The Partial Historians

The Partial Historians

By The Partial HistoriansSociety & CultureEducationHistory
Download on the App Store

All The Partial Historians episodes

  • The Tenacious Tempanius

    Welcome to 423 BCE and your introduction to the one and only Sextus Tempanius! You may not know his name just yet, but we're pretty sure you'll be as impressed with him as we are. Suffice it to say, 423 BCE is one of the more interesting and dramatic years of the decade.

    After a confusing tangent about the Samnites and Capua brought to us courtesy of Livy, we return to Rome and war with the Volscians. The Roman forces are led by the patrician, Gaius Sempronius Atratinus. However, Sempronius might be placing too much faith in the gods when it comes to war…

    With fortune seemingly turning against the Romans, a plebeian hero steps into the spotlight. Sextus Tempanius brings the cavalry to the rescue of their forces. Join us to find out how the Tenacious Tempanius made the Romans swoon.

    Episode 137 – The Tenacious Tempanius

    A re-enactor dressed as a Roman cavalryman. The gear is not necessarily historically accurate for this period, but it gives the vibe!
    Image courtesy of Jacqueline Ross via Flickr.

    My Kingdom for a Decurio!

    Sextus Tempanius is described in some of our sources as a decurio. In this context, a decurio is a commander of a decuria of cavalry. A decuria is the Latin term for a division of ten. So a decurio is a low level commander in charge of the ten riders that make up his decuria. Although we can't be precise about the exact scope of the Roman cavalry in this period of the early Republic, there is later thought to have been 30 lots of ten riders to a cavalry legion (300 riders). So for three hundred horsemen there were thirty internal leaders. The other important division was the grouping of 3 decuriones (3×10) horsemen together into a formation known as a turma. Depending on the battle situation, the Romans had the capacity to divide a legion down to collectives of 30 or 10 horsemen with their own command structure.

    Things to Listen Out For
    • Several theories about how Capua received its’ name
    • Confusion over places starting with V
    • The laziest Etruscan resistance EVER
    • Standards left lying around
    • Roman cheerleading practice
    • Friends turning on each other like real douchebags
    • Weird parallels to the Second Punic War  
    • Patrician trials – about time!

    Want to refresh your knowledge of 424 BCE? Check out our previous episode.

    Our Players 423 BCEConsuls
    • C. Sempronius – f. – n. Atratinus (Pat)
    • Q. Fabius Q. f. M. n. Vibulanus (Pat) Mil. Tr. c. p. 416, 414
    Tribune of the Plebs
    • C. Iunius
    Decurio
    • Sextus Tempanius
    Our Sources
    • Dr G reads Dionysius of Halicarnass Roman Antiquities 12.6.5; Val. Max. 3.2.8.
    • Dr Rad reads Livy ab Urbe Condita 4.37-41.
    • Broughton, T. R. S., Patterson, M. L. 1951. The Magistrates of the Roman Republic Volume 1: 509 B.C. – 100 B.C. (The American Philological Association)
    • Brill New Pauly entries for “Decurio” and “Verrugo”
    • Cornell, T. J. 1995. The Beginnings of Rome: Italy and Rome from the Bronze Age to the Punic Wars (c. 1000-264 BC) (Taylor & Francis)
    • Forsythe, G. 2006. A Critical History of Early Rome: From Prehistory to the First Punic War(University of California Press) 
    • Oakley, S. P. 2016. ‘Didactic Livy: Review of Livy’s Political Philosophy. Power and Personality in Early Rome by A. Vasaly’. The Classical Review 66:2, 431-433.
    • Ogilvie, R. M. 1965. A Commentary on Livy: Books 1-5 (Clarendon Press). 
    • Smith, W. 1854. Dictionary of Greek and Roman Geography “Verrugo”
    Sound Effects

    Thanks to the wonderful Bettina Joy de Guzman for our theme music. Sound effects courtesy of Fesliyan Studios and Orange Free Sounds and BBC Sound Effects.

    North face of the Mausoleum of Glanum, southern France, showing a cavalry battle, c. 40 BCE. This relief shows cavalry in action well after the period under discussion in this episode, but it does give you a sense of the movement and how Romans in the late Republic conceived of the cavalry.
    Source: Wikimedia Commons. Photographer: Cancre

    Automated Transcript

    Lightly edited for clarity!

    Dr Rad 0:27
    Hello, dear listeners, and welcome to another episode of The Partial Historians. I am one of your host, Dr. Rad.

    Dr G 0:36
    And I am Dr. G. And we have been tracing Rome's history from the founding of the city for years now. And we're many years into Rome's history as well. So that's exciting news. We're keeping pace with the events as they happen.

    Dr Rad 0:52
    We are I mean, the 420s are just like streaming by me. I can't I feel like I can't keep up with moving so quickly they are flying by I think this is a real indication of what happens when we lose some of our source material.

    Dr G 1:05
    Particularly Dionysius, who is, shall we say, more of a reverse somewhat of a gas bag? Indeed, I hope he does come back though. I'm looking forward to hearing from him again.

    Dr Rad 1:16
    It's been too long.

    Dr G 1:17
    Look, I suspect we've only got fragments from here on down.

    Dr Rad 1:22
    I know but whenever he pops in to say hello, you know, gives me a warm fuzzy feeling inside.

    Dr G 1:28
    Prepare to be excited because he might be popping in with a fragment in this very episode.

    Dr Rad 1:34
    Well, you know, what, if any years I wouldn't be surprised that it's this year that we're about to discuss, which is 423 BCE. But before we get into 423 Dr G., oo god, so rhymy. I think we need to pause and recap. And see what happened in 424 BCE.

    Dr G 1:53
    Well, I will really just be throwing back to you. Because 424. I had almost literally no evidence to the extent that I had to talk about what was Rome's history of founding colonies in the very early Republic as far as we can discern.

    Dr Rad 2:08
    Look, fair enough, fair enough. Look 424 It wasn't perhaps the most memorable of years we've had quite a few of these weird years in the 420s where it seems like kind of not a lot might be going on. But we did have a little bit of our old favourites, which was troublesome tribunes. There's nothing that we love more than a troublesome tribune.

    Dr G 2:31
    It's true. It's true. We do like troublemakers of the plebeian persuasion.

    Dr Rad 2:37
    We definitely do. So we had some tribunes that were complaining about the lack of plebeians that were earning themselves magistracies, even though technically, with this option of military tribune with consular power, technically, we should be seeing plenty of plebeians in power.

    Dr G 2:59
    And yet somehow they are absent. The concerns are real.

    Dr Rad 3:04
    Yes, exactly. And the tribunes were so fed up with the lack of plebeians even running for office, that they were threatening to say, You know what, let's just get rid of this whole idea altogether. And we'll just have the patricians forever, and that would maybe make you happy. Wouldn't it?

    Dr G 3:21
    It's such a typical patrician solution to a problem.

    Dr Rad 3:25
    No, that was the tribune.

    Dr G 3:26
    Oh no!

    Dr Rad 3:27
    Yeah, they were like, you wait, we're just so like, it's it's actually worse that we have the option. And yet nobody's doing it. Because then that seems to imply that actually, we're useless. But he is worthy? Yeah, exactly.

    Dr G 3:41
    Why are we even here, guys, if you're not going to make use of us?

    Dr Rad 3:45
    Precisely. And so they're proposing that and with finally, finally, they have got through to the plebeians. And we actually have some opinions allegedly running for office, and campaigning on the kinds of measures that we would normally see, plebeians run with so things like, I think that they're campaigning on some sort of land allocation policy, you know, that maybe we're going to share it out a bit more fairly than we have in the past. That there's also going top be a tax placed on the landowners, you know, classic, lower class kind of stuff.

    Dr G 4:18
    You know, we should tax the people that have money, not the people who don't have money.

    Dr Rad 4:23
    Yes, although, once again, I have to stop myself, Dr. G, I'm falling into that old pattern. We have to remember that some of the plebeians are very wealthy. It's just that they don't have a stranglehold on power, like the patricians seem to have.

    Dr G 4:38
    This is true. It does turn out that it's more about who you were born to, rather than how much wealth you possess.

    Dr Rad 4:47
    Exactly. And that opens up all sorts of doors like priesthoods and consulships and whatnot.

    Dr G 4:53
    Alright, so that's 424 BCE,

    Dr Rad 4:57
    That is 424.

    Dr G 4:57
    Okay, so let's let's hit the ground running With 423 BCE.

    Dr Rad 5:13
    All right for 423 BCE, Dr. G. And since I know that Dionysius is still breaking your heart with his broken pieces of source material, I'm going to let you tell me who the magistrates are for this year.

    Dr G 5:25
    Oh, well, thank you. There is a little bit of interest when it comes to who we've got in our sort of the players for this year. So we've got a couple of consuls, which are a nice change of affairs really, we haven't

    Dr Rad 5:40
    Well, that's sad to me though because it suggests that all that stuff I just talked about didn't come to pass.

    Dr G 5:47
    Those people put themselves up for election and did not get voted in.

    Dr Rad 5:51
    This is the thing. I get this is where our source material makes no sense. How would they be running for office? If it's not military tribunes with consular power? Yeah, can't run for the consulship. So

    Dr G 6:01
    Precisely. I mean, we do have real issues with the source material. There is no doubt about it.

    Dr Rad 6:07
    Yeah, we really do.

    Dr G 6:08
    Yeah, the plebeians not being allowed at this stage as far as we're aware to run for the consulship. So maybe the elections got a little bit messy, and maybe they changed their minds about what kind of elections they were having, you know, I'm just trying to paper over what are our gaping holes of logic and no material?

    Dr Rad 6:26
    Maybe, maybe there's no such thing as the consulship at this point in time.

    Dr G 6:32
    Horror. Shock.

    Dr Rad 6:34
    Blasphemy. Anyway, I'll skate over that.

    Dr G 6:37
    Well, okay. So there are two men who are more in charge than anybody else. One of them is Gaius Sempronius Atratinus

    Dr Rad 6:46
    Hmmm, welll I recognise these names.

    Dr G 6:50
    Well, Atratinus is an interesting name, because that raises the question about whether patrician and plebeian as it happens, because Atratinus, in the later centuries of the Republic is an exclusively plebeian name but, in this early period, we're pretty sure that this is a patrician name only.

    Dr Rad 7:15
    Dashed my hopes Dr G., how will I carry on for the rest of the episode?

    Dr G 7:19
    Well, I hope you can pick yourself up and continue on but if you can't, I'll just keep going through the roll call sheet. That will be the whole episode. Please save yourself. So Atratinus definitely has plebeian flavour about it, which might explain some of the narrative choices of our analysts historians for the previous year, we like this guy, plebeian. And the scholarship seems to fall down on the side of probably not at this stage. But later on, we'll get the reemergence of this name under a plebeian gens. So that will happen. So our second console is Quintus Fabius Vibulanus.

    Dr Rad 8:10
    Yeah

    Dr G 8:11
    And so this family has come up quite a bit. So one of the fabulous Fabii is back. And we've seen quite a lot of the Vibulanii as well. But this guy doesn't appear to have held any positions as yet. So this seems to be his first foray into the consulship. So that's exciting news for him.

    Dr Rad 8:30
    It is indeed.

    Dr G 8:31
    Go Quintus! We also have a named attribute of the plebs, a guy called Gaius Iunius. Who I suspect you might have more to say about, and we also have a prefect. So a military position, a guy called Sextus Tempanius.

    Dr Rad 8:54
    Yes, I have much to say about this young man. Very, I'm very excited to talk about him. But I love the fact that he's named as a prefect because it gives me images of him in a very sharp navy blazer with little badges on it. Maybe that's just because I'm a school teacher.

    Dr G 9:11
    He also is apparently a decurio, more specifically of the cavalry under Sempronius. So this roll call sheet hints to me that there is some military action that happens in 423 BCE. But realistically, all I've got are a couple of fragments, one from Dionysius of Halicarnassus – praise be – a little snippet from Valerius Maximus. And then I'm basing all the rest of my knowledge from a little bit of extra scholarship research that I've done.

    Dr Rad 9:45
    Well, allow me allow me to step in because this is a banner year for Livy. I mean, we haven't had this much detail and I don't even know how long honestly, who knew that 423 room was the place to be.

    Dr G 9:59
    I'm excited now. Livy does tell a good story. So I'm going to strap myself in.

    Dr Rad 10:03
    He does so you can jump in with your fragments when appropriate, but not a moment earlier.

    Dr G 10:09
    Noted.

    Dr Rad 10:11
    All right. So, as you've noted, I have the same consuls that you do. So this is good. So we start off our story with an Etruscan city, Dr. G. In fact, one I don't really recall us talking much about in its original form, and that is Volturnum.

    Dr G 10:27
    Ah, okay. So in contrast to you already, I have reference to a Volscian city called Verrugo.

    Dr Rad 10:36
    Oh, okay.

    Dr G 10:37
    And this, they may be the same place.

    Dr Rad 10:39
    Well, okay, so Volturnum actually is now Capua. When I say now, I mean, obviously in the Roman sense later on,

    Dr G 10:52
    Capua is in Campania, isn't?

    Dr Rad 10:55
    It is, yes.

    Dr G 10:57
    Okay, that's much further south than the hypothetical Verrugo that I have reference to, which is to the south east of Rome, but past the Frascati sort of region. So you've got to go beyond the hills. There's those volcanic hills to the southeast of Rome, and you go a little bit further past them. Keep going southeast, and then you hit Verrugo, which today, we think, is in the location of modern Colle Ferro, and Sacco. But it's not as far as Capua.

    Dr Rad 11:32
    I'm so glad that you have travelled so extensively in Italy because I'm just sitting here going I know nothing about geography.

    Dr G 11:40
    Look, I wish

    Dr Rad 11:40
    Just as well I'm a history teacher!

    Dr G 11:44
    Maps, schmaps, maps,

    Dr Rad 11:45
    Maps, schmaps, colouring pencils, don't need them. Anyway, no offence for any geography teachers out there actually love colouring pencils. So apparently, this now later in time, like Livy's time, is Capua. And the reason why Livy kicks off with this account is because this city is captured by the Samnites, Dr G.

    Dr G 12:08
    Hmm, all right, I'll hold on to that detail.

    Dr Rad 12:11
    Indeed. Now Livy goes on a bit of a tangent explaining how this city gained the name of Capua and he has several theories. Typical Livy so the first is that it's from “cappis”. Oh, sounds bad. Oh, cat

    Dr G 12:28
    Is it from cat piss because that's a bit-

    Dr Rad 12:30
    No no, I'm going to try that again. Cap piece. Still sounds bad. From its champagne country, and that's not champagne, like the drink. But basically,

    Dr G 12:42
    Just sparkling cat-piss

    Dr Rad 12:43
    It's sounding more and more appetising every time. I really should have tried saying this out loud before I tried to explain it to you. But apparently, what Livy is trying to get at here is some sort of word which means like open country or some sort of plain or battlefield, something like that, okay,

    Dr G 12:54
    I suspect then we might be talking about very different places then. Because Verrugo comes through in the Latin from “verruca” which, which is not what you might suspect that is a wart on the side. But like it's yeah, like, almost exactly the same. But from this idea of a “locus editus asperque”, which is a “high-lying rough place”. So this kind of like mountainous rocky outcrop. So it almost sounds like the very opposite.

    Dr Rad 13:41
    Yeah, could not be more different. Because I also have other people saying, No, Livy is wrong. It actually probably stems from the word for orchid or garden.

    Dr G 13:51
    Oh, well, that's much nicer than cat piss, isn't it?

    Dr Rad 13:54
    It does sound as if I mean, like, I'm really misrepresenting this place, whatever it is. But I also have other scholarship, which suggests that it might come from “acapitae”, and maybe once this place was the head of the Etruscan League. Oh really? Like “capite” like head

    Dr G 14:12
    Like kaput?

    Dr Rad 14:13
    Yeah. Yeah, exactly. Wow. But also it is possible that it could come from this idea of like a plain or something like that. It could also be something that arose just because this is what the people who live there were called and then you know, the place name came from the people that lived there. Those people have hands and they live on flat land.

    Dr G 14:37
    It's a no brainer, really what we should call this place.

    Dr Rad 14:40
    Yeah, exactly. Like it. Or third possibility may be a true version or Etruscan origin from a family the gens Capia.

    Dr G 14:52
    Oh, fancy.

    Dr Rad 14:53
    Yeah. So really, what I'm reading here in the scholarship and Livy is that we have no freaking idea why this place is ended. It kept lots of theories, no real evidence, indeed, but to return to the Samnites and their issue with this place. So I find this the most hilarious military story I've ever heard so far that saying something because we talk about the military a lot. The Etruscans apparently, are just so exhausted. They let the Samnites come in.

    Dr G 15:23
    Or you just imagined some Etruscans were just laying down in a faint being like, I can't go on, take the city, if you must, I'm just gonna stay right here.

    Dr Rad 15:32
    That's basically what they do. They're like, what? The Samnites at our gates, for goodness sakes, just let them come in and take the place because quite frankly, I don't have any fight left in.

    Dr G 15:42
    You know what, I can't be bothered defending this place, and I won't.

    Dr Rad 15:46
    And so they seem to strike a deal and that they're like, Look, if we don't put up any resistance, can we just share the city and the fields equally? And a semi so like, yeah, I guess that's sounds pretty good. We don't have to stab anyone.

    Dr G 16:01
    Let's not fight about it. Let's just split it in half.

    Dr Rad 16:04
    Yeah. But Dr. G. You know, when something sounds too good to be true. Often is, yeah. So the Samnites move in, they start sharing the city in the fields with the Etruscans. But they're really just playing the waiting game, Dr. G. Because one day when the Etruscans are suffering from the after effects of a holiday, read, eaten too much and have a massive hangover. The Samnites wake up in the middle of the night, and kill them all. Oh, god. Yeah, it sounds very Trojan War, doesn't it?

    Dr G 16:41
    Well, yes. I mean, the Etruscans did just let them in, didn't they?

    Dr Rad 16:44
    Well, yeah, they didn't have to pretend with the whole horse thing. But nonetheless, like the whole waiting till everybody's asleep, and then killing everybody.

    Dr G 16:51
    This might explain the Trojan name theory as well.

    Dr Rad 16:54
    Potentially, potentially. I mean, we are. We all know that the Etruscans of the Romans are related to the Trojans, right? That's what they like to tell us. That's what they like to tell us. Now the consuls that we've just been talking about. They happen to take up their office just after this happened. And I'm given the very specific date of the 13th of December.

    Dr G 17:15
    Oh, goodness. Okay. Happy birthday, everybody.

    Dr Rad 17:18
    Indeed yeah. So anyway, so they've taken up their office, the Romans receive intelligence from their own representatives, because they have spies everywhere. That the Volscians and now planning to invade them. Oh, yeah. Shocking. So I know. It's military action just everywhere. All right.

    Dr G 17:37
    So and this is unconnected with the whole Samnites taking over the other spot? situation? Is it or is this interconnected?

    Dr Rad 17:44
    I don't think it's particularly connected. I think it's more just, you know, something horrible. That happens. Yeah. Yeah. Anyway, so the Latins and Hernicians arrive and tell the Romans, “Hey, have you heard the Volscians are planning to invade?” And the Romans are saying, “yes, as a matter of fact, we already knew that thanks to our spies, but good work, everybody. Glad to see we're on the ball.” But the Latins and Hernicians mostly wanted to speak to the Romans because they were spooked. The Volscians just seemed far too energetic. And they were like, This is worrying.

    Dr G 18:21
    They're moving around a lot. And it has me quite concerned.

    Dr Rad 18:24
    Yeah, it's it is like they're just carrying out the levy. You know, managers like you know, what we need to get into things we need to make sure that we have courage to deal with this threat, it seems extremely worrying that they're levying so much.

    Dr G 18:41
    Yeah, I mean, obviously, if they're leving, they're about to send them against somebody.

    Dr Rad 18:45
    So Gaius Sempronius one of our consuls, he comes into the play here 100% has faith that fortune will see him through this mess, because fortunes never faded for anyone and fortune loves the Romans. He of course had led Rome to victory before on the battlefield. So he takes a fairly careless approach to organising the Romans. He's like Yeah, yeah, I get your the Volscians are a problem. It looks like we're facing issues. But don't you worry guys. This, I so got this. I got this so much. I don't even really need to care about how things are being organised.

    Dr G 19:25
    Trust me, the gods are on my side.

    Dr Rad 19:28
    Exactly. Which means that Sempronius ends up entering battle without really thinking through his battle plan.

    Dr G 19:39
    Yeah, who needs a plan?

    Dr Rad 19:41
    Who needs a plan? I mean, I know I like to wing things every now and then but generally not when people's lives are on the line.

    Dr G 19:47
    Well, you and Sempronius are clearly not going to get along.

    Dr Rad 19:51
    Exactly. Now. The big issue I think, with his lack of battle plan is that he has not placed his cavalry in a strategic position. As Livy says, “his lines were not strengthened with reserves”.

    Dr G 20:07
    Oh, goodness, okay. This is problematic. I mean the cavalry is both a very powerful element of any military outfit at this time period. But it is also a heightened risk in some senses like the ways in which a cavalry is vulnerable is useful to know. And maybe to plan for.

    Dr Rad 20:30
    I don't know if you heard me Dr. G. But fortune is on our side. So just like chill out.

    Dr G 20:37
    Praise be, Fortuna, and all your good works. I look forward to you winning the battle for me.

    Dr Rad 20:43
    Yeah, and now here's my other favourite detail. Apparently they're so disorganised that the Roman battle cries weren't even any good.

    Dr G 20:51
    Oh what? They didn't organise their songs properly.

    Dr Rad 20:54
    I know they're all over the shop, Dr. G. 1234. We know what is freaking battle? Wait, that doesn't rhyme what's going on?

    Dr G 21:07
    Are we to extrapolate from this, that every time Rome has gone to war so far, they've come up with new battle songs?

    Dr Rad 21:16
    I think we are and I think it means that I mean, okay. As a school teacher, I'm going to tell you a little story. Whenever we have swimming carnivals, and athletic carnivals, at most schools I've been at there is usually time allocated at some point for the students in their respective houses to practice their chanting. Now, if schools and school children do this, I'm starting to picture the Romans getting together and be like, Alright, guys, this is getting really serious. Some of us won't be coming home. It's time to practice our battle cry. What are we going to chat this time, guys.

    Dr G 21:51
    But I feel like that it would be more akin to perhaps, not disparaging the chanting athletics carnivals, and swimming, carnivals, and so forth. That is a real and genuine thing. But in addition to that, there's usually some tried and true chants that have a historical kind of impetus behind them that are part of the way in which you're brought into your particular sporting house, or your sporting team. I'm thinking particularly about football and the way that the fandom has various songs that they already know and have learned that are for their team. So they've got one for when they're going really well. They've got one for when they want to sort of pep up the players. They've got one for when they're losing, but they want to disparage the opposition. And so the idea that they're coming up with new chants all the time for every single battle seems just it's blowing my mind a little bit because I feel like surely there would be some of the old classics mixed in.

    Dr Rad 22:51
    I'm sure. I'm sure there are but it seems that no matter what they're doing you Oh, doesn't matter. It isn't any good.

    Dr G 22:58
    It is organised and we can thank Sempronius for that.

    Dr Rad 23:02
    Yeah, they're like you g l why you ain't got no excuse. You ugly? Yeah, yeah. You ugly? Yeah, yeah.

    Dr G 23:13
    Oh, those Romans.

    Dr Rad 23:14
    Yeah. Anyway, so the Volscians are pretty confident after they hear these pathetic efforts at battle cries from the Romans. They're like, Oh, my God, they haven't rehearsed guys, we've got this in the bag. Now, the Romans don't really know what to do. I think they're feeling it. They know they're unprepared. So they're looking around for a hero. Because they're very timid. When they go into battle, they just don't really know what's happening. It seems like they haven't got you know, adequate leadership. And very quickly, things turn against them, because their heart's just not in it. They don't have confidence. I mean, this is just a classic lesson. I mean, the Romans are some of the most arrogant, confident people I've ever met. And yet, even they are proving that if you don't have your head in the right place, and you're not projecting confidence, people out there are going to eat you alive, they will know, they will know. So the frontline ends up retreating, and they even leave their standards behind.

    Dr G 24:09
    Okay, this is shocking news. I mean, I'm so sad. I have no source material for this year now. Losing the standards. That is, that is the worst thing that can happen basically.

    Dr Rad 24:21
    I know and I thought might be good to remind our listeners and you're the perfect person to do it. Why the standards are so important.

    Dr G 24:27
    Well, the standards, my friends, my dear listeners, are so important because they represent almost like the energy of the entire group that works under that standard, like it's got a vested totemic symbolism about it. So it's the sort of thing that you can sort of galvanise people around. You can use it to indicate where people are on the battlefield. Obviously, it's quite visual and striking. But the really significant thing is the sense in which there's a characteristic about it that's really imbued with the character of the men who fight under that standard. So, I would imagine that things like war cries and things like that may actually incorporate references to their own standards and so forth and so on in order to emphasise that relationship. So, there is a quasi-religious divine element to the standards. And so when they are lost, there is a sense in which the whole character of that particular unit is broken down and cannot be reunified until they get that standard back.

    Dr Rad 25:34
    Now, this sounds obviously terrible, and it sounds like the Volscians are just you know, shoo in for victory, but don't write the Romans off just yet, Dr. G. While the Volscians are definitely prevailing at this point in time, the Romans aren't in like a full on retreat. They just like confused and dropping back and just trying to stay alive at this point in time. The Volscians, of course, are pursuing the advantage and they're really pushing on. But Livy makes sure to emphasise that the rumours are more being killed and running away, which makes me certain that they were in fact running away.

    Dr G 26:11
    I was gonna say, I mean, that's when you get killed the most is when you're running away. Yeah, you've exposed your backside to the enemy.

    Dr Rad 26:19
    I know. But I don't feel like Livy has it in him to actually record the Romans acting like that. He's like, Oh, yeah, they're being totally cut down. But they're not running away.

    Dr G 26:28
    Oh, Livy always trying to save Rome's reputation.

    Dr Rad 26:31
    I know that's purely my own instinct there. Nobody's told me that. Anyway, so more and more Romans are falling back because the battle is really falling apart for them. What is our consul Sempronius doing about it. Sweet F A, Dr. G. He's trying really hard to inspire them. And he's getting angry with them being like, turn around for goodness sakes, my God get back at their fortunes on our side, you idiot. But his anger is doing nothing. And I'm going to directly quote my translation of Livy cuz I really liked this sentence, “There was no virtue either in his authority, or in his dignity”.

    Dr G 27:09
    Oh, snap.

    Dr Rad 27:12
    I know. I know. That's a burden on so many levels.

    Dr G 27:17
    Oh, I don't know if Sempronius coming back from this to be honest.

    Dr Rad 27:21
    Just you wait, Dr. G. All right. So the Romans were at that point finally, where they were about to commit the worst sin possible and all turn their backs on the enemy, thus exposing them to being wounded or killed in the back as they run away. The shame, the shame,

    Dr G 27:40
    There's nothing nothing less dignifying in terms of virtus for a Roman to get wounded on the back.

    Dr Rad 27:46
    But then, Dr. G, our hero comes into the story. A cavalry decurion name Sextus Tempanius saves the day with his amazing courage. Now a little background on what a decurion is. So as far as I could figure out at decurion is in command of 10 men. So it's not just a clever name. And he seems to be in a similar position to a centurion. But just for the cavalry. Not the infantry, which is what the centurion is usually in charge of.

    Dr G 28:21
    All right, sounds fancy. So he's in charge of 10 horsemen, essentially.

    Dr Rad 28:25
    Yeah, so apparently, there would be three two decurions in a squadron, which is called a terma. And there are 10 terma in three centuries of horse, which would go along with a legion. Thank you very much notes in my Loeb translation.

    Dr G 28:41
    So a terma would have 30 cavalry, plus the three decurio.

    Dr Rad 28:49
    Yeah

    Dr G 28:49
    And then how many is that in the century?

    Dr Rad 28:52
    Then there are 10 termae in three centuries, which is far too much math for me to do publicly because that means dividing things up.

    Dr G 29:00
    No, no, that's 30 by 10. So there's 300.

    Dr Rad 29:03
    Right, excellent. Let's stick with that.

    Dr G 29:06
    It's a lot of horses. I'm just trying to visualise like how many horses here? I really did. That's quite a lot of horses.

    Dr Rad 29:13
    It is but that's that's saying that you have three centuries. I don't know how many people we have here right now.

    Dr G 29:17
    That's true.

    Dr Rad 29:18
    Anywho the other weird little detail I'm going to throw in there is that the name Tempanius is very unusual. It seems that nobody else has it.

    Dr G 29:28
    Hmm. Well, that is not a vote of confidence in favour of this story being true then.

    Dr Rad 29:35
    Pish posh, Dr G, this guy is about to be a plebeian hero.

    Dr G 29:39
    Okay, I might bring in Dionysius' fragment here.

    Dr Rad 29:44
    Okay do it.

    Dr G 29:45
    Not because I think it fits where we're at in the narrative, because it's not at all clear to me from what you've told me where this might fit, but I'll just give it to you and you might have some ideas about where it goes.

    Dr Rad 29:58
    Okay

    Dr G 29:58
    So he's talking sbout Sempronius and Sempronius has learned that the enemy is coming up in the rear.

    Dr Rad 30:06
    Uh huh.

    Dr G 30:07
    And he's despaired of being able to turn back with the men, right? And he's also concerned about being surrounded by the enemy on all sides.

    Dr Rad 30:18
    Interesting, okay.

    Dr G 30:19
    And so there is a sense that Sempronius at this point, decides to see if they can take the high ground, right? Because like if we're going to have to defend ourselves, and we're going to get surrounded, we need to get to the top of that little hill over there as fast as we can.

    Dr Rad 30:38
    Okay, I see where your story fits in. Continue.

    Dr G 30:41
    That is my entire fragment.

    Dr Rad 30:42
    Oh, okay. All right. All right. Well, let me let me I'll show you where your story fits in. Here we go. So Sextus Tempanius shouts to the cavalry, that anybody who wants to save or needs to get down off his horse right now. Now the men obey him as though he was the consul which of course he is not. He's just a humble decurion and he tells them that they are the ones that can save everything now all they have to do is follow him into battle. And he cries out show Romans and Volscians that when you are mounted, no cavalry are your equals, nor any infantry when you fight on foot. And then men are like, amazing. I love this. Let's do it.

    Dr G 31:26
    But it also feels like it doesn't really make a lot of sense, does it? I mean, he's just said to the cavalry, dismount and fight as if your infantry.

    Dr Rad 31:34
    Yeah, so he's saying, let's show everyone that we're amazing when we're cavalry. And we're also amazing when we're infantry.

    Dr G 31:40
    They've been losing. Well, they've been cavalry.

    Dr Rad 31:42
    No, no, no, they haven't been in the right spot. Yeah, you don't understand, they've been undermined by Sempronius.

    Dr G 31:49
    I see. My visualisation of this battle is all over the shop.

    Dr Rad 31:54
    Well, I think that that makes everyone involved because it is obviously a chaotic battle.

    Dr G 31:58
    Everybody's yeah, there's a lot of chaos.

    Dr Rad 32:00
    So under Sextus Tempanius, he manages to lead them wherever the hell he wants on the battlefield, because they are, they're almost in like berserker mode Dr. G, to use a problematic term from the Vikings for no apparent reason. And they make their way to the most desperate part of the battle, the Romans would not have been able to win without these guys on the battlefield. This is clear. Now the Volscian general sees them in action, and he's like, “Whoa, those guys cannot be stopped”. So he ordered his troops to allow the superstar Romans to gain ground with this clever strategy of allowing them to gain so much ground that they could be cut off from everyone else. And this is where I think your story is going to start to come, it works. They are cut off, and they are unable to break through. The remainder of the Roman army could not and would not, however, allow them to be lost, they are determined to come to their aid and push through. Now the Volscians are facing attack from two sides. Tempanius and his little band of followers, they managed to establish themselves on a mound and they sort of position themselves in a circle and they defend themselves there. This battle is going on for ever so long that it actually becomes night.

    Dr G 33:30
    Oh, goodness. Okay, I know this, this actually taps into the other single piece of evidence that I have, which is from Valerius Maximus.

    Dr Rad 33:39
    So the consuls are determined to keep fighting as long as it was possible because right now, the battle does not have a clear outcome. It is just the most confusing battle I think we've ever talked about.

    Dr G 33:52
    And now that it's nighttime, it's only going to get more confusing, I would suspect.

    Dr Rad 33:56
    Yeah. So each side in their camps are terrified because they don't really know what is happening, who's one who's lost what's happening. So they both decided to abandon their wounded and some of their baggage which would be in their camps, so that they can retreat to the nearest hills. Okay. And this is where I think there's there's some, you know, tie in with what you were saying about the hill thing. But the mound with Tempanius and his men, that continues to be attacked until after midnight.

    Dr G 34:26
    Oh, goodness.

    Dr Rad 34:28
    I know this is a crazy long battle. Now when Tempanius hears that the Roman camp had been abandoned. I don't know how he heard that. Maybe someone shouted it out really loudly because this is maybe a smaller scale battle than it sounds. It obviously makes it sound like the Romans have been defeated and they've just fled. You know, they've panicked and they've just gone. Tempanius is really worried about an ambush taking place at this point in time. So he takes a few men to check out the situation. I don't know how he manages to do this, but apparently he manages to

    Dr G 35:02
    It's dark. I don't know.

    Dr Rad 35:05
    I guess so. Yeah. I mean, yeah, they're in a circle and they're defending the amount so maybe it's not like full on like, ah, Hollywood fighting all this time.

    Dr G 35:16
    People have got to be tired. It's more like somebody else being like, Oh,

    Dr Rad 35:23
    Yeah. Now Tempanius stops along the way to chat to some wounded Volscians as you do. And he realises that their camp is also been deserted.

    Dr G 35:32
    Wait a minute.

    Dr Rad 35:34
    Yeah. So he calls out to the rest of his men. And he's like, let's go to the Roman camp. Okay, so they all go to the Roman camp. And everything's very abandoned, and it's looking very sad. However, Tempanius does not want the Volscians to find out about the sad state of the Roman camp, because of course, they would naturally attack. So Tempanius took as many wounded as he could, and leaves for Rome – he has no idea where Sempronius, the consul, has actually retreated to or gone. Meanwhile, the people back in Rome have heard that the battle is not going very well. And people are already mourning the losses because they kind of presume that a lot of people are dead, particularly people in the cavalry. They think it's really bad news. Now, other consul, Fabius has obviously been keeping charge of the city, and he's keeping watch at the gates and he's trying to reassure the Romans who are panicking, but then he sees cavalry off in a distance and he's like, Oh, this can't be good. But as the cavalry get closer, guess who it is?

    Dr G 36:45
    Is it -?

    Dr Rad 36:46
    It's Tempanius!

    Dr G 36:47
    I was gonna say I'm like it's either Sempronius or Tempanius.

    Dr Rad 36:50
    Yeah, it's Tempanius. And everyone's like – whoo – everyone's starts partying. The women don't even care about their appearance. They just in the streets, throwing themselves into the arms of their men like, “Hurray, you're not dead after all – Yay!”.

    Dr G 37:07
    Okay.

    Dr Rad 37:07
    Yeah, I think I should pause and ask you about your piece of evidence from Valerius Maximus.

    Dr G 37:11
    Yeah, like, I'll give you the piece of evidence. It's there's not a lot and it is confusing, because Okay. One, first of all, Tempanius is never mentioned at all. So right, I have no idea who this guy is. But we have a reference to a badge of glory that must be rendered to Rome's young warriors. So okay, the consul Gaius Sempronius Atratinus is unsuccessful in battling with the Volsci at this place called Verrugo.

    Dr Rad 37:46
    Right.

    Dr G 37:47
    This may be the place where your battle is at with a different name in a different place. Leave that detail aside for now.

    Dr Rad 37:54
    I think I've mentioned the name to be fair.

    Dr G 37:57
    And Valerius Maximus emphasises that to save the Roman line, which was already yielding from a complete rout, these young warriors dismounted from their horses, arranged themselves in centuries, and dashed into the enemy host. So we've got that nice parallel with Livy's account. And they get down from their horses and like we're going to do it infantry style. We do what we must.

    Dr Rad 38:22
    Yes, absolutely.

    Dr G 38:24
    Dividing themselves up, they occupy an adjoining hill, and they draw themselves they draw to them the full Volscian force.

    Dr Rad 38:34
    Right.

    Dr G 38:35
    Thus allowing the other Roman legions that are in disarray, some respite to recover that morale, and presumably

    Dr Rad 38:42
    I think that all matches up, yup.

    Dr G 38:43
    Presumably, that's where Sempronius is.

    Dr Rad 38:45
    Yes.

    Dr G 38:46
    And they, they're not sure how this all turns out in the end, ultimately, though, so it gets to nighttime. The battle technically ends with nightfall because people can't see enough to keep doing battle. And everybody withdraws. But nobody's really sure who's won. Awkward. Yeah. So from this kind of evidence, in a way, this kind of makes a little bit more sense than Livy. I would say, not. Well,

    Dr Rad 39:20
    I feel like it's kind of the same story, though.

    Dr G 39:23
    Well, it's tricky, because like we've had other instances in the past where the battle has gone all day, but it tends to finish at night because it's hard to keep going.

    Dr Rad 39:33
    Oh, yeah, the nighttime stuff. The nighttime stuff is totally made up.

    Dr G 39:37
    So what Valerius Maximus is saying here is that when night does come, actually the enemies split apart, and they go back to their respective camps, essentially, but nobody's sure of the outcome of the battle yet, so there's been no clear winner. And this happens quite frequently in ancient warfare as well with the Romans. We've heard stories of this before where they return the next day and they have another battle so that sort of thing is where Valerius Maximus is heading with his piece of evidence. But he doesn't go. He doesn't mention anybody by name, except for Sempronius. But he does talk about this group of young warriors who really do save what was going to be a disaster for the legions that were already on the ground.

    Dr Rad 40:23
    Okay, cool. Yeah. So I think I agree, I think we've got that matchup in terms of the young warriors who are cavalry, who make themselves into infantry, draw attention to themselves from the Volscians and allow the rest of the Romans to get themselves in order and do what they need to do. I definitely agree that it seems highly unlikely that they are fighting all day and then all night. That doesn't seem right. But anyway, so back in room when Tempanius and the cavalry show up, their tributes have already clocked off for the day. Because they are busying themselves with putting on trial, Marcus Postumius and Titus Quinctius, who are being charged for their lack of success at Veii. Now, this is a throwback to the year 426.

    Dr G 41:10
    I was gonna say they've left that they've left their run a bit late. It's like that was years ago.

    Dr Rad 41:15
    They'd been worried about other matters, Dr. G

    Dr G 41:17
    Fair enough, fair enough.

    Dr Rad 41:19
    But I think that they I think they're seeing an opportunity presented with the ill feeling towards Sempronius right now. Because Sempronius has also obviously done a terrible job in this battle, in that these young warriors had to come to the rescue. And so they're like, You know what, this is an opportune moment for putting these guys on trial because everyone's really hating on Sempronius right now, it's the same story all over again. Now, just to remind listeners 426, may or may not be the year in which we had that momentous fight over Fidenae. And they and we had the most ridiculously handsome, Cornelius Cossus coming out, maybe killing an Etruscan King of Veii, Lars Tolumnius. In this year, we had a dictator, Aemilius Mamercinus. We that was that year. That was that's what we're throwing back to at this point in time. So the tribunes call a meeting and they say you know what, the Romans have been betrayed by their generals at Veii. And there were no consequences. Now, once again, the army has been sent out against the Volscians as they've been let down by the consul. The cavalry has practically been slaughtered. The camp has been abandoned. This is absolutely disgusting. And this is where we get the name distributed coming in Gaius Iunius.

    Dr G 42:50
    Aha. He's in!

    Dr Rad 42:52
    The Tribune, Gaius Iunius summons Tempanius to speak. And he asks him, tell me Tempanius, how did Sempronius prepare for battle? Do you think what he did was adequate? Was it in fact, you who rallied the cavalry on that day and came up with the battle strategy that saved our asses? When the cavalry ran into issues and was cut off from the rest of the army, did the consul come to your rescue? Did he even send you any help? Was he even there the next day, when you manage to make your way to the camp? Or did you in fact, find the camp abandoned, filled only with the wounded and the stuff that was left behind? I want the truth.

    Dr G 43:43
    Oh, how intense.

    Dr Rad 43:45
    I know. And you know exactly what Tempanius says, “you can't handle the truth!” He's very calm. He's very calm. He's cucumber, like, very measured. He doesn't seek the glory for himself. And he does not want to criticise anybody. My translation describes this as soldierly dignity, stiff upper lip and what what exactly, he says, “Look, wasn't up to me. I'm just a mere soldier to evaluate the performance of my general. The Roman people had deemed him worthy of that position when they selected him. So let's just move on, shall we?”

    Dr G 44:23
    “And as for my role with the cavalry, I really do what I must do in the heat of battle. Any any other decurio would have done the same.”

    Dr Rad 44:32
    Exactly. He also goes on to testify. “Look, I saw the consul fighting. I saw him fighting at the front. I saw him encouraging the men and we were running around between the standards and missed enemy fire. I could not see everything of course, because that would be insane and that I had 1000 eyes like a fly. But I could hear the battle raging into the night. And I do not think, quite frankly, that it was possible for anyone to reach me and my men, they were just too many enemy. What you ask is unreasonable.”

    Dr G 45:08
    Oh, dear,

    Dr Rad 45:09
    He presumed that the consul had simply taken the rest of the army to a safe place. And in fact, that is what he had done. And it makes complete and utter sense that he did so.

    Dr G 45:23
    Where is Sempronius? Has he turned up back at Rome at this point in time? Or are people like that man's a well, and half the army? We don't know where it is.

    Dr Rad 45:31
    Just you wait, just you wait.

    Dr G 45:32
    Okay?

    Dr Rad 45:33
    Yeah. Now the Volscians, of course, also, were in the same tricky position. Everyone was confused, because not only was it a confusing battle, but it was nighttime for a huge chunk of it, apparently.

    Dr G 45:46
    Yeah, look at it's really hard to tell how it went. I couldn't see anything, including the enemy.

    Dr Rad 45:51
    Yeah, exactly. Tempanius is finally allowed to sit down after this damning testimony. No, not really. After this testimony, which does nothing to damn anybody.

    Dr G 46:01
    Tem-pain-ius, as we can call him, because he's in pain a lot.

    Dr Rad 46:07
    Anyway, so he's dismissed and everyone's like, wow, what a guy. I mean, could I be any more in love with him? Not only has he rescued the Romans, but he has also not actually taken up this opportunity to win all this praise for himself. He's just so humble and brave. I mean, I think I'm ovulating right now.

    Dr G 46:32
    So much virtus right now.

    Dr Rad 46:34
    Now, you asked about Sempronius. Let me tell you about where Sempronius is.

    Dr G 46:40
    Yeah, where's Sempronius? This guy is missing in action.

    Dr Rad 46:43
    Yeah, so he's travelling along somewhere called the Labican road. You may know where this is. I do not.

    Dr G 46:50
    Not offhand. No.

    Dr Rad 46:52
    Okay. So he apparently reaches a shrine. The shrine of the I think it's the Quies. Quies. It spelled q u i e s. Hmm, never heard of it. Probably should have looked that up actually. But anyway, he reached his this particular shrine. Wagons and animals are sent out from the city because he's obviously close enough to Rome that they, I guess, can see him coming or he sent word ahead and they're like, You guys must be tired. Let us help you out. “Thank God, I am exhausted. This battle seemingly never ended.” Now the consul is in the city soon after this. And he clearly wants to single Tempanius out for praise because he recognises that Tempanius was the hero of the day. However, he's also a trifle defensive about what went down.

    Dr G 47:40
    Fair enough. It's always awkward when you go into something full of confidence with no preparation and that it doesn't work.

    Dr Rad 47:48
    Who knew that it would blow up in your face? I feel like this is one of those situations where we can say I tried nothing. And I'm fresh out of ideas.

    Dr G 47:57
    I mean, it's embarrassing.

    Dr Rad 48:00
    Yeah. So the citizens are absolutely Spurius Furius in their rage against Sempronius.

    Dr G 48:09
    Fair enough.

    Dr Rad 48:10
    Yeah, they're also pretty mad about the guys from a few years back now because of Sempronius. They're like, yeah, yeah, I remember that thing that they, you military tribunes with consular power, good for nothings. And so they are in fact put on trial before the people. And Marcus Postumius, one of the military tribunes with consular power is fined 10,000 pounds of bronze for his sheer stupidity.

    Dr G 48:39
    That is, that's a lot of bronze. Poor man. All right, didn't lead well enough and there's a price to be paid. That's good to know.

    Dr Rad 48:48
    There is indeed.

    Dr G 48:49
    So the tribunes are coming forward with some effective strategies for trying to like you know, keep the patricians in check a little bit be like, sure you could lead the army, but that does mean you have a responsibility to be good at leading an army. And if you're not gonna do it properly, maybe don't get us all killed.

    Dr Rad 49:11
    Exactly. Now, you might be wondering, Dr. G, what about that other guy? Because Marcus Postumius was not alone when he was in charge of the forces at Veii and you are quite right, Titus Quinctius. Now this is a family we've had a lot to do with. This is in fact we think the brother of Cincinnatus, so he belongs to that gens.

    Dr G 49:36
    One of the famed Cincinnati's

    Dr Rad 49:39
    Yeah. Now he has had some military success. He has won some victories against the Volscians, not difficult given the Romans fight the Volscians all the time, case in point. And he also has been part of one of the Roman victories at Fidenae because he was lieutenant to the dictator Aemilius. So he's not in quite as much doo doo as Postumius.

    Dr G 50:07
    He has had some successes in his military command history.

    Dr Rad 50:11
    He has now he comes forward and completely throws Postumius under the bus. Oh, yeah, he is acquitted by all the tribes because he pins all the blame for everything that went wrong and 426 on Postumius.

    Dr G 50:28
    Wow. Cincinnatus. Not cool.

    Dr Rad 50:32
    Apparently, though, people also feel sorry for him because they still love Cincinnatus. I mean, what's not to love about Cincinnatus? He has not got a great fortune, and yet he still serves the state tirelessly. Whenever they call on him. He's there.

    Dr G 50:50
    Oh, he's basking in the reflected light of familial connection is he?

    Dr Rad 50:56
    It would seem so because it seems as though by this point, he is finally dying. And nobody wants to tell him that this is where his family is at.

    Dr G 51:08
    Your family is now out of favour. Sorry about that.

    Dr Rad 51:11
    Yeah, absolutely. Now, whether any of this is in fact, true is obviously a moot point. There seems to be something going on here. Although interestingly, I did read that the Quintii and the Postumii, often very closely related because there's some marriages going on in between their families. So interesting.

    Dr G 51:38
    I wouldn't, yeah, maybe some family jealousy at play here.

    Dr Rad 51:42
    I was gonna say, yeah, it's possible that this is a bit of a falling out between the families here.

    Dr G 51:48
    Quite possibly, the drama, gossip.

    Dr Rad 51:52
    I know. So that's kind of where 423 winds up for me. We'll probably be picking out some of the pieces of this, I think into the next year. But I would like to note before we sign off here, that I have enjoyed this episode so much because it has so many of our classic characters that live he likes to bring in the troublesome tribunes, the heroic soldierly plebeians. I love it.

    Dr G 52:18
    Yeah, I think there's a there's a good story element to what Louie has brought to the table for 423. So I'm excited to avoid all the details from you and to have thrown in a couple of details along the way as well.

    Dr Rad 52:34
    Yeah, well, the interesting thing I think about the whole story about Sempronius, because this is quite a prominent family. And as you signalled at the beginning, it is interesting because the Sempronii seemingly started out as a plebeian gens and become patricians. And then we know that they're going to have an association with the plebeians again. So it's really interesting that you noted that plebeian connection with Atratinus coming in later as well, like, clearly, there's a bit of interesting stuff going on here with this particular family. And obviously, different branches of the family, I would say,

    Dr G 53:07
    Yeah, and I think this gives us a sense of insight into the shifting sands. That is the nature of the Roman elite and the hierarchies that might be at play in the Roman state. We're never really quite sure where people sit exactly. And we know, this harks back into that big idea that we've mentioned before where we're not really sure where the elites are coming from, we're not sure whether they're patricians, or known as patricians at this stage. But there is this does seem to be a division between the citizens that can hold certain positions and the ones that cannot, and the Sempronii, seem to be one of these families that straddles both of these categories across the centuries.

    Dr Rad 53:54
    Definitely. And one of the other things that live in may, in fact, be playing with here, which we have come across before, is this and this is not living alone. This is a bit of a Roman trait. This assumption that people from the same family behave the same way no matter how much time has passed. We've seen that very much with the Appius Claudiuses that we have encountered over time, with each one of them just becoming even more despicable than the one before.

    Dr G 54:22
    Gotta uphold the family tradition. I've got to try it out to my ancestors in being terrible and arrogant.

    Dr Rad 54:28
    Yeah, and it would seem that this might be the case with Sempronius. Because this battle, which has taken place forever, you're quite correct about that being the location of this Volscian battle. It seems to mirror very closely, a very famous battle from the Second Punic War. So in 218 BCE, there was a battle at Trevia. And one of the people leading that battle is a guy called Tiberius Sempronius Longus. Now you're going to see some really strong parallels here. Because once again, we've got a consul, who is not preparing properly, we see him making foolish decisions when preparing for the battle not being properly prepared. And then we see a division of forces into two groups, and then only managing to escape through sheer luck. And also, this battle was rescued because of the dismounting of the cavalry to fight as infantry at Cannae. So it seems to be a blending together of some stories that come from the Punic Wat and being maybe used to construct the battle here. Now, as you've noted many times strategy, I am not insinuating that this battle did not in fact, happen. And that the Romans are in fact making it all up, and just using a latest story to invent their history. But they might be fleshing out the details when they know that there's a defeat of a console called sim peroneus, who ends up getting themselves into a lot of a lot of trouble by using some of the details from this Punic War battle, and probably drawing on some family folklore here.

    Dr G 56:18
    Yeah, definitely, I think you're quite right about stuff like that, where the family legacy and the idea of inherited characteristics is very much something the Romans are into. They read backwards as well as forwards into their family lines with this kind of thing. So yeah, I'm willing to buy that theory. And I look forward to the day we get to the Battle of Cannae so we can not only go through that particular battle in incredible detail, but then also have a think back to this particular battle as well.

    Dr Rad 56:49
    Absolutely. Trevia and Cannae, I'm there in like, 20 years with you. It'll happen. It's a date.

    Dr G 56:56
    I will see you there.

    Dr Rad 56:58
    Absolutely. And that really brings me therefore to the end of what I have for 423. And I don't want to go into 422 just yet. That means it is time for The Partial Pick.

    All right, Dr. G, tell us about the Partial Pick.

    Dr G 57:16
    The Partial Pick, there are 50 Golden Eagles up for grabs. Rome, can they do it? We will find out there are five categories. There are 10 golden eagles on offer in each category. Our first category is military clout.

    Dr Rad 57:33
    This is an awkward one because they clearly doing really badly for a while. And I don't think they really win so much as not lose.

    Dr G 57:44
    I think it's pretty awkward to suggest that they have military clout, when it seems like what has happened has been a failure in leadership to really pull the battle together. It sounds like they could have easily won this if they'd been prepared.

    Dr Rad 57:59
    Well, I mean, they've beat the valskis so many times. I mean, can that go off? They could have won it.

    Dr G 58:04
    Nobody's expecting them to lose at this point. So it's awkward that they have

    Dr Rad 58:08
    Yeah, so I don't know. I mean, what are we going to give them like maybe a three to recognise Tempanius snd his crew?

    Dr G 58:16
    Yeah, the amazing turnaround provided by Tempanius and his dismounting of the cavalry. Look, yeah, I think that deserves some sort of reward, maybe for being too harsh. No, I was gonna go even less actually, because I think a lot of what Tempanius does might fit into a future category. I'd be going for like, two.

    Dr Rad 58:37
    Oh, okay. Two. All right. Uh, two.

    Dr G 58:40
    All right. Our next category is Diplomacy.

    Dr Rad 58:44
    Well, where it was. So

    Dr G 58:49
    You say diplomacy? I say no, thank you.

    Dr Rad 58:51
    Yeah. And I mean, if even if we look at the random story that Livy decided to tell me about what happened to Capua, no diplomacy there either.

    Dr G 59:01
    Yeah, I mean, people just gave up, didn't they?

    Dr Rad 59:03
    That was the most random story, I think. I think maybe he was just trying to explain where the name Capua came from.

    Dr G 59:08
    Yeah, but why now? Very strange. All right. That's that's a no.

    Dr Rad 59:15
    This is your Yeah. All right.

    Dr G 59:17
    Expansion.

    Dr Rad 59:18
    I don't get the sense that they're winning any territory here.

    Dr G 59:23
    It doesn't sound like it. No. Okay. That's a clear zero as well. All right. I think there might be a bit of a comeback in Virtus.

    Dr Rad 59:30
    I agree. I mean, I think it has to be a 10 out of 10 for this guy. I mean, he comes out of nowhere, he does his duty and battle he puts himself at risk. He manages to fight amazing battle and make it out alive, saving probably the life of the cavalry with him, as well as also preserving the ruins from utter defeat. And then when he gets back to the city, he doesn't even want to brag about it. I might have a stroke. Hmm.

    Dr G 1:00:02
    Well, if you run into this guy in a bar, you can have him. I'll be your wingwoman. Yeah, there's an amazing display of virtus here, I think and I don't know that I can give it a 10 though. So that's my that's my hesitation because this is not a clear victory.

    Dr Rad 1:00:22
    Wow, way to be harsh Dr. G. Oh my god, the years have made you cruel.

    Dr G 1:00:30
    I feel like if it was

    Dr Rad 1:00:31
    But he and his band, I think they have been victorious in like preserving the Roman army from slaughter defeat disgrace. And not only that, they haven't even died themselves. I mean, sure. I'm sure a couple of them have died. But they've made it out alive. They go back to the camp. And then he didn't even throw Sempronius under the bus. I mean, what more do you want for little old Tempanius?

    Dr G 1:00:58
    Alright, alright

    Dr Rad 1:00:59
    He's a plebeian he's a plebeian.

    Dr G 1:01:02
    I'll give him a ten.

    Dr Rad 1:01:05
    Yessss. That's what I'm talking about.

    Dr G 1:01:09
    And our last category is the citizen score.

    Dr Rad 1:01:13
    Okay, I don't think this is probably great.

    Dr G 1:01:16
    It's not an ideal time to be a Roman citizen. You have been signed up and levied into an army that is being poorly Led.

    Dr Rad 1:01:24
    Yes.

    Dr G 1:01:24
    Generally speaking.

    Dr Rad 1:01:25
    Yeah.

    Dr G 1:01:26
    It seems like we don't know the outcome of this battle. So lives are definitely lost. We know that was plenty of injuries. One of the things Tempanius seems to do is go back and rescue some of the injured from the camp.

    Dr Rad 1:01:39
    I have a feeling it's considered to be like a tie, because they're both they're both panics. They're both in disarray. Neither one has dominated, sir. Yeah, I think it's an inconclusive battle, for sure. Although, in a way, I think the Romans also kind of look at that as being just as bad as a defeat because it shouldn't have been such a close run thing.

    Dr G 1:02:02
    Yeah. So it's, it's not great. If you're a plebeian and you're serving in the infantry. Yeah.

    Dr Rad 1:02:11
    We do see the tribunes coming out and being like, hey,

    Dr G 1:02:16
    that's true. Levelling some prosecutions against the generals of former times. Yeah.

    Dr Rad 1:02:23
    And current times. Oh, they're coming fast and furious.

    Dr G 1:02:27
    Just you wait. Yeah. Stay tuned.

    Dr Rad 1:02:29
    I like I like the accountability. So that's at least something.

    Dr G 1:02:33
    Okay. I'd say on the accountability side of it. I'd be inclined to give it a five and above.

    Dr Rad 1:02:39
    Oh, okay. I'm gonna go five because I don't think it's that amazing. I mean, he's fine. Like big whoop.

    Dr G 1:02:45
    Don't know how much bronze you've got lying around. But you know, it's gonna be tough.

    Dr Rad 1:02:49
    Sure, it's a huge fine and everything but I mean, you know. We know how the elites work. He'll be getting money passed to him from his other patrician buddies. He won't be really doing it tough, come on. He'll be fine. He'll be fine. He'll land on his feet. He said he's from the Postumii. He'll be fine.

    Dr G 1:03:06
    It's true. Yeah. All right. So five. Yeah,

    Dr Rad 1:03:09
    So that means Dr. G, the Romans have earned themselves a grand total of 17 Golden Eagles.

    Dr G 1:03:17
    Well, it's not a pass, but it's better than some other times.

    Dr Rad 1:03:23
    I think it's better than I was expecting. Given that this is not really a great military year for them.

    Dr G 1:03:29
    It did seem like mostly a rout. Yeah.

    Dr Rad 1:03:33
    Absolutely. So 17 Not too shabby. largely thanks to one hero, one batte.

    Dr G 1:03:42
    One man standing out from the crowd, stepping down off his horse to fight in the trenches.

    Dr Rad 1:03:48
    Indeed. And I think that we have also exposed Livy to being sued for violating the plotline of “A Few Good Men”.

    Dr G 1:03:56
    How dare he?

    Dr Rad 1:03:57
    I know he totally stole that courtroom scene, embarrassing.

    Dr G 1:04:02
    We'll have to write him a strongly worded letter.

    Dr Rad 1:04:04
    We will indeed.

    Dr G 1:04:06
    Well, it has been an absolute pleasure to learn all about 423 BCE with you, Dr. Rad.

    Dr Rad 1:04:12
    Indeed has Dr. G. I will see you next time for 422 When no doubt we will still be referring back to this horrible year.

    Dr G 1:04:20
    Oh yeah. The legacy of this is going to take some time for Rome to get over Yeah, definitely.

    Dr Rad 1:04:44
    Thank you for listening to this episode of the Partial Historians. You can find our sources, sound credits and an automated transcript in our show notes. Our music is by Bettina Joy De Guzman, you too can support our show and help us to produce more engaging content about the ancient world by becoming a Patreon. In return, you receive exclusive early access to our special episodes. Today we'd like to give a special shout out to some of our heavy hitters or our most generous patrons in no particular order. Ryan, Frederick Michael D'Andrea, Amanda, Doron Vincent, Sean Virginia, Mickey Spurius de with Augustus, Steve, AJ, Molly, David, James, John, Kiley, Chris, Anna, Aaron, Robyn Kylie, Liz, Elise, Ted, Austin Annesley, Jacob, Theodore art, Savannah, Joel, Sharon, and Roman. You can also support us, however, by getting a copy of our collaboration with Bridget Clark from Gumroad or deck yourself out in Partial merchandise. But if all of these avenues are beyond your means, please just tell someone about the show or give us a five star review. We just love having stars in our eyes. Until next time, we are yours in ancient Rome.

    Transcribed by https://otter.ai

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    1 hr 8 min
  • How the Plebeians Got Their Groove Back

    In this episode we dig into the details (or lack thereof!) of 425 and 425 BCE. Good news for the plebeians is that when there's not much going on in Rome, they get a chance to just live life a little!

    Episode 136 – How the Plebeians Got Their Groove Back

    What's in a tribune?

    What’s the deal with military tribunes with consular power? We consider the etymology of tribune (the Latin tribunus) to better understand this facet of the political structure. This also means tackling the big question of: who were the magistrates in this period of history and how much can we take from our later writers like Livy and Dionsysius of Halicarnassus?

    Games, glorious games!

    The time is ripe for Rome to hold games in honour of the gods. There's no battle to be had and diplomacy in the local region seems to be taking a turn for peace. What better time to invite everyone over for some sport and festivities?

    Jean-Léon Gérôme 1876. Chariot Race.
    This is an imagined scene of a Roman chariot race at the Circus Maximus at the height of Rome's power (we're not up to that point in Rome's history in this episode!). The Circus itself is thought to be significantly old – dating back potentially as early as the kings.

