
Sign up to save your podcasts
Or


This may be the best podcast episode you’ve ever heard, and that’s the gospel truth. We’re munching on protein bars and raw chicken as we discuss Disney’s Hercules (1997) with Professor Alastair Blanshard.
Statue of Hercules in Shrewsbury – a copy of the Farnese Hercules. Hercules leans wearily on his club, which is covered by his lionskin. Carrying out all these labours is hard work! Courtesy of Elliot Brown on Flickr.
Professor Blanshard literally wrote the book on Hercules, as well as several chapters on his representation in film. We are so lucky to have him on our show as he is not just a gigantic Hercules fanboy. He is currently the Paul Eliadis Chair of Classics and Ancient History at The University of Queensland and one of the most hilarious historians you will ever meet.
The Birth of HerculesDisney’s Hercules came out during one of the most successful animated movie streaks for the studio. However, the film was a little different to the Disney Princess films such as Beauty and the Beast and The Little Mermaid. It was also pitched at a slightly older, male audience, and used the story of Hercules to explore the awkward journey from adolescence to manhood.
As people have learnt about muscle development and nutrition has changed, Hercules has often been played by bodybuilders like Steeve Reeves and more recently Dwayne ‘The Rock' Johnson. Image of Steeve Reeves, courtesy of John Irving on Flickr.
Disney does not always provide the most faithful representation of Hercules’ story. How do you turn a myth about a serial murderer, a drunkard and a glutton into an exploration of what it means to be a true hero? Never you fear – Disney has all the answers!
This film blends stories of Hercules, such as his strangling of the snakes as a baby and the Twelve Labours, with so many other elements from contemporary American society. Whilst Hercules was not quite as successful as other Disney movies of this era, there is a lot to love about this representation.
The Greeks were not afraid to rework their own mythology, and it seems like Disney followed in their footsteps.
Hercules having a chat with his father in Zeus' temple at Olympia in Disney's Hercules (1997). Courtesy of Adam Hammond.
Join us for this fascinating conversation about the Disneyfication of a Greek hero. We delve into the characterisation of all your favourite characters: Meg, Phil, Hades, and of course, the man of the hour.
Special Episode – Disney's Hercules (1997)
If you would like to read more from Professor Blanshard, you can find a list of publications on his university profile. You can also find his contributions on The Conversations here.
Sound CreditsOur music is courtesy of Bettina joy de Guzman,
Intelligent Speech TicketsJoin us at the Intelligent Speech Conference this year! The event will be held online on November 4. You can buy tickets here and watch the event live, or access the videos later. If you use the code PEICE at checkout, you get 10% off your tickets and they'll know that we sent you.
Automated TranscriptOur automated transcript is provided by Otter AI.
Dr Rad 0:00
Hey there listeners at the partial Historians tell me, are you doing anything on November for? No? Well, Dr. Jean, I have just the invitation for you come along to the intelligent speech conference for 2023. And hear us and other amazing presenters talk all about the theme of the year, which is contingencies. What happens when history meets the backup plan? How intriguing does that sound? Just head along to intelligence speech online.com to buy your tickets now. And if you're worried about the time difference, never you fear you can of course, join in the event live online, but you can also watch the videos afterwards at your own convenience. So what are you waiting for? Go and grab your tickets now. And if you use the code peace, P E, I C E at the checkout, they'll know the partial history and sent you and you'll get a lovely 10% off. We hope to see you there.
Welcome to the partial historians.
Dr G 1:21
We explore all the details of ancient Rome.
Dr Rad 1:25
Everything from political scandals to love affairs, the battles waged and when citizens turn against each other. I'm Dr. Red.
Dr G 1:36
And I'm Dr. G. We consider Rome as the Roman saw it by reading different ancient authors and comparing their accounts.
Dr Rad 1:46
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Welcome to a special episode of the partial historians. I'm one of your hosts Dr Rad
Dr G 2:15
and I am Dr. G. And we're pretty excited about the conversation that we're about to have today. I mean, personally, I'm a big Hercules fan. And that might be a little bit of foreshadowing.
Dr Rad 2:28
Indeed, we are so lucky to be joined by I think it's safe to say the world's largest expert on Hercules, which is Alastair Blanshard. Alastair Blanshard is the Paul Eliadis professor of classics and ancient history, as well as the author of some amazing books that you might like to get your hands on, including classics on screen and Hercules a heroic life.
Dr G 2:52
Thank you so much for joining us, Alastair.
A Blanshard 2:54
Great to be here. And I'm not sure about the largest expert, but certainly the biggest fanboy for Hercules
Dr Rad 3:00
that makes you the expert in our book. So we're gonna be talking about Disney's Hercules in particular today, which is really great for us because we've been revisiting a lot of classic films, and so Hercules naturally fits right in. But before we dive straight into the Disney version of things, it's probably good to give our listeners a bit of background on who Hercules actually is, or dare I say, Herakles.
Speaker 3 3:24
Yes, absolutely. So, Herakles, as he's known amongst the Greeks, and Hercules, as he's called by the Romans was probably the most popular of the ancient heroes. Certainly his worship is found throughout the Mediterranean from signs in the far corners of Spain all the way through to Southern France. Indeed, the modern Principality of Monaco is actually named after in fact, a temple dedicated to Hercules, Hercules monoikos, Hercules, the man who lives alone, and so monoikos becomes Monaco, but to his worship continues, obviously in Greece all the way through the Black Sea to all be our panic a pm no places where modern day Ukraine is. And of course, there are important sanctuary sites in Lebanon, North Africa. So throughout the Mediterranean, Hercules was a figure that was well known and well respected and worship.
Dr Rad 4:17
Absolutely. I seem to recall some Roman emperors letting to dress up like Hercules and run around arenas, and we were just actually talking about little NAS X and his music video for call me by your name and how he might be dressed up as Hercules but like a baby pink Hercules?
A Blanshard 4:35
Well, we'll Look at don't even get me started on that video clip because that is for a classicist, or one of the greatest clips ever. I mean, not only does it include all the coliseums type scenes, him dressed up as characters, but also a quotation in actual Greek from Plato's Symposium as well, from Aristophanes speech about the nature of the soul and how it's looking for its long lost partner. So So for a classicist that that is the film clip to end all film clips,
Dr G 5:03
it is basically catnip for classicists.
A Blanshard 5:08
Who knew that that was the market he was going for? It's done
Dr G 5:11
really well, we now all talk about it. And we have a great time and all of us kind of like, we just want to meet him and sit down and have a good chat about it.
A Blanshard 5:19
Yes, I really want to know who chose that passage from the symposium because it's so perfect in terms of the concept of the song. But also the decision to carve it onto the tree in in Greek is really, really striking.
Dr Rad 5:33
I know we were speaking to Yentl love about X, we've tried a special FSA just on that one particular clip. And we were asking her like, Where does this come from? Like, who is working on this? Is this all from him? Like, who are the people that he's consulting with?
Dr G 5:46
And also, how do we get a job? But to drag it back to Hercules inherently, he's thinking about the sort of how he's positioned in the ancient world? What are some of the sort of key touchstones in the mythology that surrounds this figure so that we can set up a sort of a comparison between what the sort of the ancient Greeks and the ancient Mediterranean world thought about this figure and the stories they told and how that might end up comparing to what Disney presents us with?
A Blanshard 6:15
Yeah, absolutely. And that's a very, very good question. And it's a really interesting question to ask for Heroclix because one of the things about Hara Cleves is because he's worshipped in so many different places, there are so many different stories. And so we imagine really, that the mythology around Hercules was enormous, every place would have had its own little Hercules story, its own variation about how hurricanes came to their town often established, you know, an important institution or, or a right. And so really, in fact, the myths that we have about hurricanes that have come down to us are probably in the tip of a huge iceberg of stories that would have been circulating in in antiquity, I guess, in terms of thinking about the grand narratives to occupy Hercules as life that I think I guess there are, there are probably a couple of kind of key points. And obviously the 12 labours is a is a central point. And these were the 12 labours that Hercules had to perform as expiation for the murder of his wife and children. And that's a topic I think, we'll get into discussing, particularly when we come to the Herrick Lee's film because it's totally glossed over. But Hercules, the wife killer, the child killer, has to wash the blood from his hands. And He does this by performing a number of labours for King Eurystheus. That's you. I guess one of the great central themes or stories that relates to Hercules would live there are a number of other other kinds of stories, there's a story about his eventual death where he is poisoned effectively by a woman who loved him, dear Naira, who accidentally thinking that she's going to make her clothes love her by applying a love potion to his clothes is in fact tricked into applying a kind of burning poison to his close. And so he dies in agony, and his eventual soul is sent to the heavens where it's worshipped as the divine as a divine figure. I guess that's one of the important stories. I guess the other sort of important story is the story about his birth, which again, was a kind of very important one. So again, it's a story that the Disney film isn't particularly keen on, on showing because it's all a story about adultery and deceit, and involves Hercules being the product of Zeus or Jupiter, coming down to earth, falling in love with a woman by the name of Alcmene and then appearing to her while her husband's away in the form of her husband. And he then sleeps with her, and she thinks she's sleeping with them photo on her husband. Now, in modern days, this would be rape, right? This is a classic case of what lawyers would call rate by personation. And this is, you know, you consent achieved by deceit, but the ancient world didn't see this as right. They saw this as just a very convenient ruse on the part on the part of Jupiter. And indeed, they even played it for comic effect. So for example, plotters in the play in vitro, has this as a kind of comic setup with their people going, are you in vitro? No, you're in vitro and they play it for kind of laughs now. Now, you can play it for laughs The Greeks also played it for tragedy. So in fact, we know that there is a fragmentary tragedy, the Alcmene which takes a scenario and which has Amphitryon arriving back at home to discover that his wife has been sleeping with another man. He doesn't believe her claims that she thought she was sleeping with her husband. And in fact, he puts on her pilot and is about to set fire to an incinerator alive when in fact that Zeus appears and sorts everything out. But this extraordinary birth story of Hercules who is the product of this rape by deceit could be played for both comic effects and tragic effects in the in the ancient world. but those are I think those are I think the three stories, the birth, the 12 Labours and the death, I think are probably the three key elements in the Hercules narrative.
Dr Rad 10:08
Yeah, and like most Greek myths, I think it doesn't automatically scream made for children in this modern age, because there is just so much murder and violence and trickery and adultery and all sorts of issues that run all throughout Hercules.
A Blanshard 10:25
Yes, okay. Anyone who started to tell a Greek myth for children suddenly finds themselves having to gloss over over things. And the numbers of nightmares. I've given my poor nieces and nephews, as I've told them stories of the ancient world, it's really, really too many to name.
Dr Rad 10:42
And yes, I suppose, where all the products are being told Greek myths.
Dr G 10:47
Yeah, it's it's really interesting that there is obviously so much violence at the centre of these stories. And I think that's it's definitely not uncommon for the ancient world to sort of have these sort of like lessons that are really sort of bruntly felt upon the body as much as upon the psyche. And yet, somehow, Disney has thought, you know, what would be a great tale to tell on the animated screen, the life of a hero? And who better to choose then Hercules?
A Blanshard 11:18
Yeah, it's absolutely extraordinary, as you say, I mean, Hercules, Hercules is the figure that in fact, the ancient world does a lot of thinking about in terms of violence, right. So he's the figure, in fact, who was so violent, so bloody in terms of his actions, that in fact, the Delphic Oracle refuses to wash his hands of blood. So he turns up having murdered a whole series of people again, and turns up to the Delphic Oracle and says, Look, you know, once again, sorry, kill have killed a lot of people, can you wash the blood of my hands? Can you make me once again, clean and the Delphic Oracle says, No, not this time, I'm just sick of you turning up here, completely covered in Gore, having just murdered a whole lot of people, we're not going to do it this time. And Hercules is outraged. He grabs the tripod, on which the Oracle sits and he says, I'm gonna go establish my own oracle that will allow me to be cleansed whenever I need it, which is obviously a lot. And at this point, Apollo appears, and wrestles the tripod back from Hercules and we have this in a lot of ancient art. There are a lot of ancient artistic depictions of Apollo and heroically is wrestling over the Delphic tripod. Now, what's interesting is that Zeus intervenes, and he sends a thunderbolt which splits the two and, and he says to Apollo, Look, it's your job to purify those who commit crimes. So yes, you're going to have to purify again. And so establishes the principle that in fact, you know, there's no crime for which you shouldn't be able to get purification from it's important Greek principle. And, and it's Hara Cleves, who becomes as it were the, the test case for this, that if you could, if you can cleanse Heroclix of blood, then basically you can cleanse anyone,
Dr G 13:10
goodness me, I felt like when you were talking about that kind of detail, it just put me in mind of like, where Roman Catholicism ends up. And I was like, Oh, that's a fascinating sort of, anyway, I don't want to go down that rabbit hole. But nevertheless, this idea of Hercules like sitting in this really interesting nexus of putting limits to the test, whether they be physical endurance, whether it be the necessity to be cleansed. I think this leads us really nicely into thinking about the film and potentially how they've decided to characterise Hercules in the Disney version through his physicality.
A Blanshard 13:47
Yeah, Look, it was a really interesting choice for them to do a hurricane so that they canvassed a couple of other options. They were clearly very keen to do something in the ancient world, and two stories were greenlit. So there was a one a project based on Homer's Odyssey, and a project based on Hercules. And in the end, they decided to go for Hercules. Now, they're thinking about this was quite interesting, because they felt that the Odyssey was something too sacred that you couldn't play about with, with the Odyssey in the way that you could do with Hercules and Hercules, you could have more fun with interesting concept, and also, that he was far more adaptable. And that second issue of adaptability. I think they're onto something because as I said, there are a lot of Hercules stories. And so, you know, I think there was a bit more play in the, in the in the Herculesmyth in a way that there isn't art with the Odyssey that said, no one would have recognised what they did to directly story in the ancient world. But, but certainly, I think the notion of the ability of Hara cleaves it visa vie the Odyssey is probably probably right. But but the extraordinary an extraordinary, extraordinary choice.
Dr Rad 14:56
Yeah, well, I suppose you're giving us a bit of context for the film. So Hercules comes at the tail end of this real resurgence for the Disney Studio. So it was released I think in 1997. And Disney, of course has just had a string of mega hits like the Lion King Beauty and the Beast, Aladdin all these sorts of films. So Hercules is coming at sort of the tail end of this particular era. And I believe that they were kind of thinking that Hercules might be more for a preteen, particularly male audience.
A Blanshard 15:29
Yeah, absolutely. Right. So this is, you know, the IOC called Eisner era and Disney right. So, you know, after the disaster of Black Cauldron in 1985, which almost put an end to animation in Disney, the Disney Corporation decides that we need to really rejig things we need to rethink the whole programme in terms of animated films. And so Michael Eisner, and then Roy Disney together really rejig the animation studios. tremendous success, as you say, no kicks off with Little Mermaid beauty in the Beast, Aladdin, Lion King they inherently use and of course, they'll go on to Pocahontas. So an extraordinary resurgence, and new Disney is just hitting it out of the park in terms of these in terms of these films, until it hits Hercules. And as you say, they're trying to do something different, right? So Little Mermaid, Beauty and the Beast, Aladdin Lion King, primarily, the age group they're looking for is the kind of six plus I mean, that's the rough age it Hercules, they think, Well, Look, we've conquered that demographic, let's do something different. And so it's an 11 Plus audience, so slightly more mature, and also much more boys-y as well. And, and that's really interesting for Disney. Because, I mean, it's really interesting to think the way in which Disney dominates the female demographic, you know, the Disney Princess is, you know, the thing that kind of dominates female childhood in a way for many bad, very bad purposes. And indeed, is something that they're kind of now rethinking, but there hasn't been, as it were a kind of dominant Disney narrative, um, for boyhood, inherently, as was their attempt to do that. And as a result, hurricanes represents a slight tweaking in terms of the genre and in terms of the format of the film so so if you Look at things like as you say, Little Mermaid, Beauty and the Beast, Aladdin, Lion King, you imagine right a ratio of comedy to drama about three to one. Now, in the Hercules film, what we see is a shift more towards dramas and slightly more drama, and also the nature of the comedy changes as well. So it's less of the sort of physical comedy, but there's still quite a lot of physical comedy, but much more kind of knowing, ironic, self reflexive kind of kind of comedy.
Dr Rad 17:45
So this might be a good moment to give a very brief overview of the plotline of this movie, particularly because we've told our listeners so much about you know, the murderer and Hercules his life and that sort of thing. So what have they done with the basic plotline? What have they told us about Hercules in this film,
A Blanshard 18:02
right. Okay. So what they what they've done is they've taken various elements of Greek myth and combined it together. So the overarching narrative is the narrative of the tight end Tamaki, right the the great fight between the Olympian gods and the Titans, and Tyson slash giants. And so what they've done is they've taken this narrative from myth, and they've reworked it in such a way that in order for the gods to succeed in a battle against the Titans, which are imagined in the Disney film was called elemental forces of chaos. In order for the gods to defeat the Titans, they need to have Heroclix on their side. And this really alarms the evil figure in the in the film, who is Hades, who is cast as the villain who wants to overthrow his brothers, Zeus, he really wants to, and he wants to overthrow the gods and he wants to align himself with the Titans. Now, in order to do this, he needs to get rid of Heroclix. And so he does that, first of all, by trying to poison him as a child. And unfortunately, this doesn't succeed. But what he does do is he manages to poison Hercules so enough so that he becomes mortal, a very strong mortal, and so he is then fostered out to some mortal parents and this is Amphitryon and Alcmene, the figures of who are the traditionally the parents of Hercules and then Hercules grows up as this strong, you know, out of place awkward adolescent who doesn't really fit into society, his his strength makes him always kind of unduly clumsy. So So in a sense, he's kind of every awkward adolescent, right and he speaks to the awkwardness of adolescence. He discovers that in fact, he's the son of Zeus and desperately wants to rejoin his real father as a god and so he does all sorts of actions to try and achieve godhood this is ultimately unsuccessful until he realises that it's not the actions that make you a god. It's in fact, what's inside. And that's what makes a true hero. And, and this only happens when he falls for a love interest by the name of mega who, unfortunately for him is a pawn of Hades, and she tricks him into sacrificing his life for her. And he does. He does that. And then eventually, the Titans are emerge. But because of the Soul Sacrifice at Hercules, made, he's allowed to in fact become a great hero. He can then rejoin the battle turns the tide saves the Olympian gods. And then at the very end, when he's just about to be welcomed into Olympus, which is imagined as the whole pearly gates of heaven. As of Olympus is vector kind of gated community. In this film, he decides actually, really, he wants to be on Earth with mega who's had a change of heart who's realised that deep down all along, she loved her athletes. And together, they kind of go off, happily live, it leads to the Disney World happily ever after.
Dr G 21:13
I mean, it's the sort of thing where there's so many small details that have been altered and changed along the way to make this incredibly interesting. And it puts you in mind of not just how Disney is attempting to sort of make Hercules sort of fit within their own sort of genre standards, but also the ways in which they're trying to reshape how you might think about ancient heroism in terms of a modern hero.
A Blanshard 21:42
Yeah, absolutely. And there's a real clash between a model of heroism which is derived from antiquity and the model of heroism, which is imbued with this very strong Judeo Christian ethos and, and you see it in the figure of Heroclix. Because in the ancient world, in order to be a hero, all you need to do is just be famous, right? heroes were just famous people they were, are often morally bankrupt. I mean, Hercules is a good example right now, not only is he a murderer, no, he's a rapist. He's a glutton prone to violent outbursts, who famously murders his music teacher as a child. I mean, he's really just a terrible person. And so, you know, trying to kind of tidy him up, make him more moral. And again, it's the same with Odysseus as well, deceit for really, again, violent, bloodthirsty figures. But but that doesn't matter for the ancient world. As long as you're famous, as long as you're spectacular, as long as you're blessed by the gods. That's what makes you a hero rather than having any moral content. Now, Disney offers you a totally different version of heroism, right? I'm hearing this is what's on the inside, right. And there's a constant discourse throughout the film about what makes a true hero. Now this is distinction of the ancient world wouldn't have recognised right new hero, true hero, there's only I think you're either a hero or you're not a hero, right, the idea of being a true hero is something that they wouldn't have recognised. And indeed, this comes to the fore in one of the great musical sequences in the film, which is the zero to hero sequence,
Dr Rad 23:10
my personal favourite.
A Blanshard 23:12
I just love it. It's the one that gets me humming and tapping. I mean, I know we're all supposed to love the Michael Bolton's go to distance but, but for me, it's zero to hero. And in this sequence, what we have is wonderful montage of Heroclix Hercules doing all the kinds of things that in the ancient world will make you a hero, he beats monsters, but more importantly, though, he gets cash, he gets fame, he's got these fan girls that are totally obsessed by him. It's this one. He's doing endorsements for running shoes. It's this wonderful sequence about kind of fame and importance and monetary wealth. Now, in the ancient world, this is all you needed to be a hero. But the end of this sequence involves Hercules going to Zeus and saying, Well, looking, I've done everything you need me to do, why aren't I a hero, and he's da, it's a hero comes from inside. You didn't know he's done everything he needs to do make him a hero. But it's a great sequence. Because in a sense, the the musical number is supposed to show you what he's what doesn't make a true hero. But actually, what it does is give you a very good example of what would have made a hero in the ancient world.
Dr Rad 24:20
Can you get that great line when I hear Hercules is talking to Zeus as well. Zeus is a statue that's come to life. And he says, you know, Look over the action figure. And I think the ancient world would have been like, yeah, right.
A Blanshard 24:32
Absolutely. That sequence is lovely, because it plays with the very famous chryselephantine statue of Zeus at Olympia, which has course come to life and, and that's the thing that what everyone says about the, the content of the film visually, it's extraordinary, right, Gerald Scarfe, one of the really great artists, you know, famous for doing Pink Floyd's The wall as well as a really series of important players. Cartoons For punch and Sunday Times, you know, just it's just a fantastic job with this film, it doesn't Look like any other kind of Disney film and, but it's just so visually clever. I mean, you know, he was obsessed by the line that you get in Greek vases. And so you see, you know, even the drops of water that fall kind of when they dropped a drop, like, in the shape of Greek, Pfizer's the, the landscapes are extraordinary. It's just the most beautiful, exciting visual film. And there are all these lovely little quotations of, of ancient sculpture of ancient VARs forms, time and time, again, a wonderful occasion of ancient architecture. So visually, the film is, is lush and wonderful.
Dr G 25:40
I think there's a real visual richness to Hercules his body as well, the swirling lines that that sort of demarcate, like his chest and his ears and things like this, which is a real visual Echo to ancient Greek sort of artistry as well.
A Blanshard 25:55
Yeah, absolutely. And it's very clear that that scarf has been entrusted by the by Greek vase painting, particularly in his depiction of Heroclix. And indeed, there's a long tradition of artists, particularly Iliff line illustrated, being obsessed by Greek vase painting. So you can go back to something like Aubrey Beardsley, for example, who again, obsessed by Greek line painting. So animators line artists have always found a huge inspiration in Greek vase painting.
Dr Rad 26:25
So do you think as well that the appearance of Hercules in the animated version has been influenced by the representations of Hercules that have come before so famously, Hercules has been embodied by strong man or body builders, so people like Steve Reeves people like Eugene sand out, and more recently, since the Disney film, of course, we've had the rock. So do you think that that sort of physical appearance has characterised the animated version as well?
