates VI, Pontus, 120 BC – 63 BCE. 1944.100.41480. Obverse: head of Mithradates VI. Reverse: stag feeding
Silver Coin, Rome, 55 BCE 1944.100.2636 ANS 1944.100.2636. RRC 428/3. Obverse: Head of Genius Populi Romani right, with sceptre over shoulder. Border of dots. Reverse: Q·CASSIVS – Eagle on thunderbolt right; on left, lituus; on right, jug . Border of dots. Just one example of a wild haired deity on Roman coinage, echoing Mithridates’ aesthetic!
Silver Coin, Rome, 97 BCE 1937.158.59. Obverse: L·POMPON·MOLO – Laureate head of Apollo right; around, inscription. Border of dots. Reverse: NVMA·POMPIL – Lighted altar; to left, Numa Pompilius holding lituus; to right, youth (victimarius) leading goat. Border of dots. Numa sacrificing with his head unveiled in the Greek fashion.
Silver Coin, Rome, 64 B.C. 1944.100.2352. Obverse: L·ROSCI – Head of Juno Sospita right; behind, control mark . Border of dots. Reverse: FABATI – Girl and snake facing each other; on left, control mark. Border of dots.
Bibliothèque nationale de France, REP-17578. RRC 379/1. Juno Sospita on reverse – note the pointy shoes!
Sound CreditsThanks to the thrilling Bettina Joy de Guzman for our theme music.
TranscriptWe're exploring automated transcripts for our episodes. This one was produced by Otter AI:
Dr Rad 0:16
Welcome to the Partial Historians,
we explore all the details of ancient Rome.
Everything from the political scandals, the love of ours, that battles waged, and when citizens turn against each other. I'm Dr. Rad
and I'm Dr. G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Welcome, everybody to a very special episode of the Partial Historians. We are fabulously excited today to be sitting down with Professor Liv Yarrow from CUNY, the City University of New York, who has classics background at Brooklyn College and classics in history at the graduate centre. She holds a BA from George Washington University and an MPhil and D. Phil from the University of Oxford. So her scholarship spans the areas of ancient historiography and numismatics. In 2006, she published historiography at the end of the Republic, provincial perspectives on Roman rule with Oxford, and in 2020, her book, The Republic 249 BCE, using coins as sources came out with the Cambridge University Press. She is also the co director of the Roman republican dye project with the American numismatic society. So this is a huge honour, we're super excited, because this means that we're going to be learning more about Roman coins and coinage and concepts to do with numismatics in the ancient Roman world. And I'm just really thrilled to have you here. Thank you so much for joining us.
Professor Yarrow 2:17
Thanks a lot. I'm really excited about this. I hope it inspires everyone to go look at some actual coins, not just listen to our fun words.
Dr Rad 2:28
I think it will for sure because I mean, as much as we will talk about specific coins, I'm sure in the process of this conversation, we'll definitely need to have that visual with us in order to like really appreciate what's going on with coinage. There's such a fascinating type of evidence,
Professor Yarrow 2:45
we'll get to curate a little gallery for everybody. It'll be fun.
Dr Rad 2:49
Exciting. All right, so let's jump in. So in your latest book, The Republic 249 BCE, using coins as sources, it's designed to help guide students and scholars on the approach to the study of coinage. To get us started what is a sort of foundational idea for people who are interested in ancient coinage if they're looking to sort of develop their expertise in this area.
Professor Yarrow 3:15
So the first thing to appreciate about ancient coinage is that it is one of the only visual mass produced media from antiquity. By which I mean that a team of men, maybe three men, working at a single workstation could produce anywhere from 10 to 40,000 coins with all with the same exact image in one day. And we think issue sizes and the Roman Republic that means coins where they might be using slightly different dyes. But the intention in the pre modern era is that they all look pretty much identical might be in the terms of millions of coins. And that's a type of dissemination of visual imagery that we just don't have with any other media In antiquity or really until we get to the printing press.
Dr Rad 4:19
Absolutely. So in the introduction to your book, you noted that different types of scholars will approach interpreting coins differently. So for example, and archaeologists will come with different questions from a socio political historian. How might this difference look in practice?
Professor Yarrow 4:36
Sure, so archaeologists love coins because they are more confident about the dating of those coins and they rely on us numismatist provide a handy dandy list of what date that coin was made at. And our catalogues are really confident about this coin was is made and this year, and we're really good at dating coins. But in the Roman Republic being really good at dating coins means with a five year plus or minus error. So one of the things that we need to be really aware of is that not every date ascribed to every coin is as rock solid as we might want. So that in archaeology using a coin to date, a layer of stratigraphy is a very common approach. Another way that associate political person might look at is can I look at the person who made this coin? And can I connect this coin to the textual narrative that I receive? An art historian might look at a coin and say, Is this image representative of a statue group? And was that statue group well known? And what did it mean in the public display? And why is there that connection between the image on the coin and a famous or semi famous public image.
Dr Rad 6:15
So this sounds like it's sort of coins have so much sort of condensed information that they might provide to somebody who's interested in the ancient past, regardless of what perspective, they're coming from it. And when we're thinking about ancient Rome, we actually understand that coinage emerges relatively late in their society. So you talk about it coming, coming out in sort of the late fourth century BCE, and this is late compared to other Mediterranean societies. So I'm really interested in what sort of factors might have influenced Rome, one to adopt coinage, but also why they might have been so late to adopt coinage comparatively speaking.
Professor Yarrow 6:55
So as in so many ways, the ancient Romans were at a crossroads and a cultural crossroads, and a very literal crossroads. In terms of the peninsular Italy. They connected the cultures of the coastal areas, the sea, travelling communities and the interior. There, the Tiber was a very important point of connection. And then also, to cross the Tiber, the situation of the city of Rome, we always need to remember is where it was easiest to get across this major river. So the river is at once a conduit for travel, but also a barrier that needs to be overcome. And so the Romans are this cross cultural community from very early on. And this is especially true in terms of money. So to back up a little bit. Money is the first human invention, you might think that without coins, or some other tangible form of money, that everything is about barter. But in fact, the first invention is the intellectual exercise of realising that if you have a shared unit of exchange, or store of value, or measure of a measure of value store of wealth, that you can make transactions between individuals easier because you have a shared system of understanding, wealth and value and exchange. And that doesn't depend on a physical object or a piece of money, even if it's expressed that way. So shackles exist before we have a physical thing that we call a shackle. And so, Roman Italy, and Italy and wider. Indigenous Italy was fully monetized before the coming of coinage and their monetary system is based on measures of value tied to the Roman pound, and particularly to bronze and to not just the Roman pound the Roman pound in Rome, but the pound in any other community with their own systems of weights and measures. And there's some really exciting work being done on this idea of how different systems of information and information knowledge like standardisation of weights and measures reflect social change. And so I just nod towards like the work of Andrew Rigsby on this sort of thing that's very influential to destabilise what we think we know that the pound isn't so fixed as we might want it to be in a modern world when we go back into antiquity these things are a little bit more flexible and changeable both in terms of space and time. But coming back to my thread of money and the switch from money to coinage, the money and the physical money of Peninsular Italy among indigenous communities was primarily what we now call a scholars eyes rude, which just means crude bronze or eyes for mahtim. And that's again a made up Latin phrase just meeting, bronze that has been moulded into a shape. But the shape isn't standardised. So the Romans were already participating in an indigenous is monetary system. But they were highly aware of their Greek neighbours who were colonists primarily in the south and primarily on the coast. And travelling and meeting other Greeks through those coastal communities, that they had a monetary tradition that derives from this, the tradition of coinage that started in the kingdom of Lydia, and that's in southern modern day Turkey. And that started about the seventh century BC and that's the monetary tradition that we still participate of coinage today. Just for full perspective, we have to remember that coinage was also invented by the Chinese in about the same century. And when these two traditions of coinage meet on the central steps, they recognise each other. And we have Chinese texts from the Han Dynasty, talking about how funny the coins are from the Mediterranean, because they have faces on them, and they use these precious metals. And that's so weird, because that's not what our money the Chinese money looks like. But they're parallel inventions to solve a common problem. Coins are just a really easy way to solve the tangibility of money and to turn the invention of money into something that's easily and readily used by everyone in the community. So that Romans at this crossroads, are participating into monetary systems. And they're participating at first simultaneously. So the first coin that has the name Rome on it is made in ancient Minneapolis, what we call Naples, and we date that to 326 BCE. And we date it to the moment at which Rome enters into a treaty with Naples, after Naples has sided with their other enemies of the moment in southern Italy. But Naples is also one of these cross cultural communities of central but coastal Italy. And it's not surprising, because Naples is already making coins for many of its neighbours. It's a service that provides that one of the things they might offer to the Romans at this first moment moment of coming into a legal established relationship is to make them some coins. And those first coins look just like bronzes of Naples, they have the head of Apollo, they have the man faced bull. And we are pretty confident that we can link the coin that says, of the Romans and Greek to the moment of the treaty, because we have a pretty decent seriation of the Naples series. And we can sort of slot in stylistically that that it confirms the logic based on the texts that these coins share all of these habits. And so, in that first instance, the Romans are conceding and not in a particularly financially useful way that earliest Roman struck coins are made by Greek communities for the Romans in the name of the Romans, but they're not made in such large quantities that they would have been of particular use. The Romans themselves at Rome, itself really seem to dive into the making of physical money in the run up to the First Punic War. And that's where we get a kind of coin that has a another made up Latin phrase name, which is ice scrub, which just means heavy bronze, the heavy bronze. And, and a scholar named Burnett has this hypothesis that I think is very convincing that what I scrub represents is a combination of the sensibilities of the southern Italian Greek tradition of using coins, that a coin should have a face on one side and a design on the other, and it should be round. And it should have a fixed weight with a fixed denomination. So all of these features that are common within the Greek monetary tradition, coinage tradition, and the traditions of Central Italy, that money should be substantial and should be a bronze. And that it should have this weight. And so it seems that in this first, their first making of this mixed cultural tradition of money, they're trying to keep what's culturally important about both traditions.
Dr Rad 16:26
As they look, I think that's so fascinating, because one of the things that I often talk about with my students, both ancient and modern history is how money is essentially a human invention. And that's particularly funny in Australia, because I don't know if you're aware, but our money essentially looks like Monopoly money when we're talking about our notes. So I'm like, You do realise that this is just plastic. And the only reason why it has a value is because we say it has.
Professor Yarrow 16:53
You know, but in some ways, it's getting easier to teach that particularly with touchless payments, and the popularity of touchless payments, even growing in the backwards Land of the United States, in the course of the pandemic, to reduce our physical money, or our swiping of cards or the use of tap, because it helps us all understand the degree to which we say $1 or a pound, or any other monetary unit, but we're really just measuring some abstract concept of value. And it can be nice to have something physical to, to hold, we all like getting, you know, a couple bills in our in our birthday card, maybe from grandma, if we still get that, but we're quickly going to add that to our very untenable pot of credit with a with a bank.
Dr Rad 17:57
Absolutely. So you talked about the design of those early coins and how it evolved and that sort of thing. So if we're thinking about the artistry involved in coins, there's quite a wide range when we're looking at the examples that you have studied. What are some that you think are particularly striking from the Republican period that the Romans made and what makes them particularly noteworthy for you?
Professor Yarrow 18:20
This is so hard, because my research partner is Lucida Carboni. And she's the curator of Roman coins at the ANS with me on the Roman republican diet project. And we co teach a lot because we have a lot of student interns and volunteers. And whenever I talk about beautiful Roman coins, she's like, No, no, you go quiet, and this come from Sicily, and they're Greek. And then she goes into the vault and brings out something stunningly beautiful. You have to remember her family's from Sicily. So even though we're working on this die project, she has some concerns. But there is a little bit of truth to that, in that within the Greek tradition of bigger money. So that Tetra DRAM upwards, we're looking at something that's really substantial in your hand, and we're looking at a tradition of Engraving and striking that is concerned with aesthetics. So there they have high relief, meaning that a lot of force has been used to drive that impression on to the blank flan of metal and they attempt to centre it and they take all of this extra care in the production, the Roman mins once we're into its period of production of the denarius, so that's anytime past 211 b. See with introduction is inclined to work less rapidly and in shallow relief. And they don't seem to care about errors that we just don't see on other coin edges. So it might be struck a little bit off flan. Sometimes one coin gets stuck in the die, and they just keep striking. And then we get these double headed coins that we call blockages. And it seems that other mints that had a greater aesthetic control, that these sorts of mint errors would be thrown out so I can answer your question about beautiful coins. But first, we have to accept that it wasn't beauty. That was the number one requirement for the Romans of running a practice their denarii. So what is a what is a truly beautiful coin? I'll talk to a little bit about a beat what I think is as a beautiful and interesting trend. And it seems to be directly influenced by the war with Mithra days. Okay, so Mithridates is this eastern king. He's in relation with the Romans from the one hundreds, but he only really starts to become problematic in about the year 90, and so it's 88 that they send Salah out to try and put him in their place. But he's a very recalcitrant King, he's not easy for the Romans to control. So he then dominates the narrative of the first half of the first century BCE. Mr. Davies presented himself as the successor to both the Persian Dynasty and the Macedonian dynasty. And so he wanted to be seen as a particularly charismatic saviour figure. And his coins are exquisitely beautiful. And one of the ways in which they're exquisitely beautiful, is the rendering of his hair. His hair is not just this curly, Hellenistic locks of Alexander, but it's really flowing and dynamic and full of energy with these curly Q's that are escaping that Daya dam and this rugged yet youthful face that sort of looks up to heaven as if you want to follow him on campaign. As the great descendant of these two royal houses, this coinage seems to have made a really big impression on the Romans. And it's not surprising, they brought a lot of money home from those wars, and some of that they probably brought home, not just as raw bullion, but in actual struck method, attic coinage. And some of that's going to have ended up in the treasury. And now we're in the realm of fantasy, but we can imagine those mythopoetic coins being taken to be melted down to make new flans. To start up, strike, Roman Denari. And so you have meant workers handling these beautiful coins. And all of a sudden, the Roman coins start using this same crazy hair. And they don't use it to represent Mr. Davies, but they use it for sun gods and Quirinus. And all sorts of divinities of the late Republic start looking a little bit like Mithridates days with this extremely charismatic hairstyle and sensitive facial feature rendering on their arm versus So yeah, if I had to pick a aesthetic characteristic that I admire about the Romans, I'd go with them.
Dr Rad 24:23
That sounds sad because it kind of sounds like me in the morning. So I think this leads really nicely actually into my next question for you, which is thinking about the iconography on coinage, we've got this really sort of compressed moment, not just sort of pressed but also compressed imagery in which to demonstrate something and part of that is leaning into fashion a little bit and I think the hair also takes us in that direction already, but are there too changes or ways in which clothing and adornment is represented on coinage that might be worth looking out for. If we're thinking about the Republic,
Professor Yarrow 25:11
I wish I could say yes, but the clothing is deeply conservative and symbolic. And so if you get a citizen male being represented on a Roman coin, he's really only going to be represented in one or two ways. If he's being represented as his status as a citizen, he's going to be in a toga. And if he is being represented as a warrior, than usually he's going to be wearing the standard garb of a member of the cavalry of the Roman cavalry. So the question then is, what does it mean when they're not dressed like that. And those exceptions are really interesting. So there's a coin that shows the king NUMA sacrifice sacrificing a goat are about to sacrifice a goat. And normally we would imagine a Roman about to offer sacrifice would have his toga over his head, because that's how Roman citizen men pray and offer sacrifice. And it's an interesting moment, because that's not what NUMA looks like, in that picture. So and he's clearly labelled with his name. So we know he's the Roman king, and we're having a Roman sacrifice. My hypothesis is that it's because Apollo is the God on the omniverse. And the goat being sacrificed is being sacrificed to Apollo. And at Rome, the cult of Apollo follows the Greek, right. And the uncovered bear head is part of a legitimate ation of this particular type of Roman ritual being celebrated in a slightly alien or foreign manner.
Dr Rad 27:20
Wow, oh, that is very cool. I mean, because this is also tying into this idea that as we get into the further into the Republic, they're not just interested in representing themselves necessarily, they're interested in representing their whole history, as well. They're like, we've got some coins now. But our history predates coinage, who would we like to represent? Let's get a newcomer in there. He's having he's having a great time. Presumably,
Professor Yarrow 27:49
Numa has a remarkable number of coins more than any other king
Dr Rad 27:54
How bizarre.
Professor Yarrow 27:55
He's doing well for himself, considering you didn't miss any of them.
Exactly, exactly.
Dr Rad 28:02
So thinking about fashion, I suppose we can also think about something else that often appears on Roman coinage, and that is buildings. So what can we learn about the buildings of Rome from their depiction on coins? And maybe, what are some of the limitations of using coins to speak back to Rome's typography?
Professor Yarrow 28:22
Okay, so there are people who know way more than me on this. And so I hope that someday down. So I hope at one point, you invite my colleague, Nate Elkins on to have a proper conversation about this. And he will tell you many, many more fun stories. But to get us started, I want to say that architecture on coin is maybe not uniquely a Roman phenomena, but it's very difficult to find substantive precedent. And it really becomes a much more typical Roman motif than we would have ever seen on Greek or Persian coinage or any other of the pre existing monetary traditions within the Mediterranean realm. Why? I would argue that it's because what goes on a coin is celebrating the success of the Roman state. And the Roman self conception is a conception of themselves, as in harmony with the gods. And so Romans preserve the packs day or on the peace of the gods, by fulfilling their obligations to the gods, and in turn, the gods provide them with success and war. And so every success in war becomes proof of Divine Favour and every past action to honour the gods is part of what has brought about the success of the Roman state and ensured its perpetual endurance into the future. And for the Romans, certain acts such as the erection of temples or monuments, or the holding of festivals are an essential part of how they show their honour to the gods, and particularly given the fact that many temples are vowed by generals in a moment of crisis. And then once the crisis is alleviated through the fake favour of the gods, and then the building is approved by the community as a whole, and then funded and dedicated, it becomes evidence, the temple itself, or whatever physical monument, it is, is proof that the gods answered the vow of the ancestor, that the ancestor fulfilled the vow so upheld their commitment to the Divine, and that that interaction between the person who made the original vow and the gods was sanctioned and honoured by the community. And so to put any religious monument and almost all monuments are religious in the Roman world view on a coin is celebrating numerous acts of piety and serve as justification for the, for the Roman state and the role of the individual money or is family with in that success.
Dr Rad 31:55
Oh, that's very cool. I like that we're like we're, we're bringing in the people who are doing the coin creation as well, like this is another act, another pious act representing that building, that has been a substantial part of that history. For so long build upon that relationship with the gods over time, you think about the need for the construction of those things, and how long that takes, and all of those particular elements. And now it's represented on this coin as well. So it's sending out that message even further, and sort of distributing it.