    Things to listen out for
    • The horrifying lack of detail from the sources Dr G has to study
    • Livy writing a history of peace rather than war
    • Shocking revelations about Igor's (our resident eagle) paycheck
    • The return of the Claudii.
    Our Players 425 BCEMilitary Tribunes with Consular Power
    • Aulus Sempronius L. f. A. n. Atratinus (Pat) – Cos 428b
    • Lucius Quinctius L. f. L. n. Cincinnatus (Pat) (Broughton Cin. *3) – Cos 428b, military tribune with consular power 438
    • Lucius Furius Sp. f. – n. Medullinus (Pat), Military tribune with consular power in 432
    • Lucius Horatius M. f. M. n. Barbatus (Pat)
    Our Players 424 BCEMilitary Tribunes with Consular Power
    • Appius Claudius Ap. f. Ap. n. Crassus (Pat)
    • Spurius Nautius Sp. f. – n. Rutilus (Pat)
    • Lucius Sergius C. f. C. n. Fidenas (Pat) – previously cos. 437, 429; military tribune with consular power 433
    • Sextus Julius – f. – n. Iullus (Pat)
    Our Sources
    • Dr G reads Diodorus Siculus 12.81.1, 12.82.1
    • Dr Rad reads Livy ab Urbe Condita 4.35.
    • Broughton, T. R. S., Patterson, M. L. 1951. The Magistrates of the Roman Republic Volume 1: 509 B.C. – 100 B.C. (The American Philological Association)
    • Cornell, T. J. 1995. The Beginnings of Rome: Italy and Rome from the Bronze Age to the Punic Wars (c. 1000-264 BC) (Taylor & Francis)
    • Drogula, F. K. 2017. ‘Plebeian Tribune and the Government of Early Rome‘ Antichthon 51: 101-123
    Sound Effects

    Thanks to the fabulous Bettina Joy de Guzman for our theme music. Additional sound effects from BBC Beta.

    Greek black figure vase of a charioteer with four horses.
    This Athenian vase is obviously not a Roman artefact, but it's thought to date to c. 410-400 BCE which is very close to the period we explore in this episode. Gathering together for games and chariot racing was common across the Mediterranean. The Roman were likely inspired or influenced by ideas for games and races from the Greeks and the Etruscans.

    Automated Transcript

    Dr Rad 0:16
    Welcome to The Partial Historians.

    Dr G 0:20
    We explore all the details of ancient Rome.

    Dr Rad 0:23
    Everything from the political scandals, the love affairs, the battles waged, and when citizens turn against each other. I'm Dr. Rad.

    Dr G 0:34
    And I'm Dr. G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.

    Dr Rad 0:43
    Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.

    Hello, and welcome to a brand new episode of The Partial Historians. I'm Dr. Rad and this intelligent, ravishing creature next to me is

    Dr G 1:06
    Dr. G. Yay, I feel very complimented. Is it my sequined dinosaur t shirt?

    Dr Rad 1:12
    I mean, if that doesn't scream, intelligent and ravishing, I don't know what

    Dr G 1:16
    Ah, you're so kind!

    Dr Rad 1:19
    So I'm thrilled to be back that back again, in the studio, talking about Ancient Rome with you.

    Dr G 1:26
    Yeah we've been exploring Ancient Rome from the foundation of the city. And we are well into what is the early republic at this point, it's a roundabout 425

    Dr Rad 1:38
    It is

    Dr G 1:38
    BCE

    Dr Rad 1:39
    I feel like we've really raced ahead suddenly, like for a while, it was just like moving through slow setting cement. So I didn't feel like we could get out of the middle of the fifth century BCE. And here we are, we are getting so close to a new century.

    Dr G 1:55
    Things are speeding up. And I think we have to thank our missing source material,

    Dr Rad 2:00
    I was gonna say, probably not a good thing. It's the fact that everything seems to be a little bit blancker.

    Dr G 2:07
    There are a lot of fragments. But before we get into 425, and maybe what we could possibly know about it, let's do a little bit of a recap of where we're up to. And just think a little bit about 426. And where the land lay at that point.

    Dr Rad 2:23
    Well, it's a difficult one, because to give a recap of 426, Dr G, is but to give a recap of a 437 as well.

    Dr G 2:33
    It's a tough time in our Roman source material. And it's centered around this guy, all this Cornelius Cossus, who is most famous in all of Roman history for being one of the three Roman generals to achieve taking the spoila optima.

    Dr Rad 2:50
    I feel like that should have been a sign to them that they were maybe making it too high.

    Dr G 2:57
    All of Rome, only three men, well, maybe. But it's really challenging because it has to be somebody who is in the military in a significant position, taking down the enemy leader directly. So it's a commander taking out a commander, basically in single combat in amongst a whole other battle going on around them.

    Dr Rad 3:20
    And it makes it even more difficult because technically, he may not be that person, because he doesn't seem to matter, potentially, when he did this.

    Dr G 3:30
    Awkward awkward, like 426 is one of the years. He also could have done it in 428 when he was actual consul that would make narrative sense to me. Yeah. And that's the that's the date I would hone in on. But it could also have been as early as you say 437 – 438 as well. Yeah, so everything's a little bit hazy.

    Dr Rad 3:49
    But the bigger context for who all is Cossus. Sorry. Aulus Cornelius Cossus was fighting is Veii.

    Dr G 3:57
    Yes. Yeah. He's fighting the Etruscans. Yeah. And Rome at this point in time, the big picture is that Rome is sort of finding its way with its neighbors, like, how does it sit within the broader Italian landscape? Where do they do their strength lies? Who are their allies? Who are they against, and they're now butting up really closely against the Etruscans. And the city of Veii is the southern most Etruscan city we know of, and it is a mere 15 or 20 kilometers from Rome itself. And, you know, a good day's march – hard and fast – and you'll get there and you'll be ready to fight them by the next breakfast.

    Dr Rad 4:34
    Absolutely. And it also that conflict was they seem to be pivoting on the question of Fidenae, I think in whatever you're talking about. But in this past decade, it seems to be a real sore spot that this colony of Fidenae really wants to be sided with the Etruscans and every time they decide they're going to make the switch to room conflict ensues.

    Dr G 5:00
    Yeah, it's a tragic time Rome has convinced that Fidenae is theirs

    Dr Rad 5:04
    Yup

    Dr G 5:04
    And Fidenae is apparently a Roman colony from way back, depending on how you look at it. And Fidenae has defected they've thrown their lot in with the Etruscans. And Rome is less than pleased.

    Dr Rad 5:17
    Absolutely, they're not gonna take that. So as a result, we had a lot of military action in 426 BCE, rightly or wrongly, this is how it's come across to us with the Romans after having a difficult start pulling through Yeah,

    Dr G 5:35
    Whoo.

    Dr Rad 5:39
    Yeah, so that's kind of weird. Sarcasm may not be detected. So that's kind of where I think we ended up at the end 426, which is actually refreshing. Because the early 420s BC were a little dull. I'm not gonna lie.

    Dr G 6:01
    They were but as as 426 concludes, it feels like we've maybe reached the conclusion of a certain level of the combat because if the king of Veii, Lars Tolumnius has not died up until now. We think he must be dead by this point in time. Yeah. So that brings us to

    Dr Rad 6:23
    The extended deadline. Sorry, that brings us to

    Dr G 6:29
    425 BCE.

    Welcome one and all. Roll up, roll up for 425 BCE.

    Dr Rad 7:18
    Oh, yeah. Yeah.

    Dr G 7:22
    Dionysius of Halicarnassus is missing.

    Dr Rad 7:25
    Party on, Livy is not!

    Dr G 7:28
    The Fasti Capitolini are missing.

    Dr Rad 7:31
    Oh, really?

    Dr G 7:32
    They are. They've been missing for a little while now. And that?

    Dr Rad 7:34
    Well, you kept that quiet.

    Dr G 7:37
    I mean, there's there was no point to mention them. So this year, I have four military tribunes with consular power.

    Dr Rad 7:44
    Now, I would love for you to tell me their names, Dr G. But before you do that, I would like to pause because I was talking with a learned gentleman the other day, who asked me to explain where the title of tribune actually comes from.

    Dr G 8:03
    And it's a good question because it does have “tri-” in it. So a group of three, but we can already see with the plebeian tribunes that, maybe it depends.

    Dr Rad 8:13
    Sure. And I think it also has this link to the fact that Rome, that having at least according to their own history, Rome was organized into tribes. And so “tribune” was often a title given to someone who was the leader of some sort of group that had something to do with the tribal organization. And if we think about what you were saying in terms of the number and that idea of where does the word tribune comes from? Romulus originally divided the population of Rome up into three tribes, correct?

    Dr G 8:42
    Yes, correct. Yes.

    Dr Rad 8:44
    And so this is a title that a lot of people get in some form or another. So for example, obviously, we've got the tribune of the plebs. Now, we don't think that the tribune of the plebs have a particularly strong connection to the tribal structure to the ancient tribe. Yeah, no, we don't think so. But it makes sense, obviously, that they are presiding over a body where people are organized, it is a tribal assembly, essentially, that they presiding over as well. So there's a connection there. It's also just a say a word that the Romans start to use for these people who are leading some sort of tribal group. And I'd say it's also something that therefore, the more they get into the habit of using that for these people, the more that the practice of using that term, obviously, continues on. And then obviously, when we've got military tribunes and military tribunes refer to leaders, obviously, of a particular army group. Again, probably very early on in Rome's history, there was probably some sort of tribal organization to the group that they were commanding, but eventually it doesn't have anything to do with that, but the title stays.

    Dr G 9:49
    Yes, yeah, the meaning changes, but the would remain where it lives on.

    Dr Rad 9:53
    And so obviously military tribunes with consular power is, you know, apparently the Romans putting this idea of well plebeians they don't have the auspicium to be, you know, they can't be a consul like the patricians can, we have the auspicium we you know monopolizing all the auspicium that's out there, so you can't hold that position and therefore they give it they've used this position this military tribunes and given it the you know the authority or the power of the consul without giving it the actual consulship. So yeah, it's a very fine line isn't so complicated try and explain.

    And yet for all of the explanations that are put forward for the idea that these military tribunes with consular power should open up the position to people who aren't necessarily patrician, what we tend to find is that they're largely patrician.

    Yes. And see, I was really it's really interesting article the other day, which puts forward this argument that at this point in Rome's history, this idea of consuls, praetors, military tribunes with consular power, it's just nearly allies, because this person was saying that it seems as though Rome, obviously, is, as we've been talking about as much of the stuff that we've been talking about, I suppose, but taking it a little bit further, that Rome has this narrative that they got rid of the kings, and then they seamlessly transitioned into this Republican system, which is suspiciously similar to the late Republic.

    Dr G 11:33
    Yeah

    Dr Rad 11:33
    Yeah. And that, in this in this particular context, in early Rome, this person has suggested that actually, there are no senior magistrates, so consuls, praetors, military tribunes with consular power, it doesn't exist at this point in time. It's something that exists a bit later, probably about if we're at 425 right now, probably, what about 80 years, that's when we start to see the appearance of these sorts of things. And that really, we've just got patricians, which is much what we've seen monopolizing power. So because they are wealthy, they have resources, they have clients, they've been able to monopolize power in the countryside. And if we look at the names that the tribes have been given out in the countryside, like outside of the pomerium, outside of the city of Rome itself, they kind of reflect the power that these people hold. So like they might be named after a particular gentes. So like, Aemelia, or whatever. And then if we look at the tribes within the city, that's not the case. It's the tribal names are more reflective of like, where you live, you know, it's like the Palatina or something like,

    Dr G 12:40
    Yeah, look, I think it's pretty fair to take the position that the way that state structures form is slow. And it's a process. And things are not necessarily set in structures that make sense. And structures have to alter and change.

    Dr Rad 13:01
    Yup

    Dr G 13:02
    And adapt to situations. And part of the challenge for historians is that there is very few ways for us to get closer to what actually may have happened in the past than we already are.

    Dr Rad 13:18
    Yeah, for sure.

    Dr G 13:19
    And so these written sources that we're relying on, whether it's the fasti, whether it's Dionysius or Livy, these people are doing the best they can, I like to give them the benefit of the doubt – doing the best they can with the information that they have at hand. But the way that information is kept and conveyed over time is problematic. Yeah. And it's not rigorous in the same way like we live in this internet age where we have an overabundance, if you like of information, yeah, that doesn't mean that it's easy to access the information that is actually useful, and, and good and true. Yeah. And we know that truth is a multiplicity, depending on your subjectivity. So if we take all of those ideas that we understand into account, the complexity of what's at play here is far beyond what we're going to be able to discern from the source material. Yeah. And there's lots of things that we don't know. So the best that we can say in this sort of case is that, yes, you know, something like the name “tribune” has a couple of different sort of etymological connections that it could draw upon to make it make sense. But at the same time, it's clearly in use, and when language is in use, meanings change and adapt to the necessity of the moment.

    Dr Rad 14:33
    Absolutely.

    Dr G 14:34
    Not holding true to the etymology of how it originally came about.

    Dr Rad 14:39
    Yeah. And I think this is the thing I as you say, I don't believe I mean, I like to say “Liza Minnelli lies”, but I don't think that as you say that they're totally making this up, doesn't mean that these people that we're talking about didn't exist. It doesn't mean that the actions they took weren't taken, the events didn't happen and that sort of thing. I think it's kind of more the maybe the top titles that people held and that sort of thing, or the idea that maybe that the state was quite so formalized, which is something that we have been talking about for a really long time in this early Republican period. And I kind of I must admit, I was kind of convinced by the idea that when you look at the, even in the, in the periods where we're a bit more convinced of the fact that like the consulship, or the apprenticeship or whatever the title was given did exist, the kinds of things that those people would do are military. This idea that you might have a division of power between civilian and military positions, and therefore, these people that we're talking about, like, there's no doubt that there were people out there wielding military power. Definitely the patricians held that.

    Dr G 15:45
    I mean, it seems likely.

    Dr Rad 15:46
    It seems very likely. I mean, that makes total sense. And therefore this idea that, you know, these guys are the ones commanding the armies makes 100% sense. It's a good question, I suppose is, do they actually hold this formalized position? And are they quite as dominant inside the city as the sources sometimes make it sound? Because what this article was arguing was more the fact that it was probably more like minor officials who are doing the sort of day to day governance kind of stuff. So the people who are you know, like the neighborhood leaders, I think they're called like the things like the curio maximus or something like

    Dr G 16:24
    Oh, yeah, I love a good curio maximus.

    Dr Rad 16:27
    Yeah. So like, like neighborhood leaders and and people who hold slightly more localized positions, who are keeping things running on the inside of the city, because of course. Rome does have this really interesting ban on military power inside the pomerium. You know, the fact that the fact that military assemblies that generals, soldiers, they all have to say outside of the pomerium, and it means that whilst the patricians might be able to throw their weight around in terms of military matters, they need a different outlet for that inside the city. And that comes back to what we've talked about before in terms of them potentially dominating the priesthood. And therefore being able to keep control over things like war, and judicial matters through there, kind of just cutting of the knowledge around how things actually work. And so a lot of the stuff that we've said makes sense. It's just, it just maybe you take away the sort of official titles.

    Oh yeah, we've got no guarantees on titles around here.

    But I just I just thought that was interesting, because it's so hit the mark with so many of the things that we've been talking about, in terms of the fact that like, these ideas, and these structures probably come in later, but you can still see the events happening. And, you know, the patricians and plebeians potentially having issues of tension around who has power and the tribune of the plebs coming out of that, in terms of being able to provide protection, particularly the tribune of the plebs being connected to the city of Rome, where the patricians don't have that military power. It just, it was just really interesting to sort of see that all coming together. In one article, which I was like, Yeah, this makes this makes sense to me.

    Dr G 18:12
    Ah look, and I think this sort of thing is really important, because we're not sure how, how the Roman state really develops, like, you know, they they tell this history about themselves? Yeah. And that's fine. And we're going through it and sort of, you know, delving into it as we go along. But we're not sure about consuls at this point in time. We're not sure about tribunes at this point in time, we're not sure about the social division between the petitions and the plebeians as even being a plausible thing at this time. And so we're dealing with a murky history of Rome, where Rome, leader Romans are trying to interpret and understand themselves by sort of like retrojecting, like what would be the previous steps? Yeah. What would make sense for this thing to exist now? And they sort of they see it as a gradual sort of process. But it's open to interpretation.

    Dr Rad 19:12
    I think, I think the base story 100% make sense, which is you've got powerful, a powerful aristocracy, which is able to assert itself and remain dominant for some time once you no longer have a king. Yeah, because there's no, there's no one keeping them in check anymore. And then you have the people reacting against abuses of power and corruption. And that's where you get the birth of something like the tribune of the plebs. And luckily for them, the tribunes of the plebs. Well, luckily, I mean, that's not a coincidence, but with the development of the tribune of the plebs developing that power of or that oath being taken to protect them physically, you know, so making them in violet It offers them a level of protection, particularly because they are based in the city.

    Dr G 20:06
    You might not be able to have a sword in the city, but nobody can stop you getting beaten up unless we say so.

    Dr Rad 20:11
    Yeah exactly. But that idea of there being protection and the fact that the Romans, who are the elite, they can't just bring their soldiers in and kill these guys. I mean, if you think about this article, make the point. That's really annoying, because I want this guy. Well, they're making the point of like, how easily did they get rid of Spurius Maelius? Well, pretty easily, pretty much he wasn't attributing but I think they broke the state to do it. Well, sure. But like, at the end of the day, they got rid of him pretty easily. And he wasn't a tribune, he was just like a guy that that was making trouble for them. Why wouldn't they do that with the tribune unless they are respecting this?

    Dr G 20:46
    Yeah, but we also don't know when tribunes becomes inviolable,

    Dr Rad 20:49
    I know

    Dr G 20:50
    And we also don't really know when the pomerium becomes the be all and end all of entering or not with a sword.

    Dr Rad 20:56
    No, but it just it just made. It just made sense to me in the sense of like, the fact that there are more tribunes, it seems than there are, say consuls, like if we're going by the official

    Dr G 21:06
    Oh, yeah.

    Dr Rad 21:07
    Two consuls.

    Dr G 21:07
    And I think part of this and we will get on to those military tribunes. I'm not going to leave you hanging

    Dr Rad 21:13
    Pause for the longest digression known to man. Hi Herodotus!

    Dr G 21:17
    Hello, hello. We'll come back to those guys in a sec. But the thing with the military tribunes with consular power, is that it is clear that even from the like the long distance of looking back over like 300-400 years of history, yeah, that people in the late Republic understood Rome as not being an all powerful entity right off the bat, for sure. It is a city of struggle. Yeah. And it is not just a struggle, which results in having to exile kings and getting rid of the whole idea altogether. It's a struggle to build a workable idea of how a state looks if it's not run by one person.

    Dr Rad 21:59
    Yeah, absolutely.

    Dr G 22:00
    They really struggling to figure out how to do it. And they're being pressed at this point in time from all sides. Everybody around them wants nothing to do with them. It is a constant jostling. And it seems like every city state, essentially because you could think of them as sort of isolated states, that they're all struggling for their and jostling for their position in central Italy right now. And Rome is just another city trying to do its best.

    Dr Rad 22:28
    Oh, yeah, absolutely. And that's what's I mean, this, this kind of made sense to me. And also, I mean, also the idea that Rome will continue to be struggling to assert itself for quite some time. And the idea that consuls are a good idea that consuls and praetors don't really develop a strong connection to like civil administration and civil governance until quite some time later, because they're still dealing with all his military stuff. Like that's still their main point of existence and still there.

    Dr G 23:02
    Yeah, you gotta have that imperium. You know what I'm saying? You gotta have it.

    Dr Rad 23:05
    Yeah, yeah, exactly. And I was like, Yeah, you know that that is true. And the fact that tribune of the plebs obviously become, you know, so powerful, but again, over time,

    Dr G 23:16
    Yeah, very much over time, and we see them struggling here.

    Dr Rad 23:22
    Digression done, thank you for indulging me

    Dr G 23:24
    It was a pleasure. Always always interesting. So military tribunes with consular power it's 425 BCE. Yeah. Who have we got riding that wagon? Well, Aulus Sempronius Atratinus.

    Dr Rad 23:39
    A name I've heard before

    Dr G 23:40
    Yes, you might remember him as being part of the suffect consulship in 428. Lucius Quinctius Cincinnatus.

    Dr Rad 23:51
    Another name is very familiar, but not the guy that you're thinking of.

    Dr G 23:54
    Also suffect consul 428. Lucius Furius. Medullinus, military tribune with consular power in 432. And Lucius Horatius Barbatus nobody's ever heard of him before.

    Dr Rad 24:13
    But we have heard the name Horatii

    Dr G 24:16
    We have, but it's it's interesting to me that we've got three out of our four military tributes people who have either previously held the consulship or the military tribunate with consular power. Yeah, previously true. So which makes me think Rome is in dire straits this year, because they've only picked really experienced dudes to come back into the situation. interesting take on it. Yeah, except for Barbartus, the bready one who you know might be somebody's protege.

    Dr Rad 24:45
    Okay, well get ready to be blown away, Dr. G, by what am I about to tell you based on Livy's account?

    Dr G 24:50
    Oh, yeah.

    Dr Rad 24:51
    Are you ready for it?

    Dr G 24:51
    I am.

    Dr Rad 24:52
    Can you handle it?

    Dr G 24:52
    I don't know.

    Dr Rad 24:54
    Well, let's let's see. Alright, so 425. Livy tells me that Veii was granted a truce that was supposed to last for 20 years. And the Aequians were granted a truce of three years now. They had wanted more. But that is all there we're going to get from Rome. And that's it.

    Dr G 25:17
    That's it?

    Dr Rad 25:18
    That's it. Explicitly he says there were no foreign problems and no domestic problems. That is it.

    Dr G 25:25
    Wow. All of that experience in the military tribunate and for what?

    Dr Rad 25:30
    Well, this is why I was curious. I was like,

    Dr G 25:35
    Just you wait,

    Dr Rad 25:37
    Do they need all this experience? I don't know that they do.

    Dr G 25:41
    I mean, maybe I mean, I understand that, you know, the war with Fidenae has been concluded because you know, they they shoved a whole bunch of the troublemakers into Ostia, we populated Fidenae with some Romans, we like you to behave yourselves now.

    Dr Rad 25:54
    Yeah. And then there was slaughter, so much slaughter.

    Dr G 25:58
    But I didn't realize that the situation with Veii was coming about. So I did a bit of a timeline. A recap. Oh, okay. Yeah, cuz I've got nothing to talk about. I've no source material.

    Dr Rad 26:08
    Go for it.

    Dr G 26:08
    I mean, I've got Diodorus Siculus, who, you know, questionable, and

    Dr Rad 26:11
    You may as well have no sources.

    Dr G 26:13
    Oh, I like that man, but he's very focused on the Peloponnesian War. But to just do a bit of a backstory and Fidenae. And what's been going on in 438, Fidenae defects from Rome. That is the crucial moment. And apparently this is on the advice of the king of a Lars Tolumnius. Like, wow, you know, I saw… I saw this situation and I think you should defect. And it's at that point that Fidenae follows what appears to be a trust and advice and slaughters the Roman ambassadors.

    Dr Rad 26:45
    Yeah. Who could forget? Who could forget the headless men.

    Dr G 26:48
    The statue still stands. Yeah. When Dionysius and Livy are writing, yeah. 437: There is there is war, war begins. Rome is not having anything to do with this. And depending on which source you read, and where you are in the timeline, this is exactly when Cossus killed Lars Tolumnius and deals with that situation.

    Dr Rad 27:07
    Excellent.

    Dr G 27:08
    We think that might be not true. 435 – we have the dictator Quintus Servilius, who captures Fidenae by tunneling under the Citadel. Yep, thrilling stuff.

    Dr Rad 27:20
    I did like that. That was strategy. You know, that was real strategy.

    Dr G 27:23
    One year, one tunnel later. And it doesn't last though. So in 434, we've got Mamercus Aemelius appointed dictator, because of the threat from Veii. And this is, you know, the tension between the Fidenae and the Veii situation. All connected.

    Dr Rad 27:43
    It fizzles out ,right?

    Dr G 27:44
    There. It is a bit of a fizzer.

    Dr Rad 27:45
    Yeah.

    Dr G 27:46
    428: Cornelius Cossus consul. Yep. The Veii people are raiding Roman territory. I mean, they've got lots of ways of saying.

    Dr Rad 27:57
    It just sounds funny.

    Dr G 27:59
    The people of Veii. And Rome dispatches a triumviral commission to investigate Fidenae's participation in the raids. led by Veii. 427: yeah, Rome sends out the fetiales to demand redress from Veii,

    Dr Rad 28:18
    Ah who could forget?

    Dr G 28:20
    And then declares war, because they do not get redress

    Dr Rad 28:23
    Jupiter as my witness

    Dr G 28:25
    426: Cossus and three other military tribunes, Mamercus Aemelius, dictator for the third time; Cossus is master of the horse. It's all happening. They defeat Fidenae and Veii. Yeah, so that's like the previous year. And now it ends with a truce. And now it's truce time.

    Dr Rad 28:43
    Really long truce. 20 years?

    Dr G 28:46
    Well, I mean, at least a 10. And a bit.

    Dr Rad 28:49
    No, no, the truce is 20.

    Dr G 28:51
    Oh, it's much longer than the conflict.

    Dr Rad 28:53
    That's what I mean!

    Dr G 28:55
    We'll see if it lasts. Yeah, yeah. So apparently, there's three surviving monuments in Rome to this conflict with Fidenae. So we do think it has some historical basis beyond…

    Dr Rad 29:05
    The question is, did it last over this length of time? Or is it something that just happened at one of these points in time? And the Romans are confused?

    Dr G 29:16
    I think it would make sense for it to be a prolonged conflict.

    Dr Rad 29:19
    But this length, this length, or in this order, or in this order?

    Dr G 29:23
    Well, I don't know if Rome is a capable military force right now. I mean, they want to be but you know, sometimes it doesn't work out.

    Dr Rad 29:29
    They think that's why they get so annoyed when they don't do well like last episode.

    Dr G 29:33
    So there's the statue commemorating the four Roman ambassadors who

    Dr Rad 29:38
    Possibly headless, not sure.

    Dr G 29:41
    Yeah, we'd have to find the statue. Yeah, and then be like, Oh, no, that heedlessness is a deliberate artistic choice. We've got the spoila optima won by Cossus, which is attested in the time of Augustus. He says

    Dr Rad 29:53
    By Augustus himself

    Dr G 29:54
    He says he's seen it so I wouldn't want to disbelieve Augustus because risk of death is high.

    Dr Rad 29:59
    God knows he never lies.

    Dr G 30:02
    Don't be like that about my favorite. There is a golden crown that is also apparently dedicated in the Capitoline temple.

    Dr Rad 30:09
    Well, that's right, because the dictator was made to dedicate it, apparently in 437.

    Dr G 30:14
    Yeah. So all of these physical objects that attest to oh, look, the history,

    Dr Rad 30:19
    I have no doubt there was conflict with Veii. But it's just a question of, like, as I say, like did it all happen when they're saying how they're saying.

    Dr G 30:27
    Yeah, well, I mean, who can say but that's all I've got for this year.

    Dr Rad 30:30
    Fair enough. All right. Let me take you on to 424 then.

    Neil – History Hound 30:40
    Hello to listeners of the Partial Historians, and thank you to the Partial Historians. My name is Neil and I'm the host creator and pretty much everything of the Ancient History Hound Podcast. I'm all about ancient history, and this includes ancient Greece, Rome and other cultures from antiquity. I cover a wide range of topics. I'm sure there's something for you, but why not find out for yourself? Ancient History Hound is probably on the platform you're using right now. So come and find me and have a scroll through the episodes. I reckon there's something there for you. And it'd be great to have you join me.

    Dr Rad 31:19
    In 424, we once again have military tribunes with consular power. So who have we got Dr. G?

    Dr G 31:27
    We have Appius Claudius Crassus. Yes, Appius Claudius returns. This is the son of the infamous decemvir. Yeah, this family well, they don't know when to quit.

    Dr Rad 31:41
    I knew it wasn't the decemvir.

    Dr G 31:43
    No he's done.

    Dr Rad 31:44
    He died shady circumstances.

    Dr G 31:46
    But his son was allowed to survive and thus the line of Claudii is perpetuated.

    Dr Rad 31:53
    Look, I'll only be okay with that because eventually it'll give me my favorite topic to study: The Julio-Claudius

    Dr G 32:00
    Tiberius.

    Dr Rad 32:02
    There's a lot more to the Claudians than just Tiberius. Livia, huh? She marries into it but whatever.

    Dr G 32:11
    Spurius Nautious Rutilus, a patrician,

    Dr Rad 32:15
    Yep.

    Dr G 32:15
    Lucius Sergius Fidenas,

    Dr Rad 32:15
    Ah the hero Fidenae.

    Dr G 32:19
    Yeah. Previously consul in 437 and 429, military tribune with consular power in 433 – fancy. All right. And Sextus Julius Iullus.

    Dr Rad 32:35
    Still think that name should not be allowed to exist. Just sounds all shades of wrong.

    Dr G 32:40
    Iullus?

    Dr Rad 32:40
    Yeah. No just like the the Julius Iullus.

    Dr G 32:44
    Ah, yeah, it doesn't. Oh, it doesn't flow off the tongue.

    Dr Rad 32:47
    To be honest, it sounds like I'm making fun of him. And I'm not.

    Dr G 32:51
    It's his name.

    Dr Rad 32:52
    Yeah. All right. Well, you'll be relieved to hear I do have a little bit more detail from Livy in this year.

    Dr G 32:58
    Oh, that's exciting. So I mean, Dionysus is predictably missing.

    Dr Rad 33:02
    Okay. Yeah, I was prepared for that this time.

    Dr G 33:05
    As is the fasti Capitolini. I have some Diodorus Siculus.

    Dr Rad 33:09
    Okay. Tell me what it is. I'll tell you what's wrong.

    Dr G 33:13
    Well, there's some seems to be some question mark over the praenomen of Appius Claudius. Is it Appius? Or is it Titus? Hmm. Diadorus, says Titus. And as we know, Diodorus is often wrong.

    Dr Rad 33:33
    Look, if I know anything about the Romans is that they are very unimaginative within names.

    Dr G 33:39
    This is true. So I mean, time is is a possibility. It's within the remit of like well known Roman praenomens. But Appius Claudius makes sense as if he is the eldest son of Appius Claudius, the decemvir.

    Dr Rad 33:53
    Exactly.

    Dr G 33:54
    Yes. You always just call your kid your name, and hope for the best.

    Dr Rad 33:58
    And if we know anything about Appius Claudius the decemvir, it is that he is an egomaniac. So I think

    Dr G 34:07
    Maybe all of his sons are called Appius Claudius.

    Dr Rad 34:10
    I wouldn't put it past him, Dr G.

    Dr G 34:11
    Appius Claudius Secondo?

    Dr Rad 34:14
    Yeah, I think it makes sense. The name would be Appius.

    Dr G 34:19
    And that's pretty much it. Diodorus Siculus does an alright, job on a couple of other names. Okay, and also gets another one slightly wrong, so it doesn't really merit going into it.

    Dr Rad 34:31
    All right. Okay. Well, 424 begins with Livy telling me that once again, there are no issues within the city of Rome and no walls to be fought outside of the city. Which makes me wonder, Dr. G, is Rome losing its edge?

    Dr G 34:50
    Or is Dionysius not writing about things he's not missing? It's just that nothing happens. So he doesn't say anything.

    Dr Rad 34:56
    You know what? That's actually a very intelligent suggestion.

    Dr G 35:01
    Okay, wait a minute, I have a new topic I could write about

    Dr Rad 35:04
    You do. Alright, so the only thing that's really happening is a nice thing. It just goes to show how little this happens. I feel really uncomfortable talking about this because it's just so rare that we record something nice. History recording only the bad stuff since the BCEs.

    Dr G 35:23
    I'm really intrigued, what nice thing has been recorded?

    Dr Rad 35:26
    There are some games happening. Dr. G.

    Dr G 35:28
    Oh, well, they're not very nice once you delve into them. I mean…

    Dr Rad 35:32
    Well, I mean, for the Romans they're nice.

    Dr G 35:34
    I mean, yeah, but it's like killing animals. It's not my cup of tea watching people die.

    Dr Rad 35:41
    At this point in time, at this point in time, gladiators another thing? I don't think

    Dr G 35:47
    No, no. But the what kind of games are they playing?

    Dr Rad 35:51
    Well, he hasn't given me an itemized list. There's no ferris wheel if that's what you're wondering. Yeah. So basically,

    Dr G 35:58
    There's a boat show on the Tiber.

    Dr Rad 36:00
    It's a fulfillment of a promise, Dr G. There had previously been games vowed during the war and the military tribunes are just fulfilling that promise. So lots of neighboring people from the area are included. Okay. They've gotten over the whole, you know, Sabine abduction thing.

    Dr G 36:20
    It sounds to me like it's going to have some chariot racing. That would make sense.

    Dr Rad 36:24
    yeah. And look, the Romans are determined to go all out. They want to be the hosts with the most.

    Dr G 36:29
    I said that last time, and we all saw what happened to the Sabine women…

    Dr Rad 36:33
    But this time, they really mean it. They're really laying it on thick. They want to be the most courteous game givers in the whole of their little limited area.

    Dr G 36:42
    Everybody come?

    Dr Rad 36:43
    Yeah. Now, I'm going to say the T word. It's time to talk about some tribunes.

    Dr G 36:49
    Oh, dear.

    Dr Rad 36:50
    Yeah. That's right. So plebeian tribunes, they decide games. Perfect time to cause trouble.

    Dr G 36:58
    Something does happen in this year

    Dr Rad 37:00
    Well Livy says it starts out that way, which makes sense, because it's continuation from the previous year, which was really boring.

    Dr G 37:06
    Fair enough. Fair enough. Okay. All right. I'll strap myself back in again.

    Dr Rad 37:09
    And maybe the tribunes are also thinking the same thing I am, which is that Rome is losing its edge. You gotta like shake things up a little bit. We're gonna cause some chaos. Yeah. All right. So they start making some speeches, which are clearly designed to rile people up. Okay. They're saying they're really angry with the people of Rome, because it seems like they adore the men that the attributes of the plebs themselves despise. And I presume that they're meaning the patricians? Yeah, it would make sense.

    Dr G 37:43
    Yes. I hate those guys.

    Dr Rad 37:45
    Exactly. And they're like, people are not rising up against these aristocrats.

    Dr G 37:52
    But I love a good chariot race. Can I do this revolution later?

    Dr Rad 37:56
    No, we can't. Shut up, Timmy. They're basically saying, Why aren't you guys seizing opportunities? You aren't running for military tribune with the consular power. What is going on? Like you're allowed to, you're allowed to What? What? They're losing their mind.

    Dr G 38:20
    It looks like a tough job. You know, I've got I got this family to feed and this farm situation of I can't spend a year away from the harvest. You know, it's going to be no man. No.

    Dr Rad 38:33
    So the tribunes point out that look, if this is the way that you're going to behave, then you have no right to complain anymore, that people aren't working hard on your behalf to try and make your lives a little bit better.

    Dr G 38:49
    That's it. We got to get together and protest. I definitely want to keep complaining. Yeah,

    Dr Rad 38:53
    they're like, look, we don't like being tribune of the plebs is a great gig. You ungrateful plebeians. It's friggin hard work. And it's super dangerous. And for what? What am I doing this for? There's no reward for being tribune of the plebs. Always we get is patricians hating us and targeting us. And that's hardly a reward if you guys aren't even going to use the rights that we have worked so hard to procure for you.

    Dr G 39:29
    Wow. I mean, it does sound like Livy is making the tribunate sound like a pretty lame place to be.

    Dr Rad 39:36
    Exactly. And this is where the article I was talking about comes in again, because it points out that if we actually think that maybe there were no official senior magistracies like consul or preator or military tribute with consular power, then potentially tribune of the plebs was actually a relatively influential position, but, as you have heard, later we don't really know what. But it's certainly different to the other major cities which will develop in that they have very clear guidelines about this is the power that you have to achieve these goals.

    Dr G 40:16
    Yeah.

    Dr Rad 40:16
    And that's your area. tribune of the plebs is very much more flexible. And it really is about the fact that the people seem to have originally taken this oath that they are going to protect you.

    Dr G 40:25
    Yeah, we want some representation. And it's really shaped by the people in the role. So really, if these tribune of the plebs are a little bit upset about how that is going for them, I suggest they do something.

    Dr Rad 40:25
    Well, and this is a thing. This is potentially how the tribune of the plebs becomes more powerful, because the more that they have, the more that they can sort of play fast and loose with the fact that they can't be killed. Technically, I mean, like they can, obviously, but

    Dr G 40:53
    I'm immortal.

    Dr Rad 41:00
    Technically, obviously, unless somebody wants to get themselves into a whole lot of trouble, they can't be killed. And they only hang out in the city. So protection stance. Force field activate: the pomerium is up.

    Dr G 41:14
    I don't want to get into a religious do-do so. I'm gonna let you live.

    Dr Rad 41:18
    Yeah. So the more that they can exploit that, the more that they can push their position into interesting developments, which might explain why they eventually get veto power and not just veto power over like each other, but like, veto power. I do love this. Actually, this is not for much later, but I just have to say it now. I'll say it again later. I didn't realize that when tribunes were first allowed to attend Senate meetings so that they could use their veto power. They initially weren't allowed to actually be in the room. They had to sit outside and shout “Veto!”.

    Dr G 41:54
    Yeah, like those moments where like, you have Agrippina behind a curtain? Yeah. Really. Like I'm listening. I'm listening.

    Dr Rad 42:00
    But even more hilarious that they're actually like, everyone knows they're there. Yeah.

    Dr G 42:03
    They're expecting them to stand outside and yell in “veto!”.

    Dr Rad 42:08
    We're not going to do that

    Dr G 42:08
    Stop that!

    Dr Rad 42:09
    Stop that right now. Yeah. So anyway, that was just that was a total another tangent. But it is interesting to think about the fact that potentially these people, you know, well, this makes sense. And again, it's just like that classic thing that they set up here of these senior magistrates, who apparently so important for legislation and that kind of stuff. And like, are they? Are they the people doing this? I don't know. But anyway, anywho. So they say, Look, guys, it is time, it is time to see how the state will fare if a poor ban actually hold a magistracy for GOD'S SAKE like, the patricians sold us when we pushed for this, that no, no, you can't do it, you don't have the auspicium to carry out all the duties that come with the role. And even though we fought for you to have exactly such a role, you're not taking it up. And therefore it kind of seems like maybe two beings can't do it. So we have to end it and end it now. We must have a plane isn't going to take a freaking miracle to find a plebeian who can hold military tribune and with consular power. I think not! We need someone with courage and energy, who's going to revitalize the institution.

    Dr G 43:30
    That's very Churchillian of you. But I don't know that they're going to get their wish in this year in particular, or next year for that matter. In fact, I don't think this is going to I don't think they're going to achieve this for years.

    Dr Rad 43:42
    Well, I kind of like the way that Livy says that. Finally, like a decade or two, of being relentlessly nagged by the attributes of the plebs. Apparently, it's only now that the plebeians really start to register.

    Dr G 43:59
    Me. Oh, I see what you're saying. You. So what you meant back then, was that I could I could go for the role. Yes. What you were saying? Oh, when you first said that's not how I heard it, you know?

    Dr Rad 44:16
    But to be fair, to be fair, when he says is that basically when they first got the option to run for military tribute with consular power, they felt okay about it, because for beings have obviously shown over the years that they're capable of leading, usually in a military sense. So we've had some standout for being soldiers, commanders, that sort of thing. Well, sorry. Take that back, not command. We've had some outstanding soldiers

    Dr G 44:42
    We have: Dentatus.

    Dr Rad 44:44
    True, exactly what a man who could forget. Yeah. So we've had those sorts of people so clearly, they can do that. We've also had many plebeians who are honorable, who are courageous people, those sorts of people did try and run office when it was first a possibility, but they were bullied, Dr. G…

    Dr G 45:06
    By who?

    Dr Rad 45:07
    Bullied so hard by the patricians that they gave up and they'd rather be embarrassed and not run for office. Then try at all. So there.

    Dr G 45:17
    Wow, that is not the Roman spirit.

    Dr Rad 45:20
    It really isn't. It actually sounds extremely high school to me. It does, yeah, that you're gonna let you know, let these beliefs push you around and tell you what you can and cannot do. But also I think Tina Fey would have something to say about that.

    Dr G 45:34
    Are you going to just give up at the first hurdle? Of course, the patricians hate you. They've always hated you. That's why they patricians.

    Dr Rad 45:42
    Well, look, the tribune of the plebs are so fed up with this situation that they're like, You know what? Maybe we should even remove the option.

    Dr G 45:54
    Oh, no, no, no, no winding back. No, no, no, no,

    Dr Rad 46:00
    Because it would be better to not actually have the option that's like not being used, then have it? And no one go for it. Because that's just embarrassing.

    Dr G 46:11
    Excuse me? Yeah. What, what if somebody wants to go for it just like?

    Dr Rad 46:16
    It's making, it's making them all look bad.

    Dr G 46:18
    It's not, it's just, you know, it's only embarrassing because they've decided they're embarrassed about it. I need to go back in time and have a stern chat with these people.

    Dr Rad 46:29
    The tribunes are feeling pretty bad about it. So I think you just have to go with their feelings, Dr G.. And you know, this is how they're feeling about it. Luckily, though, the plebeians say, You know what, yes, we will run for office, we absolutely will take you up on that offer. And they promise all the standard things that any Italian citizen could ever want. And that is placing attacks on landowners.

    Dr G 46:57
    Nice.

    Dr Rad 46:57
    Yeah. And using that money to pay for soldiers.

    Dr G 47:01
    Nice.

    Dr Rad 47:02
    Yep. Because, of course, who's mostly the rank and file?

    Dr G 47:05
    The plebeians?

    Dr Rad 47:07
    Yeah, exactly. It'd be nice if we didn't have to pay for our own kit every time. Yeah. And then there also seems to be that age old issue, Dr. G, of land, and land allotment?

    Dr G 47:18
    Ah, redistribution of the property?

    Dr Rad 47:21
    Yep. Yep, exactly. So I think it will shock nobody for me to say that these policies sound extremely Gracchan in nature and therefore, late Republican. However, that's not to say that they're not also fair for the early republic, just you know, a little suspicious.

    Dr G 47:41
    The land is pretty important. I think. Land is capital. Yeah. And so you could do a Marxist reading of this as well. Owning the land and redistributing the land. Yeah. Is seizing the means of production? Yeah. Because that's how you go the green in the first place? Sure. Yeah. That you need to do anything.

    Dr Rad 48:01
    Yeah, this is true. This is true. Yeah. So you know, maybe that is what they went for. But they're at least giving it a go, whether their policies are stolen from a later century or not.

    Dr G 48:13
    I see. I see. And is this the year? This is it? Yeah. Okay. All right. Well, I really have nothing to add, in terms of the narrative, because I mean, one, you've done a great job of conveying the narrative to me my end, it is clear that, you know, there are some tensions that are being very much rejected at this point into this period. And fair enough. And because I lack so much source material, what I did instead was I was like, Well, where does Rome really sit? In this moment of time, because it's been a Republic for, you know, a wee while now. And

    Dr Rad 48:49
    We're coming up to 100 years.

    Dr G 48:51
    Yeah, we're nearly there. So it's time to celebrate and have a bit of a birthday. And one of the things that has come up with this conflict with Veii and Fidenae is that Rome does have some colonies. So there's like little outposts here and there that are considered to be Roman. And we've come across this before. We've seen it with Ardea as well, in particular. And so I went through and you know, Cornell was great, provided me a list of the places that Rome is said to have colonized early on. So Fidenae quite early, a place called Signia, Circeii, Cora, Pomezia, Velitrae, Norba, Antium, and Ardea. So we're like, we're up to like maybe like nine or 10 different areas, which by the time that we're in, in this 424, period, right, also have a Roman population of sorts. So it's not just the city of Rome, it's starting to expand out they've got a foothold in some different places. Losing something like Fidenae is a problem, not just because of its strategic value, but because of the message it sends to those other areas that they've colonized, you know, or well, if one can successfully break away, well, maybe some more could break away as well, because it sets up this kind of buffer zone around Rome itself, that gets harder to for an enemy to get close to the city. And so I'm interested in the way that Rome is shifting gradually, slowly in their understanding of themselves as not just being about the city, but being about a state that expands beyond that. And they're starting to grow out. And we've been starting to see it for a little while. But that's kind of the lay of the land where we're at at the moment.

    Dr Rad 50:41
    You know what, I know that that's probably not too bad. But I'm actually surprised it's not more. I guess it's because so many of the wars we've been talking about. They are defensive more than anything,

    Dr G 50:53
    And they're mostly inconclusive, and somebody steals the booty one year, somebody steals back the booty the next year. It's not like territorial acquisition

    Dr Rad 51:02
    Second-hand arse.

    Dr G 51:05
    Well, you know, I mean, if I have to win something, better that than nothing.

    Dr Rad 51:11
    No, thank you that geography is never my strong point. So I do appreciate it when others provide a geographical context for me.

    Dr G 51:21
    Look, I'm sorry to say that we don't know where a lot of these are necessarily. I mean, some we do we have to see it and not now they can't be that far away. I don't think they're far away now. So I actually think this is probably a good place to wrap up this episode, indeed.

    Dr Rad 51:35
    So we got tribunes causing issues as they are want to do.

    Dr G 51:41
    They really just want the best for the plebs. I think and, you know, don't we all?

    Dr Rad 51:45
    Look, I do. You know, what, sometimes it takes, you know, authority figures getting really angry with you and saying, Look, you're not living up to my expectations. Sometimes, you know, it's I'm here, but you need to hear it. But also I believe in you exactly. Know what you can do it guys. Yeah, exactly. Take that power running for office. It's great. All right, deputy. That means that it's time for the Partial Pick.

    Dr G 52:13
    [Screeching bird sound]. We've had a listener complaint about my impression of an eagle, for which I apologize, but will continue to do anyway.

    Dr Rad 52:24
    I don't know how cause I've been cutting you out and putting in the actual sound effect for episodes.

    Dr G 52:28
    Oh. My. God.

    Dr Rad 52:32
    We haven't had you doing the eagle in a really long time.

    Dr G 52:36
    I cannot believe that my mastery has been cut out. Well, clearly, when I edit the episodes I leave myself in. So I apologize to everybody. That's my editorial decision.

    You can add that to the Partial Historians bingo game. Is Dr. G's eagle imitation cut out or is it in? Because you can tell who edited an episode.

    That will be the giveaway. Yeah. Because obviously I'm an artiste. And I leave my eagle sound effect in, thank you very much.

    Dr Rad 53:07
    Look I'm mindful of the fact that Igor needs his regular income from appearing on our show.

    Dr G 53:12
    Oh, well, yeah.

    Dr Rad 53:14
    Do you really want to put an eagle out of work? Or whatever? Check whatever bird we're using as the sound effect.

    Dr G 53:19
    Yeah, it's not an eagle. Apologies on that front as well. All right, the Partial Pick. Yeah, Rome has the possibility of winning 50 Golden Eagles. Let's see if they can do it. There's five categories. out of 10 each.

    Dr Rad 53:35
    Yeah.

    Dr G 53:36
    Military clout?

    Dr Rad 53:38
    No.

    Dr G 53:40
    In a year where nothing happened. Yeah.

    Dr Rad 53:42
    Amazing how they've managed to let that one slip through their fingers.

    Dr G 53:45
    Yeah 425, 424. I mean, they're recovering from like, what, what appears to be a 10 year plus warfare

    Dr Rad 53:51
    Excuses. Excuse other people part from the Etruscans to fight?

    Dr G 53:55
    Wow. Probably tired. All right. So with zero Yeah, I agree. Diplomacy?

    Dr Rad 54:02
    Well, okay. There are two truces. Hmm, we've got the very lengthy one with a entirely undeserved that should keep him out of trouble. Yeah. And then we got the shorter one with the Aequians. Which I feel like the Romans didn't really want to give it in the first place. But they did.

    Dr G 54:19
    I see.

    Dr Rad 54:21
    So I don't know what that is maybe like three?

    Dr G 54:24
    Well, maybe even a five

    Dr Rad 54:27
    Five is way too generous.

    Dr G 54:29
    Hear me out. Okay. I'll give you my rationale. And then you can disagree.

    Dr Rad 54:33
    All right.

    Dr G 54:34
    Five, because they have been a thorn in the side of Rome for nigh on 10 plus years. As far as our narrative sources are concerned.

    Dr Rad 54:42
    Nice use of “nigh on”

    Dr G 54:45
    And the Aequians are considered one of Rome's fundamental enemies. And they've managed to like tie things up with the Volscii for now. So getting the Aequians on board with a treaty as well is super beneficial. Because this means that three of Rome's greatest enemies in this time period are now apparently technically locked into a truce of some kind.

    Dr Rad 55:11
    I believe when I said look, I'll go as high as a four.

    Dr G 55:16
    Oh, wow. Wow. All right four it is. Expansion?

    Dr Rad 55:22
    No.

    Dr G 55:25
    Virtus?

    Dr Rad 55:25
    Oh wait, actually sorry. Rewind diplomacy – the game – so the games counts as diplomacy like inviting around from the neighborhood area.

    Dr G 55:25
    I guess it depends on whether you steal their women or not.

    Dr Rad 55:36
    They didn't. They were extremely polite.

    Dr G 55:38
    Well, that put that up to five.

    Dr Rad 55:40
    Yeah. Okay. Five.

    Dr G 55:45
    Expansion, so no, yeah, that wasn't what we were rewarding, so virtus?

    Dr Rad 55:51
    No, I don't think there's anything.

    Dr G 55:54
    I mean, if you have to bully the plebs into like taking up power, I don't know if that's a virtus thing.

    Dr Rad 55:58
    That's been happening for ages.

    Dr G 56:01
    And Citizen Score?

    Dr Rad 56:02
    Okay. Now, whilst attributes very cranky and not pleased with the plebeians. The end result does seem to be plebeians trying to get a senior magistracy that may or may not exist.

    Dr G 56:19
    Well, I mean, that does sound like a great outcome.

    Dr Rad 56:23
    Yeah. But you know, like, if I if we go with what Livy says, which I generally do, then,

    Dr G 56:29
    And I have no choice but to at this stage

    Dr Rad 56:32
    Your on my ride. So in that case, yeah. I mean, it's not too bad.

    Dr G 56:39
    Look, it's not I don't think it's bad at all that we've got no wars. Yeah. There's all this diplomacy means that everyone gets to stay home.

    Dr Rad 56:46
    Yeah

    Dr G 56:47
    They got games. They're not dying.

    Dr Rad 56:49
    No.

    Dr G 56:50
    And really, yeah. All anybody wants them to do is to take and seize the power that the law says that they're allowed to have.

    Dr Rad 56:57
    Yeah. And they are taking them up on that. So I guess it's time to be a citizen. Really? Yeah. Okay, so maybe like a fine. Well, I mean, come on. We don't want to go too crazy.

    Dr G 57:08
    Yeah, they aren't having the best time. They haven't gotten the land reallotment, have they?

    Dr Rad 57:12
    Yeah, I was gonna say this is all very it's they're just running for office. I haven't got it yet. Yeah. So five, five, okay, five minutes. That means Dr. G, 10 golden eagles, which I was not anticipating any, because there really wasn't a hell of a lot going on in 425 and 424 BCE.

    Dr G 57:33
    Ten out of 50. Though that's a fail.

    Dr Rad 57:35
    Well, yeah, but, let's face it. We've had worse years we have and this was actually

    Dr G 57:40
    This was two years.

    Dr Rad 57:41
    It's really

    Dr G 57:43
    Five for each year.

    Dr Rad 57:44
    Yeah.

    Dr G 57:45
    Oh, well. Well, Rome, you tried,

    Dr Rad 57:48
    But they can't all be winners, you know, particularly not in the fifth century BCE.

    Dr G 57:53
    Well, it has been a very much a pleasure. sit down chat with you,

    Dr Rad 57:57
    indeed it has.

    Dr G 58:00
    Thank you for tuning in to this episode of the Partial Historians. Dr. Rad and myself thank you so much for listening, and supporting our work and enjoying this ride through Roman history with us. We'd like to send our special thanks to the following patrons. Roger, Steve, Maria, Anthony, Ryan, Fredrik, Graham, Daniel, Jonathan, Miki, Kara, Hillary, and Lucas. Some of these people started supporting us very recently, some over the course of the last year. And for all of them, we offer our huge things. So I don't know if you've noticed, but maybe our microphones have improved recently. That is down to you guys. It really is. So thank you so much, and we'll catch you again soon.

    Transcribed by https://otter.ai

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    1 hr
  • The Robe (1953)

    The Robe (1953) is a cinematic classic of Golden Age Hollywood. With its mix of ancient Rome and early Christianity, it was a winner with audiences around the globe. In this special episode, we tap into Dr Rad's expertise in reception in film and come to grips with the power of The Robe!

    Special Episode – The Robe

    A Challenging Context

    It was tricky to deal with modern political issues in this era of Hollywood under the influence of HUAC (the House Un-American Activities Committee). For the makers of The Robe, which explicitly dealt with the life of Jesus under the Romans, there were additional challenges due to the creation of the state of Israel in 1948. Returning to the Old Testament was often a safer bet for Hollywood films.

    The rights to The Robe were initially purchased by RKO, before finally being canceled in 1948. It found a new home at 20th Century Fox. The fact that The Robe was in production for a long time has raised some interesting questions about the impact of historical context.

    The script was initially written by Albert Maltz, one of the infamous Hollywood Ten. The original script does seem to touch on blacklist themes. In Caligula’s original speech at the end of the film he refers to the “sedition” of the Christians and Marcellus has to deny that he is involved in a conspiracy to overthrow the state. This sounds eerily close to the experience of Hollywood Communists, who were generally not radicals trying to seize control of the government. There were also more references to the naming of names in Maltz’s version of The Robe…

    People protesting in favour of the Hollywood Ten. Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica.

    HUAC and The Robe

    But HUAC lay in his future, as Maltz only worked on this project from 1942-1946. As Smith (2005) has highlighted, while Maltz could not have worked HUAC references into the script before his HUAC experiences, it is possible that the tension over Communism still shaped his draft. There were moves against Communism before the Second Red Scare that swept America in the late 1940s and 1950s, such as the actions of the Tenney Committee in the early 1940s, or the foundation of the right-wing Motion Picture Alliance for American Ideals.

    Or perhaps Maltz was more focused on providing a critique of Italian fascism, given the backdrop of World War II? Maltz wrote Cloak and Dagger (1947) immediately after The Robe, which definitely took aim at Italian fascism, whilst exalting the resistance from the Communists. He would also write Crossfire (1947), a film that tackled issues of anti-Semitism within the USA.

    Film poster for Cloak and Dagger (1947)

    Is it possible that the next screenwriter to work on The Robe worked in some sick burns? Phillip Dunne followed Maltz and would eventually receive sole credit for the film, thanks to the blacklist. He was known to be a liberal and helped to establish the Committee for the First Amendment. This group formed in reaction to the HUAC hearings in 1947. Fellow members included other Hollywood luminaries such as William Wyler, Lucille Ball, Lauren Bacall, Bette Davis and Dorothy Daindridge.

    However, Dunne was not a Communist; quite the opposite. He may have intended The Robe to be a veiled criticism of HUAC, but he may also have seen the repression of the Romans as being akin to Stalin and the Communist regime.

    References
    • Reinhartz, A. (2013). Bible and Cinema: Fifty Key Films. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203083260
    • Richards, J. (2008). Hollywood’s Ancient Worlds. Continuum.
    • Smith, J. (2005). ‘Are You Now or Have You Ever Been a Christian?: The Strange History of The Robe As Political Allegory‘, Film Studies, Winter: 7, 1-15.

    A lobby card for The Robe

    Automated Transcript

    Provided by Otter AI

    Dr Rad 0:16
    Welcome to the Partial Historians, we explore all the details of ancient Rome. Everything from the political scandals, the love of ours, the battles waged, and when citizens turn against each other. I'm Dr. Rad.

    Dr G 0:34
    And I'm Dr. G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories. Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.

    Dr Rad 1:03
    Welcome to a special episode of The Partial Historians, I am one of your hosts, Dr. Rad.

    Dr G 1:10
    And I am a somewhat healthy, Dr. G.

    Dr Rad 1:15
    I know this is true dedication, Patreons, Dr G has been suffering from the vid.

    Dr G 1:22
    I've been on my deathbed. But I've bounced back. Thank goodness.

    Dr Rad 1:27
    It was Rome that calls you for and said live live another day.

    Dr G 1:33
    And one must always follow the commands of Rome. And here I am. as ever.

    Dr Rad 1:39
    Well, I suppose luckily, or unluckily. I'm not sure. We're not doing our normal narrative today. But instead, we're taking a journey into Hollywood land, which could be good for a sick person, or maybe not.

    Dr G 1:54
    I look, I think it's gonna be it's gonna be good. I'm excited for this golden era. Hollywood is one of my favorite times in Hollywood.

    Dr Rad 2:03
    We all love it. We all adore it. So let's get into this special episode where we get to talk all about The Robe 1953.

    Dr G 2:50
    What a film. I mean, I think the best thing about it is Richard Burton.

    Dr Rad 2:54
    Definitely let's let's give a bit of a cast rundown. So in typical Partial Historians fashion, we're doing this slightly backwards in that we looked at the sequel first. But that was only for our Patreon. So for everybody else, we're just doing The Robe. So first of all, we have Richard Burton playing the lead male character Marcellus Gallio.

    Dr G 3:19
    A fine specimen of a young Roman if I ever saw one.

    Dr Rad 3:21
    Indeed. And then we have my favorite Jean Simmons playing the lead female part, Diana, I think she's actually really good in this role. Yeah, well, you know, she's got that pure beauty about her. She looks very innocent.

    Dr G 3:39
    She does.

    Dr Rad 3:39
    Yeah. And then, of course, we've got the hero of our Patreon bonus episode Demetrius and the Gladiators, because, of course, being a sequel, he's in this one too big to mature, playing Demetrius,

    Dr G 3:53
    And he does look mature, doesn't he?

    Dr Rad 3:57
    He does have a mature look about him. But lest we forget, he retired at 44. So I guess he was in his 30s at this point in time.

    Dr G 4:04
    Oh, wow.

    Dr Rad 4:06
    And then we have Michael Rennie playing St. Peter.

    Dr G 4:11
    Yeah, I feel like that was a bit of a that's a bit of a throw into the sequel as well, isn't it?

    Dr Rad 4:18
    I believe so. I think he was in both. Yeah, definitely. I mean, they knew they were filming both when they started, as I discovered last time. And then we have Jay Robinson playing Caligula.

    Dr G 4:30
    Hmm. Yeah. We'll come back to that one.

    Dr Rad 4:33
    Yeah. And then I think the main ones that we have to deal with there are major characters. Yeah, I think that kind of covers it. Yeah, yeah, definitely. So The Robe 1953 is a big film in many ways. Not only is an epic from the age of epics, the Golden Age of Hollywood epics, but it also has won some fame for some of the other milestones that are associated with this film. Now, just to give us an idea of exactly how big a smash it was, it costs a smidgen over $4 million to make. And, yeah, it took in $17 million in the US a market and $36 million world wide.

    Dr G 5:25
    Okay, so this was a profit making engine?

    Dr Rad 5:29
    Well, yeah, I mean, it has a cycle that's going to tell something

    Dr G 5:35
    built in, apparently, as well. So yeah,

    Dr Rad 5:37
    I do like this detail, though, that some of the ticket sales would have been to teachers who were pressed into going to see this movie for their students, or with their students, maybe?

    Dr G 5:50
    Yeah, goodness. I mean, that kind of made up the bulk of sales, surely.