A Blanshard 26:51
Yeah, absolutely. And it's worthwhile observing that there are two essentially bold body types in this format. There's the young, kind of scrawny adolescent Hercules. And then there's the Hara cleis, that emerges after Danny DeVito, otherwise known as Philip TTS, otherwise known as Phil takes him in hand and transforms him into this buff, gorgeous body. And both those bodies are really interesting. I'm struck by what Disney did with this kind of awkward adolescence, because I think that's probably the critically most successful bit of a film is imagining this hero as this kind of awkward adolescence. And it's striking that actually the most importance, I guess, spin off of the film was in fact the hair Achlys animated series that they did for television, which was a series of episodes of essentially, young Herrick leaves at school and his his friends, he's got a fantastic Cassandra friend who's always having these visions that no one understands. And Icarus figure has kind of been flying too close to the sun that's kind of spaced out. And now that was a that was probably much more successful. I think critically, then the film itself, and it focused very much on that adolescent here at least. And I think that's quite interesting. But as you say, when when he when he's buff, and full bodied, he's absolutely in line of the kind of standard peplum Heracles that we know from figures like Steve Reeves, whose 1960s heritage leaves films really defined, defined our notions of what Reeves has been, or should be. And indeed, I mean, there's a, as you say, there's a long tradition starts with Sandow, pretending to be the wiry Heracles and his famous stage show where he imitated life synthases famous statue of the weary Heracles, that body type of hurricanes is quite interesting, because it makes a hurricane, it's very good at lifting things, breaking things, not so good at running. I mean, if you've ever seen a bodybuilder run, right, you know, their fires get in the way, right? There's just a whole lot of chafing that's happening there. And, and that's interesting, because it was one of the labours of Hercules is in fact, him chasing down the sneaking Hind of Artemis. So one of the one of the very famous labours of Hercules involves him really running very fast. Yeah, it's hard to imagine if these bodybuilders running fast, or indeed, you know, in a sense, Disney's Hercules as well,
Dr Rad 29:13
you've actually highlighted that I think a bit in your work, the fact that the Hercules body that we're perhaps familiar with as modern audiences kind of only became possible once we were able to feed ourselves, you know, so many particular you know, vitamins and nutrients to turn our bodies into something, whatever it is even possible or practical in an ancient world context.
A Blanshard 29:34
Yeah, absolutely. I mean, it's extraordinary. We live in this amazing moment, right. So there are two key key changes are the first one is the ability to isolate muscle group and train individual muscles. And that becomes possible around the turn of the 19th century with people like Sandow developing equipment for the isolation and training of individual muscle groups. The second thing as you say, is the tremendous change in diet right so you can go to the super market and you can now eat protein in a density impurity that is unparalleled. So we can do things with our bodies that we've never been able to do before. So we can get for Hercules Look, I mean, for me, it's always very interesting because in the ancient world, you know, people don't operate with that low amount of body fat, right, those Herculean bodies that we see, or indeed, even the kind of the slim tot no Greek gods style bodies that we see in gym, they would have fallen over the first famine or long winter, right, you know, unless you've got a decent amount of body fat, you're not going to survive that winter, you're not going to survive feminine. We know that every time we model the ancient economy, we have to figure in, you know, a probably one to two years every 10 years for for famine or for struggling to meet your daily calorific requirements. So, you know, those bodies wouldn't have wouldn't have survived a long winter, which, again, always interests me,
Dr G 30:56
yeah, it puts us in a situation where even for the ancient Greeks, their idolised body is risky, because it's right on the edge of the limits of what might be possible in their context.
A Blanshard 31:06
Yeah, as I say, these are, these are bodies, which are actually, although they're proclaiming health, they're more importantly, proclaiming, well, that is, this is a body that doesn't need to worry about where its foods coming from. This is a body that can run itself right on the edge, because it knows that actually, it's it's a very wealthy body for whom it's always going to have access to resources. And so when we Look at those athletic bodies, we need to see them both as signs of kind of physicality, but also as signs of wealth, class and status.
Dr G 31:38
Yes, definitely. And thinking about the film, not just in it, sort of physicality of Hercules, but also thinking about how figures like the Olympian gods are coming into play. Certainly, there's a sort of an extended elaboration of their physicality as well, but I'm actually potentially more interested in their characterization compared to how we understand them from Greek myth.
A Blanshard 32:05
Yes, I mean, what we see is a very reductive attitude towards the Greek gods. So the Greek gods stand for one thing and one thing only right so Aphrodite is a goddess of love, for example, but we know that in the ancient world, she was also a sea goddess, importantly, depicted always with a dolphin by her side, she is the person that you imply, prey to for safe voyages. Likewise, your Dionysus is represented there is the god of wine, but he's also the godfather of theatre, the god of madness, has important role in the underworld as well through certain Dionysiac mysteries. So these multifaceted God that in the ancient world had all these various different dimensions to them, just effectively get reduced in the Disney Hercules to only standing for one for one thing. So you know, Poseidon is the god of the sea, but he's not the God of horses, not the God of earthquakes, for example, and it goes on again, and again. There are some lovely jokes. I mean, there's a wonderful joke about Narcissus, for example, he's always looking in, in his mirror and, and that's kind of right. I think, that's this is really famous for being obsessed by his beauty, but but in all other respects, their depiction of the gods is very, very reductive. We see this, for example, perhaps most strikingly, in here, who you know, in this case is just becomes a sort of doting simpering mother rather than the extraordinary powerful God is in her own right, who is responsible, in fact for making her excuses life? Hell right. Now, if you go to Greek myths, it's here that's in fact the main cause of all his all his problems. And in fact, it's here who's responsible for perhaps the most tragic event in hairpieces life which of course is sending the goddess of madness Alyssa so that hurricanes goes mad and murders his wife Megara and all his children and this is the extraordinary tragic dark sequel to in fact the Heracles film because the heritage film ends with Hercules and make mega arm in arm together off to be this loving couple now if you know your Greek myth you'll no well Look it's looking fine now but yeah, give it a few years inherit here I should in theory be sending matters to ensure that hurricanes will be murdering poor old make and all the kids they have as well. So so this is kind of really dark kind of this that every time you see big on stage and you think, Oh, God, no, just just run from Him, you know? And there are all these kind of lovely things where Heroclix says, No, I'll never hurt you make and you think, Oh, you are gonna hurt a big time don't it's, it's it really there's kind of dark ironies that run through the film.
Dr Rad 34:47
Yeah, I did think it was very interesting that given that hair, as you say, like from from the moment of his conception basically decides she's going to play Hercules because of course he is. Living Proof of Zeus is on faith. fullness, the fact that he slept with this mortal woman and that kind of stuff. His name obviously even comes from from here as well. So it's interesting that she's not the villain that Hades is. And I think that says obviously a lot about how we understand the god of the underworld. Yeah, it must be something dark and evil something down there, whereas hair is often the light cloudy world of Olympus. But Megara has is definitely a character of fascination, partly because she's obviously come into a lot of criticism because of her appearance. So the fact that I mean all the women but particularly Megara I think have this insane body shape, which may or may not be a Greek vase. But boy, that waist is tiny. And they have turned her into this, like, why is cracking female love interest? Which as you say, it's such a weird choice, because yeah, if you know, your myth, she she's going to get murdered by Hercules.
A Blanshard 35:47
Yes, and certainly, that depiction of Megara is something that that is very common, and aligns with a lot of the depictions that you're seeing in the eyes near Disney, where there's an attempt to have a slightly more sassy, slightly more independent kind of female figure. And, of course, you know, Hercules comes just before Pocahontas, which will be that and then of course, Mulan afterwards, which you know, so so you can sort of see a bit of a trend beginning with Megara going on to going on to Pocahontas and Mulan in Disney thinking. But you know, for all her independent agency, you know, it's still hurricanes who saves the day. And then that is the key centre of the narrative.
Dr G 36:32
We also get this sort of complexity in the plot as well, whereas Meg comes across as being quite independent and having a strong sense of personal agency, only for that to be revealed to us in terms of the plot that she actually she's in the grip of Hades is power.
A Blanshard 36:50
Yeah, although in her defence, you know, she did it because of her bad choice in men, right, she fell for the wrong guy and ended up you know, selling herself to Hades to save him only for him to abandon her and leave her as a slave as a slave to Hades. So, you know, for all her kind of sassy wisecracking nature. You know, ultimately, what really matters if you're a woman is are you able to choose the right guy? That that's what will lead to success or not, not your brains? Not your your ability? With a quick wit? Actually, it's Can you establish a meaningful relationship with a man? That is, that is the success.
Dr G 37:32
Thanks a lot, Disney. Thanks a lot.
Dr Rad 37:35
As you ended up with the guy, he's gonna murder her. Yeah,
A Blanshard 37:39
exactly. Well, at least you'd have to be a princess now. That's the important thing.
Dr G 37:44
What a relief, small steps, small steps.
Dr Rad 37:47
So I'd love to very quickly talk about some of these other characters that we've mentioned in passing. So some of the other sort of major minor characters, the supporting cast are, of course, Hades and Phil, do you have any strong feelings about the portrayal of these people feel obviously not being based on a real God or something per se? Hadees definitely.
A Blanshard 38:08
Yeah. So I think Phil is really interesting, right? So Danny DeVito does a great job with with with the figure of Phil. He's short for Philoctetes. So it's playing on another figure from the Heracles cycle. So Philoctetes was famous in antiquity for having this pussy foot. That meant that he was abandoned by his companions, who sailed on the trip to Troy, left on the island of Lemnos. But importantly, Philoctetes was an associate of Heracles and had the bow of Heracles. And so eventually, they have to come back apologise for abandoning him on the island of Lemnos and he didn't get reincorporated back into society so so that's the story of Philoctetes is known in antiquity as a friend of Heracles the person who inherited his his dying gives the gives his bow to not his personal trainer, but not his personal trainer, and certainly not satyr either. That's the other thing is that he has been turned into a Saturday in this in this film, but yes, yeah. And again, just a great figure you playing on a car cinematic tradition of the boxing trainer, the particularly the Jewish boxing trainer, and there's, there's a way in which Philippines picks up on particular trends in sort of cinematic New York Judaism and so so he's he's this trainer who turns hurricanes in from this kind of weakling into this wonderful buff here. Great role by Danny DeVito. And certainly a good roll by James Woods in Hades Look in played with wonderful, Suave sophistication a fantastically good line in delivery of in this kind of wonderful draw over to that he has done a good figure a complete villain very much in picking up on Judeo Christian ideas of of hell of the devil of the trickster who always always getting you to sign agreements for which you don't see the, the secret clause in. So, again, grounded not so much in weaker in antiquity but very much in Judeo Christian views of the of the devil.
Dr G 40:14
But it does offer us this amazing kind of scene right near the end, where Hercules enters into the underworld and we get our moment of katabasis that is happening where the confrontation between Hades and Hercules happens on Hades territory, which I think I don't know, I just really love that sort of moment. I don't know. It's not really I don't know if I even have a question. Really, it was,
A Blanshard 40:40
as you say, it's a lot as you say, it's a lovely moment. And again, as you rightly point out, picks up on an important epic tradition, namely, the tradition of the descent to the underworld. But catappa says, you know, whether it's Odysseus in The Odyssey, raising the dead, whether it's a near sin in the near this idea of the descent into the underworld, and so again, very, very ancient in terms of an element within ancient narratives. The depiction, of course, is completely Judeo Christian, that the flames, the location, that it picks up on, you know, mediaeval traditions of hellscape. So there's, it's really that kind of Renaissance mediaeval tradition that scarf is, is working through in terms of the visual depictions, but as you say, an important element within ancient narrative traditions.
Dr Rad 41:30
And I'd love to also bring up one of my favourite elements of the movie, which is, of course, the Muses. What are your thoughts on the Muses?
A Blanshard 41:39
How have we taken so long to get to the muses that is the best bit by far and away the stars of this film, such a clever idea to have them as his kind of backup singers, they're kind of sassy. They're funny, it picks up on the idea of the Greek chorus. But what's really wonderful about them is the way in which they kind of undercut so much kind of pomposity that runs through the film, if you if you remember that wonderful opening sequence, which begins with this voiceover,
Dr Rad 42:11
Charlton Heston
A Blanshard 42:16
giving this fantastic, how pompous voiceover, and then the Muses kind of step. So hang on, wait a minute, that's not gonna be this kind of film. And then they launch straight into the jazzy number. And they are, they are clever. They're funny, they, I think, inject a very different kind of tone to this film. They're great. They're absolutely great. I can't get enough of them.
Dr G 42:41
I think they form a great counterpoint, as you say. And there's that gospel tradition that is coming through in the way that the musical numbers operate as well, which I think is a really interesting way of tying the ancient Greek world to sort of more modern and contemporary American cultural elements for the audience.
A Blanshard 43:00
Absolutely. And that opening number of gospel truth really, you know, indicates you know, what trek kind of musical tradition they're they're working from. And again, it kind of is a lovely way of sort of undercutting a lot of the kind of potential whiteness that runs through the runs through the film as well. So it begins with these kind of white statues. And then suddenly, what we see is, in fact, this shot of a vase, or which the the muses are emerging, right, so So we're getting colour in a way that we haven't knew before. We're getting different kinds of musical traditions emerging. This is going to be a very different kind of way of doing of doing Greek myth that is, at least within Disney World, envisaged as much more inclusive and a story that is available to all
Dr Rad 43:47
and of course, there's one more character I have to mention. Pegasus. Pegasus, yes. Who has no place in Hercules? Not at all, not at all.
A Blanshard 43:58
But it's kind of gorgeous. I mean, he's he's part flying horse but also part Labrador as well. He's, he's this kind of fantastic sort of companion for for for Hercules. You're right, I mean, taken from the mythic sequence relating to Bellerophon and and kind of totally out of out of place, but but also also kind of wonderful for for the film.
Dr Rad 44:22
I didn't have it. Now, obviously, I think we've hopefully told our listeners that Disney's Hercules is actually an amazing blend of playing with epic film, Greek myth, American culture. I mean, there's so many aspects that are come together in a Christian ideas soul in this film, but we always have to kind of finish up by thinking about well, what are we talking about when we're talking about the historical accuracy? How important is it for film in general, animated film? I mean, what are your thoughts on trying to achieve historical accuracy in this sort of a film?
A Blanshard 44:56
Well, good luck. But I mean, first of all, you know, tried producing a film about her clothes and not having and doing it without doing the our rating. Right, you know, it's impossible. So, you know, Look, some of the things that worry me about the film are the way in which, you know, Hercules becomes commodified into this very kind of middle class, aspirational, suburban kind of hero. And I think, you know, there's a way in which, you know, Hercules could have been a more inclusive figure that speaks to a much wider demographic than I think, was was potential there. I mean, I think the fact that Olympia is really depicted as this kind of aspirational gated community is, I think, a problem. I think, also the fact that it fiddles around with the birth narrative in such a way that, you know, Hercules is not the product, right, but is in fact, a product of a very happy heteronormative. Couple. So again, I think the potential to to explore, you know, at least issues that were around adultery, or blended families, or even just if the issues of care, foster Hooda are really ignored in that. So I think, you know, there are, I think missed opportunities in the, in the film,
Dr Rad 46:18
I think that's always a nice thing about Greek myth, it's, I think it would have been acceptable to ancients that we play around with it. But as you say, it's the impression that we give our own culture as well, that also has to be considered.
A Blanshard 46:29
Yeah, absolutely. And I mean, there was tremendous, tremendous play in Greek with I mean, the classic example would be something like Euripides as Hercules right, which that as I say, the normal sequence, when we tell the story about the labours of Hercules is Hercules murders his wife and children, and then does the 12 labours to make up for it, your remedies, take turns on his head and has no Heroclix performing the 12 labours, and then murdering his wife and children. Because what he wanted was a tragedy, which had a man at his very highest point, when he thinks he's conquered death, gone down to the underworld, brought back Cerberus, there's nothing that can touch him, and then to be brought low, by, in fact, being caught up in the machinations of here, and the murder of his wife and children. So So even within the ancient world, it was very possible to do tremendously interventionist things with the Hercules storyline, so so that wouldn't worry the ancient world. And I think then, given the amount of play that we have, with Hara cleaves, that then has a kind of interesting ethical obligation of ours. That is, if we're going to play around that we need to think about, you know, what we are, what kinds of stories we tell,
Dr G 47:37
definitely, and I think this is the sort of place where it's probably a good chance to wrap up and because I feel like we could just keep talking about this film and, and the connections to hearing please, for hours, and I know that you need to go and live your life and and I just want to thank you so much for coming and sitting down and chatting to us today.
A Blanshard 47:58
Yeah, absolutely. Great. Fun. Great fun. Always, always good to chat with you.
Dr Rad 48:03
Absolutely. So just a reminder that if you'd like to read up on some of the issues we've touched on today, if you'd like to delve more into the life of Hercules and the myths surrounding him, you definitely want to pick up Alastair's book on Hercules, Hercules or heroic life. And if you'd like to learn more about film in general on screen, including Hercules and please pick up classics on screen which is a fantastic book, which has got chapters on lots of different movies, and Alastair is the co author of that.
Thank you for listening to this episode of the Partial historians. We hope that you enjoy the episode and if you did, please consider becoming a Patreon. It is thanks to our marvellous patrons that we are able to make special episodes like this. We'd also like to once again thank Professor Alastair Blanshard the Paul Eliadis chair of classics in ancient history at the University of Queensland, for coming on the show and chatting to us all about Hercules. If you enjoyed listening to Alastair, he really does have a wide array of publications out there beyond his work on history on film, and he's also a regular contributor to the conversation. Until next time, we are yours in ancient Rome
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/
Support the show
Patreon
Ko-Fi
Read our books
Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome
Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
We return to the 410s BCE to explore some classic Conflict of the Orders. This one will end with an evil patrician plan (mwahahaha) to divide and conquer their plebeian foes.
Episode 141 – Divide and Conquer
Some Unfinished BusinessThe Romans had been engaged in battle with the Aequians when we last checked in on them. Due to some slappy fighting between the military tribunes with consular power, a dictator had been called in to get this military campaign back on track.
Quintus Servilius was chosen for their role, and he took his son along for the ride. Fortunately for this father-son duo, the Aequians were getting sloppy. Servilius took full advantage of their overconfidence and whipped the Romans into shape. He even ordered the death of a slightly hesitant standard-bearer! With the stern Servilius Snr in charge, the Romans manage to turn the tables on their enemies.
Roman standards were considered to be sacred by the legions. It is most unusual that the dictator ordered the death of a standard-bearer on the spot! Image courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.
The Land from LabiciThanks to the defeat of the Labicani and the Aequians, the Romans finally have some new territory on their hands. Terrified that the tribunes of the plebs might try to redistribute the land, the Senate quickly established a colony in the new area.
Trouble from the TribunesThe senators were probably right to be afraid, as two tribunes decided to put forward a new agrarian law. Land taken from the enemies of Rome should be split up and divvied up between the citizens. Cue some more Conflict of the Orders!
The patricians were alarmed by this outrageous proposal. The descendent of uber—patrician royalty, Appius Claudius, was there to steer the patricians down a nefarious path. It was time to take the tribunes of the plebs on; to divide and conquer…
Things To Look Out For:Lucius Papirius L. f. -. n. Mugillanus (Pat). Previously consul in 427 and military tribune with consular power 422.
Our Players 417 BCEMilitary Tribunes with Consular PowerOur music was composed by Bettina Joy de Guzman. Sound effects are courtesy of BBC Beta.
Automated TranscriptCourtesy of Otter AI.
Dr Rad 0:12
Welcome to the partial historians.
Dr G 0:15
We explore all the details of ancient Rome.
Dr Rad 0:20
Everything from political scandals to love affairs, the battles waged, and when citizens turn against each other. I'm Dr. Rad.
Dr G 0:30
And I'm Dr. G. We consider Rome as the Roman saw it by reading different ancient authors and comparing their accounts.
Dr Rad 0:41
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr G 0:59
Hello, and welcome to a brand new episode of the partial historians. I am one of your hosts, Dr. G.
Dr Rad 1:08
And I'm very excited Dr. Racks are trying out a new setup.
Dr G 1:12
This may or may not succeed,
Dr Rad 1:15
it's gonna be the most interesting episode audio logically,
Dr G 1:20
we want to say a huge shout out thank you to our patrons, because it is through their support that we were able to invest in some new equipment, and everybody's gonna hear the results for better or worse.
Dr Rad 1:34
We are audio geniuses, of course, it's going to work out it's going to be amazing. Just your way. Yes. Now strategy, we are tracing the journey of hearing from the founding of the city. And I owe you and all of our listeners a big apology. Oh, did you break the history of Rome from the value of the city somehow I may just have. So last episode, I left you all on a cliffhanger, our dictator of 418 BC about to march out into battle. And I said I was finishing there because I thought we were heading into a new year. Turns out I was wrong. Oh no, I got confused. Because you see 417 and 416 are blended together. But 418 is in fact quite distinct.
Dr G 2:18
I have terrible news for you. You're gonna have to hand back in your PhD.
Dr Rad 2:23
I'll just be rad.
I hate it. I'm sorry. All right. So when we do the recap, therefore this episode, I am going to not only recap what happened last time, but also add some more information. Oh, excellent. All right. Well, let's get into where were we up to in this narrative anyway?
Well, so I believe we were up to 418 BCE last episode, and we ended up with some military Tribune's with consular power who could not get along to save themselves.
Tragedy. Yeah, Look, you know, arguments abound, poor strategic decisions were made. It wasn't great. And there was a man who was the father of one of these gentleman Quintus Servilius.
Sounds like I'm making fun of him whenever I use that V. But
Dr G 3:12
I mean, that's his name.
Dr Rad 3:15
I know, it just sounds funny. Like what does Servilius
Dr G 3:18
Is he asking for ridicule? perhaps, especially if I add on Quintus Servilius, Priscus Fidenas.
Dr Rad 3:26
So this guy had seen that there was going to be travelled because he it's actually only been what like maybe six or seven years, maybe eight Max, since we last had an issue where the commanders were arguing, and it led to military disaster for room. So he sees the writing on the wall, allegedly. And he basically makes sure that he and his son are going to be there and prepared to kind of step in and handle the situation, which he thinks is going to arise which is military disaster for the Romans.
Dr G 4:00
This is a typical elitist plan. Not only is he going to get himself into power, he's going to bring his son along with him, and it's all going to be great. It does seem suspicious that he and his son are the ones that you know, come in to do the whole here we come to save the day thing.
Dr Rad 4:16
I mean, yeah, I have some concerns. But you know, for 18 being what it is chaotic, fine, fine. Yes, exactly. So, essentially, the way that they did this is they made sure that not every available man had been sent out to face the Romans enemies who I should add the Aequians and the people of Labici.
Dr G 4:39
The Labicani, Yes, who re entered the narrative as one of the sort of like surrounding neighbours, who was a little bit upset with Rome for the way that Rome has treated them over and over again. And I think from what you said last time, they've been nursing this garage for almost 100 years now, pretty much as soon as the Republic is started. They've been upset.
Dr Rad 5:02
Oh No.
Yeah, exactly. So in 418 BC last episode, we finished up with the dictator Quintus Servilius and his master of the horse, which is his son, therefore, another Servilius marching out together to face the enemy with fresh troops after things predictably not going so well for the Romans. Yeah, yes, coming in to save the day. Exactly. Now, I did hint that the Aequians were in for some trouble at the end of last episode because they had been doing so well against the Romans because you know, the Romans are just too busy fighting too will fight each other I should say then to fightthat they also started to get sloppy.
the results of this was seen immediately. Dr. G. In the very first battle, you can see that the Aequians and their allies, the people of the Labicani are off their game,
Dr G 6:00
A little bit of a mess, a hot mess waiting to happen in the Castelli Romani region.