Professor Yarrow 32:26
There are monuments that exist on coins long before they're actually built, because it takes a long time to build a monument and the most famous of these are the future Augustus young Caesar, you might know him as Octarians temple to the deified Julius, and it appears he might also be doing the same thing with the Temple of Mars altar. Some people think the circular temple of Mars altar that appears on the coinage is a second one. But I think it's likely that he learned his lesson that you can make a temple real, even before it manifests on the ground by putting it on the coins.
Dr Rad 33:11
Typical Augustus, such a show pony
Ahead of you
Let's face it, maybe maybe it was just his way of announcing, like, you know, this is the building plan. Objection. Now if you don't like the design.
Professor Yarrow 33:25
Exactly.
Dr G 33:26
Amazing. So thinking about the way that politics is getting particularly complicated in the late Republican period, it's becoming not that it wasn't always the case, but prominent families and prominent individuals within families are really stepping forward, particularly when we get into that last century of the Republic. And this prominence of individuals, is this being reflected in coinage in any particular way? And can we trace the changes in Rome's politics through the coinage and the way it's represented?
Professor Yarrow 34:01
Absolutely, and it's a really thorny and debated issue. So one of the simplest ways of reading the prominence of individuals on the coins and the greatest diversity that we see on the coins is that there's heightened competition, and that these changes in design are specifically about electioneering. To react to this, and people often in that form of argumentation point to the fact that the coins start to become far more diverse at the same moment that the secret ballot is put into place. I would push back for this. Yes, any individual who wishes to seek higher office wants to prove their worthiness to be further elected on beyond the money or ship by doing a good job as a money or. But I don't think that Romans would necessarily have conceptualised what they were doing as directly competitive, that what they're attempting to do on the coin designs is articulate, much like we just said, it might answer the previous question, the way in which their individual families have participated in the success of Rome, and that there is no distinction between the individual and the state, if the individual is acting on behalf of the state, particularly in terms of exercising we are to Sir military ism, or in terms of honouring the gods, and because it is the ultimate act of piety, to not only honour the gods, but honour your ancestors, you're fulfilling both responsibilities of an acting, how a good Roman should act, the kind of Roman that should be elected further on as exemplary of what's good in the community, by performing these acts of piety that celebrate both your ancestors and your ancestors, service to the state specifically. So I'd say all of it is patriotic, it am, but it is also performative of a familial connection to the actions that have ensured Rome's status.
Dr Rad 36:54
So it sounds like they're kind of mobile propaganda, then are there any particularly notable examples that are like promoting someone's career or promoting the family? Or trying to remind people hey, we did this?
Professor Yarrow 37:07
Sure. I'm just gonna say I'm allergic to the word propaganda.
Dr Rad 37:12
Yeah, no, I knew I was being a bit…
Professor Yarrow 37:14
No, no. And I will concede that many of my colleagues will freely use the term propaganda. And I've even concede that maybe I'm a little too rigid about it. But propaganda in the 20th and 21st century, nods specifically to a moment in which mass media was harnessed in very distinctive ways to promote very specific ideologies and often ideologies that were Factional or competing against other ideologies. And quite often, when our students hear the word propaganda, they associate it with things like brainwashing or lies or distortions of the truth. And I'm not sure for all coins are certainly a form of political speech, that they fit many of the connotations of propaganda, that at least our students or our contemporaries, in casual non academic settings might associate with it. But what is a what is a moment of political speech on Roman coins that sends a clear contemporary message. One of my favourites is the coins of Salah as he marches on Rome. So our moment in time is that he has had his first march in Rome and 88. He's gone out to beat up Mithridates but in the interim, Sinha has taken control of the city and set up a completely separate political regime. So we have an effect to Roman governments in the 80s and the Sinan regime in Rome is sending out competing generals to fight Mithridates as well. So we have multiple marauding generals in the East. And so it becomes very clear that he cannot succeed in this war without securing the homefront. And so he comes to an arrangement with Mithridates he's at the Dardanelles, that's the mouth of the Hellespont just north of where it Troy is to get your geography so this key crossroads…
Dr Rad 39:56
Gallipoli for Australian listeners
Professor Yarrow 40:00
At Gallipoli. Absolutely. It's this key crossroad between Asia and Europe. And they meet and they come to an agreement. We have multiple accounts of this agreement. And later writers in the remenham. pyre like Appian really want to show this as solid extracting concessions from the beaten Mithra days. But if we look at more contemporary accounts, my favourite is a local Black Sea historian named Memnon of her clan. That agreement looks very much like a mutual treaty to ensure the success of both in their ongoing political ventures, namely that Mr. Davies provides a good deal of monetary support to underwrite sellers March on Rome. So what does he do with this wealth? A lot of it gets taken to Athens Athens becomes his base of operations, and he harnesses the Athenian mint to create a coinage in his name. One of those coins, pictures him as a triumph font or so someone who is going to celebrate or has celebrated a triumph, but he hasn't yet. How do we tell a tree on fire tour from any other dude writing in a cart before horse drawn chariot. We tell the difference on Roman coins by talking about the fast and the slow horses so do the horse horses of the gods tend to be charging into the sky and so we call that a fast quadriga. A slow quadriga is one that is on parade with the horses are high stepping and very sedate. The other difference, of course, is the dude in the car is wearing a toga, so we know that they're a Roman. But instead of holding a palm branch or even a sceptre, or some other triumphal regard, Alia. He holds a caduceus. This is the Herald staff. And we have victory flying into the scene to crown him. So we have this melding of the divine world and the mortal world. But the caduceus really speaks to me because, yes, it's about the messenger. And so the person who brings the news the Herald and usually, that news is good news. So the caduceus is a symbol of packs peace, a felicitas divine blessing, sometimes even shading into Concordia, the right ordering of society. And this coin, because it's minted before he ever triumphs says very clearly, I'm coming to triumph. And I am going to get into that chariot. And I am going to celebrate in this way when I get there. But it's anticipatory, rather than celebratory. So other coinage that has triumphal imagery. And so we have a coin that we think refers to the triumph of Marius over the Cimbri and the Teutones is and it seems to show Marius riding in his triumphal car with his son on the trace horse. That's celebratory of a religious festival that's already taken place. Whereas solace coin says very clearly, I have expectations and you will fulfil them.
Dr Rad 44:13
Love it. So this is a perfect way to ask about this moment of political speech, would Sulla have been the one coming up with the design ideas, you know, going in to see you know, a mentor and being like, Okay, so here's my concept, guys, I want to look at this way. And I want these types of horses because I'm really trying to send a message here. How exactly would these different coin designs come about?
Professor Yarrow 44:37
We don't know. That's the short answer, but I can speculate, I would say that there is an underappreciated connection between seal rings and numismatic designs. So there is a preexisting vocabulary of individuals in both the Greek and Hellenistic world By associating their personal identity with a small image often engraved on a small circular design about the size of a coin, and that that badge of identity is going to be used both on letters but also on business contracts. And so that it is a way in which you prove something as yours and you say that it is authentic. And we have a number of instances where we can connect very specific coin designs to literary testimony about the seal rings of different individuals. And so we have other coins of Salah that have his trophies and we're told that on occasion, he used his battlefield trophies as his signet ring. And so we can connect that with that design, or we have other testimony that he carved into a signet ring, the moment in which Bacchus surrenders Jugurtha to him when he was a questor his first great political success, and his son puts that design on one of his coin celebrating his father. Same with Pompey, we were told Pompey imitates sell his seal ring by having three trophies as opposed to two trophies. And again, we have coins that celebrate Pompey successes, using the three trophies and onwards to Salah. So that's with literary evidence. I have a really fun article on glass pastes, which are fake gems. Plenty is very rude about poor people who use these deceptive glass intaglios. And how dare they think they're worthy of signing contracts and participating in business if they can't afford a real gem. But plenty aside, we have ample evidence for the fact that many Romans of middle middling financial ability, wanted to have a seal ring, to mark their letters to sign their business contracts to engage in everyday life and associate those images with their own identity as markers of self. And there is an incredibly strong connection between the designs we find on Roman republican, glass intaglios. And coin designs where you can say, Oh, look, that one looks like this one, that one looks like this one, tick, tick, have a nice little chart in the back of the article. What I like about this is it suggests a number of things, it suggests that people were looking at the coins, that they found the coin iconography compelling enough that they wanted to adopt it as markers of their own identity. And then it's likely that even in places where we don't have literary testimony, the designs we're seeing on the coin may very well echoed designs of steel rings used by the money or the money or family because it is the most obvious small visual design that's pre existing to mark themselves and how they conceive of themselves. So there's a pre existing visual language out there that we can only recover a small bit of.
Dr Rad 48:41
And I think that makes sense, in many respects, because the artistry involved in producing those seals would also be a similar technology. I would know
Professor Yarrow 48:52
100% Probably even the same sort of people. You know that. If you become a money or and you have a particular engraver you like he doesn't tell us, maybe you bring them along with you the mitt?
Dr Rad 49:03
Yeah, it'd be like, This guy does great work.
Professor Yarrow 49:09
Exactly, exactly.
Dr Rad 49:12
And I think this ties in really nicely to our final question, which sort of touches on a couple of things that have come up so far as well. So you've got this great sentence, which I think is fantastic for students coming into this sort of thing. Coins were the only mass produced visual medium in antiquity. And you talked already about how we're talking millions sometimes have a particular designs coming through. What are some of the consequences for this in terms of the Roman Republic? Are there some examples where we have so many copies of a particular design that we're like, what's going on? And is this a standout message or do we just not have enough coins to know?
Professor Yarrow 49:56
Oh, that's a great question. So I've been talking a lot in these lectures I've been giving for the AIA That's the American Institute of Archaeology, about the coins of moneyers, who have a family connection to a Latin town called Lanuvium. Lanuvium is famous for having the sanctuary of Juno Sospita, and Juno Sospita it is a very fun goddess. And she is not like many Goddesses that you may think of. She is a warrior goddess, she's got a nice big shield and spear. But she also wears really fancy shoes, they curl up like elf. And not only that, she also wears a goat skin headdress much like Hercules where's the lion one, so she always gets horns and big ears. And she's often striding into battle. And her cult was also pretty wild. One of my favourite things about the junior sauce, but a cult is that in spring, they would gather up all of the virgins from the local community, and send them down into a dark, dank cave, entrance through the religious sanctuary to feed the evil snake. Now the snake would take food out of the virgins hand only if they were really truly virgins, otherwise it would gobble them up, and they would never make it back to the surface. So once the girls go down into the cave to feed the snake, the parents all wait around anxiously to see if their daughters return. And if their daughters return, there's a big party, because not only are their girls good and pure, but everything's going to grow again. And you know, it's the proof that the earth is fertile. And it's this cult of the renewal of life. So it's a pretty wild cold, and the Romans were really excited about it. And so when they conquer Lavinium in 340, they make a Treaty of Mutual alliances, and they incorporate the local community into the Roman citizenship as long as those people agree that the Romans can have a share in the control of this cult, because the cult is extremely popular and extremely politically significant with in lation itself. How does this relate to the coins? Well, we can all have this cool imagery on the coins itself. And so when people from this community are elected money are in Rome, it's this cult that they want to celebrate. So we even get a picture of a girl feeding the snake, as well as Juno Sospita herself doing all sorts of wild things. However, we also have evidence that when the local cult was throwing parties, they had to make by parties, I mean, religious festivals, they made tokens and tokens are like, well, they're their tokens, they're here have a token, this makes sure that everybody gets the same amount of bread or wine or, you know, entrance to the games or the play or whatever. It's a way of controlling access and keeping track of benefactions and access to benefactions party. So these are the parties down here. Here's my token. So tokens are not coins, but they look like coins. And so they tend to be made more crudely. They're often made out of lead because it's softer and easier to work with. But they're deeply associated with religious festivals and local communities. So the party tokens from this cult look like the Roman coins made up to 100 years earlier. Because they have this local pride our dude became the money or in Rome. What did he choose? He chose these images, we need to put something on our religious tokens for this next festival. Let's copy that design. Yeah, so that's one of my favourites sort of somebody's paying attention to the coins and they're paying attention over a long period of time, and it really matters within local communities, even outside of the city of Rome itself.
Dr Rad 54:37
I love that story. I think the next time I'm going to have a party I'm going to send out tokens instead of invitations. Perfect.
Well, this has been a wild ride. I've really enjoyed this conversation. Thank you so much for your time leave. It's been really really amazing. And yeah, Juno sauce Better water water lady
Professor Yarrow 55:01
Maybe it's the shoes I really want. I mean, I take the coat, but I really want those curly shoes.
Dr G 55:08
Fair enough. I'm with you. We'll go back in time we'll find some curly shoes. Amazing. Absolutely.
Thank you for tuning in to this special episode of the Partial Historians. I'm Dr. G. And on behalf of Dr. Rad myself, we would like to send a huge thank you to our Patreon supporters whose support enhances what we have the ability to do with this podcast. Our Patreon supporters receive early access to all of our special episodes, and we are starting to build up some exclusive content over there as well. So if you like what you hear, we would love to have you join our Patreon community. You can also find us on all social media outlets, or at least the old ones, Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. Catch you around.
For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/
Support the show
Patreon
Ko-Fi
Read our books
Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome
Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Do you get excited by a trip to the office supply store? Is The Home Edit your favourite show on Netflix? Then this is the episode for you! The Romans are in an organisation frenzy. Grab your red tape, post-its, a sword, and we’re off to 443 BCE. Expect some bureaucracy and civil war in Ardea.
Episode 125 – Big Trouble in Little Ardea
Struggle of the Orders? Or Struggle to find some Order?Last episode, there was a major shift with the introduction of military tribunes with consular authority. Our major narrative sources, Livy and Dionysius, would have us believe that this was all part of the so called ‘Struggle of the Orders’, a way for plebeians to have access to consular power with tarnishing the office of consul with their gross cooties. However, it seems that Rome might have been restructuring the state to better address their needs. They were living in a 440s world and needed a state structure to match.
The Censor is BornIn 443 BCE, the focus was on the census. The census had first been carried out by King Servius Tullius. Since then, a few have been carried out during the early republic. But 443 BCE was a turning point. Everyone could see the need for a census. Gotta have that data! The consuls were not keen to take on this additional task. Acquiring enormous amounts of personal details takes time and effort. Just ask Google! It was also not exactly illustrious work. The consuls would much rather be charging off into battle or parading around the Forum in a fancy toga than crunching numbers.
As a result, it was proposed that a new magistracy should be established. The censor and his band of assistants were officially in charge of regulating the census. Hopefully, there would not be any more large gaps in between censuses.
A map the region with Ardea and Rome highlighted.
Source: Omnis Rereum Romanitatum
Ardea has been a theme over the last few episodes. Ever since the Roman people decided to seize some of their territory, Ardea has been a sore point. The Romans don’t usually feel this much guilt! They are very keen to help out when a civil war starts raging in the city.
The domestic tension in Ardea began with a smoking hot plebeian girl. Isn’t it always the way? This nameless woman attracted the attention of a plebeian and patrician man. Her family disagreed about which man she should marry. The escalated quickly beyond a family dispute into total civil war in Ardea. Yep, that tracks. It's Big Trouble in Little Ardea.
Will the Romans be able to prevent Ardea from total destruction? Tune in to find out!
Our PlayersConsulsThanks to BBC Sounds (Beta), Pixabay, Fesliyan Studios, and Orange Free Sounds for sound effects and the thrilling Bettina Joy de Guzman for our theme music.
NoteWhen Dr G mentions the patricians getting close to having imperium at approximately the 37 minute mark, she meant to say plebeians.
Love our work? You can support us on PatreonSacrifice scene during a census from the Altar of Domitius Ahenobarbus known as the “Census frieze”. This piece dates to the late 2nd century BCE. Image courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.
Automatically Generated TranscriptAutomatically Generated Transcript courtesy of Otter AI. We are exploring options with transcripts but hopefully the software has managed to understand the Latin and our Australian accents.
Dr Rad 0:16
Welcome to The Partial Historians,
Dr G 0:20
we explore all the details of ancient Rome.
Dr Rad 0:23
Everything from the political scandals, the love of ours, the battles waged, and when citizens turn against each other. I'm Dr. Rad.
Dr G 0:34
And I'm Dr. G. We consider Rome as the Roman saw it by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 0:43
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr G 1:10
Hello, and welcome to a brand new episode of the Partial Historians. I am Dr. G.
Dr Rad 1:18
And I am Dr. Rad Welcome.
Dr G 1:21
Welcome, welcome. Welcome to this episode where we are on the tail end of 444 BCE. And in this episode, we're going to start by looking at 443 BC.
Dr Rad 1:36
That's right as we trace the journey for him from the founding of the city, we're in some very interesting times a real turning point one might say Dr. G,
Dr G 1:47
is a real turning point. We've just had this idea come to the surface of replacing the consulship, in some instances with military tribunes with controller power. And as this flow and effects of this decision start to play out, we're going to see some interesting things come up in the history. Whether that happens this year in particular, we will find out together
Dr Rad 2:14
indeed, let's do a very quick recap of what happened in 444, Dr. G. So there's a lot of tension, as you said about whether they're going to have military Tribune's or whether they're going to have consuls. But the last time we were talking, they chose military Tribune's, but then they got kicked out of office. But not because they were doing a terrible job just because there were some problems with the way they were elected.
Dr G 2:40
Apparently, apparently, the auspices were taken incorrectly and something to do with the house.
Dr Rad 2:45
Indeed. So we ended up getting consuls, after all, so much for all of that.
Dr G 2:52
Oh consuls, we're back with the old stock and Fada. All right,
Dr Rad 2:56
Indeed, indeed. But there's also been some ongoing issues with a day out because of a terrible decision that the Romans made a few years ago now. But it just keeps coming back to haunt them where the Romans basically took land that didn't really belong to them when they were meant to be arbitrating a dispute. And the Danz haven't been very happy ever since
Dr G 3:17
they have not. And this has led to an ongoing consequence, where the day ends in 444 Send some ambassadors to Rome to talk this over. So while we've been expecting a lot of warfare to be on the scene, the idea being that military Tribune's with consular power constitute a bigger body of people holding that Imperium to lead armies and do this sort of stuff. What we're seeing instead is a lot of diplomacy and conversations happening. So there does seem to be a little bit of a disjuncture between this idea and concept of military tribunals with consular power as a necessity for facing of great numbers of enemies coming from all directions. And what seems to be the political reality of some maybe some boring conversations that the Romans have to have with all of their neighbours about exactly how they're going to pull their finger out and stop being assholes.
Dr Rad 4:14
So with that being said, let's jump right into full 43 B C. All right, Dr. J. So who are your consuls for this year?