    Dr Rad 5:56
    Anyway, so let's talk a little bit about this ethic, Dr. G. So what were your initial impressions? I'm dying to know,

    Dr G 6:03
    Oh, look, I think longtime listeners of this show will be well aware that I tend to classify myself as a pagan, and my position has not changed. As a result of watching the Rome, it did feel like very much that they were utilizing Roman history as a vehicle for getting to the Christian story. And I'm not a fan of that, to be honest. Christianity is not huge. In this initial face, like this is set sort of right at the moment of the passing of the Messiah.

    Dr Rad 6:39
    Jesus is alive in this film. That tells us something. Yeah,

    Dr G 6:43
    Jesus starts alive in this film. Yeah, he doesn't stay alive. So that gives us almost everything we need to know about what moment in history we're in. But the sense in which there is a really strong Christianizing moment that comes over all of the players who've been closely associated with that moment of Jesus's death is really interesting. Yeah, and I would say, anachronistic.

    Dr Rad 7:09
    For sure. I mean, it's historically accurate to place Jesus's life in his time period. So the time period we're talking about is the tail end of the reign of Tiberius, aka the best period ever. And we then end up going into some of calculus, rain as well. And calculus, definitely around this whole movie. He's not, you know, off to the side, and Tiberius is a circle regular, I think, is definitely the main Roman imperial character that we get to know over the course of this film. And that is historical. As far as we can tell, Jesus was indeed around in the latter half of Tiberius, his reign. So anyway, the general setting for Jesus's lifetime, and when he starts to become a problem for Rome, all is accurate. And so we've got our major players, you know, being where they should be. But as you say, this is a classic Hollywood epic in that in order for you to have a good guy and a bad guy, you know, someone to root for and someone to despise while still enjoying the things that they get up to. It's pretty normal for Hollywood to go to a Christians versus Romans storyline, or at least Christians slash Jewish people. Question Mark versus Romans?

    Dr G 8:30
    Yeah. And this leads us into some like really interesting directorial choices, or maybe casting decisions as well, because the Romans quintessentially played by the English. So they've got that very sort of RP accent going on. Yeah, but then the people of Palestine appear to be American. Where, I mean, it's something

    Dr Rad 8:53
    But I think that that actually does keep into the whole accent divide. Because I think it's kind of meant to be the people who are on the side, that you're meant to be rooting for generally American.

    Dr G 9:06
    Hmm. So Hollywood would want you to believe.

    Dr Rad 9:09
    Yeah, yeah, I mean, it's not. It's not uncommon for the movies of this era to have that accent divided so that it's super clear, just in case you were thinking of rooting for the Romans that were crucifying Jesus, just in case you had a moment where you thought maybe I'm on their side. They go for the accent just to make it very clear.

    Dr G 9:30
    That and the way that they decide to portray particular were Romans. Now, Caligula, as we know, doesn't have heaps of redeeming features, ultimately, and the Romans themselves get pretty jack of them very quickly, they do. So this is what what is about to follow is not the saving of Caligula. Now, when I say I think he might have been overplayed a little bit in this film.

    Dr Rad 9:59
    Oh, Though I have to admit, though, I kind of enjoy the guy who played here. And he does have the kind of voice that really grates on you in a way that makes you think, yeah, I could assassinate this guy after a few years. I think I'd be annoyed enough.

    Dr G 10:15
    He is frustratingly inept in his presentation, and because we don't get a good read on motivation from Caligula, and because it just feels like he's being played for the sort of the hysterical, maniacal, power driven figure that is portrayed as in this film. It makes him feel a little bit unbelievable, whilst also holding down the position as the bad guy.

    Dr Rad 10:46
    Yeah, fair enough. Well, before we get too much further into Ahala, we probably should say something about the general storyline of this film. So why don't you tell us about the the story of Digi

    Dr G 10:57
    Okay, all right. Well, I mean, it starts off great opening scene. It seems like we're in the Roman Forum. Everyone's having a good time. It's clearly slave-buying season. Not that anybody should be excited about that.

    Dr Rad 11:11
    I say Why does it not slave-buying season in Rome?

    Dr G 11:14
    It seems to b a particularly busy time at the moment. And this sets up the few really important dynamics. It allows us to see Marcellus re-meeting his childhood sweetheart, Diana, they haven't seen each other for many years. So that sets up that relationship. We learn about Diana's connection as a ward of Tiberius to calendula, potentially as a love interest for him. But we also learn about myself versus ongoing tension with Caligula as well apparently those two don't get along. And then we have this sort of moment with the slave market, which introduces us to Demetrius as well, who is perhaps the most stoic character in this whole

    Dr Rad 12:00
    Oh, my God, yes.

    Dr G 12:01
    So stoic, and this guy kind of just accepts his fate as it is, doesn't seem to fight one way or the other. But does seem to be motivated by an internal set of principles. And for whatever reason, Demetrius ends up coming to the attention of both Marcellus and Caligula during this slave sail. And this becomes an important point because it's this moment. And this tension between Marcellus and Caligula, which turns Demetrius is fate. So you technically gets freed in a slave auction through being purchased at such a high price for Marcellus to sort of jab coelicolor A little bit. But because Demetrius feels that this isn't appropriate to be bought at such a high price just to be set free, he decides to become the manservant of Marcellus anyway. So these two are now bound up together in what appears to be a kind of odd duo, because my Seles then goes on to be like, let's be friends, if we're going to hang out together like this. Demetrius is, like, we are not friends. I really owe you. It's different.

    Dr Rad 13:15
    I do like the pairing, though. I mean, Burton's got the voice and Mature's got this shoulder.

    Dr G 13:22
    Yeah, so these two end up on adventures together, which are all bound up with calendula in particular ways Caligula is annoyed at Marcellus for this whole debacle in the slave market. So he sends him to Palestine as a bit of a punishment. While he's there, he ends up in a situation with Pontius Pilate, so that's good news. Everybody likes it when Pontius Pilate enters the enters the scene, Pontius Pilate sort of commands myself is to be in charge with the crucifixion of Jesus, which is awkward, but also at the same time has a Lady Macbeth moment, which is kind of beautiful, where he's washing his hands, and he's like, I need to wash my hands. And he's slaves like you just wash your hands. Yeah, like the bloods invisible but he's having trouble guys. He's ordered the death of Jesus. Then we have some really interesting moments in Palestine, one of which is this trading of the robe. So pivotal to this entire film, it would seem is that we don't see Jesus very much. We don't really see his face. We sometimes hear his voice, but we he's a mysterious figure who seems to have an effect on Demetrius straightaway. When he is on the cross, the robe that he had been wearing has been laid at the bottom of it. One of the Roman soldiers picks it up and it's like that. We could throw this into the old gambling table. Let's when the robe of Jesus and Marcellus wins it, but is then sort of overcome when he tries to put it on himself when it's raining and he wants To protect himself it seems like it has a huge negative effect on him like almost like burns his skin or something. Anyway, it's it's horrifying to him and Demetrius just wanders off with the robe in the end does like I'll take that.

    Dr Rad 15:14
    But he does have that amazing scene because there's all that storm happening around them and I must have been I think this is probably one of Victor Mature's finest moments on screen, where he sort of screams and Richard Burton's face as he's, you know, dealing with the effects of the robe and all of that kind of stuff. And he does that whole “murderers, thieves, jungle animals. Masters of the world you call yourselves. I'm curse on you. I curse on your empire.” Mwahahahaha

    Dr G 15:51
    Lightning strikes in the background and this thunder?

    Dr Rad 15:54
    Yeah, it's great. Yeah, the evil laughter was my addition, I should say.

    Dr G 16:00
    Very intense moment. And Demetrius ends up walking off with the robe, completely unharmed by it, because clearly it's there's a connection between his faith and one's capacity to hold this garment. Sacred as it is. Marcellus ends up back in Rome and seen Tiberius on the Isle of Capri being like what I do, I've got this madness. And the Romans in the wisdom decide that the road must be cursed, which is for the Romans had excellent choice really. It's like that would explain it. So Marcellus is given an imperial commission to destroy this robe. And it's like, use whatever means you need to.

    Dr Rad 16:45
    So this is great guys, how many people might have tried it on by now? Yeah,

    Dr G 16:48
    it's a disaster. We've got to find it as soon as possible.

    Dr Rad 16:52
    If anybody finds out about this garment, it's going to be a PR nightmare.

    Dr G 16:56
    That's basically what Tiberius says, when when everybody leaves. And he's like, this is the worst thing that has ever happened in my entire rule.

    Dr Rad 17:03
    And I've had some stuff happen.

    Dr G 17:06
    We must deal with this instantly.

    Dr Rad 17:08
    I mean, my brother died, I had to divorce the wife that I loved. I then had to marry a woman I hated the child that we had died, then both my natural son and my adopted son birthday, that was pretty bad. But this this robe. Okay.

    Dr G 17:25
    It is up there. Yeah. So Marcellus finds himself back in Palestine, because that's where he last saw Demetrius with the robe. It is like, Well, I'm gonna go back to the source that look for more clues. And this leads to a whole bunch of unfoldings. There's storytelling things. There's this slow journey of Marcellus from like quintessential Roman, to like, somebody, embodied in faith, very dedicated Christian, very dedicated across this journey. Yeah, he meets some villagers who really shift his perspective on things. He finds Demetrius again. And all of this sort of nourishes his flourishing belief. So by the time he does get back to Rome, he's now committed to the cause. And he also hasn't told anybody that he's back for ages as well. So

    Dr Rad 18:16
    Well, yeah, he's got he's got new friends now, the Christians. And so Peter,

    Dr G 18:20
    yeah. And you know, when Diana finds out about this, because she's been waiting for him this whole time, that he's hidden, his return from her. She's not happy about that, and she is that she demands to be taken to him. And that's when we find out that the Christians are living in the catacombs. Yes. Which, which is awkward, because they should not really exist. Yeah.

    Dr Rad 18:47
    Minor details, minor details. Yeah,

    Dr G 18:50
    Look, I was I was all fine for them to just be underground caves, like, Rome is literally riddled with natural springs and cave systems anyway, it's completely, completely fine and legitimate, but they do refer to them as catacombs. And I was like, guys, you know, that people would have have to be buried in them for them to be catacombs. And the people that we know are buried in the catacombs are. And you guys are the first Christians in Rome. So

    Dr Rad 19:17
    There's been a lot of persecution already.

    Dr G 19:21
    So much, so much persecution already. Anyway, as it turns out, one of the things it's getting more complicated as the film goes on, but Demetrius has been captured and the Christians have to save him, cuz he's been tortured for information. Yeah, yeah. And calendula has Demetrius in his grass. Yeah. And is turning the screw as it were. So the Christians all gather together and they managed to pull off a very effective saving of Demetrius and they hide him weirdly at Marcellus his dad's house. Yeah, although,

    Dr Rad 19:57
    I was going to say it's, I like the I like the infiltration because they use myself as a mole. You know, he's got the clothes, he's got the accent, he can penetrate into the palace itself in order to rescue Demetrius, which I did appreciate,

    Dr G 20:14
    Although it is a concern to me that throughout this entire film, Marcellus has been known consistently as the Tribune. So he's pretty low down on the cursus honorum. And he's definitely not progressing any higher, because for him after this film, but the thing is that I feel like given the nature of the events, we've had two trips to Palestine, at least in the course of this film, that we are looking at over a year. Oh, it's way more in terms of time. Yeah. And as a magistrate holding the tribuncianship, it seems very unlikely that Marcellus would continue to be attributed over the whole course of this film, or that given the way that he's behaved, that people would continue to recognize him as Tribune.

    Dr Rad 21:03
    Yeah, I definitely think it's meant to be more than a year for sure. But do we think that he is tribune of the plebs or just a military Tribune? That? I don't know. I feel like I kind of figured he was like a military Tribune.

    Dr G 21:17
    Well, that is an unfortunate place for the son of a senator to have ended up in terms of his career.

    Dr Rad 21:23
    I could be wrong, but that because they never really clarify that. But

    Dr G 21:27
    They don't. They don't. And he continues to be attributed throughout the whole that's true.

    Dr Rad 21:31
    Yeah, that is true. I think they do use that more than his actual name. Tribune. Give me Yeah, Tribune. I'm having some trouble

    Dr G 21:39
    You sir, Tribune. I want you to do the crucifixions. today. I'm bored. Yeah. So our final scene. Ultimately, the plot leads us to this moment where it's the ultimate showdown between Caligula and Marcellus.

    Dr Rad 21:56
    Yes. Because he's been captured, he ends up getting captured when he's trying to get everybody safely. Well, out of Rome, I think they're going after.

    Dr G 22:04
    Yeah, he's trying to get Demetrius safely out of Rome. Yeah. And in the course of that, they're being run down by some cavalry. And Marcellus chooses to sacrifice himself. Yeah, that his friend can get away. Absolutely. It's never really been clarified that they are friends now. But what assumes over the course of the travails that they've encountered that they now like each other, I think they do. Yeah. Yeah. This means that there is a huge public trial. Myself, his parents are there. All of the elite of Rome there.

    Dr Rad 22:38
    Yeah, all of them. It's a massive crowd.

    Dr G 22:40
    It's a huge crowd. So many people. Caligula comes in, in what is the reddest garment that has ever been seen on film,

    Dr Rad 22:51
    that the marvels of Technicolor for you?

    Dr G 22:53
    It's incredible. Everybody else looks pale and washed out in comparison. But Caligula Boy, that is some Imperial read that he's got. This leads into our whole sort of three ways sort of struggle between Diana, Marcellus and Caligula verbally duking it out, essentially.

    Dr Rad 23:15
    Actually, we should perhaps mentioned that Diana was meant to marry Caligula for a little while there. So yeah, yeah, it's a triangle or

    Dr G 23:24
    it's a triangle. And she certainly makes it clear where she stands to Caligula to the point that he changes his mind about being unwilling to punish her to her definitely having to die.

    Dr Rad 23:37
    Yeah, well, I mean, it's a no brainer, really. I mean, when you're choosing between Richard Burton's sultry tones, and those of Jay Robinson, I mean, can you imagine that in the bedroom data, add data?

    Dr G 23:54
    It's quite something. I mean, I hope he's got an indoor voice. Just whispered to me, Caligula.

    Dr Rad 24:03
    Yeah, yeah. So basically clears like, you know what, you guys believe so much in this afterlife and this kingdom of heaven and being saved. No big deal if I execute the both of you, and so they match off quite happily just chip off into the clouds.

    Dr G 24:18
    Yeah, it's the way this film ends is a little bit surprising. I felt like after two and a quarter hours of viewing time, I was not expecting the end scene to be a gentle walk by Marcellus and Diana, out of the trial into heaven.

    Dr Rad 24:41
    I know, I know, but I guess I guess because they knew the sequel was coming. That maybe they felt that that was okay. And look, you know, it's kind of an anti Hollywood ending. I mean, it's a happy ending. But it's not your typical Hollywood ending, I suppose.

    Dr G 24:56
    Yeah, they do get to stay together forever in love, I suppose. Oh,

    Dr Rad 25:01
    there's that. But I mean, I think if you were going for a real Hollywood ending that somehow they would both survive and Galio would become the emperor or something like that. And also maybe the Pope.

    Dr G 25:14
    Yeah, look, I mean, if you're gonna rewrite history, I mean, lean in guys.

    Dr Rad 25:19
    Yeah, exactly. So that's the rough storyline, which, as you can tell by the fact that it took us 13 minutes to tell you the story. But you know what, we're saving you from watching a two and a quarter hour movie. So although if you want to it could be fun. I'm not saying you shouldn't watch it. But you know, 13 minutes on two and a quarter hours. It's not too bad. So let's maybe talk about where this movie came in from Dr. G. So whilst Hollywood does love a Christians slash Jewish people versus Romans storyline, it did not come out of thin air is of course, based on a book, of course. Yeah. So it was actually written by a guy called Lloyd C. Douglas. And he was the son of an Indiana pastor. And he became a Lutheran minister himself, before moving over to the Congregational Church, for his career. But he started writing as we got into the like, the late 1920s, he started writing, he wrote this book called “Magnificent Obsession”, and it sold 3 million copies. Oh, my goodness. Yeah. And so by 1933, he was like, You know what, I don't think I need to be a minister anymore. I think I'm going to be a novelist.

    Dr G 26:35
    I've got a winning formula. And all I need to do is write my books. Yeah,

    Dr Rad 26:39
    he honestly became one of the most popular novelists in America in this time period. And this is not the Rube is not the only one of his books that was adapted into a film. So well, well, well, they're not they don't they're not only popular in terms of people reading them. They are popular in terms of being picked up and made into Hollywood films. So the robe had been a best seller from 1942 until 1945.

    Dr G 27:09
    Wow, okay. Yeah. It was on the bestseller list for years.

    Dr Rad 27:13
    Yeah, absolutely. I presume that publication was maybe slightly slower for like the big novels. I know. They were dying novels and stuff out, you know, in the 1950s that people could buy. And they were turned out very quickly. But I feel like it is a slightly less crowded market, perhaps at this point in time.

    Dr G 27:31
    It's a very interesting time for the novel to come out as well, like you're in the middle of the Second World War.

    Dr Rad 27:38
    Yeah, you are indeed. So it was eventually bought by RKO. However, they didn't really act on it. They just sort of bought the rights to it. And you know, by the late 1940s, it's still something that they're just sort of sitting on at that. At that point in time. Howard Hughes is in charge of RKO biblical films were not really his thing. He wasn't as into them as other people seem to have been at the time.

    Dr G 28:06
    Sounds like how would use it, I might get along. Exactly, yeah.

    Dr Rad 28:10
    But eventually, Darryl Zanuck and Fox Studios step in. And this is how the film finally kind of gets off the ground and gets made. So that's just sort of a little bit of background to the film. But as a result, and not, to be honest, this is pretty common for Hollywood movies of this time. There are a number of people who ended up working on the script for the film, because it has such a long production process. But even with the ones that were shorter, it was pretty common to have more than one person, you know, take a look at the script and give their input and that sort of thing. When the film was finally made, it definitely got a huge publicity campaign. So we're talking radio ads, we're talking television, we're talking newspapers, everywhere you look there's an ad for the road.

    Dr G 28:58
    Have you seen Cinemascope?

    Dr Rad 29:02
    Nobody has. It's the first one to have it. So of course, it's going to be viewing this new widescreen format which the studios are hoping is going to keep people coming to the movies rather than sitting at home and watching their televisions which of course the becoming a big thing in this post World War Two era and so they make the film's bigger, more colorful, more extravagant, the kinds of thing that television which is generally a little square, black and white box just can't really offer you know, we're talking about also sound you know, stereophonic sound, it's it's all a big thing. And it's given this huge premiere, where it's like a freaking circus. We're talking about, you know, the spotlights outside the cinema, the stars are attending, you know, it's a very, very big deal.

    Dr G 29:53
    There's gladiators playing games.

    Dr Rad 29:58
    Yeah, so it's definitely a huge to do when it when it comes out. So as you highlighted when this novel was first written, and people were maybe first toying with the idea of making this film, it was a world war two time. And that seems to have been thought to be part of the message of the film when they were first, you know, throwing it around that in some way, Caligula and Rome are meant to be this sort of, you know, decadent place, that they're somehow the way they're treating Jewish people slash Christians, because of the crossover. It's kind of meant to be like the persecutions that were carried out, in particular, I suppose, by Hitler, but also to some extent by Mussolini. So this was definitely meant to be something that people were, I think, picking up on when they were first, you know, developing this into a film.

    Dr G 30:59
    Look, I think that sounds reasonable. Yeah. Yeah, you do get the sense that the way that the Romans are being positioned in this film is quite particular. And it's quite different from other epics of this era that I've watched so far, because I'm not going to pretend that I'm conversant in all the Hollywood epics.

    Dr Rad 31:20
    But there are quite a few now.

    Dr G 31:22
    I have watched a few but I wouldn't say I'm in any way an expert at this point in time. But it did feel to me like the Romans were being very much positioned in a particular way. And it was, in part to do with, obviously, the focus is on the Christian story. So the Romans are, by default, the bad guys here, but also, that it's coming out of that sort of post Second War mindset. Well, how do we understand conflict? How do we understand the persecution of peoples? And so while I wasn't really consciously thinking about it, when I watched it, the vibe that the Romans are giving off in this film is intriguing.

    Dr Rad 32:04
    Yeah. And I think it's kind of one of those things as well, where were these sorts of moralizing films, it's kind of that thing of people get to enjoy watching the Romans have this very fancy schmancy life that they have, whilst also being like, Oh, isn't a terrible, look at what they're doing to those poor Christians. So it's like they because the moral is there, they get to enjoy watching the decadence of Rome. But I didn't feel like it was as over the top in the robe, as it has been in some of the other movies, we've watched, like quovadis, and that sort of thing.

    Dr G 32:38
    And I feel like the decadence was actually a little bit pared back in this film, like note that it didn't have like all of the highly colored interior scenes and the layering of different stones and things like that it was obviously trying to be quite opulent in its way. But it also felt like maybe they didn't have quite as much budget as some other films for some of that stuff. Yeah, definitely.

    Dr Rad 33:00
    Now, the other interesting thing I'm going to throw in contextually Dr G is that so when this film was purchased, and when it was being made, we're still in the time of the studio system. So this is a period where you've got kind of like five major movie studios that really dominate the production of movies in Hollywood, there are some minor studios. And then there are also some truly budget, you know, just pump out these really crappy movie studios, they do exist. But the major films, particularly the ones that most people would be familiar with today, they're going to be made by one of these major studios. And it's kind of that idea of it being like the dream factory time of Hollywood, you know, where they're manufacturing movies. And so they're in charge of who gets hired to be director who's the producer, who's on contract, like the stars are all under contract at various studios, and they have to make so many pictures per year, and they get paid this much to do it and all that kind of stuff. So huge amount of control. Now, most of these Hollywood studios, these major ones are owned by Jewish movie moguls. This puts them I suppose in an interesting position in the 20th century. Now, of course, I think part of the reason why that ended up being the case is that typically, when when movies first sort of became a thing, it wasn't necessarily the most admired or respectable profession to be involved in, you know, I mean, it wasn't the theater.

    Dr G 34:33
    In the same way that actors in ancient Rome were suffering under the pool of a lack of respect for their craft. Exactly. So too, did early filmmakers, people like that's not

    Dr Rad 34:46
    exactly yeah, and I think it's so it's something that you do tend to get people that perhaps aren't risking a wider reputation, I suppose, or aren't too concerned about what this wider society You may or may not think we're also talking about people who are potentially immigrants. You know, there's a whole bunch of reasons why you might end up getting maybe a higher percentage of Jewish people getting involved in the film industry in the early days. And their investment, of course really pays off, because everyone starts to really fall in love with movies, which makes, which makes the people that got involved in the early film industry, very wealthy when they rise to the top. Now, it's not by any means only Jewish people that are involved. But there is a trend where a lot of the big movie Americans at the studios are Jewish people. Now, they don't want to be seen to be putting prou Jewish propaganda into their films or things like that, particularly once we get into this time period that we're talking about, you know, with, obviously, World War Two, I mean, even I mean, obviously, we talk about American history, obviously, there's always been, I think, a certain stigma against anybody who's perceived to be an outsider. But particularly in the early 20th century, we know that we see a spike in terms of racism, not just directed against African American groups, but also directed against any immigrant groups, and Jewish people in the 1930s, are increasingly being associated Well, in the 1920s, and the 1930s. Really, they're increasingly being associated with communism. So especially with everything that's happened with World War Two, especially, it's not really a great time, I suppose, to be seen, to be putting out film sort of openly, you know, Pro, the Jewish course. 1919 48, I think makes it particularly touchy issue. Because, of course, this is when we get the creation of the State of Israel. So with the creation of the State of Israel, there was actually a film release that was touching on these sorts of issues, and was kind of pro Israel called the sword in the desert. But there was a riot that broke out in a London cinema when it was shown. And so it was actually withdrawn. And so I think that showed a message of, you know, people aren't really going to want to see these sorts of films, or at least that's the feeling. And obviously, we're talking about Hollywood, it's a business, you've got to, you know, make your money somehow. So a way I suppose, of dealing with that was by making biblical epics, where there is a bit of a focus on, say, the Old Testament. So we do see a lot of Jewish heroes turning up in some of these 1950s epics, another one, of course, played by Victor mature Samson, Samson and Delilah. And then of course, we've got Moses turning up in the 10 commandments. And then you've got characters like Joshua Solomon, and even in terms of women, you've got people like Ruth and Esther turning up in some of these biblical epics. So the robe is kind of an interesting one, because it is obviously crossing that, that line between Old Testament days and entering the New Testament led by one Jesus Christ.

    Dr G 38:02
    Yeah, we're in this very interesting storyline. I suspect, and it doesn't necessarily, I don't think it's over in this film. But it's clear as well, that this is about the genesis of Christianity. And it emerges out of Palestinian culture, that's clear, both from the geographic location. And it's clear from the way in which the robe engages with this story as well, like Marcellus goes on this journey, which involves him going into Palestine as part of his job as a Roman, but also learning and discovering things about himself while he is there. Yeah. And for him, that's not necessarily about Jesus in the beginning. It's a much longer journey. And so I think part of what this film is trying to do is to try to capture what does this historical moment really mean? For so that sense in which we know that there are people in Palestine during this time period historically, who are being crucified? And what kind of effect does that have on the people who are there at the time? And what kind of stories are they telling about these people? Because one of these stories ends up becoming very influential, and being retold and retold. So this is an interesting way to tackle it, I think, through the eyes of somebody who is Roman, and also through the eyes of someone who is not Roman, but he's also an outsider.

    Dr Rad 39:34
    Yeah, it is a really interesting film in that respect. And I think also the choice of having it I mean, obviously, they had to place it when they did if they were going to be accurate about when Jesus was supposedly alive and when he was being crucified. But I think there is also a tendency to set these sorts of movies during the Empire, not just because historically it makes sense, but also because there are publican era of Rome had been such a model for the USA itself. And they like to think of themselves as you know, inheriting some of those Republican Roman values. So a way I suppose dealing with the fact that they like, we're like the Romans, they're like, oh, wait a second. Not those Romans. Yeah. When like their republic and Romans, not those decadent, Imperial Roman, it's not the USA.

    Dr G 40:26
    I mean, they're very lucky in that regard that the timeline is what it is. Because imagine if this had happened in the Republic, and it very well could have because

    Dr Rad 40:35
    Their heads would literally explode

    Dr G 40:38
    We are not that far into the imperial period.

    Dr Rad 40:44
    Now, of course, for that there were some minor contextual factors. So the rivalry from television, we've got the studio system, and the people that are behind the studio system, follow the money, did you?

    Dr G 40:57
    Well, yeah. Like I hear Jean Simmons had to, like, break contract and get a different contract in order to do partly to be in this film.

    Dr Rad 41:04
    That's generally what they had to do. There's always sort of like they it was, it was almost as though the celebrities were like trading cards. And, you know, studios would be like, Look, I really want so and so from this picture, they be just right for the role. What can you do I will trade you these two women for that woman for six months? Or? Or yeah, they will, they had to renegotiate their contracts. Because often their contracts would be like for seven years. So it's quite a substantial chunk of time. So we've got television, we've got the studio system, we've got the creation of Israel, whilst this film is very slowly being developed. And then of course, the big thing that we need to talk about is the Red Scare of the 1950s. Don't know. Thank you, thank you, I needed a sound effect. So by the time the room is finally like properly in production, which is by the early 1950s, we're looking at a second round of huge hearings, which is the house of UnAmerican Activities Committee. And these are the people that are most notorious for trying to root out communists in various industries in America, but in particular, in Hollywood, and I say in particular, in that it was probably obviously the most widely publicized.

    Dr G 42:23
    Yeah, it's a horrifying time to be for the progressive political nature.

    Dr Rad 42:27
    Yes. So there's been a lot of talk about the robe and the whack hearings. Because of course, there are some key scenes in the room, which some people have taken to mean, that this film was trying to talk about the present happenings in America, whilst extensively talking about the past. I'm wondering if you can guess which scenes I'm talking about Dr. G. I

    Dr G 42:53
    don't know that I can. I didn't have this moment where I was like, aha, that's a clear us moment. I had moments where I was like, this is another Lady Macbeth reference.

    Dr Rad 43:04
    Very possibly,

    Dr G 43:05
    maybe they're the same. Look, there is this scene on the ship back to Italy, where Barcellos seems to be involuntarily moaning a bit like a lady while he's asleep. As there is the sound of the hammer on the deck of the ship. Could this be a hammer and sickle reference that I've missed? Could this? Could this be a recollection of his role in the crucifixion? Where the sounds are the hammer of minds him of the of the nails that he drilled into Jesus's body? Anyway? I don't know. But that was a great scene.

    Dr Rad 43:43
    Well, basically, it is the scene where Tiberius is talking to Marcellus, the Tribune, about finding out about the road, like tracking it down. Yeah, reaching out all the Christians, all of that kind of stuff. So he explicitly says to Marcellus, you know, I need a list of names every name, I need to know who these people are, we need to hunt them down, we need to route them down. So that has sometimes been seen as a not very subtle reference to what he wack was trying to do in the late 1940s. And in the early 1950s, because this film, of course, came out in 1953. So it was out after two rounds of Hollywood hearings, the of the committee, so some people have seen that as being a reference. But I did find this article which delves into the complicated production of this film. And part of I think the reason why people were so keen to see a parallel is that the major screenwriter during the early days of production for the robe was Albert moths. Now, Albert mult isn't a minor very well, because he was one of the Hollywood 10. So he's one of the original guys that ends up getting called up in 1947. Before he work along with another guy, I know, Dalton Trumbo, he and Trump We're pretty tight.

    Dr G 45:02
    Of course they are.

    Dr Rad 45:05
    Yeah, yeah. And then the next guy to work on the script is a guy called Philip Dunne. Now he ended up being part of a group of people in Hollywood called the committee for the First Amendment. So this is a reference to the fact that when the US UK hearing started to happen in 1947, quite a lot of the more liberal people in Hollywood were, of course horrified by what was happening, these people that they know, these people that they've worked with, and they perhaps were just liberal enough to not think that this was actually something that should be happening in America. So a bunch of them get together to try and rally support for the Hollywood 10. And they end up calling themselves the committee for the first amendment because one of the decisions one of the key decisions that the Hollywood tena decided to make in 1947, is that they were going to plead the First Amendment and not the fifth. Okay, so they're not they're not pleading,

    Dr G 46:04
    now, you're really testing my understanding of the US Constitution, because I do not know what the First Amendment stands for adults. Basically,

    Dr Rad 46:13
    we're talking about the Fifth Amendment is your right to not incriminate yourself, which tends to be what happens later on in the huge tech hearings, because the First Amendment doesn't work. The First Amendment we're talking about things like your freedom of speech. Okay, your your basic freedoms, like some of the things that Americans cling to, most daily, I see. And they basically say that they want to do that rather than pleading the fifth when they get called up in front of this committee, because to plead the fifth kind of has the connotation, I suppose that you have done something criminal, I was

    Dr G 46:49
    gonna say, surely pleading, the fifth is already an implication of

    Dr Rad 46:53
    kind of, I mean, like, it's not really, that's not really what it necessarily means, but it does have that connotation. Whereas the First Amendment, it's more about fundamental freedom, like if you're at risk

    Dr G 47:04
    of incriminating yourself, doesn't that make you criminal?

    Dr Rad 47:07
    Well, I mean, this is the thing. No, it doesn't have to, it's more just the fact that obviously, you have the right not to incriminate yourself, maybe accidentally, but it just, it just has that connotation. So yeah. So that's why it became a big thing because they took that stance that they were going to plead the First Amendment and argue this and it does not go well for them. And why? Yeah, yeah, that's a shame. He'd been one of the he was he was known to be a political liberal. And he was one of the founding members of this group, which also included some very well known names like you know, Lauren Bacall, Humphrey Bogart. Yeah. Lots of people who would do you know, radio announcements, telling people look, this is what is happening right now. This is terrifying. We need to do something about it. We need to rally and show support. So there's definitely some leftist feelings coming out of the screen writing. There's just just like, catch Dr. G. O. Albert molts was riding the robe up until about 1946. I wonder if you can do some quick math for me and tell me what the problem is with that? Well, it's

    Dr G 48:10
    after the Second World War for the huge tech hearings? I don't know. That's exactly

    Dr Rad 48:15
    right. It's before the HUAC hearing. So how could he be making coded reference to the US hearings before the hearings?

    Dr G 48:24
    I mean, the guy's got four. So what can I say? He's a smart man. And he saw it coming. Yeah. So

    Dr Rad 48:33
    while says obviously potential for there to be some Anti Fascist stuff, because yeah, that album also sort of worked into the script. You know, in terms of what everyone's just been going through with World War Two, it seems unlikely that Albert moulds would have been able to work in huge references before the huge hearings, that became a problem for him in 1947.

    Dr G 48:59
    You do make a very sound argument and I am convinced,

    Dr Rad 49:03
    I would like to claim this as my own but somebody else went into the archives in this effort. However, that still leaves the question of fill Phillip done. Okay.

    Dr G 49:15
    Yes, sinister.

    Dr Rad 49:18
    Well, not necessarily mean, I actually quite like the sound of him. He sounds like I've gotten a guy.

    Dr G 49:23
    Philip is done. That's what I'm told.

    Dr Rad 49:26
    I suppose there are also they're also supposed to pretend potential references to kind of like blacklisting and curricula being a somewhat McCarthy like figure particularly in that last big scene that you talked about. Okay, the way that he talks about the way he's talking to Gallio in that final showdown of his seen,

    Dr G 49:49
    also the way he has plants in the audience to backup his position, which, which aren't enough to get it across the line anyway, which is kind of hilarious because you think As the Emperor he'd be able to buy off more people. But he's then also immediately called out for this by Diana being like, that's all you got the people you planted in the crowd.

    Dr Rad 50:10
    I know she's very outspoken. I love the fact that in both Demetrius and the Gladiator, and sorry, Demetrius of the Gladiators, and The Robe, we have these final scenes where Roman women are super outspoken in a public fora. Yeah, in a way that I think would not fly in reality. No, just laying into them. Yeah. But I think the thing that really came through for me when I was rewatching, it is that Marcellus is very clear to Caligula that look, this is just what I believe. I'm not trying to take down Rome, you know, I can, I can be loyal to both of you, which I think is very interesting, because that's kind of the line that a lot of people who were brought up before the huge tech committee in the 1940s, and the 1950s, were trying to argue, the majority of them, I mean, particularly those who worked in Hollywood, sure, I'm sure there are some rogue communists out there in the states who were aiming higher, but in terms of the Hollywood people, they weren't trying to take over the state.

    Dr G 51:14
    And this is also I think, tapping into some bigger ideas that I think America at this time had about itself. And maybe these ideas linger today in various ways, which is when Marcellus makes this dichotomy between his ability to serve Rome, which is completely uncompromised and his perspective, and his personal interest in pursuing his beliefs, to the extent to which they don't affect his capacity to serve Rome, is tapping into that idea of freedom of religion. And also, this vaunted, but potentially quite false idea of the separation of religion and state, which is a very modern invention. And once we look into any state system, almost completely unsupported by the evidence at play on the ground in any nation state of today.

    Dr Rad 52:10
    Yeah, definitely. Now, one of the interesting things is that we do actually have a record of Maltz's version of the script, which Philip Dunne would have used to develop his idea. And Maltz definitely had more scenes that develop this idea of the need for the naming of names. And it also included a bit more development with the character of Abbey door. Now Abbey door is the informant, that must sell us users to try and find out about the Christian, the Jewish slash Christian community that he is tracking down. So in Maltz's, version, Marcellus actually gives avatar a coin in exchange for every name that is brought to him. These These were not kept, obviously in Dunne's version, which begs the question, was it purely because if there's already an incredibly long fail, or was it that by the time that done was working on the script, those sorts of references might have been seen as maybe too problematic?

    Dr G 53:19
    Maybe unseemly, given the circumstances that we're facing right now in Hollywood? Let's not mention that.

    Dr Rad 53:26
    Exactly. Yeah. Because it is no doubt that Philip Dunne is was somebody who was anti-HUAC, but the thing is, he was also anti communist. So the people that were part of this committee for the First Amendment, they weren't necessarily communists themselves. In fact, I would say that generally, they were not communists at all. They were just people who thought that he work was wrong. And thought it was important to speak out against the freedoms that were to speak out because they were basic American freedoms that were being trampled on. And also because I presume, again, because of that natural affinity for people that you knew and people that you worked with being, you know, put in this horrible situation.

    Dr G 54:11
    Yeah, look, I think that's completely fair. You always want to stick up for your friends.

    Dr Rad 54:16
    Yeah. So I mean, I guess it's like one of those movies that in a way you can kind of read it, however you like, in that you can see it as being a critique of totalitarianism. Okay, it could be seen, as you know, you could see Caligula and the Romans as being kind of Stalinist communist figures and that you're living in a repressive state, or you can read it as being I suppose, a critique of the kind of repression that was going on during the hue Acura, I think

    Dr G 54:45
    it offers itself to a range of these sorts of interpretations and the importance of the positioning of the audience in this to very much be on the side of Marcellus and that unfolding personal journey Ready to understanding is part of the key way that it's navigating all of these tension.

    Dr Rad 55:06
    Yeah, definitely. Yeah. So overall, Dr. G, after, after us talking all about all these various contextual issues for the making of the room. What is your final impression of this film?

    Dr G 55:21
    Oh look, I don't want to see it again. I know, I like my Roman history to just be a little bit more grandiose. I don't know that I'm into it as being a backdrop for some other sort of moral didacticism, which it feels very strongly as what's going on here. I did enjoy the elder Tiberius, he seemed like the most reasonable guy around traps in this building.

    Dr Rad 55:54
    Although I must admit, I thought you would pick up on this, did you pick up on the fact that Tiberius was very skeptical about Roman religious practices?

    Dr G 56:03
    I mean, I suppose he should be. He's seen enough in his time. And in terms of my overall I probably gonna give it maybe three stars, it's clearly been very well put together for its time and its age. I want to see more Romans, the robe, it didn't feel like it was well explained.

    Dr Rad 56:26
    You mean how the magic worked.

    Dr G 56:29
    Look, guys, what's going on with this robe?

    Dr Rad 56:33
    Well, I think it's kind of interesting, because I suppose like a lot of blockbuster films these days. Interestingly, there was a bit of a divide between critics and the audience. So as I mentioned at the beginning, clearly it was well patronized, lots of people went to see it, you know, and I think that, that has to be partly put down to the fact that it was a new screen technology. And even though television might have been enticing people away from the movies a little bit, there's still no way that a 1950s television could compete with the sort of star studded epics. That was so colorful. And you know, the other than that, you know, the sound has been so rich, and the colors were so dazzling. I don't think television could really compete with these sorts of things. So I can see why the average person on the street with like them, but critics were a little bit more hesitant about this sort of film. So I did find an article which I will cite in the show notes, which had some of my favorite ways of summing up the robe, so I thought you might enjoy them as well. So from the New Statesman on the 28th of November 1953. Most of the film I have found dull and the rest nauseating.

    Dr G 57:50
    Goodness me Well, that one's not not enjoying it at all.

    Dr Rad 57:54
    From the Daily Mail on the 20th of November 1953, fundamentally, distasteful

    Dr G 58:00
    Distasteful.

    Dr Rad 58:03
    From the evening news on the 20th of November 1953, just money down the drain. From the Evening Standard, on the 20th, November 1953, boring heavy faltered and ham fisted

    Dr G 58:18
    look, I think I'd agree with that, to be honest,

    Dr Rad 58:21
    from the Sunday Express on the 22nd of November, tediously earnest and crushingly sentimental. And finally, my favorite one from the Financial Times 20th of November 1953. Although why the Financial Times of reviewing the robe I will never know. A long lacrimose, high class sleeping draught.

    Dr G 58:44
    I spent a lot of money and I napped very well. Thank you. Yeah, look, and I hear that I did find it tough to get through this film. And I will say that there is a moment where I expected the robe to really do itself justice. And the robe failed to show up. And that's the moment where Demetrius is clearly at death's door. Oh, sure. Yeah, there at Marcellus, his dad's house, and the Roman physician is there. And he's like, look, there are limits to what science can achieve. It's like I can't put the blood back in his body. And yeah, kind of gives up on it. And then he walks out there, we have pee to go in. I was like, it's now time for the robe. Surely a healthy application of the robe is going to fix this guy. But not only do we not get to see it, but it doesn't seem like the robe was involved. There's some other miracle happening there. And I was like, Guys, you really missed a trick. The robe could have done the job, and it would have made the magic. palpably real for everybody at that point.

    Dr Rad 59:52
    I know exactly what you mean. But it since they were already planning a sequel, lest we forget that that's what cures Demetrius' love in Demetrius and the Gladiators, part two of The Robe. So I wonder if they knew that that was going to be the plot device for that. Alright. I don't want to undercut the power of the robe. No, yeah, you can't, you got to overuse a piece of fabric. And of course,

    Dr G 1:00:14
    I went into this already knowing that piece of information because we've talked about the sequel before we've talked about the original. So I was kind of like, surely it's robe time, just to wave the robe over and gently have a stand. Yeah, that's a little blanket. And it's like, he's gonna come good. Trust me. We know this. But they don't. And I was like, Ah,

    Dr Rad 1:00:35
    I wonder if it's because they needed to make use of, you know, Peter, a little bit more St. Peter. They needed his talents on display. I mean, he was

    Dr G 1:00:42
    definitely under utilized in this film. I think I was like, Why is he here? He's got to get to Rome. Somehow. I suppose.

    Dr Rad 1:00:49
    I met the guy who plays him. I mean, come on, he really does look like something out of a DaVinci painting. I love that guy. Like already, hats off to you definitely has the look. Yeah, yeah. And I think we mentioned this when we talked about Demetrius and the gladiators. Lest we forget that Christianity became a vehicle for showing your patriotism in this time period in America. And we all know how much Americans love and showing their patriotism. And so it was kind of like one of those things where if the Soviets your enemy in the Cold War, godless communists, then Americans, freedom loving Christians, and so going to church every week was a sign of not only your personal religious faith, but your loyalty to America and your patriotism. So I kind of presume that going to the sorts of films, it must have been something that was very much a part of the, you know, the general vibe, particularly in certain areas in America in this time period.

    Dr G 1:01:56
    Oh, yeah, definitely. And I can imagine there'd be people trying to sell the robe after you left the cinema as well.

    Dr Rad 1:02:05
    Well, funny, you should mention that because I do have another statistic here from also another article that I will cite in the show notes. That said that tells me that between 1950 and 1963 Ancient World epics topped the US box office in seven out of the 13 years, so I don't so we have Samson and Delilah, Victor Mature in 1950. David and Bathsheba in 1951, The Robe in 1953. Then there's a little bit of a lull, is it because of The Robe?

    Dr G 1:02:39
    Probably everybody's like I brought all my tickets. I really can't afford to go to the cinema.

    Dr Rad 1:02:44
    The Ten Commandments in 1957 Ben Hur in 1960s Spartacus in 1962 and Cleopatra in 1963. And Quo Vadis in 1952 was second only pipped at the post by the greatest show on earth. Wow. And this is the same. This is the thing whilst we might say okay, so maybe there's a bit of a yearning for Christianity in this time period because of the cold war. But it's the same way the world over. Now. To be fair, the world is more Christian, as in there are more people that would probably identify as Christians in general, in this time period, as well. So perhaps not surprising, but they don't have to go and see it to show their loyalty to their governments or whatever they're trying to do. So that's true. Yeah, yeah. But I thought I wanted to use this to sum up with, okay, the road, we've done it, I agree with you. It's not my favorite, although I do love Richard Burton and Gene Simmons, as actors in this film, and I do enjoy a bit of curricula. I actually think I enjoyed Demetrius and the gladiators more. But I thought a good way of summing this up was to take this little snippet from a Sunday Times critic called Delos Powell. She wrote something which I really enjoyed, which were the Scripture prizes 1932 to 1961. Are you ready for the awards? Dr. G?

    Dr G 1:04:06
    I'm ready.

    Dr Rad 1:04:07
    Okay. The award for most vulgar film goes to the side of the cross. Applause Applause Applause

    And that's a film from the 1930s. The award for Most nauseating film goes to Quo Vadis.

    The award for the most exhausting film goes to The Ten Commandments.

    Dr G 1:04:38
    That is exhausting as true.

    Dr Rad 1:04:40
    The award for the most nondescript film goes to The Robe.

    Dr G 1:04:47
    Nondescript, yeah,

    Dr Rad 1:04:50
    the award for the most luxurious bloodbaths goes to Samson and Delilah. The award for the most idiotic additional dialogue goes to the big fisherman. award for the most genteel orgy goes to Solomon and Sheba.

    Dr G 1:05:15
    She's just making these categories up.

    Dr Rad 1:05:18
    Yeah, that's the point. And finally, a special chariot race award goes to Ben Hur,

    Dr G 1:05:29
    Hur hur hur. I mean, I'd be very surprised if it went to The Fall of the Roman Empire. But it's up there.

    Dr Rad 1:05:38
    Oh, I think that would definitely be number two, surely. And I will I very much like talking to you about the road because whilst the robe might not actually be the most flashy of the ethics of the Golden Age in the 1950s, it certainly has a lot of the things that I like to talk about, which is the war on television, the studio system at play modern politics, in terms of the foundation of the State of Israel, and of course, American domestic politics, the background of the huge tech hearings and the hunt for reds under the bed.

    Dr G 1:06:19
    Yes, wow. Caligula did have a very red robe and that should be a hint to anybody

    Dr Rad 1:06:25
    Absolutely.

    Transcribed by https://otter.ai

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    1 hr 9 min
  • Building the Bromance

    What do you get when Mamercus Aemilius Mamercinus and Aulus Cornelius Cossus return in our source material? The continuation of a beautiful bromance.

    After an unfortunate amount of disease and destruction in our last episode, we return to Rome for some classic political and military action.

    The Romans are ready to put a year of horrible drought behind them and seek revenge on Veii and the ongoing thorn in their side. Fidenae. It also turns out that war is the perfect backdrop for some male bonding.

    Episode 135 – Building the Bromance

    Jupiter as my Witness!

    Before the Romans can get involved in any conflicts with Veii, there are rules of warfare that need to be observed. It is time for the fetiales! With Jupiter as their witness, they will make sure that Rome only goes to war in the right circumstances.

    Fresco of Jupiter, National Archaeological Museum of Naples (inv. nr.9551).
    From Pompeii, House of the Dioscuri, dating to the 1st century CE, so much later than the 420s BCE! Jupiter was invoked by thefetiales during their rituals.
    Image courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.

    Building the Bromance

    The Romans elect military tribunes with consular power as they embark on their war with Veii. Unfortunately, the tribunes don’t have a talent for teamwork. It’s time for a dictator!

    Our old friend Cossus nominates Mamercus Aemilius as dictator. In return, Aemilius makes Cossus his Master of the Horse. The bromance between these two is so strong that Veii doesn’t stand a chance. They are the Roman equivalent of Batman and Robin.

    Watch out Etruscans! The caped crusaders are out to get you.

    The classic duo: is that Mamercus and Cossus or Batman and Robin? When we squint, we can't even tell, that's how strong the bromance is here.

    Things to Look Out For:
    • More confusion over consuls  
    • Murder most foul
    • Birds in the sky (they might be trying to tell you something)
    • Smugness from Mamercus
    • Fiery combat
    • Did we write a book? Oh boy, yes we did! If you enjoy the podcast, this might be just the ticket. You can purchase our popular history Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome HERE
    • Interested in the first instalment of the bromance between Cossus and Mamercus? We've got you covered – that'd be Episode 129 – Lars Tolumnius and the Fate of Fidenae
    Our Players 427 BCEConsuls
    • C. Servilius – f. – n. Structus Ahala (Pat) Mil. Tr. c. p. 419, 418, 417
    • L. Papirius (L. f. – n.) Mugillanus (Pat) Mil. Tr. c. p. 422
    Our Players 426 BCEMilitary Tribunes with Consular Power
    • T. Quinctius L. f. L. n. Poenus Cincinnatus (Pat) Cos 431, 428a, Mil. Tr. c. p. 420?
    • C. Furius – f. – n. Pacilus Fusus (Pat) Cos. 441
    • M. Postumius A. ? f. A.? n. Albinus Regillensis? (Pat) Mil. Tr. c. p. 403?
    • A. Cornelius M. f. L. n. Cossus (Pat) Cos. 428
    Dictator
    • Mam. Aemilius M. f. – n. Mamercinus (Pat)
    Master of the Horse
    • A. Cornelius M. f. L. n. Cossus (Pat) Cos. 428a, Mil. Tr. c. p. 426
    Legates
    • T. Quinctius Poenus Cincinattus (Pat) Cos. 431, Mil. tr. c. p. 426, 420?
    Our Sources
    • Dr G reads Diodorus Siculus 12.78.1, 12.80.1; Dionysius of Halicarnassus Roman Antiquities 12.6; Valerius Maximus 3.2.4; Frontinus Stratagems 2.4.18-19, 2.8.9; Florus 1.6.7; Aurelius Victor De Viris Illustribus urbis Romae 25; Orosius 2.13.8-11
    • Dr Rad reads Livy ab Urbe Condita 4.31-34.
    • Broughton, T. R. S., Patterson, M. L. 1951. The Magistrates of the Roman Republic Volume 1: 509 B.C. – 100 B.C. (The American Philological Association)
    • Cornell, T. J. 1995. The Beginnings of Rome: Italy and Rome from the Bronze Age to the Punic Wars (c. 1000-264 BC) (Taylor & Francis)
    • Forsythe, G. 2006. A Critical History of Early Rome: From Prehistory to the First Punic War(University of California Press) 
    • Ogilvie, R. M. 1965. A Commentary on Livy: Books 1-5 (Clarendon Press). 
    • Santangelo, F. 2008. ‘The Fetials and Their Ius’. Bulletin: Institute of Classical Studies 51:1, 63-93.
    Sound Effects

    Fesliyan Studios, Orange Free Sounds and Pixabay.

    Thanks to the fabulous Bettina Joy de Guzman for our theme music.

    The Apollo of Veii, dated to around 550-520 BCE. This is a terracotta artefact that is now held in the National Etruscan Museum in Rome.
    Source: Obelisk Art History Project.

    Automated Transcript

    Transcript generated by Otter AI. Edited by Dr G for those tricky Latin names!

    Dr Rad 0:16
    Welcome to The Partial Historians,

    Dr G 0:19
    we explore all the details of ancient Rome.

    Dr Rad 0:22
    Everything from the political scandals, the love affairs, the battles waged, and when citizens turn against each other. I'm Dr. Rad.

    Dr G 0:33
    And I'm Dr. G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.

    Dr Rad 0:43
    Join us, as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.

    Dr G 0:54
    Hello, and welcome to a brand new episode of The Partial Historians. I am one of your hosts, Dr. G. And sitting with me in the realm of cyberspace.

    Dr Rad 1:09
    Is Dr. Rad. That's cyberspace.

    Dr G 1:17
    I feel ya, I feel ya. And we are tracing the history of Rome from the foundation of the city. And hoo-we, we have made it out of the 430s and scraped into the 420s. And we are about to look at 427 BCE. But before we do that, perhaps we should do a bit of a recap of where we're up to in the narrative.

    Dr Rad 1:47
    I was just thinking to myself, how do you recap nothing? How do you recap, the nothingness that was the previous three years?

    Dr G 1:58
    Well, I mean, it's not like there was absolutely nothing. There was a drought, there were some there was some bad news. And there was a truce made between the Aequians and the Romans.

    Dr Rad 2:10
    Definitely, like there was some stuff going on. But by the standards that we have come to expect of Rome, it was it was low, it was low.

    Dr G 2:20
    And I think we can attribute part of the fallowness of those years to the source material. As much as Livy is still with us. He did say that nothing happened.

    Dr Rad 2:33
    He did, I can't deny it. But also, I feel like this has to do a lot with what we've been talking about for a really long time now, literally years for us. So decades. For the Romans, we talked about the fact that there does seem to have been this really tough time in Roman history. If we look at the archaeological record, I thought we were looking at a tough time in the late 450s and into the 440s. But I had no idea what was awaiting us in the 430s. It is out of control.

    Dr G 3:10
    Yeah, there's heaps of problems with like, what might be going on with how Rome is in central Italy in this period. And, as we've noted before, there's not any sort of extensive record of a building programme, we've had some references to what this new temple to Apollo come up in the last few years, but that's the first building we've heard about in a while.

    Dr Rad 3:33
    They're suspicious of that building now.

    Dr G 3:36
    Yes,

    Dr Rad 3:36
    Just slightly, just slightly

    Dr G 3:37
    That temple. Can we trust Apollo? That God looks fishy to me. And so they have a sense in which their competition with their neighbours is so all consuming that it makes it very difficult to make progress at home. And that's just adding into what is the broader confusion, which is all of our source material, generally speaking, comes from centuries later, where they're unsure about what happened. And they're trying to figure it out from the limited records that have survived from this period. And they're a little bit all over the shop. So we're in some trying times, and that's okay. We'll just keep going.

    Dr Rad 4:23
    Look, I'm excited because the next couple of years, I know that there's potential for some very dramatic things to happen. So let's get into it, Dr. G. Let's head into 427 BCE!

    Dr G 5:20
    It is 427 BCE and Dionysius of Halicarnassus is missing.

    Dr Rad 5:29
    Fair enough. Well, once again, you know, I'm very good sharer. You should have the magistrates you should have that honour.

    Dr G 5:36
    Oh, thank you. Thank you. Well, I don't have many to report for this year. We apparently have the names of the consuls. So we've got Gaius Servilius Structus Ahala. Ahala!

    Dr Rad 5:54
    Ahala the armpit.

    Dr G 5:58
    Ahala.

    Dr Rad 5:59
    Yes, the famous armpit. Yeah.

    Dr G 6:01
    Well, yeah, so I was gonna say if this name sounds familiar, it's because we've already had a very infamous Gaius Servilius Ahala, the armpit as master of the horse in 439, who was responsible for or scapegoated as the person responsible for the assassination of Spurius Maeilus, also known as the Nacho King. And so this is big news because literally the same name, but we do think that they're different people. This seems to be the next one down the line.

    Dr Rad 6:39
    He was meant to be sent into exile, wasn't he?

    Dr G 6:41
    Well yeah, he was sent into exile. We don't seem to hear from him again. And do have this name Structus stuck in this guy for this year. And that name is not present for our previous Gaius Servilius Ahala. So okay, we don't really we're not really sure, but it does seem to be slightly different guy.

    Dr Rad 7:04
    Okay.

    Dr G 7:05
    So possibly the eldest son of the infamous armpit because the Ahala name is one of these cognomens, so it's one of these sort of individualising names. But how many people could be known by their armpit?

    Dr Rad 7:21
    I've never thought about it. I never thought.

    Dr G 7:25
    I mean, if this is a nickname, I don't know, but maybe it's inherited. And our second consul is Lucius Papirius Mugillanus.

    Dr Rad 7:35
    Papirius again!

    Dr G 7:39
    Another Papirii so this gens is doing well for themselves. But this guy is new. Mugillanus is a new figure that we haven't really come across before. This seems to be connected, potentially, to a family from the Latin town of Mugilla.

    Dr Rad 7:59
    Okay.

    Dr G 8:00
    Don't bother trying to find it on any maps because we don't know where it was.

    Dr Rad 8:05
    Then Moogly up to the server at night. All right, look, I've got a little bit of detail about this year. So let's get into it. I think you'll see the pace is starting to build up again. So this is a good sign. So, as is typical for Livy, we've had this horrible drought, causing all sorts of problems in terms of disease, death, chaos

    Dr G 8:29
    Mange.

    Dr Rad 8:30
    In the previous year. Yeah, it's all bad. But it's miraculously just all over now. We're on to new things, and the Romans feel well enough to seek vengeance against Veii who, lest we forget, seem to have been conducting some raids into Roman territory over the past year or two.

    Dr G 8:50
    All right, I'm just gonna interrupt you there because it's clearly rained, which means and this is one for the Australian listeners, Marge, the rains are here!

    Dr Rad 9:04
    Classic Simpsons reference and in the previous episode, we had a great Seinfeld reference, we're basking in the glory of the 90s.

    Dr G 9:12
    It's all happening.

    Dr Rad 9:13
    It is alright, so they want to deal with Veii. Okay, and we've got our consuls as you said. However, it was decided that they could not declare war on Veii straightaway. So we know that there's been this niggling backwards and forwards, but it was iffy about whether they were actually you know, still at war, like it was like an ongoing conflict that they could just renew. And I guess it was decided that it was best to be cautious and therefore presume that they weren't really already at war with they, and therefore this means that some of your favourites the fetiales have to go through their procedures before anything else can happen. So I thought this might actually be a good time to sort of review, what it is that these people do?

    Dr G 10:03
    Oh, yeah, look, the fetiales is some of my favourite priests. So they come in pairs. And they roam about the countryside looking for just war. so

    Dr Rad 10:14
    Sounds very noble when you put it like that

    Dr G 10:17
    One of them is dressed very fancily, one of them's not. And they go around together, if if Rome is in the mood, where they're like, we really do think that possibly conflict is on the horizon, is it going to be just in the eyes of the gods, then they get the fetiale crew out and about, and they have a very particular job, they've got a walk towards the territory, which Rome has a problem with. And as they walk along, they sort of announced periodically that they are seeking some sort of like righting of the relationship between Rome and this place, particularly when they get to what is considered to be the borderland between the two and before they step over into the symbolic other place, then they keep going, and periodically keep saying the things until they start to encounter people of that land. And you know, the message starts to spread, and these to continue onwards towards the major city centre of whatever place it is, and continue to announce, and they make some demands being like, you need to really liaise with Rome, otherwise, it's going to be a bit problematic, then they wait a specified period of time for an answer. And if they get one, that's fine, they take it back to Rome, and they start to figure things out from there. If they don't get one, they head back to Rome. And they're like, I think it might be time to consider a just war. And so then they go out again, and they do a bit of spear throwing into the other territory. And check out how the gods react to that. And if it's all looking good. War is just and may commence in the eyes of the god.

    Dr Rad 11:51
    Yeah, absolutely. They have this really interesting position where to quote the article that will be in our sources. So if you want to have a look at this article in full, please do they are in a sense, the people that preside over the rights that precede a war begin a war and at the end of the war, as well. And they serve this really interesting role as the kind of judges slash guardians of the peace of Rome, which I like as a nice little way of conjuring up what it is they do. And their role changed over time, as we shall see, it's not it's not always exactly the same.

    Dr G 12:33
    Look, there's nothing like a good twist on the tale, or like these are priests that are definitely involved in war. So to suggest that they're very much involved with peace is fascinating and hilarious.

    Dr Rad 12:45
    Well, yes. I mean, I think in terms of, you know, as you say, it's about are the Romans going to war for the right reasons should peace be broken, I suppose in order to go to war in that sense. Yes. Anyway, so we have the fetiales going through their proper procedures, okay. And we know, of course, there has been some conflicts with Rome and Veii because they were involved in the whole issue, over Fidenae, the colony that was and then wasn't, and then was, but doesn't seem to be committing to it wholeheartedly. You know, it's all very iffy with Veii and Fidenae at this point in time, I think we can definitely say that, if what the accounts that were given are correct. Rome is really struggling to assert itself in this whole decade in this part of Italy.

    Dr G 13:39
    Yeah, they can send as many fetiales as they like searching for just war, but they can't hold it together. And they can't seem to retain the things that they have laid out as their own. So Fidenae was theirs. And they're definitely struggling to hold on to it at this point.

    Dr Rad 13:57
    Yeah. So after the whole issue that they had had over Fidenae, they had a truce with Veii that had expired, admittedly, but the Romans still see the need to obviously declare war properly. So the fetiales go out and do their business, but rudely, they are completely ignored.

    Dr G 14:17
    Yeah, amazing. Well, I mean, let's face it, let's imagine you imagine the time these two weirdos from Rome, one of them dress very fancily, and the other one sort of like he's offsider and they sort of approaching and they're doing this sort of like, did you know that you are not in right relation with Rome?

    Dr Rad 14:42
    Like ah, yeah, I think I just stole your cow.

    Dr G 14:46
    They're like, Well, sure, but whatever. And then the you know, like they walk another 50 metres and like, did you know that you're not a right relation with Rome, and you know, like waving a fancy stick and stuff. And I can see how some people might not take them very seriously. Or, conversely realise the import of these two people and just laugh in their faces being like, this is how your gonna win the war. Really?