Dr Rad 6:05
Yeah, so the dictator Quintus Sebelius, he goes into battle leading hard with the cavalry, and the cavalry caused the entire front line of the Aequians to be disrupted. They're in chaos, Dr. G.
Speaker 2 6:20
Well, a dictator shows up and everybody runs for the hills, basically. Now this guy is super hardcore, because wait till I add this detail. So once they've sent the frontlines of the Aequians and the leper colony into chaos, he orders that the Romans sort of quick march and just advance quickly, I guess the idea being sort of overwhelmed them as fast as possible. And apparently one of the standard bearers kind of like hesitates. Now, I don't know if this means he's like, Wait, left, right? Where are we going? I don't know what hesitation he's giving like, did he cry..?
Dr Rad 6:52
Can we stop for for gelato? Guys, because I really need a break right now. Yeah, I don't know what the hesitation was. But whatever it was Servilius dictator does not take it kindly, and he has him killed on the spot.
Dr G 7:04
I would have thought that would be a bad omen. The standard bearer is a very important person. They're looking after the standard.
Dr Rad 7:11
I know, it seems so weird, but he was like he's getting cut down on the spot.
Dr G 7:16
I feel like the Romans who had viewed that would be shocked and traumatised.
Dr Rad 7:21
Well, apparently they're very excited. Dr. G. That's what they are very excited.
Dr G 7:25
These people will never cease to amaze me with their horrors.
Dr Rad 7:28
They're just like, You know what, we're just gonna give it our all. And so the Aequians and the leper colony quickly overwhelmed, they lose the battle, they flee the battlefield, they run back to their camp. Oh, how the tables have turned.
Dr G 7:41
So you're telling me that in the time of you've got to like get the troops roused up somehow that the best way to do that is to kill one of their own?
Dr Rad 7:48
Well, I don't know if they're excited because of the standard bearer staff. They're just excited because it seems that they're doing well, I think. Yeah, and I think they apparently invigorated by the energy of Quintus Servilius which is Stern.
Dr G 8:03
So invigorating, exactly.
Dr Rad 8:06
Silverfox Yeah, so wiliest, sir. Yes, sir. Yeah, so the Romans are able to quite easily also capture the camp of the enemy. And of course, within the camp, there are many spoils she had
Dr G 8:19
Oh, booty,
Dr Rad 8:20
It is bootay time.
Dr G 8:23
I wonder where that leather armour went?
Dr Rad 8:25
Yes. As we've often pointed out, because they are fighting the same people and over again, we really feel like their possessions are just in rotation.
Dr G 8:32
It is tough out there. It takes a long time to make a full suit of armour. Yeah, of course, you want to steal it back.
Dr Rad 8:37
So Servilius, I guess to show his gratitude says that the soldiers may have the booty
Dr G 8:43
very generous.
Dr Rad 8:44
I know, I know. Now the Roman cavalry. Meanwhile, they are hard at work. They are chasing the Aequians with the remaining ones, I suppose as they run away from the camp. They've just been running all day or stuff out there. I mean, they're in a hilly region. It's not like this is an easy run. I know. And they come back and inform our dictator Servilius that the remaining Aequians and the Labicani who've managed to survive the slaughter up until this moment are all hiding in Labici.
Dr G 9:15
Yeah, fair enough. I mean, that's where I would hide as well with Rome's known enemy, who was also involved in the battle, but currently not being chased. Best place to hide
Dr Rad 9:23
so the Romans march off to Labici The next day, have a good rest beforehand. They quickly encircled us letters to get over the walls and completely ravaged this city. Oh, yeah. It's all in a very.
Dr G 9:39
I didn't even have a reaction to that. I'm just like, really? That's it?
Dr Rad 9:43
Because Livy's very precise in his details here. So Servilius marches back to room with his triumphant army and once he gets there, he hands back his powers and he had been dictator live. He tells me for a total of eight
Dr G 9:55
days. Wow, this is an exceptionally false cat. In pain I know, right? I mean, it would take at least until lunch on the first date of March there.
Dr Rad 10:05
Yeah. So it's considering that it's built up as being obviously, you know, a potential disaster for Rome, typically a bit suspiciously. The Romans bounce back very quickly and very easily.
Dr G 10:15
This is their way they love a good bounce back is it's
Dr Rad 10:18
just the way that the history has been written.
Dr G 10:24
I cannot possibly comment at this time.
Dr Rad 10:27
I demand answers. Now, obviously, we actually finally have a bit of expansion on our hand strategy,
Dr G 10:35
do we we do Oh, my goodness. And still in 418? Yeah,
Dr Rad 10:39
yeah. This is Oh, 418. Oh, yeah. So the Senate concerned because we now have the city of Labici in our evil imperialist clause. But there are concerns because you know, who else would like to have Labici?
Dr G 10:56
Is it the Aequians? No. I mean, the people who used to live there are lots
Dr Rad 11:02
of people that would like to have it. But I mean, within Rome. Oh, nice. Like to
Dr G 11:07
have people who would most like to have it in a row? Yeah. The military traders who control the power,
Dr Rad 11:12
kind of, but the people that the Senate are most concerned about are, of course, the tribune of the plebs and the people themselves. Wow, that makes sense. Yeah, they're very concerned that they're going to start buying off all this new land that's coming in from the Labican territory, so they very quickly hold a meeting and determined that they will establish a colony
Dr G 11:34
there. So land distribution is not on the table. Well,
Dr Rad 11:38
I think that's what they foresee. And they're like, No,
Dr G 11:42
that's not on my what
Dr Rad 11:44
No. So 1500 colonists are sent from Rome to this new colony. And they are apparently given five eighthsWe of an acre.
Dr G 11:54
Well, that's pretty good. That's more than people get today.
Dr Rad 11:57
Well apparently, my commentator thinks that the amount that is specified in Livy, would not be enough for a family to survive on and therefore, it's not really correct that he thinks they would have been given a lot more.
Dr G 12:12
Yeah, it is problematic. It might be enough for one person to grow some things but I don't know if it's enough for self sufficiency for a family.
Dr Rad 12:21
Yes, my commentator thinks that this amount that Livy's specifies must be more in reference to where his household gods would reside. Like this is the area in which his household essentially is being established.
Dr G 12:37
Ah, as in the building itself. Yeah,
Dr Rad 12:39
I guess so. Yeah. And this is like his little sacred land sort of thing of his of his skins. interesting theories. And that is actually where for 18 Should Have Ended?
Dr G 12:53
Well, under those circumstances, I'm willing to give Rome one more gold eagle for their expansion.
Dr Rad 13:00
Exactly. I mean, they're still gonna get it, they're just gonna get it a bit later. But that takes us into 417 BCE for me, Dr. G. Would you like to tell us who the magistrates are and I should say, I think we probably should go through 417 and 416 together because in my account, they are treated as really one in the same
Dr G 13:22
foreshadowing.
Dr Rad 13:32
Hey, listeners, do you enjoy awkward family dynamics, relationships between mortals and gods? Then you will love our book Rex: The seven kings of Rome. Rex is newly available in an ebook in the Amazon Kindle store and also on Gumroad however, if you're keen to get your hands on a printed copy, we still have a few left, and they are now being sold through Abby's bookstore in Sydney. And thanks so much to all those who've already bought a copy we really appreciate your support. And now back to the episode
Dr G 14:20
is 417 bc we have military tributes with concealer power. So first cab off the rank Publius Lucretius Hosti Tricipitinus I do not like this name. He has returned and I still don't like it.
Dr Rad 14:42
Ironically, Tricipitinus does not trip off the tongue.
Dr G 14:46
No, no, indeed. Previously military Tribune with consular power in 419. So very recent that we've had this sort of horror of pronounciation upon us He is joined by Agrippa Menenius Lanatus, also previously console in 439. And also previously military Tribune with Triciptinus that old chestnut in 419. So these two it's like being reunited for our whole new adventure.
Dr Rad 15:17
It is interesting that he had a gap of 20 years seemingly between holding magistracies Until Tricipitinus. Is is on the scene a year
Dr G 15:27
raising suspicions about Roman naming conventions. It might be fair enough. And we also have Gaius or potentially Lucius Servilius Axilla, or Structus. This guy we don't know. I mean, he's all over the shop name wise. But the good news is that he's on year three of his hat trick of military tribune with consular power. Not that he got to do much the previous year because he kind of got swept up in the whole being master of the horse instead business. Yeah, so this is the son of our dictator. This is the son of our dictator. So he was the one who was hanging around as the master of the horse in Rome. Last year. Yeah. For 18. Yes. The name confusion continues on Sky is a tricky one. Yeah, there is also Spurius Rutilius Crassus. I know offer this with massive question ma indeed, because it seems more likely that the fourth guy is not a Rutilius Crassus but is a Spurius Veturius Crassus Cicurinus. I mean, I don't know. But the problem with it being a Rutilius Crassus is that this is very much a plebeian name.
Yes. And we're not there yet, as we've established. Many and many
scholars don't agree on many things. But one of the things that they tend to agree on is that this is way too early for them to actually be a plebeian in this role.
Dr Rad 17:03
Unless, of course, it's all crap. And the Roman state isn't established the waiver and said it is and for the ins and patricians? Do they exist at this point in time? It is I'll have
Dr G 17:12
more to say on that topic later. So the trouble with the rebellious thing is that there's no routinely i in the fastI, as we are aware of it, yeah, for another 250 years. Yeah. And
Dr Rad 17:27
with Roman naming conventions, it feels really unlikely that you would just have one random guy from a family pop up, and then no one in the family pop up again.
Dr G 17:38
This is something that you build over time, and family reputation gets sort of baked in. And so you're expecting a slow progression of people to come into positions and then to be followed through by their relatives. And that's not what we see. In this case. We don't get a routine AI for ages. The praenomen Spurius doesn't go with this gens historically, from the examples that we do have, neither does the cognomen Crassus.
Dr Rad 18:00
Yes, exactly.
Dr G 18:01
So it's all just kind of speculation and wildness and probably not a plebeian sad news, because we're Pro Plebeian on this podcast. It's pretty clear. Yeah. And that is not what we're getting in 417 BCE.
Dr Rad 18:15
So should we do 416? Or do you have enough information to separate those years out?
Dr G 18:22
Don't be like that. What I can tell you is in terms of my source material, yeah, is that I have a little excerpt from the Fasti Capitolini Which basically proves that Lucretius Hosti is somebody that we should care about. Likewise, Agrippa Menenius and otherwise everybody else is up for grabs. And that Diodorus Siculus appears to be more on top of the names than Livy
Defeat I don't know people better the place than me seem to think that or Siculus got the information right
Dr Rad 19:04
this time. Fair enough. Fair enough. Look, it's not like Livy hasn't made a mistake with names before All right, well, shall we get it through for 16 then because as I say, this is a very blended together for me.
Dr G 19:17
Okay, so you've got some blending I've got a whole bunch of different names for 416
Dr Rad 19:21
No, no, I do like that. They are separate but I mean, the actions all blended together All right. Yeah.
Dr G 19:27
Okay, well, I feel sorry for the aforementioned players of 417
Dr Rad 19:32
out they're gonna come into it maybe the Chinese are a bit
Dr G 19:34
bit players at best. So our people for 416 We've got military tributes for cultural power again, yeah, Aulus Sempronius Atratinus
A name we know well by now.
Yeah. Previously consul in 428. Not a named consul, but one of the sort of suffect consul and also a military Tribune in 425 and 420. Oh, My other note is that despite his appearance in many years, he doesn't appear to have distinguished himself in any particular way.
Dr Rad 20:06
Well, this is the guy I think, who was accused of holding fake elections and it led to his relative being prosecuted.
Wow. And yet he's back. Yeah, I'm pretty sure that's him. His reputation has recovered. Well, yeah, cuz I mean, it's just attributing to accused him of it and nobody pays attention to the interview. Oh, that's right.
Dr G 20:25
I listened to those guys that crazy. Yeah. And Marcus Papirius Mugillanus. Yes. Again, very familiar. Yes, very recently. Was military Tribune in 418. Yep. Quintus Fabius Vibulanus. Again, I've heard that name before console in 423. So you know, we're all coming about in the same sort of air. Yes. Spurius Nautius Rutilus. US military Tribune in 419.
Dr Rad 20:52
Noticing a bit of a bit of a trend Yeah. And
Dr G 20:56
some return of some players. Everybody sort of had a bit of a role before. Is this a sign of trouble afoot for row on the military front where they're like, You know what, we don't just need commanders we need experienced commanders might say something about that. Don't give the narrative away just yet. We also have two named tribune of the plebs. Yeah, as I understand it, Sextus Maecilius. And somebody who might be Marcus Metilius.
Dr Rad 21:27
Alright, so let me explain why, at least in my narrative, this all blends together a lot.
Dr G 21:34
All right. I'm looking forward to the tail. Well, yeah.
Dr Rad 21:36
I guess as as Livy's specifically notes that we do have a lot of repeat players this time around in both for 17. And for 16. And basically room is actually in quite a peaceful period externally. Allegedly, I'm a little bit suspicious because there are so many military Tribune's is constantly power. But also, I mean, it hasn't been very peaceful recently. This is true. Maybe it's just a precautionary measure, but not so peaceful. internally. Dr. G. Once again, agrarian issues come to the fore.
Dr G 22:10
Yeah, well, they didn't give me enough land this. I mean, how am I supposed to live?
Dr Rad 22:15
Yeah, well, not the not those issues. You might expect it will be the colonists, but it's not.
Dr G 22:19
It's not coming from the new colonists of the Labicani? Okay, yeah.
Dr Rad 22:24
So if the tribunes have got sort of causing problems, okay, our friend Maecilius, who apparently is serving for the fourth time as Tribune, and Metilius, who is apparently serving for the third time
Dr G 22:38
Oh, so we have some very experienced plebeians in the rows.
Dr Rad 22:42
Well, again, now, this is not to say that they didn't serve, but we haven't had any record of who's going
Dr G 22:50
to be like that. Obviously, they're preparing for the fourth and third time,
Dr Rad 22:53
we're just gonna have to take Livy's word for it that they have served previously. So these two Tribune's decided that they're going to put forward a law where land taken from the enemies of Rome should be split up and apostle given to each Roman citizen. So effectively, what they're doing is to take away the riches of the very wealthy. And the idea is that most of the really noble Gavin's in Rome would be hit and hit hard if they manage to pass this law. Now, there are a lot of red flags here, in case you're wondering. So the only new territory we've really mentioned of late is of course, Labici. Right. So you might be thinking that they're referring to that land specifically, but it doesn't seem like they are it kind of seems like maybe they mean, land in general. That room has been founded on territory that's been gradually one and pieced together. That's That's why they'd be hitting the families really hard.
Dr G 24:04
Okay, that sort of inch by inch, clawing it back from the list guns or something.
Dr Rad 24:10
Yeah. And it's also kind of insinuating that obviously, the idea is that land that is one in battle becomes part of the public land, and that the patricians are somehow monopolising that, or have monopolised that in the past and pavilions aren't just getting a Look in at all. But as we've talked about before, this isn't a rich versus poor divide. We do have wealthy plebeians. And so this kind of asks us to believe that the only way wealthy plebeians have acquired land is by buying it somehow when it comes up for sale. It just it just raises a lot of questions about how exactly this is working. Do they just mean the new colony? are they referring more broadly to other things? It's a bit up in question. But certainly the tribunes feel that this is fair because they think hardly any land within room or outside of it has not been won by fighting. And yet the patricians hold most of the land. And so obviously, this is the ill feeling that they're tapping into.
Dr G 25:17
Yeah. And that seems appropriate. And it's trying to think about how would an ancient economy navigate things like this? So like, how is wealth characterised? And how do you come into the acquisition of land? And how do you retain it? Because it's not like you necessarily have like a piece of paper? We have, we're thinking about the foundation of the city itself. You've got stones that mark out areas? Yeah, you know, so if a family goes out and sticks some stone somewhere overnight, who knows? Like, does that make it legal? How does it operate in a practical sense? And if are you capable of only possessing the things that you can fight for and then win? Yeah. Because then your gains become super important to your land holdings, because part of the function of again, is to come together as a war band, and to protect property ownership. Yes. So the bigger the gains, the more powerful the more potential. So it might not necessarily be about wealth acquisition, outside in an economical sense, because that might not be the sort of power you need to be able to take land and then retain it.
Dr Rad 26:26
Well, and this is exactly I think, this kind of story. I mean, Look, I should perhaps say that people are very dubious about whether this ever happened because it is just such a classic conflicts between the patricians and plebeians, you know, the squaring off against each other. People are very dubious about whether this actually happened, particularly because we're the character of Metilius. There's been questions raised about whether that name was injected potentially by one Dionysius of Halicarnassus because his patrons were Metiliii…
Dr G 27:00
Well, Well, Well, trash talk.
Dr Rad 27:05
Exactly. But there have been questions raised certainly about the veracity of these events. However, I think if we do Look at this story, it would again suggest that Rome is far more disorganised tribal and warlord ish, which is totally legitimate academic word, then it is being
Dr G 27:26
described in our literary material from hundreds of years later.
Dr Rad 27:29
Exactly, exactly. But Livy and Dionysius are making it seem like there's a really organised state with a very clear career progression and
Dr G 27:39
yeah, and highly D alienated class system already in
Dr Rad 27:42
play. Yeah. Which seems unlikely. If you Look at this sort of story.
Dr G 27:46
Well, there's no reason why you wouldn't have a hierarchical system of some kind happening. So how does it unfold in practical terms, and is what the sources telling us the most likely implausible explanation for what was happening in the past based on other things that we might be able to find out. And this is the part of the trouble that we have generally with this period is that we have so little extant material from other sources to be able to sort of CO opt into something that might be a narrative. We've got archaeological remains, and we've got a little bit of epigraphy. And we've got this and that, and they're, they're there. But they're not necessarily providing that wholesale sort of sweeping narrative that our riders later on are able to produce and then go on to survive. So we're a little bit hampered by what we have access to.
Dr Rad 28:38
Exactly. So if I am going to proceed with this story, let's obviously pretend that we believe everything Livy's saying,
Dr G 28:46
I'm so excited for when I'm gonna let you tell your story. And then I'm gonna maybe I'll do is I'll do some things.
Dr Rad 28:52
All right, so the military tribune's with consular power had been consulting with the Senate. So obviously a bit more of an official public kind of consultation that's going on, but they also are having little private teetotalers with the leading men. So I would read the men with the most doctorates as potentially the most wealth, and certainly substantial political and military experience behind them. And in this narrative, definitely patricians and they're trying to come up with an evil plan to defeat the tribune of the plebs. Now live he doesn't explicitly say at this point, so the story goes, which makes it sound incredibly like hearsay that's this is where one Appius Claudius enters our narrative. Oh, no,
Dr G 29:45
no, no, I'm still I'm still dealing with my trauma for the last FAS Clodius they caught me back No.
Dr Rad 29:53
So Appius Claudius. Now dear listeners room and naming conventions strike again. This is not the The Appius Claudius of infamy, but the grandson of the decimvir, who you may be recalling the one that had organised the potential abduction with the idea of obviously making her sexually subservient to him of Virginia, the plebeian maid.
Dr G 30:19
Yes. what a what a man who could forget
Dr Rad 30:22
now this Appius Claudius is the youngest man in the Senate. Cute. Yeah. No.
Dr G 30:28
How old is he
Dr Rad 30:29
doesn't say, I mean, it could be 30. I mean, even 40. Really?
Dr G 30:35
I was gonna say, the Spry 42. Exactly,
Dr Rad 30:39
exactly. Now, he decides that he's going to put forward an old idea from way back in the day from his family. Oh, yeah. You know, it's gonna be awful. So this comes from not the desam there, but an even even Appius. Claudius. Yes. Now, there are some disputes about exactly how great this grandfather is. Is it his great grandfather or his great, great grandfather? But either way, his name is still Appius Claudius.
Dr G 31:09
It doesn't matter how far back you go. It's Appius Claudius all the way down.
Dr Rad 31:13
We think that this particular Appius Claudius would have been his great grandfather who was consul in 471 That he's throwing back to him. Yeah, the the good old days. Yeah. So Appius Claudius reminds his fellow senators that a good way to destroy the power of the Tribune's of the plebs, is by harnessing the veto power of other Tribune's of the plebs, in other words, turning them against each other divide and conquer my friend, exactly. I do remember talking about this. He says, It's not that hard. Because elite men in Rome just have to choose someone who's not as experienced not as established amongst the tribunes and use their influence to turn them against their colleagues and use them for their own advantage. Because the whole idea, of course, is that there's obviously more than just these two Tribune's who are serving at this point in time. These attributes, however, are getting all the notoriety they're sucking all the air out of the room, Dr. G, by causing issues and trying to win popularity with the people. What about those that are left behind in the background? Dr. G, what about the wallflower Tribune's? What about them?
Dr G 32:27
What about the quiet Romans? Exactly.
Dr Rad 32:30
So instead, one way that they could advance their career path is by getting on the good side of the whole Senate by really helping them out doing a solid, you know, by turning on their tribute and colleagues, and particularly in it for them favour favour. Especially currying favour with the leading senators. Well, well, well yeah. Now the Senate is really like this flat because
Dr G 33:02
that's the kind of plan where they get to do exactly what they like and maybe they have to throw a nice dinner party later and and fight this guy that they don't even care about once.
Dr Rad 33:11
Exactly. And so it is on like Donkey Kong, they Cana then listed. All the senators are also very impressed with Appius. Claudius, especially.
Dr G 33:24
It's kind of hilarious. Be like, why did we think of that? Like, dude, you'd have thought of that?
Dr Rad 33:29
Especially Quintus Servilius Priscus, our dictator from the previous year who's clearly an Uber for attrition, so he says to Appius Claudius, you're living up to the Guardian name your young whippersnapper pipit carry on.
Dr G 33:45
I love it carry on the great tradition of your forebears.
Dr Rad 33:49
Yes. And so all members of the Senate are given a mission possible. We're going to talk to a tribune of the plebs and try and get them to use their veto. So three promising favours personal gratitude, as well as also I think, a bit of a mixture of, you know, threats, they managed to win over six of the tribunes of the plebs today aside, wow.
Dr G 34:14
And we've only got two names.
Dr Rad 34:16
I know. Me as traitors. Yeah. They change to the dustbin.
Dr G 34:23
Gordon reason day, you'd be a class trader.
Dr Rad 34:26
Exactly. So the following day, the Senate set the plan into motion. So let's start by discussing the issues raised by my Caelius Antonius. The leading senators then get up and make speeches about what they have proposed, all very, as we would expect, they then beseech the tribunes to protect the Republic, don't stand against this law, put forward by their colleagues.
Dr G 34:50
She's in danger. Somebody's got to Look after
Dr Rad 34:53
Yes, they will. Like Tribune's can do more than just create problems between the patricians and plebeians. If you can stop your colleagues from harming
Dr G 35:04
the state, yeah, you can solve problems.