Dr G 4:27
I have the consuls Marcus could gone yes mess arenas consul for the second time did and Titus Quint tears capital liners consul for the fifth time?
Dr Rad 4:40
Yeah. Now these two are quite a contrast because gayness was consul in 447, which was that really mysterious year just after all the drama of the second December it the second secession of the plebs, all of that stuff that had happened? We had that really bizarre year where we had almost no information And he was cancelled during that year where they were, I think just trying to prevent civil war from erupting in Rome, basically. And that's when the young patrician started to get out of hand. So he was cancelled on that year. Capital lioness, on the other hand, oh, he's had some big concealer years in his path. And it's
Dr G 5:15
also an open question about whether this might be two people as well, because the year spread for these consul chips is quite wide. So first consulship 471. Yeah, second, 468. And five. That was the big one. Yeah. 446. And we're now in this situation where we're it's also 443.
Dr Rad 5:40
Yeah, absolutely. So there's been some that have been quite recent, but then it's been going back a while. You getting on? He's getting on,
Dr G 5:47
he must be pretty old by
Dr Rad 5:48
this point. Yeah. But experience, which is what the Romans like,
Dr G 5:51
a man with experience, they say
Dr Rad 5:55
indeed. All right. So what is going to happen in this year?
Dr G 5:59
Well, that's a great question, because I've basically got a paragraph and then dynasties of Harlequin SS cuts off forever. For a while. It may be the end of book 11. But when book 12 comes into play, we're missing some information.
Dr Rad 6:16
Wow, this is a historic episode then. Because for the past, what, eight or nine years, as we've been tracing the journey of Rome for the founding of the city, I have been reading Levy and you have been reading Dionysius, and he finally broke it off. But it's actually amazing. We managed to keep going. So
Dr G 6:36
it is a problem. He's had a little bit of gap before now once or twice, just briefly, but this is going to be a chunk of a few years. Right. But I'll give you what's in the paragraph that I've got. So it seems that there have been some issues with the Senate neglecting certain aspects of the way that Rome operates. So because there's been so many military expeditions, and I'm sure our ongoing listeners will be aware that we've been dealing with a lot of sort of military backwards and forwards Rome, having issues with her neighbours, yes. And solving them by picking up some pointy sticks and running at them really quickly. Yes. And this means that other things on the homefront have been neglected, one of the most essential of which is the census.
Dr Rad 7:26
Ah, yes, this census Gudo red tape, get out the administrative gears.
Dr G 7:33
If Romans love anything, it becomes apparent as time goes on that they love bureaucratic process. Yeah, they like keeping tabs on everybody. And they like records. And this feeds into how we understand the modern world in many respects, because these guys are all over bureaucracy. So they get people together, they count them in various ways, and then they categorise them based on the stuff they own. Harsh. Yeah. It's not they don't care about who you are as a person. It's not about personalities are about kindness. So what about your contribution to the community? It's about how much stuff you've got
Dr Rad 8:09
is interesting, isn't it? When you think about it, because I guess we're so used to thinking in those sorts of terms. But we do live in a capitalist society. It's kind of interesting to have this kind of measure. I said,
Dr G 8:20
this is a proto capitalistic society. Yeah, feel it with these kinds of ideas. This sense in which people's worth is measured by the stuff that they possess. Yeah, is idiosyncratic. And there is no way if we're thinking about like history, and we're thinking about the different peoples and societies that have existed, there is no reason why this should be the way things are measured. And the fact that it's the way the Romans measure it. And we can see ourselves in the depths of a pretty interesting version of capitalism right now. Those things are connected.
Dr Rad 8:54
Absolutely. The interesting twist to the census, the way that Romans do it, is that there is this moral dimension, which becomes introduced as well, eventually, where it's not just about as you say what you own, although that is obviously important. But it is also about how you're conducting yourself as to whether you're going to be classed, you know, a certain way. That's something that develops as time goes on. But also, I feel like the reason why they want to know how much stuff you have is because they do expect people who have a lot to give back in certain ways as well, whether that's military service, or whatever. Do they though I think they do in the sense of they want to know what people own to they can figure out who's going to serve what capacity in a military sense.
Dr G 9:40
Yes, yeah. Although to be honest, the more stuff that you've got, the more likely you are to be classified as patrician, which means you basically get to be an officer. Rather than a foot soldier.
Dr Rad 9:54
That's really heavy. We're gonna say gentleman
Dr G 9:57
you get to be making decisions not necessarily risking your own life, although you do get kudos for risking Europe
Dr Rad 10:05
totally smacks of say, you know, British Army First World War, you know, if you're higher class, you're more likely to be you're gonna be an officer. Whereas if you're low class, you're going to be you know, in the frontlines, and that sort of entirely smacks of that I hate it. I hate everything about it. But it is a little different to the way that we would understand the census these days.
Dr G 10:25
Certainly. And it turns out that there hasn't been census for quite some time. And this is a problem. And the the new consuls bring this to our attention. And it is notable that in 443, that we do have consuls again. We've just yeah, we've just created the Romans have just created not we, the Romans just created this new role, military tributes with controller power. Yeah. And we've literally only had three of them in place for 73 days, according to datasets of Harlequin SS. And we're up to what is perhaps the second year of it being possible to have this position
Dr Rad 11:02
filled. It's not the most inspiring start have ever seen.
Dr G 11:06
Is this the new wave of change we've been seeing in Rome, no.
Dr Rad 11:11
Social change was always very smooth.
Dr G 11:15
They had the idea, but they haven't really run with the concept. Yeah,
Dr Rad 11:18
this is interesting. And this is often seen as being one of those turning point years. So we talked in quite some depth when we were talking about the military tribute idea, and that whole plebs vying for the consulship wanting to overturn the marriage laws that supposedly forbade into marriage between patrician and plebeian. We did discuss how this could be a bit of an organisational turning point for the Roman state could be where they looked around and said, You know, when things have changed, things have changed in the last 50 or so years, we need to update the system. And that might be at the heart of what's really going on here. I feel like this censorship position is also a part of that. The rejigging of the Roman state, because when we talked about the census previously, I actually think it's been mostly associated with the Regal period, we've had one or two, we've definitely mentioned a few since then, like we've had some citizen counts and that sort of stuff. But the big moment for the census was when it was introduced by the kings.
Dr G 12:23
And it is interesting that we're at this point where they're like, wait a minute, we haven't done one of those for ages. Yeah, because it gives the sense very much that this is not yet a procedural thing that's done with any particular pattern to it. Yeah. It's something that people are like, Oh, we couldn't do it. We haven't done it. Oh, well, until somebody gets to a point you're like, you know, what would be really good idea? We haven't had one of those for a while. Absolutely. Well, those are not fully legislated. And the traditions are not fully set, you
Dr Rad 12:53
know? No. And they also come along with those ceremonies of purification. So we know we have talked about a census once or twice. I know, we've mentioned the last room before where the city is purified at the end of the whole census procedure. But yeah, it, it has all of those connotations to it, so I can understand that they've probably been far too busy to bother with this kind of stuff.
Dr G 13:17
Fair enough, fair enough. So that's pretty much all that I have for 443 BCE. The only other source that I've got is Diodorus Siculus, who has come up a couple of times. For me when we've got a gap with datasets or Halycon. SS, he's not known for being the most reputable source. He epitomises other histories. He reads widely, it seems but doesn't really go out of his way to access everything. Like he's sort of grabs what's at hand and goes with it. He's from Sicily, originally, which is where the Siculus in his name comes from. And he does end up in Rome, and he's writing in between the sword about 6030 BCE. So a long time after the events that he's recounting his take on 4443 keep wanting to say 43 We're definitely not up to that. 443 BCE is mostly a thing in history and what's going on with them and their particular battles. Right. And so and that consumes most of it, he does mention the consuls, he gets the names pretty, right. So that's
Dr Rad 14:28
pretty right. Do the names we're talking about.
Dr G 14:31
I know and he often gets them pretty wrong. But he does get them pretty right this time. Like Marcus could Gardius Masaru Yunus is correct. Okay. And he gives us tightest, Quintus right. Just leaves off the capital lineup.
Dr Rad 14:44
Oh, okay. That's all right. Yeah,
Dr G 14:46
I'm giving us like a 90%. No, no,
Dr Rad 14:48
you said pretty rad. I'm like, what did he change? No. All right. Well, I have a little bit more detail about this whole censorship process. I mean, it honestly feels really unnerving for Livi to have more detailed and Dionysius on these sorts of things. I'm really excited about this, if not crazy announced, because this is live we were talking about. But there's a bit more discussion about this actual role of sensor being created. So rather than it being something that happens, or for example, that the consuls might carry out in place of the kings who used to carry it out, they talk about creating this actual office of sensel. Which is why it seems like a bit of an organisational turning point, you know, fine tuning that bureaucracy. It's exciting times here the partials and stories.
Dr G 15:39
Do you want to brand new role in our government?
Dr Rad 15:43
Yeah, exactly. So the consuls are still kind of preoccupied by the fact that Rome, still in a vaguely threatening situation militarily? We haven't discussed the fact that war seem to be looming.
Dr G 15:56
The Fog of War surrounds us. We can't see the enemy, though. Yes.
Dr Rad 16:01
And so carrying out a census, obviously, it's a huge amount of work in terms of counting all the citizens figuring out what jobs they do, how much property they have, and all of that kind of stuff. And it was seen as being beneath the dignity of a consul out. I know. And that's why they decide we really need someone who is going to be the magistrate for this thing.
Dr G 16:23
I like being the big decider. I don't want to have to deal with all of the little decisions that go with being a censor, basically. Yeah.
Dr Rad 16:29
So I how can we free up some mental space for the consul? You know, I mean, the burnt out band, it's bigger issues to think about, yeah, how are they going to have those big picture, leadership visions, all their time is taken up with administration, the new CI of the bureaucracy, no time for it. So they decide we really need to have different magistrates, who are going to have people that are going to help them out to take charge of the records, and really make this a more regular orchestrated thing. So the senators love this idea, because this would mean more Patricia magistrates in Rome, Dr. J.
Dr G 17:15
Oh, thrilling stuff. That's just what Rome leads.
Dr Rad 17:19
Yeah, the patrician see big things ahead for this. So like, if we get the right type of people, and by the right type of people, I mean, important patricians into this role, it would naturally become an important Madrasi. To see it, you can just see it happening. It would have that certain. Tata.
Dr G 17:40
Yes. It's good to have that ring of influence about it, isn't it?
Dr Rad 17:44
Exactly. And of course, the tribune of the plebs being dull as they are, they have no problem with this because they see it as something that is just a function, you know, that needs to be performed. I think it just has to happen. Not something that is necessarily super important, and they also want to be seen as troublemakers heaven forbid that they see as troublemakers in the room. Wow,
Dr G 18:07
the tribune of the plebs. They've really settled down as last year or two, haven't they?
Dr Rad 18:12
Well, I think this is a bit of that elite bias coming in, perhaps, and also completely written with hindsight, because we know that the Office of sensor does become important. We know that people like Augustus are going to end up wielding it to great effect by the time that Livy is writing, so I feel like he is being overly snooty and insinuating that they should have somehow foreseen what this position was going to end up
Dr G 18:41
with. This is a miss by the tribune of the plebs. Exactly. They should have registered some complaint
Dr Rad 18:47
early on pretty much. Yeah, exactly. So the very, very top people aren't particularly interested in taking on this position, because it isn't super important. So
Dr G 18:58
I'm like work as well. And if I was a patrician, I'm not sure I'd be in for that. Oh,
Dr Rad 19:03
it's definitely a game if you do have helpers, but I actually have some name. Oh, yeah. I don't even know. Dionysius gave you names on it. No, you get Okay, so I've got one Lucius purpureus new Gleaners. And I've also got one Lucius sim Prunus at truthiness,
Dr G 19:26
whose name I think we weren't sounds familiar. Actually,
Dr Rad 19:29
they both had been Suffect consuls in the previous year. Okay, so they really should ring a lot of bells
Dr G 19:38
should have rung more bells that rang
Dr Rad 19:39
for me. Yeah, absolutely. It's at this point. So census is all wrapped up by this point. It's at this point that the envoys from a data arrived again, they're in desperate need of help because their city is on the verge of collapse. They tried to keep things as peaceful as possible. And you know, just keep it under wraps because that's what Roman wanted but they are in a position where civil war seems imminent. There are factions that are threatening to tear a day are apart. And this is all had its roots in a private conflict when a hot plebeian girl attracted the interest of both a patrician and plebeian be prepared for a soap opera ensuing. Yeah, I'm excited. This is this is what this is what it helps the factions to develop. Okay, sounding a little bit like the Virginia story in a way or work in Yeah, sorry. Basically, the Libyan guy obviously needed the approval of her family. The patrician guy, on the other hand, he was really just interested in her because of her very good looks. Yes, yes, classic, patrician move. Yeah. This, of course, had led to lots of party strife in the household of the girl about the politics of these guys and the factions that they come from. The mother preferred the noble, but also the patrician, I should say, because obviously, he would offer her certain opportunities in life. And he she wanted her daughter to marry as well as possible, but her guardian thought it was important to ally with their fellow plebeian, Okay, interesting in debt, and they really couldn't resolve the matter in their own household. And therefore, this results in a huge legal case, and the magistrates had ended up deciding in the favour of the mother and allowing this girl to marry the patrician. Now, I'm just going to flag here that in the translation that I was looking at, it mentions that the patrician was from the Optima Artis party.
Dr G 21:37
Oh, that seems way too early for the optimizer to come into play. It is Aster is listeners?
Dr Rad 21:44
Definitely. This is something that is very much i term I would associate with the late Republic,
Dr G 21:50
and even then, late Republican historians still are unclear about exactly what would make somebody in optimality, as opposed to the other faction, which is the popularities.
Dr Rad 22:04
Yes, I think the general jest and again, it makes sense, I suppose given when Levy's writing, and I probably should have consulted the original Latin. But as usual, I forget to do that. But I presume it because of the notations in this that they had already done that. I think the connotation is meant to be that this patrician is very much about the elites in his allegiance, not the people. I mean, I think that's what we're meant to get from this. But yeah,
Dr G 22:32
it's just that he's a conservative leaning, patrician elite. Yeah,
Dr Rad 22:37
I just thought it was really interesting. He
Dr G 22:39
must be very good looking.
Dr Rad 22:42
I know, right?
Dr G 22:43
It seems he's forsaken all of his class values.
Dr Rad 22:47
One would think for this woman just because she's hot. Yeah. Wow.
Dr G 22:53
He Rome sobered up in 443.
Dr Rad 22:57
So much drama. Anyway. So what ends up happening is of course, after this legal decision is made, her guardians are not prepared to abide by this decision. So they decided they're going to publicly address a crowd of their fellow plebeians about how ridiculously unfair this decision was the guardians and get together again and abduct a girl from her mother's house. Wow. I told you this is a total soap opera idea, coming to the rescue. Anyway, so this is obviously very, very problematic, very dramatic at this point in time. But the patrician is hardly going to let it's he got to be kidding. He gets together again in his own war like aristocrats of course. Yes, absolutely. So literally gang warfare breaking out as a result of this girl and her good looks. I mean, hello. Hello, Troy.
Dr G 23:54
Yeah, there's some really interesting parallels here,
Dr Rad 23:58
isn't there? Yeah. This results in a battle and the plebeians on the streets. Yeah. Okay. I mean, it doesn't specify but I presumed Yeah, results in a battle that Cobain's end up losing, but they set up a camp on a hill and then from their camp, they go forward and destroy the farms of the patricians and they started thinking that maybe we're just gonna lay siege to the whole of our data. Why? Why stop at just five? Why stop at just patricians? Let's just go nuts. Other people have started to join them, not for their lofty moral reasons, but because they just want stuff.
Dr G 24:35
Yeah,
Dr Rad 24:36
I can see our day have been pretty annoyed at this point. This is why the Danes have come to Rome and been like, Excuse me. We seem to be in a spot of
Dr G 24:47
and there is some private interests taking hold around our homeland and we're not best pleased. Yeah.
Dr Rad 24:53
So the patrician faction in our day, it had been the ones to ask for help from Rome, right? So we have to imagine the envoys speaking and very often he's written in on a beret, wearing tweed with elbow patches. On the other hand, the plebeians have sent for help from the vole skins who are all smart move. Yeah. Who are also in the same region, as Rome and idea?
Dr G 25:21
Well, well, yeah. So if we're thinking about visualising this on a map of Rome, think of Rome as being in the centre of the map idea is to the south west, on the shore, it's on it's a coastal town. And the whole skins are to the south east of Rome. And so they're kind of sitting at the same sort of like, is it longitude as they are, but there's latitude,
Dr Rad 25:43
latitude. You know, I remember next I had to teach geography for a little while. Oh, latitude is flat a tude?
Dr G 25:50
Yeah, I have issues with things that involve the nature of the globe, where how you name winds, and also reading clocks. I'm gonna put them all together as issues that I have. So the volsky i are sort of the neighbours of our data, but also neighbours of Rome. Yes. Yes. And historically, one of Rome's greatest enemies at this point,
Dr Rad 26:12
Oh, definitely. There's been so much conflict between them. So they've all skins send out a rescue party led by clue alias. Name, we might remember. Yes, yes. And equi include alias. And they get to our day at first, and they start hoping to procedure there because they seem to go along with this idea that Sure. Let's just besiege the town. Well, the
Dr G 26:38
volsky. I have an interest in our data, and they have done for quite some time. And that's been facilitated by the fact that Rome has weakened our day as defences over time as well. So the volsky I have this reputation of sort of popping in under the radar, as Rome has weakened somewhere and being like, and now it's out
Dr Rad 26:55
and we're being like, hey, wait a minute. And there is often an association between the old skins and the alien. So this all adds up. Yeah. So the Romans, of course, hear about what's happening. So one of the consuls, Marcos Giga Aeneas ends up leaving with an army to assist in the situation. When they are getting close to enemy forces. He obviously sets up his camp, he lets his soldiers you know, splash some water on their face, freshen up a little bit, put on some new mascara, you know, get out the pumps, and that sort of thing. Then they march out, though, so fast that at sunrise of Oskins realise, oh my goodness, we're actually in a bit of a risky situation. The Romans are here. Yeah, dammit. The position that were in is actually kind of even worse than a day is positioned right now given where the Romans have set up camp and how quickly they've managed to try it out against us. Gainey has also managed to ensure that his friends in our day out could come and go as they please. So the moleskin is clearly had not managed to completely surround the city in this huge. The foreskin commander also did not have food supplies stored in advance which
Dr G 28:08
Wait a minute. Yeah. That is a logistical error of a high magnitude How long did they expect to be on the field?
Dr Rad 28:16
Well, I think this is the thing I think this is why they got there first, they didn't really think about it too much.