    Dr Rad 15:18
    I feel like the people of Veii are not particularly interested in preserving peaceful relations at this moment in time. So.

    Dr G 15:26
    And they probably have good confidence for that.

    Dr Rad 15:28
    Yeah. Well, should they though? Should they?

    Dr G 15:31
    Well, well, I guess we'll find out.

    Dr Rad 15:36
    Anyway, so it's obvious that a war is going to happen. A controversy breaks out over who has the right to actually declare the war? Is it the Senate or the people?

    Wha-whoa

    Turf war. Yeah. So I think it's, I think it's seen as like standard procedure at this point in time that the people are generally the ones that decide whether they are going to go to war. But they're starting to say, well, do we need to take it to the people? Is the senatorial decree enough? Now, again, this is probably a little bit anachronistic, I am not entirely confident in this idea of a senatorial decree, at this point in Rome's history. Now we are getting later, maybe I'm being overly cautious.

    Dr G 16:25
    We're in this very hazy period where it's hard to say. So from thinking about how Rome works. And we're not sure like that's, that's where we're at in terms of the scholarship, we're not entirely sure how it's working at this point in time. What we do know is that, generally speaking, the Roman people are involved in decisions relating to war, because it relates to things that they're specifically going to have to do.

    Dr Rad 16:57
    Yeah.

    Dr G 16:57
    And the Senate has lots of mechanisms and levers to push and pull those people in particular ways. This is not a democracy. But surely, the Senate has enough of its own levers still, to be able to persuade the people one way or the other. I would have thought this would suggest if we're looking at something where the Senate is like, well, we're just going to make that decision for everybody. That would seem to suggest to me that they've actually lost control of the populace.

    Dr Rad 17:29
    Hmm, interesting take. So the tribunes ended up winning this argument, which kind of makes sense. I would kind of expect them to be the people who are representing the people. And they say, look, you're going to let the people say whether it's war or not, because if you don't, then we're going to screw up your levy. And then who's going to fight for you, Senate? Who, who?

    Dr G 17:56
    Dear Lucretia, I didn't sign up for the levy this year. But somehow I'm still in the battlefield. I don't know how it happened.

    Dr Rad 18:03
    I am apart from you. And it is so painful, because I do not know why.

    Dr G 18:10
    I didn't sign up for this. And I don't know why I'm here.

    Dr Rad 18:14
    So what ends up happening is and this is a bit weird, Livy, or at least the versions of it that I'm reading, so it might be a typo. I probably should have checked the Latin I was a bit slack and I didn't, the consul Quinctius, which is weird, because we haven't mentioned a Quinctius in this year.

    Dr G 18:30
    Yeah, that's a surprise. Where does it Quinctius? Where is he coming from?

    Dr Rad 18:35
    I'm wondering if he means like the ex-consul Quinctius, that's something I probably should have checked in the Latin that me. But anyway, he's forced to present the question of war to the people. And you know what, it all ends up exactly how they wanted it anyway, because the centuries all vote for war anyway.

    Dr G 18:52
    Well, well, well. So I mean, it turns out that, in actuality, flesh rabbits, cause we're still not really sure what's going on, that the Senate gets their way by using the very levers that it already possesses in order to ensure that the people do what they want them to do, because we know that that voting system is I mean, by any measure of a modern standard completely rigged.

    This this artificial tension. It's really probably not anywhere near as dramatic as it sounds.

    The people agree to the thing that they've been convinced to agree to, and war shall proceed.

    Dr Rad 19:35
    Yeah. And the rich people have most of the say.

    Dr G 19:39
    Hmm.

    Dr Rad 19:39
    Either way. Either way you look at it.

    Dr G 19:42
    I mean, does it sound like the modern world?

    Dr Rad 19:45
    I don't know. The modern world is just such a delight filled with equality and justice.

    Dr G 19:52
    Indeed.

    Dr Rad 19:54
    So this takes me to the year that I've been very excited to get to for actually a number of episodes.

    Dr G 20:00
    Oh, okay, well hold that thought. I only have, I only have one more detail to add about this year.

    Dr Rad 20:06
    I was going to say, what detail are you adding?

    Dr G 20:09
    Before we vacate 427, I just want to draw attention to what appears to be the naming conventions in some of the Fasti records that we have attached to this year for Mr. Armpit himself. Ahala. Yeah, because in the Greek this comes through as Axilla. And in one of the Latin Fastis that comes through as Achillo. So we get this sense that there is a potential sort of like Achillius naming convention that might be coming through here where Ahala has been substituted in instead, or there's been a merging of those names over time. Anyway. Yeah, not that I see this guy as being in any way resemblance of Achilles. But, I mean, we don't really know what he did. But I thought it was an interesting little detail.

    Dr Rad 21:09
    Yeah, like until he has a temper tantrum and really stuffs things up for everyone, I'm not convinced.

    Dr G 21:15
    The other thing that's worth noting is Diodorus Siculus gets the names right for both consuls this year.

    Dr Rad 21:22
    Wow.

    Dr G 21:25
    Yeah, bringing his a game to this year.

    Dr Rad 21:28
    He is. All right. So that takes us to 426 BCE. At last!

    Dr G 21:34
    We're here this year is filled with drama, and people and potentially lots of stuff.

    Dr Rad 21:41
    Absolutely. So I don't know about you, Dr. G. But instead of consuls, I've got military tribunes with consular power.

    Dr G 21:48
    Oh, yes. I got some of those as well.

    Dr Rad 21:51
    Alright, tell me.

    Dr G 21:52
    So we have Titus Quinctius Poenas Cincinnatus,

    Dr Rad 21:57
    Who might be the Quinctius who Livy is talking about

    Dr G 21:59
    Indeed, in the previous year.

    Dr Rad 22:02
    Yeah.

    Dr G 22:02
    So he has been consul twice so far, 431 and in 428, and is now back in this new position. With consular power. We have Gaius Furius Pacilus Fusus.

    Dr Rad 22:19
    Yeah, it's been ages since we had a Furius – whoo!

    Dr G 22:23
    A Furius returns.

    Dr Rad 22:24
    Yeah.

    Dr G 22:25
    And he was apparently also previously consul in 441, so this guy's gotta be getting on a little bit, because it's been a while.

    Dr Rad 22:32
    Yeah, it has.

    Dr G 22:33
    And he was also censor in 435. So they've done quite a few censorships as well. It's been, it's been tough times for the Romans. Our third military tribune with consular power is Marcus Postumius Albinus Regillensis. A new guy in town. Don't be fooled all of those names add up to somebody different. And Aulus Cornelius Cossus, the best looking Roman that everybody's ever known about.

    Dr Rad 23:04
    Absolutely.

    Dr G 23:05
    Very famous. Is this the year he's famous for?

    Dr Rad 23:10
    I think it might be. We also have a dictator, don't we?

    Dr G 23:15
    Yeah. So this year, it gets out of hand. So the thing that we tend to assume with military tribunes with consular power is that there is a lot of conflict going on, and Rome doesn't know how to deal with it anymore. And they need more consuls, essentially. And so they've whacked a whole bunch of those people into play. Turns out or it seems initially just from reading this list that that is not enough to deal with this situation and a dictator is required. And this is Mamercus Aemilius Mamercinus.

    Dr Rad 23:45
    A familiar name.

    Dr G 23:46
    Yeah, he was part of the special commission in 428. So just a couple of years ago, and you know this name crops up a little bit as well. Was he also the dictator of 437 and 434? Was he milit- was he military tribune in 438? It's a common name. So he has a master of the horse and we see very quickly the return of Aulus Cornelius Cossus getting apparently upgraded from a military tribune with consular power to master the horse.

    Dr Rad 24:20
    I think these guys are Batman and Robin I think that they are the dynamic duo of this decade.

    Dr G 24:26
    I can't possibly do it without your Cossus. Would you join me? Yes, sir.

    Dr Rad 24:31
    All right, well,

    Dr G 24:32
    oh wait oh wait, because apparently we also have a legate as well

    Dr Rad 24:38
    Okay

    Dr G 24:39
    Which is Titus Quinctius Poenas Cincinnatus. So, so we have this weird sort of, I would say just looking at this list that we are looking at some real confusion from our annalistic sources and our fasti source material. Very confusing. We've either got many people in multiple roles, or we've got a collapse in the chronology and people don't know how to separate the years out into the individual pieces, and they've just lumped them all in together and they're like, You know what? I'll make it work.

    Dr Rad 25:13
    Yeah, I think that you can see this very much, because if you actually look at what Livy says, rather than look at Broughton's record of the magistrates. Livy explicitly says that Titus Quinctius Poenas was consul in the previous year. So that's a bit weird. And then we've got Gaius Furius, Marcus Postumius, Aulua Cornelius Cossus all serving as military tribunes. Now, what they do is they're going to divide and conquer, Dr. G. So Cossus is placed in charge of the city of Rome itself, and the rest of the military tribunes start organising the levy because they of course, are going to go and kick Veii's butt and it is a big butt. There is a problem. Yeah, there is a problem. You've got three of these guys. They're, I imagine, pretty typical Roman elites. They're all very confident in their own opinion, and they refuse to compromise. And so they very quickly start disagreeing with each other, which means that there's a little sliver of light for the people of Veii, because this is going to be undermining for the whole Roman war effort. The army is really confused because they're being given different instructions, different orders, you know, some of them are saying, now go sound the charge other than saying no, not yet. Stay in place. It's just it's just a big mess where he's messy us at a time like this. He's the man has a job. Yeah. So the Romans are in terrible trouble. They flee back to their camp. They're not really physically injured or anything, but they are injured on the inside, because there is nothing more humiliating or shameful for a Roman soldier than having to tuck his tail between his legs and run back to his camp without having dominated over the entity.

    Dr G 27:09
    It is tough out there, isn't it.

    Dr Rad 27:12
    Yeah, so the Romans are sitting around, crushed, forlorn, heartbroken deal to lose They're the heroes in this story. They never lose.

    Dr G 27:22
    I got no spoils and I got nothing to send, ya.

    Dr Rad 27:27
    Now the people back in the city are so irritated. You can't explain how irritated they are with the military tribunes and they're like, you know what, forget you guys, you are useless. It's time for a dictator. Now, it seems like once again, we have a bit of an argument about exactly how or even if this could come about, some people were saying earlier consul can name a dictator. And do we have a consul? No, we do not.

    Dr G 28:01
    No, but we do have lots of military tribunes with consular power. And if they have the consular power, that might mean they're they're able to do the thing. And

    Dr Rad 28:11
    I think you're missing the point, they're not a consul.

    Dr G 28:16
    Well, what's the point of them having consular power if they can't use it? Dionysius of Halicarnassus does have a little excerpt here.

    Dr Rad 28:26
    Oh, okay.

    Dr G 28:28
    Yeah. And he talks about when Aulua Cornelius Cossus was consul for the second time.

    Dr Rad 28:38
    Okay.

    Dr G 28:39
    And that's problematic for a whole bunch of reasons.

    Dr Rad 28:42
    Sure.

    Dr G 28:43
    Partly because maybe what he goes on to say, should really go back to 428. Right, but we're in maybe 426 as well. So for instance, there's a whole bunch of sort of like Dionysius comes back, but like to what value because he talks about a land that has suffered from a severe drought, all the moisture, and the flowing streams have dried up so you know, the echoes of Livy here?

    Dr Rad 29:16
    Yeah, definitely.

    Dr G 29:17
    The sheep, beasts of burden, and cattle have disappeared.

    Dr Rad 29:21
    Oh, this all sounds very familiar. Don't take me back there!

    Dr G 29:26
    Humans have been visited by many diseases.

    Dr Rad 29:28
    Yeah, yeah. Deja vu.

    Dr G 29:31
    Particularly the mange

    Dr Rad 29:34
    oh my god,

    Dr G 29:35
    yeah, dreadful pains in the skin with its itchings and ulcerations, a most pitable affliction, and the cause of the speediest of deaths. I mean, it doesn't sound like mange, it sounds like Ebola, but I'll give it to them. They're calling it as they see it. But we have this issue because he talks about this is the time period when Cossus and Quinctius are consuls together.

    Dr Rad 29:59
    Hmm

    Dr G 30:00
    And that's that's a weird thing to say. But they're definitely both military tribunes with consular power right now.

    Dr Rad 30:08
    Yeah, look, I think I can help you out here. It's actually quite straightforward. Dionysius is wrong and Livy is right.

    Dr G 30:15
    Wow

    Dr Rad 30:15
    it's just really obvious and I'm glad I could clear it up for you and everyone.

    Dr G 30:26
    I don't know if I'm gonna buy what you're putting down but

    Dr Rad 30:30
    All right, is that is that all the Dionysius has to say?

    Dr G 30:32
    Yeah, look, I mean, things get pretty wayward for me in this year in terms of source material. Just to give you a sense of like, where this is going, I've got some Diodorus Siculus. I've got some Valerius Maximus, I've got some Frontinus. Two different passages from Frontinus. I've got Florus, I've got Aurelius Victor, Pseudo-Aurelius Victor and Orosius.

    Dr Rad 30:55
    Okay

    Dr G 30:55
    So it's all manner of craziness over here for like, trying to figure out what to do with this year. But it tells you that something's gonna happen, I think. And you might know what it is, even though I've got no idea despite all the sources I looked at.

    Dr Rad 31:09
    I think I do. So we've gotten this argument about whether you actually consul to name a dictator, so they ended up turning to the augurs which I thought would be something that would excite you. So, the augurs are a religious position, do you want to tell us a bit about what it is that they do? I had, I hear it's something to do with the bird life?

    Dr G 31:31
    Yeah, look, it's the sort of thing that could go wrong if you decide to not follow the rituals like they did a couple of years ago. You know, like, imagine if you decided to start reading the bird signs differently. The augurs have a very specific role. So part of it is dividing up the sky into quadrants, first of all, and then looking and observing the way that birds move in the sky to determine the will of the gods. And the reason why you might be like, I mean, I've seen birds fly, not that interesting. But one of the things that they're really interested in is those murmurations that you get of starlings as they shift through the air, which are really quite poetic and beautiful. And they're considered to tell us something, but they're interested in all variety of bird life really, vultures, eagles, whatever they can see, it's all got some sort of meaning. And the augurs have been integral to the Roman's self definition since time in memorial

    Dr Rad 32:34
    Indeed they have. So the augurs are consulted, and they make sure that the signs say that it is not only a council who could name a dictator.

    Dr G 32:45
    Well, that makes it easy.

    Dr Rad 32:46
    Yeah. So Aulua Cornelius Cossus picks Mamercus Aemilius as dictator and Mamercus Aemilius then names Cossus as his master of the horse. Aren't they are adorable.

    Dr G 33:00
    These two like, will you be my buddy? I'll be your buddy. If you'll be my buddy.

    Dr Rad 33:05
    It's a bromance to last the centuries, Dr G. Yeah. So now, just a bit of a recap here. Lest we forget the last time that we were talking about Mamercus Aemilius which okay, there are some question marks about whether we should have been talking about him in that time period. but we were, he was taken down by the censors in a pretty devastating way. He basically I mean, they basically took away some of his key rights as a citizen, like they kicked him out of his tribe.

    Dr G 33:35
    Intense.

    Dr Rad 33:37
    Yeah.

    Dr G 33:38
    But he seems to have bounced back from this.

    Dr Rad 33:41
    Well, this is the thing Livy comments that this guy was so amazing, that he just rises to the top when it's a dangerous time for Rome. You know, I mean, suck it censors. The best revenge is a life well lived. You know, you can't take it away from me.

    Dr G 33:58
    He must be charismatic, I'm guessing.

    Dr Rad 34:01
    I think so. Livy was all over him the last time like when we were talking about what the census did to him live, he was clearly devastated. And now he's all happy again. Anyway, the people have they are thrilled in the meantime, because they've done so well against Rome. They're like, oh, my god, this is amazing. So they send out word to other Etruscan cities, they're like, yeah, we didn't just take down one Roman commander, we took down three in just one battle, only. The Etruscans are not interested. They're like, whatever.

    Dr G 34:35
    I wonder what the Etruscans by and large, are really doing. I mean, we know that they're located generally, to the north, but Veii is like their most southern significant outpost. Yeah. And they really don't tend to do a lot of reinforcement, or at least not in this period.

    Dr Rad 34:52
    Look, let that be a lesson to you. It's the same issues that the Greeks had: unity. Unity is what is important. Don't go back to each other up because you do anyway. So the Etruscans are not interested. However, there are some people who are interested in joining their cause because of course, whenever there's this kind of thing going on, like reading whatever, there is bougie aplenty for everyone. So officially, not many people are interested, but there are some. And would you be shocked to know that one of the places that decide that they might join in is none other than Fidenae?

    Dr G 35:35
    Oh, colour me surprised. This is a turn in the narrative I was not expecting.

    Dr Rad 35:40
    Yep. So Fidenae. I mean, god, what is it at this point in time, it's been going backwards and forwards with its allegiances so many times between Rome and the people of Veii I can't even tell what ethnicity the people there would have been.

    Dr G 35:55
    Look like everybody in this region. They're Italians.

    Dr Rad 35:59
    Okay, yes. Anyway, so they decided they're going to throw their lot in with Veii. Again, because it went so well, the last time.

    Dr G 36:07
    Well look, to be honest, I think Fidenae had been pretty consistent in their desire to get away from Rome for at least a few years now. And they've been forced and coerced by the Romans back into the fold. And at every opportunity, they'd be like, nah, I'm with those guys.

    Dr Rad 36:25
    How dare you provide an anti imperial narrative when I'm trying to make Rome look good?

    Dr G 36:32
    I've got nothing to say to that.

    Dr Rad 36:34
    Dad, dad, dad, dad out data.

    Dr G 36:38
    I mean, anyway, they're working on it.

    Dr Rad 36:41
    Anyway, so Fidenae, obviously, as you say, not happy with what's going on. But they decided to do it in style, just like they did the first time. So lest we forget, the really big conflict that we talked about, which may or may not have happened about 10 years ago, was really kicked off when the people of Fidenae murdered the Roman ambassadors. This time, they decide they're going to slaughter all the new settlers.

    Dr G 37:11
    Well, well, well, I mean, yeah, this is bad news. But it does echo very nicely what has previously happened.

    Dr Rad 37:22
    Yeah, I mean, I think we can understand why scholars are like, what is going on here? Did this really happen again? Or is there some confusion in the narrative because there are a lot of similar notes that are being struck here.

    Dr G 37:37
    And there's also the sense of like, I mean, this is yet again, another candidate for the year that Cossus does the business with killing Lars Tolumnius? That guy keeps coming back from the dead. Tell you what,

    Dr Rad 37:52
    Well he hasn't been mentioned by name. But yes. Anyway, so there's a bit of a debate about where they're going to set up their headquarters. Veii or Fidenae, but they decided that Fidenae was more suitable. So the people of Veii head on over there and set up. The Romans are freaking out.

    Dr G 38:09
    And this and fair enough, because it's on. As I've noted before, like Fidenae sits on the opposite side of the Tiber, from Veii, which means that it technically sits on the Roman side of the Tiber. And the Tiber is considered this, like, you know, the point between the two territories. And so if you've got that foothold in Fidenae and the Fidenese, like let down their little bridge, or whatever, or the who knows how they did it, and they're like, come across, Veii come across, it's like you're letting the foxes into the chicken coop of Rome.

    Dr Rad 38:47
    Yeah, I get ya. So Veii recall their forces from Veii who aren't in a great mood. They're pretty depressed, to be honest. Because things haven't gone well until then. And they set up camp just outside the Colline gate. One of the many ways that you can get into Rome which apparently is walls at this point in time,

    Dr G 39:07
    Well, yeah, and they and the Colline gate is at that side of room that will lead them directly to Fidenae. So all makes sense.

    Dr Rad 39:14
    Yeah, absolutely. So they make sure everything's pretty fortified. You know, they do the typical thing arms, men placed along the walls. They also kind of say, right, everybody stop what you're doing. Pay attention. So business in the courts stop shops close. Livy says that Rome ends up looking more like a military camp than a city at this point in time. The dictator now starts to get down to what he was brought in to do in the first place. He dispatches heralds to go through all the streets of Rome, to round them all up because they're all terrified and cowering. Take them to an assembly. When they get there. He is furious with them for being so quick to think that Rome is actually going to be defeated. How dare they? Rome had beaten Veii six times and captured Fidenae so many times he can't even count for heaven's sakes. Get a grip. And they didn't lose just recently because their army was weak. They lost because their commanders were arguing. Big difference.

    Dr G 40:13
    And now, now they have a dictator, there's gonna be no more arguing and only victory.

    Dr Rad 40:32
    Exactly. And he says, You just wait guys, you will see that the men who appointed me as dictator have done an amazing thing for Rome because I am awesome. Everybody thinks so. Especially Livy!

    Dr G 40:46
    Also Cossus the man who appointed him.

    Dr Rad 40:49
    Exactly and those who tried to ruin him had done the biggest disservice to the state. Hint, hint, censors, need some ointment for that burn. So Mamercus then makes an offering to the gods. Again, this is all sounding very familiar, but not not like it's not standard practice. I was gonna say

    Dr G 41:13
    I mean, I mean that's familiar but to be expected.

    Dr Rad 41:16
    Yes, absolutely. Marches out sets up camp near Fidenae, make sure that he is shielded by mountains on one side and protected by the Tiber on the other so strategically sound position, he orders his lieutenant to secure the mountains and to secretly sneak sneak sneak occupy the riches behind the enemy. So that's Titus Quinctius Poenas. So he puts on his sneakers, he gets all the men following him to put on their sneakers. And they are, are over to that location. So the next day, the enemy are feeling pretty confident because of course of everything that's been happening, they're ready to fight. The Romans are like, you got lucky. Thank you very much. Mamercus, however, he is not going to be rushed by these people. He's not impetuous, he is wise. So he's going to wait until he's got all his ducks lined up in a row. He needs to make sure that Quinctius has made it to the ridge so that he's secretly in position.

    Dr G 42:22
    Yeah, it's one of those powerful things going into battle to be the one making the decisions.

    Dr Rad 42:28
    Yeah. And it's then that he decides, okay, I think I'm almost ready. I'm going to take my infantry and against the enemy. And I'm going to do it really quickly at speed, like, whoo, you blink and we're there.

    Dr G 42:42
    Guys, I want you to sprint on my command.

    Dr Rad 42:44
    Now notice I did say infantry, because he has a special plan for the cavalry. Now, naturally, master of the horse does seem to have some sort of connection to cavalry. And so Cossus is in charge of the cavalry. He says, don't follow me. I want you to wait and not join the battle until you get an order from me. I need to keep the cavalry from coming in. And so just the right moment, and then it's going to be the biggest thing you've ever seen, Cossus. Do you remember how awesome you were? You killed a freaking king, man, last time? I can't even wait to see you at the head of the cavalry. This is gonna be awesome. He actually says that to him.

    Dr G 43:32
    Yeah, okay, so in Livy's account. Lars Tolumnius is definitely already, well dead.

    Dr Rad 43:42
    Oh, yeah. He's just like, he's just like, look, remember how amazing you were the last time we went battle together, man. Let's bring that energy again. Let's get the band back together. Batman and Robin – Whoo. Whoo.

    Dr G 43:52
    It's gonna be great.

    Dr Rad 43:55
    They jump together and they chest touch but because they're wearing some sort of armour, it doesn't go too well.

    Dr G 44:01
    Yeah

    Dr Rad 44:01
    I'm just kidding. All right, so the battle commences – it is fierce. The Romans are so mad because of the murder of the colonists. And the fact that the Fidenates clearly have no honour. They're just murderers and traitors, and the people of Veii just faithless breakers of truces. Disgusting, they are Spurius Furius on the scale of anger. That is how angry they are. Now, the people of Veii, the Fidenates they are like completely blindsided in some ways because the Romans are just so angry and they've hit them so hard that at first, they are taken aback. Yeah, I was gonna say

    Dr G 44:43
    this is gonna be shocking feeling the full force of this anger and particularly this pairing of our dictator and our master of the horse being such buddy buddies as well.

    Dr Rad 44:55
    Yeah, exactly. Anyway, but then the Romans had a moment where they're a bit shaken, because the gates of Fidenae open and what's described very vaguely as a new type of army comes pouring out of the gate. Oh,

    Dr G 45:09
    I have I have some detail on this.

    Dr Rad 45:12
    Okay, go ahead. There's a bit of a spoiler with this one isn't there?

    Dr G 45:15
    There might be there might be. I have a little snippet from Frontinus who talks about, and interestingly, like the dates are a little bit mixed up, so he talks about this moment where the Faliscans and the Tarquinians disguise themselves as priests

    Dr Rad 45:35
    Oh

    Dr G 45:35
    and held torches and snakes in front of them like the Furies and that this tactic and this is, this is a spoiler for 356 BCE. This panics, the Romans, and he says that this there is an occasion where the men of Veii and Fidenae do the same thing. They dress themselves up as priests, grab some torches, grab some snakes, goodness knows, and wander out towards the army of the Romans. And put the fear of the gods into them!

    Dr Rad 46:17
    Yeah, I definitely get the sense that there is something going on here. I must admit, this is one of those things where I probably should have again, checked the Latin but we all know how good my Latin is. So it probably wouldn't have helped. But yeah, there's definitely something unexpected. It's not just the fact that the enemies coming out with blazing torches, it as you say they're dressed up some way, or I've even read somewhere in one of the academics, I was looking at that maybe it was like they thought they were facing women. But anyway, there's something

    Dr G 46:43
    Wow, that would be enough to make the men turn tail and run wouldn't it. They're like, Oh, yeah. Oh, the women have come out.

    Dr Rad 46:52
    But anyway, they're definitely whoever they are. And however they're dressed that they are bearing blazing torches as weapons and the Romans are momentarily stunned. It's at this moment that Mamercus is like, right, let's get Cossus and Quinctius into action, as well as turning to the troops that are around him, you know, in the battlefield, and like trying to, you know, get them to like, get back into the spirit. Like, come on, step out of it. This isn't a big deal. Like

    Dr G 47:20
    They're men dressed up as women. They're not the Furies at all, those aren't real snakes.

    Dr Rad 47:25
    Yeah. So he hurries over to the left flank, which is the most intimidated away, or the fire gives them a massive pep talk. Like, remember, you are Romans, remember your glorious ancestors. Remember your courage. And this is all the weapon that you need. Now unleash it against them, set Fidenae alight, don't let them let take you on fire. Or something to that effect. The Romans are encouraged by this because he's apparently just the kind of guy that can just say something and they do it. So they start seizing torches by force, or they pick up ones that have been dropped or, you know, when someone being killed or time being careless or something like that. And then of course, we've got Cossus, right. Now, apparently, and this is a direct quote, he invented a new kind of cavalry fighting, and that he told his troops to take the bridles off their horses, and just charge into the fire. And apparently it was, so there was just so many of them that apparently, you know the chaos of battle, all that kind of stuff, they can barely see you with everything that's going on.

    Dr G 48:33
    That seems like a really bad idea, removing the bridles from the horses as they're about to charge the cavalry unit into fire.

    Dr Rad 48:44
    Nonsense, Dr G. It's glorious, and it's magnificent success!

    Dr G 48:49
    Look, let's just think about this realistically. Most animals have a healthy respect and fear of fire. A bridleless horse is a horse that you cannot change the direction of because it's going to run whichever way that it wants, unless you've trained it to be controlled by the stirrups alone, which is a whole other thing entirely. And it doesn't sound like they've got that. It just seems like madness, Cossus what are you doing?

    Dr Rad 49:14
    Actually, as a side note, and I could be wrong here because this is something that's just come to me out of nowhere. I'm almost 100% sure that the Romans did not ride with stirrups, not at this point in time and

    Dr G 49:27
    yeah, so so it's bridles or nothing

    Dr Rad 49:31
    It's your thighs, god dammit, Suzanne Somers would be proud.

    Dr G 49:35
    Well, well well

    Dr Rad 49:36
    Yeah. Anyway, the horses are apparently not frightened. The Romans are not frightened. The cavalry ends up just eating up huge amounts of the enemy just knocking them out of the battle. Then Quinctius makes his attack – the enemy is trapped. They have nowhere to flee. There's nowhere to go. They're pinned in all around. So the people of Veii and the Fidenates, they're just running around in chaotic circles. The people of Veii, they're trying to get to the Tiber and the Fidenates are trying to get to their city. But a lot of them are just running in the wrong directions, or they can't go where they want to go. And they just ran into the very worst parts of the battle. So they're either killed because they're in the battlefield, or they drown trying to escape. The Romans, of course show no mercy, they are going to recapture that city if it kills them. So they enter the city, they make their way to the wall, and they send the signals say that Fidenae was captured. Again.

    Ooo boy

    Mamercus was in the camp of the enemy, with all his man, when this signal sort of goes up. The soldiers are really keen to be like, Yeah, cool. Let's get pillaging this is what we came for. Mamercus says, look, let's just stay calm, be methodical, takes them to the city. Once they're inside, Mamerucs can see that the enemy are trying to reach the Citadel there. And they make sure that they basically finish them off. So there's just slaughter everywhere until finally the enemy surrenders. And then they can loot and pillage and sack the city and the camp.

    Dr G 51:22
    Oh, wow. All right, this is slightly different in some of the details then. And I'll admit, I've got some pretty disparate source material at my disposal. And so it's probably not a surprise that they're quite different. So I've got Florus. Yeah, who is probably most famous for doing an epitome of Livy.

    Dr Rad 51:47
    I was gonna say, surely that means that you should agree with everything I say.

    Dr G 51:52
    And you'd be surprised, and but it may be the case that the detail that Florus is providing here actually belongs to maybe a later time period, though there does seem to be a bit of overlap in the detail.

    Dr Rad 52:03
    Right

    Dr G 52:04
    So he talks about the people of Fidenae are not a match for the Romans. And what they had done is they armed themselves with torches, and they'd put on a variety of fillets, so like head gear, resembling serpents, so we've got that serpent reference again. Yeah, and they had marched forth like Furies. And so, so far, there's a little bit of match up there. But he also says that their funereal attire was an omen of their overthrow.

    Dr Rad 52:36
    Oh

    Dr G 52:37
    And also seems to indicate that at some point, and maybe this is anachronistic, and maybe it's a bit of a spoiler for things to come, that Fidenae is consumed by its own flames.

    Dr Rad 52:51
    Ah, well, I guess that's, that's, I think that all kind of matches up really, we've got these confusing costumes, which kind of are evoking female. You know, in the way they're presenting themselves. We've got torches, we've got fire. I can see some similarities there.

    Dr G 53:11
    It's tricky. It's tricky.

    Dr Rad 53:13
    Back in my account, the cavalry man and the centurions all draw lots for a single captive each. So this is one of the sad parts obviously, of ancient warfare that the survivors of the sorts of wars usually ended up being captured and sold into slavery, if they're not killed. Anyone who had received notices fighting with exceptional bravery received two, and then whatever was leftover was sold off at auction. So sad. It's very sad. This is a this sounds like a lot of people. I mean, obviously, it's not an on quite a scale that Livy would probably like us to imagine, but it still sounds like a decent amount of people that are being taken into slavery here.

    Dr G 53:59
    Yeah, this. I mean, it's pretty typical, I suppose. And depending on how much Rome might be interested in punishing somewhere that it has taken might depend on how many people they decide to then co opt into slavery.

    Dr Rad 54:14
    This is true.

    Dr G 54:15
    So if they're really looking to, to have an impact on Fidenae's ability to do anything, they might take most people as slaves.

    Dr Rad 54:24
    This is very true. So, unlike the previous time in 437, when Mamercus and Cossus came together in a battle against these two places, after the murder of the ambassadors, etc. Mamercus is the one that returns to the city in glory. Now, obviously, he wasn't completely ignored last time because he was also in a position of power then, but this time, there is no Lars Tolumnius for Cossus to have slain in single combat. And so while Cossus has done very well. Mamercus gets to triumph. And he and Cossus give up their power as dictator and master the horse. And apparently this has all happened in 16 days.

    Dr G 55:10
    Wow. Yeah, that was Fast. Yeah. Look, nothing like the efficiency of a dictator in ancient Rome.

    Dr Rad 55:17
    I know they're in and they're out. So lovely little detail right at the end here, Livy always throws these little bits in, he says that certain analysts – not of course, tell me who these certain analysts are – also mentioned, a naval battle in this war. And we did sort of talk about this when we were talking about the events of 437. And the confusion, mainly between these years. In that, there, it seems like the confusion might have come from the use of the term “classis”, that that that might have somehow given connotations that there was something to do with ships involved here. Whereas other people have said, no, this has more to do with who's serving.

    Dr G 56:04
    I was gonna say, I mean, we're pretty inland, are we talking about river boats?

    Dr Rad 56:08
    Perhaps perhaps. So Livy says, as if there was a naval battle, even in my own time, the river was not wide enough to accommodate ships or a naval battle like this. Or maybe there was like a ship. And it's been exaggerated over time. And I'm going to finish with a direct quote from my translation, as so often happens, by those who added to the inscription the false claim of a naval victory. So..

    Dr G 56:41
    Okay, so the, he's just introducing a whole level of doubt about any record to do with naval battles, and what appears to be like a fairly standard belief that the inscriptions are docked over time.

    Dr Rad 56:56
    Well, apparently, and this is in the notation of the translation I was using from the Loeb Classical Library. Apparently, they think that what he probably is referring to is an inscription that accompanied Mamercus' portrait. So obviously, Mamercus is a pretty awesome guy, everybody loves him, of course, naturally, he would be represented somewhere in the city, and there would be an inscription there. So it seems that Livy is suggesting that there is something about a naval battle mentioned in this inscription, but that he thinks it's been faked. And I guess that would be maybe by his family, like, maybe he's descendants.

    Dr G 57:36
    I just feel like he's not using his imagination enough. I mean, there is a river there. And just because you can't fit an ocean going ship in the river, does not mean, you don't have any naval warfare going on. And it's like, I mean, I feel like I can see it now. It's late at night. Somebody's on the river. You know, somebody's got to shoot arrows into the fleeing people from Veii, you know,

    Dr Rad 58:04
    Look Livy does concede that maybe there were some ships, but he's like a naval battle. Are we really going to call that a naval battle?

    Dr G 58:12
    Well, I don't know. I mean, they will have to come up with other words in the Latin for it, I suppose. But barring the fact that they haven't come up with a river battle situation themselves, maybe naval battle is as good as they've got. It's on the sea, it's water.

    Dr Rad 58:27
    Yeah. Anyway, so this is how the conflict of this particular year with Veii, Fidenae and Rome comes to an end. But you can see why there are certainly a lot of similarities with what we described in 437. Not everybody, as you said, believes that Mamercus Aemilius Mamercinus, was actually dictator, back in 437, when we first talked about it, and for some academics, they believe it would make more sense for Cossus to have killed Lars Tolumnius in this year only because, as a king, he's obviously a hugely significant political figure. So it would kind of be a fitting end to the conflict that has stricken the region, if they kind of give up because they've lost their leader. And this is kind of why there's maybe be confusion. It is obviously though a lot of speculation. And clearly our source material is so confused. I don't know that any academic is ever going to prove beyond a doubt that their account is the right account.

    Dr G 59:33
    Oh, yeah, I think it would be very difficult to come to a really firm consensus on this. One of the problems that scholars face and part of the reason why people argue that maybe the stuff with Tolumnius happened in this year rather than the previous account is because Cossus is in this position as master of the horse. And prior to that, before taking on that role, he was is a military tribune with consular power. So the idea of the spolia opima, which is where you take the spoils from a military commander, as a military commander directly, so like one on one combat, you, as a commander have killed and slain the opposing commander, very rare, very difficult to do. Cossus is in a more senior command position in this moment in time than he was in that previous decade where he was pretty low down, he was like some sort of legate. And so it doesn't seem reasonable that that would have counted as the moment. But this means that, like Livy gives us this whole different battle setup. Our later sources, some of which are epitomising Livy, are giving us very different details about what's happening in this particular battle, versus what was happening in that previous battle. And there's no way to reconcile those sorts of things. We know that our historians are sometimes making up a little bit of the detail in order to flesh things out and to give it that spice. But where those stories are coming from, whether they're like from family traditions, or elsewhere, we're not really sure. And even Livy, you know, throwing out the sort of like dissing the inscription. Amazing.

    Dr Rad 1:01:23
    Don't believe it just because it's carved in stone.

    Dr G 1:01:27
    I've seen that inscription. Rubbish. I tell you, rubbish.

    Dr Rad 1:01:30
    Anyway, and so I think this is finally, finally going to bring a little bit of a resolution to the question of Fidenae, I'm sure there's going to be more conflict in this direction. But I think that the really big conflict is going to be resolved for a little bit of time. So

    Dr G 1:01:54
    This does seem to be a pretty bad defeat for them. So I guess time will tell I look forward to finding out what happens next.

    Dr Rad 1:02:02
    Absolutely. You know, that means, Dr G. I think it's time for the partial pick.

    Dr G 1:02:18
    The partial pick, Rome has five categories, where they can score up to 10 golden eagles each. So if they max it out, and they've done the best that they possibly can. They will get 50 gold eagles. It's time to find out. Our first category is military cloud.

    Dr Rad 1:02:41
    Well, I think we can definitely say they've got nothing but clout at the moment.

    Dr G 1:02:45
    It feels like a big 10, really, it's a resounding-

    Dr Rad 1:02:48
    Well hang on

    Dr G 1:02:51
    In the end, it is a resounding defeat of the enemy. It is confusing how they get there.

    Dr Rad 1:02:58
    In the beginning, it's definitely not. I don't think we can quite give them a 10 out of 10. I feel like it's got to be an eight.

    Dr G 1:03:05
    Yeah. So like the chaos leading into the dictatorship. All right. All right.

    Dr Rad 1:03:11
    They did get defeated three commanders in one battle.

    Dr G 1:03:15
    We all know those commanders were rubbish. They were never going to come to anything.

    Dr Rad 1:03:18
    Were they though? Were they?

    Dr G 1:03:22
    Hard to know, but certainly I take your point. Fine. I won't give them 10.

    Dr Rad 1:03:27
    Okay, eight it is

    Dr G 1:03:29
    Diplomacy?

    Dr Rad 1:03:31
    No. Nobody has any sense of diplomacy in this episode.

    Dr G 1:03:38
    Expansion?

    Dr Rad 1:03:42
    I can't even remember what we said last time that they recaptured Fidenae, which is meant to be theirs in the first place.

    Dr G 1:03:46
    Yeah. I don't think that counts as expansion.

    Dr Rad 1:03:48
    No, I don't think so. Particularly not the second time they recapture it.

    Dr G 1:03:53
    Yeah, it's beginning to look careless, ancient Rome.

    Dr Rad 1:03:57
    I shouldn't even say the second time. It's way more than two.

    Dr G 1:04:00
    Yeah, who knows where we're up to with that. So expansion is a no. All right. Virtus?

    Dr Rad 1:04:08
    Okay.

    Dr G 1:04:09
    Hmm.

    Dr Rad 1:04:11
    I feel like Mamercus has got some things going on here.

    Dr G 1:04:14
    He did do some resounding sort of speechifying.

    Dr Rad 1:04:17
    I think Livy is it real pains to redeem this guy, which is weird, because he then disses his inscription at the end. I mean, he doesn't name Mamercus personally, I'm speculating based on what I've read in the translation. But yeah, he definitely seems very keen on him. I think this guy is a big deal.

    Dr G 1:04:36
    Mm hmm.

    Dr Rad 1:04:37
    Yeah. And I think I think he could say that all the speechifying he's done, the careful planning, he gets a triumph. I mean, it's not maybe the most impressive most original thing we've ever seen. But yeah,

    Dr G 1:04:50
    Yeah. I'm just trying to think about it in terms of like, like, literal virtus, where it's kind of like, I mean, these are all the things that are kind of expected of a Roman military commander, and he does do them and they go well, so I suppose that does count. And then you've got Cossus, who sort of goes a bit wild, it would seem, with his like, just take those bridles off the horses, and let's like the launch in there, and it works. And in a way, I wonder if that is a greater demonstration of virtus in the Roman perception of like really taking that sort of risk, and it really working out in the heat of battle. So like, afterwards, Mamercus is getting sort of lauded with the triumph and that sort of thing. But it might be the case that people like that Cossus guy though. Wild.

    Dr Rad 1:05:43
    Yeah, yeah, I mean, this is true. And this is exactly what happened the previous time, which is why we see those weird parallels right, where Mamercus is technically in charge to the previous time as well. And yet, it's Cossus to gets most of the attention because he does something that no one is expecting.

    Dr G 1:06:02
    Yeah, so

    Dr Rad 1:06:03
    Or he fights with particular vigour.

    Dr G 1:06:06
    And so maybe this is the power of this duo is that like they work best together and Cossus always just slightly by accident upstages Mamercus.

    Dr Rad 1:06:18
    But he doesn't seem to mind I think Mamercus seems incredibly confident. He's like, you kicked me out of my tribe. Look at me rescuing you, or when you're in danger again, because I'm so amazing. And my plans always work out and I have the best team and everything I do is amazing. He doesn't seem at all shaken.

    Dr G 1:06:38
    That's true. There's a firmness of the resolve. Yeah, look, maybe. I feel like maybe a six.

    Dr Rad 1:06:46
    Really?

    Dr G 1:06:47
    Yeah look, I mean, between the two of them. I don't think I don't think this is like the most

    Dr Rad 1:06:53
    impressive

    Dr G 1:06:54
    impressive kind of Roman virtus. It's not like yeah, it's it's the expected kind of masculine embodiment stuff. Yeah.

    Dr Rad 1:07:06
    All right. Okay, so we that takes us okay, so I get a six. All right. Next category,

    Dr G 1:07:10
    The citizen score.

    Dr Rad 1:07:12
    Oh, we really haven't heard much about the citizens apart from the fact that they are annoyed with the military tribunals when they stuff up.

    Dr G 1:07:20
    But they're also like, you know, like ever present, like there's no way that Rome could have won this without bodies on the ground in the infantry in the cavalry and stuff like that. So yeah, they're definitely there. And they do get to partake in those spoils as well.

    Dr Rad 1:07:37
    This is true, and it sounds like Cossus and, Quinctius, and Mamercus, are pretty popular. So there's that too. So I'm gonna hedge and say a four, just because they weren't very happy with the tribunes and their performance. And you know what, I can't help but think that this is also a little convenient. That, you know, they've been pushing for military tribunes with consular power, and then they just get, you know, replaced with a dictator, because there doesn't work out. But anyway, not that they were plebeians, but

    Dr G 1:08:13
    the more that you talk about it, the more it makes me think that maybe this is a lower than a four then because it's like not only do they have to go to war, which is always a problem because people die. But they haven't been very happy about the whole process anyway. And there was that moment where, what the Senate was kind of like, well, maybe we'll decide whether it's a war or not.

    Dr Rad 1:08:32
    Yeah, this is true.

    Dr G 1:08:34
    And the the citizens are like, excuse me?

    Dr Rad 1:08:36
    Yeah, maybe like a three. Although they do win that battle.

    Dr G 1:08:39
    That's true. Yeah.

    Dr Rad 1:08:43
    It's a three or four for me.

    Dr G 1:08:45
    Let's go with the three. I want Rome to really knock it out of the ballpark for the people and they're not doing it this year.

    Dr Rad 1:08:50
    Fair enough. All right. Dr. G. That means we've ended up with a grand total of 17 out of 50 golden eagles.

    Dr G 1:08:58
    that's actually more impressive than expected.

    Dr Rad 1:09:01
    Well, I knew this was going to be a good year because I knew Cossus and Mamercus were going to you know, be teaming up. So well done. Batman and Robin, well done. You have once again protected Gotham City and the citizens are safe to walk the street. Not at night, because that would be insane. But during the day

    Dr G 1:09:20
    At other times. Yeah, these two are classic. One hopes to see the duo again, although I have my doubts.

    Dr Rad 1:09:32
    All right. Well, thanks for taking a little trip into this bromance with me.

    Dr G 1:09:36
    Oh an absolute pleasure.

    Dr Rad 1:09:42
    Thank you for listening to this episode of the partial historians. You can find our sources, sound credits and an automated transcript in our show notes. You too can support our show and help us to produce more engaging content about the ancient world by becoming a Patreon. In return you receive exclusive early access to our special episodes and the occasional bonus episode. However, there are other ways you can support our show. We have merch a collaboration with Bridget Clark on Gumroad. And we now also have a book. If you'd like to purchase a copy of Rex, the seven kings of Rome you can find the details on our website or you can head straight to Highlands Press and order a copy now. Today we'd like to send a special shout out to our patrons who pre-ordered this very book. And that's Dana Erin and Divus Augustus, salve! However, if all of these avenues are beyond your means, please just tell someone about our show or give us a five star review. These are not little gestures to us, they mean the world. So until next time, we are yours in ancient Rome.

    Dr G 1:11:22
    Have you ever wondered how to cover up an axe in the head, Dr Rad?

    Dr Rad 1:11:28
    You know, I actually have.

    Dr G 1:11:32
    I told you that the Romans did it first.

    Dr Rad 1:11:36
    Oh, what? How?

    Dr G 1:11:39
    I know. Well, there's this little thing that I think we could call regal assassination. Regicide, if you will. We wrote about it in a book together.

    Dr Rad 1:11:52
    We did?

    Dr G 1:11:53
    We certainly did. It is called Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome. And boy is it a romp through history. Packed with source detail, packed with salacious stories

    Dr Rad 1:12:07
    and packed with our trademark brand of humour.

    Dr G 1:12:12
    Yes, well where would we be in a book if it is not for our humour? If you would like to support our endeavours into podcastally research then we would love to treat you to Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome. Please

    Dr Rad 1:12:33
    head over to Highlands Press. If you would like to order a copy now.

    Dr G 1:12:38
    It should be delivered to you at some time in the future.

    Transcribed by https://otter.ai

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    1 hr 13 min
  • The Partial Recap - 430s BCE

    We recap the confusing details of the 430s BCE. Be careful – there's a lot of dictators about!

    This is a short, sharp, scripted overview of all the big events that defined the 430s BCE. If you’re inspired to delve into more details, all the episodes from this decade can be found in our Foundation of Rome series starting with Episode 127: The Assassination of Spurius Maelius.

    The Partial Recap – 430s BCE

    A view to the East over the Roman Forum with the Temple of Saturn on the left and the Palatine Hill on the right, showing the Temple of Castor and Pollux, the Arch of Titus, Santa Francesca Romana, and the Colosseum. Detail from the photograph by Nicholas Hartmann, June 1976. Image Source: Wikimedia Commons. Used under license.

    Sound Credits

    Our music was composed by the incomparable Bettina Joy de Guzman.

    Automated Transcript

    Dr Rad 0:16
    Welcome to The Partial Historians,

    Dr G 0:20
    we explore all the details of ancient Rome.

    Dr Rad 0:23
    Everything from the political scandals, the love affairs, the battles waged and when citizens turn against each other. I'm Dr. Rad

    Dr G 0:34
    and I'm Dr. G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.

    Dr Rad 0:43
    Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.

    Welcome to the Partial Recap for the 430s BCE.

    Dr G 1:12
    I'm Dr. G.

    Dr Rad 1:14
    And I'm Dr. Rad

    Dr G 1:15
    And this is our highlights addition of the 430s in Rome will take you through from 439 to 430. In an epitome of our normal episodes

    Dr Rad 1:27
    Perfect for those mornings when you don't want some lengthy rhetoric with your coffee. But Please be warned. The Roman world is a violent one

    Dr G 1:34
    Get ready for a re-cappuccino.

    Dr Rad 2:02
    439 BCE. In 439 BCE, the consuls were Agrippa Menenius Lanatus and Titus Quinctius Capitolinus Barbatus, Rome was still having issues with their green supply and 439 BCE. Perhaps it would be more accurate to say that they were having issues with the man who had tried to solve the green crisis and to be honest, the dates are blurry here. This is more 439 and 438. An equestrian named Spurius Maelius had used his private fortune to secure desperately needed corn, something that the officially appointed prefect of corn supply Lucius Minucius had failed to do. Spurius Maelius had allegedly been using his success with the grain to curry favour and after carefully building support amongst the plebs instal himself as monarch. Funnily enough Minucius was the one to uncover this dastardly plot. Jealous much? This may somehow connect to another version of events we have in which the people overthrew Minucius and put Maelius in his place. In this time of crisis, the Romans turned to Cincinnatus, that old war horse or did they? Officially Cincinnatus was made dictator and chose Gaius Servilius Ahala, whose name means Gaius Servilius ‘Armpit', as the master of the horse, depending who you believe Ahala was either just a random elite man who was given a senatorial approval to kill Maelius, or he was sent by Cincinnatus to arrest the scheming Spurius. When Spurius decided not to go quietly, and when he screamed for help from the nearby plebs, Ahala decided to murder him on the spot. Naturally. Ahala and a band of young patricians reported the crime to Cincinnatus, who was thoroughly pleased that Maelius was dead. The populace were less thrilled and Cincinnatus summoned an assembly to explain exactly how Maelius' murder went down. With Rome safe again, Maelius' house was torn down. Too much evil plotting had gone down in there to leave it standing. It became a memorial named the Aquaemaelium to commemorate whatever he was supposedly doing. The rest of his property was donated to the public treasury. Again, according which account you believe some other traitors flesh rabbits may have found their heads detached for their bodies and displayed in the Forum. In the aftermath of the Spurius Maelius debacle, Lucius Minucius was given an ox and a gilded statue outside the Porta Trigamenia, he may also have been made a plebeian and an 11th tribune of the plebs just to keep an eye on them after this attempted coup business, but even Livy is unsure about this one. The tribunes certainly weren't pleased that Minucius was being honoured, so they pushed to have military tribunes with consular power and 438 BCE. Come on pleb power! Ahala did not fare as well as Minucius going into “self imposed exile”. Wink. Looking to delve deeper into the details of 439 BCE, check out our Episode 127 The Assassination of Spurius Maelius.

    Dr G 5:49
    438 BCE in 438 BCE, the military tribunes with consular power were Mamercus Aemilius, Lucius Quinctius Cincinnatus and Lucius Julius Iullus. If the idea to have military tributes with consular power is to allow non elite Romans into the politics then we can call this year a fail. These guys are all patricians. It's a tough time in Rome because the Roman colony of Fidenae decided to revolt and side with the Etruscan city of Veii, led by King Lars Tolumnius: disaster! To make matters worse, the Fidenates ended up murdering the ambassadors that the Romans sent to sort out this mess. Lars Tolumnius may have had something to do with this, but it is all very murky. The four slain ambassadors received statues which were erected at the public expense in Rome, lest we forget. Me thinks the Romans have vengeance on their mind. Jump into Episode 128 Mopping up Maelius, to catch all the details.

    Dr Rad 7:31
    437 BC in 437 BCE, the consuls were Marcus Geganius Macerinus and Lucius Sergius Fidenas. Rome was in crisis mode, so no one was causing issues at home, but a dictator was clearly needed. And Mamercus Aemilius was chosen for the job. Lucius Quictius Cincinnatus, son of the famous Cincinnatus, was selected as master of the horse. During the emotionally charged battle that followed, a really ridiculously good looking tribune from the Roman cavalry named Aulua Cornelius Cossus distinguished himself. Determined to make his family name proud, Cossus decided to take down the king of Veii. Tolumnius was wreaking havoc for the Romans, but not once Cossus was finished with him. Cossus did not just kill Tolumnius, he decapitated him. The Etruscans lost their nerve after the death of their King and were defeated. Cossus became known as the first man since King Romulus to defeat an enemy leader in single combat, and he dedicated his spoils to Jupiter Feretrius. The senate and the people agreed: all of this glory added up to a triumph for our dictator.

    Dr G 9:15
    436 BCE, in 436 BCE, the consuls were Lucius Papirius Crassus and Marcus Cornelius Maluginensis – what a mouthfull! The year began with some raids into enemy territory. We're in familiar crowds now with the Romans and the Romans took some booty, both human and animal from Veii and the Faliscans, those bastards. The enemy was presumably busy licking their wounds, and so there was no actual battle to be had. At least no battles before Romans were struck down by a pestilence. Not to be stopped by disease, Spurius Maelius – a relative of our grain loving murder victim – decided to use his power as tribune of the plebs to prosecute Lucius Minucius and to confiscate the property of Servilius Ahala. Crazily, the people seem to have been quite indifferent to his efforts. Perhaps it was the worsening pestilence…

    Dr Rad 10:21
    435 BCE. In 435 BCE the consuls were Gaius Iulius and Lucius Verginius. After all that pesky illness, the patricians and plebeians were ready for a peaceful year, but the people of Fidenae had other ideas. Fidenae and Veii teamed up to create terror for the Romans with their pillaging, reaching the very gates of Rome. You know what this means? It's time for a dictator. Quintus Servilius Priscus was made dictator with Postumius Aebutius Helva as master of the horse. Any male who could fight was called up and a battle ensued near Nomentum. The enemy retreated into the city of Fidenae, which was a hard nut to crack. But Servilius was no ordinary military strategist. Using clever diversionary tactics, he managed to seize control of the city. Back in Rome, the censors approved a new public building fittingly called the Villa Publica. This would be used to take the census. Just as exciting as siege warfare, clearly censors know how to party.

    Dr G 11:35
    Build a house for the very same.

    434 BCE. Now things get pretty confusing around 434. The first problem, there seems to have been two sets of consuls. The consuls are variously listed as Gaius Julius Iullus, and Lucius Verginius Tricostus or Marcus Manlius Capitolinus and Quintus Sulpicius Camerinus Praetextatus. So imagine that so you know, so much Latin, no overlap of names. And to make matters even worse, there were also three military tributes with consular power listed for this year as well. Servius Cornelius Cossus, Marcus Manlius Capitolinus and Quintus Sulpicius Camerinus Praetextatus. And yes, you're definitely starting to hear some overlapping names. This year was simply lousy with magistrates. The sources themselves seem quite confused over who was running the place. But whoever was in charge, they soon found themselves replaced by dictator Mamercus Aemilius and his master of the horse. Oulus – Aulus, I should say Postumius Tubertus. Mamercus was called in because it seemed like war might break out with Veii and some of their allies, but it all fizzled quite quickly. Mamercus therefore decided that he was going to change some things at home, he focused his attention on the censorship. These guys were too powerful. A law was proposed that would limit the censorship to a year and a half, that people were giddy with delight. But the censors now saw Mamercus as public enemy number one. They kicked him out of his tribe, and drastically increased his tax bill. Ouch.

    Dr Rad 13:56
    Hell know no fury like a censor scorned.

    Dr G 14:01
    What is this tax? It's just for you, my friend. Lucky for the censors, Mamercus was content to take this one on the chin, or they may have found some of his devoted fans waiting for them in the forum with baseball bats and switch blades.

    Dr Rad 14:44
    433 BCE. In 433 BCE, the military tributes with consular power where Marcus Fabius Vibulanus, Marcus Folius Flaccinator, and Lucius Sergius Fidenas. The tribunes of the plebeians decided that this was a good year to start some trouble. They tried to block the consular elections and the rumours were apparently close to having to move to an interregnum. A compromise was reached and military tribunes with consular power were elected instead. But none of the men chosen were plebeians. The best laid plans. More political shenanigans may have ensued, but a serious epidemic struck the city so serious that a temple was given to Apollo on behalf of the people's health. But many people died and the Romans were worried that widespread death would lead to famine, which would lead to more death. So they started searching high and low for grain which they could stockpile.

    Dr G 16:09
    432 BCE, and we're back with some military tribunes with consular power, Lucius Pinarius Mamercinus, Lucius Furius Medullinus and Spurius Postumius Albus Regillensis. The disease that had affected the population in the previous year started to ease up and the Romans did not have to add famine to their list of worries as they were so damn organised. All of that stockpiled grain coming in handy. There were murmurings of war between Etruscans, the Volscians and Aequians and Rome, but it was decided to postpone any conflict for a year. The tribune of the plebs started strategizing about how they could get a plebeian elected as military tribune with consular power. It was crazy that only patricians had been elected so far. Somehow this led to a law being proposed by the tribunes that political candidates were not allowed to whiten their toga. In other words, no advertising the fact that you were running for office with your very shiny very white toga candida. To avoid dirty plebeians winning any more power, the patricians made sure that consuls were on the cards for the following year.

    Dr Rad 17:56
    431 BCE. In 431 BCE the consuls were Titus Quinctius Poenas Cincinnatus, and Gaius or Gnaeus Iulius Mento, and they apparently hated each other. The consuls really needed a strong army this year, so a levy was held under a lex sacrata, which meant that anyone who offended against this law was sacer to the gods. The Aequians and the Volscians set up their camps at Mount Algidus and seem to have strong armies in the field. The Romans were spooked or defeated in battle and didn't want to talk about it, and the Senate decided to appoint a dictator. After all, so many young Romans had perished in the plague and the consuls were not a great team. However, the consuls did agree that a dictator was a terrible idea. In desperation Quintus Servilius Priscus, an elite Roman, appealed to the tribune of the plebs, and ask them to force the consuls to name a dictator. The consuls were livid. But finally it was decided by lot that Titus Quinctius should choose the dictator. Quinctius selected his father-in-law Aulus Postumius Tubertus, aka the “face of stone”. Lucius Julius was named master of the horse. A levy was declared and the Romans were ordered to focus all of their attention on the war effort. Postumius was just what the campaign needed. With his team and fellow elites, they managed to defeat both the Aequians and the Volscians. The only downer was the possible execution of Aulus Postumius' son on his father's orders. The “face of stone” strikes again! But nobody wants to believe this story. As a parting blow to his colleague, Gnaeus Julius dedicated the Temple of Apollo without consulting his colleague Quinctius. How rude.

    Dr G 20:16
    430 BCE. In this year the consuls were Lucius Papirius Crassus and Lucius Julius Iullus. A new law was introduced this year called The Papira Julia, which changed the valuation of fines by changing how they decided to count cattle. Those Romans will the excitement never end when it comes to their lawmaking! After their disastrous defeat in the previous year, the Aequians – surprise, surprise – managed to secure an eight year truce with Rome. Ahh, the bliss of peace. The Volscians on the other hand, were distracted by their own internal dispute, which made for an unusually peaceful end to the decade.

    Dr Rad 21:25
    And that was the 430s in ancient Rome. Or, was it?

    Dr G 21:29
    Wow, that is the big question. Remember, this has just been a highlights reel of the ancient sources and the decade that was so if you want to delve into the complexities of the different evidence from this period, check out our narrative episodes, you'd want to be jumping in at Episode 127 The Assassination of Spurius Maelius to join us for a deep dive into the decade that was the 430s BCE.

    Dr Rad 22:00
    Thank you for listening to this episode of The Partial Historians, we'd like to send an extra special thank you to all of our supporters, especially our Patreon and our Kofi donators. Thank you so much for helping keep the show going. Until next time, we are yours in ancient Rome.

    Transcribed by https://otter.ai

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    23 min
  • Special Episode - Our Top Ten at Ten

    On the 1st March 2013, something momentous happened. We published our first episode of the Partial Historians podcast! Clearly, this is an event akin to Hannibal crossing the Alps or the expulsion of the kings.

    Well, perhaps not quite. But it certainly changed our lives forever in ways that we could not imagine. Therefore, we decided to mark the occasion by getting together and discussing our Top Ten Moments from the Roman Republic thus far.

    We hope you enjoy our chat about the Republic as much as we have enjoyed making this show for the past ten years.

    Special Episode – Our Top Ten at Ten

    Things to Look Out For:
    1. The Conspiracy to Restore the Tarquins (Episode 45 – The Last Gasp of the Regal Period)
    2. The Downfall of Spurius Cassius (Episode 71-73)
    3. The Career of Lars Porsenna (Episode 46-47)
    4. The First Secession of the Plebs (Episodes 58-59)
    5. The Rise of Volero (Episode 85-86)
    6. The Sneak Attack of Appius Herdonius (Episodes 96-97)
    7. The Death of Verginia (Episodes 114-115)
    8. The Life and Times of Dentatus (Episodes 105-106, 113)
    9. The Rise and Fall of Spurius Maelius (Episode 127 – The Assassination of Spurius Maelius)
    10. Aulus Cornelius Cossus vs Lars Tolumnius (Episodes 129-130)
    Sound Effects

    Thanks to the talented Bettina Joy de Guzman for our music.