Dr Rad 35:07
Yeah. And so all the senators call on the tribunes to come to their aid and as dire out of need. And the tribunes, who had been won over now spoke up and said they were only too happy to use their veto against this proposal. And the Senate version. Thanks. Wow. Yeah,
Dr G 35:26
I'm very disappointed. I know. But we get so close to land reform, and then it just snatched away in an instant. Yeah,
Dr Rad 35:33
Maecilius and Metilius can't really do much anymore. Apart from summit and assembly.Call all these tribunes that agreed with the Senate turncoats and class traitors and lots of other nasty names. They rant and rave and then they grumpily agreed to put an end to their proposal. Wow. And that is when 417. And 416.
Dr G 35:55
It's a bit of a mess, isn't it?
Dr Rad 35:57
It is Look, I mean, number one, it suggests that there isn't necessarily just like this clear classifier that you are patrician, or you're playing. As we've talked about before, it would be highly possible if we accept that these two different classes exist that wealthy affiliates actually have more in common with patricians than they do perhaps, you know, people who are like really low down in terms of their socio economic status. However, it does also suggest to me that potentially, maybe some of the problems are being blamed on the plebeians. Possibly, I mean, I have no basis for this, apart from the fact that I think Louis is very pretty patrician.
Dr G 36:38
Yeah. So like, how does Roman politics work? And like, what are the sort of like class politics, not just class politics, but you know, how does the society function through the decisions that are has to make as a collective like part of the point of having something like Rome, which is functioning like a city state at this point? How does it navigate the requirements that are coming up from its citizen body? And part of that might have to be an acknowledgement that we're dealing with the cream of the crop here? Yeah, almost at all times. We very rarely actually get to see people, or and we certainly don't get the perspectives of people who are living their daily lives in the struggle, and tend to be then co opted and levied into the army, yeah, for some sort of military action, and then returned home or not, depending on what happens. Yeah, otherwise, we're dealing with what seems to be this sort of finicky interest group of people jostling at the very top, who wants something a little bit more than they've already got, and can't quite agree on how they're going to make it work. And the people who have things already, obviously, have a vested interest in maintaining the status quo, and the people who are on the edge of that are looking in and being like, I'm so close to having that they don't want to take down the system necessarily. They want to be firmly embedded in the system at the very top.
Dr Rad 38:01
Exactly. And that's also I think, feeds into this idea. I feel like we see more corruption on the side of the plebeians, and we do to patricians, it's not that you don't ever see, like class traitors on either side, you do, we've talked about them before the patrician ones tend to get killed.
Dr G 38:17
There's been some great instances of prescriptions that have sort of elevated plebeian causes or taking the side of the tribunes at certain points in time. But the way that our source material is navigating that is to suggest that maybe that was problematic at best.
Dr Rad 38:32
Yeah. And I just feel like that's plebeians come off. In a worse light more often, particularly the tribune of the plebs, they're either causing issues causing problems, or they're betraying each other to get ahead, but it just doesn't come up. Something about it just makes me suspicious and makes me think, Hmm, what are you about young Livy?
Dr G 38:54
I think it's worth being suspicious. I mean, Livy is writing under Augustus, essentially. And this means that his perspective on Rome is a very different world from the world that he's writing about in this period of his history, too. So there is that fact, first and foremost, but so the political context is very different. But also, who is his intended audience? Is it other Romans, and then again, which other Romans, he's writing in Latin, he's writing for somebody. So those sorts of questions start to raise themselves as well. And we're dealing with this period where, from our perspective, now, we've got very little to counteract a narrative presented to us like the one that Livy's offers.
Dr Rad 39:37
Well, it's so bizarre to me, because of course, by his own time, being patrician or being plebeian, it barely matters anymore. Like it does matter for a few things. But it's certainly not a barrier to success. You know, if you're if you're from the plebeian classes, you can indeed be very wealthy and be involved in politics. So it's weird to me sometimes I suppose when we see these sorts of things, but as we talk about that when we see the blending of patrician and pavilions gradually over time, it's still just the elite. It's just the elite that are at the top there, and therefore, who he's writing for is the elite. And even though, you know, fortunes rise and fall for families, and that's one thing over time, but we do often have similar families, I think, who are going to be at the top for substantial periods of time, I think
Dr G 40:23
in if we're thinking about Livy, and what's going on with patricians and plebeians, my flesh rabbits, yes. And we certainly see that some people do change from one to the others might distinctly and there's various ways to do that. And I think that tells us that gives us some indication of the nature of what we might think of today as class. And I'm using this as an analogy. It's not, it's not something that you could base or hinge everything on. But in the way in which a class society and I thinking of the English in particular, because I think they form a great example, Australians like to think they don't have class. And that is problematic in itself. But the English definitely recognised class as a category. And if you're born into an upper middle class family, that's very different from being the lowest here of the aristocracy. And everybody knows it. And it almost doesn't matter how much you achieve in your life. It's very different, very difficult to shift from upper middle class into the aristocracy. You know, there was a huge barrier there. Yeah. So I think this is one of those things where the Romans might be in that kind of situation where it's like, everybody knows precisely where you sit. Yeah. And it's very difficult to move. Very rare cases of it happening. Yeah. And it does have, it probably has an effect on the way you think about yourself as a Roman, what kind of Roman i So I wonder, but I said I was going to break some stuff.
Dr Rad 41:49
I was gonna say I'm waiting for your electrifying details. So to GE,
Dr G 41:52
well, in the absence of my source material, I went to the secondary scholarship.
Dr Rad 41:56
ood
Dr G 41:58
tell me Well, so I was like, you know, let's find out some more about what's happening in this period. If we can get what your school is reckon might be happening. I mean, we're all dealing with very sort of small amounts of information. How do we do anything? Yeah. And I started reading Holloway's article from 2008. Who were the tribuni militum consulare potestate? Who were they? Who were the military tribunes with consular power? Yeah. And his position or their position, I should say, because I don't know the gender of their position seems to be that. What if the fastI and the list that we have for magistrates were really retrogene actually made up? Once people started writing down history?
Dr Rad 42:47
This is very much in keeping with what we've just.
Dr G 42:51
Yeah, so what if it is the case that you know, people in like the first century BC decided to write some mysteries and the like, is going to be great. They're like, where do I start? And like, there are no records. There were literally direct
Dr Rad 43:03
material guys. Yeah, that's really tough.
Dr G 43:05
How do I write this? You know? And what they then do, is they do what we we've talked about this before they go to family archives, yeah. Walk into people's houses, and people have their family trees on display, essentially with the Margot's?
Dr Rad 43:20
Absolutely, I mean, that that would definitely be a source that would exist because the Romans are super into their families,
Dr G 43:25
super into their families. And so the masks of their deceased ancestors are all displayed on the wall and you know, presumably in some sort of order, which gives you a sense of their illustriousness, or their antiquity, etc, etc. Yes, but obviously, that's one element of it. He then also talks about how Cicero warns everybody against believing family archives, were like, you know, people make up some stuff for that, you know?
Dr Rad 43:50
Well, yes. But Cicero was also fairly new. He
Dr G 43:54
was a novice. Homer really is true. Yeah. Didn't have an ancestor to his name. So Cicero is, you know, sort of like, be careful, because people exaggerate their achievements, which I think fair, cool. Yeah. They also might falsely tell people about magistracies that they've held that they've never
Dr Rad 44:10
held, because he's going to be added yet.
Dr G 44:12
Coombe lenient? Yeah. And Spurius genealogies, like where did your family come from? That's like, Oh, come on. I'm a routine alias. Obviously.
Dr Rad 44:23
This again, is giving me such America, you know, 19th century. It's like, Where does your family come from? Really?
Dr G 44:31
Really? Yeah, like you can just make stuff up. It's not very far back in my own family's history where people were making stuff up. I know about that. But I don't know. Don't go checking everybody.
Dr Rad 44:45
And jump to Ge Ge was a GE
Dr G 44:48
Search carefully. As single letter, what can you discover? We also have this idea that perhaps we've got the fastI but Holloway is kind of like maybe we don't have the facts. St may be the first to our creation once people start writing that narrative history, and they need to fill in the blanks. And they're consulting these family archives, and there are too many names. And too many people hold too many positions, right? You know, so then they get into this situation be like, Well, how do I resolve this? I got a lot of names now. And it's like, there's only supposed to be two people per Yeah. And now I've got like, six people, you know, I've got like, you know, 200 names, and I need to like figure out the next 25 years, like, how am I going to do that? So they
Dr Rad 45:29
invented a position?
Dr G 45:33
I don't necessarily what is say that they did. But I think we have to put it out there as a reasonable potential. Because if people are not necessarily counting things out specifically themselves within their family genealogies, they're just kind of like I have an illustrious ancestor, and they will console three times. And that's a story that's handed down in your family. Yeah. So one of the stories that's handed down in my family is that we're related to Samuel Johnson. Oh, no. Which is a great story, but not true.
Dr Rad 46:02
Interesting. Well, I'm related to King Henry the sixth, which is true, because it's not a brag. Terrible.
Dr G 46:11
Wow. How do you get back that far? Look at you. I didn't know I was doing a podcast with royalty.
Dr Rad 46:17
Are you kidding? It was clearly obvious from day one.
Dr G 46:21
I should have picked it. Damn it.
Dr Rad 46:25
I mean, this is the thing. This is just what I've been told, I actually have no idea whether it's true or not. I'm trusting the genealogical research of my relatives, which may very well be flawed.
Dr G 46:35
Interesting. Yeah. So my mother is a genealogist. And maybe that's where I get my historical interest from. But yeah, she's searched far and wide to sort of back up this claim. And yeah, there doesn't seem to be a way to do it. So I think that sort of stuff is fascinating, because that is a sort of an apocryphal story of our family totally. And you're like, I don't know if we can substantiate that. And, you know, that's the distance but of what 400 or something years, and I'm like, This is what happens when people tell stories. And then they're sort of reified through the retelling. And maybe they can become more exaggerated over time. And then all of a sudden, you've got too many people and not enough years, and you're writing an animalistic history, and you have to solve that problem. Somehow,
Dr Rad 47:19
hi, they didn't have consuls, they had something else and they were allowed to have more than two
Dr G 47:24
years, something with consular power. Very good
Dr Rad 47:30
military stuff with the tribes of Rome.
Dr G 47:33
Fascinating. Fascinating. Yes, I like it. Let's do that.
Dr Rad 47:37
That way, we can all have illustrious relatives. You get a consul and you get a consul, you get a consul. So
Dr G 47:44
Indeed, indeed. And so one of the other things that Holloway is pretty suspicious of is the Annales Maximi, which is the Pontifical record. And
Dr Rad 47:55
g is the basis for so much of your beliefs.
Dr G 48:00
Just putting it out there, I'm just raising more doubts and just deal listeners. Yeah, if you're ever in doubt about Roman history, this is the episode for you. So there's apparently 80 books of the finales maximum, right. And Holloway is kind of like, but they what do they even have in them? Like, it's just going to be an oddball collection of stuff that probably doesn't make a lot of sense. Gonna stay close to the chicken. Then there are the linen books. He talks about these before. Yes, because cost of living Yeah, preserved in the temple of Juno monitor. And also cited by Linnaeus Mesa and Eilis tuber, other writers that we only have fragments of indeed,
Dr Rad 48:38
also cited by with me. And yes, I think I think the whole idea is that levy has potentially some information from living in books via his sources that use
Dr G 48:49
them. Oh, there doesn't seem to be a consensus about the quality of the information in the linen books. There's potential for disagreement within those as well, actually. So that's good. And, you know, so this leaves us in a situation where, what is the history of where we're getting rapidly towards the end of the fifth century BCE? We were heading there now. But this is a period where so little is something that we can hold on to as like, fact.
Dr Rad 49:19
Well, particularly because I think we've mentioned this in quite a few episodes, when we get to these really confusing times where people are saying, Ah, that's it didn't really happen, and those people probably didn't really exist and they just made up names and it starts to make you question, what am I even doing? Right when it seems so doubtful, but as we talked about before, there is this real turning point where allegedly room is destroyed, razed to the ground, lots of records destroyed, and that our records will presumably get a bit more reliable once Rome itself and its record keeping is a little bit more protected from external attack and that sort of thing. But I mean, to be honest, even after that, you know, still had a lot of bloody fires in your nose was being destroyed?
Dr G 50:07
Well, exactly. And I think there's always a value in considering how people writing about history within a society are thinking about their own society as well. And even if, at best, what we're learning is what did Livy's and Dionysius and other sort of first century BC or C authors really think about this really early period of their own history? I still think that's a really valuable sort of tool because it provides the mindset for people of the day do then think about, well, if this is what Rome is, how do I operate from here? How do I fit into this? And how can I push and change from within this context? A shared understanding of history is one that allows you to make different decisions. Yes.
Dr Rad 50:49
And who are we to question Livy? Really?
Dr G 50:55
I mean, so I'm Dr. G. And I use that as my basis for being able to Livy's At times,
Dr Rad 51:03
I know very realistically there, even though he is writing many centuries after we are podcasting 1000s of years after, so, I'm hoping that somewhere he had access to better sources.
Dr G 51:16
I mean, I'd like to think so.
Dr Rad 51:19
Or identity. So I think that brings us to the end of our episode or 417 and 416, which was seemingly really more about 416.
Dr G 51:30
Nobody got to Look at in from 470 really know
Dr Rad 51:33
that anyway. It's done for the Partial Pick.
All right, Dr G, tell us how does the Partial Pick?
Dr G 51:46
There are 50 Golden Eagles up for grabs. 10 across five categories? Yeah, the higher the Eagles score, the greater room is.
Dr Rad 51:57
Alright, so what's our first category? Military clout? Okay, well, there is definitely some stuff here. I mean, not so much 417 and 416. But because I left the tail end before it taken out. We do have some victories we do
Dr G 52:10
a victory over what the Aequians and the in the Labicani really? Yes.
Dr Rad 52:15
I mean, it's one of those stories where always when Rome hits problems, we then get a story very soon after, where they just sweep everything before them. Effortless, easy, simple. But nonetheless, it happened to
Dr G 52:30
you telling me there's some kind of narrative flow that you can detect in the history,
Dr Rad 52:34
the ebbs and flows, but nonetheless, we are told that they are victorious. And, and how I mean, they not only manage to beat them, but
Dr G 52:42
a shout out to those letters really rapidly. Yeah,
Dr Rad 52:45
they captured they can they made them run away to a nearby city to take refuge and they captured that city and took all the beauty from that. And then they set up a colleague. Oh, my God. That's a lot of military class.
Dr G 52:56
Oh, give them to what? Just because you think it didn't really haven't? No. Doctors? I mean, they've only taken one place.
Dr Rad 53:08
Do you know how long it's been since they're
Dr G 53:11
willing to up it to three?
Dr Rad 53:12
I think they do deserve a three. I mean, it is a little suspicious that this guy didn't get to travel anything, huh? Indeed. Very. All right. Well
Dr G 53:22
gave me three diplomacy. No. Yeah, it was pretty abject failure. In fact, the patricians are trying to really ruin the potential for diplomacy internally. Yeah. Getting some of the tribune of the plebs on the on their side.
Dr Rad 53:38
Well, I mean, I guess that is diplomatic, and that they're not stabbing them in the streets. But I think I think there's again, as we keep coming back to I think there's a difference between being slightly diplomatic and mostly manipulative, and actual diplomacy.
Dr G 53:53
Yeah, yeah. So I'm giving them zero for that.
Dr Rad 53:55
I agree. Expansion. Yes. Yes. 1000 times? Yes.
Dr G 54:02
We have a whole new colony now. Do you? Oh, my God, the love and Connie are probably pretty unhappy. We'll see how that turns out.
Dr Rad 54:10
If they felt they started this century. I'm happy. It's only getting worse. And yet well, so what are we saying? We've got to call any reasonable amount of people. They're all given a bit of land for.
Dr G 54:23
Not enough to live off. Well, I
Dr Rad 54:25
mean, as we say, this could just be a misunderstanding.
Dr G 54:26
All right, for we're to us.
Dr Rad 54:31
Look, we do have some news for patrician douchebags on the scene, but I'm not sure if it's quiet enough.
Dr G 54:36
Yeah. I don't think they're necessarily engaging you weird to us.
Dr Rad 54:40
Yeah. I mean, is killing your standard bearer. sign of weakness.
Dr G 54:44
I feel like I need more details to be able to clarify, because it might well be, but I don't know. I feel like no citizen score.
Dr Rad 54:52
Hmm. Well, I mean, I guess there is a new colony being set up but the way the tribune is carrying on I feel like it's not been good news for the people. While
Dr G 55:00
it does seem like they're getting the raw end of the prawn, so to speak,
Dr Rad 55:05
yeah, and then the tribunes betray may cause so that can't be so not ideal if you're a citizen. No, no, not positive. So is that a zero?
Dr G 55:15
I think that might be a zero.
Dr Rad 55:18
I mean, on the other hand, though, I'm just going to throw it out there. There is peace in 417 and 416. All the problems are internal, which means no war, no levee. After you farm, see the kids?
Dr G 55:32
Yeah, sure. But you're not getting any land or you're not any
Dr Rad 55:35
more land. I mean, this is what we've often talked about, is the absence of war worth a point or is it?
Dr G 55:46
I think it's a case by case basis. But if we want them to have not an objectively low score, perhaps we could give them one.
Dr Rad 55:53
Well, Look, I don't mind having a low score. I guess I'm just wondering if the absence of war isn't itself something we maybe have to recognise,
Dr G 56:01
I think, well, I mean, not going to war is great. But also they were trying for some things at home, which didn't really get pulled off at all. So I feel like it's risky.
Dr Rad 56:13
Yeah. Okay. So probably easier than yes. We get data love seven out of 50 Golden Eagles for two and a half years of Roman history.
Dr G 56:28
Boy, ancient Rome.
Dr Rad 56:31
Yes. Didn't. Don't why studied you for so long.
Dr G 56:36
They get good later, I think. Yeah, I've heard a rumour. But it just depends.
Dr Rad 56:43
Well, did you thank you once again for joining me to talk about the history of rain from the founding of the city.
Dr G 56:50
It has been an absolute pleasure, and I Look forward to continuing the journey with you soon
Dr Rad 56:56
indeed.
Thank you for listening to this episode of the partial historians. You can find our sources, sound credits, and an automated transcript in our show notes. Our music is Bettina Joy De Guzman, you too can support our show and help us to produce more engaging content about the ancient world by becoming a Patreon. In return, you receive exclusive early access to our special episodes. And today, we'd like to give a special shout out to our newest Patreon Dick Karis and Vanessa, you can also support us by buying a coffee on coffee. Huge thanks to Anne Marie, Dana Gray and Augustus naturally for their generous cups of support. However, if all of these avenues are beyond your means, please just tell us more about the show or give us a five star review. We massively appreciate your very kind words. Until next time, we are yours in ancient Rome.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/
Support the show
Patreon
Ko-Fi
Read our books
Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome
Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
We sit down with Yentl Love to talk all about classical reception in Lil Nas X’s 2021 music video for ‘Call Me By Your Name'. Yentl Love is the famous Queer Classicist and we recommend checking out her blog for accessible analysis of the ancient world. We are thrilled to have Yentl return to the show – you may remember her from the insightful conversation we had about the reception of Cleopatra.
Lil Nas X has enjoyed great success with his debut album Montero and we were keen to learn more about how he utilised allusions to the ancient world to drive conversations about black identity and queerness as well as to complicate ideas about the heroic and how we might derive meaning when we analyse the past.
It's definitely worth watching the music video before getting into the episode itself!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6swmTBVI83kThe ancient world has a wealth of symbolism and allusion that has built up and developed over time through the use and reuse of imagery and ideas and this conversation really just touches some of the potentials.
Special Episode – Classical Reception in Lil Nas X with Yentl Love
The Ideal ManWhat makes the ideal man? Lil Nas X poses the question with a visual allusion to Doryphoros, the famous sculpture by the Greek Polykleitos, which is thought to represent the physical ideal in ancient Greek culture. Doryphoros was a favoured subjected in later Roman sculpture as well.
Doryphoros from Pompeii – A Roman marble reimagining of a Greek sculpture by Polykeitos.
Now in the MAN Napoli.
The opening of the music video provides a sweeping vista that on the surface has the appearance of paradise but is dotted with ruined buildings and structures. What could this mean? We ask Yentl's perspective.
Still from ‘Call Me By your Name' showing a Doric Temple in the foreground and an Aqueduct in the background
Just a regular symposium…Famously, Plato's Symposium gets a shout out in ‘Call me By Your Name' with a quotation that roughly translates as “After the division the two parts of man, each desiring his other half…” We consider the significance of this phrase in context and enjoy the fact that every so often someone uses an ancient language in a modern setting!
Still from ‘Call Me By Your Name' Ancient Greek from Plato's Symposium on the Tree of Knowledge
I like my hair like I like my Flavians!As the music video progresses, we see Lil Nas X shift scenes to an arena. The hairstyles on display in this scene recall the gravity defying hair styles favoured by the Flavian dynasty.
Still from ‘Call Me By Your Name' showing hairstyles echoing the Flavians
For comparison, consider the hair style of the portrait bust below. Although the identity of the subject is not certain, this piece is often identified as Julia Titi, the daughter of the Flavian emperor Titus. She was reputed to be a great beauty, but it's the very high ringlets that win the day here!
Portrait bust of a young woman with an extremely high hair style made of ringlets.
Capitoline Museum. Source: Tumblr
Interested in learning more about the writers mentioned in this episode? Consider the following:
Our music was composed by Bettina Joy de Guzman.
Still from ‘Call Me By your Name' Music Video by Lil Nas X.
Notes that the video was directed by Tanu Muino and Lil Nas X, song produced by D. Baptiste, D. Biral, O. Fedi, R. Lenzo.
Lightly edited for clarity.
Dr Rad 0:12
Welcome to The Partial Historians.
Dr G 0:15
We explore all the details of ancient Rome.
Dr Rad 0:20
Everything from political scandals to love affairs, the battles waged, and when citizens turn against each other. I'm Dr. Rad.
Dr G 0:30
And I'm Dr. G. We consider Rome as the Roman saw it by reading different ancient authors and comparing their accounts.
Dr Rad 0:41
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr G 0:57
Hello and welcome to a brand new episode of The Partial Historians. I'm one of your hosts, Dr. G.
Dr Rad 1:06
And I am Dr. Rad.
Dr G 1:08
And we are thrilled to be joined today by Yentl Love, who is working on her PhD at Potsdam University and is universally famous for her blog as The Queer Classicist. Thank you so much for joining us.
Yentl 1:26
Thank you so much for having me. Yeah, I'm so glad to be back chatting to you more.
Dr Rad 1:31
So we're very excited because we're discussing something extremely cool. And actually, quite frankly, a little out of our comfort zone today.
Dr G 1:41
Yeah, look, I don't think we are known as paragons of popular music. Nevertheless, we were super fascinated to see the rise. And the continued rise, I think of Lil Nas X, and what he is doing with his musical journey. And it is a thrill to sit down today with anto to talk about one specific music video that has come through and his debut album, and that is Montero “Call Me By Your Name”.
Dr Rad 2:09
So let's kick it off with our first question. So let's think about maybe classical reception more broadly. Because of course, the video clip is kind of what's intrigued us all, I think with its imagery and whatnot. So classical reception can obviously take many forms. I personally like the film side of things, but can you talk us through what the phrase classical reception means to you?