Dr G 28:21
They just were like were around
Dr Rad 28:23
earlier for Popeye, no problems. And so he's men had been relying on just foraging in the local area for food and now he finds he has no supplies. This is probably why he realises he's in a worse situation than Isaiah because the Romans that probably cut him off from any real food, no
Dr G 28:42
foraging for you. Back to the camp, and hungry
Dr Rad 28:47
so naturally, he does the smart thing and ask again so they can enter into negotiations. Okay, like look, if the Romans are intending to put an end to the siege, why don't we just call it quits, we'll just we'll just go home, okay, by the Romans and not say, loves the chubby. You attacked our allies. You don't just get to walk away. The gain is demands that what they need to do is hand over their general lay down their arms admit that they have been soundly beaten and give into Roman authority. If they refuse, the Romans would be dead. Adam is for all eternity. Wow. Yes, Ganey is you might be gathering
Dr G 29:40
he sounds like a little bit of a douchebag. But,
Dr Rad 29:43
you know, he's determined that he's gonna go home with a resounding
Dr G 29:48
victory. I was gonna say he wants a trial. Oh, yeah. And he's gonna find a way to get one.
Dr Rad 29:52
Absolutely. And he also doesn't want a kind of slushy piece. You want something that's going to look Really impressive volsky? I
Dr G 30:02
don't on your knees. Exactly. The vols
Dr Rad 30:04
games, of course, can't really agree to these conditions because I just watch evaluating. And so they are forced to enter into battle with the Romans in a position that's not really
Dr G 30:13
great. Never go into battle on an empty stomach.
Dr Rad 30:17
Right? Always carry a Snickers. Always Yes, you know yourself when you're hungry. They're not only starting in a bad position, but they're also in a situation where if things don't go well for them, they're not going to be able to run away very easily. Ah, yes. So spoiler, the decimal.
Dr G 30:37
Oak, come on volsky. I, I mean, I feel for them. I feel like the thing to have done here would have been to be like, we just need to go back and talk about your suggestions. And we'll come back to you with an answer. Go back to camp pack it up quickly and run away. Yeah, exactly. So
Dr Rad 30:51
what a failure of strategy so terrible that they beg the Romans just for the battle. I don't know what that looks like in the middle of a battle, but I'm imagining they just thought of dropping to their knees dropping their swords. I'm guessing
Dr G 31:03
that there is signals of surrender. Yeah. universally known in the area. Yes. And
Dr Rad 31:09
so they willingly then hand over their command hand over their weapons, and they are made to pass under the yoke with a single garment each. Oh, completely humiliated. Yes. Now
Dr G 31:21
passing under the yoke. This is something that we have encountered before we have and it is what seems to be a ritual that encompasses both humiliation to a certain degree for the defeated, but is also a ritual acknowledgement of their failure and their consent in some ways to fall under Roman leadership,
Dr Rad 31:45
which is an interesting one, isn't it? So the remaining defeated vole skins once I've gone through this process, they set up camp near Tusculum. We haven't talked about Tascam for a while. I like Tusculum, though, it's cute. I know. The testicle ends. However, I'm holding on to an old grudge, no doubt made during one of the numerous conflicts between Rome who would have been assisted by the task, gluons, who are the allies and the volsky ones who are traditional enemies. And so they decide that they're going to attack this foreseeing camp, even though they are clearly in no position to fight back. And as a result, they're apparently on the very few survivors from this volcano.
Dr G 32:27
Okay, so Tusculum turn up and and finish off what Rome has had started essentially, well,
Dr Rad 32:34
only because of our skins go near them. Okay, as they retreating, they set up a cabinet. artikelen. Right. And so they're, I guess, just taking refuge there. Yeah, hospitals aren't having that now and it because it does seem to be an interesting force that the Vols skins have assembled here. I'm not even sure how official this army is meant to be. Exactly. But certainly it is a group of people from the moleskin area. But how official it is it's a bit unclear. So they had retreated in disgrace. Maybe they just didn't want to go home that had happened.
Dr G 33:08
So the volsky I have retreated visually on the map. They've retreated to the east. And Tusculum is one of these places that is in the foothills of the Albion Hills. Yeah, so they're sort of heading back towards their homeland. But they have to pass by tussle and to some degree in order to get there. Yeah, they've ventured too close.
Dr Rad 33:31
Maybe I mean, maybe because they pass under the yoke. I mean, maybe they were kind of going into that area because it is associated with Roman Roman allies and Roman control hospital and didn't
Dr G 33:41
know that the yoke passing had already
Dr Rad 33:43
they didn't. You got into your kidney. These guys. Anyway, so the Romans are now free to restore order in our day out which they do very efficiently. Typical Redmond style, just chop off the heads of the people that started the trouble. Wow, yeah. Then Then let's take that property and put it in the public treasury. Now everybody's happy
Dr G 34:07
in the public treasury of a day out or in the public treasury of room doesn't say
Dr Rad 34:11
but I'm presuming on day because they are restoring order in Yeah, yeah. The day in Sorry, I shouldn't say the dance. The odd dance apparently is what they called a dance just seems so
Dr G 34:22
you can say all day. And so it's a very English thing. Let's okay.
Dr Rad 34:25
Yeah. The day is felt that the Romans had now repaid the debt. So after that terrible decision that they made, they have helped them out. But the Roman senate is actually still feeling really guilty about that thing. They just the disgrace really hangs over Rome for years and years, according to Libby's account. So again, it goes back to Rome, anyway, of course, gets his triumph. Exactly feeling pretty good about himself. Kubilius, a guy that had been the commander of the volsky in forces is made to walk in front of his chariot, there is all the booty taken from the moleskin army before they made them pass under the yoke. So that's all looking pretty good for him. Quint Diaz capital lioness also is singled out for praise by levy because whilst the gayness was off doing all that kind of stuff, he made sure that there was peace in Rome itself, making sure that law was justly applied, whether you are a patrician or whether you're a poor being my
Dr G 35:28
normal gang warfare, no more chasing after pretty women in the streets,
Dr Rad 35:32
or ducting urine relative
Dr G 35:36
has been a tough year for this kind of thing.
Dr Rad 35:38
Yeah, so the Senate is really happy because I presume by Senators levy also is obviously just meeting patricians more generally, they are happy with Quintos capital owners because they see him as being you know, a strict console someone who's keeping things in line. But the plebeians are not alienated by his strictness. They don't see him as super oppressive, they see him as someone who's got a lot of personal dignity and integrity, integrity, and they're happy to work with him. He can hold his own against the Tribune, so kind of everybody is happy. I think, as we were flagging, at the beginning of this episode, the fact that he has held the console ship so many times and seemingly over such a long period of time. He is an older man, by this point, his experience counts for a lot. He's very beloved by the whole population. He's well known to everybody. Yeah, absolutely. And he carries himself well, he's he's fair. You know, he's strict, but he's fair. And live. He says that by this stage of his career, he himself is almost more revered than the office of consulship itself.
Dr G 36:47
Wow,
Dr Rad 36:48
patting myself a bit here. And because gayness and Quintus capital liners are doing such a great job in terms of internal harmony, external victories. I mean, come on. Oh, can you what people are forgetting about the idea of military tributes? Oh, yeah, when you got men like these on the block, who has
Dr G 37:12
time for it? Oh, just when the patricians have this sights on being able to have some proper Imperium. Alright, everyone's like that. It's going really well with the consuls. Now. Don't worry about it. Exactly.
Dr Rad 37:23
So that is where I wrap up the year for 43. Before
Dr G 37:29
a year, thank you for sharing Levy's account. I wish I had something to share in return.
Dr Rad 37:34
Look, I can't believe that Dionysius breaks off just before that soap opera I know. But anyway, that means Dr. G, that it is time now for
Dr G 37:44
about your big
Dr Rad 37:50
thank you. Ego, you rejoined us again near to go see the eagle return in Z?
Dr G 37:58
Well, the partial pit room has the potential to earn 50 Golden Eagles across five categories, each ranked out of 10. Let's find out together how well Rome is performing against their own criteria. Okay. Military cloud.
Dr Rad 38:16
Well, I mean, it's pretty good guy. Got it. It
Dr G 38:20
does all right for himself doesn't really does well. Doesn't get any better than that. Only when the two consuls go out and and have success, I think Oh, and
Dr Rad 38:29
also, I mean, if we think about what he's actually doing, I mean, resolving this kind of conflict. I don't know if it's the most illustrious thing I've ever seen. So he's probably give him maybe like a seven.
Dr G 38:41
Okay, yeah, yeah, I was gonna say it's not a full tan. I don't think I'm that great. I think we've seen better and I think Ron can do
Dr Rad 38:46
I mean, he milked the most of this opportunity. There's no doubt about that.
Dr G 38:51
That means we move on to diplomacy.
Dr Rad 38:55
Well, okay. Even though obviously, warfare tends to imply that diplomacy has failed. I think the Romans did kind of try like there was some negotiating it was pretty strict.
Dr G 39:09
I don't know. I mean, isn't it the case that our day I came to them to negotiate? I think we could say that the Danes are engaging in diplomacy. And Rome has responded by sending an armed force that's which may or may not have worked out for our dear. But is that diplomatic? Maybe? Maybe not. Yeah,
Dr Rad 39:27
that's true. Okay, so maybe like, I don't know, one.
Dr G 39:31
I was gonna say maybe three, so I could go with a two perhaps. Okay. All right. Expansion.
Dr Rad 39:37
Well, not really. I mean, they're just settling a civil dispute and a neighbor's area.
Dr G 39:44
They definitely haven't gained more territory. That is that is a firm zero. Yeah, we're tours. Hmm, I'll look a goddess is doing some pretty. Like he's being strict. He's being really clear about what he wants. Yeah. And he succeeds in getting it. That's true. So from a Roman perspective, not only has he been courageous in putting forward a really robust position of what he wants, yeah, but he's also found the means in order to acquire it. Like when it comes to battle, he goes in and takes it.
Dr Rad 40:14
Oh, yeah. And the Romans, just particularly the Senate, and the patricians are feeling a really strong sense of shame over the whole business with our day or and ruin, basically stealing its territory.
Dr G 40:27
So this is kind of like a redemptive meeting moment as well, more broadly. Yeah, for Rome to sort of maybe rectify some of the poor decisions it's made in the past with relation to our data.
Dr Rad 40:38
Having said that, though, I don't know that is again, the best example I've ever seen.
Dr G 40:44
No, I'm not. I'm not gonna suggest that. No, but I think there is some weird to us at play for sure. And Romans at the time would have been like, there is some weird words here. Yeah. Recognise where to us.
Dr Rad 40:54
Even Quincy has capitalised. I mean, is a little bit different, obviously. But the fact that Livi singles him out for particular praise
Dr G 41:02
Rila. Is a good looking, do I have to form again?
Dr Rad 41:11
So maybe I don't know if five? Yeah, okay.
Dr G 41:15
All right. And that leaves us with the final category, which is the citizens score. How nice is it to be a Roman citizen, walking the streets in this year.
Dr Rad 41:26
Okay. Not great in the sense that after fighting so hard to get military tribute into the consular authority, so that plebeians can hold very important officers, they're not getting that so that's not great. However, the plebeians are said to be satisfied with their leaders at this point in time, and justice is apparently being administered fairly, regardless of what group you belong to. And ramesside.
Dr G 41:52
There also, is a patrician gang coming after a plebeian group. Well, yes, but that's,
Dr Rad 42:00
that's an idea that
Dr G 42:01
well, but But
Dr Rad 42:04
I there was also Toby and Patricia, and Holger knows,
Dr G 42:10
there is some Yeah, I mean, I have some questions. And maybe a day doesn't count under this sort of? Well, I
Dr Rad 42:15
think that's the question. Yeah. Are we including what is happening in our data? Because that story I told you is definitely and I, Dan.
Dr G 42:25
Yeah. And I guess not. I think they would be that's definitely not how this category works. This is how good it is to be a Roman citizen right now. Yes, yes. And Roman citizens seem to be pretty happy with their lot right now.
Dr Rad 42:39
Yeah, I think so. Yeah. So maybe like a fun? Yeah, it's
Dr G 42:43
not it's not like they've had great concessions or anything. It's not like the A lot has improved. But it certainly hasn't gone backwards.
Dr Rad 42:50
No. And as I say, the main thing that they're always concerned about, and this is where the patricians so they tend to get uppity and demand more rights, and all of that kind of thing when they are being treated unfairly, which makes sense. At the moment, they're not being treated badly. They're not being treated as second class citizens in the sense that it's not in a way that they've noticed at a time to come. No, I mean, they are obviously always, but it's not in such a way that's like so egregious that
Dr G 43:24
they have to say something, yes. Speak. No, we're being oppressed.
Dr Rad 43:28
There aren't people being, you know, murdered in the streets. So that's a win as far as that consent, which means strategy, that we have a grand total of 19 Golden Eagles for room this time. I think that's probably the highest it has been.
Dr G 43:44
I think that's yeah, it's pretty good for a while. It's definitely not a pass. Yeah. But you know, it could have been much worse. Definitely.
Dr Rad 43:56
You go to Summit for 43 BC, a fairly mediocre year.
Dr G 44:04
Classic times for Rome. Yeah.
Dr Rad 44:05
Well, it's
Dr G 44:06
been a pleasure to speak with you as always, and to learn all about Livy's account of what's happening with our data, and how the Romans are really coping with themselves right now.
Dr Rad 44:17
Absolutely. See you next time.
We hope that you have enjoyed listening to this episode of the partial historians, and we would like to send a special thank you to all of our Patreon ‘s out there. And this month, we would like to say a particular hello to Zera, Tamara and Justine, who joined us all the way back in 2020 2020. If you too, would like to become a patreon then please head on over to our page and pledge your support. It really helps with the costs of running the show. In return, you get early access to special episodes and also some new exclusive Patreon only content. However, if you aren't able to support the show in that way at the moment that is completely fine. You can also help us out by spreading the word about the passion of historians wherever you go, whether it's in real life or on social media. Until next time, we are yours in ancient Rome
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/
Support the show
Patreon
Ko-Fi
Read our books
Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome
Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
There is much less scholarly work on the early Roman Republic than there is on periods like the late Republic or early Empire. This is understandable as there are fewer primary sources, and what we have does not always seem quite as reliable. There are still people who have chosen to focus on this era, and one of our major scholarly sources has been the work of Emeritus Professor Tim Cornell.
Special Episode – Early Rome with Emeritus Professor Tim Cornell
Professor Cornell has held many prestigious academic posts in his long career, working at Christ’s College, Cambridge, the British School at Rome, University College London, the University of Birmingham, the Institute of Classical Studies, and he is currently the President of the Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies. His book The Beginnings of Rome: Italy and Rome from the Bronze Age to the Punic Wars (c. 1000-264 BC) (1995) is an incredible resource. Another of his major contributions to scholarship was overseeing the multi-volume Fragments of the Roman Historians (2013) which brings all the fragments of scholars for whose works are not extant together in one collection. In short, Cornell's work has had a huge influence on the field of early Roman history!
We were blown away that Professor Cornell agreed to sit down and chat to us about all the most confusing parts of early Rome. He helped us to address issues such as:
We hope that you enjoy this episode as much as we enjoyed recording it. It certainly helps to draw together a lot of the themes in our episodes so far and paint a more complete picture of this first phase of the Roman Republic.If you are interested in reading more of Professor Cornell's work, please check out his profile on Academia.Edu.
Cornell's work on early Rome is pretty amazing and we recommend you check it out!
View of the Roman Forum from Via di Monte Tarpeo (2017) by Marcel Roblin and courtesy of Wikimedia Commons
For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/
Support the show
Patreon
Ko-Fi
Read our books
Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome
Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
The role of the Military Tribune with Consular Power (tribuni militum consulari potestate) is very particular. It seems to have been created out of the need for a new way forward from the role of the consuls. In our previous episode we encountered them for the first time as part of a patrician plan to placate plebeian discontent in 445 BCE, but our ability to understand this period is complicated by a number of issues:
Both Livy and Dionysius of Halicarnassus talk a little bit about their sources around this subject. Livy makes specific reference to the writer Licinius Macer while Dionysius makes note of the discrepancies in the various annalist records.
Episode 124 – The Military Tribunes with Consular Power
As Rome transitions into 444 BCE we find out about our first elected Military Tribunes with Consular Power, but it's not long before ambassadors from Ardea arrive to discuss their ongoing conflict involving Rome…
Things to listen out for:
Thanks to BBC Sounds (Beta) for sound effects and the wonderful Bettina Joy de Guzman for our theme music.
Imperial Roman Veterans, an illustration by Peter Dennis as part of the Warlord Games ‘Hail Caesar' miniatures.
Automatically Generated TranscriptWe’re exploring transcription options! The transcript below was automatically generated by otter.ai. Hopefully those Latin names and places can still be understood!
Dr Rad 0:00
All right. Welcome to a brand new episode of the partial historians. I am one of your hosts, Dr. Rad.
Dr G 0:09
And I am Dr. G. And what a thrill it is to be here for this episode.
Dr Rad 0:15
I know. So we have been tracing the history of Rome from the founding of the city. And last episode was kind of a turning point. So let's do a bit of a recap, shall we? Dr. G?
Dr G 0:26
Oh, yes. So we've had this really sort of quite dramatic moment for the Romans in terms of how they think about their politics. Yes. And for Livy, and Dionysus of helican S's this issue has been framed around class struggle, patricians versus plebeians. And we've had this play for power from the plebeians being like we would like actually to be part of the consulship. That might be nice.
Dr Rad 0:51
And while you're at it, we'd also like to be able to marry patricians because it seems a bit like segregation, otherwise,
Dr G 0:59
it is awkward. Yeah. To be ruled by people, and for there to be no class mobility. Yes, exactly. And this has led to what appears to be a very dastardly plan on the half of the patrician side, where they're like, look, it would be absolutely a sacred travesty to allow the plebeians to be consoles, because it's not just a Magister see of law. It has a ritual component, there are relationships with the gods to be maintained.
Dr Rad 1:33
Get your goofy little bean paws off the consulship.
Dr G 1:36
You're tainted, you can't be part of this.
Dr Rad 1:39
This is an us thing, not a wee thing. Yeah.
Dr G 1:43
And so the patricians are a bit like that. And on the other hand, they've decided that the crisis is so overwhelming, because Rome is basically facing war on every side true, surrounded by potential enemies, and they really need to raise an army. And they're like, We need the plebeians involved, because we've got to have fodder on the field.
Dr Rad 2:01
Yeah. And they are also much larger group than.
Dr G 2:06
And in order to do that, they need to feel more than two armies, because usually consoles will lead an army each, but two armies is not going to be enough. So they've got a numbers issue, both at the command level, and at the rank and file soldier level. Definitely. They're like, how are we going to solve that? And they come up with a plan, the patricians come up with a cunning plan.