    Just a few photos of us together over the years. Are we partial to a dress up for the sake of Roman history? You betcha!

    Automated Transcript

    Dr Rad 0:00
    That's right isn't just any bonus episode. Dr. G. It's our anniversary episode. I know I can't believe it. But we have been recording this podcast for 10 years as of today, the first of March.

    Welcome to a special bonus episode of the Partial Historians. And this might just be the most special bonus episode that you will hear of this show for a long time. Not that you should stop listening or anything. But just because this is our 10 year anniversary show. That's right. 10 years ago to this day, we released our very first episode. And so to mark that occasion, Dr. G, and I did what we did 10 years ago, which is we sat down, and we had a chat in our living room about Roman history. We hope that you enjoy the show.

    Dr G 0:54
    Hello and welcome to a fabulous bonus edition of the Partial Historians. I am Dr. G.

    Dr Rad 1:04
    And I am a 10 year old Dr. Rad

    Dr G 1:08
    10 years old.

    Dr Rad 1:09
    That's right isn't just any bonus episode. Dr. G.

    Dr G 1:13
    It's our anniversary episode. I

    Dr Rad 1:15
    know I can't believe it. But we have

    Dr G 1:18
    10 years old??

    Dr Rad 1:23
    the first of March.

    Dr G 1:26
    Look, there are marriages that do not last as long as this podcast.

    Dr Rad 1:31
    I know. And I felt we could not let this occasion pass without marking upon it. Because being independent podcasters as we are and have been for 10 years. I think that really the fact that we're still here now actually has a lot to do with the fact that we are just determined in clueless.

    Dr G 1:54
    We shall persist regardless the circumstance. Well, I mean, that may be so but I think it is also the case genuinely that over time, we have found our audience, our beautiful listeners, they're out there,

    Dr Rad 2:08
    I know. And we're so incredibly grateful because we look back to 10 years ago, and it really doesn't feel like 10 years ago because we even though we don't release episodes as often as other podcasts because we are dependent, and we have to balance full time jobs and all that kind of stuff. At the same time. We actually haven't taken a break. There hasn't been a month where we haven't released a podcast in 10 years, we have never stopped making the show.

    Dr G 2:35
    That is pretty consistent. I'm gonna give us a large pat on the back for that. Congratulations. For a while we were doing them every two weeks. I think that was a that was a period of early insanity, where we thought we had more time. And podcasting was not so strenuous.

    Dr Rad 2:52
    Yeah, because I mean that this is the thing. I was thinking back to our early days. And initially you and I had mooted the idea of starting a YouTube channel. But back in 2012, when we were initially having these discussions, that was a little out of our budget.

    Dr G 3:08
    It was it was and to be honest, who knows what would happen if we attempted to start a YouTube in 2012? It's like the dark ages of YouTube.

    Dr Rad 3:18
    Exactly. But instead, we decided that we would start a podcast because it required a little bit less investment. And back in those days also a little bit less know how.

    Dr G 3:27
    Yeah, I look, I don't know that it requires heaps of know how now, but we certainly do know more now.

    Dr Rad 3:35
    Yeah, definitely. But yeah, so we basically for an hour, if there's a word that I say all the time? Of course, I have to say it on our turn. Yeah, I say basically a lot on the show. But we initially take that basically, just we're recording our conversations, and we proudly did not edit our shows at all until I think about maybe three years ago.

    Dr G 3:59
    This is true. We did spend a long time not editing anything. Yeah. And and that my friends is the secret to an independent podcast.

    Dr Rad 4:11
    Yeah, but it wasn't it wasn't just because of time. I mean, we genuinely sat down I think to record our conversations. And I think that's been one of our challenges as well. The fact is that you amuse me endlessly Dr. G, and I am what we call a laugh speaker naturally, as anybody who knows me in real life knows, I tend to laugh as I speak all the time, regardless, and I'm a teacher so there are a lot of people out there that have to listen to me teach history whilst simultaneously somehow

    Dr G 4:42
    I think that's fine. It's more like when it gets into like disciplining the students and you're still laughing and that's that's the toughy.

    Dr Rad 4:50
    Ahh Yes, my my notorious laugh-yelling less heard on the podcast. But anyway, I think that that's exactly it when we first started sitting down and having conversations it genuinely, I think it still is to a certain extent. But for a really long time, you and I were really just in a bubble, I felt like where I almost forgot we were recording. I just don't have a great time talking to you. And therefore getting too excited, laughing too much being too loud.

    Dr G 5:21
    Oh, look, and I don't think that's a real issue. And I have to say that if we're in this sort of compliment sandwich, which is this anniversary episode, and I feel like that's where we, that I enjoy your company events. And I would not be able to turn up every time for 10 years and have such a good time. If it weren't for you, my esteemed colleague.

    Dr Rad 5:43
    No, I couldn't agree more. And the crazy thing is that if we hadn't come together, I mean, we met at university, everybody, I think, who listens to our show probably noticed that we did meet at university, but we really didn't know each other at all, while we were doing our degree. I remember having a conversation with you at some postgrads thing that was at Macquarie I can't even remember what it was about. And we were talking about the fact that at the time, we were both dating men who were really keen cricketers. And so we were talking about how the fact that we were like cricket widows on a Saturday or something along those lines. But apart from that, I don't think we exchanged more than five words to each other whilst we're at uni together. It wasn't until we were both graduating essentially, that we were kind of thrown together and somehow decided that even though we knew each other, but we didn't know each other that well that we would start a podcast together.

    Dr G 6:35
    Let's just do this thing. I think at that point, we were really driven by our passion for history and wanting to continue to do history. Yes. And that was pretty clear. And we also, the circumstances of us getting to know each other more through doing the podcast is absolutely true, because we did know, of each other. But I wouldn't say that we necessarily knew each other deeply at the time that we agreed to do this thing. And in a way that's potentially a benefit. But I would have to say also, that the circumstance of us coming together was through a mutual friend.

    Dr Rad 7:11
    Yes.

    Dr G 7:12
    And so we, we had both already been vetted and approved by somebody we both trusted.

    Dr Rad 7:18
    And we had been spending some social time together because of the mutual friend, definite

    Dr G 7:23
    Shout out Abby!

    Dr Rad 7:24
    Our original photographer, guys. And that's just it, we ended up developing a number of important mutual friendships, such as Dr. Smith. Hi, Dr. Smith, also one of our photographers are our long suffering friends that have had to take photos of us wherever we go.

    Dr G 7:44
    Yes, and we've really only sorted that out recently, as well by buying a ring light. So we could put this phone on a stand to take the photos for us. And goodness knows. That may be more silly than having somebody take your own picture. I don't know.

    Dr Rad 7:58
    This is true. But it just seems crazy to me that if it hadn't been for that brief moment, that we might not ever have stayed in touch. Like, I know, it's kind of crazy to me, like you're literally the person I talk to you the most in the world.

    Dr G 8:14
    That's a sliding doors moment

    Dr Rad 8:16
    That's actually listening to me, that's the key.

    Dr G 8:19
    Oh, no, is this the time where I tell the truth?

    Dr Rad 8:25
    But anyway, but no look, it has been such a an immense privilege and pleasure to talk about. I'm just gonna say history, because although it is Roman history, we have talked about other things as well. So just talk about history with you for 10 years now. And for you to tolerate my laugh talking.

    Dr G 8:42
    It is really no burden at all.

    Dr Rad 8:45
    And also, I mean, you know, there are many co hosts out there that can say they've also had to adjust to podcasting with a co host who's losing their hearing, which has got to be a challenge.

    Dr G 8:57
    I mean, between the two of us, I guess we'll see what happens. But as long as we're able to figure it out, I think we can keep talking about for sure. So this will be our transition into video and sign.

    Dr Rad 9:09
    It's coming. It's coming. I'm learning Auslan slowly. So we decided to get together today because we also wanted to share this moment with our listeners. Because whilst you and I, for the vast majority of our podcasting career have mostly just talked to each other and assumed that nobody else is listening, it turns out that we were wrong about that. That's actually a lot of people that listen to our podcast. Yeah. And honestly, we are so incredibly grateful for the people that we've collaborated with over the years. I mean, they're too numerous to mention. But we have had a lot of people who had us on this show who shared expertise who shared their support, whether it's, you know, through resources that they have access to that we didn't have access to. I mean, we're really so grateful for all the people out there that have reached out and also to the people that have taken the time to write to us and write nice reviews and nice comments. I mean, honestly, for two people that are still podcasting after 10 years in their living rooms, it's really, really so incredibly meaningful when you do that. So thank you so much for listening. And thank you for your support. And now as a gift to you, we decided that since it was our 10 year anniversary, that we would get together and have a bit of a bonus chat about our 10 top moments from the Roman Republic, which has absorbed our attention for the vast majority of the past 10 years, not entirely. But obviously, if you want to know what we think about the Regal period, you can go and buy our book now.

    Dr G 10:40
    Oh, yeah, we've sealed the deal on the Regal period by writing a book about it. And we are still in the Republican period. And we will be for hundreds more years. Yeah, I suspect that our 20 year anniversary will probably so banner above like, Look, if we get to the Punic Wars by the 20th anniversary, I think we will have done well.

    Dr Rad 11:01
    Deal, we've gotta go now. The Punic Wars by 2033.

    Dr G 11:09
    Everyone's gonna have a 10 year strategy, don't they?

    Dr Rad 11:12
    Exactly. So let's talk through some of our top 10 moments Dr. G, and just re-live the violence the horror, because I realized looking at this list, there aren't that many nice list. We can pull this list and it's it's full of violence. I'm not gonna lie. Well, why don't you tell me what's your what's your fav?

    Dr G 11:35
    Oh, look, I don't know that I necessarily have a fave. So we have compiled a document. So I'm just gonna go from number one to number 10. That's how this is gonna work. Number one is the conspiracy to restore theTarquin dynasty the final terrible family of kings. And somebody at Rome like, you know, it would be a great idea to have those sad sacks back in charge, even though we just literally kick them out.

    Dr Rad 12:03
    Definitely. Look, I think that this is one of our top moments because it's one of Brutus' top moments. And Brutus, as we know is you know, Roman man, par excellence?

    Dr G 12:16
    Yes, a very honorable man indeed.

    Dr Rad 12:18
    So just for those of you who don't recall, Episode 45. When we dealt with this, you can go back and listen to it in more detail. But as you might expect, when a regime is toppled, there are those that were attached to the regime that are no longer enjoying quite the cushy benefits that they used to. And you know who I'm talking about Dr G? It's time to mention the young patricians.

    Dr G 12:44
    Oh, no.

    Dr Rad 12:46
    Now to be fair, they're not I don't think they're actually explicitly in my account, called the Young patricians. But Livy is explicit that they are young men have important families. So I've been read between the lines. Young men have important families, it sounds like we're dealing with the elites, at the very least, exactly. Even if they're not called the patricians in this time period. Exactly. They're the people that are going to spawn their patrician class, and therefore I burn them. These young people, they're not loving, being without the talk wins, because they're just not enjoying the lifestyle to which they have become accustomed. And therefore, when envoys come from the Tarquins, saying, hey, so like, you know, how they're exiled and all but what about their property that's still hanging around the place? What about that? What about it?

    The young men of Rome are open to some subterfuge on the side. So whilst ostensibly representing the property interests of the top ones, these envoys are putting out feelers and lo and behold, they find some people that are willing to try and assist the torque winds to get back into power. Now, they don't seem to be the best conspirators I've ever come across. I'm not going to lie. Because not only do they put things down in writing, which I feel like it's never a good idea. Awkward guys.

    Dr G 14:15
    Conspiracy much?

    Dr Rad 14:16
    Yeah, exactly. Letters are exchanged. So not only is stuffed down in writing, but they don't seem to be very secretive when discussing the super secret plot to bring back the king in their own homes. Now, Hmm. Maybe this is just complacency, because the people that overhear them are slaves. So maybe they're just like, well, you know, I do everything else in front of my slaves. You know, I have sex in front of them. I address in front of them. I go to the toilet in front of them. I eat in front of them. You're certainly not expecting them to do the dirty on you, that's for sure. Yeah. But anyway, as a result of all these various types of evidence, they ended up getting found out pretty quick-smart and convicted of conspiracy now why? Why Dr. G? You might ask Does any of this have anything to do with Brutus?

    Dr G 15:10
    I think some of his relatives, nay, his children may be involved.

    Dr Rad 15:16
    Exactly. So Brutus, supposedly was one of the first consuls, see our other episodes for the lengthy discussions about whether consuls actually existed this quickly or not. Brutus is apparently one of the very first consuls, and he is naturally you know, taking charge of steering this ship that is room through the dangerous waters that lie ahead as they enter the Republican harbor after exiting from the kingship. But he has to face the fact that his own sons, Titus and Tiberius seem to have been caught up in this conspiracy. And this is not entirely surprising, because lest we forget, Dr. G. Brutus is a part of the Tarquin family.

    Dr G 16:01
    Yes, he's part of the extended gens that is related to Superbus himself. So it is perhaps problematic that his sons are involved, and also unsurprising.

    Dr Rad 16:15
    So this means that Brutus has to oversee not only the conviction of his sons, which would be shameful enough, but the punishment and this is what I think really cements, Brutus, his reputation in the Roman mind, putting state above self.

    Dr G 16:33
    Indeed. And it's an unpleasant business to execute people in ancient Rome. These guys are stripped their scourged and then ultimately beheaded.

    Dr Rad 16:46
    And Brutus has to stand by and watch it all. Ugh.

    Dr G 16:51
    Well, I mean, he doesn't have to stand by and watch it all. But he does.

    Dr Rad 16:54
    This is true. And this is the this is the thing. It's that toughness, isn't it? You know, Roman men are meant to be either masculine in this sense. So he's tough. He's got that sort of stoic vibe to him. I know that it's probably a bit anachronistic to say that, but you know what I mean, I'm using it in the modern sense. And he is absolutely putting the New Republic above his own family.

    Dr G 17:21
    Yeah, it's a impressive and tragic start to the New Republic.

    Dr Rad 17:27
    But for that reason, I had to put her on the list because Brutus will continue to be a bit of a touchstone I think for subsequent generations of Romans, because of his key role in overthrowing the Tarquin dynasty and then ensuring that they can't sneak their sneaky little way back in.

    Dr G 17:46
    They certainly cannot. Yeah, people will die. Yeah, heads will fall.

    Dr Rad 17:51
    Absolutely. And this moment, for those of you who are playing along at home, was immortalized by Jacques Louis David, French painter who was quite drawn to the Republican period during the French Revolution. You can see his illustration of the lictors bringing Brutus the bodies of his sons. If you feel like a visual that would just cheer you up no end. And on that happy note, this brings us to another horrible incident in the Roman Republic, this made our list Dr G and that is the downfall of Spurius Cassius.

    Dr G 18:24
    And look, I'm not going to pretend that I remember much about this one, to be honest. I mean, he clearly he's important. We spend at least two episodes on him. But. But what did he do?

    Dr Rad 18:38
    Well, this is the thing is first, Cassius, some people might think he's a bit of a controversial choice. We did talk about him in Episode 72 and 73. Just to be clear, we're talking about Spurius Cassius Vecellinus, or Vecellinus, which sounds a little bit like Vicks Vapor Rub or something like that to me. But he held the consulship quite a few times. And he seems to have been prominent in this early Republican period as well, because he holds it in 502 and 493, which is kind of a key year, because that's the year that Rome is dealing with the whole Lake Regillius, and all of that kind of stuff where they've been battling the Latins, and so on, and then finally in 486, so yeah, that's a pretty decent run early on and thinks it does sound impressive. So spirit, Cassius is mostly known, I think, probably there for his downfall, which was a pretty big deal in our show. And look, I think the reason why some people might find him a controversial choice is because his downfall is probably a little bit anachronistic. But nonetheless, I think it was still a pretty big moment and the fact that whether it was entirely in the way that Livy and Dionysius painted it or whether it is a bit of a retrojection from their own time period. It still comes across as a pretty key moment in the republic to me. And that's because his downfall is very much tied up with the whole question of land redistribution in room.

    Dr G 20:15
    Yes, this is a big and perennial issue.

    Dr Rad 20:18
    So in spite of the fact that Spurius Cassius is a patrician as generally all our early magistrates seem to be, he seems to have been in favor of putting forward an agrarian law that was going to help the barbarians in terms of securing land, which obviously is key to survival and status in the Roman world. His family, patricians weren't super keen on this idea. And so he ends up being basically, I think, set up as someone who's aspiring to be a tyrant, and he is convicted and taken down and he ends up being thrown off the Tarpeian rock.

    Dr G 21:01
    Oh, intense. The fact that I can't even remember this is a testament to just how long were they podcasting. Because that's a pivotal event!

    Dr Rad 21:10
    Absolutely. I mean, look, for those of you who are fond of the latest Republic, you'll probably think that this sounds a little bit like a man we mentioned very often for people that are still in the Regal period and the early republic most of the time, and that is Tiberius Gracchus.

    Dr G 21:26
    Yes, everybody's

    Dr Rad 21:29
    Yeah, Tiberius Gracchus also came to a sticky end because of his push for land laws, and I think fair treatment for the people. And so it is suspected, that perhaps spurious Cassius as life has somehow been maybe jazzed up a little bit, whether with a crack and feel so Gracchan glitter, sprinkle sprinkle. But as you often said to me, Dr. G, it seems really unlikely that our sources would entirely lie to us about something.

    Dr G 22:07
    Yeah, I mean, I tend to I tend to take that line.

    Dr Rad 22:12
    Yeah. And so there must be something about this man. That I think I mean, there must be some truth to his story. I think the nature of his death, I find it hard to believe that people would make that up.

    Dr G 22:25
    Yeah. But the idea that there is a crisis going on, and that somebody is trying to stand up for the little man, that seems relatively believable. I mean, that's the broad brushstrokes of the story. You're like, okay, I can I can be on board with something like that. That makes sense. It's politically expedient, if nothing else, to try and pick up some of that support in some way.

    Dr Rad 22:53
    For sure, and like, we don't know, a lot of things about the Republic, including exactly how land that was public land was managed to this point in time, we can't be entirely certain how much of an issue, land ownership was, at this time, in the sense that I'm sure it was an issue because, you know, as I said, it is the basis of wealth and prosperity and status in this society. So I'm sure it's probably always an issue. But at the same time, we can't be entirely sure exactly if the nature of the tension at this point in time, but I had to put Spurius Cassius on the list, because to me, it seems like he was actually maybe one of the not so bad patrician, because you and I are both crazy leftist.

    Dr G 23:41
    That's true. And it's very rare that one of the good guys comes through. Well, I think this leads us to our third on the list on our top 10 Lars Porsenna. What a man what a man. And this guy is like a king from outside of Rome, who manages according to some sources to take over Rome.

    Dr Rad 24:09
    Absolutely. I mean, how could we not bring back Lars Porsenna, the king of Clusium?

    Dr G 24:15
    Look at him go. And not just king of Clusium I tell you, he might also be in charge of this place as well.

    Dr Rad 24:23
    Yeah, so last four centers on we talked about as well back in the very, very early days of the Republic. But I do enjoy this story. And I do remember this story. So that that tells you something. We did talk about him for a number of episodes if you go back to our 40s because that's how long ago it was. You'll find a number of episodes that mention Lars Porsenna.

    Dr G 24:45
    And there is this great set piece story of the moment that Porsenna is trying to infiltrate Rome militarily speaking, and there is the amazing story You have of Hartius Cocles who defends Rome from this attack, over the only bridge that appears to exist at this point in time, the Sublician bridge over the Tiber.So this means that Porsenna's forces are sitting somewhere near the Janiculum. And it means that the Romans are kind of like this is our last chance to defend ourselves. It's this bridge or bust. And Horatius Cocles does some incredible work to try and save Rome

    Dr Rad 25:33
    That he does. In fact, I believe from memory he cops are very serious butt wound in the process.

    Dr G 25:35
    I was gonna say he saves Rome's arse, but he's not able to save his own.

    Dr Rad 25:38
    So true, so true. So Porsenna is it is a really interesting character because he comes up seemingly because the exiled Tarquin and dynasty have taken refuge with him, and perhaps trying to persuade him to attack Rome. And I guess they're hoping that this is going to be their avenue back into power, since that conspiracy inside of Rome has failed.

    Dr G 26:14
    Du-du-duuuun.

    Dr Rad 26:16
    I know. But scholars have tried to make sense of this because whilst Livy and Dionysius represent it in this kind of light. We have later sources like Tacitus, and plenty that are seemingly certain that Porsenna actually captured Rome, really low point, obviously, for Rome, because not only did he capture it, but he also brought in some really, really serious baby steps that were not beneficial to Rome at all.

    Dr G 26:45
    Yeah, I mean, I think it's an interesting sort of alternative tradition, as it were, because you've got the Romans very much are interested in not being captured by an external force. And they do have to navigate that at various points in their history. So for this to be one of the examples that they don't necessarily agree on, I think is fascinating and tells us something about the politics of this moment. And this, I think, heads right back in towards what we know about the Roman kings as well, in terms of like, was there an Etruscan takeover during the Regal period? And, you know, the sources try to worm their way away from that interpretation in various ways. And it seems like maybe something similar could be happening here.

    Dr Rad 27:38
    Definitely. I mean, some people say Porsenna is actually the real end of the monarchy, because he starts being a problem for Rome in about 508. So a year after the kings have been kicked out, supposedly. But yeah, some scholars have seen this as actually being the moment where the monarchy ended, because you have this foreign takeover of Rome. But that when looking back, the Romans maybe found it a bit easier to write a history where the kings were horrible, and they were kicked out. And then they allied with persona, and therefore, these guys were the enemy together, rather than Porsenna potentially being the person to come in and take room. And also, of course, Porsenna's lengthy campaign against the Rams, because it lasts for quite some time. He's really an annoyance to them for a good four years, maybe five years according to our records. We have some of the most famous moments of the early republic, including Gaius Mucius Cordis otherwise known to history as Scaevola.

    Dr G 28:45
    Hmm.

    Dr Rad 28:47
    And this is another of course, amazing moment of virtus much like Horatius Cocles that you mentioned earlier. So Scaevola's story is all about room being besieged by Porsenna. They're not in a great state. So this guy, guy sneaky has caught us, puts his hand up, puts his hand up and says, you know, I'll infiltrate the camp. I'll pretend to be a deserter. And I will assassinate Porsenna and that will put an end to this whole issue.

    Dr G 29:18
    We'll cut off the head of the Hydra. That's how we'll do it.

    Dr Rad 29:22
    Exactly. Now, I won't go into all the details of his story. But eventually he is found out within the camp of Porsenna. He actually ends up putting his own hand into flames to sort of be like Hiiiii. And Porsenna is so impressed by his bravery, by his physical fortitude, that he releases him.

    Yeah, and this is where this is where the hand thing comes in, because of course Scaevola is a name that he earns apparently, yeah, because he becomes “The Left Handed”.

    Dr G 30:01
    Well yes, the right one. It's a bit dodgy now.

    Dr Rad 30:05
    So we've got that famous moment. And then of course, we've got a very rare appearance from a heroic woman.

    Dr G 30:11
    Oh yeah, I'm excited about the story of Cloelia, who manages to get some hostages back to Rome at a daring escape. And for this, she gets awarded an equestrian statue. And this is huge. It's very rare for Roman women to win a statue of any kind. And, yeah, she stands out as one of the very impressive early Republican women.

    Dr Rad 30:42
    Absolutely. Now, of course, the fact that scandal or include Cloelia and Horatius Cocles are probably mythological figures should not dampen our enjoyment of their stories. And also, we have to thank Lars Porsenna for bringing them to us.

    Dr G 30:59
    Thank you, Porsenna. Okay, number four on our list, the first secession of the plebs. Now this, this is a massive issue.

    Dr Rad 31:08
    Yeah, the moment that started at all I mean, we're still dealing with the repercussions of the struggle of the artist, and we will be for so many more episodes,

    Dr G 31:16
    We will and you know, it's tied up to some elements of debt. And there seems to be like, how do you get yourself out of debt? And how do you get yourself out of debt bondage, this is a real problem. So the plebeians are struggling under the economic shackles of the early republic, not that they weren't suffering under the Kings, they probably were, but it's now it's really a headline act. Now the the trouble that the plebs are facing, and the consuls are taking a pretty hard line on this sort of stuff, and they do not want to negotiate. And this ultimately means that the plebs decide to leave room altogether. They're like, that's it. You know what, I cannot live in this place, if you're going to treat me so badly. I'm the guy that gets up every day when there's a war, and I fight on the front lines. And when I come home, it's all just taxation, and enslavement, and no land, and what am I supposed to do with my life? Why don't I live over here on this hill, so they repair to somewhere else, they're like, I'm out. I'm just out, I'll make friends with other people, I'll find a new place to live, it's going to be fine. And it takes a lot of backwards and forwards diplomacy on the behalf of some very patient, but sympathetic patricians to talk to these guys and really be like, Look, actually, Rome cannot be Rome. Without you. We are a unified people. And I think this is the moment where we get the head and the stomach analogy coming for that moment where the patricians or the head and the plebeians of the stomach, and neither can function without the other. And it's some sort of glorious symbiotic relationship that exists.

    Dr Rad 33:12
    Yeah, that's the immortal words of Menenius Agrippa. There, give me the analogy of look, Rome is like a body. And you guys have you know, the hands and that kind of stuff, and the patricians of the stomach and we just need to absorb what you give us and, and we also take on board, you know, the, the food to the brain, and we end up being the mastermind of this whole operation.

    Dr G 33:34
    Ah the patricians are the stomach, of course.

    Dr Rad 33:39
    Look, I had to put this one on the list, personally, not only because we've been talking about the struggle of the orders, which is this lengthy tension between patricians and plebeians, which we have so little information on considering how long it apparently lasted. But it certainly been the topic of many episodes it. In fact, I don't think there are many episodes where we don't mention something about the patricians and plebeians at this point in time, whether it's warranted or not. And so I thought, we have to mention this particular moments in Republican history. Because again, it's one of those moments sliding doors, as you say, where everything could have really changed because, of course room at the time was at war with the Sabines in the Volsicians. And the patricians really needed the plebeians to come back, which I think is probably why they entered into negotiations in the first place.

    Dr G 34:33
    And lucky they did I mean, it works out well for the patricians as far as I can tell.

    Dr Rad 34:39
    It did it did indeed, because they do end up prevailing upon the plebeians to come back. And one of the things that the plebeians apparently get out of coming back is, of course, the office of the tribune of the plebs. The tribune of the plebs. They've caused me so much To light with all their troublesome meddling.

    Dr G 35:04
    Well, and this is actually a really interesting segue to number five on this list. So it is the life and times of Volero Publilius. Which is fair enough, and you might think to yourself, now wait, I remember those episodes. What's that got to do with the tribune of the plebs. But the whole year that this guy is involved with and his rise up is preluded by the sudden death and probable murder of a tribune of the plebs. A Gnaeus Genucius. And so this is what 473 BCE. And so this kind of time period, a we've clearly got a little bit of political tension in the city. We've we've got a tribune of the plebs turning up dead, which is a bit of a disaster, because those guys are supposed to have inviolable bodies. Under no circumstances, are they meant to be murdered? And so, this kind of sets the scene for what will be the life and times of Volero? Publius.

    Dr Rad 36:21
    Absolutely. Because this guy Volero Publilius. Or, if we use his slightly easier version of his name, Volero Publius. Gah that rolls off the tongue so much easier. He is a centurion. So kind of just a fairly average joe, Dr. G. You know how it goes. He turns up to enlist for the army, because that's what you do. If you're a decent Roman man, you do duty, even though it's tough. But when he turns up to enlist, he finds that he has seemingly been demoted from centurion to a common soldier.

    Dr G 37:04
    Ouch.

    Dr Rad 37:06
    Could there be a larger disgrace for a man like this? Who's done his duty for so many years?

    Dr G 37:12
    Oh, just you wait, I think there might be.

    Dr Rad 37:16
    So causes a bit of a fuss. He ends up being bundled up by the lictors. And nobody's very happy about this situation. We ended up getting full on brawling in the streets of Rome, that plebeians will not have these violent hands being laid on Volero, not they're Volero.

    Dr G 37:35
    No, yeah, this brawling really gets out of hand because Volero is pretty adamant that nobody should be laying any hands on him. He's merely raising some important questions about the whole situation. And he's like, I've fought for a long time. What do you mean, I'm not not a centurion anymore? And, you know, so he's raising those questions, he gets bundled up by the lectores. So this means that the consuls essentially at the levy doing their job of getting soldiers enrolled, and their electors are then like, on him, because he's starting to cause some trouble. But instead of that settling the trouble, what this does is inflames the street violence, because the plebeians that are there at the time, presumably also lining up to satisfy the levy are like, wait a minute, if this can happen to this guy, this could happen to us. Oh, no, it's time. And so like, whatever that five is, and that tension in the air for this particular levy, it does not go well. And things get so out of hand that reportedly the fast skis themselves get broken, which is a lot.

    Dr Rad 38:46
    Absolutely. I mean, the fast guys are meant to be this representation of the consul's power over the population to beat them and if necessary to execute them, so that they have smashed these out, is a pretty big message of defiance. And I think if we put this all together with the mysterious death of Genucius, it seems like there's some serious class issues going on in Rome at this time. And of course, Volero ended up being quite a character in a few of our episodes. Chi Chi, so I had to put him on the list because I had fond memories of him,

    Dr G 39:20
    He's always standing up for the little man.

    Dr Rad 39:22
    Yeah, absolutely.

    Dr G 39:24
    So number six on our list, the Sneak Attack of Appius Herdonius, the Sabine in 460 BCE. This is an epic moment in Rome's history. I have to say this one stands out just because it is both horrifying and surprising and then becomes an environment in which a whole bunch of people really go to in terms of Roman virtus.

    Dr Rad 39:57
    Absolutely. I vividly remember Are these episodes where we talked about this because I don't think it's something you hear about all that often, I guess, because it's kind of in the middle of this century that is kind of known for being a tough one for the entire area room included. And it's not a period that people I think dwell on too much. So I don't think I'd actually ever heard of this, say, by an attack on Rome before.

    Dr G 40:23
    But the Sabines actually take the Capitol. And this is the thing that makes you want to follow up on a story like this, because there are really famous stories of Rome being sacked by the goals and things like that stories that we have not reached our narrative episodes. But before those pivotal moments, we have something like this, like the Republic is always in danger, there is never a moment where it is really safe. And the city is constantly under pressure from its neighbours. And for the Sabines to turn up and to do a sneak infiltration into the Capitol, which is the most sacred hill of the city is suggestive that of Rome sort of like place within this broader relationship in central Italy, it is by no means secure in its own power. And when they find out about this attack, they really are on the backfoot. And they have to get all of their forces organized quite quickly to defend the interior. And this is tough, because the Capitol is a hill and the Romans themselves and not on the top of that hill.

    Dr Rad 41:39
    Crucial error.

    Dr G 41:40
    This is bad news. And so we have the the tragic death of Valerius Publicola, one of the heroes of the Romans, who's who was famous for holding, I think, many consulships by this point. And he is lost in this battle. This is a tragedy. But also and we learn this much later. This is also a battle that Dentatus fights in. So we'll come back to that guy. But Dentatus is here fighting as well. And he talks about this battle in really particular terms because it is so intense.

    Dr Rad 42:21
    This is true. And I think that the other reason why I had to mention this one as one of our top 10 moments is because it's an ancient Roman example of fake news. Because of course, this episode has something to do with the conflict of the orders as well, because I think one of the reasons why the Sabines were supposedly able to sneak into Rome and seize the Capitol before people seem to really know what was going on, is that the Romans were really distracted by their own internal problems. The young patricians, my favorite characters of our show, had been terrorizing the plebeians. And when trouble initially is afoot, because of Appius Herdonius, it seems that there's some suspicion that may be the consuls, just saying that there's an attack and an invasion, in order to deal with the class warfare because this is the classic go to patrician move, right to distract the plebeians with external problems, so that they will stop talking about their unhappiness with the internal political situation. And the tribunes I think, are encouraging them to believe that this is, you know, this is potentially something that the consuls have stirred up, either that or that this is their moment to stand firm and not act and be like, well, this is what happens. I don't want to serve when you don't treat me very well. Maybe I'd be better off with the Sabines. Have you ever thought about that patricians?

    Dr G 43:48
    Disaster, if they don't fight now, they'll lose everything they ever, ever valued.

    Dr Rad 43:53
    Exactly. So they do they do come together as at this point, they always seem to do, but I think that instance of you know, who do you trust in these moments of crisis? Who do you listen to? Who are the authority figures that you go to? To get reliable sources of information? I mean, that always touches a bit of a nerve with me.

    Dr G 44:14
    Fair enough. And as a historian, I'm not surprised.

    Dr Rad 44:19
    All right, and that brings us to number seven on the list.

    Dr G 44:21
    Ooh, this is the death of Verginia slash or the beginning of the end of Appius Claudius

    Dr Rad 44:30
    I like to say is about we're getting out because we get so few women in the Republic, it's crazy.

    Dr G 44:36
    And it looks like Verginia holds a really particular place in this narrative of the end of the decemvirate. So there is a point in which the Republic of Rome does collapse. This there is no doubt and it doesn't take very long into it. And what replaces it is this decemvirate this group of 10 men who refuse to let go of power, and Appius Claudius is by far the most proud and offensive of the lot of them, but also the one who's most charismatically in charge, apparently, honing in on those very patrician qualities that the Romans really quite like, from their elites, you know, the arrogance, the refusal to negotiate, and all of that kind of stuff.

    Dr Rad 45:27
    This is all tied up with again, part of the apparent struggle of the orders, although we've switched, as you may have noticed, for I'm talking about land issues to talking about the laws, because this all came out of the law about the laws, which became a big issue, I think, particularly in the late 460s in the 450s, where it seemed like the issue so that obedience became that they really wanted to have set down somewhere, the rules that were being applied to their society, which seemingly the patricians who occupied the senior magistracies and priesthoods had exclusive knowledge of or access to. And so the decemvirate was meant to fix all of that they were meant to produce a law code, and the first decemvirate went pretty well, but the second decemvirate, as you say, not so much, because they decided they were going to stay in power forever.

    Dr G 46:13
    Yeah, rather than producing the laws and letting everybody get on with it. They were like, wait a minute, I'm enjoying this power, what if I don't do my job and just stay forever?

    Dr Rad 46:23
    Exactly. Now, we spent quite a lot of time talking about this. So we won't go into heaps of detail now. But essentially, beginning I think, becomes a bit of a symbol for Appius Claudius, and the way that he is out of control.

    Dr G 46:35
    Yeah, she is a reputedly a very beautiful young woman. And he decides that he desires her and that he can have her because he's so powerful, and no one can stop him. And as it turns out, the Romans don't agree with that. And despite his best efforts to try and find a way to make it legal for him to have his way with her, she is defended by her family at every turn. And they go into bat for her, and they see the injustice and they rail against it. And ultimately, it ends in tragedy, where her father is with Verginia. And they're in the forum together. And it seems like what Appius Claudius is going to do is he's going to seize her anyway, and just do his business. And Verginia's father decides that the only way to save her from this fate is to is to kill her.

    Dr Rad 47:39
    Absolutely. And this is such a pivotal moment, it really seems to be the turning point for I think a lot of people when it comes to Appius Claudius and a second decemvirate, as you say, becomes the kind of the thread that is pulled and starts to unravel that whole regime. But what a tragedy for a woman's death, murder at the hands of her own father in public, how, yeah, how deeply disturbing it is that this is how it is in Rome, that a woman must die in such circumstances or so it would seem in order for tyranny to be brought to justice.

    Dr G 48:18
    Yes, it tells tell us something about the way that this society dysfunctionally navigates its relationship with women,

    Dr Rad 48:25
    Indeed. And that of course, then brings us to another person who fell afoul of the second decemvirate and that is Lucius Siccius Dentatus.

    Dr G 48:36
    Dentatus, the man born with teeth. I shall never forget. And Dentatus is renowned, first and foremost for being an excellent soldier. And he earns a reputation in some of the latest source material as the Roman Achilles, which I think is fantastic. But he also at some point is able given the opportunity to to stand up in front of the crowd to speak at the rostra. And boy, does he reveal his political hand at that point, because he has been a soldier for 40 plus years, by the time he gets to speak. And he tells everybody about his achievements, his golden crown for recovering the standards, which he did personally when he was 27 years old. talks about his 45 wounds that he's received over the course of his 40 year career. All of those wounds on the front of his body, very respectful. Everybody's like bow down. The man is great. Not only that 12 of those wounds he tells us were received on the day that Herdonius seized the Capitol. So that you know, there's there's references even within our top 10 lens.

    Dr Rad 48:53
    Link!

    Dr G 49:07
    You can have a top 10 list but they all connected. He also won 14 corona civica. So this is the crown for saving a Roman citizen himself three corona muralis for going over the wall first and numerous other awards and and then he says, regardless of all of this, all of the things that I've achieved in my career, I have no land that I can call my own basically starts riot right there. Everyone's like, oh my god, it doesn't matter how hard you work in life, the system is rigged against us and we're never going to have anything. And so this becomes his – he might not realize it at the time, but this speech becomes the speech that really gets him into the tribuncianship. So he becomes a tribune of the plebs on the back of this kind of like discussion. Everyone's like, well, if this guy, this guy will be able to get us the land. So we've, we've switched from like law about the laws, which is also very important simultaneously back to like, the first crux issue that the plebeians had raised, which is like, we need some land to be able to do our farming and look after ourselves.

    Dr Rad 51:12
    Yeah, well, I think there's no matter no matter what you're talking about, with the struggle of the orders, there are three themes that float in and out. And there doesn't seem to be much rhyme or reason to why certain issues are, you know, prevalent at certain times and not others, but it's definitely land allotment. That's one, debt bondage and debt. That's another and the law about the laws. And essentially, what that is relating to obviously, as we said, is like control of the knowledge.

    Dr G 51:37
    Yeah, a law about the laws is basically also the publication of law in such a way that the everyday man can have access to it.

    Dr Rad 51:47
    Yeah, we know they had laws before the 12 Tables, which is what comes out of the decemvirate. But as you say, it's about well, does everybody know about them? Does everybody have access to them in this sort of society? Probably not.

    Dr G 52:00
    It's unlikely. I think it's suffice to say that the old Dentatus gets on the wrong side of the elites, which at this time, are the decemvirs.

    Dr Rad 52:15
    Oh, yeah, he's another he's another for being here. And we love our party and heroes like Volero and Dentatus

    Dr G 52:21
    But it doesn't go well. And it seems like Dentatus who sent back into the fray essentially, after his tribuncian days are over. And he is of the understanding that he is going to be meeting up with the army and getting the right sort of support. But instead what happens is some Roman soldiers have been paid, it would seem to turn against their own and he is taken down. And this all comes out eventually. hugely problematic. But at the time, it's told us a story of tragedy being like we lost Dentatus. Who knew?

    Dr Rad 52:58
    You know what that sounds like? To me, Dr. G. It sounds like an evil plan.

    Dr G 53:05
    There is some conspirosity going on.

    Dr Rad 53:09
    Couldn't get through our 10 year anniversary about an evil plan.

    Dr G 53:13
    Fair enough! Fair enough.

    Dr Rad 53:14
    Speaking of evil plans. That brings us to number nine analysis, which is the rise and fall of Spurius Maelius.

    Dr G 53:21
    A popular figure. This guy is a plebeian who happens to be quite rich,

    Dr Rad 53:27
    Another plebeian hero!

    Dr G 53:29
    Yeah, plebeian hero. It doesn't bode well for him either. Like spoilers, as as we're all aware. So it's, there is a crippling famine in Rome. And it's around about 444-39 BCE. And there is a prefect of the grain, Lucius Minucius, who is in charge of making sure that Rome is fed. And he is having trouble completing that task, because grain is in short supply.

    Dr Rad 53:56
    It is and I'm sorry, I just have to interrupt because you're not using his official title, which is the Nacho King of Rome. And I think we all agreed on that.

    Dr G 54:05
    I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Lucius Minucius. The Nacho King of Rome, is in charge of sourcing grain, but he's finding it hard to purchase it at a reasonable price. And it seems like everybody else is also going through a famine. So maybe they're not for sale. These grains are not for buying. And so he's having some issues. So enter stage left Spurius Maelius, very rich plebeian, who's like, well, you got to offer more cash, you know, very Han Solo about it. And so he sets up some relationships that really do work out and he has riverboats of grain coming into the city, and they are stamped all over with the name spirits. Maelius bought this grain and the plebeians, they know. They might not be able to read everything, but they can tell and yeah, You know, Maelius is handing it out and the plebeians take the position that well, if spurious, Maelius is bringing in the grain, surely that makes him the prefect of the grain.

    Dr Rad 55:18
    Exactly, we've got a new natural King in town, and I'm loving it.

    Dr G 55:22
    Not only is this guy bringing it in, it's raining grain, and I'm hungry. So this guy is now he's our prefect, this is man we go to nothing could be more calculated to ruin a patrician stay than finding out that their position of political power has been hoisted out from underneath them by a plebeian and popular support. Minucius is not happy. And this leads to trouble. Ultimately, things get really, really like sort of heated and chaotic, and it seems that the Romans decide that maybe murder is okay.

    Dr Rad 56:04
    Yeah, there seems to be a bit like the whole Porsenna plot with Scaevola. Or it seems in some accounts, like this is a case of state-sanctioned murder.

    Dr G 56:15
    It does feel that way. And you know, they institute a dictator. So and this is all coming from the elites, obviously. So a dictator is put into place. He asked for a master of the horse, a madman, basically volunteers. He was like, I love stabbing people. Let me stab somebody.

    Dr Rad 56:33
    They're like, they will hold a sign that he was a madman. I mean, for God's sakes, his name means “Armpit”.

    Dr G 56:38
    And so you know, they send Ahala “the armpit” off to Maelius. And then a hollow does away with him in broad daylight. And everyone's like, wait a minute, did that. Did that guy just murdered that? Wait, what? No.

    Dr Rad 56:55
    Yeah, so this is another guy who I mean, he is an equestrian. So he is actually as we say, he's wealthy. He's not suffering, like the average Roman citizen probably is at this point in time. But nonetheless, like Spurius Cassius before him, he seems to be someone who's at least trying to do something for the people may be self motivated. I mean, you know, it's rare in this world for anyone to do anything for free. But nonetheless, he seems to be doing these nice things for the people at this time of crisis. And in my account, certainly, it was all painted like he was again aspiring to tyranny like trying to make himself a king or something like that. Just like whisperers, Cassius before him, you know, where he ends up being accused of aspiring to some sort of higher power. And, of course, that's a surefire way to get rid of someone in ancient Rome.

    Dr G 57:47
    Goodness me.

    Dr Rad 57:47
    We spent, we spent quite a bit of time dealing with Spurius Maelius and mopping up that whole affair, so we couldn't help but mention him.

    Dr G 57:53
    Oh, look, I think I think it's a it's a nicer second last position, because coming in, drumroll, please. Number 10, for 10 years of the podcast, it's all as Cornelius Cossus vs. Lars Tolumnius. This is our second Lars in the top 10.

    Dr Rad 58:22
    It's no coincidence that he's also Etruscan.

    Dr G 58:23
    No, I remain unsurprised.

    Dr Rad 58:26
    No. But look, I had to put Cossus in because over the years, we have had several really, really ridiculously good looking men come into history,

    Dr G 58:37
    It would be a shame to miss out old Cossus. One because he's very good looking, according to all reports, but also he achieved something that has not yet been achieved in the Republic until he does it. And that is for him as a military commander to slay the enemy commander. So in the field about a one on one, and this is what Cossus reputedly does with Lars Tolumnius. And it's bad like there's a gouging of the thigh. You know, it depends on who you read, but it gets quiet.

    Dr Rad 59:13
    Yeah, I think last Tolumnius ends up pinned to the ground in my account, which sounds so painful. I really don't like to think of

    Yeah, he gets pushed off his horse and then pinned to the ground and then yeah, it's it's unpleasant. So Cossus does something incredibly violent, and has only been topped by Romulus in this regard in terms of taking out an enemy commander. So you have to go right back to the very early days of the Roman kings to get a story quiet like this.

    And the reason why he's number 10 is because Romulus is probably mythical, and there are so many questions about exactly how on earth he managed to get this accolade given that We're not sure when it happened. We're not sure if it happened, because there's so many question marks about when it supposedly happened and what position he was actually holding at the time. But I will say this, to go back to what you always say to me, Dr. G, the Romans really make everything up. So I do believe that last Tolumnius existed, that there was an Etruscan King, and that he was taken out by ridiculously good looking Roman.

    Dr G 1:00:28
    We just don't know when or exactly how.

    Dr Rad 1:00:33
    Exactly, but what a note to end on uncertainty with our sources, which has also been a constant refrain for 10 years.

    Dr G 1:00:42
    And I don't think that's gonna get cleared up anytime soon. To be honest.

    Dr Rad 1:00:47
    It's not. But look, we hope you enjoyed us counting down our top 10 moments over the Roman republic, and we hope that you appreciate just how violent and bloody and gory really is.

    Dr G 1:00:59
    Yes, and here's to another 10 years.

    Dr Rad 1:01:04
    To get worse, I think

    Dr G 1:01:05
    Oh, no!

    Dr Rad 1:01:06
    Yeah, but we have so enjoyed having you all along for the ride. We really appreciate your support. We've accomplished things that I don't think we ever dreamed of when we first sat down in one of Dr. G's apartments that you have had in the time I've known you. Actually, I was just remembering the other day how there have been recording sessions where you know, one of us would go over to the others house and then someone next door to be doing renovations and we had to flee to the library and the library kept putting announcements over the loudspeaker, you would have no idea listeners, just how much we have sometimes been challenged.

    Dr G 1:01:42
    Well, it's been a wild ride so far, and may it long continue.

    Dr Rad 1:01:47
    And I mean, I'm actually amazed that we've managed to get through this podcast without one of our little furry guests making an appearance. It's true,

    Dr G 1:01:53
    My cat has been yelling outside the door.

    Dr Rad 1:01:58
    Well, here's to another 10 years, Dr. G. Thank you so much for starting the Partial Historians with me.

    Dr G 1:02:05
    Oh, and thank you, and always huge thanks to you listening it out there.

    Dr Rad 1:02:23
    Thank you for listening to this extra special episode of the Partial Historians. Dr. G and I are so proud that we finally been able to put an X on the old bedpost and we're looking forward to notching up a few more because our passion for ancient Rome will never fade. And we are so incredibly grateful that we have found other people who not only love ancient Rome, but love making fun of ancient Rome as much as we do. When we started out in 2013. I don't know that we were entirely certain that two women from Down Under who love history would necessarily find an audience. And yet, here you are. Thank you so much. We particularly like to thank anybody who's ever reached out to us and written us a really kind message, or written a five star review, you have no idea how much particularly as independent podcasters those mean to us as we're researching, recording and editing the show. This is probably also a good time to thank our Patreons, I mean, where would we be without our Patreons past and present, it means so much that you would consider spending your hard earned money on our show. And you've certainly allowed us to upgrade our equipment. And we're also looking to expand into new areas this year. So keep your eyes peeled. Speaking of new areas, we'd like to thank Highlands Press our publisher. It's been so much fun to be able to write a book together, particularly a book that's kind of rooted in our podcast. So thank you so much to the Highlands Press. On a more personal note, as we sign off, we would like to thank our friends and family who have offered us constructive criticism, support, they have been very tolerant at the time that we've invested in the show over the years. We'd also like to say thank you and hello to all the podcasting community that have been so generous with their time and expertise over the years. It really is an amazing community to be a part of and social media has allowed us to connect with so many other podcast shows all over the world. And it's been such a blast getting to know you all and we look forward to many further collaborations. And also as a part of that, we would like to say thank you to anyone who has ever guessed it on the Partial Historians. What a special honour it has been to talk to so many academics who have been incredibly generous with their time and expertise. And I think we can all say that we have learned so much from those special episodes and I just can't imagine a bigger privilege than being able to talk to academics about their specialty. So with all that being said, it's time for Dr. G and I to sign off. That's 10 years a wrap. And until next time, we are yours in ancient Rome.

    Transcribed by https://otter.ai

    For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


    Support the show

    Patreon

    Ko-Fi


    Read our books

    Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

    Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

    Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

    1 hr 6 min
  • A Dry Period

    Prepare yourself, dear listener, for a drought or two! After spending several episodes on individual years, we are speeding ahead in our latest episode. We are covering not one, not two, but THREE years in a single instalment. Join us as we tackle 430, 429 and 428 BCE.

    Episode 134 – A Dry Period

    Financial Affairs

    The Romans enjoy a remarkably peaceful year in 430 BCE. This means that they can turn their attention to financial matters. At least the new law that is introduced seems to benefit the people.

    A Year About Nothing

    The citizens must be confused as the peace continued into 429 BCE. No war? No internal conflict? Are we trapped in an episode of Seinfeld?

    A classic photo of the Seinfeld cast. Source: www.geekblast.com.br

    The Return of Cossus

    The ridiculously handsome Aulus Cornelius Cossus returns for a consulship in 428 BCE. Thank goodness! We need some eye candy around here. The drama returns to Rome with raiders from Veii and Fidenae. However, the Romans cannot stay mad for long. A severe drought devastates the people. We’ve hit a dry period in this very dry period.

    All the Romans could think about was how to improve their relationship with the gods. Will their luck turn around?

    Looking to catch up on why Cossus is so famed? We’ve got your back:

    • Episode 129 – Lars Tolumnius and the Fate of Fidenae
    • Episode 130 – The Cossus Controversy
    • Things to Look Out For
      • Confusion over consuls (Who really was in charge in 428 BCE, Livy?)
      • Colony building
      • Irritating skin diseases
      • Aediles taking care of business
      • A special commission
      • Confusion over bovine equations
      • Book promotions. Gotcha! You can buy our book HERE!
      • Our Players 430 BCE
        Consuls
        • L. (or C.) Papirius – f. – n. Crassus (Pat) Cos. 436
        • L. Iulius (Vop. F. C. n.?) Iullus (Pat) Mil. Tr. c. p. 438
        • Censors
          • L. Papirius (Pat)
          • P. Pinarius (Pat)  
          • Our Players 429 BCE
            Consuls
            • Hostius Lucretius – f. – n. Tricipitinus (Pat)
            • L. Sergius C. f. C. n. Fidenas (Pat) Cos. 437, Mil. Tr. c.p. 433, 424, 418
            • Our Players 428 BCE
              Consuls Ordinarii
              • A. Cornelius M. f. L. n. Cossus (Pat) Mil. Tr. c.p. 426
              • T. Quinctius L. f. L. n. Poenus Cincinnatus (Pat) Cos. 431, Mil. Tr. c.p. 426, 420
              • Suffect Consuls
                • L. Quinctius (L. f. L. n. Cincinnatus) (Pat) Mil. Tr. c.p. 438, 425, 420?
                • A. Sempronius (L. f. A. n. Atratinus) (Pat)
                • Special Commission
                  • L. Sergius (Fidenas) (Pat) Cos. 437
                  • Q. Servilius (Priscus Fidenas) (Pat)
                  • Mam. Aemilius Mamercinus (Pat) Mil. Tr. c.p. 438
                  • Our Sources
                    • Dr G reads Cicero De Republica 2.60; Diodorus Siculus 12.72.1-12.75.1; Festus 203-4L, 220L; Plutarch Romulus 16.
                    • Dr Rad reads Livy ab Urbe Condita 4.30 and Cicero’s De Republica 2.60.
                    • Broughton, T. R. S., Patterson, M. L. 1951. The Magistrates of the Roman Republic Volume 1: 509 B.C. – 100 B.C. (The American Philological Association)
                    • Cornell, T. J. 1995. The Beginnings of Rome: Italy and Rome from the Bronze Age to the Punic Wars (c. 1000-264 BC) (Taylor & Francis)
                    • Forsythe, G. 2006. A Critical History of Early Rome: From Prehistory to the First Punic War(University of California Press) 
                    • Ogilvie, R. M. 1965. A Commentary on Livy: Books 1-5 (Clarendon Press). 
                    • Sound Effects

                      Sound effects courtesy of Fesliyan Studios and Orange Free Sounds. Thanks to the glorious Bettina Joy de Guzman for our theme music.

                      Roma, Lazio, Italia. Acquedotti. Source Wikimedia Commons. Photographer iessi

                      Automated Transcript

                      This transcript was generated by Otter AI. Apologies for any errors.

                      Dr Rad 0:17
                      Welcome to the Partial Historians,

                      Dr G 0:20
                      we explore all the details of ancient

                      Dr Rad 0:23
                      ruins. Everything from the political scandals, the love of ours, the battles waged, and when citizens turn against each other. I’m Dr. Rad.

                      Dr G 0:35
                      And I’m Dr. G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.

                      Dr Rad 0:44
                      Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.

                      Welcome to a brand new episode of the Partial Historians. I am one of your hosts, Dr. Rad.

                      Dr G 1:15
                      And I am one of your other hosts Dr. G. Welcome to the show.

                      Dr Rad 1:21
                      That sounds like there are more to come.

                      Dr G 1:23
                      And you imagine if we expanded our repertoire and brought other people in as hosts? I don’t know if that the vibe would be the same.

                      Dr Rad 1:31
                      No, I don’t think each of us could handle that. We’re already too talkative. To two fabulous. Exactly. Yes. So, Dr. G, I’m so glad to see you. Because it’s been too long since we talked about the history over and from the founding of the city. Why it feels like more than 24 hours.

                      Dr G 1:51
                      I can’t get enough to be honest. And I’m excited to dive in because on the back of where we just wrapped up, which was 431 BCE, and I’m still getting over various mascius being such an incredible dude.

                      Dr Rad 2:08
                      And then disappearing without a trace. Suspicious. I mean, I think we all know what happened to him, but still,

                      Dr G 2:16
                      did it involve stepping maybe

                      Dr Rad 2:19
                      you don’t get to throw a name as fabulous as that out there. Maybe and then not tell me what happened to this man.

                      Dr G 2:25
                      Look, Livy is letting you down right now. I’m sorry.

                      Dr Rad 2:29
                      Well, I mean, Dionysius has disappeared. So you know, glass houses, stones?

                      Dr G 2:35
                      I might not have any sources, but boy, do I have names?

                      Dr Rad 2:39
                      That’s right. Dr. G, let’s do a quick recap. So we’ve given a bit of a hint there about what happened last episode. But where are we up to in the narrative of rooms history last time we spoke?

                      Dr G 2:52
                      Look, as far as I can remember, it was a pretty exciting year full of ups and downs, military prowess by the Romans, everybody heading out down south for a bit of a battle at Mount Algidus and just mayhem generally speaking, I believe there was a dictator could be wrong about that.

                      Dr Rad 3:13
                      There definitely was a dictator.

                      Dr G 3:15
                      I had lots of like little supplementary sources hinting at various things that happened in this year because it was Tubertus as dictator and he was quite an incredible figure. And he’s made it into the history books, partly on the back of a story that we’re not sure can be fully ascribed to him. It might be apocryphal, that involves the killing of his own son for disobeying orders on the battlefield.

                      Dr Rad 3:42
                      Yeah, Postumius Tubertus showed his stuff on the battlefield against the aqueous and the Volscians to great acclaim. And then bit sour for us. Not for the Romans killed his own son. Maybe, maybe not.

                      Dr G 3:57
                      Yeah, yeah, if so: tragic, but also a huge demonstration of Roman virtus, placing the state before anything else.

                      Dr Rad 4:05
                      Exactly. So basically, we left Rome on a bit of a military high, I suppose you could say last episode. Yeah. They’re excited. Yeah, exactly. Which means it’s a perfect time to transition into another year. So I think we’re heading into 430 BC.

                      All right, Dr. G, so it’s 430 BCE. Tell me who’s in charge.

                      Dr G 4:53
                      So it’s a good question. I literally have the names of the consoles and the names of the sensors. And that is almost all I have in terms of source material.

                      Dr Rad 5:06
                      I kind of fake it. Yeah, I kind of fake it and that’s why I thought I’d let you tell me who the magistrates were

                      Dr G 5:11
                      That’s very kind of you. So as you know, Dionysus of Halicarnassus is sadly missing in action is becoming more and more fragmentary, and will soon be completely gone. The Fasti Capitolini is also missing for these years. So we’re relying on some fastI records that are kind of like a little bit of a backup system. This means I’m left with source material like Diodorus Siculus, a little reference from Cicero, and a bit of Festus, which has never really been translated into English, so I had to do a bit of a dodge on the Latin. So

                      Dr Rad 5:48
                      Latin Oh, no.

                      Dr G 5:50
                      I know I used to be alright at Latin. Now it’s just a little bit tricky, but you know, I gave it a whirl. So our consuls for this year. Lucius, in brackets or Gaius Papirius, son of nobody grandson of nobody, Crassus, consul for the second time, apparently, also consul in 436 BCE.

                      Dr Rad 6:15
                      Yeah, they’re amazing. Papirius I remember that

                      Dr G 6:18
                      Papirius Crassus and he’s joined by Lucius. Or Gaius, Julius Vopiscus Iullus . Also a patrician, and was previously military tribune with consular power in 438 for people following the career, like a red hot razor, and was also most famously master of the horse in the previous year to Tubertus himself. So this guy has been elevated from being the master of the horse to the consulship. Fancy, Nancy.

                      Dr Rad 6:55
                      Nice, nice. Now, I believe you mentioned we have some censors as well.

                      Dr G 6:59
                      We do. And I mean, things are gonna get a bit weird with the sensors, I think, as I’m sure you’re about to tell me, but we have Lucius Papirius who sounds like he must be related to Lucius Papirius, the consul. I was like, I don’t think this is the same person. But I also can’t be sure Rome…

                      Dr Rad 7:20
                      I’m not gonna say anything yet. I’m not gonna say any

                      Dr G 7:22
                      Rome and their names we’ve got two Lucius Papirii, what could be going on. And we also have Publius Pinarius as the co-censor. So the job of the censor is count everything up, basically, check how the population is going, look at the distribution of the wealth and so forth. So I guess we’ll see what happens.

                      Dr Rad 7:47
                      We will, we will, I mean, their censorship has been an interesting controversy in this past decade. So it’s interesting that we have sensors named again. Now look, I’m not going to not gonna lie. Livy does not have a huge amount of detail for this year. If I’m not alone, I’m going to say yeah, I’m going to say I think this episode might be a low point for Livy as well, and you’ll see why later on. Not as it is not interesting, but just as in in terms of the depth of the information provided, but well, we’ll get to that. Of course, here we are in 430 BC, and what are the tribune of the plebs pushing for but military tributes with consular power? I think you can already know how that wound up given that you’ve given me the magistrates as consuls.

                      Dr G 8:37
                      Yeah. So they wanted this year to be filled with military treatments with consular power. Is that the idea?

                      Dr Rad 8:43
                      Yeah, they wanted military ship into the consular power but didn’t get there. It seems to be the way to be honest. They seem to lose more often than they win in this battle. So the previous year, as we mentioned, we had some conflict with the Aequians and the Volscians mentioned and the Romans did pretty well in that scenario. In this year the aqueous erstwhile enemies of room sent envoys to the Romans Senate requesting a treaty the Senate come back yes the Senate come back to the aqueous and say, You know what, why don’t you just flat out surrender and say that were awesome and where the man and nobody can be at room?

                      Dr G 9:23
                      Fascinating. Okay, so that’s, that’s not really a treaty. That’s just they’re asking Romans like, rather than a treaty, how about you completely submit to us?

                      Dr Rad 9:32
                      I think that the Romans are doing what I try and do, which is you ask for something that’s more than you want. And then you work your way down.

                      Dr G 9:41
                      I see. I see a great negotiating strategy from the victor of the battle.

                      Dr Rad 9:46
                      Yes, exactly. Anyway, it ends up happening that the Aequians secure an eight year truce with Rome.