Yentl 2:30
So yeah, I mean, as you said, this is a really, really broad field that we're talking about, and it encompasses so much within it. On its most basic level, I'd say that when we are talking about classical reception, we're kind of considering how the classical world so really looking at ancient Greece and Rome, and how it has been received and portrayed or represented across time. So this can be anything from an architecture, when we see buildings deliberately kind of evoking this ancient Greco Roman kind of period. Or in literature, like, famously Madeline Miller's “Song of Achilles”, or in music, like Lizzo's music video for “Rumors”, and we're going to talk about Lil Nas X's music video. And as well as like, where we see these parts of ancient history depicted. I think another big part of classical reception is thinking, why do we see these particular parts down? Why is there this use of like Greek and Roman material? What is the specific message that the work of reception is trying to put through? Through using it? But yeah, the field really is just massively wide. And what I really like about it is I think that all uses of classical reception are equally valid and equally worthy of study, like a piece of fanfiction about, like Mark Antony and Augustus, could be discussed in like just as much detail as like the architecture of the Brandenburg Gate in Berlin. All of this is just different types of classical reception.
Dr G 4:08
Yeah, there's really a wide array of uses and reuses of ancient imagery. And when we're talking about classical reception, hinting back at particularly Greece and Rome are though I imagine at some point, we're also going to see in our lifetimes, the interrogation of classical in a more robust way, and I'm looking forward to seeing how that goes. But taking off from where we're starting with, like this idea of classical reception in modern culture, for a little bit of context for our listeners out there who spend all ages and all interests, who is Lil Nas X?
Yentl 4:43
Okay, so Lil Nas X is a stage name for Montero Lamar Hill. He is a black, queer American rapper and singer songwriter, and I think probably he's most famous for his song “Old Town Road”, but then he released his first studio album “Montero” in 2021. And yeah, the music video we're going to be talking about is from one of the songs on that debut album.
Dr Rad 5:11
Absolutely. I mean, I had never heard of it before. I know everyone's gonna be really shocked that I don't follow rap. In any, you know, I really stopped listening after “Shoop”. And so I'm really glad that I had my attention directed towards his music video, because it is really fascinating. And we're not the only ones to be interested in it. Because there's some really intriguing representations and expressions of queerness. And the ways that the music video explores allusions to the ancient world. So what are some of the significant images and symbols that come through in the music video?
Yentl 5:47
So one of the things that's like, most interesting, I think about the video is the way it forms almost like a long heroic art are a long narrative around this central character. But we can really split the whole video into three sections. There's this kind of chasing at the start. And that's taking place in a landscape where we see like architectural ruins of Greek buildings and temples, we see Greek inscriptions. And then that continues as we move into the second thematic section, which is in this kind of arena, big quality and style venue. So again, we've got this repeated association with Greco Roman architecture, which kind of really grounded it and discussion of the video as a work of receptions. And what's really interesting with the second thing is that the figures are all depicted with these very, very tooled like elaborately cold wigs, which almost perfectly mirror the statues that we have of women from this period of Rome called Flavian. Rome. And in that period, we start to see a lot of concerns emerging about female independent about female sexuality. And so it's the start of this like real discussion about almost like changing gender roles and concerns about sexuality. So it's a really kind of niche insight into this ancient discussion of what was happening with gender and sexuality and then brought through into, you know, Lil Nas X's exploration of this kind of queerness. And we also then, in the same scene have known as a pairing and chain, which has both been read through this kind of biblical lens as a reflection of John the Baptist, or of Samson with like Samson and Delilah, but also seems similar to Herakles or Hercules in Rome, in his outfit the way he's portrayed, like in modern strongman, that's not my area. But we see that same pose when you're holding up columns with big chains, and that is referred to as the Hercules pose. So we get this kind of reflection of Hercules and no knights portraying himself as this kind of hero throughout the throughout the music video. And then again, when the venue changes, he descends into hell or Hades. And we see statues outside the gates which seem very, very Greek. They're looking like these depictions of Doryphoros, which was sculpture, Polykleitos says he was sculpting like the ideal man. And so it's like the spear bearer, and we see them standing outside the gate to hell. And then as he enters, we see statues of Medusa, which again, is a kind of image we've seen all throughout this music video. And that in itself has massive ties to both classical mythologies, classical receptions, and also to black culture. We have a lot of poems by black and diasporic women, where they kind of claim Medusa as a collective ancestor. Or they compare the way that Medusas hair is treated to the way that black women's hair has been historically shamed. And kind of reviled by white western culture. If you want to read up more on that poets like Dorothea Smartt, and Shara McCallum really talk about this and exemplify this in their work. But yeah, so we have these kind of repeated motifs of different eras, the heroic area, the Medusa kind of metaphor, and the Medusa symbols, and then also this repeated discussion of like the architecture, the ruined architecture, and throwback to specific period and Roman history.
Dr Rad 9:36
I have to say, I am blown away by how much has actually been packed into this video clip because it's like less than three minutes long.
Yentl 9:45
Yeah unbelievable. Literally, when I presented on this topic at a conference in April, I think, and when I was looking through the music video, it was almost like every two seconds just pausing it and being like taking note that oh, okay, and another thing on thing? So yeah, it's just massively like you said, it's really packed in.
Dr G 10:07
And I think it has this amazing capacity to draw on multiple sources at once and sort of enrich itself through its sort of intertextuality. So you're storing that sort of reference, not just to Roman history, not just to the Greek heroic mode, but also those connections between queerness and blackness, and how that representation might be filtered through these different types of lenses. I really love the Flavian hair, I have to say, I think that's amazing. And the Flavian is have this really tricky period where it's this sort of backlash against the jeweler chlorians and the excesses of that, and some of the perceived power plays of women within that former dynasty. And so it's like, how will Flavian women be perceived, and the way that this video sort of touches on that as well, and has that sort of call back to that sort of constraint in the feminine, that is happening through the way that hair is dressed is really interesting.
Yentl 11:09
Yeah, absolutely.
Dr G 11:10
So on that note, not only does Lil Nas X engage in classical illusion, visually, but we also get this direct intertextual reference to Plato's Symposium. So there is a tree of knowledge in this video. So there's no way to separate out the classical reception with the Christian reception that is going on here. But this tree of knowledge is a really prominent symbol in the video. And there is this moment where we get this close up of the tree trunk, and it's inscribed with ancient Greek. And we never get a translation for that in the video, it's just left there for the viewer to ponder on and enjoy. Or if you study ancient Greek to be like, Oh. My. God. Something is happening. So even though the phrase remains untranslated, it doesn't really take long for the collective world to come together and look at what is being considered here, which is this really particular idea of “the division of two parts of men, each desiring his other half.” And I'm interested in the significance you read in this intertextual illusion.
Yentl 12:20
Yeah, I completely agree with the excitement when I first saw it as like, this is why all of those like hard use of doing ancient Greek, they are worth it for this specific music video. But yeah, this quote is one of my favorite, I think aspects of the whole video. So it's referencing, as you said, Plato's Symposium. And the specific part has been quoted comes from this discussion by the character s Aristophanes, talking about how early humans were double formed by two bodies in one. And then when their bodies were split by Zeus, they will always like search for their original half. So if you're a woman that was in a female female body, you will search for another woman, if you are a man from a male male body, who search for another man, if you're from a male female body, you will be searching for the other gender. So obviously, this discussion is supposed to be taken literally, they're just swapping stories about ideas that they have about love in this passage. But it forms a really interesting kind of early discussion of the idea of soulmate, but also explaining why different people might be attracted to certain genders. So this quote, to me has this really important like dual meaning, not only the fact that it's untranslated ancient Greek, I think really, like we said before, kind of grounds this as a work of classical reception, and grounds the whole piece in this discussion of kind of Greco Roman antiquity. But it's also this deliberate reference to ancient discussions of sexuality. And the ways that ancient people were talking about same sex attraction, attraction, same sex love, which really establishes this video as, like beautiful queer performance. And also kind of brings up the idea of collective ancestors, or that queer desire has always existed, which I think is very important to be talking about now, especially when we're saying, you know, there's a lot of anti like homophobic, transphobic legislation going on in lots of different parts of the world, but particularly in America, where this video is being produced. And so yeah, I think it's a really important reference back to the ancient Greek tradition.
Dr G 14:39
Yeah, definitely. I think it's giving us an opportunity to think a little bit more deeply about where our attitudes first of all sprang from, and also just how embedded in the human experience queerness is and thinking about where people sit in terms of their identity and where they sit in terms of their sexuality, how has always been a conversation that people are having with each other, and sometimes in a much more structured, and dare I say polite way than is happening today?
Yentl 15:12
Oh, yeah, absolutely. I completely agree.
Dr Rad 15:15
And it's really interesting to consider because I, when I was doing a bit of research in preparation for this conversation, I believe that when you look at the lyrics and the the meaning of those that Lil Nas X was drawing on some of his own romantic experiences as the sort of story for this particular song. And I think I think it was about somebody who he was having a form of relationship with, and that person wasn't out yet. So it is kind of interesting, I think, to consider having that inscription in this video clip with that in mind as well, I guess.
Yentl 15:52
Yeah, absolutely. I mean, like, the kind of one of the repeated kind of refrains in the chorus is like, tell me you love me in private? And so yeah, I think it's a very interesting kind of divide between the discussion of love, which has been had to be kept private, because of, potentially someone's in the closet potentially worried about repercussions, versus this kind of very public discussion of all different types of love that they're having in Plato's Symposium at the dinner party where they are treating, you know, a different character at one point says, oh, there are two types of love. There's like the common love which men have for women, and then there's the Heavenly love which men have for other men. And so, you know, we're, we're even saying at times that like, this kind of same sex attraction, same sex love is like on the highest level here, this is what we should all aspire to, in the in this like, wider kind of piece by Plato. And then yeah, to then have that comparison there between this very public discussion. And then the, “tell me you love me in private”, like this very secretive kind of way that they're discussing that throughout the lyrics of the music video, I think is a very emotional and very interesting device that we have.
Dr G 17:11
Yeah, I think you're absolutely right. And while you were going into the detail about that, I was also put in mind of the fact that we've got this sort of like layering of this tree of knowledge with the ancient Greek philosophical outlook as well. And so there's this really sort of rich questioning that I think that is brought to the forefront by placing the ancient Greek within that context, because they were all for context. But there is a suggestion over time that symbolism around Christianity has really taken on its own kind of significance. And yet, something like this is bringing those two worlds back together and back in conversation with each other, which I think is absolutely fascinating as well.
Yentl 17:56
Yeah, I completely agree. I think, also, in my undergrad degree, that was the first time that I'd really got the opportunity to study kind of like early Christianity. And I think it's very interesting to consider, you know, that when we're talking about specifically kind of like coming into late antiquity, that these two worlds are happening at the same time. And so I think it's really interesting to discuss, you know, when we have when we talk about, you know, allusions to like John the Baptist, or different kinds of figures like that from, you know, celebrated in the Christian faith, we also see them then being talked about and the similarities to how, you know, we see other Christian persecutions in ancient history and ancient Rome specifically. And yeah, it's a really interesting kind of overlap, that I think is easily forgotten about, it's easy to just pin Christianity into like that this is a religion, we don't really need to study it, because it's just a belief. It's just, you know, that kind of religious practice. And so it's very interesting to them. Consider, especially in early Christianity, and that's happening in the same time as all this other kind of ancient history. And yeah, I think it's really interesting to see the two being brought together like that.
Dr Rad 19:13
Yeah, we definitely have a really interesting overlap in the opening sequence of the video, which you could potentially interpret to be taking place in the Garden of Eden. And yet, it's also littered with all these ruined buildings that are obviously meant to remind us of ancient Greece in ancient Rome. So the layered symbolism that we see here kind of offers the potential to read the garden as a place beyond Christian archetypes. Why do you think this might be important within the scope of Lil Nas X's work?
Yentl 19:42
So yeah, as we've talked about, we have like two equally interesting, I think interpretations of the music video here. Both are equally valid, both are equally important. And you can certainly see a lot of from the kind of references to Christianity there. As this kind of act of reclaiming that as a queer artists, obviously we have seen throughout history sees still see now there is potentially a lot of backlash against the queer community, from religious people from some Christian people, obviously not all that there has been historically some backlash. And so then this acts kind of as an act of reclaiming then to use these symbols associated with Christianity and to use them in this celebration of, you know, the queer experience. But on the other hand, bringing in this kind of more Greco Roman ancient history perspective, I think the depiction of the ruined building is very interesting if you do this kind of deep reading, arguably way too intense analysis that was completely unintentional, but it's very well within that kind of overall video and beam. So like the two main types of building that we see, there's this Doric Temple, which is just an artistic type of Temple, and this aqueduct or viaduct. Now, Doric temples, especially in Rome, were associated with masculinity and manhood by particular authors, and disco Vitruvius, who's like an architect and engineer, that he said, like Ionic tempos are feminine. Doric temples are masculine, direct temples, if you're going to have a male god has to be in a dark temple, because they're masculine, and all curvy, little architecture, they're just strikes narrow, that masculine and manly.
Dr Rad 21:33
Such nonsense! Never heard of it.
Yentl 21:40
So yeah, and then when we see viaducts, they're kind of a massive part of Roman propaganda, in the like, politics of their expansion there and the empire building, because through bringing water to areas that were previously like, arid, didn't have water, they thought they had conquered the quote, unquote, savageness of the natural world. And so these kind of massive buildings like acted as this like monument of the symbol of like their victory of civilization over the rest of the world. So through showing these kind of both of these buildings as ruined and destroyed, I think we get this, the start of this motif, or this theme of the destruction of traditional masculinity and manhood, as well as the queer potential for kind of disrupting civilization disrupting social order. And yeah, instead kind of challenging the like political, cultural, societal norms. And so, yeah, this theme of like queer disruption, and the challenge to like hetero masculinity really flows throughout the whole video. And so I think it's interesting that we see this depicted in the specific ruined buildings that are included within this kind of Garden of Eden, early scene.
Dr G 23:03
Yeah, we get the sense of the ways in which society can be challenged, how it can be overcome. And I think this actually, these ideas feed in really nicely to thinking about Lil Nas X and the intersection of his identities as both being black and queer as an artist, both of which have been historically marginalized. And I'm interested in how this context that he is bringing to the table as an artist is influencing how he might interpret this music video, and its significance.
Yentl 23:38
So to me, I think this is one of the most important parts of the whole music video. See, yeah, Lil Nas X is a black man. And unfortunately, when we see classics being used outside of scholarship, and also traditionally within classical scholarship, it's often associated with white supremacy or with racism. If you look at any reports of like the alt right or white supremacist rallies in America, you see people with “molon labe” signs, which is like ancient Greek term meaning come and take them, which by them, they mean weapons or in US politics, guns, which distributed to the Spartans. And I mean, speaking of Spartans, like man who did outright love they're literally everything, the 300 they've seen themselves as these kind of hyper masculine macho men fighting against like all effeminate Eastern culture that these like yeah, effeminate foreigners are coming to, like, destroy our culture, I think
Dr G 24:41
Nothing says manhood, like sprayed on abs.
Yentl 24:45
Know exactly, and a bunch of men are naked together holding spears.
Dr Rad 24:49
Yup, that is true masculinity.
Yentl 24:54
I mean, yeah, it's horrific, but they just love these ancient kind of heroic men. They see like Ancient Greece and Rome as all whites hypermasculine heroic ideal, which let's be clear, untrue, for so many reasons, every part of that is untrue. So for Lil Nas X to represent himself kind of as a territories figure or this ancient hero, he embodies this ancient heroism as a black man, while he simultaneously also embraces femininity. And I think this really challenges on multiple levels, this hateful, racist rhetoric that is massively associated specifically with ancient Greek warfare and heroes. And so we see Lil Nas kind of reclaim Herakles and these heroes from the hands of the alt right. And he turns this heroic narrative from this, like hyper masculine kind of white call to power into a celebration of Black excellence, femininity and beauty, which is just massively important and powerful. And then kind of on top of that, you have the constant constant references to his queer identity. And the historic presence of queer desires queer relationships, which are solidified by there's a Latin inscription right at the very end of the music video, which reads, “they condemn what they do not understand”, which is a very, very emotive reference that you can read to, towards, you know, LGBT experiences, LGBTQ plus lives, and this kind of discrimination against them, which is, sadly still kind of present at the moment.
Dr Rad 26:36
Yeah, and I think particularly if we think about the imagery of that potential Hercules/Herakles scene, we probably should mention for people who haven't seen the video clip yet, although I'm sure they will stop this episode and kind of watch to me that the coloring as well I think is really feminine. The fact that he's got like, almost like a fairy floss pink wig and yeah, accessories. Yeah.
Yentl 27:03
Yeah, absolutely. Yeah.
Dr Rad 27:05
I mean, if you didn't if you didn't know, it was a potential allusion to like the flavors to me. It almost gave like Sofia Coppola “Marie Antoinette” vibes.
Yentl 27:14
Yeah, absolutely. I completely agree with that. Yeah. With a massive tulle, over-the-top hairpieces? Yeah.
Dr Rad 27:22
And the color scheme being almost like candy.
Yentl 27:25
Yeah, yeah, for sure.
Dr Rad 27:30
So, so think about that Herakles scene in particular, obviously, like a key, it's a key scene in the video to show him under arrest and being led into this building, which, as you've noted, seems very sort of Colosseum like, or like an ancient arena of some kind. So I think we could definitely see this a number of ways you could see it as an allusion to Christian persecution under the Romans, particularly when the scene later reveals that Lil Nas X's in chains before our large crowd, which is seated really high above him, but what do you take away from this particular scene? And how do you see this particular classical illusion operating?
Yentl 28:06
Yeah, I think definitely, you can read this as that. Christians were largely persecuted within this period of Roman history, because they were seen as being kind of other not acting the way they should. Part of this strange almost like sound family vibe, which really threaten the way that society worked at the time, this kind of patriarchal, family-centered norms of society, the idea that Christians were being really threatened that. And so actually, a lot of that backlash really kind of parallels the experience of LGBTQ plus people in today's society. And so yeah, I think that definitely just acts as a mirror in itself right there. But then, from a classical perspective, we have this parallel to the figure of Herakles, Lil Nas enters wearing what looks like the skin of like a lion, albeit pink, which is how we see Herakles depicted in art. And he's also got chains similar to kind of the modern concepts that we talked about earlier. But a lot of Herakles' mythologies are actually very queer in nature. When he's with the queen of the Amazon to politics, they swap clothes and swap gender roles. So he's out there like almost in drag, you know, dressed as a woman. And then he also has a massive amount of boyfriends. Plutarch actually says that it will be impossible to name all of his male lovers. But most famously, one of his relationships with this guy called Iolaus. I actually have never said that out loud, I've only read that so apologies if I'm saying that wrong. But with this other hero, Plutarch actually says that pairs of male lovers would go to his tomb to pay their respects because of this kind of queer association. So yeah, I think his characterization is heritage is also really plays on this really interesting thing kind of balanced between masculinity and queerness. And all of these questions about traditional heteronormative ideas of manhood and how femininity and sexuality can influence and kind of play with these ideas.
Dr Rad 30:16
Yeah, so against our modern version of Hercules, I think because he is your strong man, Arnold Schwarzenegger type figure. It's yeah, I think it's bizarre to most people who haven't spent much time in sort of the classical world to see him as being queer.
Yentl 30:32
I mean, did The Rock play him at one point, I swear there's a film?
Dr Rad 30:35
Yes, he did.
Yentl 30:37
I would love to see that and take into account like these, when he goes to the Amazon see him in this little dress, just like doing all the women's jobs and like not not being annoyed. He doesn't seem fussed. He just gets on with it.
Dr Rad 30:50
I think The Rock would be up for that.
Yentl 30:52
I think he would be.
Dr Rad 30:53
Yeah, I think he's up for that.
Yentl 30:55
Yeah, if he listens to your podcast,
Dr Rad 30:58
He definitely does!
Yentl 31:00
I'm sure he does, yeah.
Dr Rad 31:02
That's where he got the idea for the movie naturally.
Dr G 31:07
I think this actually draws a parallel as well to the other really famous sort of heroic figure from the Greek side of things, which is Achilles, because he also has these moments where he hides at certain points amongst groups of women dresses, takes on the dress of women, and is also reputed to be very close with Patroclus. And that sense of that intense loving relationship between those two men is something that drives the Iliad in many respects. So it's fair to say, I think that Lil Nas X is drawing upon a really rich tradition of Greek masculinity. And the way that that intersects really clearly and boldly with queer identity.
Yentl 31:56
Yeah, absolutely. And I think in a way that doesn't necessarily translate to how people might view this kind of heroic, hyper masculine man in the modern day. And I think it's really important and interesting kind of drawback, because, yeah, all so many of these kinds of heroes have these queer storylines behind them? And yes, I think it's really powerful, and also a challenge to the idea that when we think of like, a super masculine man, we think are, must have like loads of women, or must be, you know, has to be straight. And so I think it's a really interesting challenge to be like wellness, like all of these, you know, heroes from Greek myths, that are really also held up as being like, oh, yeah, these are like the best, the strongest, most manly macho man. And so to say, actually, you know, there wasn't this supposed incompatibility between queerness and femininity, and also being a very strong, very powerful man. So yeah, I think it's a really important discussion.
Dr Rad 32:58
I mean, there's six guys, but they're six guys for all. It actually does make you think when you look at when you unpick all of these examples, and all of these, you know, ways of interpreting the classical world that the alt right throw around, it does make you sort of wonder like, have you studied the classical world at all? started using this so called evidence?
Yentl 33:25
Yeah, it's even like with the “molon labe” signs like “come and take them”. They seem to like conveniently forget that the Persians did indeed take those. The Persians very successfully defeated. It's like what you just, yeah. I mean, obviously, they've done little to no research whatsoever. No reason.
Dr G 33:45
I feel like they've just missed all of the good bits, guys. The Spartans lost, and you can love whoever you want. It's okay.
Yentl 33:55
Yeah, don't worry. It's fine.
Dr Rad 33:57
Look into Spartan marital practices. And you're like, Yeah, talk about complicated relationships.
Yentl 34:03
Yeah, exactly.
Dr Rad 34:05
And a slight difference between ancient Spartan weaponry and semi automatic weapons.
Dr G 34:17
Well, but you know, getting back to the subject. So in the third section of this video clip for that you've mentioned, we have this descent to hell, and it appears to be initially an extension of the arena. If anything, it's here that it becomes really clear that we've got a reference visually to the Colosseum, because it seems like the Colosseum is operating as a portal to another plane of existence. I'm curious about the sort of commentary you see Lil Nas X making about the ancient world in this sort of transition.
Yentl 34:58
Yeah, it's a really interesting They make part of the music video. And I think, you know, you can read from that, potentially, you know, a lot of people did die in the Colosseum, especially with like Christian persecution. People don't think that, like, historians don't really think the whole like fed to the lions thing rarely happened as much as we actually, like. It is said that it happened in kind of modern culture, I don't think that really happened as much as so you know, people did die here. And so the idea of this being like, on the journey to death really, I think, is a very valid kind of way to look at it. But also, I think it's particularly interesting if you consider it as part of this heroic narrative that we've seen happening kind of throughout the music video. So just after the Coliseum scene, and before he kind of descend down, we see Lil Nas X kind of ascend to what might be seen as like heaven, potentially, or this like paradise. This winged figure appears above him that he can't make it there. And he falls back down. And we get this very famous, very sexy pole dancing descent into hell. Definitely worth watch if anyone hasn't seen it already.
Dr Rad 36:12
I only wish I could pole dance like that.