Dr Rad 2:29
Oh, sorry, that's evil. Well, you know what? I think? I think it goes, I think it goes,
Dr G 2:33
I think you're in very safe territory. And this cunning plan is to take the concept of the military Tribune, yes. Who is a figure who is kind of selected as they get brought into the army to lead a small group? Yeah. And to give them consular power, not the whole bag, they don't get to be consoles, you don't get the title. No, the title is the thing. You don't get the title, you don't get the capacity to move into the Senate later on in your career. But if you're a military Tribune, with consular power, yeah, a bit of a mouthful, I know. But the Romans are into that kind of thing. And that if you hold that position, what happens then is that all of a sudden, you've got the capacity to create more numerous armies more than two, yes. And you can send them out in any direction you need to Yeah, and get the stuff done, because they will have the legitimate legal authority, yes, to lead an army.
Dr Rad 3:28
And we spoke last time about how, whilst our sources are very much pushing the idea that this is part of the conflict of the orders. And this is a turning point in the relationship between the patricians and the plebeians and how they see themselves belonging to the Roman state, etc. What most historians definitely see as being the case is that this is also part of just the evolution of Rome as a state in terms of obviously, governments change and systems change as circumstances and demographics change. And so, you know, sure room does seem to have been going through a tough period, if we look at other types of evidence, like archaeological evidence. And so it's possible that Rome did need to have a sort of regroup moment where they thought, Hmm, how is this all going to work for Rome now, rather than Rome, say, you know, 50 to 100, maybe even a couple of 100 years ago.
Dr G 4:20
And we're seeing that sense in which Rome is in a constant state of change. Yes. And obviously, this runs in direct contrast to the things that the patricians really like we choose tradition and stability.
Dr Rad 4:33
Imagine, imagine in 2022 this words, they just seem so alien coming out of your mouth,
Dr G 4:40
tradition and stability. That is what we will provide patricians. Yeah.
Dr Rad 4:44
So this decision to allow for military tribunals with consular authority, as well as the fact that they did indeed overturn this marriage law, which forbid the intermarriage of patricians and plebeians. Apparently, it does. actually appears that A, B and C and levies account. So that does actually it is balm to the wound.
Dr G 5:05
Yes, I'm interested in what Libby thinks about this because it plays out in a very particular way in Dionysius of Halicarnassus. And I definitely want to tell you about it, but I'm keen to understand what Levy's perspective.
Dr Rad 5:18
Okay, so, essentially, the way that it starts to unfold is that there are these elections which take place, obviously, once they've decided that this can be a thing. And the idea is that you could choose three of these tributes with consular power. So lots of Colombians are running around trying to rally support for themselves because they're just so excited. Oh, my God, I could do it. I could do it. I'm going to the prom. They're wearing their target candy. It is. I think you get a slight patrician bias coming through Levy's account. Not yet. Not that. Yeah. But yeah, it is that sort of upper class bias. I should perhaps say where he's kind of like, you can't believe that this is happening. It's so doubloon. Yeah. And he obviously sees these people as being troublemakers the way that he talks about them. He's like, these troublemakers. You know, they've done nothing but bad things for the state and look at them in their target can't do this. It's rope bolting. Anyway, the patrician Nobody's Fool.
Dr G 6:16
Nobody's Fool. Yeah.
Dr Rad 6:17
They're patricians. Looking around as well, and kind of horror and I think they're a bit lost. It's like getting punched in the face and someone ran away. Because it's so much for being competition because they're all so excited. And because they bringing so much energy because it's safer selection guys. And they think, Oh, God, we really want to like, I don't know, like work with Cool beans. That seems not ideal. And so they're not so keen on standing for office. They can like, you know, just take myself out of this situation.
Dr G 6:47
I don't need to stand this year. I'm out. Yeah,
Dr Rad 6:51
it's not my thing. The patrician leading patricians, I should say, however, they're like, Guys, you can't just step aside and let the Libyans run the show that would look like the patricians are just getting off on Rome all together and out of the government,
Dr G 7:06
so don't like it anymore. And I'm not gonna do it.
Dr Rad 7:09
Well, they end up being convinced that Yeah, yeah. So as we have to represent, and then of course, it this is all just farcical because when the election actually rolls around, it shows that people just wanted the option of having fob and to rule the state. What? Because the people all elect patricians to be these military Tribune's according to his account.
Dr G 7:34
This doesn't make any sense. Yeah,
Dr Rad 7:36
I know. It's look, it's a bit. But anyway, so yeah, that's kind of how it all my fees account
Dr G 7:46
how, what an anti climax I have to say,
Dr Rad 7:48
Yeah, but it's gonna get worse in the next year. This is just rounding off for 45. All right.
Dr G 7:53
All right. So to that end, in comparison, there seems to be a good synergy and parallel between Livy and Dionysius of Halicarnassus. Okay, basically, the people the plebeians, love this idea of this military tributary with control of power like this is their way in and they're like, Yes, take that opportunity with both hands. Yes, people do heaps of canvassing, they're having a great time. The plebeians kind of look at their own going around and nominating themselves for the position and they like you're an idiot, I would never vote for you. I'd been out with you on cap just not gonna happen. I've seen what you've done. And so even though the plebeians are now sort of like looking at their own with the possibility of being able to vote the meat, they can't bring themselves to do it. Okay. And so, I mean, it's just massive, dramatic irony, I think. Because we've got this situation where they're like, Oh, well, actually, I mean, I'm going to vote for who I think is the best candidate. And lo and behold, it turns out that they all vote for patricians. They've got more experience. They've been in the role before, you know, they've had that high level command, what whatever they come from a distinguished military family. So you know, presumably, being a good general has been passed down through the ages. Yeah. And it's just baffling. Having said that, some of the names that come through for this we have not seen before.
Dr Rad 9:17
Oh, are we going to go into 444 BCE? Well, not yet. No. Oh, really? Okay. The names are minor and 444 BC, and I was going to do a little
Dr G 9:26
let's do a little doodly doo. I think it's a good time for doodly doo. Okay. Who gets voted in new say, Yeah, well, I've got some names for you. Okay. I've got candidates, men of distinction, namely, all a sudden peroneus at her rottenness,
Dr Rad 9:47
yeah, that's a weird name. Yeah. Huh. at 13 at 13 atheria. Tina's Yeah,
Dr G 9:52
Lucien Achilleas. Loose kiss Hmm. Bit of a mouthful as well.
Dr Rad 9:58
Hey, there's remember names that sound like me. case.
Dr G 10:02
And Titus, clue alias Siculus.
Dr Rad 10:05
I also have those names down in my account. And even though they are allegedly or patrician, some of those names Dr. G,
Dr G 10:14
some of these names we have not seen before holding high office. So there might be some speculation to be had about who these people really are. Yeah. But that's nevertheless what we told. Indeed, Dionysius then does this weird thing. And it's it comes through in the translation. So I don't know if I should blame him directly or, or blame the translator. But he calls these men that assume Pro Concealer power. Oh, but there's a bit of a mistake here. So I want to just give a bit of a pause, because this is a term that people hear all the time when they're doing Roman history. Pro Concealer power. Yeah. What is that? Exactly?
Dr Rad 10:53
I don't think we've really talked about that. Because that's comes in much late comes in much later. Yeah,
Dr G 10:57
so it's really misplaced here. And that should be the first flag definitely, that when we're not in the period of history where we understand Pro Controller power to be happening. No. And yet it creeps in in Dionysius, because we've got this bit of a retro reaction happening. This is how he's understanding it, or interpreting it for his audience to appreciate what this power is. Well, I
Dr Rad 11:17
can see the similarity with military children's with concealer power, and what a Proconsul essentially has. Yeah, yeah.
Dr G 11:23
So when we're talking about Pro Concealer, power comes from the Latin phrase pro con su li, which means instead of the consoles, right, that's essentially its basic thing. So there are a state official who exercises controller power. So that is Imperium. Yeah. So that's the basic side of things, not the ritual side of things. Yeah. Outside of the city. But importantly, they're not allowed to consult the auspices, right? So they can't look for special signs,
Dr Rad 11:50
which would track with what military tribunes with consular authority was trying to avoid in the first place, which is plebeians doing things like taking your services?
Dr G 11:59
Well, the thing is that as far as we can tell, the military Tribune's with controller power could consult the auspices interesting
Dr Rad 12:05
Well, then why not just make them consoles never.
Dr G 12:09
That's not how it works.
Dr Rad 12:15
Oh, God room room.
Dr G 12:18
It's the thing is that the military tribunes with consular power is all about keeping replicating the Bolivian Yes, but also keeping them out of class advancement. So yes, not being able to get into the Senate. Yeah, not being able to progress by stealth as it were into the patrician class. What. Wait a minute. I'm noticing like, oh, yeah, we'll have another that patricians don't want that. Yeah. But they do have the capacity to do this almost beside of things concerning the organs is something they're allowed to do, apparently.
Dr Rad 12:56
Okay. The reason why I'm confused is because in case anybody remembers from previous episode, the patricians were kicking up such a stink about them becoming consoles, because of things like, you know, consulting the auspices. Am I wrong? Am I miss remembering?
Dr G 13:11
No, I don't think so. Yeah, and yet, so this piece of information has come in part from studies that have been done on this position, right. So there is a little bit of confusion, not gonna lie. Yeah. But and we have these two threads, like these separate threads coming together, where we've got Libyan Dionysius telling us that, you know, these consular military Tribune's shouldn't be able to engage in ritual activity, and that's part of the deal. We want to keep them away from that side of things. Yes. But that doesn't seem to be necessarily the case. Looking around the whole thing. Yeah. And so this is part of the problem. So I think this is a point for argument. And its potential that scholars are going to disagree on it as well. But certainly, they don't have the capacity to then gain entry into the Senate. Yeah. Which is kind of like a thing. That would be nice. And they're not allowed to hold a triumph. Right. You know, there are certain limitations on what they're able to do. Okay. So that's, yeah, they're not exactly consoles, I guess. And, and then we get to this situation where we've all of a sudden, we've got these three military tributes or controller power, and they're all patrician, apparently. Yes. And then we have this situation where something seems to have gone wrong with the auspices. Yeah, well, I mean, almost instantly, something goes wrong with yours. But yeah, I mean,
Dr Rad 14:40
as you said, like I get the sense that 444 BC set it off quite smoothly in that, you know, this the internal situation with Rome is settling down. And I guess with these, you know, three military attributes they're anticipating they will use them to go to war with they as well to deal with the eight queens in the valskis as well. has to do with the revolted idea. But exactly as you've highlighted, they are not in power for more than sort of three months.
Dr G 15:08
They don't do anything. They really power for 73 days, apparently. Wow. That's very precise. Yeah. Thanks, Dionysus. Yeah. 73 days and then they have to voluntarily resign. Yeah. Because the omens haven't worked out the omens prevent them from being able to continue engaging in public business.
Dr Rad 15:28
Yes. And it's the augers. Yeah, who seemed to have pointed out that there was a problem with the election. And the problem was, that guy is courteous. Guys courteous. Who was apparently, you know, the guy in charge, did not correctly choose the ground for his tent for this. Damn, it was about pitching a tent and the wrong place. Oh, I
Dr G 15:55
have to say on this, I think, yeah, that I sense a bit of a conspiracy from the patrician,
Dr Rad 16:03
it would seem that way that they
Dr G 16:07
don't want this to happen. And they're finding alternative means to make it impossible. Yeah. Like, what are the chances after all of these years of pitching the tent in the right spot in the right way? This would be the year that somebody fluffed it.
Dr Rad 16:23
Yeah. I'll just explain quickly as well. What this whole tent businesses because that probably sounds like they're probably you know, like going camping or something like that. No, quiet. We're talking about something that I believe the technical term is a tabernacle. Mmm hmm. Which was erected over the templum and it basically marked out where the ceremony was going to take place. And there was some sort of opening in the roof through which you could observe and look for the flight of the birds. Okay, sounds good. Yeah, if you didn't do it properly, you're in trouble. Can't see the bird. Yeah.
Dr G 17:00
You're in a bit of a bird doo doo.
Dr Rad 17:02
Hello, Alfred Hitchcock. I'm having trouble with my
Dr G 17:09
so problems a foot those guys leave pretty
Dr Rad 17:11
early. Yeah. Well, you know, I mean, some years.
Dr G 17:15
They are replaced. Lo and behold, surprise, surprise by consoles. Yes. Indeed. And so that leaves us and we're in a roundabout. What seems to be for me is the date is not at all clear. I'll be I'll be level with me. This
Dr Rad 17:29
is definitely 444 BCE. Yeah,
Dr G 17:32
it's 444. But maybe it's 441. Okay, well, Dionysus gives us the great dates and they are the names of the Archons. And that doesn't tally up to where we are in the Roman numerical system as we've been sort of going through it anyway. Never mind that. We've got new consoles they're called Suffolk consoles because they don't take the year name yes, yes. They are. Lucius purpureus Muga Lana's disgusting name and Lucia sim peroneus. At rat Tina's another one of those Yeah, so if you've thought that name sounds vaguely awkward and familiar, that's because his brother always was one of these military Tribune's with consular power who just had to resign.
Dr Rad 18:28
I'm just going to add in a little bit of extra detail here don't CFA, please there is actually dispute in my account about whether consoles or military tribunals should take the place of the guys that had to step down so they are not letting it go without a fight. Okay. And there is actually an interacts in this in Levy's account while they're obviously deciding what they want to do and then also holding the elections because otherwise there's you know, nobody there, and who should be chosen as the interacts? none other but our old friend, Titus quinque DS capital liners, Bob barters,
Dr G 19:02
ah, the bearded man,
Dr Rad 19:04
he has held the consulship many, many times for those who are keeping score at home.
Dr G 19:11
Well, you definitely have more detail than me. Dionysius does mention that we've got an interacts doesn't say who it is, but that there is a swirling sort of conversation going on about whether there should be consoles or more military tribute. Yeah, given the situation. It hasn't gone. Well, the first time around. Yeah, maybe the gods don't agree.
Dr Rad 19:32
Yeah, well, I think I think that in Levy's account, he talks about the fact that even though they did fight over this, it seems like the Libyans kind of give up a little bit because, with the patricians, having been chosen to be the first set of military Tribune's, I think the tribute is in the clubs have had the wind taken out of their sails a little bit. And so they're kind of like, well, I guess it's probably going to be patricians, who are military Tribune's or console So, you know, whatever, what is kind of the point in a sense, and they'd also rather be part an election where they actually, you know, really counted as serious candidates rather than an election where people were looking at them going you you're inferior, you're gross. Get off the stage. Yeah,
Dr G 20:20
yeah. Look, I feel for this period for the analyst historians that we're reading. Yeah. So Levy and Dionysius, I don't think they've got too much information to go on, or at least the story as they give it to us, doesn't feel like it adds up very well.
Dr Rad 20:36
No. And that's probably because they're making something that was probably quite complex and maybe slightly lengthier process. And you know, what they're telling us it was, they're making it maybe a little bit tidier, a bit a bit neater, a little bit more compacted than it perhaps. And I
Dr G 20:51
think they're trying to find their way through while also keeping their allegiances and political, their own political perspective. in tact.
Dr Rad 20:58
Oh, I believe there's definitely an elite perspective coming through my account to see
Dr G 21:03
likewise, yes. And so and Dionysius does let us know that there are some problems with the annalistic records that he's been consulting and interesting for this period. Okay. He's like some of these people are not recorded in all of the animals, right? These names don't crop up everywhere. So we've already got some gaps, and we don't know how to feel them. And we also get a sense in which there's some confusion about who is holding what position? Are these people military tribunes, with control of power? Or are they consoles, right? We're not really quite sure when we start comparing the different animals. And so this means that Dionysius is telling us that he's going out and he's looking at these different lists. Yes. of who's doing what, in what year? Yeah. And he's like, look, the lists are not congruent, depending on which list you're looking at. Yeah, we've got some issues here. So he's telling us he's doing his research. Yeah, he's also acknowledging that he's not really sure what to make of the gaps that he's coming across. Well,
Dr Rad 22:03
to be honest, I would rather that he did that Ben pretended that everything was fine. And interestingly, levy also has a bit of a moment like this, but it comes through in a little anecdote, he tells us about our data. Do you have anything about our day? Or shall I
Dr G 22:17
please go into our day, or I have a little okay, but you go.
Dr Rad 22:20
So whilst all of this stuff is going on, internally, ambassadors from a day I arrived in Rome, basically continuing to bitch about the decisions that the Romans had made. If you're not sure what decision I'm talking about, please see some of our previous episodes. But basically, the Romans had made a terrible decision territorially, by the day, it's been a bit greedy and taken it for themselves.
Dr G 22:39
They had taken our day off, and I'll do the local elders and people were not happy about that. No. And historically, they're different from a different language group. They're quite a unique people. They're not far from Rome. But they definitely don't want to be Roman. Yeah. And the Romans took their land, it was kind of like, deal with it. And the audience were like, no, yeah. And conflict ensued. Yeah. So
Dr Rad 23:00
the Romans are aware that because not everyone was in favour of the decision to take their territory, the Romans are aware that the idea is have a just claim to restoring their land. And they can also tell that the people of IDEO will stick to the treaty that they had with Rome and remain like a friendly people if the right decision is made.
Dr G 23:21
Oh, ouch. Okay. Yes. Yeah.
Dr Rad 23:23
Well, I mean, they're not so much saying this. I think it's just that it's clear that this is the situation, you know, they're obviously just unhappy at this temporary situation. It doesn't have to be this way. But the Senate felt that well, the people did make this decision, and we never overturned a firm decision of the people. Plus, it's really awkward time ambassadors, because we've only just tried to you know, appease the plebeians. It's really tense between the patricians lovely hands right now might not be the right time to set a precedent for overturning a decision made by the people. And so they asked her a little bit more time, and they promised the audience that they won't be sorry, if they have been patient, they just need more time to talk to the people. And is it this moment that they sorted out all their internal stuff? So it's at this moment that that election of consoles and everything takes place, and you got an interact and all of that kind of stuff? Once all of that stuff is sorted? They end up having the treaty or with that day out, renewed? Okay. And this is where Livi brings up documentation? Oh, yeah. Because he talks about the document of the of this treaty without without data, and he talks about the fact that it proves that these men that we talked about as coming in as the stuff that consoles did serve as consoles, even though their names were not included in ancient annals old list of magistrates, okay. And he talks about the fact that okay, well, maybe their names were included, because the year began with military tributes and therefore there was some confusion about whether to include They're in Arizona or whatever. And he also says that he was using like cuneus Mecca or Mesa if you want to have a soft see there. He mentions him saying that these were the names of the men that were on the treaty with idea and that these are the names also found in the linen rolls held in the temple of Munna, moneta? I think it is. Oh, yeah. I presume that this is the temple of Juno moneta, which was erected on the Capitoline Hill in 344. Okay, yeah. And, yes, I mean, just a little bit of extra detail. I believe that this also later helps to room and mint.