                      Dr G 9:54
                      Okay, very specific. We’ll see how that goes. I know

                      Dr Rad 9:57
                      it is very specific, isn’t it? Eight years like why not just and even 10. Guys, just an x.

                      Dr G 10:03
                      I mean they use base 10. They, that’s odd. Okay.

                      Dr Rad 10:07
                      Yeah. Anyway, the Volscians of course, we’re also defeated in this recent military combat that was going on. But internally, they’re now facing division. And to be honest, this I love this because we often find that we end up talking about like, what’s happening in Rome after something big has happened. So it’s kind of nice to get a sneak peek into what apparently is happening for the Volscians. So there are those who want to secure peace with Rome, and those who want to, I think, pursue more war. So they’re kind of arguing amongst themselves, which means Rome is in a very peaceful state, right? There’s not a lot going on.

                      Dr G 10:49
                      Oh, yeah. Well, if the Volscii Aren’t organised, then they probably still mourning the loss of Messius. Well, I did say I kind of like if we can breed them like that maybe we can take the whole place and make it our own.

                      Dr Rad 11:01
                      Who knows. So the Romans turned to what they normally do in peaceful times, which is needless bureaucracy.

                      Dr G 11:09
                      I see the censorship I sense is coming.

                      Dr Rad 11:12
                      Yes, this is where it is coming in. So Livy mentioned that there was a new law introduced regarding the valuation of fines, which was very popular with the people. Now when it actually happened was that the tribune of the plebs were actually putting this law together, and they knew it would go down well with the people. Unfortunately, one of them got a little bit too chatty, loose lips sink, ships strategy. And so the consuls ended up putting forth a law before the tribunes and they get the credit.

                      Dr G 11:43
                      Oh, no. Okay, so distributors come up with a great law, only to have it stolen out from underneath them by the consuls. Fascinating.

                      Dr Rad 11:53
                      Yeah. Now, of course, I had no idea what they were talking about in terms of what this actually involved. I’ve got a little bit of detail on this, I think, okay, I can I can I can say this is where I think Cicero comes in.

                      Dr G 12:05
                      Yeah. Yeah. So Cicero’s sort of jumps in to the to breach the gap, as it were, of all of our the source material. And, you know, he’s spoiling on about a whole bunch of things like Cicero does. But he’s honing in on this moment of the censorship. And he gets the names, right, generally speaking, and he talks about this transfer of the imposition of fines. So and it’s something to do with lightening the final load for people and figuring out how to measure that so that they can distribute the fines appropriately, but also lower their sort of consequence. In effect, it seems like fines are getting out of control, and nobody’s very happy about it. And their choice seems to be to shift a number of cattle out of private ownership and into public ownership. Now, these are two details. And I do not know how they’re related. How does shifting some cows, from private to public ownership actually alleviate the situation with fines? And I think this is related to how they measure wealth. So how they count up somebody’s assets for the censorship test. If the cows are owned by the people, ‘the public’ as it were, rather than by a certain person individually, then that capital doesn’t count to your asset marker. So you’re looking after some cows, but you don’t technically own the cows.

                      Dr Rad 13:42
                      Interesting. Yeah. Well, when I was sort of doing a bit of digging into this, the previous law that was replaced by this law was apparently a local the Lex Aternia Tarpeia, which was introduced in 454 BCE, so not that long ago. And it apparently had set up the conversion rate for fine. So one ox was the equivalent of 10 sheep was the equivalent of 100 pounds of bronze or 100 asses – aw yeah. Give me that booty. Apparently, see, we’re not entirely sure what is happening with this new law. But we think that the conversion rate is what has been made more favourable. And probably because there might have been people who wish to pay in money, rather than in things like cattle, I guess. And so kind of might have ended the optional payment. This is just a theory. This is a set in stone. It might have ended the optional payment and it might mean that all fines had to be paid in money from this point onwards.

                      Dr G 14:51
                      Ah, this might tie in I’m not sure necessarily how, but Festus does suggest In a passage 220, from the Lindsay addition, if anybody’s keen for that, that it was about estimating cattle based on the hundreds within the herd for and then sheep were estimated based on the 10s in the herd. So they came up with a new counting method that allowed them to count less, essentially.

                      Dr Rad 15:22
                      Right. Okay, gotcha. That’s it. It might be there. Yeah, the conversion rate kind of thing. Yeah. Okay. All right. Well, clearly something is going on. It’s getting mathematical. I don’t care for it. Shall we move on to 429 BCE? Because that is all I have.

                      Dr G 15:38
                      You want to end this year on the high note of bovine counting and we’ll leave it at that.

                      Dr Rad 15:43
                      I think I’d like to I’d like to leave the cows behind. Let’s move on.

                      Dr G 15:51
                      Or as the case may be, all right, well, that wraps up what a year to be in Rome.

                      Dr Rad 16:21
                      Okay, 429 BCE. Tell me what you got Dr. G.

                      Dr G 16:24
                      Well, no surprise Dionysius of Halicarnassus is missing.

                      Dr Rad 16:30
                      I had a hunch. I had a hunch. I’ve learned from history.

                      Dr G 16:36
                      I think I have even less source material for 429 that I did for 430. Which is kind of a abysmal, because all I’ve got is the consul names. And a little snippet from Diodorus Siculus. Who as we know, tries his best, but is often a little bit confused. So I mean, I’ll take you through it. We have as our consuls, apparently Hostus Lucretius Tricipitinus, so I hate that name. Tri-cip-i-tinus, yeah. And Lucius Sergius Fidenas. And he’s consul for the second time previously consul in 437. And also previously and a little bit more recently, military tribute with consular power in 433. They’re the only magistrates I’ve got names for for this year.

                      Dr Rad 17:33
                      I don’t have any other magistrates either. So strap yourself in this is what Livy tells me happened in 429. Nothing? Nothing happened.

                      Dr G 17:45
                      What now?

                      Dr Rad 17:46
                      Yeah, no, not as in not as in he’s missing like Dionysius, as in, he actually is there. And he just says, Look, nothing happened. So let’s just move straight onto 428.

                      Dr G 17:56
                      Oh, incredible stuff. Livy. I mean, he loves to talk, I can’t believe we found nothing on this time period at all. Well, that means my source becomes very handy. Diodorus Siculus you back in the mix, buddy. So the thing with Diodorus Siculus. And it’s been going on for a while in his narrative is that there is a about a 10 year discrepancy or more between the things he tells us and when they happened, and how they might line up with when the Roman say that they happened in Rome. So the annalists may be a little bit out in their count, Diodorus might be a little bit out in his count. But the thing that he’s giving us that the Romans aren’t giving us yet is he’s lining things up according to the Athenian dating system, the eponymous Archon in Athens, and generally speaking historians feel pretty confident about those dates. So it’s a bit problematic for all of the Roman writers like Livy to be like, it’s 429 when Diodorus is like it’s 422. We got some missing years somewhere in there something has happened. But the thing that redeems the Roman analysts and where Diodorus then immediately lets himself down as he gets everybody’s names slightly wrong. So

                      Dr Rad 18:15
                      It doesn’t bode well.

                      Dr G 18:26
                      No, it’s not great. I feel like he’s probably maybe okay on numbers, but he’s not great on his source material. So there’s a lot going on. He says the consuls for this year are Opiter Lucretius, ‘Opiter’ being a name that we’ve never heard of as a praenomen, so nice try, but probably wrong. And then Lucius Sergius Fideniates which is very close. Yeah, very close. He’s just gotten the last one a little bit a little bit smooshed up.

                      Dr Rad 19:51
                      Yeah, but I’m not giving him a cigar.

                      Dr G 19:53
                      Yeah, but maybe you overheard at a dinner party. You know, I feel like that’s the Diodorus Siculus way where it’s like somebody’s saying the names to him when he’s writing them down. He looks at his notes later. And he’s like, What did I even put there? Yes. For the manuscripts.

                      Dr Rad 20:06
                      Yeah. Look, I agree. Certainly there have been modern academics that have suggested that actually, if we, we probably should shift events around a little bit. And there probably was stuff happening in this year. But just in the version of Livy that we have the way that Livy chose to record things, it seems like a very dull year, indeed.

                      Dr G 20:28
                      Nothing to report a living well, well, well,

                      Dr Rad 20:33
                      I think we’re gonna go for a record. That means we’re on tour 428 BCE. Oh, we’re speeding through thing I know, people will think we’ve had a stroke,

                      Dr G 20:43
                      Dear listeners, calm yourselves. It’s a whole new year again.

                      Dr Rad 21:10
                      Now, this is a bit of a confusing year, as far as magistrates are concerned.

                      Dr G 21:14
                      This is very confusing. Yeah. And we’ve got some, there’s a whole bunch of potential issues here. So for instance, one of the things that I was holding on to for a long time, and I think I flagged in many episodes prior to now is that Dionysius of Halicarnassus kicks back in about 428. But I think I was mistaken about that. Having read what is there in the source material, in preparation for this episode, I was like, wait a minute, that doesn’t sound like 428 to me at all. So some minor revisions might have to take place.

                      Dr Rad 21:56
                      That’s all right, wait, as long as we know that, we’re going to briefly catch a glimpse of him again one day, that’s all we need to know right now.

                      Dr G 22:03
                      He shall return – not in his full glory – but he’ll be back limping across the finish line in his fragments. So we have two sets of consuls. In this year, as far as I’m aware we’ve got which means we have to divide them up between the consul ordinarii, the ones who named the year and the consul suffectii the ones who sort of fill in, in the back catalogue. But I also have and this is where Broughton, bless his soul is always so helpful. Also knows that there is a special commission in this. Yeah. And there’s a bunch of people involved in the special commission. So we’ve got plenty of names, even if we’re not really quite sure. What is going on.

                      Dr Rad 22:47
                      I think I can help you with that maybe actually does provide me with some detail this year. So why don’t why don’t you tell me who the magistrates are and then I’ll try and fill in the blanks.

                      Dr G 22:55
                      All right, this this sounds good to me. It’s a deal. It’s a deal. So our first consul is Aulus Cornelius Cossus.

                      Dr Rad 23:05
                      Not the most handsome man in the world.

                      Dr G 23:10
                      You may remember him, dear listeners, for being awesome. In 437, where you may have first encountered him, he was merely a military tribune. But this year, he’s actually a consul.

                      Dr Rad 23:25
                      Nice.

                      Dr G 23:26
                      So you know, I mean, I don’t know what he’s been doing for the last 10 years, but I’m gonna assume he’s even more handsome than before.

                      Dr Rad 23:33
                      Absolutely handsome men don’t need to work hard for political office.

                      Dr G 23:37
                      I wouldn’t assume so especially when women have the vote. Oh, wait. And then we also have Titus Quinctius Poenas Cincinnatus. Another quite familiar name at this point is this is his second bite at the consular cherry previously consul in 431 and also most likely one of the sons with a very famous Cincinnatus.

                      Dr Rad 24:03
                      I weas gonna say he’s not THE Cincinnatus.

                      Dr G 24:06
                      No. Poenas Cincinnatus is one of the sons of the very famous twice dictator Cincinnatus for those tuning in from Cincinnati and possibly also the younger brother of Lucis Quinctius Cincinnatus who has exactly the same name as the great man himself, so very confusing. So those two are consuls. Then apparently we have another two sets of consuls and that would involve Lucius Quinctius Cincinnatus.

                      Dr Rad 24:39
                      Right.

                      Dr G 24:39
                      The brother

                      Dr Rad 24:41
                      Just to makes things even more confusing. Yeah.

                      Dr G 24:44
                      Two Cincinnatuses consul in the same year.

                      Dr Rad 24:47
                      Did that make them a Cincinnati?

                      Dr G 24:49
                      I think it does. I think I think we’ve reached the Cincinnati moment. It’s finally happened and also Aulus Sempronius Atratinus.

                      Dr Rad 25:01
                      We’ve heard that name before.

                      Dr G 25:04
                      Yeah, I mean, it sounds vaguely familiar to me. But I haven’t written any notes on that. So I have not done my due diligence with that guy.

                      Dr Rad 25:10
                      Now, I think I don’t think it’s necessarily the same person. But I do remember that name of Atratinus. And of course, Sempronius. I mean, the Sempronii are going to pop up again and again.

                      Dr G 25:23
                      They are going to have a long legacy as patrician family.

                      Dr Rad 25:26
                      Yeah.

                      Dr G 25:27
                      So that’s our two pairs of consuls. Then we head into our special commission, and I’m excited to learn about what this special commission might be all about. But it involves at least three people. Lucius Sergius Fidenas, who cropped up in the previous year as consul. Quintus Servilius Priscus Fidenas. So, two Fideni in there.

                      Dr Rad 25:54
                      Yeah.

                      Dr G 25:54
                      And Mamercus Aemilius Mamercinus, who we also have previously seen was a military tribute with consular power in 438. And also seems to been appointed to investigate the participation of the Fidenates in the raids led by Veii

                      Dr Rad 26:19
                      Yeah, so that’s what I’m going to fill in a little bit for you. So let’s get to it. Okay, so we’ve got our consuls of Cossus, who, as you mentioned, was our ridiculously good looking tribune who managed to defeat an Etruscan King on the battlefield had the whole spolia opima thing going on for him which nobody, but Romulus had managed to do so what a consul. And then we also have Titus Quinctius Poenas Cincinnatus, as you said, now, what starts to happen under their consulship is that the people of Veii start to make moves on Roman territory. A common tale, we have talked about the fact that this time period as much as it seems to be filled with these awesome Hollywood blockbuster epic battles, really seems to be this constant kneeling of Rome and its neighbours and they’re constantly trying to get each other’s territory and steal each other’s stuff. I mean, honestly, it feels a bit like kindergarten sometimes, Dr. G. Now is also rumoured, as you just mentioned that some of the young men from Fidenae were in on these raids. Okay, we’re taking part. Lest we forget, the Romans aren’t feeling really great about Fidenae right now do you want to remind us why?

                      Dr G 27:40
                      There seems to be a bit of a problem. So in the history of Fidenae, it starts out as a Roman colony that seems to be it’s how it comes into being. So the Romans always consider it theirs. And it’s actually a really strategic anchor point to the slight north of Rome, because it sits on the same side of the Tiber as Rome. And this means that they’ve got a sort of like a defence in the north, that allows them to sort of feel more at ease about where their enemies might be coming at them from. Problem for Rome is that the Fidemae populace decides that they’re not having anything to do with Rome anymore, and they decide to throw in their lot with the Etruscans, which makes a lot of sense, the Etruscans are really quite close. They are a much more numerous people. And if you were looking at a side by side comparison of who you should ally with at in this time period, you’ve got Rome, a single city, a little outpost, run by a bunch of gangsters, versus the Etruscans, who have centuries of history in the region, and a full 12 member kingship going on, there is a lot of power and a lot of history there. They’re well embedded in their power structures. So it makes sense that a reasonable offer might have been made to Fidenae and they fluttered their eyelashes at they and said, well yes, of course we’d love to join you. And Veii and the Etruscans now have a strategic position to filter into Rome from a side that they are not usually able to approach the city from.

                      Dr Rad 29:26
                      Strategically important. Absolutely. So obviously, they have a bitter taste in the room, his mouth and I’m going to tolerate these rumours that are going on there like look, it’s one thing for today like we expect it from Veii, but Fidenae after everything we’ve just been through, I don’t know think so. So as you mentioned, a special commission is set up I feel like we need to have some some cry music Don’t Don’t do too. And so we got Lucius Sergius, Quintus Servilius and Mamercus Aemilius according to Livy who are putting in charge of looking into these rumours, and some men could not account for their whereabouts at the time in question. So I’m definitely putting the Law and Order vibes right now.

                      Dr G 30:12
                      You don’t have an alibi. Why? No, sir. I was sleeping in the field.

                      Dr Rad 30:17
                      Yeah, they were away from Fidenae. And they but where were they? Who could vouch for their whereabouts? Nobody. That’s who. So they are banished to Ostia.

                      Dr G 30:26
                      I mean, that’s pretty disappointing that they couldn’t even get a friend to lie for them.

                      Dr Rad 30:32
                      It would seem to be pretty easy back in this day and age but it’s not like they’re battling you know, CCTV and mobile phones cell tower was pinging all around. Nonetheless, the goats were quiet that day. And nobody could say where they were. They’re banished to Ostia. And I guess Rome is also starting to think about, hmm, what can we do with this whole Fidenae situation? Because clearly, they’re still not really on board with this whole idea of being allied with the most awesome city state in all of Italy. Not that it’s known as Italy right now, but hey. So they decided they’re going to send more settlers and establish what not establish a colony, but reinforce the colony at feed name. And so they take land from the property of people who had died. And they give it to the new colonists. So they’re sort of trying to, you know, set them up.

                      Dr G 31:27
                      Okay, so they shift some things around like, yeah, it’s an offworld opportunity.

                      Dr Rad 31:33
                      Some creative accounting.

                      Dr G 31:34
                      Yeah, it’s gonna be very exciting for you here, take this stuff. Yeah, I think the other thing that might be said for this year is this is the year that Cossus holds the consulship. So for some scholars, and it would make sense to go down this path, this is actually the year where the king of Veii, Lars Tolumnius, is met in battle and is slain directly by Cossus.

                      Dr Rad 32:03
                      Okay, see, I have that a little bit later in some of the stuff I’ve written. So definitely the fact that he’s consulship. Now is Yeah, definitely.

                      Dr G 32:11
                      This is yeah, this is one of the candidates is going to pop up. This is going to crop up again.

                      Dr Rad 32:16
                      And of course, we’ve also got Mamercus Aemilius too. Yeah. also has those connotations. So yes, this is one of the candidates, but I definitely with my Livy narrative, because you know, Livy is my man. I’m going to plump for a bit later on. But anyway, so we’ve got to colony set up at Fidenae. And then of course, it’s been far too peaceful. And Disney-like for too long, Dr. G, a drought hits are really, really bad drought.

                      Dr G 32:16
                      I see. Okay, I think these things might crop up in a slightly different year for me. So we’ll, we’ll see, we’ll keep going.

                      Dr Rad 32:54
                      Okay.

                      Dr G 32:55
                      I’m interested.

                      Dr Rad 32:55
                      So Livy tells me that it’s not just the fact that it’s not raining very much, which is part of the problem, but also what he calls perennial streams, do not have enough water. So I think that probably means that obviously, where people would normally locate their water, it’s, you know, they don’t usually have any problems from the sources that are drained from from the ground. They’re also drying up.

                      Dr G 33:19
                      Yeah, yeah. So creeks and small rivers are also dry. Yes, it’s bad time.

                      Dr Rad 33:25
                      Yeah, exactly. Now, of course, when we don’t have enough water, what happens? People start to die. So basically, the cattle the first today, so they start dying, and you’d find them sort of strewn all around these dried up water sources where they would normally go to get a drink. And they’re also starting to die from mange, which is still a disease that can afflict various animals these days. But basically, it’s some sort of skin condition, which is caused by these parasitic microscopic mites. And what ends up happening is when you’ve got all this drought, people are suffering, cattle are suffering, cattle are dying, cattle are diseased, sure enough, our disease spreads from the cattle to the Roman people. So at first, you start to see people who are living in more rural areas and slaves starting to die, but then also it spreads into the city. And it’s obviously again, I mean, it feels like only yesterday we were talking about a bad sickness in Rome, but it seems like once again, the Romans are really suffering badly.

                      Dr G 34:28
                      Yeah, I think we would have to assume that if we’re in a situation of this kind of drought, we’re looking at years of consequence, not just a single year, like in order to be in a situation where usual water sources are actually dry. This is an ongoing drought that’s been happening for some time and it’s now getting quite severe.

                      Dr Rad 34:51
                      Absolutely. Now, the people because they are suffering so badly, they start getting desperate and what In terms foreign superstitions become very popular, and other people in room are starting to take advantage of the situation, presumably to, like make not money like cash, I would presume, but presumably to earn some sort of financial gain or to win influence with people. So some people are pretending to be seers. So sort of taking advantage of that superstitious state desperate state that people are in. And they start talking the room and people into adopting new types of beliefs and weird ways of sacrificing, and it’s happening in their homes, the leading citizens start to notice that it’s spreading everywhere. And that there are just like strange sacrifices happening all over the city, because the people just, they can’t help but think that they’ve done something to upset the gods, and that the only way that they’re going to make it right is if they figure out, you know, what’s the right offering? What’s the right sacrifice? How can I possibly, you know, restore the balance between our people and the gods. So it seems to be getting out of hand, I’m gonna unpack what this all means in a second. Eventually, the angels are put in charge of ensuring that everyone returns to normal, and I’m using my flesh rabbits religious practices, and that they return to only worshipping Roman gods in a Roman way, God dammit.

                      Dr G 36:25
                      I see. I mean, it makes a lot of sense that things like this would happen. And it is also quite interesting that the Roman response to this would, is not that sort of expansive, inclusive sort of approach that we see much later in Rome, where they, they really do just sort of absorb and embrace and adapt different modes of worship into their own way of doing things. There seems to be like a distinct moment of crisis, in terms of like ritual practice, brought about by environmental crisis.

                      Dr Rad 37:00
                      Yes, absolutely. And I think we can sympathise with that these days, even though it might not necessarily be an environmental crisis, although it might be. We see people in tough times these days, often, that’s the moment that they find some sort of faith because you know, when push comes to shove, and you’re desperate, you might look for answers in places you haven’t considered before. Now, that’s not to say that the Romans haven’t considered being religious for for all, but they just might be looking in into new gods. Now.

                      Dr G 37:28
                      Well, certainly if the rituals that they’ve been performing, haven’t done the trick, and the drought is getting worse, then it would be a reasonable thing to assume that maybe there’s something wrong with the ritual practice.

                      Dr Rad 37:40
                      Yes. So looking at how academics have interpreted what Livy is saying here, because he doesn’t give me any specifics about exactly what kind of practices and that sort of thing, it seems to be assumed that he’s referring to the cult of Apollo. So you might have forgotten, but in 431, they dedicated a temple to Apolo, when we’re suffering from that really terrible plague, it actually been vowed in for 33. But it wasn’t until first 431 that the temple was, you know, up and running. And so it might be something to do with that,

                      Dr G 38:19
                      Somebody built it wrong. You gotta gotta take that down.

                      Dr Rad 38:23
                      Well, it might just made it that was like, you know, the new cult on the block. Oh, yeah. So it might be that there is something like that going on. It’s possible. That’s what they’re referring to. And it won’t be the last time that we see this kind of outbreak of extreme. Well, what the room is sore is like more extreme or superstitious practices, like people getting a bit caught up in things, we’re gonna see this again, when we get to the years of like the Second Punic War and that sort of thing. Now that we’ve isolated Yeah, the final weird thing I’m going to note is that we of course, have the seemingly plebeian aediles. Now, it’s not explicit that this is who they are, but possibly, it’s the plebeian aediles who have been put in charge with restoring everything to rights, which might not seem to add up at first, if we think about the kinds of functions that the aediles serve later on in Rome’s history where they’re more concerned with, I suppose, more prosaic matters of life rather than religious beliefs. But for this earlier period, it does seem that there is potentially a connection for them where there is that sort of religious aspects obviously there I mean, all magistrates obviously, it’s not like in the modern day where you have a real separation between politics and religion. Obviously, all magistrates are going to be involved in religious practices somehow, whether it’s the rights they have to carry out or whatever, but But we’ve seen also that it seems like the Aidells were the ones put in charge of the publishing of the 12 Tables, they also possibly were overseeing senatorial records and making sure that they were kept at this point in time. And they therefore might have been seen as valid people to be overseeing how people are observing their religion, I suppose. And that, yeah, they have this sort of religious aspect to their role.

                      Dr G 40:32
                      Interesting, very interesting. So we’ve had this mention of aediles, we don’t know, we don’t have any names.

                      Dr Rad 40:41
                      We do not. We didn’t know. And then so this is all speculation, we don’t really know what’s going on here. We don’t have enough detail. And it’s not that they’re trying to wipe out the cult of Apollo. They’re just trying to make sure that it doesn’t get excessive. And there is a balance between what and who the Romans are worshipping.

                      Dr G 41:01
                      And there’s also the broader question of like, what’s going on with like, the demarcation of responsibility here. So we have had previous years before now where we’ve known who the Pontifex Maximus is, yes. And it doesn’t happen very often in this early period. But they have been mentioned. And we also get this sense, particularly from very early on, definitely pre Republic, that there are a whole bunch of really quite significant priesthoods that are already in existence, such as the fetiales, such as a whole bunch of sort of priests to Jupiter, priests to Mars, the pontificates as a college, augers. And so the idea that it is in this moment, that the responsibility is delegated to the aediles to try and sort out this issue does raise some questions

                      Dr Rad 42:08
                      It does. And as I say, it’s just a theory. But I think it’s, it does sort of highlight that. We honestly can’t say a lot for certain about a lot of people’s positions at this point in time. It’s not that they are they’re not obviously a pretty straight as you’re saying they’re not a pretty soon, as you say it’s more that something’s been delegated to them, and that they might have been seen as the kind of people that were able to oversee something like this,

                      Dr G 42:32
                      The idea that this could fall within their remit somehow,

                      Dr Rad 42:36
                      Potentially, but again, like I think it just sort of even even if this is just a theory, it’s just once again, a reminder that we really know so little about exactly what being a consul this period, you know,

                      Dr G 42:47
                      well, yes. And I think, I mean, it’s worth noting that often, this has been simplified as well, like when we talk about consuls in this period, we’re not even sure that they’re called ‘consul’.

                      Dr Rad 42:57
                      Exactly. That’s the question marks and it’s just sort of highlights that if you look up what an aedile does, this would probably not be something that I think they would normally associated with when you get later in Rome’s history.

                      Dr G 43:10
                      Yeah, and we’re in this period where things nothing is solid. Uncertainty is high. Yes. I think unless you have other details this might be the place to wrap up this episode.

                      Dr Rad 43:24
                      That is all I have. But I will say that some of the details that I’ve just given you are going to come back in the most major way you have no idea or maybe you do I don’t know if Dionysius is kicked back in or not but the next episode some of these little seeds that are planted they’re going to flower into something horrible.

                      Dr G 43:42
                      Oh, I can’t wait to find out well and well if you share your story with me I’ll let you know what I discovered.

                      Dr Rad 43:50
                      All right, Dr. G, that means it is once again time for the Partial Pick

                      all right, Dr. G, so this is the point where we sum up Well normally the year that was but in this case it’s the three years that we’re and we rate room out of five different categories and in each of those categories, they have the potential to score 10 Golden Eagles Something tells me it’s going to be rough today.

                      Dr G 44:23
                      Yeah, like in a year where nothing happened well all right, so let’s see how they do the first category is military clout

                      Dr Rad 44:34
                      Nope that to stick really

                      Dr G 44:39
                      I couldn’t fight I had the mange

                      Dr Rad 44:43
                      Yep, so that’s that’s this year. So what’s our next category diplomacy. Okay, well, there’s a little bit of that going on here. We’ve got the truce with the aqueous that’s true

                      Dr G 44:53
                      and they did negotiate some people out of feed and a get you there get you to Ostia will bring it A pack of robots to replace you. I mean, they could be seen as diplomatic. For the

                      Dr Rad 45:05
                      Romans. I think that is diplomatic. They didn’t just outright kill them. Not Yeah. Nice. Yeah. So what, like four or five? I mean, it’s not that impressive.

                      Dr G 45:16
                      Well, I feel like yeah, the diplomacy with feed and a doesn’t count for much. I don’t think that’s maybe a one. But actually coming to it. You truce with the aliens and the volsky. I that actually does sound pretty. Oh, okay. The moleskin is under the bus like that. I retract I retract the A quien treaty. Yeah, true. So I should say so the treaty a truce for eight years? Yeah. Yeah, look, I’m gonna give them about a five.

                      Dr Rad 45:48
                      Okay, so we’ll give them a five. Alright, so we’ve got five what’s our next category?

                      Dr G 45:51
                      Expansion? No.

                      Dr Rad 45:54
                      Fear while I feel

                      Dr G 45:56
                      it’s hard to expand under these conditions, they’re being pressed from all sides.

                      Dr Rad 46:00
                      They are and from and internally the cows.

                      Dr G 46:07
                      Sorry, I was like being pressed internally, I went somewhere else. We’re tourists

                      Dr Rad 46:14
                      can’t say that I do.

                      Dr G 46:17
                      That a lot of winters going on. No specific examples come to mind. They’re just they’re doing things but uh, and citizen score.

                      Dr Rad 46:27
                      Look, for the first few years that we talked about the fact that there’s a lot of peace that nothing is happening.

                      Dr G 46:33
                      There’s fines being alleviated? I mean, it all sounds pretty good. Really.

                      Dr Rad 46:37
                      That’s pretty good. It’s just unfortunately, we’ve bundled it together with this hideous route, which makes everyone really suffer and makes them ill. Yeah. So it’s gonna be balanced out. I think maybe maybe like a four

                      Dr G 46:53
                      points for reduced fines, taking your way points for the mange

                      Dr Rad 46:58
                      given that we’re not really entirely sure exactly. What that whole fine business involved. It’s all very speculative. I’m

                      Dr G 47:06
                      assuming it benefits the rich more than it benefits the blue bands. But I could be wrong about that. We have

                      Dr Rad 47:13
                      talked a lot with the people. So I’m presuming it was actually to their benefit and don’t don’t

                      Dr G 47:19
                      look for something into things that haven’t been good for them before.

                      Dr Rad 47:23
                      This is true. But the fact that Libby says the tributes of the collapse were the ones that are originally coming up with it. And then the console stole their idea. And

                      Dr G 47:32
                      maybe, well, maybe a four then as you say,

                      Dr Rad 47:37
                      Okay, well that actually you know what, it’s better than I thought although not great when you consider it three years rolled into one cart with a total of nine golden eagles. Dr. G.

                      Dr G 47:48
                      Wow, Rome, you’ve really excelled?

                      Dr Rad 47:53
                      Yeah, yeah. Definitely have Hey, you know what, there? It’s definitely better than some of the other years we’ve dealt with in the 40s. I thought that the December it was a bad period, but actually the full 30s have been rough.

                      Dr G 48:07
                      They have I mean, between like the absence of source material and just like hit after hit to the Roman psyche. It’s been a tough time.

                      Dr Rad 48:17
                      Well, that’s a G, there’s no one I would rather talk about nothing. We’re

                      Dr G 48:23
                      gonna take that as a compliment.

                      Dr Rad 48:25
                      Absolutely. Join us next time for the podcast about nothing. Oh,

                      Dr G 48:30
                      from the foundation to nothing.

                      Dr Rad 48:44
                      Thank you for listening to this episode of the partial historians. You can find our sources, sound credits and automated transcripts in our show notes. You too can support our show and help us to produce more intriguing content about the ancient world by becoming a Patreon. In return, you receive exclusive early access to our special episodes. Today, we’d like to give a special shout out to some of our newest Patreon, Daniel, Nicole, Vincent and Michael. There are other ways that you can support our show. We have merchandise a collaboration with Bridget Clark on Gumroad. And we now also have a book and you can find all the details of that on the highlands press website as well as our website if you’d like to purchase a copy of Rex, the seven kings of Rome, our popular history. However, if you are travel short of denari, we would massively appreciate it. If you told someone about the show. That kind of recommendation is worth its weight in gold. Until next time, we are yours in ancient Rome.

                      Hey, Dr. G, would you know what to do if a fella started floating in the fire before you?

                      Dr G 50:29
                      Probably not?

                      Dr Rad 50:32
                      Well, then have I got the book for you? Did you know that we wrote a book?

                      Dr G 50:37
                      What we wrote a book? No way.

                      Dr Rad 50:39
                      I think we wrote a book. Yeah, absolutely. We read a book and it’s called Rex, The Seven Kings of Rome.

                      Dr G 50:47
                      Oh, that’s right. The details are starting to come back to me now. Yes, yes, the Regal period. What a time for the Romans to be alive. And also what a time for historians to revisit and to consider the source material.

                      Dr Rad 51:00
                      Absolutely. So if you’re interested in picking up a copy of our popular history of the Roman monarchy, please head over to the highlands press website.

                      Dr G 51:10
                      That’s Highlands, Dash press.com (

                      Dr Rad 0:17
                      Welcome to the Partial Historians,

                      Dr G 0:20
                      we explore all the details of ancient

                      Dr Rad 0:23
                      ruins. Everything from the political scandals, the love of ours, the battles waged, and when citizens turn against each other. I’m Dr. Rad.

                      Dr G 0:35
                      And I’m Dr. G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.

                      Dr Rad 0:44
                      Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.

                      Welcome to a brand new episode of the Partial Historians. I am one of your hosts, Dr. Rad.

                      Dr G 1:15
                      And I am one of your other hosts Dr. G. Welcome to the show.

                      Dr Rad 1:21
                      That sounds like there are more to come.

                      Dr G 1:23
                      And you imagine if we expanded our repertoire and brought other people in as hosts? I don’t know if that the vibe would be the same.

                      Dr Rad 1:31
                      No, I don’t think each of us could handle that. We’re already too talkative. To two fabulous. Exactly. Yes. So, Dr. G, I’m so glad to see you. Because it’s been too long since we talked about the history over and from the founding of the city. Why it feels like more than 24 hours.

                      Dr G 1:51
                      I can’t get enough to be honest. And I’m excited to dive in because on the back of where we just wrapped up, which was 431 BCE, and I’m still getting over various mascius being such an incredible dude.

                      Dr Rad 2:08
                      And then disappearing without a trace. Suspicious. I mean, I think we all know what happened to him, but still,

                      Dr G 2:16
                      did it involve stepping maybe

                      Dr Rad 2:19
                      you don’t get to throw a name as fabulous as that out there. Maybe and then not tell me what happened to this man.

                      Dr G 2:25
                      Look, Livy is letting you down right now. I’m sorry.

                      Dr Rad 2:29
                      Well, I mean, Dionysius has disappeared. So you know, glass houses, stones?

                      Dr G 2:35
                      I might not have any sources, but boy, do I have names?

                      Dr Rad 2:39
                      That’s right. Dr. G, let’s do a quick recap. So we’ve given a bit of a hint there about what happened last episode. But where are we up to in the narrative of rooms history last time we spoke?

                      Dr G 2:52
                      Look, as far as I can remember, it was a pretty exciting year full of ups and downs, military prowess by the Romans, everybody heading out down south for a bit of a battle at Mount Algidus and just mayhem generally speaking, I believe there was a dictator could be wrong about that.

                      Dr Rad 3:13
                      There definitely was a dictator.

                      Dr G 3:15
                      I had lots of like little supplementary sources hinting at various things that happened in this year because it was Tubertus as dictator and he was quite an incredible figure. And he’s made it into the history books, partly on the back of a story that we’re not sure can be fully ascribed to him. It might be apocryphal, that involves the killing of his own son for disobeying orders on the battlefield.

                      Dr Rad 3:42
                      Yeah, Postumius Tubertus showed his stuff on the battlefield against the aqueous and the Volscians to great acclaim. And then bit sour for us. Not for the Romans killed his own son. Maybe, maybe not.

                      Dr G 3:57
                      Yeah, yeah, if so: tragic, but also a huge demonstration of Roman virtus, placing the state before anything else.

                      Dr Rad 4:05
                      Exactly. So basically, we left Rome on a bit of a military high, I suppose you could say last episode. Yeah. They’re excited. Yeah, exactly. Which means it’s a perfect time to transition into another year. So I think we’re heading into 430 BC.

                      All right, Dr. G, so it’s 430 BCE. Tell me who’s in charge.

                      Dr G 4:53
                      So it’s a good question. I literally have the names of the consoles and the names of the sensors. And that is almost all I have in terms of source material.

                      Dr Rad 5:06
                      I kind of fake it. Yeah, I kind of fake it and that’s why I thought I’d let you tell me who the magistrates were

                      Dr G 5:11
                      That’s very kind of you. So as you know, Dionysus of Halicarnassus is sadly missing in action is becoming more and more fragmentary, and will soon be completely gone. The Fasti Capitolini is also missing for these years. So we’re relying on some fastI records that are kind of like a little bit of a backup system. This means I’m left with source material like Diodorus Siculus, a little reference from Cicero, and a bit of Festus, which has never really been translated into English, so I had to do a bit of a dodge on the Latin. So

                      Dr Rad 5:48
                      Latin Oh, no.

                      Dr G 5:50
                      I know I used to be alright at Latin. Now it’s just a little bit tricky, but you know, I gave it a whirl. So our consuls for this year. Lucius, in brackets or Gaius Papirius, son of nobody grandson of nobody, Crassus, consul for the second time, apparently, also consul in 436 BCE.

                      Dr Rad 6:15
                      Yeah, they’re amazing. Papirius I remember that

                      Dr G 6:18
                      Papirius Crassus and he’s joined by Lucius. Or Gaius, Julius Vopiscus Iullus . Also a patrician, and was previously military tribune with consular power in 438 for people following the career, like a red hot razor, and was also most famously master of the horse in the previous year to Tubertus himself. So this guy has been elevated from being the master of the horse to the consulship. Fancy, Nancy.

                      Dr Rad 6:55
                      Nice, nice. Now, I believe you mentioned we have some censors as well.

                      Dr G 6:59
                      We do. And I mean, things are gonna get a bit weird with the sensors, I think, as I’m sure you’re about to tell me, but we have Lucius Papirius who sounds like he must be related to Lucius Papirius, the consul. I was like, I don’t think this is the same person. But I also can’t be sure Rome…

                      Dr Rad 7:20
                      I’m not gonna say anything yet. I’m not gonna say any

                      Dr G 7:22
                      Rome and their names we’ve got two Lucius Papirii, what could be going on. And we also have Publius Pinarius as the co-censor. So the job of the censor is count everything up, basically, check how the population is going, look at the distribution of the wealth and so forth. So I guess we’ll see what happens.

                      Dr Rad 7:47
                      We will, we will, I mean, their censorship has been an interesting controversy in this past decade. So it’s interesting that we have sensors named again. Now look, I’m not going to not gonna lie. Livy does not have a huge amount of detail for this year. If I’m not alone, I’m going to say yeah, I’m going to say I think this episode might be a low point for Livy as well, and you’ll see why later on. Not as it is not interesting, but just as in in terms of the depth of the information provided, but well, we’ll get to that. Of course, here we are in 430 BC, and what are the tribune of the plebs pushing for but military tributes with consular power? I think you can already know how that wound up given that you’ve given me the magistrates as consuls.

                      Dr G 8:37
                      Yeah. So they wanted this year to be filled with military treatments with consular power. Is that the idea?

                      Dr Rad 8:43
                      Yeah, they wanted military ship into the consular power but didn’t get there. It seems to be the way to be honest. They seem to lose more often than they win in this battle. So the previous year, as we mentioned, we had some conflict with the Aequians and the Volscians mentioned and the Romans did pretty well in that scenario. In this year the aqueous erstwhile enemies of room sent envoys to the Romans Senate requesting a treaty the Senate come back yes the Senate come back to the aqueous and say, You know what, why don’t you just flat out surrender and say that were awesome and where the man and nobody can be at room?

                      Dr G 9:23
                      Fascinating. Okay, so that’s, that’s not really a treaty. That’s just they’re asking Romans like, rather than a treaty, how about you completely submit to us?

                      Dr Rad 9:32
                      I think that the Romans are doing what I try and do, which is you ask for something that’s more than you want. And then you work your way down.

                      Dr G 9:41
                      I see. I see a great negotiating strategy from the victor of the battle.

                      Dr Rad 9:46
                      Yes, exactly. Anyway, it ends up happening that the Aequians secure an eight year truce with Rome.

                      Dr G 9:54
                      Okay, very specific. We’ll see how that goes. I know

                      Dr Rad 9:57
                      it is very specific, isn’t it? Eight years like why not just and even 10. Guys, just an x.

                      Dr G 10:03
                      I mean they use base 10. They, that’s odd. Okay.

                      Dr Rad 10:07
                      Yeah. Anyway, the Volscians of course, we’re also defeated in this recent military combat that was going on. But internally, they’re now facing division. And to be honest, this I love this because we often find that we end up talking about like, what’s happening in Rome after something big has happened. So it’s kind of nice to get a sneak peek into what apparently is happening for the Volscians. So there are those who want to secure peace with Rome, and those who want to, I think, pursue more war. So they’re kind of arguing amongst themselves, which means Rome is in a very peaceful state, right? There’s not a lot going on.

                      Dr G 10:49
                      Oh, yeah. Well, if the Volscii Aren’t organised, then they probably still mourning the loss of Messius. Well, I did say I kind of like if we can breed them like that maybe we can take the whole place and make it our own.

                      Dr Rad 11:01
                      Who knows. So the Romans turned to what they normally do in peaceful times, which is needless bureaucracy.

                      Dr G 11:09
                      I see the censorship I sense is coming.

                      Dr Rad 11:12
                      Yes, this is where it is coming in. So Livy mentioned that there was a new law introduced regarding the valuation of fines, which was very popular with the people. Now when it actually happened was that the tribune of the plebs were actually putting this law together, and they knew it would go down well with the people. Unfortunately, one of them got a little bit too chatty, loose lips sink, ships strategy. And so the consuls ended up putting forth a law before the tribunes and they get the credit.

                      Dr G 11:43
                      Oh, no. Okay, so distributors come up with a great law, only to have it stolen out from underneath them by the consuls. Fascinating.

                      Dr Rad 11:53
                      Yeah. Now, of course, I had no idea what they were talking about in terms of what this actually involved. I’ve got a little bit of detail on this, I think, okay, I can I can I can say this is where I think Cicero comes in.

                      Dr G 12:05
                      Yeah. Yeah. So Cicero’s sort of jumps in to the to breach the gap, as it were, of all of our the source material. And, you know, he’s spoiling on about a whole bunch of things like Cicero does. But he’s honing in on this moment of the censorship. And he gets the names, right, generally speaking, and he talks about this transfer of the imposition of fines. So and it’s something to do with lightening the final load for people and figuring out how to measure that so that they can distribute the fines appropriately, but also lower their sort of consequence. In effect, it seems like fines are getting out of control, and nobody’s very happy about it. And their choice seems to be to shift a number of cattle out of private ownership and into public ownership. Now, these are two details. And I do not know how they’re related. How does shifting some cows, from private to public ownership actually alleviate the situation with fines? And I think this is related to how they measure wealth. So how they count up somebody’s assets for the censorship test. If the cows are owned by the people, ‘the public’ as it were, rather than by a certain person individually, then that capital doesn’t count to your asset marker. So you’re looking after some cows, but you don’t technically own the cows.

                      Dr Rad 13:42
                      Interesting. Yeah. Well, when I was sort of doing a bit of digging into this, the previous law that was replaced by this law was apparently a local the Lex Aternia Tarpeia, which was introduced in 454 BCE, so not that long ago. And it apparently had set up the conversion rate for fine. So one ox was the equivalent of 10 sheep was the equivalent of 100 pounds of bronze or 100 asses – aw yeah. Give me that booty. Apparently, see, we’re not entirely sure what is happening with this new law. But we think that the conversion rate is what has been made more favourable. And probably because there might have been people who wish to pay in money, rather than in things like cattle, I guess. And so kind of might have ended the optional payment. This is just a theory. This is a set in stone. It might have ended the optional payment and it might mean that all fines had to be paid in money from this point onwards.

                      Dr G 14:51
                      Ah, this might tie in I’m not sure necessarily how, but Festus does suggest In a passage 220, from the Lindsay addition, if anybody’s keen for that, that it was about estimating cattle based on the hundreds within the herd for and then sheep were estimated based on the 10s in the herd. So they came up with a new counting method that allowed them to count less, essentially.

                      Dr Rad 15:22
                      Right. Okay, gotcha. That’s it. It might be there. Yeah, the conversion rate kind of thing. Yeah. Okay. All right. Well, clearly something is going on. It’s getting mathematical. I don’t care for it. Shall we move on to 429 BCE? Because that is all I have.

                      Dr G 15:38
                      You want to end this year on the high note of bovine counting and we’ll leave it at that.

                      Dr Rad 15:43
                      I think I’d like to I’d like to leave the cows behind. Let’s move on.

                      Dr G 15:51
                      Or as the case may be, all right, well, that wraps up what a year to be in Rome.

                      Dr Rad 16:21
                      Okay, 429 BCE. Tell me what you got Dr. G.

                      Dr G 16:24
                      Well, no surprise Dionysius of Halicarnassus is missing.

                      Dr Rad 16:30
                      I had a hunch. I had a hunch. I’ve learned from history.

                      Dr G 16:36
                      I think I have even less source material for 429 that I did for 430. Which is kind of a abysmal, because all I’ve got is the consul names. And a little snippet from Diodorus Siculus. Who as we know, tries his best, but is often a little bit confused. So I mean, I’ll take you through it. We have as our consuls, apparently Hostus Lucretius Tricipitinus, so I hate that name. Tri-cip-i-tinus, yeah. And Lucius Sergius Fidenas. And he’s consul for the second time previously consul in 437. And also previously and a little bit more recently, military tribute with consular power in 433. They’re the only magistrates I’ve got names for for this year.

                      Dr Rad 17:33
                      I don’t have any other magistrates either. So strap yourself in this is what Livy tells me happened in 429. Nothing? Nothing happened.

                      Dr G 17:45
                      What now?

                      Dr Rad 17:46
                      Yeah, no, not as in not as in he’s missing like Dionysius, as in, he actually is there. And he just says, Look, nothing happened. So let’s just move straight onto 428.

                      Dr G 17:56
                      Oh, incredible stuff. Livy. I mean, he loves to talk, I can’t believe we found nothing on this time period at all. Well, that means my source becomes very handy. Diodorus Siculus you back in the mix, buddy. So the thing with Diodorus Siculus. And it’s been going on for a while in his narrative is that there is a about a 10 year discrepancy or more between the things he tells us and when they happened, and how they might line up with when the Roman say that they happened in Rome. So the annalists may be a little bit out in their count, Diodorus might be a little bit out in his count. But the thing that he’s giving us that the Romans aren’t giving us yet is he’s lining things up according to the Athenian dating system, the eponymous Archon in Athens, and generally speaking historians feel pretty confident about those dates. So it’s a bit problematic for all of the Roman writers like Livy to be like, it’s 429 when Diodorus is like it’s 422. We got some missing years somewhere in there something has happened. But the thing that redeems the Roman analysts and where Diodorus then immediately lets himself down as he gets everybody’s names slightly wrong. So

                      Dr Rad 18:15
                      It doesn’t bode well.

                      Dr G 18:26
                      No, it’s not great. I feel like he’s probably maybe okay on numbers, but he’s not great on his source material. So there’s a lot going on. He says the consuls for this year are Opiter Lucretius, ‘Opiter’ being a name that we’ve never heard of as a praenomen, so nice try, but probably wrong. And then Lucius Sergius Fideniates which is very close. Yeah, very close. He’s just gotten the last one a little bit a little bit smooshed up.

                      Dr Rad 19:51
                      Yeah, but I’m not giving him a cigar.

                      Dr G 19:53
                      Yeah, but maybe you overheard at a dinner party. You know, I feel like that’s the Diodorus Siculus way where it’s like somebody’s saying the names to him when he’s writing them down. He looks at his notes later. And he’s like, What did I even put there? Yes. For the manuscripts.

                      Dr Rad 20:06
                      Yeah. Look, I agree. Certainly there have been modern academics that have suggested that actually, if we, we probably should shift events around a little bit. And there probably was stuff happening in this year. But just in the version of Livy that we have the way that Livy chose to record things, it seems like a very dull year, indeed.

                      Dr G 20:28
                      Nothing to report a living well, well, well,

                      Dr Rad 20:33
                      I think we’re gonna go for a record. That means we’re on tour 428 BCE. Oh, we’re speeding through thing I know, people will think we’ve had a stroke,

                      Dr G 20:43
                      Dear listeners, calm yourselves. It’s a whole new year again.

                      Dr Rad 21:10
                      Now, this is a bit of a confusing year, as far as magistrates are concerned.

                      Dr G 21:14
                      This is very confusing. Yeah. And we’ve got some, there’s a whole bunch of potential issues here. So for instance, one of the things that I was holding on to for a long time, and I think I flagged in many episodes prior to now is that Dionysius of Halicarnassus kicks back in about 428. But I think I was mistaken about that. Having read what is there in the source material, in preparation for this episode, I was like, wait a minute, that doesn’t sound like 428 to me at all. So some minor revisions might have to take place.

                      Dr Rad 21:56
                      That’s all right, wait, as long as we know that, we’re going to briefly catch a glimpse of him again one day, that’s all we need to know right now.

                      Dr G 22:03
                      He shall return – not in his full glory – but he’ll be back limping across the finish line in his fragments. So we have two sets of consuls. In this year, as far as I’m aware we’ve got which means we have to divide them up between the consul ordinarii, the ones who named the year and the consul suffectii the ones who sort of fill in, in the back catalogue. But I also have and this is where Broughton, bless his soul is always so helpful. Also knows that there is a special commission in this. Yeah. And there’s a bunch of people involved in the special commission. So we’ve got plenty of names, even if we’re not really quite sure. What is going on.

                      Dr Rad 22:47
                      I think I can help you with that maybe actually does provide me with some detail this year. So why don’t why don’t you tell me who the magistrates are and then I’ll try and fill in the blanks.

                      Dr G 22:55
                      All right, this this sounds good to me. It’s a deal. It’s a deal. So our first consul is Aulus Cornelius Cossus.

                      Dr Rad 23:05
                      Not the most handsome man in the world.

                      Dr G 23:10
                      You may remember him, dear listeners, for being awesome. In 437, where you may have first encountered him, he was merely a military tribune. But this year, he’s actually a consul.

                      Dr Rad 23:25
                      Nice.

                      Dr G 23:26
                      So you know, I mean, I don’t know what he’s been doing for the last 10 years, but I’m gonna assume he’s even more handsome than before.

                      Dr Rad 23:33
                      Absolutely handsome men don’t need to work hard for political office.

                      Dr G 23:37
                      I wouldn’t assume so especially when women have the vote. Oh, wait. And then we also have Titus Quinctius Poenas Cincinnatus. Another quite familiar name at this point is this is his second bite at the consular cherry previously consul in 431 and also most likely one of the sons with a very famous Cincinnatus.

                      Dr Rad 24:03
                      I weas gonna say he’s not THE Cincinnatus.

                      Dr G 24:06
                      No. Poenas Cincinnatus is one of the sons of the very famous twice dictator Cincinnatus for those tuning in from Cincinnati and possibly also the younger brother of Lucis Quinctius Cincinnatus who has exactly the same name as the great man himself, so very confusing. So those two are consuls. Then apparently we have another two sets of consuls and that would involve Lucius Quinctius Cincinnatus.

                      Dr Rad 24:39
                      Right.

                      Dr G 24:39
                      The brother

                      Dr Rad 24:41
                      Just to makes things even more confusing. Yeah.

                      Dr G 24:44
                      Two Cincinnatuses consul in the same year.

                      Dr Rad 24:47
                      Did that make them a Cincinnati?

                      Dr G 24:49
                      I think it does. I think I think we’ve reached the Cincinnati moment. It’s finally happened and also Aulus Sempronius Atratinus.

                      Dr Rad 25:01
                      We’ve heard that name before.

                      Dr G 25:04
                      Yeah, I mean, it sounds vaguely familiar to me. But I haven’t written any notes on that. So I have not done my due diligence with that guy.

                      Dr Rad 25:10
                      Now, I think I don’t think it’s necessarily the same person. But I do remember that name of Atratinus. And of course, Sempronius. I mean, the Sempronii are going to pop up again and again.

                      Dr G 25:23
                      They are going to have a long legacy as patrician family.

                      Dr Rad 25:26
                      Yeah.

                      Dr G 25:27
                      So that’s our two pairs of consuls. Then we head into our special commission, and I’m excited to learn about what this special commission might be all about. But it involves at least three people. Lucius Sergius Fidenas, who cropped up in the previous year as consul. Quintus Servilius Priscus Fidenas. So, two Fideni in there.

                      Dr Rad 25:54
                      Yeah.

                      Dr G 25:54
                      And Mamercus Aemilius Mamercinus, who we also have previously seen was a military tribute with consular power in 438. And also seems to been appointed to investigate the participation of the Fidenates in the raids led by Veii

                      Dr Rad 26:19
                      Yeah, so that’s what I’m going to fill in a little bit for you. So let’s get to it. Okay, so we’ve got our consuls of Cossus, who, as you mentioned, was our ridiculously good looking tribune who managed to defeat an Etruscan King on the battlefield had the whole spolia opima thing going on for him which nobody, but Romulus had managed to do so what a consul. And then we also have Titus Quinctius Poenas Cincinnatus, as you said, now, what starts to happen under their consulship is that the people of Veii start to make moves on Roman territory. A common tale, we have talked about the fact that this time period as much as it seems to be filled with these awesome Hollywood blockbuster epic battles, really seems to be this constant kneeling of Rome and its neighbours and they’re constantly trying to get each other’s territory and steal each other’s stuff. I mean, honestly, it feels a bit like kindergarten sometimes, Dr. G. Now is also rumoured, as you just mentioned that some of the young men from Fidenae were in on these raids. Okay, we’re taking part. Lest we forget, the Romans aren’t feeling really great about Fidenae right now do you want to remind us why?

                      Dr G 27:40
                      There seems to be a bit of a problem. So in the history of Fidenae, it starts out as a Roman colony that seems to be it’s how it comes into being. So the Romans always consider it theirs. And it’s actually a really strategic anchor point to the slight north of Rome, because it sits on the same side of the Tiber as Rome. And this means that they’ve got a sort of like a defence in the north, that allows them to sort of feel more at ease about where their enemies might be coming at them from. Problem for Rome is that the Fidemae populace decides that they’re not having anything to do with Rome anymore, and they decide to throw in their lot with the Etruscans, which makes a lot of sense, the Etruscans are really quite close. They are a much more numerous people. And if you were looking at a side by side comparison of who you should ally with at in this time period, you’ve got Rome, a single city, a little outpost, run by a bunch of gangsters, versus the Etruscans, who have centuries of history in the region, and a full 12 member kingship going on, there is a lot of power and a lot of history there. They’re well embedded in their power structures. So it makes sense that a reasonable offer might have been made to Fidenae and they fluttered their eyelashes at they and said, well yes, of course we’d love to join you. And Veii and the Etruscans now have a strategic position to filter into Rome from a side that they are not usually able to approach the city from.

                      Dr Rad 29:26
                      Strategically important. Absolutely. So obviously, they have a bitter taste in the room, his mouth and I’m going to tolerate these rumours that are going on there like look, it’s one thing for today like we expect it from Veii, but Fidenae after everything we’ve just been through, I don’t know think so. So as you mentioned, a special commission is set up I feel like we need to have some some cry music Don’t Don’t do too. And so we got Lucius Sergius, Quintus Servilius and Mamercus Aemilius according to Livy who are putting in charge of looking into these rumours, and some men could not account for their whereabouts at the time in question. So I’m definitely putting the Law and Order vibes right now.

                      Dr G 30:12
                      You don’t have an alibi. Why? No, sir. I was sleeping in the field.

                      Dr Rad 30:17
                      Yeah, they were away from Fidenae. And they but where were they? Who could vouch for their whereabouts? Nobody. That’s who. So they are banished to Ostia.

                      Dr G 30:26
                      I mean, that’s pretty disappointing that they couldn’t even get a friend to lie for them.

                      Dr Rad 30:32
                      It would seem to be pretty easy back in this day and age but it’s not like they’re battling you know, CCTV and mobile phones cell tower was pinging all around. Nonetheless, the goats were quiet that day. And nobody could say where they were. They’re banished to Ostia. And I guess Rome is also starting to think about, hmm, what can we do with this whole Fidenae situation? Because clearly, they’re still not really on board with this whole idea of being allied with the most awesome city state in all of Italy. Not that it’s known as Italy right now, but hey. So they decided they’re going to send more settlers and establish what not establish a colony, but reinforce the colony at feed name. And so they take land from the property of people who had died. And they give it to the new colonists. So they’re sort of trying to, you know, set them up.

                      Dr G 31:27
                      Okay, so they shift some things around like, yeah, it’s an offworld opportunity.

                      Dr Rad 31:33
                      Some creative accounting.

                      Dr G 31:34
                      Yeah, it’s gonna be very exciting for you here, take this stuff. Yeah, I think the other thing that might be said for this year is this is the year that Cossus holds the consulship. So for some scholars, and it would make sense to go down this path, this is actually the year where the king of Veii, Lars Tolumnius, is met in battle and is slain directly by Cossus.

                      Dr Rad 32:03
                      Okay, see, I have that a little bit later in some of the stuff I’ve written. So definitely the fact that he’s consulship. Now is Yeah, definitely.

                      Dr G 32:11
                      This is yeah, this is one of the candidates is going to pop up. This is going to crop up again.

                      Dr Rad 32:16
                      And of course, we’ve also got Mamercus Aemilius too. Yeah. also has those connotations. So yes, this is one of the candidates, but I definitely with my Livy narrative, because you know, Livy is my man. I’m going to plump for a bit later on. But anyway, so we’ve got to colony set up at Fidenae. And then of course, it’s been far too peaceful. And Disney-like for too long, Dr. G, a drought hits are really, really bad drought.

                      Dr G 32:16
                      I see. Okay, I think these things might crop up in a slightly different year for me. So we’ll, we’ll see, we’ll keep going.

                      Dr Rad 32:54
                      Okay.

                      Dr G 32:55
                      I’m interested.

                      Dr Rad 32:55
                      So Livy tells me that it’s not just the fact that it’s not raining very much, which is part of the problem, but also what he calls perennial streams, do not have enough water. So I think that probably means that obviously, where people would normally locate their water, it’s, you know, they don’t usually have any problems from the sources that are drained from from the ground. They’re also drying up.

                      Dr G 33:19
                      Yeah, yeah. So creeks and small rivers are also dry. Yes, it’s bad time.

                      Dr Rad 33:25
                      Yeah, exactly. Now, of course, when we don’t have enough water, what happens? People start to die. So basically, the cattle the first today, so they start dying, and you’d find them sort of strewn all around these dried up water sources where they would normally go to get a drink. And they’re also starting to die from mange, which is still a disease that can afflict various animals these days. But basically, it’s some sort of skin condition, which is caused by these parasitic microscopic mites. And what ends up happening is when you’ve got all this drought, people are suffering, cattle are suffering, cattle are dying, cattle are diseased, sure enough, our disease spreads from the cattle to the Roman people. So at first, you start to see people who are living in more rural areas and slaves starting to die, but then also it spreads into the city. And it’s obviously again, I mean, it feels like only yesterday we were talking about a bad sickness in Rome, but it seems like once again, the Romans are really suffering badly.

                      Dr G 34:28
                      Yeah, I think we would have to assume that if we’re in a situation of this kind of drought, we’re looking at years of consequence, not just a single year, like in order to be in a situation where usual water sources are actually dry. This is an ongoing drought that’s been happening for some time and it’s now getting quite severe.

                      Dr Rad 34:51
                      Absolutely. Now, the people because they are suffering so badly, they start getting desperate and what In terms foreign superstitions become very popular, and other people in room are starting to take advantage of the situation, presumably to, like make not money like cash, I would presume, but presumably to earn some sort of financial gain or to win influence with people. So some people are pretending to be seers. So sort of taking advantage of that superstitious state desperate state that people are in. And they start talking the room and people into adopting new types of beliefs and weird ways of sacrificing, and it’s happening in their homes, the leading citizens start to notice that it’s spreading everywhere. And that there are just like strange sacrifices happening all over the city, because the people just, they can’t help but think that they’ve done something to upset the gods, and that the only way that they’re going to make it right is if they figure out, you know, what’s the right offering? What’s the right sacrifice? How can I possibly, you know, restore the balance between our people and the gods. So it seems to be getting out of hand, I’m gonna unpack what this all means in a second. Eventually, the angels are put in charge of ensuring that everyone returns to normal, and I’m using my flesh rabbits religious practices, and that they return to only worshipping Roman gods in a Roman way, God dammit.