Yentl 36:16
If we consider heroes in ancient Greek tradition, for example, we have this kind of katabasis, or this descent into hell, forming a massive part of their heroic identity, their heroic narratives. We see this, again with Herakles, but also with Odysseus, with Theseus even with Aeneas. So this really emphasizes Lil Nas X's kind of character is being one of these typical Greco Roman heroes, is really brought into the ranks of all of the heroes that we've seen before him. And then after, again, this incredible kind of lap dance to the devil theme, we see Lil Nas X defeat the ruler of hell or of Hades, and he immediately gain once he's like completed this task, he gains the like wings, these massive wings that he would have needed in order to reach this kind of heaven or paradise that we've just seen earlier. So he's kind of just completed his heroic narrative there, because you've gained what he would have needed to be successful at the start. And so I think this aspect of the video can really be read. And yeah, it's like cementing them as exes character as a classic Greek hero, completing the same kind of narrative arc, and then bringing with that all of the challenges to the heteronormative hypermasculine, white supremacist adoption of Greco Roman heritage that we've discussed earlier.
Dr Rad 37:43
I must admit, I will say it still boggles my mind how much has been packed into this short video? Do you have any sense? Because I mean, I know that Yentl and Lil Nas X, you guys are as close as people can be. Do you have any sense whether this all came from him? Or whether this was part of like a creative team he was working with?
Yentl 38:01
I don't know. I've actually tried to look this up, because I wanted to see if there was any ancient historian on the team, because I felt like surely there must have been, but I couldn't actually find any of the details. But obviously, Lil Nas X listens to your podcast as well.
Dr Rad 38:14
Naturally, naturally, all the greats do.
Yentl 38:17
If he could get in contact with me, and let me know, I'd be very interested. Because yeah, I tried to use that when I was speaking about this topic at a conference. And I couldn't actually find whether there were historians involved. But I would really like to. I volunteer my services, of course, for later music videos, I'm available.
Dr Rad 38:36
We could all become part of his advisory team.
Yentl 38:41
Yeah, exactly. Yes, I see that as a very real possibility.
Dr Rad 38:47
All he needs to do is listen to this episode, he'll be like, Oh my god, they've been wanting me to contact them. And I was too shy.
Yentl 38:52
Okay.
Dr G 38:53
Get in touch, man. Get in touch. We're out, we're ready.
Dr Rad 38:58
Just as a an interesting question, I suppose to sort of wrap everything up. I suppose that by talking about all the challenges that Lil Nas X is posing to some interpretations of like the classical world, and, and all of that kind of stuff that we've been, we've been talking about, it kind of makes the ancient world sound like this queer paradise where anything goes in terms of your sexuality. I was wondering if maybe we could wrap up with maybe a bit of a chat about about that, and about what we can tell about how people were living their lives and exploring their sexualities in the ancient world.
Yentl 39:34
Yeah, so I think, by no means we should consider ancient Greece and Rome is kind of this utopian paradise, which is very easy to do. We choose specific sources and we look at specific things. But that wasn't actually the case. And there were a lot of, although in some scenarios, same sex relationships, same sex attraction was considered to be Eat good. And to be honest, like ideal, it was in very, very select situation. So in ancient Greece, we see if there's an adult man, and a kind of younger, like 14-15 year old boy, then that's acceptable, because we have this kind of pederasty, this, like erotic relationship. And it's seen as a way of kind of almost like a social ritual to transition from boys into adult men. But even then it seemed like, the adult man should be very into it, and the boy shouldn't really be that into it. So it's very, there are very a lot of restrictions on that. And adult men potentially shouldn't be in a relationship like that. That's not proper, if the man is too old. Some sources say like, if the young man has a beard when he's too old, then that's it. But then we do have in Plato's Symposium, you know, one of the characters is saying that people that have this kind of upper level of love, this desire for men will continue on into adulthood, and will have wives and children because they have to, but would rather live with other men by themselves in a fake kind of union, and will be very happy just living with a man just by themselves, they do have the recognition that obviously like this did still happen, even if that wasn't the ideal way that sexuality should be portrayed. And in ancient Rome, it's kind of the idea is that the, there is no shame if you're a man, having sex with anybody else. But if you're the kind of receiver of the sex, and that is shameful, because that's being like a woman. And as we all know, women are shameful, it's literally a word. Men should not be like a woman in any way, because that will be awful and wrong. So yeah, so again, we have this kind of split between what was acceptable, and then the kind of role that then wasn't acceptable. But then obviously, if you are a powerful person, whatever goes, you know, like when Nero took was married to two different men, one of them, he was, like, took the role of the bride. One, he was like the groom, as we would say, I guess. And you know, he's the Emperor who's going to do anything to him, like, he what he says go, you know,
Dr Rad 42:31
Until he gets stabbed, of course.
Yentl 42:38
So we have this whole spectrum of what was considered acceptable, what wasn't considered acceptable. But then also, we have these kind of pockets of same sex attraction, same sex relationships, like the Sacred Band of Thebes, are this band of warriors that are said to all be in kind of erotic relationships with each other, so that they would fight better. And, as far as I know, there's not much I haven't seen a lot of ancient sources saying, like, oh, this was wrong, because they were all men that were fighting together, you know, there are certain areas where it's considered acceptable. But also, it's just evidence that queer relationships were happening, and happened, you know, in all kinds of ways, a lot of our sources just come from these main city points, like in Athens, in Rome, whatever. But the ancient world goes so much further than just these kind of hotspots of where a lot of our sources come from. And so I think that what we can take from them is that yeah, there was obviously same sex attraction. People were in queer relationships, and we have from loads of sources talking about even when, you know, a relationship might have started as this kind of socially acceptable pederasty in ancient Greece, they didn't break up then when the younger one got to a certain age, they just carried on dating. And so yeah, there's I mean, you just have to read the works of Sappho as well to see that we do have, you know, also romantic relationships or same sex attraction between women occurring and see it written down in different places.
Dr Rad 44:15
Yeah, it is so fascinating when you look at the ancient world, because whilst obviously some of our sexual norms are quite different to the rules that were in place in these different places, I kind of feel like there is one commonality and that power is so often a hallmark of all of our sexual standards or our sexual relationships, it even though it might not play out in exactly the same way, I feel like power always has a role that it always is what people are kind of really concerned about.
Yentl 44:44
Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. But I think also that it's an important thing that we shouldn't overlook. Like when certain figures from history are kind of, you know, I went to an exhibition on kind of, like queer love, race. something or a few years ago, and they were kind of celebrating, like Hadrian and Antinous as this kind of beautiful queer relationship, but also like Hadrian was an emperor who was a lot older, and Antinous was like a 16 year old boy. And so it's like, can we really? Should that be the kind of relationship that we're celebrating? Was there a lot of agency there? And so I think we definitely can't look back on this as kind of this paradise of Oh, and it was completely accepting. And, yeah, and it was so forward thinking, because it wasn't in massive amounts of waves for many, many reasons. And so yeah, while we can see that queer people have always existed, that people have always experienced, same sex attraction, same sex love, we can't kind of hold this up as like this perfect kind of paradigm of what society should be like, because it was very problematic in so many different ways.
Dr Rad 46:02
Yeah, especially in Rome, because it was often that, you know, like, a man could have sex, as you say, with, with, with most people who were seen as being beneath him. So like his, like slaves or women. But he wouldn't be able, I don't think to have sexual relationships with say, like a citizen boy, without that being frowned upon, regardless of the role he was taking.
Yentl 46:25
Yeah, yeah, exactly. And so. So yeah, I think it's very important that we don't, it can be tempting, obviously, to look back at these figures and see collective ancestry or whatever, you kind of searching for to see that. And it's definitely valid to, you know, see these examples of queer desire and LGBTQ plus slides. That also I think we need to take it with a pinch of salt, and also be just thinking, okay, yeah, thinking critically about these things as well.
Dr G 46:55
Yeah, there's that sense of there is both the ideas which is central to the way that we understand the world and drawing upon that history to further deepen our understanding and appreciation of humanity in all of its facets. But then keeping note of that critical lens on particular contexts and how these things are embedded in real worlds and the consequences they have for the people who lived in those periods of time.
Yentl 47:22
Yeah, absolutely. I couldn't agree more.
Dr Rad 47:24
Yeah, I've been thinking about this a lot recently, because obviously, with pride month, there have been so many episodes of podcasts coming out about Oscar Wilde. And I love Oscar Wilde writing so much. And he obviously studied the classics, and he really adored them. And he did. So he did talk about, you know, Greek ideals of homosexual love and homosexual relationships, and that sort of thing. And it is really tempting to obviously see him as this tragic persecuted victim, which, obviously, I think on so many levels, he was a victim of his context and that sort of thing. But one thing I had forgotten was how many of his relationships were with much younger boys, because he was at he was sort of holding up that Greek sort of plastic ideal in quite a few of his relationships. And it is easy to sort of overlook that kind of aspect of his life as well.
Yentl 48:19
Yeah, absolutely. I think, yeah, we can't hold up certain figures. I don't know what the equivalent I've been talking about some in like teaching about, like, not holding up female figures and saying, like, don't want to, like go boss them, but I don't know what the equivalent for.
Dr G 48:36
I think it's “boy boss”.
Yentl 48:38
boy boss – yes. Let's not boy boss characters as queer heroes. But yeah, and just an important thing with pederasty as well, because I think it can link to and be used in like, certain aspects of like, homophobic rhetoric, the in ancient Greece, also, this age that the boys were when they entered these kind of relationships is the same age that girls were considered ready for marriage. That wasn't like a specific thing, just because it was a same sex relationship. That was the idea at the time was okay. By the time someone is around 15, they are ready to have a sexual relationship and they are ready to like, either if they're a girl to be married, if they're a boy to then begin this transition into becoming a man and then they will marry when they are older. So I think that it's an important thing to remember that it's not just that this is to do with it, the fact that it was queer or fact that it was like homoerotic. And I just think that's an important. That's an important thing to remember.
Dr Rad 49:36
Definitely. And in fact, that was something that again, come out came out at the time with Oscar Wilde's trials in that people were some people were highlighting that everyone was getting in such a tizzy about his relationships with men at the time, but they didn't seem too concerned about the age that women were when they were being, you know, either married or for you Maybe forced into sex work or whatever. So yeah, it's it's funny that there Yeah. There's also that caveat to that particular example as well.
Dr G 50:09
Yeah, I think this conversation has gone in in so many different directions. Now. It's really like yeah, like, and it's, I think it opens up the conversation in really important ways. Because it's like, there is a historical through line for us when we think about how we understand ourselves. And also, like the contextual differences over time as well, that become really those points that you hold on to as well, because it's like, yeah, as you say, there's not necessarily a utopia out there in the in the past, but there is ways in which we can utilize the ancient world in the way that like Lil Nas X has done in this music video, to think about and to requestion, some of the values that are on display in the mainstream today.
Yentl 51:01
Yeah, I completely agree. I think the music video just wraps all of this up and really emphasizes the discussions that this can that it can foster about antiquities, sexuality, and also the modern day.
Dr Rad 51:15
Well, hopefully, a lot of the people who have been persuaded by the views of the alt right will be super keen to listen to this episode, and check out Lil Nas X's work. And so to see the lies that have been fed, the classical way of looking at this particular song, and I must admit, I felt like my mind was really opened up by looking at this particular example, which I don't think I would have come across, if not for your work, Yentl, so thank you so much.
Yentl 51:42
I'm glad you enjoyed. Yeah, I think everyone should watch the music video. Critical piece of art.
Dr G 51:47
And I think as you say, like every time you look at it, you see more in it. Like, I'll admit that like Latin is by far more preferred ancient language of ancient Greek and I did not spot the Latin.
Yentl 52:02
Yeah, literally, every single time I watch it, there's something that I haven't seen before. Oh, wait. Actually, that's, maybe that's a reference to this thing, this very nice, ancient historical fact.
Dr Rad 52:14
Well, people should definitely check out your blog on this particular music video, because I know I remember from when I was reading it, that there's so many more allusions to episodes in mythology that we haven't even touched on. I mean, the snake. We haven't mentioned the snake and, and I mean, there's so much more. So please go and check out Yentl's blog. She is the Queer Classicist.
Dr G 52:34
And thank you so much for coming on the show. Yeah. And so it's been an absolute pleasure.
Yentl 52:38
Thank you both for having me. It's been, yeah, so much fun to chat to you both.
Dr G 52:55
Thank you for tuning in it to this interview episode are The Partial Historians, we want to say a huge shout out, thank you to all of you, our beautiful listeners. And if you'd like to show your love for the show, there's a few ways you can do it. We would love to read your positive reviews on whichever platform you choose to listen to us on. You can also follow us on our social media – we're on Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, and Mastodon. You could buy us a coffee on Ko-Fi or join our Patreon crew for early releases. We are so thankful for your listenership and we'll catch you next time soon.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/
Support the show
Patreon
Ko-Fi
Read our books
Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome
Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
After the kerfuffles of 420 BCE, it’s time for a brand new year or two! In this episode we consider 419 and 418 BCE. These two years are packed with exciting moments as we get to learn about an uprising from below – we're siding with the slaves!
We recorded in a new location for this episode. So if you hear a little bit of crowd noise in the background that's all part of the atmosphere of taping out and about.
Episode 140 – The Commonwealth of Slaves
The Slaves are Revolting!It happens every so often, but in this year there’s a few twists! Whose side are the gods on? Is that the smell of smoke? We consider the representation of enslaved people in the ancient written literary sources that provide us with their annalistic narratives…
As events unfold, we take a moment to explore the nature of bodily punishment and particularly crucifixion in ancient Rome. Where did it come from? When did it come into practice? We consider the details.
Still from the film “Spartacus” (1960) showing the crucifixion of the rebels by Rome. We touch on Spartacus in our consideration of the practice of crucifixion. Note, the fate of the historical Spartacus is not known.
Source: No Name Movie Blog
It comes as no surprise that the Romans might be facing trouble from their neighbours, but the years 419-418 BCE hold not just trouble without but disagreements between the military tribunes with consular power. How will Rome wrangle their own leaders into line? And will they be able to do it in time to win the day on the battlefield? We delve into the details.
Things to Listen Out ForOur music was composed by Bettina Joy de Guzman. Sound effects are courtesy of BBC Beta.
A map showing regions south and east of Rome including a possible location for Labicum – just north east of Tusculum!
Other important sites include Tusculum in the Alban Hills to the south-east of Rome.
Image credits to ColdEel and Ahenobarbus. Source: Wikimedia Commons.
Lightly edited for clarity!
Dr Rad 0:12
Welcome to The Partial Historians.
Dr G 0:15
We explore all the details of ancient Rome.
Dr Rad 0:20
Everything from political scandals to love affairs, the battles waged, and when citizens turn against each other. I'm Dr. Rad.
Dr G 0:30
And I'm Dr. G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it by reading different ancient authors and comparing their accounts.
Dr Rad 0:41
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr G 0:56
Hello, and welcome to a brand new episode of The Partial Historians. And I am one of your hosts, Dr. G.
Dr Rad 1:05
And I am your other host Dr Rad. Welcome.
Dr G 1:08
Welcome, welcome one and all, we are tracing Rome's history from the foundation of the city. And it's exciting times. It's been exciting times for a while. It's always an exciting episode when we return to Rome,
Dr Rad 1:21
I think, I think so. So last time, Dr. G, we were in the midst of 420 BCE.
Dr G 1:28
Ah, it was a great year.
Dr Rad 1:30
It was a great year because we actually got to talk about a woman It has been so long since we mentioned a woman.
Dr G 1:36
We've been going through a real dry patch with ladies.
Dr Rad 1:40
Which is not something you want to hear.
Dr G 1:42
No, no as a lady that is not not a great status quo. So we touched on the life and times of the Vestal Virgin Postumia. We did and she got herself into a little bit of trouble for having a sense of humor and a sense of style.
Dr Rad 1:58
I mean, if they're not a criminal offense, I don't know what is.
Dr G 2:03
With the danger of live burial on the table. I think she changed her tune and adjusted her behaviour.
Dr Rad 2:09
It seems like she backed down once she realized just how seriously they took this kind of stuff.
Dr G 2:16
Imagine trying to have a personality in ancient Rome, and now…
Dr Rad 2:20
That's not what being a Vestal's about.
Dr G 2:22
Ouch.
Dr Rad 2:22
Yeah. Luckily, she did escape live burial. I mean, that was my real concern that she was actually going to be buried alive for her raunchy dressing. And her jokes.
Dr G 2:36
Yeah, tragic times, tragic times. But no, all is safe. And well, Postumia goes on to live. So she's presumably still alive as we run into the year. That was 419.
Dr Rad 2:48
Yeah, I know. And we've also got, obviously a bit of a patrician-plebeian and drama that's been happening in that we also had the trial of Sempronius.
Dr G 2:55
Yes, well, that's what happens when you run away from a battle.
Dr Rad 2:58
Well, this is the thing right? Our sources, as we discovered last week, made out like the tribunes were attacking him because they wanted to vent they rage against his family, and they couldn't vent it against the person who they felt actually deserved it at that point in time, who was allegedly someone arranging fake elections and not allowing the plebeians to get through and so they decided to target the other Sempronius guy Sempronius military general from a few years before, but if you actually think about it, he deserved to be prosecuted. Because he had done a terrible job.
Dr G 3:36
It's true.
Dr Rad 3:37
Yeah.
Dr G 3:38
Yeah, look 420, what a time.
Dr Rad 3:41
Yeah, it was interesting. I mean, lots of legal action really. So we really need to insert the doo-dum
Dr G 3:49
I see what you did that more. I heard what you did.
Dr Rad 3:54
Anyway, but that sounds so yeah, it was really all about the legal stuff and 420 but now I think we're probably ready to move into 419 BCE.
Dr G 4:26
It's 419 BCE
Dr Rad 4:29
Certainly is. Now let me guess, let me guess. You don't have any material from Dionysius of Halicarnassus?
Dr G 4:39
Oh well on that front, you'd be mistaken. It's not that I have a lot of sources though. And it's not like I have a lot of Dionysius of Halicarnassus.
Dr Rad 4:50
Okay.
Dr G 4:51
But let's start with our main players for this year.
Dr Rad 4:56
Let's do it. Now. I think very excitingly, we have military tribunes with consular power.
Dr G 5:01
We do, and we've got four of them.
Dr Rad 5:04
Ooh.
Dr G 5:04
Let me introduce you to our cast of illustrious gentleman.
Dr Rad 5:08
Please do.
Dr G 5:09
We have Agrippa Menenius Lanatus – previously, apparently, consul in 439, which was a long time ago!
Dr Rad 5:20
Who can remember that long ago that was what five years ago now?
Dr G 5:24
Notable for the issue with Spurius Maelius.
Dr Rad 5:29
Ooo, okay yes, I am remembering this guy now. Yes, of course. How could I forget 439?
Dr G 5:37
Yeah, it was a big year.
Dr Rad 5:38
Yeah.
Dr G 5:38
We also have Publius Lucretius Hosti Tricipitinus
Dr Rad 5:46
Bloody hell, what a name
Dr G 5:48
Tri-cip-i-tinus
Dr Rad 5:52
I have another version which is I think TricipiTINUS
Dr G 5:56
Oooo.
Dr Rad 5:57
Yeah, I know but who knows? I think basically we can say that three is a part of that name.
Dr G 6:04
I think we can and there are too many ‘i's for me as an English speaker to be able to handle
Dr Rad 6:08
Yeah, too many.
Dr G 6:08
Which is why I struggle with Italian as well. This guy seems to be new – no mention of him in previous years.
Dr Rad 6:15
I think we'd remember that many syllables.
Dr G 6:17
Look, I'd have trouble every single time as well. I keep tripping over his name. Third off the ranks is Spurius Nautius Rutilus.
Dr Rad 6:31
Yep. Yep.
Dr G 6:33
Also new.
Dr Rad 6:35
I remember I remember Nautius before I feel like I've heard that.
Dr G 6:38
Yeah, I like Spurius Nautius. I feel like that's the nice companion to Spurius Furius.
Dr Rad 6:43
Yeah. Spurius Nautius is just a little bit camp.
Dr G 6:47
He goes to all the parties.
Dr Rad 6:47
He's like, Oh, giiirl.
Dr G 6:52
The kind of man you want to be friends with.
Dr Rad 6:54
Exactly, exactly.
Dr G 6:55
And last but definitely not least, Gaius Servilius Axilla.
Dr Rad 7:01
Ooh. Now that is an unusual name. But again, I feel like we have maybe come across that before.
Dr G 7:06
We have – previously consul in 427.
Dr Rad 7:09
There you go.
Dr G 7:09
And is about to start a really stellar hattrick as military tribune with consular power – this is the year that it begins. So that's some foreshadowing for everybody.
Dr Rad 7:23
Now, I'd like to start with a quote, if I may. Oh, unless you have any more magistrates?
Dr G 7:27
No, no, I think that's it.
Dr Rad 7:29
I didn't think so. You just looked at me like, “wait, there are more magistrates.” I was like, “Are there? Did I miss it?”
Dr G 7:35
No, there's only four.
Dr Rad 7:36
Okay, so my translation of Livy has great sentence, I think for kicking off 419 BCE: “It was a year remarkable, thanks to the good fortune of the Roman people, for a great danger, but not a disaster”.
Dr G 7:51
Wow. Livy's setting up that sense of suspense and mystery really early on.
Dr Rad 7:56
Yeah, but also letting you know that it's going to be okay. I think like in the grand scheme of things.
Dr G 8:00
Phew – okay, for whom, though? I feel like Livy is a bit pro-patrician really.
Dr Rad 8:05
A bit? Yes, I think you would be correct in it. So I do have a bit of a story about some slaves, Dr. G. Should I tell it to you or do you have some?
Dr G 8:17
I would love that.
Dr Rad 8:18
Okay, so what Livy, I think, he's referring to here is that we actually have a bit of a conspiracy from below.
Dr G 8:27
Oh, no, not conspirosity?
Dr Rad 8:29
Yeah. Yeah. So the slaves have this plot. And it's just the slaves. Like, I presume that means every single slave, but obviously, why get into specifics, when it's coming to the lower classes. They have a plot to set Rome on fire from various points. Now, that's not because they're actually trying to set room on fire. Stay with me.
Dr G 8:52
That is an accidental side part?
Dr Rad 8:54
It really is. The idea is that the fires are a mere distraction, Dr. G, because the idea is that the Roman citizens would therefore be sort of pulled in different directions all over the city and kind of to the outskirts of the city, because this is where the fires would be happening. They'd be trying to save their houses. They're trying to put out the fire. The slaves would be taking over control of the Citadel and the Capitol using an armed force. It's an evil plan!
Dr G 9:26
Well, that's very exciting. Okay, all right. I I'm not sure how to necessarily feel about that. There is some correlation in Dionysius of Halicarnassus.
Dr Rad 9:38
Really?
Dr G 9:39
My man's back! For one show only.
Dr Rad 9:43
Well, I have two more details to tell you about that. Should I tell you about it?
Dr G 9:46
Yeah, go for it.
Dr Rad 9:46
Okay. So, as Livy alluded to, this is a great danger to the city, but it did not end in disaster. Because Jupiter was looking out for his people. That's right. Jupiter made sure that the Romans did not suffer and the slaves did not succeed. Now, he then tells me that there is evidence gathered from some of the participants of this plot. So a couple of the slaves basically informed on what was happening. And it allowed everybody else to be arrested, rounded up, interrogated and punished
Dr G 10:24
Class traitors? No!