Dr G 25:38
Yeah, no, that's very cool. Yeah. So Liv is telling us that one, he's done more research. He's gone and looked for additional documents beyond the animals, because it does make sense that the consoles of this year would their names would not be recorded in the animals. Yes. Because they're not serving as the first concealer magistrate. Yes. And so they could have been left off, particularly if the Romans this is kind of like a rare thing to have happened. Yeah. It's like, how do the Romans navigate that? They don't have a way of doing that yet? Yes. They haven't formed their tradition, as it were, indeed, and this temple. So I mean, we're looking at a temple that's built nearly 100 years later.
Dr Rad 26:23
Yeah. Well, I mean, it's obviously that sounds really suspicious, but Livy is also writing hundreds of years after the temple was Oh,
Dr G 26:32
yeah. disputing that it might contain it might end up containing pieces of writing that are 100 years old. Yes, yes. But yeah, it's obviously it's a tricky thing as well, like how that preservation is happening.
Dr Rad 26:43
Yeah. And it's not clear. Livy doesn't make it 100% clear that he personally saw the treaty with our day. I think I get more of the impression that maybe it's like cuneus maker or Licinius. Mesa, you want to say
Dr G 26:57
he's reading mesa. And he's phasers.
Dr Rad 27:01
Yeah, exactly. Yeah, exactly. And the linen rolls might be the thing, I suppose that maybe insulted but given that that temple which is erected in Rome, you know, live is not rubies, not Roman, is not renowned for going travelling for source material. But he's also not It's not impossible that he, you know, he
Dr G 27:24
sorted I suppose he moved on. He may. Yeah, maybe he went on a research jaunt.
Dr Rad 27:29
Maybe he did. We have we have done that.
Dr G 27:33
So I think that kind of wraps up this relatively complicated year of 444.
Dr Rad 27:40
It does. And even though we had all this threat of warfare live, he is very clear that actually things are pretty calm. Even though there are threats. There are threats, but there's no actual warfare.
Dr G 27:51
Yeah, it's kind of amazing how it seems that everything is built up in this sense of the threat coming from all directions. And yet, we don't hear anything about any of those enemies really advancing on Rome, and even our data sends ambassadors first. It's like, they're not going to war yet. They're having a preliminary discussion decide whether it's worth their time.
Dr Rad 28:11
Yeah, no, exactly. It is like, Oh, my God, the tension is built to such a feat of pitch and nothing and nothing nothing,
Dr G 28:18
which also may make one suspicious.
Dr Rad 28:21
Yeah, I think so. But, you know, we know that that's the kind of pattern that our accounts tend to follow the drama of it all indeed. Alright, so that means that Dr. G, I think it is time for
the personal pick covering for me that I left my phone in the other room.
Dr G 28:45
I am the sound effect.
Dr Rad 28:47
Alright, so our first category is Well, I hope you terrible. fifth category is military cloud
Dr G 29:01
military cloud. I think that's a big fat. Oh, look, let's explain where we office. Yeah, they could win. Rome could win 50 Golden Eagle. It could be very impressive. Yeah. Chances are they won't because I'm about to give them zero on the first category. That's right. No military clout whatsoever.
Dr Rad 29:17
No, there's none of that. Alright. Expansion.
Dr G 29:21
Oh, that's.
Dr Rad 29:23
Well, although, I mean, they do restore the treaty. But maybe they
Dr G 29:28
expand their mind.
Dr Rad 29:30
Diplomacy. Oh, well, I
Dr G 29:32
suppose the treaty does count as something and there is quite a diplomatic moment there isn't there?
Dr Rad 29:37
I think so. Yeah. Yeah. So I think maybe I mean, it it's a diplomatic moment that the room is a almost creating for themselves because they made such a terrible decision. I don't want to go too high. Yeah, but maybe a five. I think a five is good. Yeah. Okay. So we've got a five and
Dr G 29:54
also they kind of make that decision on the back of not wanting to upset the people that are already very upset.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/
Support the show
Patreon
Ko-Fi
Read our books
Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome
Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
The most famous assassination in Roman history took place during the Ides of March. Julius Caesar, dictator of Rome, was stabbed to death in Pompey's Senate House by a group of conspirators. What exactly were these men hoping to accomplish? Caesar had been taking up too much air-time and was changing the nature of the Republic into something suspiciously close to monarchy. Well, you can't have that! What are the other elite Roman men supposed to do if one man rules all?
Since 44 BCE, this assassination has inspired and perhaps plagued many political theorists, filmmakers, playwrights, artists, politicians, and historians. Dr G and Dr Rad sat down to talk about a twenty-first century example of the reverberations of Caesar's final moments across the centuries. The murder of Jon Snow in the season five finale of Game of Thrones was clearly modelled on the death of the Roman dictator.
Enjoy this mini bonus episode!
Mini Episode – Beware the Ides of Jon Snow…
If this episode tickles your fancy for a little more classical reception, we have explored lots of depictions of ancient Rome on film, which you might enjoy as well 🙂
Jon Snow and Ghost
Image courtesy of https://gartic.com.br/deanwinchester_/desenho-livre/jon-snow
Music by Bettina Joy de Guzman.
The Renaissance bust of Julius Caesar by Andrea di Pietro di Marco Ferrucci c. 1512-14 and a still of Kit Harrington as Jon Snow
For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/
Support the show
Patreon
Ko-Fi
Read our books
Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome
Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Rome seems to be an impasse. Facing war on all fronts and with escalating crisis between the patricians and the plebeians the place of Rome in the Italian world is at the brink. It’s 445 BCE and the republic is still young enough to fail. How will Rome face the chaos coming at them from outside while weakened from their own internal conflict? Tune in to find out!
Episode 123 – The Turning Point
In order to get Rome motivated for war, the internal problems need to be resolved first. What better time then for some of the more senior Romans (who also just happen to be patrician) to get together for a clandestine meeting… Some important decisions are reached but despite the secrecy of the meeting, it does not go unnoticed. Is Rome really more of an oligarchy than it likes to think it is?
On the other side of town, the tribune of the plebs, Gaius Canuelius, is getting fired up about the restrictive marriage laws that are part of the Twelve Tables. And boy does he have a speech to make about it! He digs deep into Rome’s history right back to the kings to explain to the plebeians how their exclusion from marriage to patricians is offensive. He explores the way Rome is in a process of constant adaption and change with examples to support his case that excluding plebeians is insupportable.
In a time of great struggle innovation becomes a necessity. With Rome facing threats from just about every direction, the consuls won’t be able to be everywhere they are needed commanding armies. Livy and Dionysius of Halicarnassus view the development of military tribunes with consular power as part of the patricians trying to placate the plebeians. But is there more to it than that? We delve into the background of the role, what it means for the structure of Roman governance, and compare the sources on the subject.
Thanks to BBC Sounds (Beta) for sound effects and the wonderful Bettina Joy de Guzman for our theme music.
Joseph Gandy c. 1830 – A Scene in Ancient Rome: A Setting for Titus Andronicus, I, ii.
An imagined view of Rome from a much grander period of history than what we’d expect to find in the fifth century BCE!
See this picture up close here.
We’re exploring transcription options! The transcript below was automatically generated by Descript and can also be accessed here. Hopefully those Latin names and places can still be understood!
Dr Rad00:01
Welcome to a brand new episode of the partial historians, where we trace the history of Rome from the founding of the city. I’m one of your hosts, Dr. Rad, and
Dr G00:12
I am Dr. G and we are in the thrilling year of 445.
Dr Rad00:18
Yeah. This is a big year. We’ve had a few years since 449, the year that never ended as we were talking about the second December and the 12 tables and the second succession and all that stuff is going on. Now, it comes to another bump that year. And it’s a really big year because there’s lots of gums going under it to G
Dr G00:37
there’s lots of conflict and how this conflict gets resolved. Fascinating. So we’re in the console ship of Marcus good nucleus and Gaia’s courteous Chilo or Kylo. And so far, we’ve had a bit of a situation where the Tribune of the plebs have come out and they’ve started to demand some pretty rigorous changes.
They want a marriage law change. And they would also like to have half the console ship, please.
Dr Rad01:08
Yes, very much about the land rights because of the marriage law they want changed is the second December it. And the 12 tables had added this ban on marriage between Patricia and simple beings. Seemingly part of this process that as patricians were sort of coring, more status and more power inside of room for themselves and way of doing that is obviously to make themselves.
Very special in terms of their bloodline. And of course the console ship deck, it’s like the most prestigious, obviously you can hold. Yeah.
Dr G01:37
And so, and the plebeians now want half, they, like, we want one console out of the two to be plebeian. Well, this throws the Senate and the current consoles into a bit of a tailspin.
And while they’re trying to cope with their feelings about. It turns out that just about everywhere around Roy is exploding with conflict and it’s coming for Rome. So we’ve got the Etruscans from veil coming down. We’ve got people from our data being annoyed about the way that their territory has just been claimed by Rome.
The previous year we’ve got the aqueous and the Wolski. Also quite irritated. And so Rome is facing war on just about every front and can imagine while at the same time facing this internal conflict with the attribute of the plebs refusing to allow the levy of the army to happen and to they get some, at least some preliminary decrees passed that are going to improve the lot of the plebeians over time.
Dr Rad02:39
Absolutely. So without further ado, Dr. G, let’s see how this whole situation revolves asset. So without further ado, Dr. G, let’s see how this whole situation resolves itself by checking out the wrist of 4 45 BC.
All right. So I left on quite a tense moment in my account where the consoles of throwing the toys out of the prime. And they’ve said that they would rather die than see, put beans in the console ship, the Tribune so said that they would rather die than not get this law. That’s going to overturn the marriage.
And demanding half of the console ship through, they’re not going to let people enlist in the army. So that’s a pretty,
Dr G03:24
everybody’s going to die.
Dr Rad03:25
Yeah. That’s not a great situation to be in what’s happening in Dionysius land.
Dr G03:30
Well, in dynasties of how it can asses the consoles have made the decision that in order to try and figure some of this stuff out, it’s probably a good time to have a private meeting with some key patricians okay.
They’re going to sneak off. Bit of a chat all by themselves. Now this is, I mean, having a private chat is not a bad thing. People can do that, but this is going to upset some people, one of the key people who is invited to attain this secret get together is Gaius Koreas.
Dr Rad04:03
Oh my gosh. I could just get through, I don’t know, six months without hearing a Claudius mentioned.
Dr G04:13
So guidance Claudius famously the uncle of the highly disgraced, uh, Appian Claudius of the December period.
Dr Rad04:23
He’s one of the guys that introduced this law apparently.
Dr G04:27
Well, well, well, fancy him being invited to the secret meeting.
Dr Rad04:32
I mean, sorry, obviously it’s introduced a little hot guys.
Dr G04:35
Yeah. So guys Cornelius is here and the Claudia are famed for being quite arrogant, um, highly traditional, uh, patrician.
Dr Rad04:44
Vintage patrician. Patricians that we love to hate.
Dr G04:50
And he’s a key motivating features in his speech in this private gathering is. And use violence isn’t necessary.
Dr Rad04:59
You know what? I could have seen that coming a mile away
Dr G05:03
shall be given to those Patricians. They go to a corrupt, everything, um, and they’ll ruin the ancient form of the government and people who oppose the ancient form of the government, uh, enemies of the state and alien.
Dr Rad05:23
Wow. Okay. Hang on a second. Hang on a second. Ancient form of the government. Are they forgetting that their public is only about 50 years old at this stage? Doesn’t matter. Doesn’t
Dr G05:33
matter, guys. Claudia’s is pretty keen on the idea. And you see this crop up with, um, groups that are highly nationalist. It’s like if you criticize us and you’re not.
Then you are against us and you’re our enemy and you’re not one of us. You are an alien to us. So it’s like, you can’t be part of the Inc group, unless you agree with exactly everything that we’ve already
Dr Rad05:57
done. Yeah. Which is a huge problem in today’s society as well. Because if you don’t learn to talk to and compromise with people who are different to you, we are never going to fix the very serious challenges that face our world.
Dr G06:13
Yes. Well, Gaia’s Claudius today would be helping nobody. Um, this meeting continues, uh, he sits down and he said his peace. Uh, he gets to talk pretty much first because he’s one of the oldest guys around and being an Accordi I’m sure he would put his case. Totally. And then we have Titus Queens. Stand
Dr Rad06:33
up.
Yeah. Is this capital land? This guy,
Dr G06:36
this is, yeah. Try squint his capital on his boat bottles. So when you imagine this guy, you have to imagine he’s got a nice beard. Yeah. He gets up, he was the console of 4 46. Um, so you guys successful? Yeah. It does have a right to. And he’s also held the console ship four times hugely popular as a console.
Absolutely. And he says that violence is probably not the answer because that would be civil bloodshed. Um, yeah,
Dr Rad07:03
we kind of need the people to fight out numerous entities. I mean, remember how we were all panicking a minute ago, because we’ve got three different. France to
Dr G07:12
deal with. And he’s like, we can assume that that’s not our ideal.
Um, if we kill them and they fight for us, I can’t assume we can
Dr Rad07:22
assume. That’s not going to say about assumptions.
Dr G07:26
Never assume. Never say. And he’s also black, notably, we’re always going to be opposed by the tribunes. Yes. Um, you know, they are sacrifice. In many respects and they swim very serious. Oh. So we have to take all of that into account.
We can’t just wait in there and do the yield. Nothing use violence, if necessary attitude sort of approach. That’s not going to work here. It’s not going to get us what we want.
Dr Rad07:55
This is why this guy’s popular because whilst he is completely patrician through and through at least he’s smart. Yeah. He’s not an idiot and he’s not so hotline.
That yeah. Violence is the main thing that he’s going to suggest,
Dr G08:09
but white Ford then Claudius is like, okay, look, I take your point. Uh, which is pretty big of him to be honest. Cause usually it doesn’t take anybody
Dr Rad08:18
to make maybe the fact that, you know, Accurus was murdered or died by suicide, his dad and his enthusiasm.
Dr G08:28
It was trying to temper himself. Yeah, exactly. And it’s a private meeting, so he feels like he can speak openly. I’m not unaware of the great calamities that we face just to put it out there. And I think it’s important that every man should be able to say. About what he thinks will be to, uh, to the advantage of the state.
Um, and then we’ll have the decision made by the majority. Now that’s weird. They were in a private meeting of select patricians and consoles. They’re like a secret meeting. There’s a secret meeting and he’s like, well, as long as we all agree and the majority comes to a decision, that’s
Dr Rad09:06
fine. Is he need, does he need the Senate?
Does he mean like the widest Senate or it’s not at all clear. Surely he doesn’t mean. No,
Dr G09:13
no, no. He means Patricia. Um, and he then goes on to say, Only the patricians are alone, are qualified by both law and ritual practice to
Dr Rad09:25
hold the console ship. Ah, I see. So, okay. So Danny says, essentially put the words that are in Livy as like a general comment from the patricians about their special position in society into the mouth of someone specific.
Yeah, it was horrifying who it matches the reputation of his family.
Dr G09:47
Further to this. He’s like, what about if we propose an alternative?
Dr Rad09:54
Uh, ha lessening listening. Here
Dr G09:57
we go. What if instead of the two consoles, we appoint six military tribunes with consular power.
Dr Rad10:08
Ah, I see. You’re you’re you’re jumping ahead of me.
Okay. Yeah.
Dr G10:13
Only three of them could be patrician. And the other three could be plebeian.
Dr Rad10:19
I don’t for one hot second, I believe that a Claudia suggested I sorry,
Dr G10:24
but then wait for the rationale. The beauty of this is that we offer them consular power without debasing the consulate position.
Dr Rad10:38
How is that not debating, is
Dr G10:40
it because instead of invoke, instead of voting in, in the next year, instead of voting in two consoles, it’s like, let’s vote in six military tribunes with concierge
Dr Rad10:51
power, right.
I actually mean cause the title is different. The title is different. Yeah.
Dr G10:56
And some stuff about that is going to be very specific and interesting and different as well. So that’s the teaser of. I’ll stop there. Okay. I see what Libby has to say.
Dr Rad11:07
Well, see, this is where the differences in our account, make it a little tricky to tell a cohesive story, because as we talked about last episode, Libby does talk about these sorts of issues and I will get to where you’re up to, but he’s also very concerned about the intermediary,
Dr G11:28
but wait up guys, what about the intermarriage
Dr Rad11:31
law?
Which makes sense because everything that they’re using as an argument for opposing plebeians in the console ship, or that idea about purity and prestige of the patrician. Cos, if you want to call them that eats very much what they’re worried about with intermarriage as well. So prepare yourself to JT.
There is a beanbag in this room
Dr G11:54
because well, I have to put my face
Dr Rad11:56
into it when you might have to fall into it. Oh, faint. Because levy has a long speech. Oh yeah. Oh, I’m excited.
Dr G12:05
Now one speech. This is unprecedented.
Dr Rad12:09
It’s really. Okay, but I think it’s important because he doesn’t often have these sorts of speeches.
So it’s also putting the mouth of the Tribune of the plebs, the one who had apparently proposed the bill to overturn the marriage ban and to put for beans into the console ship can no less. So he dresses the people at this very tense moment where neither side seems like they’re going to give in, you know, life or death.
It’s just like, no, we’re not going to do this. So he starts talking to the people and says, The patricians clearly hate plebeians. I mean, why else would they make our lives so difficult? Now look, maybe the majority of Roman people don’t have the same amount of money that the patricians have, but at the end of the day, we have Romans too.
We live here too. This is our town. Oh, where requests. First and foremost is the right of intermarriage, which he, interestingly notes, people who aren’t from Rome could be granted. So yeah, enemies, that room had defeated. They’re allowed to marry. Patricians gross. What about the blood lines? But this is what he’s pointing out is patricians are able to marry.
People who aren’t Ruben who are even defeated, enemies, been one earth, shouldn’t the plebeians have that same, right? Why are the consoles and the patricians and the centers all getting so upset? Why they even making threats? I get the, I guess, the Sacra sanctuary of the trivia, which has only just been restored in the aftermath of the second December and the second session, 12 tables and all of that, you know, why, why are they finding this?
So. Ah, and oh, I’m not anyway needs anyway. Need done? Good. You ladies wonders. Eighth of the beans had actually realized just how little respect the patricians really.
Dr G14:15
I’m pretty sure they’ve realized
Dr Rad14:17
time for a reality check can kind of be brutal. I’m going to be brutal. So he’s pointing out that the way that they’ve responded to this request about the concert.