                      Dr G 36:25
                      I see. I mean, it makes a lot of sense that things like this would happen. And it is also quite interesting that the Roman response to this would, is not that sort of expansive, inclusive sort of approach that we see much later in Rome, where they, they really do just sort of absorb and embrace and adapt different modes of worship into their own way of doing things. There seems to be like a distinct moment of crisis, in terms of like ritual practice, brought about by environmental crisis.

                      Dr Rad 37:00
                      Yes, absolutely. And I think we can sympathise with that these days, even though it might not necessarily be an environmental crisis, although it might be. We see people in tough times these days, often, that’s the moment that they find some sort of faith because you know, when push comes to shove, and you’re desperate, you might look for answers in places you haven’t considered before. Now, that’s not to say that the Romans haven’t considered being religious for for all, but they just might be looking in into new gods. Now.

                      Dr G 37:28
                      Well, certainly if the rituals that they’ve been performing, haven’t done the trick, and the drought is getting worse, then it would be a reasonable thing to assume that maybe there’s something wrong with the ritual practice.

                      Dr Rad 37:40
                      Yes. So looking at how academics have interpreted what Livy is saying here, because he doesn’t give me any specifics about exactly what kind of practices and that sort of thing, it seems to be assumed that he’s referring to the cult of Apollo. So you might have forgotten, but in 431, they dedicated a temple to Apolo, when we’re suffering from that really terrible plague, it actually been vowed in for 33. But it wasn’t until first 431 that the temple was, you know, up and running. And so it might be something to do with that,

                      Dr G 38:19
                      Somebody built it wrong. You gotta gotta take that down.

                      Dr Rad 38:23
                      Well, it might just made it that was like, you know, the new cult on the block. Oh, yeah. So it might be that there is something like that going on. It’s possible. That’s what they’re referring to. And it won’t be the last time that we see this kind of outbreak of extreme. Well, what the room is sore is like more extreme or superstitious practices, like people getting a bit caught up in things, we’re gonna see this again, when we get to the years of like the Second Punic War and that sort of thing. Now that we’ve isolated Yeah, the final weird thing I’m going to note is that we of course, have the seemingly plebeian aediles. Now, it’s not explicit that this is who they are, but possibly, it’s the plebeian aediles who have been put in charge with restoring everything to rights, which might not seem to add up at first, if we think about the kinds of functions that the aediles serve later on in Rome’s history where they’re more concerned with, I suppose, more prosaic matters of life rather than religious beliefs. But for this earlier period, it does seem that there is potentially a connection for them where there is that sort of religious aspects obviously there I mean, all magistrates obviously, it’s not like in the modern day where you have a real separation between politics and religion. Obviously, all magistrates are going to be involved in religious practices somehow, whether it’s the rights they have to carry out or whatever, but But we’ve seen also that it seems like the Aidells were the ones put in charge of the publishing of the 12 Tables, they also possibly were overseeing senatorial records and making sure that they were kept at this point in time. And they therefore might have been seen as valid people to be overseeing how people are observing their religion, I suppose. And that, yeah, they have this sort of religious aspect to their role.

                      Dr G 40:32
                      Interesting, very interesting. So we’ve had this mention of aediles, we don’t know, we don’t have any names.

                      Dr Rad 40:41
                      We do not. We didn’t know. And then so this is all speculation, we don’t really know what’s going on here. We don’t have enough detail. And it’s not that they’re trying to wipe out the cult of Apollo. They’re just trying to make sure that it doesn’t get excessive. And there is a balance between what and who the Romans are worshipping.

                      Dr G 41:01
                      And there’s also the broader question of like, what’s going on with like, the demarcation of responsibility here. So we have had previous years before now where we’ve known who the Pontifex Maximus is, yes. And it doesn’t happen very often in this early period. But they have been mentioned. And we also get this sense, particularly from very early on, definitely pre Republic, that there are a whole bunch of really quite significant priesthoods that are already in existence, such as the fetiales, such as a whole bunch of sort of priests to Jupiter, priests to Mars, the pontificates as a college, augers. And so the idea that it is in this moment, that the responsibility is delegated to the aediles to try and sort out this issue does raise some questions

                      Dr Rad 42:08
                      It does. And as I say, it’s just a theory. But I think it’s, it does sort of highlight that. We honestly can’t say a lot for certain about a lot of people’s positions at this point in time. It’s not that they are they’re not obviously a pretty straight as you’re saying they’re not a pretty soon, as you say it’s more that something’s been delegated to them, and that they might have been seen as the kind of people that were able to oversee something like this,

                      Dr G 42:32
                      The idea that this could fall within their remit somehow,

                      Dr Rad 42:36
                      Potentially, but again, like I think it just sort of even even if this is just a theory, it’s just once again, a reminder that we really know so little about exactly what being a consul this period, you know,

                      Dr G 42:47
                      well, yes. And I think, I mean, it’s worth noting that often, this has been simplified as well, like when we talk about consuls in this period, we’re not even sure that they’re called ‘consul’.

                      Dr Rad 42:57
                      Exactly. That’s the question marks and it’s just sort of highlights that if you look up what an aedile does, this would probably not be something that I think they would normally associated with when you get later in Rome’s history.

                      Dr G 43:10
                      Yeah, and we’re in this period where things nothing is solid. Uncertainty is high. Yes. I think unless you have other details this might be the place to wrap up this episode.

                      Dr Rad 43:24
                      That is all I have. But I will say that some of the details that I’ve just given you are going to come back in the most major way you have no idea or maybe you do I don’t know if Dionysius is kicked back in or not but the next episode some of these little seeds that are planted they’re going to flower into something horrible.

                      Dr G 43:42
                      Oh, I can’t wait to find out well and well if you share your story with me I’ll let you know what I discovered.

                      Dr Rad 43:50
                      All right, Dr. G, that means it is once again time for the Partial Pick

                      all right, Dr. G, so this is the point where we sum up Well normally the year that was but in this case it’s the three years that we’re and we rate room out of five different categories and in each of those categories, they have the potential to score 10 Golden Eagles Something tells me it’s going to be rough today.

                      Dr G 44:23
                      Yeah, like in a year where nothing happened well all right, so let’s see how they do the first category is military clout

                      Dr Rad 44:34
                      Nope that to stick really

                      Dr G 44:39
                      I couldn’t fight I had the mange

                      Dr Rad 44:43
                      Yep, so that’s that’s this year. So what’s our next category diplomacy. Okay, well, there’s a little bit of that going on here. We’ve got the truce with the aqueous that’s true

                      Dr G 44:53
                      and they did negotiate some people out of feed and a get you there get you to Ostia will bring it A pack of robots to replace you. I mean, they could be seen as diplomatic. For the

                      Dr Rad 45:05
                      Romans. I think that is diplomatic. They didn’t just outright kill them. Not Yeah. Nice. Yeah. So what, like four or five? I mean, it’s not that impressive.

                      Dr G 45:16
                      Well, I feel like yeah, the diplomacy with feed and a doesn’t count for much. I don’t think that’s maybe a one. But actually coming to it. You truce with the aliens and the volsky. I that actually does sound pretty. Oh, okay. The moleskin is under the bus like that. I retract I retract the A quien treaty. Yeah, true. So I should say so the treaty a truce for eight years? Yeah. Yeah, look, I’m gonna give them about a five.

                      Dr Rad 45:48
                      Okay, so we’ll give them a five. Alright, so we’ve got five what’s our next category?

                      Dr G 45:51
                      Expansion? No.

                      Dr Rad 45:54
                      Fear while I feel

                      Dr G 45:56
                      it’s hard to expand under these conditions, they’re being pressed from all sides.

                      Dr Rad 46:00
                      They are and from and internally the cows.

                      Dr G 46:07
                      Sorry, I was like being pressed internally, I went somewhere else. We’re tourists

                      Dr Rad 46:14
                      can’t say that I do.

                      Dr G 46:17
                      That a lot of winters going on. No specific examples come to mind. They’re just they’re doing things but uh, and citizen score.

                      Dr Rad 46:27
                      Look, for the first few years that we talked about the fact that there’s a lot of peace that nothing is happening.

                      Dr G 46:33
                      There’s fines being alleviated? I mean, it all sounds pretty good. Really.

                      Dr Rad 46:37
                      That’s pretty good. It’s just unfortunately, we’ve bundled it together with this hideous route, which makes everyone really suffer and makes them ill. Yeah. So it’s gonna be balanced out. I think maybe maybe like a four

                      Dr G 46:53
                      points for reduced fines, taking your way points for the mange

                      Dr Rad 46:58
                      given that we’re not really entirely sure exactly. What that whole fine business involved. It’s all very speculative. I’m

                      Dr G 47:06
                      assuming it benefits the rich more than it benefits the blue bands. But I could be wrong about that. We have

                      Dr Rad 47:13
                      talked a lot with the people. So I’m presuming it was actually to their benefit and don’t don’t

                      Dr G 47:19
                      look for something into things that haven’t been good for them before.

                      Dr Rad 47:23
                      This is true. But the fact that Libby says the tributes of the collapse were the ones that are originally coming up with it. And then the console stole their idea. And

                      Dr G 47:32
                      maybe, well, maybe a four then as you say,

                      Dr Rad 47:37
                      Okay, well that actually you know what, it’s better than I thought although not great when you consider it three years rolled into one cart with a total of nine golden eagles. Dr. G.

                      Dr G 47:48
                      Wow, Rome, you’ve really excelled?

                      Dr Rad 47:53
                      Yeah, yeah. Definitely have Hey, you know what, there? It’s definitely better than some of the other years we’ve dealt with in the 40s. I thought that the December it was a bad period, but actually the full 30s have been rough.

                      Dr G 48:07
                      They have I mean, between like the absence of source material and just like hit after hit to the Roman psyche. It’s been a tough time.

                      Dr Rad 48:17
                      Well, that’s a G, there’s no one I would rather talk about nothing. We’re

                      Dr G 48:23
                      gonna take that as a compliment.

                      Dr Rad 48:25
                      Absolutely. Join us next time for the podcast about nothing. Oh,

                      Dr G 48:30
                      from the foundation to nothing.

                      Dr Rad 48:44
                      Thank you for listening to this episode of the partial historians. You can find our sources, sound credits and automated transcripts in our show notes. You too can support our show and help us to produce more intriguing content about the ancient world by becoming a Patreon. In return, you receive exclusive early access to our special episodes. Today, we’d like to give a special shout out to some of our newest Patreon, Daniel, Nicole, Vincent and Michael. There are other ways that you can support our show. We have merchandise a collaboration with Bridget Clark on Gumroad. And we now also have a book and you can find all the details of that on the highlands press website as well as our website if you’d like to purchase a copy of Rex, the seven kings of Rome, our popular history. However, if you are travel short of denari, we would massively appreciate it. If you told someone about the show. That kind of recommendation is worth its weight in gold. Until next time, we are yours in ancient Rome.

                      Hey, Dr. Chi, would you know what to do if a fella started floating in the fire before you?

                      Dr G 50:29
                      Probably not?

                      Dr Rad 50:32
                      Well, then have I got the book for you? Did you know that we wrote a book?

                      Dr G 50:37
                      What we wrote a book? No way.

                      Dr Rad 50:39
                      I think we wrote a book. Yeah, absolutely. We read a book and it’s called Rex, that seven kings of Rome.

                      Dr G 50:47
                      Oh, that’s right. The details are starting to come back to me now. Yes, yes, the Regal period. What a time for the Romans to be alive. And also what a time for historians to revisit and to consider the source material.

                      Dr Rad 51:00
                      Absolutely. So if you’re interested in picking up a copy of our popular history of the Roman monarchy, please head over to the highlands press website.

                      Dr G 51:10
                      That’s Highlands, Dash press.com (https://highlands-press.com/highlands-press-bookstore/)

                      Dr Rad 51:15
                      It’d be a great way to show your support of the show and to get a great read

                      Dr Rad 51:15
                      It’d be a great way to show your support of the show and to get a great read

                      Transcribed by https://otter.ai

                      53 min
                    • A Dry Period

                      Prepare yourself, dear listener, for a drought or two! After spending several episodes on individual years, we are speeding ahead in our latest episode. We are covering not one, not two, but THREE years in a single instalment. Join us as we tackle 430, 429 and 428 BCE.


                      Financial Affairs

                      The Romans enjoy a remarkably peaceful year in 430 BCE. This means that they can turn their attention to financial matters. At least the new law that is introduced seems to benefit the people.


                      A Year About Nothing

                      The citizens must be confused as the peace continued into 429 BCE. No war? No internal conflict? Are we trapped in an episode of Seinfeld?


                      The Return of Cossus

                      The ridiculously handsome Aulus Cornelius Cossus returns for a consulship in 428 BCE. Thank goodness! We need some eye candy around here. The drama returns to Rome with raiders from Veii and Fidenae. However, the Romans cannot stay mad for long. A severe drought devastates the people. We’ve hit a dry period in this very dry period.

                      All the Romans could think about was how to improve their relationship with the gods. Will their luck turn around?

                      Looking to catch up on why Cossus is so famed? We’ve got your back:

                      • Episode 129 – Lars Tolumnius and the Fate of Fidenae
                      • Episode 130 – The Cossus Controversy
                      Things to Look Out For
                      • Confusion over consuls (Who really was in charge in 428 BCE, Livy?)
                      • Colony building
                      • Irritating skin diseases
                      • Aediles taking care of business
                      • A special commission
                      • Confusion over bovine equations
                      • Book promotions. Gotcha! You can buy our book HERE!


                      Catch all out shownotes + full transcript over on our website: https://partialhistorians.com/2023/02/16/episode-134-a-dry-period/


                      For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


                      Support the show

                      Patreon

                      Ko-Fi


                      Read our books

                      Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

                      Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

                      Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

                      53 min
                    • Postumius Tubertus, Dictator

                      It’s around 431 BCE and Rome is busy contending with her neighbours in pretty much every direction. Turns out that it’s not easy trying to establish yourself as an independent state! It might just be time for a dictator. Enter: Aulus Postumius Tubertus.

                      Episode 133 – Postumius Tubertus, Dictator

                      Rome is taking the need to put troops on the field seriously with a levy of the citizens held under the conditions of the lex sacrata, which is considered to be the most strict conditions requiring compliance in line with the gods. Who are they scared of? Only the most enduring thorns in their sides, their southern neighbours the Volsicians and the Aequians! It isn’t long before Rome is convinced that they need a dictator to sort out this mess.

                      Getting to the point of having a dictator in place though is quite another story. In this episode we explore some intriguing details relating to the consuls, the tribunes of the plebs, and the interference of a certain patrician. Beyond them is the actual battle itself, which takes on grand overtones with comparisons made to Homer’s Iliad. This year is also tinged with a sense of tragedy with a story involving the dictator Aulus Postumius Tubertus and his son.

                      Hold on to your hats, dear listener, this is going to be epic!

                      Things to tune in for:

                      • Familiar locations like Mount Algidus
                      • Some beef between the consuls!
                      • Intense levies
                      • Battle plans!
                      • The heroism of Vettius Messius
                      Our Book on the Roman Kings

                      We've gone back to where it all began (or so the Romans would say…)

                      We delve into the history, myth, and complexities of the ancient Roman kings. You can support our work and get a very cool ancient Roman history book in return by pre-ordering a copy of Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome from the Highlands Press. Due for release in late January 2023.

                      Highlands Press is an independent publisher supporting historians and we’re excited to be pairing up with an indie producer for our debut book together.

                      What did early Roman soldiers wear on the field? It's a good question, while we might assume leather was important protective gear, some elites likely had more sophisticated armour. Above is a bronze helmet of the Montefortino type. Considered to be the oldest type of metal Roman helmet. This example dates from the third century BCE and is now in the British Museum.

                      Our PlayersConsuls
                      • Titus Quinctius L. f. L. n. Poenus Cincinnatus (Pat)
                      • Gaius/Gnaeus Iulius – f. – n. Mento (Pat)
                      Dictator
                      • Aulus Postumius – f. – n. Tubertus (Pat)
                      Master of the Horse
                      • Lucius Iulius (Vopisci f. C. ?n) Iullus (Pat)
                      Military Legates
                      • Marcus Fabius (Vibulanus) (Pat)
                      • Marcus? Geganius (Macerinus) (Pat)
                      • Spurius Postumius Albus (Regillensis) (Pat)
                      • Quintus Sulpicius (Camerinus Praetextatus) (Pat)
                      Other Patricians
                      • Quintus Servilius Priscus
                      Pontifex Maximus
                      • Aulus Cornelius Cossus
                      Volscians
                      • Vettius Messius
                      Our Sources
                      • Dr Rad reads Livy ab Urbe Condita 4.26-29.
                      • Dr G reads Diodorus Siculus 12.64-65.1; Ovid Fasti 6.723f; Valerius Maximus 2.7.6; Plutarch Cam. 2; Gellius 17.21.17
                      • Broughton, T. R. S., Patterson, M. L. 1951. The Magistrates of the Roman Republic Volume 1: 509 B.C. – 100 B.C. (The American Philological Association)
                      • Cornell, T. J. 1995. The Beginnings of Rome: Italy and Rome from the Bronze Age to the Punic Wars (c. 1000-264 BC) (Taylor & Francis)
                      • Forsythe, G. 2006. A Critical History of Early Rome: From Prehistory to the First Punic War(University of California Press)
                      • Ogilvie, R. M. 1965. A Commentary on Livy, Books 1-5 (Clarendon Press) 
                      • Wilson, M. 2021. The Evolution of the Roman Dictatorship (University of Michigan Press)
                      Sound Effects

                      Sounds effects in this episode are sourced from BBC, Pixabay, and Pond5. Thanks to the highly talented Bettina Joy de Guzman for our theme music.

                      Roman soldiers and their general by vukkostic.
                      This painting imagines a Roman army much more organised and sophisticated than that of the early Republic. Nevertheless, it evokes the spirit of Roman warfare which is very much at play in this episode.

                      Automated Transcript

                      We've tried to edit this one to help with all the Roman names!

                      Dr Rad 0:16
                      Welcome to The Partial Historians.

                      Dr G 0:20
                      We explore all the details of ancient Rome.

                      Dr Rad 0:23
                      Everything from the political scandals, the love affairs, the battles waged, and when citizens turn against each other. I'm Dr. Rad.

                      Dr G 0:34
                      And I'm Dr. G. We consider Rome as the Roman saw it by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.

                      Dr Rad 0:43
                      Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.

                      Dr G 0:58
                      Hello, and welcome to a brand new episode of The Partial Historians. I am one of your hosts, Dr. G. And sitting with me, across the vast distance of cyberspace

                      Dr Rad 1:13
                      Is Doctor Rad. Hello, everyone. Hello,

                      Dr G 1:17
                      hello. We're in for a thrilling time, I think in this episode. So we're going to be looking at 431 BCE. And you might think to yourself, that doesn't sound very exciting, just another number. But just us join

                      Dr Rad 1:33
                      us for this episode as we continue to trace the history of Rome from the founding of the city at the moment, predominantly with Livy by our side.

                      Dr G 1:44
                      Yeah, look, Dionysus of Halicarnassus, which is the main source that I've been reading for a long while now has dropped off the wagon, and will remain missing for a few more years before finally disappearing altogether.

                      Dr Rad 2:00
                      All right, well, before we get into force, anyone and all the excitement that awaits us strategy, should we do a brief recap to see what was happening in Roman history in our previous episode?

                      Dr G 2:08
                      Hmm. So in our previous episode, we covered two years, and it was 433 and 432. And realistically, it was mostly about a pestilence and the getting over of said pestilence.

                      Dr Rad 2:25
                      I think we can all relate to.

                      Dr G 2:27
                      Yes, yes. touches their heartstrings. That does, indeed, and Rome gets through it, but it seems that there might be rising tensions from their neighbors, people who are seeing Rome's malaise as an opportunity potentially

                      Dr Rad 2:44
                      Indeed, you've got the fall scans in the aqueous rearing their ugly heads, and they seem to be potentially allying with the Etruscans. More specifically, perhaps the people from they because Rome has had some beef with a in the past decade over territory.

                      Dr G 3:05
                      Yeah, and Veii is super close to Rome, just a little bit to the north. And so it's perhaps unsurprising that these two are often at loggerheads with each other. Yes, absolutely.

                      Dr Rad 3:14
                      So we've got that lingering in the background. We've got Livy valiantly trying to continue to forge a conflict within Rome itself between the patricians and plebeians In our previous episode. So let's see how it all plays out shall we in 431 BCE?

                      Dr G 4:51
                      431 BCE What a time to be alive in ancient Rome. We have consuls this year

                      Dr Rad 4:59
                      we do in case you have forgotten, it was thought that with potential trouble with external places on the horizon, only consuls would do, because God forbid you have military turbulence with constant power and one of them's a plebeian and I mean, it's clearly going to result in a defeat.

                      Dr G 5:20
                      We can't take that risk. And Rome doesn't they put in Titus Quinctius, son of Lucius, grandson of Lucius, Poenus Cincinnatus, who is a patrician and yes, is related to the famous since I was

                      Dr Rad 5:36
                      gonna say it's a famous name. It's a famous name.

                      Dr G 5:40
                      So famous family and this appears to be one of his son.

                      Dr Rad 5:43
                      Okay, excellent. And then we've got another famous name I believe is our other consul.

                      Dr G 5:48
                      We do we have a Gaius or a Gnaeus, debate rages Julius Mento

                      Dr Rad 5:55
                      I'm sorry, did you just offer me a breath mint?

                      Dr G 5:59
                      I did. It's delicious.

                      Dr Rad 6:01
                      What a weird cognomen.

                      Dr G 6:04
                      Yes, and I'd love to tell you more about it. But I'm out of my rabbit hole of cognomen. Nah, I'm good. I don't have anything to tell you on that.

                      Dr Rad 6:13
                      I can actually tell you what it means strategy. Oh, good. It means “long chin”.

                      Dr G 6:20
                      Oh, goodness. Well, well. What happens when a Mento and a Flaccinator end up in the same room?

                      Dr Rad 6:29
                      I feel like it is something something very peppermint tea that would happen. Not just to get long chin's always remind me of peppermint. That's fantastic. Yes. strong flavors. Definitely.

                      Dr G 6:40
                      The fresh maker.

                      Dr Rad 6:41
                      Yes.

                      Dr G 6:43
                      All right. So I mean, we've focused on Mento. But it's really the Gaius Julius element of the name that perhaps would ring bells for everybody. And it's not our guy were way too early for him. Yes.

                      Dr Rad 6:57
                      And it just in terms of the debate raging around his freedom. And so apparently, Gnaeus is not a name commonly used by the Julians, as again. So that's why I think there is some debate about that first name, whereas Gaius we know is definitely used by them.

                      Dr G 7:17
                      Definitely, definitely. But as a foreshadowing of the year ahead, I've got some other people holding power that are perhaps worthy of note, we do get a dictator in this, as far as I'm aware that

                      Dr Rad 7:33
                      the 430s is a time for dictators. They are literally flooding us with dictators at the moment.

                      Dr G 7:40
                      It's a stunning time to be a dictator. And we have Aulus Postumius Tubertus.

                      Dr Rad 7:47
                      Mmmm a familiar name again, the Postumii,

                      Dr G 7:52
                      indeed, I don't know if we've seen this specific guy before, but we've definitely seen the family

                      Dr Rad 7:57
                      just the family. Yeah.

                      Dr G 7:58
                      And if you have a dictator, you can always bet your sunshine, that you're also going to have a Master of the Horse. And this is Lucius Iulius Vopisci, or Vopisci, Iullus.

                      Dr Rad 8:15
                      Oh, okay.

                      Dr G 8:16
                      Another patrician.

                      Dr Rad 8:17
                      Is he related? Do you think to one of our consuls?

                      Dr G 8:22
                      Ahhh I don't. I don't know. I mean, they they come from the same gens. So I mean, they must be extended relations of some Yes. But all of the other names don't really match up. So that suggests they come from different family lines. But this guy we have seen before he was apparently a military tribune with consular power in 438. Okay. Okay. So I don't remember him. But we're getting into that period where all Roman names start to sound the same.

                      Dr Rad 8:50
                      So we're only now getting to that period? We're getting to that period?

                      Dr G 8:55
                      Just now just recently.

                      Dr Rad 8:56
                      Yeah. Okay. Fair enough. Fair enough.

                      Dr G 8:58
                      We have some legates as well. So I think this is an indication usually we don't find out who the legates are. They are a military or some sort of military commander. So we don't tend to hear about them. They're usually around. But something has to sort of be quite narratively significant for the legates to get mentioned by name. And we have a few of them mentioned by name this year. So that gives us a bit of a heads up that there's something on the horizon. So we have Marcus Fabius Vibulanus, you may have heard of him before military tribute with consular power in 433.

                      Dr Rad 9:36
                      Ahh Fabulous Fabian

                      Dr G 9:37
                      Yes. Marcus, we think, Marcus Geganius Macerinus.

                      Dr Rad 9:44
                      I've definitely heard of him before.

                      Dr G 9:46
                      He was consul in 447, 443 and 437.

                      Dr Rad 9:51
                      Yes, I remember.

                      Dr G 9:52
                      Well, lots of lots of consulships under his belt. So this guy comes with a huge sort of pedigree so I like it. You is not as high up in the in the chain of greatness as being a consul but this guy would be highly respected as a military commander under a consul. And then we have Spurius Postumius Albus Regillensis.

                      Dr Rad 10:14
                      I've definitely heard that name before.

                      Dr G 10:16
                      sounds super familiar because just a couple of years ago, he was also a military tribute with consular power. So we've got a whole bunch of legates who have previously held command, essentially. So they're bringing in the big guns. And that's not all. I'm turning the page. We have Quintus Sulpicius Camerinus Praetextatus. Who was a consul or military tribute with consular power in 434.

                      Dr Rad 10:51
                      So he was from the year of chaos as it shall henceforth be called.

                      Dr G 10:55
                      Yeah, where we don't know who was who holding what, which position necessarily. It was so bad.

                      Dr Rad 11:00
                      Exactly. Exactly. All right. Well, I think this is our cast our cast of 1000s.

                      Dr G 11:06
                      Yeah, and I hope listeners that you've been paying careful attention because all of those names uniquely matter.

                      Dr Rad 11:12
                      Exactly then at all interchangeable. All right, so let me tell you what these guys are getting up to and why there are so many names mentioned specifically in the year 431. So as we know, war is looming. I guess that means I have to go back to my British accent from pre war was on the horizon. zactly it's not looking good chaps, quickly, we got to hell, the levy god dammit.

                      Dr G 11:38
                      Roll up, roll up, join the greatest army on earth,

                      Dr Rad 11:42
                      Your country needs you. Yes, that's exactly what happened. So a levy is held by the consuls, and it's held under a lex sacrata, because it's generally held to be the most effective way of gathering soldiers. Why do you ask? Well, I'll tell you, because whoever did not obey the call, to enlist, was considered sacer to the gods or forfeit to the gods. So, yeah, this, this ties into the idea that fighting was kind of a religious duty of a Roman citizen, particularly I suppose, at this point in time when Rome does not have a standing army.

                      Dr G 12:25
                      Yeah, service to the gods. Well, it makes sense in many respects, and we we've got a lot of priesthoods that are connected with either being able to read the signs to indicate whether it's an appropriate time to go to war, you've also got the fetiales who go out to ensure that the wars just in the eyes of the gods, there is a lot of sense in which Rome doesn't engage in any military action unless they really certain that things are looking appropriate through a divine perspective. So you certainly don't want men in your ranks who are not approved from divine sanction.

                      Dr Rad 13:02
                      Indeed, exactly. So what's going to happen is that the aid grants and the moleskin say, certainly postponed for a war for a year, but they're very punctual. And that year rolls around because they are getting ready. They have put forward very strong armies from both of their locales, they have met up at Mount Algidum, or Algidus, which we have mentioned several times as a point of conflict, it's just seems to be the place where battles happened. But they have set up separate camps. So they're not in they're close to each other. But they're not entirely in the one camp that will become important later on, which is why I'm specifically mentioning it now. And then they start to drill them in hard. So it's Train, train, train. The Romans presumably can see this and appreciate it because it makes them more concerned about the situation according to Liddy, so concerned that it's time for dictator.

                      Dr G 14:02
                      Oh, wow. That just happened also quickly, they're like, I saw them training over there. And I'm now really quite concerned and a console is not going to be enough for this situation.

                      Dr Rad 14:13
                      I really feel like if I were to characterize room in the 430s, at least as it's coming through in the sauces, it's that once they pop that cherry with one dictator, they can't help but keep going forward again. And again. It's just like, you know, it's kind of a bad habit. Really, it's a reflex.

                      Dr G 14:32
                      Well, this is interesting, actually, because I've just started reading Wilson's book on the evolution of the dictator. And part of the argument that he is setting up is to assert that the dictator has always been a feature of the Roman Republic. And is indeed, you know, it comes into being with the Republic itself very early on in the piece. And so, in a way in this early period is part of the way that Romans do business. If They see a situation where they're like, no, no, we need one person in charge for this, even if it's just for a limited time, they have that position in reserve, knowing that they could use it at any time. So that it's this kind of part of the way that they may be their business as usual practice in this early period of the Republic, because we're certainly entering in this phase where we're seeing a lot of them. And we're going to continue to see a lot of them for quite some time.

                      Dr Rad 15:29
                      Oh, yeah. And look I suppose it's a bit like if you're in a plane, and the plane starts to get into trouble, you're not going to be like, wait, wait, let's see how this plays out. You're going to pull the parachute Goddamnit, get the hell out of there. So I understand the instinct. But it does seem like in the 430s, they're particularly prone to calling on a dictator. I guess, it ties into this bigger picture that we've often talked about that Rome is not in its best way at this point in time. It's not it's not his best self, in this time and the Republic?

                      Dr G 16:01
                      No, and it's really I think, part of what we're learning through this process of the 430s. And even the previous decade, and potentially, the decades to come, I haven't read that far ahead, I'm trying to keep it fresh for myself, is that Rome is really trying to establish itself. And it's a consolidation period. And this means conflicts because they need to figure out where they sit in the pecking order of Central Italy. And it's just going around in circles.

                      Dr Rad 16:30
                      I think that's definitely what we can see. Now, interestingly, in the future, of course, it'd be the Senate that always gets the power to decide when is room officially in a state of emergency at this point in time, although the Senate are the people that are like, you know, what, I think we need a dictator, they're training awfully hard. It's not like they're official right at this point in time as it would kind of become their their business, if you like, in a few centuries time. Now, it might seem a little bit odd that the Romans are so nervous at this point in time, because of course, they have trounced the Aequians and the Volscians countless times in the past. I mean, I actually honestly could not tell you how many times we have related a story where the Aequians and the Volsicans have been defeated by Rome.

                      Dr G 17:21
                      And look at some of them have been at Mount Algidum as well now to guide us, which is this spot in the Alban hills to the south east of Rome, which is traditionally linked to Aequian territory. So it's, it's not like this hasn't, it feels like we're a bit on a repeat. We're like a DJ doing. And it's like, here we are, again, guys. It's ah Mount Algidus. And who knows what's gonna happen here, but probably Rome.

                      Dr Rad 17:49
                      Exactly. Well, the reason why they're a little bit more nervous than usual, perhaps in spite of their amazing track record, is that not only do those Aequians and Volscians seems to be training very hard. I don't know what that means. But they they're doing the whole

                      Dr G 18:05
                      I hope this means that they have their shirts off.

                      I think it does. I think they're doing the pumping iron montage, you know, it's all looking pretty scary

                      Too to doo. Too to doo.

                      Dr Rad 18:15
                      Exactly. And “Eye of the Tiger” is playing, you know, they're running up and down stairs, it's not good. Anyway, on top of that, though, of course, we have to remember what Rome has just emerged from which is a pretty serious plague. A lot of young Roman men have died during his time. So I guess we're in feels like it's not at full strength.

                      Dr G 18:34
                      And the ones that are left with them, they got like little chicken legs that like I haven't been able to get back to leg day. I don't know what to tell you not feeling confident going into this.

                      Dr Rad 18:42
                      These thighs are not intimidating enough. But this is my favorite detail. And I am so excited to share this with you. The little cherry on top of why the Romans are a bit more nervous than usual. Why they call on a dictator is that the consuls do not get on at all.

                      Dr G 19:04
                      Oh, they voted these two guys in and they're like these guys are like nup can't stand him

                      Dr Rad 19:09
                      Yeah,

                      Dr G 19:09
                      The man's a jerk

                      Dr Rad 19:10
                      They're like the odd couple, but without the sweet, sentimental moments where actually they do care about each other.

                      Dr G 19:17
                      Okay, so they don't get along and it seems like they're gonna be unable to come to any unified decision if it comes to war.

                      Dr Rad 19:23
                      Exactly now this is another little intriguing detail that let me throw this out there. He reports that some writers have recorded that the consuls actually went to war and fought a battle at Mount Algidus and were defeated, hence the dictator being appointed. But that's all he'll give me. So I'm using my flesh rabbits. Some writers who the who?

                      Dr G 19:47
                      It sounds pretty awkward for the consuls, though. Like they tried to get their shit together even though they didn't like each other and it really didn't work out. Now everyone's like, you know what? Just go well,

                      Dr Rad 19:59
                      there is one thing that they agree upon one thing and that is no dictator, no dictator, dictator, when it cancels, we want to be in charge.

                      Dr G 20:12
                      This is going to be a real slap in the face. I think for Cincinnatus son of the legendary Cincinnatus, twice dictator.

                      Dr Rad 20:19
                      Exactly, exactly. And so we're like, yeah, they're resisting the constants are like no no no dictator. We don't want a dictator no stop talking to a Senate. We don't want to hear it right now. But the information about the Aequians and the Volscians and their forces is just getting more and more concerning. Rome is getting increasingly worried the council's are still not listening to the advice of the Senate.

                      Dr G 20:43
                      The reporters on the ground at Mount Algidus are drawing sketches of how well muscled the enemy is and sending those sketches back to Rome and people are getting increasingly concerned being like, those guys are developing muscle at a rate I've never seen before. They're getting bigger day by day, we have to do something before they explode.

                      Dr Rad 21:01
                      Exactly, if we don't go to battle, they're training will mean that they are so much better than they need to be. They're gonna be unstoppable. Exactly. So at this point in time, one Quintus Servilius Priscus, who was a very respected elite Roman man for the previous positions that he had held within the state appeals to none other than the tribune of the plebs. Yeah, that's right, a patrician turning to the tribune of the plebs, desperate times in deed. He says, You guys are annoying. Can you please be annoying right now and use your authority to force the consuls to name a dictator?

                      Dr G 21:46
                      Wow.

                      Dr Rad 21:47
                      Yeah.

                      Dr G 21:48
                      That's fascinating.

                      Dr Rad 21:49
                      I know. Now the tribunes of course say, hey, people need us we're wanted. They like me. They like me. And they see this as a golden opportunity to increase their own power, because the tribute is the worst. So they start chatting amongst themselves being like, conspire, conspire, because how are we going to use this to our advantage? They then declare that the tribunes all think that the consoles should obey the Senate, and that if they keep resisting, they should be thrown in prison. Oh, that'll teach them. Yeah, absolutely. The consuls, understandably, are outraged that the tributes have been used against them. They're like that is no bigger slap in the face. Than you guys turning to our arch nemesis, the tribune of the plebs.

                      Dr G 22:46
                      Like this is insulting. And I also do not want to go to jail.

                      Dr Rad 22:50
                      Well, perhaps they have a point in the sense that they're like, if you actually allow this to happen, like allow the consuls to be thrown in prison for not doing what they're told by other people like the tribune of the plebs, then you are just undermining the authority of the office. Now. I do hate the patricians, but they do have a point about a dangerous precedent, because we know that the Romans are all about precedent.

                      Dr G 23:19
                      Yes, this is really interesting, actually, because this is going to feed into the one story that I have for this year, which doesn't come until much later.

                      Dr Rad 23:27
                      Okay. Anyway, so it's finally decided by a lot. I mean, after that objection is noted. They're like, great, whatever. They decide by a lot that Titus Quintus as in Cincinnatus. 3.0, is going to be the one who's going to be allowed to pick the dictator. And so he turns to Aulus Postumius Tubertus, who was his father-in-law, who was very well respected and very strict, apparently

                      Dr G 23:55
                      has a bit of a reputation.

                      Dr Rad 23:57
                      And he of course, then chooses Lucius Iulius as his Master of the Horse, as you said earlier.

                      Dr G 23:57
                      Hmm.

                      Dr Rad 24:05
                      Now, I'm just going to flag here. There have been questions raised about the legitimacy and timing of this dictatorship. did happen in this year? Maybe, maybe not. Maybe it was a year earlier. Maybe it was invented.

                      Dr G 24:19
                      This is a chaotic time for the chronology. There is no doubt about that. So it wouldn't surprise me that everything that we're sort of talking about that we're assigning to particularly years could be anywhere between a particular decade to be honest.

                      Dr Rad 24:33
                      I think this stuff happened. But yes, I can see that the timing might be the issue.

                      Dr G 24:39
                      I think this story about Tubertus certainly has some legs and there is some lingering sort of aftermath of this, of this whole situation. So even if it's not in this year, I'm just going to foreshadow that. It seems like people across the board believe that it happened.

                      Dr Rad 25:00
                      I agree, I agree Anywho. So a levy is declared. And this is a serious levy. This is not just like your regular levy. This is one where all legal business is stopped in the city because everyone should be doing their bit to get ready for war. In fact, it's so serious that men who might normally be able to claim some sort of exemption from military service, for whatever reason, are told we don't have time to deal with your cases, buddy. You're just gonna have to put your name down and turn up on the day. If you don't, you're going to be treated like a deserter.

                      Dr G 25:40
                      What about my tennis elbow?

                      Dr Rad 25:42
                      Too bad!

                      Dr G 25:43
                      I can't possibly swing a sword.

                      Dr Rad 25:45
                      Too much time on the courts, pal. Get your arse in line. Yes. So basically, because this is like a state of emergency. No cases of exception are going to be considered not even like after everything's said and done. It's not like you can turn up with your little medical note and be like, I know I didn't turn up but my doctor did say that I can't have balls fly at my face. You know, that kind of thing. Yeah. Now they also they also enroll people from the her nations and the Latins. Their ally

                      Dr G 26:17
                      Classic allies

                      Dr Rad 26:18
                      Classic allies exactly. Now they then kind of divide and conquer. So Gnaeus Julius, the consul, and Lucius Iulius, the Master of the Horse are both assigned to Rome. So that makes sense, but the constants up if they don't get along. Now, this is supposed to ensure that if there are any sudden issues that arise, they'll be able to be handled by these two guys who are being left in charge. And their main priority is obviously to make sure that the needs of the army are being met, and that the city are supporting that goal. So far, so good, all makes sense. Now, at this point in time, our dictator promises that there will be games glorious games, if Rome wins, and he is basically repeating a promise apparently made by the Pontifex Maximus at the time, one Aulus Cornelius Cossus perhaps? Yeah, he said there would be great games if everyone was victorious. So we're all on board with the whole let's, let's celebrate if we win. Yeah, that sounds like a good idea. Now, the dictator Postumius, he splits his army up with a consul that he's been paired with, who is – I don't really know what to call him – I don't want to call him Cincinnatus. I guess Quintus. I'll call him Quintus

                      Dr G 27:37
                      You could call him Poenus, because that's one of his names and it doesn't come up. It hasn't come up very much so far.

                      Dr Rad 27:44
                      No, it's actually an odd name “sideways”. It has something to do with some connection with Carthage or being a Carthaginian or something like that.

                      Dr G 27:52
                      Yeah. So I mean, maybe call in Poenus Cincinnatus.

                      Dr Rad 27:56
                      Okay. Poenus Cincinnatus, so they've divided up the army, and they're going out to deal with the Aequians and the Volsicians. Now, the Romans had noticed the way that the Aequians and Volsicians were kept separately, but close together, so they do the same thing. So you've got Postumius with his own camp, and Quinctius Poenus with his own camp. Now the locations that levy gives me apparently do not make sense. I haven't set this up. Personally, I am using Ogilvie an academic who apparently knows a bit more than I do about geography. So Livy says that the stimulus was closer to Tusculum. And that Quinctius Poenus was nearer to Lanuvium. However, apparently, Lanuvium is separated by the Alban Hills from Tusculum. And therefore not really near the site of battle. So don't really know what that means. Yeah, that's fine. It's all relative. Who knows what this means?

                      Dr G 28:53
                      I think this requires us to take a trip to Rome in order to investigate the geography for ourselves.

                      Dr Rad 28:59
                      Absolutely, Patrons, get on it. We need to sort out this geography. Once the Roman camps are set up. Small scale skirmishes begin between the Romans and the Aeuqian and Volscian forces and Postumius is like, Yeah, and you know what, why not? Why not skirmish away. Go ahead, indulge yourself, knock yourself out. You know what, maybe this is the way that we're going to just win the war. So he's just like, Yep, this is how we're going to do it. Just like low level, low pressure engagements at slow and steady. Yeah. And it does seem to have that kind of effects because eventually the Aequians and the Volscians become increasingly desperate, so much so that they decide to hatch an evil plan. They're going to ambush the consul's camp in the nighttime.

                      Da-da-daaaa!

                      Exactly. Unfortunately for them, the alarm is raised before they do that much damage.

                      Dr G 29:59
                      If it's like a classic comedic situation being like, you know what we'll do, we'll do this. Oh no, the alarm system!

                      Dr Rad 30:06
                      Exactly like they've, you know, they've made some headway but not much. So Quinctius Poenus he springs into action. He immediately is like, Well, more guards, more security quickly, schnell schnell. And so everybody springs into action. And of course, our dictator Postumius immediately sends over reinforcements to help out his colleague in arms, and they are put under the command of a lieutenant Spurius Postumius Albus, our old friend.

                      Dr G 30:38
                      Oh.

                      Dr Rad 30:39
                      So Postumius and part of his army, they now move themselves to a location where they can't be seen during the battle that is going on. So this way, I think they're setting themselves up obviously for like an ambush of the enemy at an opportune moment. Sneaky.

                      Dr G 30:58
                      Where did those guys go? I don't know. That has gone.

                      Dr Rad 31:01
                      Yeah, exactly. Now, of course, since he's no longer present in the camp that he had set up, he has to leave behind a lieutenant in charge, and this is Quintus Sulpicius. So that's one of our other lieutenants. Now he's out another lieutenant, we're taking them off becomes another one, because another one Marcus Fabius, our fabulous Fabian, another lieutenant, he is placed in charge of the cavalry. But no, he is ordered to wait until daybreak to do anything, because it's way too hard to use your cavalry in the nighttime.

                      Dr G 31:39
                      Yeah, do not charge the horses in the dark. Yeah, it will go wrong.

                      Dr Rad 31:43
                      So Postumius is obviously justifying the choice of himself as dictator, because he's just doing everything right. He then decides he's going to actually attack the enemy camp, because of course, they have depleted the forces in their camp in order to attack the Roman camp of the consular. Clever. Yeah. So once again, I've got another Lieutenant for you, Marcus Gaganius. And some of the cohorts are sent to ambush the camp. And again, yes, finds that the people at the camp were completely fixated on like, what was happening with the attack on the consul's camp, so they're sitting there eating popcorn, they've got their 3D glasses on. They weren't really paying attention to security of their own campsite. So when he attacks, he seems to take it pretty easily, and is therefore able to send up a smoke signal that he had pre arranged with Postumius to be like, job done. Tick, tick.

                      Dr G 32:40
                      Nice. Yeah.

                      Dr Rad 32:41
                      So Postumius

                      Dr G 32:42
                      So far, so smooth.

                      Dr Rad 32:43
                      Yeah. So Postumius sends out word to everybody. It's all good. Everybody the camps been captured. We're making great progress here. And then daybreak, which means enter the cavalry. And…

                      Dr G 32:56
                      I was gonna say, the charge of the horse.

                      Dr Rad 32:58
                      Exactly, exactly. And also, our friend Quinctius Poenus, he now feels that he can properly engage with the enemy. I think he feels that things have definitely turned in their favor. Daybreak. It's a bit easier, obviously, you know, to deal with the situation. And plus dubious of course, is going to ambush the enemy from behind. So it's looking pretty grim for the aqueous and the vowel skins. I mean, they seem to be trapped from a lot of different directions.

                      Dr G 33:27
                      I was gonna say this is more than a pincer movement. They've got them surrounded.

                      Dr Rad 33:31
                      However, it's time for a hero, Dr. G.

                      Dr G 33:34
                      A what?

                      Dr Rad 33:35
                      A hero!

                      Dr G 33:36
                      We don't we don't have one already?

                      Dr Rad 33:38
                      No, a hero on the other side.

                      Dr G 33:40
                      Oh,

                      Dr Rad 33:41
                      Yeah. So one Volscian called Vettius Messius.

                      Dr G 33:47
                      Vettius Messius? Amazing. I love this guy already.

                      Dr Rad 33:51
                      I know. So Ogilvie has suggested that he is crafted very much in the form of a Homeric hero. And so he steps in. He's not maybe it's because he's so well. He's been doing a lot of training. Anyway, so he steps in. He's not a super elite guy. He's not from the most powerful volsky and family you've ever heard of, but he has earned respect from his people. Through his many impressive deeds, which live he does not take the time to tell me about dammit, yeah. But he is the one that starts rallying the Aequians and the Volscians. He's like, Come on, guys. We can't give in. I know things will desperate. But this is not the time to surrender we have to fight on. Now. Whilst he might be a bit of a Homeric hero type character that's stepping into our story here. Ogilvie thinks that he is a genuine person, or at least like there's some basis for him in reality, because messiness is apparently an Oscan name.

                      Dr G 34:59
                      Hmm.

                      Dr Rad 35:01
                      Yeah, it's like a it's like related to the name Mettius, which we've seen before, like Mettius Fufetius, another favorite name of ours from our past episode. And you can apparently find the name Vettius in Etruria and also Sabine country.

                      Dr G 35:20
                      Oh, interesting. Okay, so he's got a name that's not doesn't sit in within the sort of like the Roman history of names. It sits in that surrounding area of Italy. So, you know, if they've made him up, at least they got the detail right about where his name might have come.

                      Dr Rad 35:38
                      Exactly. So the fight against the Romans is now renewed because they have their hero standing up for them.

                      Dr G 35:47
                      I need a hero.

                      Dr Rad 35:48
                      Yes, exactly. So they start attacking the Romans who are under our friend, I'm just gonna call him Albus. The other Postumius, because otherwise, it's way too confusing. So our friend Albus is being attacked and the Romans are actually being driven back such is there further in this fight. But this is when the dictator Postumius' men show up and there's really fierce fighting happening. The Romans are determined, but Messius is there, and they're just as determined it's up. It's crazy. Dr. G, so many people get hurt, so many people die. This is the mark of a great battle. And Roman leaders even get hurt. So it would seem

                      Dr G 36:34
                      Oh, that's rare.

                      Dr Rad 36:36
                      So it would seem that our lieutenant Postumius Albus is the only one who is sort of taken for the battle because his head has been badly injured by a stone.

                      Dr G 36:48
                      Oh, no. Alright.

                      Dr Rad 36:50
                      The dictator, Postumius, he's fighting on but he's received a pretty serious shoulder injury, and Fabius – and I don't really understand how this works, and to be honest, I don't want to have it explained to me – Fabius apparently his thigh. He's somehow been injured in a way that's pinning him to his horse.

                      Dr G 37:11
                      Oh.

                      Dr Rad 37:12
                      Yeah.

                      Dr G 37:12
                      Oh, that's not good.

                      Dr Rad 37:14
                      I don't I'm

                      Dr G 37:15
                      Not good for him and not good for the horse.

                      Dr Rad 37:16
                      I'm kind of hoping that means the horse gently fell over. But I don't think that's the case. And Quinctius Poenus has sustained a serious injury is one of his arms. I actually think that Livy means that he's lost one of his arms.

                      Dr G 37:33
                      Well, that is pretty serious.

                      Dr Rad 37:35
                      Now, apparently, this is an this whole episode bears an uncanny resemblance to some of the happenings of the Iliad.

                      Dr G 37:45
                      Hmm.

                      Dr Rad 37:46
                      So I'm once again going to cite Ogilvie who's highlighted that the injury sustained in the arm by Quinctius Poenus is very much like one sustained by Agamemnon, whereas the injury sustained by Fabius with the whole leg thing and being pinned, that is like Diomedes, and Iulius' damaged side and shoulder is also very similar to the other mentioned, we have to the the shoulder injury, and Hector was the one that got hit in the head with a stone and taken from the battlefield in this particular battle.

                      Dr G 38:27
                      Now, I don't want to ruin this theory, because obviously, Ogilvie is an excellent scholar and bless his soul. He was with us for too short a time. But when you're in an ancient battle, and you're on the battlefield, and you've got your ancient weapons, and you've got your horses, and you've got your rocks, how similar over time, are the injuries likely to be?

                      Dr Rad 38:53
                      I hear what you're saying, I just thought I'm gonna flag it because it does seem like a very strange coincidence. So we've got all these elite men on the battlefield. And the injuries that they sustained are very much like this particular battle in the Iliad.

                      Dr G 39:10
                      Yeah, I hear you. I hear you. I'm just gonna I'm gonna maintain my my small dose of skepticism.

                      Dr Rad 39:17
                      Oh, sure. Yeah, for sure. I totally get where you're coming from. But yeah, it's just one of those things where it's like,

                      Dr G 39:22
                      Is Livy trying to tell us that this battle is equivalent to the Iliad?

                      Dr Rad 39:30
                      No, I don't see I think that Livy has a tendency to make these Republican battles much more epic than they actually were. I see. I think that's definitely the case. Anywho So, Mercy is keeping up the fainting along with his band of courageous use of the vault scans. They end up trampling over the carcasses of slain Romans in their battle to make it back back to the Volscian camp. Because the Romans had seemingly captured the Aequian camp previously. Of course, they are pursued by the Romans. So they are followed by the dictator and the other Roman forces were another fierce and full on battle ensues at the camp itself. And it's apparently at this moment that Quinctius Poenus throws his standard into the stockade of the camp, encouraging the Romans to go and fetch, go get it, boy.

                      Dr G 40:32
                      The Romans love that kind of thing. We've seen some examples of this before where it's like, you know, there's nothing quite like holding on to the standard. And I know that Livy will be all across those kinds of narratives as well due to later moments in history.

                      Dr Rad 40:46
                      Exactly. And finally, this is apparently what enables them to break into the camp from one direction. And then from another direction, you've got the Romans making headway under the dictator. And this is where the Volscians just give up. They throw aside their weapons and they're like, you win, we surrender. We give up.

                      Dr G 41:04
                      Oh, no, this is a bad time. It's like so they're surrounded. And they, they give up.

                      Dr Rad 41:09
                      They do. So the camp is taken. Sadly, the men who are captured are sold into slavery, although Livy has an intriguing detail that senators were not sold into slavery.

                      Dr G 41:13
                      Hmm. Okay, all right. All right. But what do we know about Messius, then? Is he sold into slavery? Is he a senator of…

                      Dr Rad 41:36
                      Alas, I do not know, Dr. G. His fate is lost to history.

                      Dr G 41:40
                      It's a very mess-ius affair all round.

                      Dr Rad 41:42
                      It is Indeed. So the Romans capture a lot of booty because they've taken these two camps. They give a portion to their allies, the Latins and the Hernicians. Mostly stuff that seemingly was taken from them in the first place. But I guess it's the thought that counts.

                      Dr G 41:59
                      Here, have this back.

                      Dr Rad 42:00
                      Yeah, the rest is sold at auction by Postumius. Postumius then leaves Quinctius Poenus is in charge of the camp. And he goes back to Rome to do the right thing because of course, he is an all around awesome guy and lay down his power as a dictator. Now that mission accomplished.

                      Dr G 42:20
                      I've done that thing, and I no longer need to be the supreme leader of all of Rome.

                      Dr Rad 42:26
                      Exactly. Now, there is a weird little postscript to this whole affair, which is that there is a possibility that Aulus Postumius, our dictator's son, had been a part of this conflict.

                      Dr G 42:41
                      Oh, oh, I have a story on this. I will jump in. And then potentially you'll just correct me anyway, because my story myself, I don't have many sources. But the sources that I do have suggests something really quite interesting. So this is coming from Valerius Maximus sort of compiles lots of interesting tidbits of the past. And he talks about Postumius Tubertus, this dictator – really particular name, so he stands out in any material he appears in – as being like one of the great dictators, and really sort of amps up this guy. And I will read out the quote, I think, because it is there's a lot of flourish here, which I think is worth noting. “So there I too Postumius Tubertus and Manlius Torquatus (another guy that comes up later in history) strictest guardians of war-like concerns. I feel hesitation as I include you in memorial narratives, because I perceive that overwhelmed by the weight of the glory you have deserved, I shall reveal the insufficiency of my abilities, rather than present your virtue in its proper light.” So he's kind of like, I don't think I can tell this story and do it justice: this is how great you are. “For you, dictator Postumius, you had a son, Aulus Postumius, whom you had been gotten to propagate the succession of your line, and innermost rights, whose infant blandishments you had fostered in your bosom with kisses, taught him letters as a boy, arms as a young man, blameless, brave, loving you as he loved his country. But because he went forth from his post, and routed the enemy of his own motion, and not by your bidding, you ordered the victor, to be beheaded. And your fortitude availed to the using of your parental voice, for the execution of this command. For I am well assured that your eyes overspread with darkness and broader stay, could not look upon them. might work of your spirit.” So like we've got this story where it's like, his son is part of the command structure somehow in this battle, and we don't have him listed anywhere in the official records, but apparently sees an opportunity, takes the initiative as a commander. And because he wasn't given the direct order, by the dictator, his father, he shouldn't have executed he shouldn't have gone forward with with moving into the battle. And because he comes back victorious, maybe the son thinks, you know, all will be forgiven, you know, all they did was see an opportunity and go for it. And isn't that you know, the mark of virtus of a Roman military commander? And the answer to that is: very much not. Everything is about the structure of command, and the structure of command must be preserved at all times. And it becomes the duty of the dictator, to then perform the order to execute his own son. Horrifying.

                      Just like Brutus, eh!

                      Well, I feel like this is kind of the moment where we can see how, at the end of the Regal period where we have that situation with Lucretia upholding what is this sort of ideal feminine virtue within the constructs of patriarchy, and the toxicity of that moment, we can see the same sort of toxic element of Roman patriarchy now playing out and how it works for the men. Because this is a moment where a military commander, having won the day his son has contributed to that, but because it hasn't happened in the right sequence, he has to perform this execution. And it's a tragedy all around.

                      Dr Rad 46:54
                      Absolutely. So that's pretty much the story that I get as well that Postumius who obviously has this connection, this family connection to the great Postumius who had helped to secure that victory at Regillus. You've also got obviously other Postumii involved in the battle. But yes, in this moment of triumph, he has to come home and execute his son by having him beheaded, because he left his post when he was specifically ordered not to. The only detail that I can add on is that Livy does not believe that this is the case. Now, I love his reasoning for it. And okay, yes, this isn't this is the translator talking but I think it captures – I'm gonna run with it. He says that no one wants to believe this story. And the diversity of opinion allows one to reject it.

                      Dr G 47:49
                      Is this Livy, not naming his sources again?

                      Dr Rad 47:52
                      It is. But I just love the idea that look, everybody has an opinion about this story. And we all think Postumius, is an amazing guy, and nobody wants to believe he would execute his own son. So let's just say didn't happen.

                      Dr G 48:04
                      I don't want to believe.

                      Dr Rad 48:06
                      Yeah, one of the reasons that he cites is that there is a similar story, as you've alluded to, which we'll come to again later on with a guy called Titus Manlius. So Titus Manlius, his his son had also defied his father's orders and entered into a fight when he wasn't supposed to. And even though he won the fight, his dad felt it was necessary to assert the authority of a console and therefore had him bound to a stake and his head cut off. And this therefore gave rise to a particular saying about Manlian discipline. Now, Livy thinks that, I guess because this happened later, perhaps, that it would make any sense for them to have the saying of Manlian discipline, if Postumius was the one who did it first. And also Manlius was known to be so strict that he was given the surname, Imperiosus, Imperiosus, or “The Despotic” and Postumius wasn't given anything like that. So even though he was known to be, like, strict and stern, as a Roman man was supposed to be, particularly he's in a position of authority. Maybe he didn't go quite that far.

                      Dr G 49:20
                      Yeah, it's I wonder, then when where the story kind of derives from and wonder if maybe what we're getting here is – and this is just pure speculation, there's no way to prove this one way or the other – whether this is part of a family story of the Postumii that is told amongst themselves in order to explain the death of a young man somewhere in their line. And that somehow that's worked its way into sort of a greater imagination at some point, but maybe doesn't make it into all of the records.

                      Dr Rad 49:54
                      There's definitely confusion about it. And so I wouldn't be surprised as you say, if this is some sort of family lore or oral history or something like that.

                      Dr G 50:02
                      Well, all I can say is that Valerius Maximus clearly leans into the narrative and gets super emotional in his recap of it. So definitely one of the people that's sort of sitting on the opposite side of the fence to Livy on this one.

                      Dr Rad 50:19
                      Although I think they do share in common their admiration for Postumius, this particular Postumius amongst other Postumiuses. So I do have a tiny little bit of detail to finish off the year, which is hilariously anticlimactic, but I'm gonna throw it at you anyway. So now that all this is all wrapped up, Gnaeus Julius comes back. And he makes the official dedication to the Temple of Apollo, which had been promised to the god back in 433, allegedly, when there was that year of really bad plague. Now, he did not wait for his colleague Quinctius Poenus, to come back for them to draw lots about who had the right to do the dedication, because Quinctius, of course, is still out minding the camp that was left behind by the dictator.

                      Dr G 51:10
                      These two really don't get along, do they?

                      Dr Rad 51:12
                      Oh, boy, oh boy is Quinctius upset when he comes back and finds that this is what has happened. Because of course, you can't undo a dedication of a temple.

                      Dr G 51:22
                      Yeah, if the gods say it's okay to do it. You go ahead with it. Yeah. Really awkward.

                      Dr Rad 51:27
                      Yeah. So he therefore makes a formal complaint to the Senate who do nothing.

                      Dr G 51:34
                      Amazing.

                      Dr Rad 51:35
                      Yeah. Which I just thought again, sometimes, even in the midst of doing something, it's not every day that someone these days would dedicate a temple. And yet, the toxic workplace, the HR that does nothing.

                      Dr G 51:51
                      I can't believe you would undermine me like that. I'm gonna put in a complaint.

                      Dr Rad 51:55
                      Yeah.

                      Dr G 51:56
                      Why have I never heard back?

                      Dr Rad 51:58
                      And did so I thought that was just a hilarious little side note to add to wrap up the year 431 before we head into the Partial Pick. All right, Dr. G, tell us what the Partial Pick is all about

                      Dr G 52:17
                      The Partial Pick. Well, we evaluate Rome by its own criteria, which means sometimes they do fabulously. And sometimes they do terribly. They can win up to 50 Golden Eagles across five categories out of 10 each. So first cab off the rank is military clout.

                      Dr Rad 52:37
                      Oh, yeah. I mean, this has got to be a high one. I think

                      Dr G 52:42
                      they did route them in the end after fierce fighting in many quarters.

                      Dr Rad 52:48
                      And they don't really seem to have ever put a foot wrong.

                      Dr G 52:51
                      That's true. Yeah. Hit the cavalry. That was a good move.

                      Dr Rad 52:56
                      Yep. sneak attacks. Working as a team. Yeah.

                      Dr G 52:59
                      Throwing a standard into a camp. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, despite I mean, all of the commanders seem to get injured in fantastically Homeric ways. But aside from that, or good, I mean, this as long as the scars are on the front, still. Okay.

                      Dr Rad 53:15
                      Absolutely. So is it a 10? Or is that too high?

                      Dr G 53:19
                      No, I think it might be a 10. Because everybody loves this dictator. It seems like the legacy of the narrative is like this guy was great.

                      Dr Rad 53:27
                      Yeah. Okay, so we're on a 10. Good start, or we've already beaten that previous goal. Let's just stop.

                      Dr G 53:35
                      Diplomacy.