Dr Rad 10:26
Yeah, well, I Okay. This is where it gets really interesting. He actually says that the informants were given 10,000 pounds of bronze and their freedom.
Dr G 10:36
Wow.
Dr Rad 10:36
Yeah, which I actually, I didn't think that the slaves would actually be treated that generously, I kind of thought that the Romans would see that as just something that they should do. Because you know, they owed it to their masters like maybe freedom, maybe manumission. Sure. But giving them Yeah, money, I wouldn't have actually seen that coming. And Livy's actually even a bit dismissive about the amount they're given. He said, this passed for wealth back then. A pittance now.
Dr G 11:05
I think it's one of those things where, presumably what the patricians are attempting to encourage here is for more slaves to come forward more often. Before these sorts of conspiracies really get off the ground.
Dr Rad 11:22
True. And I mean, you know, if this has anything to go by, it's working for them.
Dr G 11:28
We've set the precedent. And now we'll see how we go.
Dr Rad 11:31
And I feel like this is really intriguing. I mean, what a, what a treat for us, in a sense, because last episode, we got to talk about a woman, we haven't been able to do that for a while. Now we're able to talk about slavery, because we haven't really talked about slaves very much.
Dr G 11:44
Yeah enslaved people don't tend to get a lot of currency in our source material at this point in time, but the ancient world is really foundationally built on the exploitation of human labor. And there's no doubt that it's, well, maybe there is doubt, it seems reasonable, that the Roman population may even be outnumbered by enslaved people at this point in time.
Dr Rad 12:11
It's, it's so hard to figure out, isn't it? Yeah. Because generally, we associate slavery and Rome, I think, in that period, when the Romans are truly taking part in these sort of large scale wars of conquest. Now, lately, even though we have seen the Romans taking part, in a lot of warfare, as we've talked about, with our expansion scores, it's not really about adding territory, you know, of late, like, there's been the odd time when they've added a bit of territory in like, the last 100 years that we've talked about. But generally, it's been more about, you know, either putting those people in that place or defending Rome from an attack, it hasn't really been about adding territory. So they're not really, you know, expanding their control right now. certainly nowhere near on the scale of that they're going to, in the well, I say, the not too distant future, but God knows, probably 10 years away.
Dr G 13:02
Hundreds and hundreds of years from now.
Dr Rad 13:06
And that's I think, when we tend to think of them having slaves, because obviously, one of the easier ways to get slaves is to conquer a place and take the people that have managed to survive the conflict and make them your slave population.
Dr G 13:19
I think the important part here is, as you know, we're dealing with things that are very close to home geographically. So the slaves that are currently in Rome at this point in time, these are all people from the surrounding areas, they're all Italic peoples or Etruscans. And that's just going to continue to expand as Rome continues its expansion. Yeah, it's not sure bet for Roman at this point in time, that's pretty clear.
Dr Rad 13:49
For sure. And I mean, the thing is, as well, you have to assume that the slave population is being fed through other avenues. I mean, it's so hard to know, because we really don't have much information on slavery in this time period. A lot of what we think we know about slavery comes from later time periods. But obviously, you could become enslaved through debt. We talked about that. That's obviously one of the things concern the Romans themselves, in that, you know, debt bondage, and then also being sold into slavery because of debts is a huge year has been a huge issue at various points.
Dr G 14:20
Yeah, it's a thing. And we also have seen them capturing out and about, and so there might be like prisoner exchange and things like that going on a lot. But there is also definitely enslavement of people when cities sort of stand up to Rome for too long. Rome gets jack of that they've raised the city and they take people, slaves.
Dr Rad 14:41
Yeah, we definitely had mentioned that. And then of course, we can't rule out the possibility that even at this early time period, you have maybe parents giving up children that they can't support. You know, if you have too many children, then you could potentially expose them and I don't mean that You're unnecessarily thinking that they're going to die from exposure, but as in there might be left for people to take. And that's one way of also getting slaves. I think it's a less common way of doing it. But it is a possibility.
Dr G 15:13
Yeah, I don't know that we've got good evidence in this time period.
Dr Rad 15:16
We definitely don't. Yeah. But for later on, we do have some evidence of that happened. And so it's like, well, maybe that's what's happening some of the time. Yeah, we don't really know.
Dr G 15:26
Yeah. Bring out your children. Yeah.
Dr Rad 15:30
It's just yeah
Dr G 15:31
Have they misbehave this week? Are you at your wit's end? Get a great price on the open market?
Dr Rad 15:38
They're free!
Dr G 15:40
Please, just take them!
Dr Rad 15:41
Just take them, I can't handle it anymore.
Dr G 15:44
We are not suggesting by any means that you should enslave your children. Yeah. So Dionysius of Halicarnassus has a lot of parallels. I've got one fragment from Book 12, part 6, sections 5 to 7. He talks about three of the military tributes with consular power, being involved in the discovery of the plot.
Dr Rad 16:09
Oooo.
Dr G 16:09
Yes. So it seems that it comes to their attention – to the highest magistracy. And that it is being led by a commonwealth of slaves. So there's some sort of like, you know, class unity going on?
Dr Rad 16:23
Yeah.
Dr G 16:24
Get together.
Dr Rad 16:25
The commonwealth of slaves.
Dr G 16:26
Yes. Get together. Look after your brothers and sisters. And this idea of planning to set fires across the city. Yeah, definite parallel with the aim ultimately of, as you say, seizing the Capitol. And if they can do that, that is a sense in which Rome falls at that point? Yes. Like they they are in a position of power. They're on the biggest hill. It's the defensive structure par excellence. Since the beginning of the Republic, it's the one that everybody cares about. Yeah. So if you didn't take the Capitol and the Citadel that's on that hill, more power to you – Rome's yours!
Dr Rad 17:05
Well, we have seen that before, not by slaves per se. But remember, when we had that there was an invasion…
Dr G 17:10
I was gonna say the Etruscans do the sneaky invasion, where they were like, we're just gonna cross this little bridge here. And we're on the Capitol.
Dr Rad 17:17
Yeah.
Dr G 17:18
And Rome fights back, and they managed to win the day in the end. But that was a while back now. And they haven't really had this sort of problem for a while. So this would be, it would be amazing if the enslaved alliance could pull this off. They don't seem to though.
Dr Rad 17:37
No, it's sad.
Dr G 17:39
Now, the thing that struck me as really quite interesting about this, like, in addition, I've got this idea of there are two informants. And they win their freedom as a result of informing against their comrades. And they also receive 1000 denarii. From the public treasury. Oh, okay. So I don't know how that figures with your figure. Ancient economy, it's all over the shop.
Dr Rad 18:06
I was gonna say. Yeah, that's,
Dr G 18:09
I have to do some calculations and think about that.
Dr Rad 18:11
Yeah, I think Livy's given it to me in like the asses system, which is the old school system.
Dr G 18:19
Which is fair enough. But I don't know what the equivalent and the type of denarii have not been specified. So, I mean, are we talking silver or?
Dr Rad 18:29
Like, it's clearly far too much maths.
Dr G 18:32
Too much maths and too much money.
Dr Rad 18:34
Exactly. That's gonna give it away.
Dr G 18:36
Yeah. So. But what happens is that the ringleaders are discovered through the informants. Yes. And they are then scourged and led away to be crucified.
Dr Rad 18:48
Oh, okay. So Livy just told me that they were arrested and punished. He doesn't get specific with the punishments. But you know, what? Doesn't surprise me about the crucifixion thing? Because that would be the kind of punishment I think you would expect.
Dr G 19:02
Well, this is where I went down a rabbit hole. Then I was like Roman crucifixion. What do we know? And when do we know it?
Dr Rad 19:08
Yeah. Like when did it start? I mean, it is something that you would use for people who were like traitors, right?
Dr G 19:12
Definitely. Yeah. And obviously for writers like Dionysius of Halicarnassus and Livy's. The big example is Spartacus.
Dr Rad 19:20
I was gonna say, I mean, I didn't want to be the one to bring it up. Not that he himself was crucified, I should say, that's a Kirk Douglas thing. We don't know what happens to Spartacus, he might have been crucified, but he might not have.
Dr G 19:37
No, but what we do have is the source from Appian. And Appian talks about what happens in the Spartacan revolt after the force is defeated, essentially by the Romans.
Dr Rad 19:49
Oh yeah, the survivors are crucified.
Dr G 19:51
Yeah, and apparently Crassus rounds up about 6000 survivors and you've got this horrific imagery of them being crucified along the road from Capua to Rome.
Dr Rad 20:02
Yeah, it would be bleak. I mean, I can't I honestly can't picture 6000 people on crosses,
Dr G 20:09
I don't really want to. But mathematically, I wonder how far apart the crucifixion is have to be. Anyway, that is just a matter for mathematics, which I'm not going to delve into.
Dr Rad 20:19
I don't know why you keep going down these mathematic paths. Why bring them up? I can't solve them for you.
Dr G 20:24
I don't like maths. I don't do maths. It's bad enough that we have years that have numbers. So crucifixion, the big sort of ticket example that our source material probably thinking about and having a heads is that Spartacan revolt. But that doesn't tell us anything about when crucifixion might have begun in the Roman world, because clearly, it wasn't a surprise, then.
Dr Rad 20:49
No, but I but I feel like it is something that I feel like there is a sense that it is something you would only do you know, it had to be that it was like a weighty punishment it was wasn't that you were hanging out left, right and center to just anybody who annoys you or anything.
Dr G 21:06
Wow, to imagine like thinking about it. Well, they're crucifying me so I must be special.
Dr Rad 21:11
Well, no, no like that. But I just mean that. I think sometimes I guess because of the association of crucifixion with Jesus. I feel like sometimes people think, “Oh, it was so cruel and barbaric”, which it was, but that they might have been handing crucifixions out like, a lot more often than I think they maybe were.
Dr G 21:29
It's possible. Yeah. There's also the sort of broader context of the ancient Mediterranean to think about and this is part of where I was sort of going with, with some of this because yeah, corporeal punishment is, by no means unusual in the ancient world. It's something that happens a lot. Even the scourging process that happens to these characters in 419. Prior to the crucifixion is corporeal violence. You know, they're beaten, essentially, until they almost can't handle it anymore.
Dr Rad 22:01
Yeah. And that's, that's with rods as well. Not just with fists, which you honestly you wouldn't do because it would hurt you as well as hurting the person being punished.
Dr G 22:08
So scourging – being beaten with rods – sometimes that's enough to kill the person. Sometimes they're scourged to death. That doesn't seem to be the case in this example. But if we're talking about the broader Mediterranean, this idea of impalement in various ways, the puncturing of major organs as a way to elicit pain and suffering. Fixing people to stakes is something that has a variety of uses, through sources that come through from Mesopotamia and Egypt and Greece.
Dr Rad 22:41
So when you say stakes, so we're talking like large stakes, like body sized stakes?
Dr G 22:46
Like T-bone steaks?
Dr Rad 22:49
Delicious. No, no, I mean, yeah, like, are we talking like when I think of stakes, I think I think of like, garden size stakes.
Dr G 22:55
Oh, you're thinking like, like the vampire moment where the stake is going through the heart?
Dr Rad 23:00
Maybe? I mean, I just I don't think it's something large. I guess it's my point. Are we talking about like, fixed into a stake?
Dr G 23:05
Yeah.
Dr Rad 23:06
Like a human sized stake? Okay.
Dr G 23:08
Yeah, large stakes, fixing people to the stake.
Dr Rad 23:10
Gotcha.
Dr G 23:11
Yeah. Now, that is slightly different from crucifixion. But you can see how they're heading in that direction.
Dr Rad 23:17
Oh, they're going there. Yeah.
Dr G 23:18
Yeah. And so the Romans, they're not outliers in terms of corporal violence in terms of the ancient world. They do take it to new heights, simply because they ended up being so dominant in the region, I think, so they gain this reputation, which others don't have the opportunity. Terrible though that might be.
Dr Rad 23:37
Oh, no, I mean, let's face it. They're also concerned about law and order, and loyalty, which I mean, as you say, anyone probably would be in their position, but I do feel like they're particularly equipped for. That's just something so bureaucratic.
Yes.
Yes. And they militaristic,
Dr G 23:57
They're militaristic, they're legalistic, and they're hugely superstitious. It's not a great combo. So we don't really have any firm idea about when crucifixion comes into, like the Roman sort of practice. But they are sort of drawing on a much broader context of this kind of corporeal violence, which involves this kind of stuff. So they're not the first. They won't be the last.
Dr Rad 24:24
Is this our first mention of crucifixion as punishment?
Dr G 24:27
That's what I was trying to recall.
Dr Rad 24:30
And you didn't go back and listen to all of our previous episodes?
Dr G 24:33
I was just about to say, but we've been doing this podcast 10 years. And you know what, I can't remember what I said yesterday.
Dr Rad 24:45
You know what, honestly, I'm digging deep here. I really feel like we haven't mentioned crucifixion before on this show. Apart from obviously doing Spartacus, which is even though we've done an earlier episode, it's later in time.
Dr G 25:00
Yeah, it's out of the chronological sequence. I'm not sure. I'm not going to put money on it, because I don't trust my memory to that degree. But I felt like it was something when it came up in the source materials like, Oh, this is something that that is worth sort of doing a little bit of digging into.
Dr Rad 25:15
Yeah, like, I feel like it's been mostly like the classic punishments. We've definitely had people being, you know scourged before we've had people being scourged to death before. Certainly that, but yeah, I feel like this might be the first time that it's come up.
Dr G 25:31
Mm hmm.
Dr Rad 25:33
We're open to corrections on this point.
Dr G 25:36
Rome – entering a whole new phase of violence.
Dr Rad 25:38
Super fans, to the archives!
Dr G 25:42
And so that's pretty much all I have, okay, or 419 BCE, the rest of my source material is essentially different fragmented Fasti.
Dr Rad 25:52
Okay.
Dr G 25:53
And that just sort of confirms the names that we've already got.
Dr Rad 25:56
I might be able to piece some things together for you. Look, I don't have a huge amount of additional detail. This slave conspiracy is definitely the headliner of this particular year. But I do have a bit of military action. Oh, yeah.
Dr G 26:08
Hello.
Dr Rad 26:08
So the Aequians once again enter the story. I mean, these guys have been quiet for a little while and all sudden, they're just everywhere.
Dr G 26:14
I think they were just waiting for the Volscians to get off their high horse, and then they could sweep in for the victory.
Dr Rad 26:20
Perhaps Perhaps. So the Aequians are apparently gearing up for conflict again. Now, geographically, Dr. G, can you remind us where the Aequians are?
Dr G 26:31
Well, they come from the sort of south-east-ish region of Rome.
Dr Rad 26:36
Yeah. Now I actually did, because this is a shorter year, I actually did try and look into the Aequians a little bit.
Dr G 26:43
Who are these people?
Dr Rad 26:44
I know, the verdict seems to be that we really don't know much about them.
Dr G 26:49
This confirms everything that we've talked about so far.
Dr Rad 26:51
Yeah, there are some archaeological remains, which I think you've talked about before, you know, we've got some fortifications in eastern Latium. So obviously, in this region, were we expecting, as you say, in the area we be expecting, which tells us I suppose that they were somebody was there, somebody was there, and they were trying to defend themselves, I suppose. Hints such military conflict, which is confirmed by our written sources, perhaps. But, yeah, we really don't know much about these people.
Dr G 27:23
In the same way that we don't know heaps about the Volscians.
Dr Rad 27:26
Yeah, exactly.
Dr G 27:27
But I mean, there, there are definitely groups in and around Rome.
Dr Rad 27:31
Yes. Well, I think that this, bringing up the Aequians, again, you know, Rome having to deal with like military action again, I think that this whole episode, kind of reinforces what we've said before about this potentially false narrative that we're being presented in terms of the way that the Roman state developed, in the sense that military tributes with consular power – if such an office did exist – it seems that it is far more likely that it came about out of necessity, because you couldn't just have two guys if one of them needs to be with the armed forces. And one of them needs to be in the city. Because if you're facing multiple enemies, or you know, you're, you're being attacked from multiple directions, you need more guys. And so it's it does seem likely that this position, if it exists, at this point in time exists because Rome is potentially facing a lot more conflict than it has previously. But anyway. And that's because there is a new enemy.
Dr G 28:27
Uh oh.
Dr Rad 28:28
Yeah. On top of the Aequians. And I love the way Livy's says he says the Romans hear from reliable sources.
Dr G 28:36
I'm just raising my eyebrows for everybody listening at home raising my eyebrows “reliable sources”?
Dr Rad 28:42
Yeah.
Dr G 28:42
So who's Livy gone to?
Dr Rad 28:45
The word on the street, Dr. G's, and there's some new enemies in town. And they're the Labicani.
Dr G 28:52
Oh, yes. They are gonna come up for me next year.
Dr Rad 28:55
Okay. Well, I think there is a bit of blending happening at this point in time, which is what's been happening to me a lot in the last decade that there's a bit of confusion sometimes about when exactly something's happening, but
Dr G 29:07
What's even going on?
Dr Rad 29:08
Yeah, exactly. But these guys are apparently teaming up with Rome's more traditional enemies. I presume that means people like the Aequians
Dr G 29:18
Ding, ding, ding, ding, ding, new enemy enters the ring.
Dr Rad 29:20
Yeah, and again, we don't know much about these people. I really did try and find some information about them. But it seems that all we really know is that they're also from somewhere in Latium.
Dr G 29:31
Oh, I'll tell you all about them… next year.
Dr Rad 29:34
Okay. I've got potentially a location of somewhere near the Alban Hills as where they're from, but I don't really know if that's true. Anyway, so the Romans are actually kind of blase about this whole situation because I like the Aequians – those guys – we fight them every year. I mean, you know, just say those same are right and I'm like too true Romans, too true.
Dr G 30:01
Send out the force do what you need to do. And then we'll go home.
Dr Rad 30:05
Yeah. But they are concerned about these new enemies in that I think they want to initiate contact, establish relations. So they send off some envoys.
Dr G 30:15
Oh, that's nice. “Hi! Are you trying to kill us? Because if you are, we will crush you.”
Dr Rad 30:23
So they send out these envoys, the envoys don't get the response that they're hoping for?
Dr G 30:31
Well, there's a surprise.
Dr Rad 30:34
Yeah, for the Labicani are somewhat non-committal. It seems like they don't want to fully say yes, we are going to come for you. But they also don't want to say no, we're not so…
Dr G 30:47
“Yeah, look, you know, I'm just, you know, I'm feeling the way I feel and I'm just gonna have to go with my vibes. So guys, I don't really have an answer for you right now. But come back next week with your army.”
Dr Rad 30:56
Yeah, and this is when Spurius Nautius' like, “Giiiirl”. So yeah, that definitely, I would say that yeah, they're preparing for war, but they're not quite ready yet. So they're just playing for time.
Dr G 31:08
How coy.
Dr Rad 31:09
Indeed. So the Roman say, Okay, fine. You see what you're doing here? They turn to they're good friends, the Tusculans, the most adorable people in this region.
Dr G 31:18
Awww.
Dr Rad 31:18
I know. And they say to the Tusculans, “Can you just keep an eye on this? Watch them?”
Dr G 31:25
I don't trust those guys.
Dr Rad 31:26
Not for a second and that's where 419 ends for me with the Tusculans watching the Labicani.
Dr G 31:33
Getting out their small – but very inefficient because they don't have the technology yet – spyglasses.
Dr Rad 31:38
Exactly, putting on monocles, like that's going to make any difference.
Dr G 31:42
Wearing their moustaches as they creep through the undergrowth like, “No one will ever know it's us.”
Dr Rad 31:47
“Quick. We need some trench coats.” So that's where it ends up for me. So I agree that we're going to hear more of the Labicani in 418 BCE.
Dr G 32:22
Turning over my notes.
Dr Rad 32:24
Okay, so, before we get into the action, we have far more magistrates to deal with, I think this year, Dr. G.
Dr G 32:31
Oh, it's a confusing time in Rome done its usual and started with some magistrates, thrown them all out, replaced them with some others and hoped for the best.
Dr Rad 32:39
It's very confusing .Yes, yes. All right. What tell me about the more traditional ones first.
Dr G 32:44
We have three military tribunes with consular power.
Dr Rad 32:49
Correct. I don't know why I'm doubting you, Sorry.
Dr G 32:53
Excuse me, I did my research. So first of all, Lucius Sergius Fidenas – very illustrious so-and-so. You might have heard of him before.
Dr Rad 33:04
I believe that he got that special last name from conquering Fidenae. Or taking part – actually no..
Dr G 33:13
Or being related to somebody who did that?
Dr Rad 33:14
Yeah, true. True. Yeah.
Dr G 33:16
Previously consul in 437 and 429.
Dr Rad 33:19
He is the guy! If he was caught on the 437 he is the guy.
Dr G 33:22
It's him.
Dr Rad 33:22
It is him. It is the original, the original and the best.
Dr G 33:29
And previously military tribune with consular power in 433 and 424.
Dr Rad 33:35
The last couple of decades have been good to him.
Dr G 33:37
Yeah, look so illustrious. This guy so many magistracies under his belt.
Dr Rad 33:41
Well, Fidenae It's just such a pain in the arse, or at least it used to be so having a role in bringing them to heel.
Dr G 33:48
Yeah, so we got we got this guy. We also have Marcus Papirius Mugillanus.
Dr Rad 33:54
Hmmm a name I've definitely heard before.
Dr G 33:56
But this guy is new to our list.
Dr Rad 33:59
He is new, yeah, but he's from a family I've heard before. I've definitely heard of the guy before.
Dr G 34:02
Yeah. And I think we've had some Mugillanii as well.
Dr Rad 34:05
Such an unattractive name. It reminds me actually of like, every time I hear it, I think of a really meaty Italian stew, which I like but the name I don't like.
Dr G 34:18
And it's one of those names that ends with anus. So it's always a bit of – a bit of a killer. Yeah. So He's new. Congratulations, Mugillanus, let's hope that it goes well for you. And then we have Gaius Servilius Axilla on his second consecutive military tribunate with consular power.
Dr Rad 34:43
Slightly unusual, slightly unusual.
Dr G 34:45
Yeah, he's in the middle of a streak.
Dr Rad 34:47
Mm hmm. Now do we want to talk about the other magistrates or do we want to introduce them?
Dr G 34:52
Well, I think it's worth introducing. Mostly because this is gonna give you a foreshadowing of how this year is gonna go.
Dr Rad 35:02
Foreshadowing, foreshadowing.
Dr G 35:04
We have a dictator!
Dr Rad 35:07
Yes.
Dr G 35:09
It is Quintus Servilius Priscus Fidenas.
Dr Rad 35:12
So related potentially? No.
Dr G 35:15
Well, I mean, I think they seem to have gotten the Fidenas cognomen. Probably through maybe similar military prowesses.
Dr Rad 35:25
I know I said it and then I'm like, wait, wait a minute. It's not in the right place for them to be related.
Dr G 35:29
All of their names though. They're nomens and things like that suggests that these come from very different families. So there's clearly a legacy of issues with Fidenae that are coming through.
Dr Rad 35:42
We know we can see it. Yeah, we can see it in the names.
Dr G 35:44
Yeah. And then we also have the master of the horse
Dr Rad 35:47
Naturally, the dictator's sidekick. He's the Robin to his Batman, if you will.
Dr G 35:53
And it's an upgrade for our man who's on a his streak Gaius Servilius Axilla.
Dr Rad 35:59
He's just raking it in.