It’s almost as though they’ve asked to put a slave or a Friedman in command to the state. So it disgusted the patricians. And so he’s like, do you get that? That’s like insulting. Like they called you a month, you know, do you, do you get that? Because if you don’t, I’m here to bring reality to you. So the patricians he claimed.
The goal in life is to take everything from a even, and this is just hilarious thing would take the sunshine away if they could. Oh, that’s quite poetic. So Patricia essentially start asking you, at least as concerned, resent the existence of the pavilions. They resent them, the oxygen, they breathe, they resent their right of speech.
They resent the fact that they look the same. We call them, tell them a book, Sterling. Yeah, it’s all terrible. And they just hate them through and through. And this is why he starts going into some interesting backstory as well. He’s asking about the fact that the pole beans, if they’re not allowed to do things like consult the phone, All the commentaries of the pontiffs, then that knowledge is being held from them.
And again, apparently knowledge that even foreign is, could potentially access more easily than I have some
Dr G15:48
pretty big questions for Olivia. At this point, I feel like it’s very unlikely that they’re going to allow foreigners to rock up and have a look at the sacred texts that relate to the participant.
And then just go away
Dr Rad15:59
again. Listen, this is exactly it. I mean, who knows if maybe they’re talking about like during particular ceremonies, but yet it’s interesting that he makes that, that comment, maybe you can, at least is getting a little carried away here, but anyway,
Dr G16:15
we’re talking about the Etruscans possibly have a right to have a look at those books because they were part of them being written
Dr Rad16:21
and they’re also better at interpreting science apparently.
So, yeah, that’s what I mean, like. Who knows who the who’s been invited in to have a peak foreign dignitaries and
Dr G16:34
want to check out
Dr Rad16:34
my secret text. And this is where he starts going all the way back to the Regal period. So he’s really digging deep here. He’s pointing out something that we noted when we covered.
Time period. Roman Kings could come from anywhere. In fact, they generally weren’t Patricia, some academics and this is, this is not
Yeah. So that academics have even suggested that one of the, uh, CA uh, I don’t know when you say one of the categories for the thinking was not to be a patrician. Ah, you know, that they actually had to come from outside the country. So, yeah, that’s, that’s even been suggested, but certainly we know that how you would sustain that as a theory.
No, I’m just saying like it’s being theorized. And so, yeah, I agree with him. Certainly we know a lot of the Kings were not Roman, you know, so, you know, new mom came from say bind territory and therefore a lot of them also weren’t patricians and, you know, Soviet choice apparently was, you know, from a defeated at any such site background,
Dr G17:39
let’s just be logical for a moment.
Um, the trouble with this kind of argument is that RO emergent. As a state that is cobbled together from the surrounding areas. That’s the story it tells about itself. Of course, the Kings aren’t patricians cause the Patricia that is created in the Regal period by the Kings and those Kings have to come from somewhere and they can’t come from Rome because Rome
Dr Rad18:07
isn’t a thing.
Ah, but he also points out that the Colombians themselves weren’t Raven, they have not, now they know that. Yeah. But they came about after. Yeah. After the Patricia apparently would have started to be created. If we accept that Romulus started the Patricia, which is okay, dubious, because he knows the Romulus existed.
But let’s say for argument’s sake that the propitiation did have his origins under Romulus. The Colombians don’t come along under Romulus. There saved my family to come along later. And he’s he’s point is that if people can. Be incorporated and recognize for that excellence and become patricians. What about the people that live here?
And this is ridiculous. Like we should only, we should just be prioritized. Excellent. You know, look at the, you know, look, uh, Lucius stuck when you use Crisco. So you look at these people who are recognized for being excellent and ruled Rome and nothing disastrous happened when you had an outsider ruling road.
That’s his point, I suppose, I get where you’re coming from, but that’s his major points, I suppose. Um, and so, yeah, he, he cites all these previous Kings is, you know, fantastic examples. So clearly they must have for bands in past. Because otherwise you’re going to get people like the second December it coming back again, like it’s just inevitable that there are going to be terrible people coming to power.
Again, you need to have a check on that, I think. Okay. And he also points out that. Okay. So let’s say that this is the situation we’ve got. Outreach to argue that Rome never changes, never adapts is Rome just going to stay exactly how it is right at this moment and never alter anything. Like that’s not, that’s not good government.
I mean, it’s bad policy. And he says he points out all the things, all the things that have made Rome better. So new Matt introduced. And Sophia’s Twilio is the king. He introduced the census apparently and reorganized Rome, and that made run better gradually in their Republic. Dictators were introduced.
You had the addition of we’ll be interviewing. So, I mean, that’s not an argument’s going to continue convincing patricians, but he thinks that that’s a good addition. You also had a dolls and questers all these additional offices where. And you had the destined verse. They came in, they were terrible.
They’re gone. Rome changes, Rome changes. And you know what, it’s generally something that is for the better, but Patricia is in the background.
unless it benefits us in which case we’re all for it. Yeah. So he’s talking about the fact that. It’s such an insult that there, that this idea that there, the patrician blood was somehow be polluted, especially considering that a lot of them come from places like Alba and say buying territory. Whereas a lot of the food beans, allegedly, uh, bull and bread, my friend born bread in Rome.
Not everybody can say that they are, you know, totally natives and he’s like, can’t, they just maintain their status and appears you and all that kind of stuff. And. Can I be into marriage? Like, is that, is that really so inconceivable that yeah. Say the Patricia needs conceivable. Yeah, exactly. Um, and so he says, you know, why not?
Why not just take it further? Why not introduce a law where you ban marriage between rich and poor? I mean, essentially that’s always been the way it’s worked. Hasn’t it? It’s not like rich guys are marrying poor chicks and vice versa. Why not take it even further. Why not ban Patricia to me even living near Cobain or even Ben, and from walking down the same road, I find this fascinating because this is so similar to like segregation in say, you know, America or Australia in terms of what happened.
Uh, African-Americans and indigenous Australians. It is like disturbing that what he’s essentially saying is this is the beginning of segregation. Yeah. This is what is
Dr G22:12
the logical conclusion of the thing that the patricians are arguing for. This is the
Dr Rad22:16
start and this is where it’s going to add. Yeah.
Okay. I’m going to wrap up NASA, be relieved. He points out that to finish. We need to think about this. We kicked out the king. And apparently the point of that was that old Romans would have equal Liberty. That was the point of establishing the Republic. Allegedly. Now the patricians have assumed so much power.
I mean, is there equal, does he easily petite and right. Or are the patricians calling all the shots, all the room and people in command of this. No, I don’t think so. I think so. Shouldn’t the Roman people be allowed to introduce bores. Isn’t that the whole point of what just happened a few years ago. Okay.
In that, what we decided that, you know, Pauline decisions were going to be binding on everybody or should the patricians be able to bring in a levee in retaliation every time they propose a piece of law and now. We don’t think that that’s necessarily what they were doing right now. I think there is legitimately some military problems on the horizon, but they have done it in the cost.
Yes, I can. I can understand
Dr G23:35
rousing speech
Dr Rad23:41
So the petitions have already shown that when the plebeians you not light during the time to the succession. So the first session and for. Second secession in 4 49, the patricians have shown that they have, I haven’t got to like to stand on. And this is where I’m going to take a slight side note. We’ve talked about this, the sessions before in the sense that they are really interesting because even though the beans surely must vastly outnumber the patricians, even though the Patricia, okay.
Might be a significant number of people considering the population of room at this time. Well, that’s all highly speculative because we don’t know how many people are living in Rome at this time. Surely that the beans outnumber them because that’s the whole point of being part of an elite. Okay. You’re part of a minority and yet they’ve never resorted to, um, struggle.
Like they’ve gotten close, but generally they just kind of opt out and do their own thing. You know, it’s really, he’s really interesting. So by this point in time, but the beans really are kind of developing this interesting. Parallel culture. Some people have even dumped in as being like a state within the state because by this stage they’ve actually set up their own archive system where they actually start like depositing Rick, their own records, which is something that the Patricia will something that will be incorporated into the Roman state as a whole, you know, like some of the, a lot of their ideas and their innovations will eventually be worked into the Roman system.
So it is kind of interesting that they have developed. Yeah, this idea. And it is interesting that once again, they’re talking about the fact that we just need to stand up and oppose them. We don’t necessarily even need to fight them. We just need to stand United. The beans are of course, prepared to fight in this war, which faces numerous France, but cannula is determined that they’re only going to get it.
If they get those two things, the ban being overturned. And access to the government via the concept ship. If they get the demands they want, he was coming up the boom up. And if not, nobody is going to enlist because quite frankly, why should they, they are being treated like debt.
Dr G26:00
Oh,
Dr Rad26:02
thank you. Thank you. I read it myself, myself.
All right.
Dr G26:09
So I assume that the beans are going to react well to this speech.
Dr Rad26:13
I actually don’t have much of a reaction from the liens because we go straight into the reaction of one of the console. Oh no. Okay. So can you listen, turns around, ask the console. So tell me why. Why are you going to be so mean again?
Why
Dr G26:31
would you say all of those
Dr Rad26:32
things in public really hurt my feelings? Yeah. Courteous responded that once again, we got to go back to this ID off the auspices and he uses the word that I really love. And again, it seems very hard punch to me. You also, this, this would be confounded people being stride to undertake them.
It has to be a patrician. This
Dr G26:51
just feels like a really filthy argument from Libby. I have to say.
Dr Rad26:55
There is a different lady or is it from the horrible Patricia?
Dr G26:59
I mean, it’s coming through and Livy. I get no hint of it at all in Dionysus of how can I say,
Dr Rad27:06
because I have the spirit Libby and funnily enough, he makes a little note.
Cody’s probably should’ve read the room that wasn’t really probably the best moment to bring that up, which I love because of course for the hands are absolutely for your ears at that’s the response after that huge speech that can, Elise has gone through. Exactly. He’s the planes are at race because they’re like, okay.
So not only do you think that we are the scum between your toes? But now you’re also suggesting that the gods just us, that we can’t possibly
Dr G27:41
screw you, buddy role of your
Dr Rad27:43
friends. Yeah. The building’s attributes are therefore locked into their position. They are incredibly determined, but they’ve been insulted too many times.
The patricians given. Wow. Just like that. What? Just like that? Yeah. They loud the ban on into marriage to be overturned. On the understanding that they’re hoping that the whole thing about the console ship will just be forgotten
Dr G28:08
about. So what, they just don’t say anything about that?
Dr Rad28:11
Well, no, they just like, okay.
We agree into marriage should be allowed. And just, we’ll just we’ll think about the other thing later. We’ve got to deal with the war and now for the lovey. Yes. Now of course the Philippines have only just gained a massive confidence boost.
Dr G28:31
Yeah. So if you’ve agreed to number one, what about your agreement?
Number two,
Dr Rad28:36
you need, we just have to give a really long speech. Well, we could have done that a long time. Well, Libby. Yeah. So they are totally, I totally got an energy boost from this overturning all of the marriage man. And they thought, well, you know, I think, I think we can, maybe I think we can maybe hold out, you know, I think maybe we can, we can keep fighting.
We can keep pushing for the console ship, you know, let’s,
Dr G29:04
let’s see one cliff, maybe we’ll jump off
Dr Rad29:06
the other and the councils aren’t able to get anything through the Senate at this point in time, because allegedly the tribunes are prepared to use their theater. Now you and I have flagged this before as being problematic.
To be honest as we’ve, as we’ve highlighted, the way that the circle of the orders is laid out is super problematic in terms of when they get certain rights, the whole position of the Tribune, it’s hard to figure out what they actually would have had in terms of their powers at this point in time, as opposed to what Lydia assumes, they had all the analysts who are, who Lydia is basing his count on.
Yeah, I think they probably assuming that the tribunes have. The power more power than they probably have. But nonetheless, this is why they turn to a private meeting with the consoles and other leading men in the status and narratives. So they begin to power a little badly. I told you we get there eventually.
And so in the private meeting, and I start talking about the fact that look, we’re either going to have a civil war now. Or we’re going to be conquered by the numerous entities that are out at our gates right now. And the interesting thing to note here is that all X console seem to be involved in this meeting except for the Larry’s and Heraclitus oh yes.
This
Dr G30:26
will come up in Dionysius
Dr Rad30:28
as well. Yes. Um, and so hilarious. And Bharatiya sister reminds you guys, these were, these guys are patrician through and through. But they were patricians that could see that the second December were tyrants and that the power that they held in, the position that they held in the state was problematic.
And they also could see, as you pointed out the common sense or not wanting the plebeians to secede from the state of Roni, go and live elsewhere and start their own band.
Dr G30:56
Yeah. These are the two guys that go out when the, when the plebeians do succeed and go and have a chat to them. They’re like, Look, we know it’s not okay.
And we’re going to do our best, let us lead you. And so they come across as monitoring.
Dr Rad31:13
Patricians and they also introduced the laws after the second December and the second session to sort of restore things like, so they were the distributor, they restored certain rights to the plebs and distributing.
And so yeah, they, they seen as being kind of tops flight
Dr G31:27
into the secret
Dr Rad31:28
meeting. so interesting. It’s room seems to be just like so segregated right now, but anyway, and that’s where I come in to the whole thing with guys, Claudia. At also capital liners, having their discussions. Exactly. As you said, you know, one of them suggesting let’s just fight, let’s just kill them all.
And the other one saying maybe not, maybe not civil bloodshed God. Yeah, exactly. And that is where we get the introduction of this new position, military tribunes with consular authority, which we made up of patricians and proving. But the console shape of course will remain unchanged in terms of like who’s allowed to hold that so that it won’t be corrupted.
And this decision very much appeases the tribunes and the plebs in my account. How do they feel in your account?
Dr G32:18
Oh, okay. So this is just the first in a moment of grand deception as it were. So they have this secret meeting where clueless. Guys Claudia. So of all people is the one who makes this a sort of suggestion that we have these military tribunes with consular power.
Now listen, as if you’re hearing this and you’re like, but what does that even mean? Uh, fair enough. Uh, what this means. Is when they organize, uh, the Roman army. So when they do a levy, part of what happens is they make a selection within the people that have been levied. That song will be military tribunes.
Yes. Now the numbers for this very, and we’re not sure, it depends on the time period. Uh, records are scattered at best, but there’s usually between three to six military tribunes poorly. Yeah, so they kind of like an organizational structure and then you can, you can be patrician or you could be poor band and you could be a military Tribune.
Yeah. It just depends on how the levy happens. And this seems to be a selection process, but whoever is fighting within that Legion, some of those people will end up being military patients with some degree. Of responsibility to report back to the generals who would be the consoles at this point, and then to like sort of distribute, uh, the sort of orders as they come down.
Dr Rad33:43
Yeah. And suddenly exactly, as you just slacked right there. It’s also important to note that the console shape really was not just a political position at this point in time. It definitely is a military military position. You can’t, you can’t split facing support in room at this
Dr G33:57
point in time. Yeah. The cultural shift is military.
Uh, political and ritual in nature, and most Magister sees ends up having a, sort of a sacred aspect to them in the way that they’re performed. Um, and it’s no different for the console shit. And so, but the military Tribune is kind of just like a functional leadership position within Allegion, so that don’t necessarily have any sort of ritual ties.
Um, and it can be held by anybody. Usually an experienced soldier at a certain point might go on to be a military tribute. So they take this concept that they’ve already got embedded and they’re like, well, what if we take that idea? And we expanded out and we give them, uh, Cancilla power. So this is in the political sense to a certain degree, but mostly in the military sense and probably not a what on the ritual side.
So it’s this ability to sort. Be a leader, make decisions for the cohorts that you’re looking after. And by placing them as the top magistracy in, in place of the console ships. So you wouldn’t have consoles and military tributes with Cancilla power. You either have one or the other. They sort of allowing console a power to be distributed down the line a little bit amongst a greater number of people.
And
Dr Rad35:21
this is really interesting because if we think about how academics have interpreted, what is going on in this period, certainly the suggestions has been that this, this time period around 44, 4 45, Really important for Rome in that it almost seems like Rome is actually just restructuring and talking about to collapse.
Yeah. It seems like there are new challenges potentially facing room. Um, possibly because they have made a name for themselves in the area, made some enemies and it’s not going down well, but for whatever reason, There does seem to be a need underlying this decision, which might not be actually anything to do with the struggle of the audience.
So, yeah, and this, this is what’s interesting because we like our sources play it up as being very much about Patricia investments for being anything, but actually might just be Rams and clever. It
Dr G36:13
might just be a practical decision to deal with the threat that they currently face. Yes, they have enemies on all sides of this.
It is a problem. They do need some solutions and if they only. To consoles. They technically can only divide up their forces in
Dr Rad36:31
two different directions. Yeah. And at the same time in 4 46 questers were brought in, uh, which is, it’s not something brand new. Exactly. But the way that they were sort of brought back.
Um, you know, for the needs of the state, apparently I haven’t been around for a while. And also just looking ahead a little bit in 4 43, we’re going to see the resurrection of this Institute. So it does seem like there’s a whole bunch of offices that are being either like resurrected rebranded, re yeah.
Oh, this restructuring is going on around these periods. So it is a really crucial period for Rome. Yeah.
Dr G37:07
And I think we can see this as part of the broader sense in the way that the consequences of the December it playing out as well, because that is also a structure that is
Dr Rad37:17
about
Dr G37:17
instability. Yeah. And we’re seeing that instability continue.
It seemed like they’d sort of swept it aside a little bit, but it seems like they haven’t gotten out of. And now things have come to a head again, and they’ve had to come up with a new way to navigate themselves through a difficult period. And so this military tribute it with the lot power is going to be this new group.
This is their new idea to solve a problem that they’re currently facing, which seems to be mostly a military thing. Um, so we’ll see how that pans out for them. But anyway, we’ve got this. Alongside both sort of considerations is the kind of literary narrative which has really betrayed. This is about the Kloss struggle.
Yes. So Claudius comes out of this, um, uh, suggestion that they have this new position and that’s exciting, but then he says, let’s go in with a plan we’re going to need to, so this to the people first, we need to pass the preliminary decree in the Senate. Then we need to give the floor to anybody who wants to see.
But let’s decide who’s going to speak here. I’m not going to start either. Is queen tedious? Uh, my, my good friend Quinty is who suggested that civil bloodshed might be a little bit disastrous. Let’s why don’t we start with Lucy is hilarious. And immediately after him, friend of the popular. we’re going to load those two to speak first.
They haven’t been invited to this meeting at all. They’re just,
Dr Rad38:49
we’re going to use them and abuse them.
Dr G38:52
And now they can say whatever they want, whatever. Wow. And then all come up and speak and I’ll do my usual speech about, you know, where I’m a traditional patrician and this is what I want, et cetera, et cetera.