                      Dr Rad 53:37
                      I think we have agreed in the past that when war is happening, it tends to imply that diplomacy is not,

                      Dr G 53:42
                      but they do give the spoils to the Latins and the Hernicians that were their spoils in the beginning. That seems a pretty nice thing to do.

                      Dr Rad 53:53
                      I guess there's a certain diplomacy involved in that. But I again, I'm only going to give them the one Dr. G.

                      Dr G 54:01
                      Always having to convince you on the diplomacy.

                      Dr Rad 54:04
                      They're not they're not a very diplomatic people. They're just not.

                      Dr G 54:06
                      That's true. That's yeah, yeah. Expansion.

                      Dr Rad 54:09
                      No, I mean, they they're just fighting, I think a defensive or at this point in time.

                      Dr G 54:14
                      Yeah. There's no claiming of territory, really. Virtus?

                      Dr Rad 54:17
                      Yes. I think that would be a yes.

                      Dr G 54:20
                      Incredible amounts of virtus on display.

                      Dr Rad 54:23
                      Yeah,

                      Dr G 54:23
                      Wounded shoulders being pinned to horses, conking a stone in their head. It's all happening. And also that final tragic story, whether we believe it or not, is actually a huge example of the way that Romans think about virtus as well. Like, what is the most important thing for a Roman man, and part of it is to prioritize Rome over anything else.

                      Dr Rad 54:49
                      And there's nothing more precious than a son.

                      Dr G 54:52
                      Hmm,

                      Dr Rad 54:53
                      Yeah.

                      Dr G 54:54
                      So that that is a big thing to do.

                      Dr Rad 54:56
                      Yeah.

                      Dr G 54:56
                      And it seems that like it was super important that he did it. In order to maintain the structures as they stand.

                      Dr Rad 55:04
                      So is that going to be a 10? out of 10? Again?

                      Dr G 55:07
                      I feel like it yeah.

                      Dr Rad 55:08
                      Okay. All right. Let's do it.

                      Dr G 55:09
                      Horrifyingly so.

                      Dr Rad 55:11
                      Yeah. Who would have known that the execution of children is what would bring us to this point?

                      Dr G 55:18
                      It was old enough to be in battle. I don't think I mean, he was a child in the sense that you know, that his father did it. But, uh, you know, anyway, yeah. The citizens score.

                      Dr Rad 55:29
                      But there's not much specific mention of citizens, apart from the fact that there's no Get Out of Jail Free card in this battle.

                      Dr G 55:37
                      No, it's not a it's not a great levy to be part of. No,

                      Dr Rad 55:41
                      but on the other hand, there are no specific complaints. So

                      Dr G 55:49
                      Are complaints permitted under a dictator?

                      Dr Rad 55:52
                      Well, he's not always in charge. There's no specific complaints mentioned in the lead up to him being appointed, you know whether consuls are bickering.

                      Dr G 56:04
                      Yeah, look, I don't want to say that the absence of evidence means that it's definitely not happening, but

                      Dr Rad 56:13
                      Oh, no, I don't think it's great. I would, I would wait, I would fall on the side of it not being a great time because there's conflict. Nobody's accepting any excuses. Room is victorious. Okay. It could be a lot worse, but

                      Dr G 56:29
                      People definitely have to die for that to happen. It's not like they get out unscathed.

                      Dr Rad 56:33
                      Exactly. So when are we going to say like a three? Yeah, maybe a two or three? Yeah. Okay. Well, let's say three. That means that room has a grand total of 24 Golden Eagles. They're so close to getting a pass.

                      Dr G 56:53
                      One day soon.

                      Dr Rad 56:55
                      But you know, that's a massive improvement from our previous episode, which was one.

                      Dr G 56:59
                      Yeah, look, they've come a long way in just a year. It's amazing what a couple of great battles and a dictator will do for you.

                      Dr Rad 57:05
                      Exactly, exactly. Well, thanks so much for telling me all about another glorious Postumius to add to my collection.

                      Dr G 57:15
                      It's been an absolute pleasure. And thank you so much for sharing all of these details about 431. I knew so little going in, and now I feel so enriched.

                      Dr Rad 57:23
                      Don't thank me. Thank Livy.

                      Dr G 57:30
                      On behalf of Dr. Rad and myself, I want to send a huge thank you to all of our listeners and supporters. As you may know, we have our new book, our first our only currently book coming out very soon it is called “Rex, The Seven Kings of Rome”. And if you're interested in pre ordering a copy, you'll need to head over to Highlands dash press.com to secure your copy. You'll be supporting an indie publisher, which is very much in keeping with what we're all about, as well as indie podcasters. And in keeping with our thanks to our patrons, we want to send a shout out to the following people as well. Alex, Amanda, Zara Ben CW Dariel David M. David R. David T. Dendrio, Dorian, Alicia and Erin, thank you so much for your support. And thank you for listening in.

                      Transcribed by https://otter.ai

                      For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


                      Support the show

                      Patreon

                      Ko-Fi


                      Read our books

                      Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

                      Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

                      Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

                      59 min
                    • Enslaved Women During Slave Revolts with Assistant Professor Katharine Huemoeller

                      We were thrilled to sit down and talk with Assistant Professor Katharine Huemoeller about her research into the representation of enslaved women during slave revolts in ancient Rome. This conversation reveals plenty of food for thought about the representation of women in the ancient world as well as exploring the way women go on to be represented in later eras.

                      Special Episode – Enslaved Women during Slave Revolts with Assistant Professor Katharine Huemoeller

                      The Slaves are Revolting

                      And rightly so. Conditions for enslaved people in ancient Rome could vary widely from difficult manual roles such as mining and agriculture to the challenges of proximity to enslavers in the domestic sphere. Human trafficking also has a significant role to play in understanding gladiators. Assistant Professor Huemoeller takes us through some of the main ways to consider slavery in Rome before turning our attention to three key slave revolts:

                      • Revolt of Volsinii (265 BCE)
                      • First Sicilian Slave War (135-132 BCE)
                      • Third Slave War/ Spartacus Slave War (73-71 BCE)

                      These examples offer the opportunity to consider enslaved women a little more closely and it's here that the conversation gets really interesting.

                      A coloured mosaic depicting two lovers together surrounded by attendants (likely slaves).
                      One pour liquid from a vessel; one attends beside the bed.
                      Image courtesy of Wikimedia Commons. Taken in the Kunsthistorisches Museum (Vienna, Austria)

                      Things to Listen Out for
                      • The role of menstruation during Spartacus' war against Rome!
                      • The agricultural uprising in Sicily and the ways in which slaves treated free women
                      • The challenges of reading with and against the evidence when it comes to the Volsinii
                      • And no conversation about Spartacus would be complete without a deep dive into the representation of women in Kirk Douglas' Spartacus (1960) and the more recent Starz series Spartacus: Blood and Sand

                      A painting called ‘The Slave Market' by Gustave Boulanger (1886) which shows a range of enslaved people waiting to be sold. Most wear discs around their neck indicating their enslaved status.

                      Music

                      Thanks to the glorious Bettina Joy de Guzman for our theme music.

                      Readings
                      • Huemoeller, Katharine P. D. 2021. ‘Sexual Violence in Republican Slave Revolts‘ in Kamen, D., Marshall, C. W. (eds.) Slavery and Sexuality in Classical Antiquity (University of Wisconsin Press), 159-173.
                      • Huemoeller, Katharine P. D. 2020. ‘Freedom in Marriage? Manumission for Marriage in the Roman World‘ The Journal of Roman Studies 110: 123-139.
                      • Huemoeller, Katharine P. D. 2021. ‘Captivity for All? Slave Status and Prisoners of War in the Roman Republic‘ TAPA 151.1: 101-125.
                      Automated Transcript

                      Generated by Otter AI. Hopes and prayers for the AI learning our Australian accents, Latin terms, and other very niche phrases!

                      Dr Rad 0:16
                      Welcome to The Partial Historians,

                      Dr G 0:19
                      we explore all the details of ancient Rome.

                      Dr Rad 0:23
                      Everything from the political scandals, the love of ours, the battles waged and when citizens turn against each other. I'm Dr. Rad

                      Dr G 0:34
                      and I'm Dr. G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.

                      Dr Rad 0:43
                      Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.

                      Welcome to a special episode of The Partial Historians, I am one of your hosts Dr. Rad

                      Dr G 1:07
                      and I'm Dr. G.

                      Dr Rad 1:09
                      We are joined by a very exciting guest who shares some of our interests today, we are joined by Professor Huemoeller. Assistant Professor Huemoeller worked for a nonprofit, the National Women's Law Centre in Washington, DC for several years before returning to the academic world. She has taught at Princeton University, Middlebury College, and at US correctional facilities through the prison teaching initiatives. She is currently the Assistant Professor of Roman History at the University of British Columbia. And we are very excited to talk to her today, because her special areas of interest include things like slavery and sexual violence, and we're going to be another word excited about sexual violence. But we're excited that we're going to be talking about issues of slavery and gender. That's probably what I should say. So welcome to the show.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 1:59
                      Thank you so much. That always happens to me. I can't wait to teach this class on slavery. It'll be interesting that Yeah.

                      Dr Rad 2:08
                      All right. So let's kick off with one of our introductory questions. So you've obviously written a lot about incidents of slave results in the Roman Republic, but just to set the scene for our listeners, can you tell us a little bit about the status of slaves in Rome?

                      Katharine Huemoeller 2:24
                      Yeah, absolutely. So I'll talk specifically about slaves in the Republican era, because slavery is quite distinct in different periods of Roman history. And it really sort of takes off in terms of numbers in the Italian peninsula, in the third and second centuries BCE, as Rome expands, more and more people are trafficked into Italy, and sold on the slave market. So there's a direct link between Roman conquest and the growth of the Roman Empire and the growth of the Roman slave system. But what slavery looked like and how it was experienced was extremely diverse. And some people were were employed on plantation style, agricultural estates, for surplus, you know, production of food, with very, very tough conditions, very harsh conditions, and very little chance of ever being manumitted, much less living a very long life. Other people lived in an urban context, or worked in a domestic context. And the lived conditions were perhaps a bit better than agricultural slavery. But it came with its own horrors, including proximity to owners, maybe increased chance of sexual violence and sexual exploitation, especially for enslaved women, but also for enslaved men. So it looked really different depending on who your owner was, and where you lived, and also, who you were, where you came from. And if you are a man or a woman or a child or an adult.

                      Dr G 3:58
                      Yeah, it's a there's a lot to take in when it comes to thinking about like the status of slaves in the ancient Roman world, just because there are so many diverse areas that somebody could end up in in terms of like, their place, either like, maybe it will be mining, maybe it will be in the field, maybe it will be in the home. And all of those come with their own risks. And to I don't think we should ever underestimate the nature of the human workforce that is being utilised in many ancient societies in particularly ancient Rome, just in terms of when you look back to see what was achieved and also the labour that was utilised to achieve those things. So thank you so much for giving us a bit of a taste of the things that are going to be coming out. As we delve further into the questions.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 4:53
                      That point about under estimating is an important one too, because the big challenge with ancient slavery is I mean, we can say It looks very diverse, that's clearly true. But it's hard to say much else definitively because our record for ancient slavery is is so difficult. And certain types of slavery, certain sleeving strategies appear appear more clearly in the historical record than others. So we have more information, for example, about agricultural slavery in this period, you know, and sort of less idea what's going on in a domestic context or more information about enslaved men than about enslaved women. So it's always the question of filling in these very large gaps in our archive.

                      Dr Rad 5:35
                      Oh, definitely. Look, we've found we've been looking at the Roman monarchy a bit because we've been working on a book on that period. And as you said, I tend to think of slavery more later in room's history, you know, during the Republic, when we start to see those big wars that are happening, and lots of people being captured in a conflict and then being made slaves, and then that obviously setting up the possibility of having more slaves because their people are bought into slavery, etc, etc. But the crazy thing was that when we actually stopped and looked at the records, there were references to slaves, and they were everywhere, even in that very early period. And whilst Okay, yeah, some things you know, you might look at them as being maybe troops or something like that. There's just so many references to think that slavery itself wasn't a part of Roman society, even all the way back at the beginning.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 6:27
                      Yeah, I completely agree. And I think there's still a lot of work to be done on these earlier forms of slavery. I mean, obviously, it's in the tall tables, which I know you guys covered. And that's a great indication that it's, you know, significant, and it's a maybe a fairly clear demarcated legal status. But then, of course, it's also, you know, only one of many different types of dependency in that period, including debt bondage, and, and maybe there was less of a clear line between these types of exploitation. And then the other issue, of course, is that I think in that early period, maybe there are more enslaved people coming from closer to the city of Rome, as opposed to from very far away. And so I expect there, you know, there's a difference there in terms of the relationship of ethnicity and slavery, but I think there's a lot more work to be done.

                      Dr G 7:17
                      Definitely. Yeah, once you start looking into the little tidbits that we do have access to is like, Yeah, you get the sense that this is a much wider picture. And there's much more that we can learn as we go along. So thinking about your work and where it has led you in your research, you have focused on three main revolts, slave revolts. So when people are rising up against these conditions that they have found themselves in their lack of agency, and then recapturing that through the process of revolt. And I'm wondering if we can just go through the details of them a little bit. So starting with the revolt of the Volsinii in 265 BCE? What's going on there?

                      Katharine Huemoeller 8:00
                      Yeah, this is one I really didn't know much about until I started researching this topic. This the Spartacus revolt is very famous, right?

                      Dr Rad 8:07
                      I've never heard of it.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 8:14
                      So um, so this revolt is as definitely more small scale earlier on right in the third century, middle third century. And the sources for it are a bit sketchy, but it is attested in multiple sources. And what seems to happen is that there's some sort of uprising in this atrocity and city. And it's a sort of class struggle, and the exact identity of the people rising after it is different in different sources. In some sources, they're enslaved people. And it's a serious enough for revolt that the city asks Rome to intervene and assist and, you know, setting the social order back to what it was. So that's, that's one of these revolts. And I think it's an interesting one, because it's clear that there's actually a lot of smaller scale revolts happening in the third and second century that we only hear little snippets about, but it seems actually to have been quite frequent. And Amy racialist has done some work on gathering these into a timeline in her slave theatre book. So, just recognising that probably this is happening quite frequently in the Italian peninsula and these two in these two centuries, even though you know, the ones we hear about are these larger scale ones that are called the really the first second and third servile wars essentially. So moving into the second one there, or the first one there, that's a little less than a century later and the 130s in on the island of Sicily. So, all of these are taking place, you know, I guess I say the Italian peninsula but including Sicily, so in you know, Italy, Southern Italy and Sicily, in regions where agriculture is, you know, predominant. And this first slave revolt is led by a charismatic figure named Yunus As who sort of rises up in one of the major cities in the Catanian plain of Sicily, again, this really important sort of grain producing region, and he manages to, you know, work with other enslaved people in the area to capture the city, and then the revolt spreads to the whole island. And you know, that's when, of course, Rome takes notice. And then the third one that's quite that I focus on is the Spartacus slave war, sometimes known as the third slave war, which again, is happening a little less than a century after that. So in the 70s BCE, and in this one, an interesting man, a very enigmatic man named Spartacus, who is maybe Thracian, maybe not, is captured and enslaved in a gladiatorial school in Capua, and manages to break out along with other enslaved Gladiators, and maybe his wife, but we'll get to that. And once again, you know, similarly to the first slave revolt, the revolt is sort of, at first seen as a minor thing, and not much effort is put to putting it down. And then it sort of grows in size as the rebel army starts to grow as encompasses other people, other enslaved people, but also maybe other free but disenfranchised people in the south of Italy. And it becomes a quite massive revolts that, you know, the Roman army actually takes a few years to suppress.

                      Dr Rad 11:29
                      Amazing, thank you so much for that. So obviously, there's a lot that is interesting about these slave revolts. But I believe the reason that you have focused on these ones in your article was that these revolts involve violence, and particularly, they are revolts that involve sexual violence. And we've got records of that. So what did you notice about the way this violence has been represented in the sources?

                      Katharine Huemoeller 11:57
                      Yeah, so these these revolts came to my notice, because I am currently working on a book project on the sexual exploitation of enslaved people. And what I noticed in these revolts is that one of the types of violence that the enslaved rebels are said to direct at the free people, and particularly at their enslavers is sexual violence. And so I was interested in looking at sort of what how that manifested itself, not so much to understand what happened during these revolts. But instead to understand from the perspective of these free writers, what did they think enslaved people wanted to rebel against? What kind of violence did they think they wanted to inflict on the Masters, understanding that this is essentially a sort of role reversal, where the enslaved people are said to inflict the types of violence that they themselves have experienced as slaves? So I thought this could tell me something about the conditions of slavery. What I found when I looked at the sources is that there's actually lots of different types of sexual violence that are inflicted on free people in these revolts. But it's all directed at free women. And so what we see is that the slave rebels are said to commit acts of rape, and other types of sexual outrage, essentially, it's very vague, to free matrons and to free virgins, and that these are done in front of their husbands or fathers. And that second part of that second detail clued me in to the fact that these acts are actually sort of intended to injure the free men, using the free women sort of as an instrument. And so that's, that's what I became interested in, through studying these is the way in which these enslaved men are sort of claiming the privileges of free masculinity in the revolts.

                      Dr G 13:56
                      Yeah, this is a really interesting aspect and insight into Roman sexuality, isn't it? Because the this ties back into these ideas about the power that is thought to be inherent from a Roman perspective in sexual encounters, where it's partly to do with the gender of the people involved, but it's also partly to do with how you place yourself in the patriarchal hierarchy of Roman society who gets to do who to white becomes super important for being able to like know exactly where you sit socially, not just sexually, and the utilisation of women in this not as sort of agents in their own right, but perhaps as vehicles for conveying something about Roman masculinity is not at all surprising, but incredibly infuriating. I feel like

                      Katharine Huemoeller 14:50
                      yeah, that Yeah, that's exactly right. What I've what I found is that it wasn't just that these enslaved men were raping the free women. It was also the If they were, for example, protecting some free women from rape and choosing to rape others, or so this idea that the free masculinity or hegemonic masculinity and Roman society is about not just getting to do what you want to other people, but choosing right, who experiences what and who was allowed to do what. And so that includes not only, you know, sexual violence directed and enslaved people, but also that includes the sort of protection or maybe you could say, I don't know, supervision, control of free women. So one of the stories that we get in the slave revolts is that the slave rebels choose this one teenage free woman who was very kind to them when they were enslaved, and they escort her to the house of her family members, and explicitly are protecting her sexual virtue. And I think that is as much a privilege of free masculinity, as you know, raping the matrons in front of their husbands.

                      Dr Rad 16:06
                      Absolutely. And I mean, obviously, this sexual violence is taking place in a broader context as well. Like, that's not the only privilege that they're claiming all of the time. And the one that particularly stood out to me in this regard is the the revolt of Athena, which I never really heard of before reading your article, as you said, it's the lesser known. So thinking about what the slaves might have been trying to achieve through their actions, you know, more broadly speaking, because I know that during that particular revolt, they take all sorts of crazy actions, you wouldn't expect slaves to, you know, to be able to take or to even maybe want to take in trying to, you know, set themselves up in a new way of life after their revolt. Yeah,

                      Katharine Huemoeller 16:49
                      this is a really interesting one. So supposedly, they, they sort of enact a number of reforms. It's actually very, it's very legalistic, rather than, you know, crazy violence, right. So one of the things they do is they become senators, they set up a sort of their own Senate. Another thing they do is they sort of rewrite the rules of inheritance. And it's a little unclear, either they become the heirs to their former owners, or they write their own wills, it's not clear which one and then they also rewrite the rule of stupid, which is illicit sex in Roman law. So this is technically happening in an attractive city, but extremely Roman. And always. And so what they say is that a free woman is is not allowed to get married to a free man, until an enslaved man has, has had sex with her first, which is just an extremely strange reform, and is again clearly linked to these ideas about what masculinity is and how to punish free men. And this is the sort of ultimate punishment right to make them marry a woman over whom they've had no control over her chastity or sexual virtue.

                      Dr G 18:05
                      I think this also tells us something about the nature of what our written sources, perhaps fear most, they're kind of writing a narrative about, like, what are they most afraid of happening to them? If the slaves succeed? This is not a narrative of how slaves might have pursued their own freedom or how they would have defined it. I don't know if I was a slave, I'd want to be my first task would be inheritance law, for instance.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 18:30
                      Right? Yeah, absolutely. This is like all of these sources are about what free people fear, they, I think have give us almost nothing about what actually happened with these revolts, or what the enslaved people want. But yeah, what's so notable about about their desires, as represented in these sources is that they just want to be the free men, they want to take over all of their life and their privileges and their wives and their daughters. There is nothing in these accounts, hardly about enslaved women, or children. Right. So the idea here is that these men, when they sort of take control of society, they want to marry the wives of their former owners. That is not like what we see, for example, in Roman comedy, which is from a similar time period, right in which matrons are like gross, no one wants. They're not. They're not like objects of desire, right? But in these narratives, they are like, these are the women who are raped or taken as wives by these by these freed slaves. And so what we're seeing there definitely is intended to show what emasculation looks like, I think in the Roman worlds, that's what's feared. And of course, you get that in the military context, right? The slaves are actually winning battles against the Romans. That's really embarrassing to and emasculating. And now we also see sort of what's emasculating in the private sphere in the home, or in the domestic sphere. Well, it's

                      Dr Rad 19:58
                      so fascinating that you mentioned this, but because we one of the categories that we use in our show, when we're ranking, the Romans performance when we're doing a narrative is where source. So this inherently masculine, you know, like value, I suppose you'd call it or quality. And we try and think of that as obviously the, in a way, it's like that right to take action, and to do so in a particular way. And it kind of ties into what you're talking about, I think a little bit here about what the slaves are trying to claim potentially.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 20:32
                      Yeah, absolutely. It's, it's definitely where to send the Roman the Roman definition of virtue of manliness, the ability to dictate what gets done to other people, all of these other people who are subordinate to the, you know, the free male head of household. And I think that this is really encapsulated in one other event from these revolts that we haven't talked about, which is a very another very strange one. It is the slave supposedly throw a funeral for a free captive matron, who has committed suicide, because she was raped by these slave rebels. And then to make this inversion even stronger, they force the men to perform the free men who are also captive here to perform gladiatorial combat, in honour of this woman at her funeral, because initially, that's where gladiatorial combat came from, it was a funeral thing. And so, you know, they're putting the men obviously in the position that they once were as gladiators. But they're also forcing them to, you know, to participate in this sort of strange mourning of this woman who they should have been able to protect but failed to.

                      Dr G 21:49
                      Yeah, it's a complicated situation for everybody to be in, I mean, the woman and what she went through that led her to her committing suicide, the situation where the roles have been reversed with the slaves and the Romans, and then the gladiatorial lair of a formal mourning process.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 22:09
                      And yeah, yeah, especially an interesting story. That's so yeah, ripe for analysis. I mean, she's very much the woman is like, very much like this Lucretia figure, right?

                      Dr Rad 22:18
                      Yeah. And so they that particular incident that you're talking about, I believe, takes place allegedly, in the third serve our war, or the Spartacus revolts, whatever you want to call it. And I believe it comes from a source, a rosiest? Yeah, who's writing a lot later, who's actually writing in a Christian context. And I think that this kind of highlights not that this is something that you're necessarily focusing on. But this sort of highlights, I suppose the issues that you must encounter with the varying kinds of source material that you're working with for the sorts of incidents?

                      Katharine Huemoeller 22:50
                      Oh, yeah, that's a huge problem. You're using a Christian source to look at sexual norms in the Roman world. It's gonna be quite different. Certainly, then, you know, Salas, for example, who's you know, writing in the Roman Republic, the sources for these revolts, especially, you know, as we'll go on to talk about for, you know, the presence of enslaved women and these revolts or the participation of women, these revolts there, so fragmentary and problematic, they've come down to us by chance, often, and they just kind of feel like they got in there by chance. Like, we weren't even supposed to know about this. Yeah.

                      Dr G 23:27
                      Yeah. Like, I feel like I've got a question forming that's related to the way that women are represented in these in these source materials. I mean, it's partly the Euros Yes, question, I suppose in that sort of like that Christian framing, although I do love a good a rose. Yes, he does a lot of things that we don't get to wear. But that sense in which none of these sources seem to really consider a woman's perspective. They're always a sort of utilitarian device in these narratives. And I'm wondering how much we can actually get out what it might have been like for these women, either as enslaved peoples, or ones who were free and become part of these enslaved narratives through these sorts of revolts with this role reversal stuff going on? Yeah,

                      Katharine Huemoeller 24:15
                      it's really tough. The women and the stories, both free and enslaved women are very much sort of instruments of male competition, you know, violence. Yeah, just they're sort of communicate with each other through these women is how I see it. And that's true of the free women and the enslaved women. So when it comes to trying to understand their experience of revolt, their role and participation in it, we kind of have to work against what our sources are doing frequently. So that's kind of a project I'm working on now is trying to understand the role of, of women in these revolts. It's quite clear that there were women present In all of these revolts, enslaved women present in the revolts because they kind of creep into the sources just occasionally. So you just get these sort of casual asides about them, which are very tantalising. And then so I'm trying to sort of use each of these very, you know, casual references, and you focus in on it and try to unpack what it can tell us about women and these revolts. So I could we could go through a few of them if you'd like, because they're really fascinating.

                      Dr Rad 25:28
                      I really hoping that this is the part where you're going to bring up the women who apparently separated themselves from the Spartacan army because they're almost exactly my favourite.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 25:36
                      They are my favourite example. We have to excitingly we have two references to this one incident, probably the same incident, where these two women are separated from the rest of the Spartacan army. They're on a hill of sorts. And they're doing something on that hill. And from the vantage point of the hill, they see the Roman army approaching, trying to stage an ambush, and they sound the alarm and the ambush fails. So what's so interesting about this, the sources that are this incident is that the two writers who record it, record different reasons for why the women are up there. So Salas, who's writing in the Republic tells us that the women were Adminster Russell window, which is you a phrase used in other texts, in reference to menstruation. But it basically means like carrying out their monthly things, duties,

                      Dr Rad 26:30
                      rituals, women's business.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 26:33
                      Yes, exactly.

                      Dr G 26:36
                      Just up on the hill doing what,

                      Katharine Huemoeller 26:38
                      we don't want to get too detailed about it, but there and then Plutarch, writing later, and probably looking at Sallust says that the two women are up there sacrificing or carrying out some sort of religious ritual. These things aren't mutually exclusive, of course, right? They might be carrying out some sort of monthly ritual.

                      Dr G 26:56
                      Look, I feel like in the ancient world, if I was menstruating, I would definitely want to have a ritual associated with that of some kind and be like, Gods what's going on? Yeah, it's been days. When does this stop?

                      Katharine Huemoeller 27:07
                      Yeah, yeah. But once you do it in the middle of a revolt,

                      Dr G 27:13
                      like it's tough, and it's like, you know, if you hang out with the revolt, and you're down on the ground, and it's happening, and the men are turning to you being like, Are you wounded? And you're like, I am? I am. That's definitely what's happening here. Like the enemies no where here. And there is definitely a situation, I don't know what to tell you. Like, maybe it would be easier to go up the hill and be like, you know, I just need some respite from this revolt. These guys. I don't know.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 27:38
                      Yeah. And I'm gonna take a friend with me here, the two of us are going off. Yeah, I mean, this. So this is a perfect example of the way these women sort of creep into our sources, because the only reason we even know about the stylist is that tiny fragment was excerpted for grammatical reasons. They liked the reference that women are Gallic, and there's this weird word for Gallic in it. So they're accepted by this later group, Marian. And then we have one single manuscript that preserves this reference by the Grimm Aryan. So that is how these women come down to us, like, by so many different elements of chance, and without the stylus, we would really not understand what foods are. So it's just like, they've kind of slipped into the record, I like to think of it that way. And, and so it's exciting opportunity for us to, to think about, you know, in what other ways they've slipped in, but also like, all of the ways that they're missing, but clearly there. So in this case, you know, my, what I think is so funny about this account is like, this is basically a very embarrassing situation for the Romans, they are already engaged in a war against enslaved people, which is embarrassing, and then they're, they're, you know, about to, you know, have this ambush and to women. Foreign enslaved women are the ones that spy

                      Dr Rad 28:57
                      on their periods like, yeah, it's

                      Katharine Huemoeller 29:00
                      Just like the worst of the worst for them, right?

                      Dr G 29:03
                      Yeah, it's hitting me, right in my virtus as a Roman man, I don't know.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 29:08
                      Talk about virtus, exactly. Like, of course, to me. Of course, these writers want to explain their presence. In other ways. They don't want to say, hey, they were up there scouting, and they were successful.

                      Dr G 29:21
                      Yeah, these women were actually great at reconnaissance. And that's why we sent them up there. And their sole job was to like, watch for the Army coming. And boy, did they nail that assignment?

                      Katharine Huemoeller 29:31
                      Exactly, exactly. Instead, they're like, well, they just happened to be up there. And like, you know, they were very lucky that they saw us, you know, and that's the other thing. It's like, why would why do we trust Plutarch or stylist to tell us with us? I remember doing I mean, it's crazy talk about like, you know, who has authority to tell us information? The Roman army would have maybe they would know they had been spied right. But they would have no idea like by who or why I mean, it just doesn't make sense.

                      Dr G 29:57
                      Oh, come on. There's gotta be somebody from ancient Rome Entertainment Tonight interviewing people afterwards. Like you were there. What did you see? What were you doing?

                      Katharine Huemoeller 30:06
                      Yeah, I mean, actually think that the most likely source is a cat a later captive, right? Because we know like Julius Caesar, for example, regularly interrogated captives to ask like what happened to them? And you know so so that's kind of interesting. But yeah, I just love this this incidence of you know what, to me very clearly is these women you know having a strategic role essentially in the military and instead are explained away for other reasons.

                      Dr Rad 30:32
                      He reminds me of one of my favourite scenes from Parks and Recreation, where the whole gang from Parks and Rec are out on a shooting trip, someone gets shot accidentally. And a polis character is trying to cover for how that's happened by taking responsibility herself because she has a gun licence and the person who did it doesn't. And so when she's being interviewed by the Ranger, or the sheriff, or whatever, she's like, I don't know, I'm wearing this bra that like open at the front, and it just threw me I want chocolate. I love my period, bitches be crazy.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 31:05
                      Every possible

                      Dr Rad 31:07
                      everything related to him and every stereotype at it, you'll it'll land, it'll land. And actually, I

                      Katharine Huemoeller 31:12
                      should note too, like, it'll lands not only with an ancient audience, but with a modern one. Because What's so weird about this source is that there is actually no attestation of menstrual seclusion. As a practice, no, in the West, like, that is not a thing. And yet everybody's like, Oh, there it is. So we knew it was happening here, too. And you're like, What is this the source we're gonna use for this? Really?

                      Dr G 31:34
                      You're one fragment that's from a single source. Good luck, guys. Yeah.

                      Dr Rad 31:42
                      So interesting. And then of course, the other woman that we we can't neglect to talk about is Spartacus' wife, very intriguing character.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 31:51
                      I was about to say Varinia. But then it was like, wait, no,

                      Dr Rad 31:53
                      I was about to say exactly the same thing. Because to me, she is for any issue will always be Varinia, yes. But if we're going by the ancient source material, the nameless woman that is known as Spartacus is why

                      Katharine Huemoeller 32:05
                      exactly, yeah, we have we here plutonic that Spartacus, basically it's sort of Plutarch introducing Spartacus as a character, a person and he says that he came from Thrace, and that he had a wife with him, who prophesized that he would be, you know, a great force, essentially, by seeing a snake curled up around his head, I think, and this was taking place in, you know, the slave market, and then somehow that they actually wound up together at the gladiatorial school, because he also, Plutarch also says that she was with him when he escaped, or she took part in the escape. So that's interesting, because it suggests right, that this idea that, you know, they were together for a longer period of time, and that they somehow managed to stay together. Yeah. Yeah. I think that fact especially has attracted a lot of attention and made them like kind of a good opportunity for romance, essentially. Because for a story, right, because it's so such an interesting, unusual detail.

                      Dr Rad 33:04
                      Absolutely. And she's such a, she's become so much a part of Spartacus as legend, I suppose in subsequent interpretations as well. She's been really fully fleshed out. But we have so little about her apart from the fact that she might have been, like some sort of profit tests. And that Yeah, and that she managed to stay by his side, which just seems so unlikely in given what we know about slave auctions and gladiatorial schools, it just seems so rare that they would still be together.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 33:34
                      This whole episode is we're like, no, that didn't happen. to happen. It didn't happen. But I was curious Dr. G, what, like, just because the other element of her that's interesting is right, that she's this really yeah, she's his profit figure. And then, you know, these other women that were part of the revolt were maybe, you know, engaged in sacrifice. So there is this sort of like aura of religiosity around these women. I was wondering what your take on that was, as you know, someone who's looked at?

                      Dr G 34:01
                      Yeah, look, I think it's really fascinating the way that when women crop up in narratives, it's one of the ways that's acceptable for them to do so is through the practice of ritual. And what we're seeing is that this pertains not just to Roman women, but to non Roman women as well, because the in all of these cases, we're dealing with, presumably enslaved women who have at this stage by the time we're in the Spartacus war period when we're talking about foreign slaves, really. And so we get that weird sort of sense. But it also, I feel like this taps back into like, really ancient narratives and stuff, and I feel like the figure that pops out to me at the moment, mostly because I've been working on the Roman kings is Tana Quill, and this idea, so she's the Prophet Hess. She can read the auspices and she ends up being able to prophesize the role of her husband, Lucia Tarquinius, Priscus well, before he get gets into power. And so this kind of sense in which Romans explain unusual rises to power and shifts in power through the divine, and not just through the divine, but through a female interpretation of the acts of gods. And so those women up on the hill, maybe it was the ritual, and Renea, my flesh, rabbit. Maybe it was the ritual, although I don't know how anyone could possibly explain her being in that gladiatorial school as being like a realistic idea about the narrative. But so I'm really fascinated to understand more about gladiatorial schools to be like, do they always just take the ladies with them to keep them happy? Or something? I don't know. Do they come as pairs? I'm looking around. And but yeah, this idea of direct line between like Women's Action, informing men's action through ritual understanding in the middle, it's really common. And I think it's partly because of that patriarchal framing of like, one way to women fit in this society, and it's not at all clear. And God's being somewhat unexplainable, like women, God,

                      Katharine Huemoeller 36:11
                      both unexplained, mysterious. Yeah, I think that's definitely that, that that makes a lot of sense to me. And it's, I think putting that the religious aura of Spartacus, in the context of the slave revolts is important, too, because a number of this sort of leading figures are said to have this some sort of religious significance or prophetic charismatic, fire, breathing, whatever, in whatever way it manifests itself. And so in some ways that actually may have been a really important part of Spartacus is leadership of this revolt. And she's clearly an important part of that. And yet, her significance to the revolt Overall, though, is still really slim with it. So it's kind of interesting, because you could think, oh, this made her a really key part of the revolt, because, you know, his charisma is really significant to the revolt success. And yet, you know, it's she's only associated with him at the moment of breaking out and then we don't hear what if she's involved in the revolt for as it grows larger and larger and more significant, she drops out of the narrative altogether. So it kind of minimises her role by placing her at the very beginning, even though there's a possibility that that prophecy was actually really significant to the level.

                      Dr G 37:27
                      And it also helps, I think, from a Roman perspective, to really explain why things don't go their way. And having those sorts of prophecies. It really taps into that sense of like, well, we didn't make a mistake. We're Romans, the gods were against us.

                      Dr Rad 37:43
                      Yes, good point. Well, I mean, it kind of depends as well on what their background is potentially like, if if Spartacus was genuinely Thracian, not fought as a Thracian. Maybe she was also Thracian. And so it's just there's so many question marks, though, about whether they actually weren't any of this. But certainly, in relation to your earlier question, Dr. G, it's not out of the question, obviously, that there are women who are being used for sexual purposes in a gladiatorial school. Certainly, if you became a highly prized successful gladiator you earned, you know, more privileges in the greater terrorist gladiatorial school where you were staying, you know, you could actually be like, somewhat tolerable, apart from the fact that you had to, you know, fight for your life and that kind of thing. But I don't know whether a new recruit to a gladiatorial school will have earned any such privilege. And so I guess it just sort of, it must be chance if it actually happened, although I've also highly dubious about whether it did, but it must be chance that she also just happened to be what they were looking for in terms of, you know, like pitch and stuff. Or maybe they did want her for sexual purposes. Like, who knows. But yeah, whatever the purpose was, it must have been purely accidental. There is no way they'd be doing Spartacus anything. That's yeah,

                      Katharine Huemoeller 39:01
                      and especially the way it's represented in Plutarch is that they are captured together, right? They come from the same place, and then they that's why they're together and the slave market. And then it's like, almost like they're bought in a lot.

                      Dr Rad 39:13
                      Exactly. Yeah. That's very possible. Yeah. But it does seem a little a little weird for a gladiatorial school to be like yeah, man, women. Yeah, whatever. We'll take them all. Yeah, yeah. Cuz this is before the time when it's common for women to be fighting in the arena, so she wouldn't have been bought for that purpose. So yeah, strange. Very strange. Yeah, but ripe for fictionalisation. Right? Yeah. Well, that's just said I was thinking like, I spend a lot of my academic career being like, where is vernia? Why isn't she more prominent, speaking to you just and it made me realise that actually, it's really pretty accurate for her to drop out of the store. But it's my sister button for modern purposes. I constantly am like, Why isn't she more fun of the story? Why has history are being downgraded? You know, why isn't she represented the way that she was originally intentioned by Howard Fassler novelists, you know?

                      Katharine Huemoeller 40:09
                      Well, that's, you know what? Yeah, that's what's so interesting, I think about this idea that she was a prophet test because, you know, when she does appearance in fiction, and you can speak more to this, because I can't now I don't know exactly the distinction between the script and the way the movie, I only know the movie, the way Spartacus 1960 ends up representing her, but, you know, she is she's a completely domestic figure, at least in the second part of the movie during the revolt itself, important as you know, a vessel for bearing a child essentially. And so that's so different actually, from from the, you know, her significance in Plutarch.

                      Dr Rad 40:46
                      That is, I mean, I think this is where the TV show by stars plays more with her religious role. You know, it's a, they go back, because they have more time to play with obviously, they kind of start before the revolt, obviously. And they make Spartacus and auxilary. And they, they give him a whole backstory about why he turns against Rome and all that kind of stuff. And she's a part of that story. Her death is a part of that story. But her prophecy about how he's going to achieve like great and glorious things and, and the snake. It's a theme that goes throughout the whole series, because she is his motivation. And those words are constantly going back to so they make something of that angle in the TV series. But they don't really talk about that angle very much in the Howard first novel that was used as the basis for the 1960 film. And they don't really in all of the various versions of the script. The religious side is not really what she's known for. But she is actually a very significant figure in how it fasts novel, because his novel is told entirely through flashback. So Spartacus is dead by the time you start reading the book, and it's told through the memories of Varinia, and David, the Jewish guy, who's also one of Spartacus, his crew. And so it's really told through her through her reminiscences a lot of the time, and she's the one that like in the movie ends up surviving goes on to have children and it's through her and her children that the legend of Spartacus is kept alive. But she's she's very significant in terms of being represented as very fierce. So unlike Spartacus, who is born into slavery, and like his life is pretty dreary from the beginning. Varinia has, Varinia is more a person who earlier versions of scripture has been free, and then becomes a slave. And so she fights back like there, there were scenes that were meant to be shown of the slave, the owner of the slave school raping her and her fiercely resisting. And that's why he gives her to Spartacus, because he couldn't physically overpower her or at least not to his satisfaction, like it's, it's a bit unclear, like they don't always see obviously, it's like we see the attack, we see the fight, and then we see her or bruised and stuff. In some versions, I think she's meant to have been raped in some versions not. So the way it all plays out. It's really crazy. And then once you get into the actual scripts, they have all these different versions of what she was meant to be in some versions, she was actually meant to be really highly educated. And she teaches Spartacus to read. Yeah, yeah, they. So there's, there's all these sorts of things. But certainly in the in the early versions of the script, you see what you see in the Howard first novel, which is that she's a fighter, she actually there's actually a line from the Howard fosse novel, which always stands out to me, she says, I can fight like a man can fight. And she's, she's definitely portrayed as being at the forefront of these attacks is like this, almost like Valkyrie, like, you know, kind of figure. And when the slaves in the novel erect this big statue to themselves to sort of commemorate who they are, they have representations of all the men from different ethnicities, but then they also have the figure of a woman, and that's meant to be Varinia. So she's, she's definitely like the mother of the slave revolt. But as they get further and further into the script development, her character receives less and less attention, and she does sort of drop out a little bit, and what you're left with, there are elements of the novel. So her being this figure of fascination for any man that meets her, you know, Batiatus, Spartacus, Crassus, Gracchus, they all fall in love with her. That's retained, but she's made much more passive. And it was actually something that the screenwriter, when he first saw the first kind of the film, he rebelled against it. He's like, what the hell this is not the Varinia that I envisioned and where all the other slave women they just like disappeared, and so they actually did reshoots to add in more families, more slave women more Varinia but I think because of the nature of the ratios, she did end up becoming this What I like to call Stepford Varinia type character?

                      Katharine Huemoeller 45:03
                      Yeah, yeah. Cuz the, these, these scenes they interspersed are like, women like doing the laundry in the river, you know, during the revolts, and these, like, very domestic.

                      Dr Rad 45:14
                      Yeah. Which I mean, to be fair, again, if I'm, if I'm being fair, obviously, it's not like, in the Roman world, it's not like that wouldn't have been the kinds of things that women would have been doing if they were attached to a slave army. But it is disappointing when you know, how she could have been represented, I suppose, as this, like she only really stops fighting in some of the earlier versions of the script, because she gets pregnant.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 45:36
                      Right, right. It's so interesting to hear that, that there was this distinction made between them, where she was the person who had experienced freedom and therefore was considered to be sort of more, you know, was willing to rebel more, because that's, that is, you know, sort of that's kind of a debated topic, like some of the scholarship on the slave revolt says that one of the reasons these happened in this period was because a lot of the people who are being trafficked and you know, into slavery are recently free, and that they like have this sort of memory of freedom, or, you know, impetus for it that other people who are born into slavery might not have, which I don't think bears out historically. I've also recently published an article that argues that, you know, many of the people who are enslaved in Conquest were already enslaved in other contexts, right in other cities, because they're the people who are most likely to be trafficked to be taken captive and trafficked, a lot of the male, you know, free combatants are killed. And it's women, both enslaved and free, and enslaved men, elderly people that are the ones who are taken captive. And so I think just because these people are recently sold in, you know, Italy or Sicily, that doesn't mean that they were free in their lifetime, necessarily, nor does that mean that you would like, be more, you know, willing to revolt necessarily, I think

                      Dr G 47:02
                      Some of this must be about like, what are the suitable conditions for a revolt to take place? Like, yeah, like, there's the moment of becoming enslaved whenever that might happen, whether you're born into slavery, or whether you're captured, and you have this understanding of our freedom. But I think it would be very naive to assume that people born into slavery don't have an idea about freedom. What conditions would permit a moment where you're like, Okay, this is this is the time to stand up and and take that risk, because it is a risk.

                      Dr Rad 47:32
                      Yeah, look, I think it has a little bit to do with a quick of how I'd fast novels, or how I fast I was attracted to write about Spartacus because of the connection with the revolts, or attempted coup that took place in Germany in 1919. And he started looking into Spartacus and he decided that he was going to make Spartacus, someone who was born into slavery as someone who had worked in the mines most of his life. Now, anybody who knows anything about slavery, whilst you might say, whilst we might not know anything about Spartacus, a backstory that we can definitively prove, I think it's safe to say we all know that slaves in the mines do not live for really long periods of time. So the idea that he would have somehow been a slave working in the mines, like, basically his whole life or something like that. It just, it doesn't make sense. But it's something that they played with, I think, in the various versions of the movie in terms of making Spartacus, someone who was born into slavery, they had all sorts of different ideas about how they were going to start the movie, they were always going to start in the minds like they do. But yeah, either way, I think it's a quirk from Howard fast, which is probably one of his less credible interpretations of the material.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 48:48
                      That's really interesting. Do you think that there was that, you know, he wanted him to be why did he want him to be born into slavery was this idea that he had to be slowly shown another way to live?

                      Dr Rad 48:59
                      I think that was part of it in a way. Part of the part of the thing about Spartacus is that he learns from other people like he learns from people like David Perdue, who he comes into contact with, but I think it's meant to be his nature. His his nature, and the nature of Ernie or the nature of all the slaves is meant to somehow be in stark contrast to the Romans, almost like it's something genetic, though they are meant to represent the right way of life, which is that men and women come together because they love each other. They have to have children, they take an interest in raising those children. It's it's heterosexual. And the Romans, on the other hand, everything's perverted. So they might not have children at all. If they do. They're not interested in them. They're not interested in family life. That's not their thing. They take part in all sorts of twisted sexual practices. Now I say that in the sense of 1950s contexts which for a 1950s context involved homosexuality, but also incest

                      Katharine Huemoeller 50:07
                      And the women choosing which gladiator to watch.

                      Dr Rad 50:12
                      That's that, yeah, that kind of thing. Exactly. So everything about them is meant to be like kind of impure debauch deviant, whereas everything about the slaves is meant to be much more pure. And I think that's, and it's also because he's he's offering a commentary. I mean, he was a communist. He is he's offering a commentary on the way that industry and business contributes to this corruption of the soul. So he has actually like some quite lengthy passages where he talks about, I think it's crisis's perfume business. Because you do, but yeah, so it's meant to be about obviously, like, the way that wealth works in each society, and what each society is valuing and how they're treating workers and the class system. It's all of these kinds of things, which is why the slaves are meant to be kind of more pure, and the way that they the way that they erected the statue, it's obviously very, like Soviet Union, in terms of, you know, putting up that kind of imagery of themselves.

                      Dr G 51:17
                      We need a monument. Quick, somebody

                      Dr Rad 51:19
                      Yeah, exactly.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 51:21
                      And that that actually works really well with those scenes from the movie then where there's these kind of, it's sort of like this idyllic pastoral existence, like they're engaged in the middle of a revolt, but they're, like, you know, taught like singing around a fire and out in the fields. And well, and

                      Dr Rad 51:37
                      that's very much, that's very much how Howard Fast had envisioned the slave society is being like faily. It is like proto communist, you know, that's exactly how he envisioned is everything working, even the way that he imagines men and women coming together, women are supposed to be able to choose their sexual partners, they're not just like claimed by another, Gladiator or another man, just because, well, we're out of the gladiator school, but you're still a woman, and I still get to say what you do, he still has this vision of people being able to choose, and that includes women being able to choose who they cohabit with, and who they have sex with, as part of their whole,

                      Dr G 52:14
                      As long as it fits the heteronormative status quo…

                      Dr Rad 52:18
                      As long as that does that. Yeah.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 52:21
                      I mean, it's so interesting that even though, you know, the reasons that these scenes wound up in the movie contemporary to his era, and very historical, in the end, one thing that the movie does, that I think is more true in some ways, is it does indicate, you know, it represents other people and engage in revolt besides just the, you know, enslaved adult men. And so, I mean, not that I think it accurately represents what their women might be were doing necessarily, or whatever, in the revolt, but it does, it just adds new people to the scene. And so that I think that that then can make you think, as a historian think, Okay, well, is there any truth to that? What were these people doing? And, and this, you know, goes beyond just the experience of enslaved women to just to think about when, you know, these rebel armies are, you know, moving up and down all over Italy? And what is the experience of everyone in in this context of revolt, right, the people who are in the town where the rebels arrive in the rebel army, this is obviously something that's going to affect everyone in society. But we don't often consider right, everyone.

                      Dr Rad 53:35
                      Well, definitely, as you said, the Spartacus slave revolt does manage to last for a couple of years. And therefore, we know that there are women part as part of this collective that have gathered behind Spartacus and the other slave leaders. It is certainly not out of the question that people are having sex, women are getting pregnant women are giving birth, you know, like, it's not another question that that is happening,

                      Katharine Huemoeller 54:01
                      Or that families joined it to begin with, because, you know, we know that what's happening on these agricultural estates that, you know, although are the writers tend to talk mostly about enslavement on these estates? You know, historians have done work already to reveal that women were absolutely there. And children were absolutely there. They're just not the focus of the agricultural treatises. Right. But so, you know, in that case, are they you know, what is their relationship to these revolts as the rebels move through? Are they joining? Are they assisting their owners in hiding them, right? They have to make choices essentially, there's no way to stay neutral. And I think you know, that that is that does come out of the narrative ancient narratives, right? There's a story in the Spartan revolt where the slave rebels enter a town and it talks about how many in the town were sympathetic allies to the slaves and basically people had to make a choice whether they were going to reveal where their masters were hiding or you know, help them hide right it it was not On a possibility to remain neutral. Yeah, then we have to think okay, so then what is the experience or revolt like for all these people?

                      Dr Rad 55:06
                      Yeah. And that's that's something that has was toyed with in there's actually there were actually two Spartacus movies that were going to be made based on two Spartacus novels that came out around the same time or early 20th century. So we had the one by how fast which becomes the Kirk Douglas movie and then we've got the one by Arthur Koestler, which was meant to be made into a Spartacus film called the gladiators, but didn't end up happening because of character, Douglas' project. But in there's an interesting crossover with these, which is some of the stuff that I've looked at where the director of Spartacus 1960s to cook Douglas protect Stanley Kubrick became interested in the novel by Arthur Koestler, which was meant to be the basis of the other film. So there's all sorts of weird crossovers between them. But certainly, in the novels in the various versions of the films, there are scenes that were toyed with about the slave men having conversations about, look, these women and children and old people is slowing us down. Like what are we going to do about this? And so they have toyed with these sorts of questions about how do you actually deal with a revolt? And certainly there, there certainly were going to be scenes and whether other movie, I can't actually remember which one at the moment, I'm pretty sure it was Spartacus, 1960, where they actually had conflicts between the slave leaders over the question of whether they actually just welcome anybody or whether they only welcome those who can fight.

                      Dr G 56:28
                      So thinking about this situation for the slave revolt and their organisation? Isn't this presumably just as problematic fit any kind of armed force, like logistics in the ancient world depends on the people. And you've always got this sort of, presumably entourage that has men and women, in addition to the fighters themselves, in which case, you possibly if you're on a really significant campaign, there may be births involved there as well. And it's like an armed forces, not just dudes wandering around with their swords out just waiting to reach the battlefield, I don't think and so this logistics issue that the slaves are facing is presumably the same kind of logistical issue that the Roman army proper might also be facing conceivably in different points in time,

                      Dr Rad 57:20
                      I think. So I think the difference is that obviously, the Roman army is supposed to be helped by the state, you know, they've got this additional backup of baby, maybe they're helping with food supply, depending on where they're fighting, of course. But logistically, there's like backup, whereas I suppose for a slave rebel force, they're constantly having to look out for potential attack people turning on them. And I guess they're not necessarily going to have like a bunch of trained fighters, whereas the Roman army presumably has a reasonable amount of men who have seen battle or have been trained,

                      Dr G 57:59
                      and maybe not supply lines, you know, just kind of a wandering force.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 58:04
                      I think you're right, though. I think you're right, that that that is an issue, because, you know, there is quite a lot of concern about camp followers called, and, you know, marriage bans, right, like there is a there is there are attempts throughout human history to sort of control outside of the army and like concerns about that slowing them down and messing with discipline as well.

                      Dr Rad 58:25
                      Yeah. And I think to be fair, although I'm, I'm really speaking off the cuff here, because it's been a little while since I've looked over my material. But I have a feeling that part of the arguments, and at least one of the things they imagined was actually about, do we accept fighters. So we're sick of accepting agricultural workers, whether they're men or women who are coming to join us, because they imagine that there's, you know, a core group of gladiators who know how to fight. And so I think it was partly about that some of the time or their training then their gender or their age. But they also played with those questions, obviously, of children and the elderly, and women in particular, slowing people down. But yeah, I mean,

                      Katharine Huemoeller 59:13
                      that is true to the ancient sources, too. And that the way slavers thought about women was as a way to actually attach men to the estate to reduce the chances of rebellion. Women were thought of as like instruments in that way to you know, have control that men would be less likely to revolt if they have wives if they have children. Right. So the agricultural writers are very attuned to that dynamic. And I think that's one reason that they don't conceive of women as participating in the revolt because they're supposed to be doing the opposite, right?

                      Dr Rad 59:47
                      Yeah, exactly.

                      Dr G 59:49
                      You were supposed to save us from a vote.

                      Dr Rad 59:53
                      Yeah, exactly. Oh, my goodness. Yeah. Obviously, this could be an entire episode in itself because Varinia is endlessly fascinating, or the character of Spartacus, his wife is endlessly fascinating. She's had many, many different names, and many, many iterations where she had no name at all.

                      Dr G 1:00:13
                      I suspect it's probably a good time to wrap up. So we've got one final question. So when we were talking about you, in the introduction, we noted that you have a background that's not just in academia, which is, you know, cool and interesting. You know, some people have a very straight path, and some people don't. And so, you know, the paths into these sorts of things, I think, are really fascinating. And we're interested in your work in the nonprofit sector, and also how that might have impacted the direction you took when you came back into academia?

                      Katharine Huemoeller 1:00:47
                      Yeah, absolutely. I left university unsure what I wanted to do. But knowing that I was passionate about reproductive justice in particular, and gender equity. And so I worked for a few years in the nonprofit world, working on contemporary issues. And it didn't end up being what I wanted to do long term. But it definitely informed my interest in the ancient world. So when I decided to go back to graduate school, it took a little while before I could combine these interests, of course, you know, not in Greek lit survey so much. But eventually, when I got to, you know, choose my own research projects, I wanted to do something that touches on these these long issues of gender inequities, and in particular, reproductive injustice. And so I, I became really interested in Roman slavery, and the path and currently I'm most interested in particular in the hereditary nature of Roman slavery, and the fact that it goes through the maternal line. And I'm interested in how that shapes the experiences of enslaved women, what kinds of sexual and reproductive exploitation that leads to. That's why I'm so fascinated by for example, right? That this idea that in the movie, Spartacus is supposed to be born of an enslaved woman that's like the opening lines of the 1960 movie, right? Or is that a woman I think it's something like a woman gave birth to a child, and that increased her masters a state and that child was Spartacus. And, and you know that it's fascinating to me that that's in this movie, because that's actually not really in the scholarship. We don't we don't talk that much about the importance of maternal dissent in slavery. So that's absolutely shaped by my experience in the nonprofit world. And by thinking about how legal systems shape inequities in society, and and also what people do within, you know, the actors within legal systems, how to slavers, choose slaving strategies, knowing that women will bear enslaved children.

                      Dr G 1:02:50
                      It's really interesting, isn't it? Because just thinking about what you're saying at the moment about the maternal line, because we know that's the easiest way to measure a line. And it's like, you know, a woman grows, and then all of a sudden, it's like, oh, yeah, and there's a cord attached for a little while. You're like, yep, that that one definitely came from me. Exactly. Yeah.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 1:03:10
                      In Roman law, it's the the only the mother is ever truly known.

                      Dr G 1:03:16
                      Yeah, exactly. And so it's like, it's like, there's never really any doubt about the mother, and yet Roman society and many, so societies, like from a Western perspective that sort of grown out from that, a very patriarchal, they're like, No, we've always got to know who the dude is. And it's like, do though, because it's like, really easy, really easy if we just decided that the

                      Dr Rad 1:03:36
                      difficult thing,

                      Katharine Huemoeller 1:03:37
                      Yeah, that's why they're so anxious about protecting about women's chastity, right? Because that is the way so for Roman citizens status is transmitted through the line of the Father, and that creates paternal power and, and legitimate air. And so for anyone who's not a citizen, including enslaved people, but not only enslaved people, which status transmitted through the mother, but that, you know, that is what comparatively looking at slavery over time and space. That's not the only pattern of transmission. It's the one that was used during the TransAtlantic slave system, slave trade. And so it's one that's very, I think, present in most of our minds, but actually, sometimes status is passed through the parent of highest status, or lowest status, or whatever household they're in, or there's lots of possible patterns of status transmission, and they all had rippling effects on the experience of being enslaved. Yeah, definitely.

                      Dr G 1:04:31
                      I think it's really fascinating because it's kind of like there is always in operation, a two tiered system where there is the perceived status quo of patriarchy as like the right way from for being free and things like this. And then there's all of the other systems that will fall under that which can be classified within slave strategies, and to see that the maternal line comes out so free Currently there and I was like, Oh, guys, you know, the real answer here is just, you know, patriarchy, maybe you could put that to the side a little bit, and you make it really easy for yourselves. But it obviously goes against something that's really quite ingrained in Roman society and how they understand themselves, it's just not possible for them to do something like that.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 1:05:18
                      Yeah. And what's so what's so interesting about it is that they see transmission to the maternal line as what is natural, that's part of the you scan to my natural law, that's what everyone does. But what Roman citizens do, right, the special privilege of Roman citizens is to have status transmitted through the Father. So that is like wrapped up in what it means to be a citizen and what and all these you know, special, this special treatment and special privileges you get with being a citizen, that's a key one, it's this transmission through the Father. And that's kind of like, unnatural, it's like part of Roman Civil lots, you know?

                      Dr G 1:05:53
                      Yeah, yeah. And it is obviously built into the all of the sort of adoption laws that are at play within the elite classes as well, where it's like, well, we can we can rearrange your male line a little bit to make things a little bit easier here. And that's sort of on theory legal.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 1:06:10
                      Exactly. But I mean, getting back to that, remember that crazy revolt at Volsini right, the idea that the slaves are, you know, wanting to reform the system of inheritance, like, to me that speaks to the significance of status transmission, right, this idea that, like they can decide who their heirs will be. That's, you know, that is a privilege of, again, we're two's to Roman citizen masculinity. That's, it's just kind of wrapped in everywhere you look, all of a sudden you see it significance, I think,

                      Dr Rad 1:06:40
                      I guess it must be particularly interesting for you to be considering these issues at the moment, given the recent developments, which have been highly publicised all over the world in terms of control over reproductive rights in America.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 1:06:53
                      Yeah, absolutely. This, I would say that my present day informs this work in many different ways and informs my work because while I'm been writing this book, I've had two children. And so I've thought a lot about what it means to be a mother, how we can, you know, think about that over time and space, what reproduction looks like in different political contexts. Now, being in Canada, I'm in a very different political context than how I grew up. In the US. I'm very relieved not to be there right now, with the current climate and the current loss of reproductive autonomy for women* there, it's hard for me to imagine myself being there or putting my children, my two daughters there, right, bringing them there. And so that all of that informed the way I look at the past. [* Dr. Huemoeller wishes to make a correction to what she said during the recording: people of all genders, not only women, are being stripped of reproductive autonomy in the US.]

                      Dr Rad 1:07:45
                      Definitely, well, we might wrap up on that note, but we hope very much that by the time we talk to you the next time because I'm sure that our research interests will cross paths again, that maybe the situation let's call it over there has changed so that people have more rights rather than less.

                      Dr G 1:08:02
                      Thank you so much for taking the time to sit down with us. We really appreciate it and such a fascinating topic of conversation.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 1:08:08
                      Thank you.

                      Dr Rad 1:08:09
                      Absolutely. Before we before we sign off, would you like to say anything about publications or where people can find you and your work?

                      Katharine Huemoeller 1:08:17
                      The best place to find me would be at my university website. So University of British Columbia, and you can search my name. I have a few recent articles out on these topics, if you're interested in one that's I think, particularly accessible is in the Journal of Roman studies. And it follows one woman's story, one woman who was enslaved and then freed to marry her owner, and then ended up leaving him of sort of form of rebellion and was cursed for it. So it's a really interesting personal story that I think helps you maybe sort of connect on an emotional level to the past, so that would be the one I would I would recommend.

                      Dr Rad 1:08:54
                      Well, I think we've got our next podcast collaboration topic. Thank you so much for joining us today.

                      Katharine Huemoeller 1:08:59
                      Thank you.

                      Transcribed by https://otter.ai

                      For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/


                      Support the show

                      Patreon

                      Ko-Fi


                      Read our books

                      Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome

                      Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire

                      Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

                      1 hr 10 min