And then, then we’ll get tied to school. The console’s brother. So we’re in the year. What? 4 45 Marcus gooky is the console. We’ll get his brother Titus to stand up and Hugh propose the measure about the military tribunes with consular power. We’ll get him to do it. This
Dr Rad39:23
is so orchestrated. Yeah,
Dr G39:27
we’ll get, we’ll get, uh, Marcus canoe.
He to be like, look, I think my brother wants to speak. Let’s get him up here. And. That’s how we’re going to play this because by the time we get through those two moderate, patricians having their say, um, and sort of trying to get people to, to do what they need to do in the nicest way. Possible me being an asshole.
They’ll definitely buy it coming from. Wow.
Dr Rad39:51
This is crazy. This is so different when I have this
Dr G39:54
secret meeting is full of plaid. Yeah. Now the tributes rightly a highly suspicious of this secret patrician meeting with the council, of course. And so they’re like, we need to have a strategy as well. So they get together with their allies and they’re like, well, let’s have our own private meeting show and they start out by like, okay.
So whatever they do, we just have to, we just have to say, no,
Dr Rad40:19
basically it’s kind of in a way,
Dr G40:23
what could they possibly be doing? We just have to say no. So they have, we move into the execution of guys, coy. This is planned. Right.
Dr Rad40:32
Okay.
Dr G40:33
And they have the preliminary decree me. And then we have guys can utilize Tribune of the plebs finally comes forward.
And he’s like, I wonder though, about this secret meeting that’s been had and why weren’t Valerius and her audience invite. You know, our
Dr Rad40:54
a fair question. These are the
Dr G40:56
patricians that are most, uh, willing to, to side with the plebeians.
Dr Rad41:01
You and I know why I think everybody knows why,
Dr G41:05
but please know that Gaia’s Courtney says master plan has already taken that into account.
Yeah. And so. They take clearly says speech where he’s like, look, it’s not, it’s not, it’s not okay. Uh, for those two who are so great and lauded in their positions to have been left out of whatever secret meeting you’ve been having, it’s not okay. And I guess they’ve been left out because you’re trying to screw us over and then they have the beautiful moment where the Patricia.
Oh, oh, well, why don’t we let them speak
Dr Rad41:41
first? Wow. How many kilos now?
Dr G41:46
Volaris and varieties haven’t been let into this secret net, like
Dr Rad41:51
Patricia, just speaking off the
Dr G41:52
cuff, just speak off the cuff. Yeah. And they try to do what is, what seems most appropriate. Apparently hilarious makes a long speech, but Dionysus of pallet Kinesis, thankfully doesn’t give it to us.
Just tells us that there’s a little. Any kind of hopes, um, that we’ll be able to move forward and we’ll be able to work together as a state. And, you know, we’re only, um, as equal as, as we act. So, you know, we all have to act
Dr Rad42:25
together. Awesome.
Dr G42:29
And, you know, and having a law that gives a share of the pencil ship to all Romans, um, those who have lived irreproachable lives and performed actions worthy of honor, they do serve this.
Uh, but he also winds up by saying, but you know, what’s important here is that we have war on all fronts that we’re facing. So we should probably leave the decision about. Until after the war,
Dr Rad43:00
if I say I haven’t been here.
Dr G43:02
So he does a lot of sort of nice sort of like. I’m
Dr Rad43:07
with you. You deserve this, but just, can we just press pause?
Can we just,
Dr G43:12
I, and it’s me, it’s coming from me, the moderate Patricia. And so, and then Harati has gets up and he’s like, look hilarious. Who’s being very wise here. You know, of course, it’s true that you deserve this and we should definitely look into it, but please, please, please just go on. Fine. Just go flat.
Yeah, just this. It’s going to be important that we do this. This proposal is a great tool by everybody, but everyone is angry about it. So we have this moment where Dionysius lets us know that, um, because it’s postponed through means are like, okay, you’ve convinced us that we need to postpone it, but I’m pretty angry about having to do that.
Not only that. The patricians conservative. Patricians angry about this because basically these two Valerius neurotic have said we’ll make it. So after the
Dr Rad44:10
war, they were
Dr G44:12
counting on that. So they’re like, well, we’re agreeing because it means that we’ll go to the wool, which we really need to do right now.
Oh, pissed off about that. Now I’m going to have to deal with this thing all over again after the war.
Dr Rad44:28
So I wouldn’t have that content clay. I wouldn’t have the wall press the issue.
Dr G44:32
Yeah. So basically these two manage to enrage everybody in, into agreeing with them, but being frustrated by that at the same time Harati is Gaius Claudia steps out to do he’s prepared speech.
Of being a douchebag
Fancy seeing the smell of shit in front of me. Once
Dr Rad45:00
again,
Dr G45:03
he says yes, that the law should be refused all together. And he’s like, that’s a dumb plan. We should go to that war and we should not do that thing afterwards. You know why? Because it’s the right Patricia and thing to do. And no one will be able to tell me otherwise, Thank you very much.
That’s guys bloating. You can find me in my Villa,
Dr Rad45:25
which one? Which one?
Dr G45:27
So that’s annoying. So guys, Claudia says speechies met with outrage
Dr Rad45:34
as planned though,
Dr G45:35
as planned opening the way for who else, but Titus good news is we like gods. There’s a third way. And people like what? It’s not just war and no, no, uh, sort of reward in return for just fighting all the time, because there’s a third way.
And he’s like, yes, yes. Think about
Dr Rad46:00
it the
Dr G46:01
middle way we could have wait for it because nobody’s ever suggested this before. Military tribunes with consular power and people like, no matter what now, the who to what, and everybody loves it. Even the tribunes are kind of like, well, that’s not a hot, bad idea.
Right?
Dr Rad46:22
Okay. So this is where our narratives is sinking up again. Okay, good, good, good, good.
Dr G46:27
Not a half bad idea. And the people love it. They’re like, oh my God
Dr Rad46:35
wagon. I get our sharing power, um, heard
Dr G46:39
of, but this might also be the cliffhanger moment. Okay. To wind
Dr Rad46:44
up this epic.
Dr G46:45
Or as well, I feel like if I go further now,
Dr Rad46:48
fair enough.
Fair enough. Look, we can, we can leave it there. So we’re wrapping up on this cliff, hang a moment where we’re on the brink of potentially introducing a shared plebeian patrician system, overruling Rome. We have to see how this is obviously going to play out in practice, but if we strip it back and put our academic hats on.
I think we can both agree. This probably isn’t really anything to do with this truck, the orders, and actually what’s going on is based on the archeology based on what we can see happening throughout this entire decade. So going all the way from the December all the way through the fall. I think we can say that Rome is an absolute crisis.
You know, there’s obviously economic issues is obviously military and political issues going on. Rome is in real trouble. And this is a restructuring of the state. I think of some of some. So there might have been an element of who’s going to take what role now, but the idea of it being part of the struggle of the orders is probably, actually not quite the headline.
That lady and Dionysius and potentially their sources believed it was
Dr G47:55
maybe not. We definitely got a crisis of some kind, definitely. And the fact that we’re getting to a point where the elite patricians, uh, coming to the table with a suggestion to share power, I think might suggest that there is something, there are rumblings coming from below, which can no longer be ignored.
Absolutely. How that plays out. We will
Dr Rad48:21
see, I think that there is, I think there is trouble in Rome at this point in time. And the patricians have accrued so much power by this point that they are kind of taking the lead in terms of how to fix it, how to address it, that they’re trying to still hold on to their monopoly of power in this time of crisis.
And I think that’s where you get the rumblings from below, because as is often pointed out in the scholarship, the Cobain’s generally. Act at this point of time in terms of protecting themselves and defending themselves, I don’t often go on the aggressive, like everything they’d done, it might seem aggressive.
And that’s how our sources want to play me when it to play out in terms of leaving dynasties and the troopers. But they’re reacting, they’re reacting. They’re always reacting and. Then not setting out to challenge their leaders, but certainly if there is this time of crisis, I think it’s understandable that there would be questions asked about who should be leading room, you know, and who should have a say if there is this problem going on.
So definitely I think the struggle with the audience has played off, but I can totally see that there would be an element of, well who plays the, what now in this whole conversation that’s happening. So it will be interesting to see. What room looks like on the other side. And with that in mind, Dr. Jay it’s time to go to Vic.
Alrighty, sir. This is where we get to rank room, according to his own values. Dr. Jay. Tell us how it works. Ooh.
Dr G49:56
So we have 50 golden Eagles up for grabs across five categories. We will give them a score in each of those categories out of 10 and together we will see how Rome has performed according to its own values.
All right.
Dr Rad50:13
So the first category is military collapse.
Dr G50:16
Ooh. I don’t think we’ve even levied an army
Dr Rad50:18
properly yet, which is interesting actually, because again, At this point in time, serving in the army would have been a real mark of distinction. So it is interesting that that. The thing that they chew. I mean, it is a good weapon to use, but yeah, it’s
Dr G50:34
interesting.
I think it depends on the nature of the conflict. If it’s one that the Senate has maybe made up, I think, I guess the trouble is how do you know if the enemy is truly surrounding you or whether somebody is telling you a whole pack of lies? Those guys they’re just herding sheep
Dr Rad50:55
about that. All right. So no military cloud, no expansion.
I think it will say. And that’s a no, that’s a no that they’re going to be fighting to defend their territory. Once again, diplomacy. Ah, there is some internal diplomacy going on here. There does seem to, yeah, I mean, it’s very manipulative,
Dr G51:12
as Courtney says, counting plan
Dr Rad51:16
mean
Dr G51:16
in a way it is diplomatic. He is now offering.
Something well beyond anything that has ever been offered to the plebeians before,
Dr Rad51:26
and also in my account, the patricians have made concessions about the marriage
Dr G51:33
voted. I’m going home to
Dr Rad51:37
bury that. Oh my God, there’s a, um,
I turned know off. You can call that to play in this either. They literally just gave him maybe a two, I think a two. Okay. So that’s a two we’re tourists. Oh, not really getting it. I mean, there’s a lot of rhetoric going on, but there’s
Dr G51:58
a lot of rhetoric going on and I’d say that maybe if we take the pot of a very conservative patrician white guys, Claudius coming up with a grand and cunning plan might be considered quiet,
Dr Rad52:12
man.
it doesn’t feel safe to man. It feels quite underhanded. I’m willing to give him a one and that’s it. All right. All right. So that’s a three. Okay. Five school is the citizen school. Well, this actually is good. Well,
Dr G52:31
things have been improved remarkably. Yeah. They’re allowed to Colombians and Patricia is now allowed to marry.
Dr Rad52:39
And apparently I think they always were up until December or something around that time. But.
Dr G52:48
And then with this potential for a military tribute with Consolo power is actually quite significant. That’s a big
Dr Rad52:55
step up. Yeah. And then we we’re living under the cliffhanger in terms of what room will look like and how this will play out.
But definitely change has been achieved. That’s definitely been changed chief. So I am almost willing to give it a 10, but wow. Is that going too far? I mean, there is still a war on all fronts. Maybe an eight is safer. Let’s
Dr G53:15
go with nine. Let’s go for that safe. I care.
Dr Rad53:17
That means that we end up Dr. Deanna grand, total of 12 goal and ego.
That’s impressive because there was a lot of really objectionable material in that episode. That is double what they
Dr G53:31
scored for the previous episodes. It’s impressive.
Dr Rad53:34
You know, I think the difference. There’s a lot of Cobain talk, not so much Patricia chit-chat that’s the case. All right. Well, join us next time to see exactly how this potentially sharing of power goes on in Romania.
Dr G53:51
How’s this going to work?
Dr Rad53:53
Yeah, this is a new world for Rome. This is jealousy is to be turning point for rearing. So, so exciting.
Dr G53:58
Yeah, forget consuls. It’s now military tribunes with consular power.
Dr Rad54:01
If you think it sounds like a mouthful because it is.
Rome seems to be an impasse. Facing war on all fronts and with escalating crisis between the patricians and the plebeians the place of Rome in the Italian world is at the brink. It’s 445 BCE and the republic is still young enough to fail. How will Rome face the chaos coming at them from outside while weakened from their own internal conflict? Tune in to find out!
In order to get Rome motivated for war, the internal problems need to be resolved first. What better time then for some of the more senior Romans (who also just happen to be patrician) to get together for a clandestine meeting… Some important decisions are reached but despite the secrecy of the meeting, it does not go unnoticed. Is Rome really more of an oligarchy than it likes to think it is?
On the other side of town, the tribune of the plebs, Gaius Canuelius, is getting fired up about the restrictive marriage laws that are part of the Twelve Tables. And boy does he have a speech to make about it! He digs deep into Rome’s history right back to the kings to explain to the plebeians how their exclusion from marriage to patricians is offensive. He explores the way Rome is in a process of constant adaption and change with examples to support his case that excluding plebeians is insupportable.
In a time of great struggle innovation becomes a necessity. With Rome facing threats from just about every direction, the consuls won’t be able to be everywhere they are needed commanding armies. Livy and Dionysius of Halicarnassus view the development of military tribunes with consular power as part of the patricians trying to placate the plebeians. But is there more to it than that? We delve into the background of the role, what it means for the structure of Roman governance, and compare the sources on the subject.
For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/
Support the show
Patreon
Ko-Fi
Read our books
Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome
Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Who has the right to rule Rome? Who should have the right? In this episode, we tackle one of the major developments of the so-called ‘Conflict of the Orders' as the plebs push for new laws that would give them greater political power. The archaeology confirms that the mid-fifth century was tough for Rome, so the political unrest may be reflecting this difficult time.
Episode 122 – The Right to Rule Rome
Rome Gets GreedyIn our last episode on the year 446 BCE, Rome was kicking some serious butt. The Aequians and Volscians could not sit down for WEEKS! Sadly, these military victories were undermined by a foolish call by the Roman people. The cities of Aricia and Ardea had been engaged in a dispute over boundaries and appealed to Rome to settle their differences. The Romans got a bit greedy and decided that they had the rightful claim to this land, leaving neither city satisfied.
Their land-lust would come back to haunt them in 445 BCE when revolt brakes out in Ardea. Oh, and did we mention that the Veientes, the Aequians and the Volscians were also attacking Roman territory? With the enemies at every gate, the Romans needed to present a strong, united front and march out to deal with these tiresome foes immediately. At least, that’s what the consuls and patricians want. The plebs have other ideas.
The Tribunes Strike BackLivy and Dionysius provide different accounts of how the internal politics of 445 played out, but there were seemingly two major sticking points for the plebs and Caius Canuleius before they were willing to let the levy go ahead. Firstly, they wanted the very unpopular law that forbid intermarriage between the patricians and the plebeians overturned. This law was allegedly the brainchild of the second decemvirate, so thanks again Appius Claudius. Secondly, the plebeians wanted a share in the consulship. There were two consuls, so why not have one patrician and one plebeian?
Often in ancient Rome, our depictions of married couples come from funerary monuments. This is a funerary monument of Gaius Volumnius and his wife (name potentially lost based on the remains)
Italy, c. 1-50 CE (so much later than our period as well!). Now in the Altes Museum.
Photo by Anagoria via Wikimedia Commons
The patricians are HORRIFIED by both suggestions. Intermarriage would pollute the patrician bloodlines and also have dangerous implications for the auspices (reading bird behaviour to interpret the will of the gods). It would also lead to children who belonged to neither the patricians or the plebeians, and yet was somehow both. As for the consulship, it would clearly be a disaster to hand over such power to the plebs. Look at Icilius, or Canuleius himself – troublemakers, the lot of them!
The ‘Conflict of the Orders' Enters a New PhaseThis is one of the most confusing developments yet in the so-called ‘Conflict of the Orders', especially as we can't be sure exactly who the patricians and plebeians really were or when these groups developed! It can be hard to tell when our sources are projecting their own first century BCE understandings back into the early Republic.
With the tribunes and the consuls swearing that they would rather DIE than give in, 445 BCE is shaping up to be a very conflicted year for the Romans….
Our PlayersConsuls 446 BCEThanks to Orange Free Sounds, BBC Sounds, Fesliyan Studios, Gfx Sounds, Free Sound Library, Orange Free Sounds, and Sound Bible for sound effects and the wonderful Bettina Joy de Guzman for our theme music.
This episode is dedicated to a very special group of students who are out there somewhere whom Dr Rad may or may not have taught recently...
This third century CE Roman gold ring is thought to have been used as betrothal or wedding band. While we're not sure if similar styles or rings were in use in the 440s BCE, the concept of being connected through a ring has a long history even as far back as Rome.
For more on Roman rings, you might enjoy this article.
For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/
Support the show
Patreon
Ko-Fi
Read our books
Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome
Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
We are thrilled to bring you an exploration of the relationship between the ancient world and metal music. We’re joined by Dr Jeremy J. Swist an expert in the subject. Dr Swist is a lecturer in the Department of Classical Studies at Brandeis University. He holds a PhD in Classics looking at the Reception of the seven kings of Rome in imperial historiography from Tiberius to Theodosius. His research covers everything from historiography to the classical reception in metal music.
Special Episode – Classical Reception in Metal Music with Dr Jeremy J. Swist
It’s a big topic and we delve into many facets of reception. One important area is thinking about Roman virtus as it is explored in metal. We also consider the connections between metal music and sword-and-sandals cinema. AND the way in which this genre of music can be a way of exploring the edges of human experience.
There may even be a discussion of Spartacus!
There’s lots of bands mentioned including:
Jeremy has very kindly compiled a Spotify list for you to enjoy as well.
The Power of the VisualThe connection between heavy metal and the ancient world is not just about the lyrics or the stylisation on stage though. One of the primary ways classical reception happens is through album artwork.
Consider the depiction of Poseidon on the cover of Wrathblade’s 2017 album God of the Deep Unleashed.
Poseidon cuts an incredibly fearsome and muscular figure as he looms in a giant wave above to destroy an ancient town.
Meanwhile the French band Autokrator have worked in twists on Roman imperialism with the cover of the eponymous album from 2014 and then their latest album released in 2021.
The 2014 album is a wash of red colour over a black background. Before the Colosseum is a fearsome, slightly skeletal sculpture of a Roman…
Autokrator's 2021 album cover for Persecution shifts the colour scheme to greys over a black background.
The building in the background you may just recognise from the Roman forum while the sculpture draws references to Marcus Aurelius.
Coming to Grips with MetalNeither of us know much about metal music so this was a real treat for us to learn more about the rich references to the ancient world in this genre. So join us for an engaging and insightful conversation.
If you're looking for even more metal after listening to this episode, you might want to check out the upcoming conference Heavy Metal and Global Premodernity which is being co-run by none other that Dr Jeremy J. Swist and Dr C Naylor Davis.
For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/
Support the show
Patreon
Ko-Fi
Read our books
Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome
Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.