Dr G 36:03
He's on his horse, and he's ready to go. Yeah. And there are also censors this year. One of whom we have the name of.
Dr Rad 36:12
Who is someone we've already talked about?
Dr G 36:14
Yeah. Oh, is it? No, I don't think it is. It's somebody different.
Dr Rad 36:19
Oh, really? Okay, let me redo that. Then. Censors you say?
Dr G 36:22
I'm so glad you asked. Lucius Papirius Mugillanus – another Mugillanus, but a different one.
Dr Rad 36:31
A different one.
Dr G 36:32
Yeah.
Dr Rad 36:33
Okay. Confusing.
Dr G 36:34
Yeah. Probably brothers. I mean, they've got to be related. The only difference is the praenomen.
Dr Rad 36:39
That's why I got the Yeah, that's why I was confused. I was like, Wait a second Papirius, Italian stew, man. What are you doing back here? How can you be serving two offices at once?
Dr G 36:50
You do what you gotta do. This suggests that the Romans are not only counting the population for taxation and various other social cultural purposes, but there's also some kind of military or some other kind of issue that crops up this year.
Dr Rad 37:08
Definitely. Alright, so do you want me to spin my narrative?
Dr G 37:12
Please do.
Dr Rad 37:13
My narrative web. Okay. So the ambassadors from Tusculum arrive telling the Romans that in – and I don't, I don't know, like, in a couple of months, maybe I don't know how long it's passed that we're talking about here – but finally, the Labicani are ready for war.
Dr G 37:29
“I've seen some pointy sticks. And I'm pretty sure they're going to run at somebody soon.”
Dr Rad 37:34
Oh no, they've gone further than that. They've actually started attacking various areas in the countryside in the near area, with the Aequians by their side.
Dr G 37:45
Oh, I see.
Dr Rad 37:47
Treachery.
Dr G 37:49
Raiding hey?
Dr Rad 37:50
Yeah, definitely some raiding going on. And so we have a joint Aequian-Labicani force. And they have decided to camp on no other place than Mount Algidius – perhaps the most named mount in our Republican era-
Dr G 38:06
Very close to Tusculum.
Dr Rad 38:08
Yes, but I don't know. I don't know why. I guess just because it's in that local area. Everything's very small scale. But I feel like I have sent said that location more than any other. And it's always because someone's camping on it.
Dr G 38:19
I think it's because it's a relatively low hill with a good outlook. It's definitely not the highest hill of these particular hills.
Dr Rad 38:27
But it's handy, very strategic. So the Romans to say, well, this is enough, this is all I need to do here. And they officially declare war on the Labicani. Well, now, Dr G., the Romans – well, some of the Romans, I should say I shouldn't tar them all with the same brush – don't really come out of the next bit of detail very well. Because the Senate say, Well, we're going to need to send two of our military tribunes to deal with these people, because we're now officially at war. And one of you needs to stay in Rome clearly, to look after things here.
Dr G 39:02
Okay, so they're going to have two go out and one stay, that's fine.
Dr Rad 39:06
They've got three, you would think that would be fine. The problem is the three men start arguing with each other about who is going to go out and who is going to stay at home?
Dr G 39:16
Well, yeah, because you can't win a triumph when you stay at home.
Dr Rad 39:19
You can't and so they are trying to do this by bragging about how amazing they are militarily.
Dr G 39:27
This is not gonna go well for the new guy on the block.
Dr Rad 39:29
No they're like, “Oh my god, I'm the best general ever. I mean, I'm so military, I sleep in my full armor.”
Dr G 39:36
“I crushed Fidenae – crushed them underneath my boot heel.”
Dr Rad 39:41
“I only speak in battle cry – that's how military I am.”
Dr G 39:46
I'm not going to try to do my Xena war cry because it's been too many years.
Dr Rad 39:50
Fair enough. Fair enough. But the message is clear to the people who are observing these arguments clearly. Looking after Rome itself is seen as – and I quote: “a thankless and ignoble task”. Nobody wants it.
Dr G 40:06
Well, I mean you can't win a triumph…
Dr Rad 40:11
You can't but the honour!
Dr G 40:14
There is no honour if there's no triumph.
Dr Rad 40:17
Well, the senators don't agree with you.
Dr G 40:18
I'm getting into my patrician like outlook in life what do I live for I live with military glory.
Dr Rad 40:24
Yeah definitely I was gonna say the vibe in here is getting uncomfortable. But anyway, the Senate are gobsmacked – they can't believe that three grown arse men are having this debate amongst themselves and not just you know manning up I mean, okay. Can't win a triumph, but they are already military tribunes with consular power, I mean…
Dr G 40:45
Play scissor paper rock guys. Not hard.
Dr Rad 40:50
Should go back in time and tell them about that game. Anyway. So this is where Quintus Servilius decides to step in and put an end to things. Yeah, he says, I listen your three you have a no respect. No respect at all.
Dr G 41:06
Does he sound like that?
Dr Rad 41:08
Well, if you know, it's just the it's just a no respect line that got me I was like, interesting. I felt like you know, I had to.
Dr G 41:19
Yeah, fair enough.
Dr Rad 41:20
Now this guy Quintus Servilius. He's the dad of the hat trick, dude.
Dr G 41:25
Oh, yeah. Interesting.
Dr Rad 41:28
Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. And so he's like, look, this isn't the way that we do things here. This isn't the way that the Republic works. I am going to step in and use my father's authority to put an end to all of this. Yeah. So he says, I'm going to put my son in charge of the city. Stop this mess.
Dr G 41:51
Okay, so he makes Gaius Servilius Axilla, his son, master of the horse and says you stay home. I'm going out to fight.
Dr Rad 42:00
Just to stop the fighting. Like I can't take it anymore.
Dr G 42:03
Oh, okay.
Dr Rad 42:04
Yeah. And then he says-
Dr G 42:06
So the Senate calls for a dictator? And they decide that Quintus Servilius Priscus Fidenas should be the guy. And he immediately sets one of the military tribunes over the other two essentially?
Dr Rad 42:23
I'm not up to that point yet. You jumped ahead.
Dr G 42:27
Oh, no, I was just trying to figure out what's going on.
Dr Rad 42:29
Okay. Okay. Let's rewind, okay. So, Quintus Servilius steps in, and he's put his son in charge of the city. He's like, you're the one that's staying behind. The other two are going out to combat. Job done. Because as dad, I can tell you, son, you're grounded. That's what's happening. And he says, I only hope that those who are eager to make the campaign may be conducted with more consideration and harmony than they display in seeking it. In other words, you're pretty keen to be a general, so you better be damn good at it. Now, they decided they're not going to conduct a levy on the whole population. Yeah, they decided that they're going to use just 10 tribes chosen by lot for the levy. From those tribes, the two military tribunes selected the men of military age to serve with them. Okay, so they're rounding up their forces at this point in time.
Dr G 43:22
Okay, so they must not feel that threatened. They're not levying the whole population.
Dr Rad 43:27
Well, this might be setting back to something I said from 419, where the Romans are feeling a bit blase about the Aequians by this point in time, but we'll see. We'll see. Anyway. Now, obviously, there's a lot on the line. These guys have really been bragging hard about how amazing they are. But unfortunately, their rivalry is not over.
Dr G 43:45
Oh no.
Dr Rad 43:47
So the feuding that had started amongst the three military tribunes now continues between the two military tribunes and it just gets worse-
Dr G 43:57
Boys boys boys.
Dr Rad 43:59
I know, I know. They're each keen to be like the dominant one. They can't share power.
Dr G 44:07
No, I'm the alpha. No, no I'm the alpha.
Dr Rad 44:10
Yeah, exactly. They basically as they cannot agree on anything. They're just each pushing their own views and their own ideas. And the hatred is obviously just building and even their lieutenants can't take it anymore. They're like, “Oh, my God, enough, you guys, this is getting ridiculous. What we're going to agree is that you each are going to hold supreme command on alternate days.
All right, okay. So that sounds reasonable. I mean, it's a bit like a consulship.
It is it is kind of like that. However, the people back in Rome find out that this is what's happening that like the fighting got to such an extent that lieutenants had to step in and be like, right, well, you guys can't work together. So you're going to hold power and like alternate days. And look, I guess there is a risk with the military campaign with that being the system, there's no obviously, continuity. Typically, they actually do have such different ideas that they can't accept what each other say.
Dr G 45:08
It does sound like a recipe for a Roman defeat.
Dr Rad 45:11
Yeah, absolutely. So this is where Quintus Servilius gets involved again. Yeah, he's like, Alright, I think we need to ask the gods to protect the city. Because I am foreseeing that this is going to end really badly for us, like has happened previously with feuding commanders at places like they, and I can't have that happen again. So he tells his son, go out and enlist more men and get them ready because I'm sensing that this is going to go badly, and we're going to need to act quickly. So we basically need to be prepared, we need to have a backup, ready to go. Okay, now, we have on one day Servius, one of our military tribunes being in charge. Okay? The Romans are in a bad strategic location to start with. Okay, so it's not beginning. Well, the Aequians start pretending like they're scared being like, “Oh, my God, oh, my god,” and retreating to their ramparts. And the Romans had basically fallen for the trick. Okay, I guess pursuing them getting into this, like bad location. So that's why they ended up there. And so they found themselves being attacked by the Aequians being chased down the hill into like a sloping valley. And it must be pretty bad because lots of Romans are not really just being chased. But they're actually like tumbling down the hill. And because they're falling over, and like, I guess they're going, you know, arse over head-
Dr G 46:32
They're going to be picked off.
Dr Rad 46:33
Yeah, well, exactly. They're being slaughtered because they're not even able to stand upright, because in trying to run away, they just like tripping over themselves. Basically, they only manage to hang on to their camp by like the skin of their teeth that particular day. So as predicted, the military campaign is not going very well. So the next day, the Roman camp is almost entirely surrounded. And they're like, I think we have to abandon it. Because if we don't leave now, we're going to be completely surrounded and probably slaughtered. Now, the shame, Dr. G, the shame. It's intense.
Dr G 47:14
Well, yeah, there's kind of that moment of no return. If your camp is completely surrounded by the enemy, there is a point at which you will be overcome by them. Yeah, like, so you have to be really quite strategic, because there is a closing window of opportunity to leave the camp when that sort of military formation is starting to happen around your camp. And you haven't been able to like secure an exit passage yet.
Dr Rad 47:38
Exactly. Yeah. So the generals and lieutenants and the people who will have the standards, they try to get out and they had for Tusculum. And it seems like the rest of the armed forces are just kind of like fleeing through the fields, whichever direction they can, it obviously seems like the Roman forces are in like full chaos at this point in time. There's no real order to it. And so some of them make it to Tusculum. But some of the guys that are just like sort of randomly running through the field, eventually managed to make it back to Rome. And when they get there, they're like, “Oh my god, it has all gone south, guys. It's a terrible defeat. We're in real trouble.” And they're exaggerating it and making it sound. Well…
Dr G 48:17
Are they exaggerating? I don't know. They've just run 20 kilometers home. They're not feeling the best.
Dr Rad 48:24
I guess it may be a little uncertain about whether the camp maybe, you know, whether there was anybody there to be like slaughtered when it was, you know, like when it was obviously left to be captured and that sort of thing. Yeah, whatever it is. They're saying it's not clear, but they make out that it's really, really, really terrible defeat so maybe they say like everyone's been slaughtered except the me. Oh, and that guy as well. So I don't think they have any idea what's really happened to them as a whole force. Yeah. So it's bad.
Dr G 48:52
They're lacking military intelligence. They haven't been on the ground for a while. They've been running for a long time. They don't know how things are. What's going on.
Dr Rad 48:59
Yeah, exactly. Now, luckily, the Romans are not too disturbed by this news, they're like, “It's okay. We knew this was gonna happen.”
Dr G 49:08
“Soon as you two started bickering.”
Dr Rad 49:10
Yeah, exactly. And they're like, it's okay. We've already got some men standing by. And Servilius had gotten in touch with the lesser magistrates, which I presume means the aediles and the quaestors and that sort of thing. Made sure that the city remained calm. Okay. He had also sent out scouts.
Dr G 49:29
I'm sorry, I just have these visions of everybody like popping like lavender essential oil on their pillows, like, just stay calm.
Dr Rad 49:36
We've been here before. It's okay. It's okay. Just breathe.
Dr G 49:40
I'm just gonna lead us through a guided meditation.
Dr Rad 49:43
You can come and collect your paper bag for breathing calmly anytime you like from the senate house. Yeah, so Servilius has sent out scouts as well. They've all come back and told him that don't worry, the generals and the rest of the army. And the standards are all at Tusculum. So they're safe. So the people are feeling actually kind of good, which seems weird because clearly things aren't going well from them. And this is when Quintus Servilius Priscus is appointed dictator by a senatorial decree.
Dr G 50:16
I see. Okay. So it was just like his sort of like auctoritas and patrician persuasion earlier in the year that enabled him to sort of settled this three way dispute between the military tribunes.
Dr Rad 50:28
Yeah. And also the fact that he's obviously got, you know, the good pedigree in terms of you know, previous leadership experiences people trust him. He's not like an unknown quantity. Yeah. And so, and also, he definitely, he definitely had a role in crushing Fidenae. And that, hence his his cognomen. And so yeah, I think people are trusting him already. You know, they've taken his advice already. And now, he just seems like an oracle, because he foresaw all of this happening. And because of, you know, all the things that he suggested and put in place, they now don't have to panic about what would have been seen as a military disaster. So that he just seems the most wise man that they've ever met, because he foresaw all the problems. And this is why obviously, his son ends up as his Master of the Horse, his, you know, his aid, because he had made sure that his son was the military tribune who stayed behind in the city. So he's available
Dr G 51:26
Very convenient.
Dr Rad 51:27
Isn't it just is this an evil plan? I think it might be so sorry, then you can bring in your additional detail now that he is dictator.
Dr G 51:37
Now that he is dictator. Now, I'm not sure that I've got heaps of additional detail, but I'll give you what I have. So we've got the Fasti Capitolini, which just lists the three military tribunes but also then gives us some fragmented parts of the names of the dictator, the magister equitum – master of the horse – and the censor. We also have Diodorus Siculus letting us know about three military tribunes, which he gets mostly right.
Dr Rad 52:10
Impressive.
Dr G 52:11
Yeah, very impressive. This Servilius Priscus business, this name, or this combination of names, has also prompted people to think again about the dictator, who is around when the Faliscans are doing their thing. And this idea of the standard bearer and throwing the standard into the hostile enemy. So maybe that is something that comes up for you. But maybe it's not I'm not sure I probably should have looked into it action. I don't I don't take this piece of evidence. This is from Frontinus. So don't take this as being particularly on point right now.
Dr Rad 52:49
Okay.
Dr G 52:50
It's it's a reference because we've got a Servilius Priscus. But I think we've utilized this piece of evidence in another moment in time previously.
Dr Rad 52:59
Yeah, I definitely remember that story about the guy like being like, “Go get the standards!” to inspire the people.
Dr G 53:07
I then have another reference from Didorus Siculus for the same year, but right at the end, he spends all of his time talking about the Syracusan war, so he's very keen about Greek history at this point in time. But he does mention that in Italy, the Romans went to war with the Aequians and really reduced Labici by siege. So the Labicani-
Dr Rad 53:33
They are from Labici
Dr G 53:34
They are from Labici or Labicum or Lavicum.
Dr Rad 53:39
This is sounding more and more like a lady's body part every time you say it.
Dr G 53:43
An ancient city of Latium. So as you noted, it's the exact location is disputed, but it's thought to be part of the Alban Hills. So that south-east hilly region. Very nice, that's where Tusculum is
Dr Rad 53:58
Near the Aequians.
Dr G 53:59
Yeah, that's where Alba Longa is. There's lots of cool things around there. It's where Mount Algidum is.
Dr Rad 54:06
Make sense? This is a very localized fight.
Dr G 54:10
Very, yeah, but these guys are not completely unknown to us. Okay. There are a couple of references way back. Oh, yeah.
Dr Rad 54:21
I don't remember ever talking about them.
Dr G 54:24
So in the 490s,
Dr Rad 54:26
Okay,
Dr G 54:26
Yeah, way back way back in the early early days of the Republic.
Dr Rad 54:32
So in like 2015 for us.
Dr G 54:36
So Dionysius of Halicarnassus actually records Labici as one of the Latin cities that joins into an alliance against Rome.
Dr Rad 54:44
Well, that makes sense. I was gonna say, I bet they were part of the whole Lake Regillus.
Dr G 54:48
Yes, they were. The infamous battle, Lake Regillus.
Dr Rad 54:54
So they're just being seem like seething away ever since.
Dr G 54:57
You know, first of all, they wanted to reinstate the Tarquin dynasty and now they're still pissed off. So it's not like the Romans don't know about them. There is, like 29 cities listed in this group that ally themselves against Rome in the 490s.
Dr Rad 55:13
They're obviously just not like the largest one. Well, well the most powerful.
Dr G 55:17
I mean, I don't know Dionysius lists them in alphabetical order.
Dr Rad 55:22
So he doesn't avoid irritating any.
Dr G 55:24
Certainly, nobody is given preference in that list. And then we also see them hooking up with Coriolanus. Yeah. So Coriolanus takes his army – and this is when he's leading the Volscian forces – and he's like defected for Rome. Okay. And he marches against Labici.
Dr Rad 55:48
Oh, okay. As part of a Volscian force?
Dr G 55:51
Yeah. So the Volscians aren't into them.
Dr Rad 55:53
No, I'm not into them.
Dr G 55:56
But the Aequians are. So we do have this sense in which there is a sort of a potted history of the Labicani having a relationship generally against Rome, but also maybe not fond of the Volscians either.
Dr Rad 56:12
Yeah, yeah. The power dynamics of this early early time.
Dr G 56:18
And that is literally all of the detail I have.
Dr Rad 56:20
Alright, well, I don't have a lot more. So all I can say is that Livy's says that some other sources – names unknown – have said that it's actually Servilius Ahala, who was made the Master of the Horse Now, that doesn't stack up to me, I feel like it's far more likely that a dad would pick his son.
Dr G 56:41
Well, maybe although having said that this Axilla cognomen has been a source of confusion every time it gets mentioned and the Ahala is one of the potential rereading of it. So…
Dr Rad 56:55
Fair enough. Fair enough. Well, Livy acknowledged. Yeah, he acknowledges the difficulty anyway. So the original Servilius, the dad, he has out with us fresh troops. And he also calls on anyone who's managed to flee to Tusculum. And he sets up a camp near two miles from the enemy. Now this is where things start to get a little confusing. For me, it seems like I'm kind of blending into 417. A little bit here. I'm not going to go into too much detail. But certainly, we're gearing up for a campaign with Servilius as dictator at the head. And the Aequians are overconfident because they've done so well against the Romans,
Dr G 57:34
They they just had a pretty solid victory where the Romans ran away. Yeah.
Dr Rad 57:40
Obviously, they also think that the Romans have suffered a terrible defeat. And they're not anticipating Servilius' organizational skills. And his ability to tell the future.
Dr G 57:49
I don't know. Is it organization or – by holding back the whole of the Roman military force in the first instance – was the reason why they failed?
Dr Rad 57:58
Well, no, it's the arguing – it's definitely the arguing.
Dr G 58:04
I'm just putting it out there. And imagine if you'd turned up with a proper army, Rome, the first time round, and maybe if this Servilius guy was like, you know, like thinking about things realistically, wouldn't it have been better to just win it once?
Dr Rad 58:22
True, but I think that Livy's quite heavily suggesting that it's the leadership that's the problem, not the size of the army. It's the quality, Dr. G.
Dr G 58:30
Well, you need to sort out that before you go to war.
Well, this is exactly it.
So everything's easier from hindsight. And I as a historian can attest…
Dr Rad 58:38
No, I think I think they held back the entire army, because I think there's meant to be that sort of, “Look, there's going to be a problem, we're going to need some reserves” kind of sensation from the beginning.
Dr G 58:50
Don't give these losers all of the troops.
Dr Rad 58:55
Maybe that maybe they were known before this for not liking each other or being argumentative. But anyway, so I'm not going to go much further. I'm just going to leave it on the cliffhanger of the Aequians are getting sloppy and careless. And now we have a dictator in charge, which means there's no arguments or death.
Dr G 59:16
Oh, boy. Yeah.
Dr Rad 59:17
So I think with that in mind, Dr. G, it might be time for The Partial Pick. All right, Dr. G, what is the Partial Pick all about?
Dr G 59:26
The Partial Pick is where we rate Rome. That's it. I mean,
Dr Rad 59:33
Our of five categories.
Dr G 59:35
Five categories. They're capable of getting 50 Golden Eagles if they really pay their cards, right. Five categories. 10 Eagles each. Military clout is our first category.
Dr Rad 59:46
Okay. Well, in terms of what they've actually accomplished, it's not good.
Dr G 59:56
No, I think it might be a zero loss. Yeah.
Dr Rad 59:59
I mean, there's There's a hint that it might not be so bad. But that's not enough for some eagles.
Dr G 1:00:05
No, no, you would actually have to have done something. Yeah. What we've heard is that they ran away. Yeah. And, and tumbled down the hill.
Dr Rad 1:00:13
And what are you concerned with their own personal reputation and authority tasked to actually get it together
Dr G 1:00:18
at the camp surrounded by the enemy? Yeah, no bad. No good. Zero, I'd give them minus equals right now, if I could.
Dr Rad 1:00:23
Well, the only thing I think, allowing them to hang on to their dignity at all, is the fact that they at least have the standards and they didn't get killed. And that's not enough for an eagle
Dr G 1:00:34
Oft. Alright, so that's a solid zero. Diplomacy is our second category.
Dr Rad 1:00:42
Well, look, they did try and send envoys to the Labici. They tried to avoid war, they only declared war once. The Aequians and the beachy had attacked.
Dr G 1:00:54
I mean, we really do need to know more about how those envoys behaved.
Dr Rad 1:00:59
Yeah, I mean, look, I'm not gonna say the Romans have a great reputation with this kind of stuff. But at the same time, we don't have evidence to suggest that they were awful. I don't know that they wanted a war at this point in time, to be honest.
Dr G 1:01:11
I'll give them a one. That's fair. Our third category is Expansion.
Dr Rad 1:01:19
Well, that's definitely a zero.
Dr G 1:01:21
No, if anything things have contracted. And our fourth category is Virtus. How manly have they been?
Dr Rad 1:01:31
Well, I feel like Servilius is on the cusp of doing something. But I don't know if he's done enough yet.
Dr G 1:01:38
I think there's something to be said for those military tribunes arguing once themselves about who goes out because they want the glory. They want the virtus. Glory is interconnected with virtus.
Dr Rad 1:01:49
Yeah, but they do such a terrible job of it. I don't know if they get eagles for that. Just wanting it isn't enough. Everybody wants that. Everybody.
Dr G 1:01:59
Just trying to put it in context before we give it a score of zero.
Dr Rad 1:02:04
Yes, I think it's a zero.
Dr G 1:02:06
I think so. I mean, it's been a mess.
Dr Rad 1:02:09
I've considered it carefully.
Dr G 1:02:11
Yeah. And our last category is the Citizen Score.
Dr Rad 1:02:15
Well, again, I'm gonna say it's probably not a great time to be a citizen, because you've got slaves conspiring to kill you. Just leave probably. But nonetheless, it's not a great time. In that sense. Now, they don't succeed. I'll grant you that. But that can't be good. Can't be good feeling.
Dr G 1:02:34
No one doesn't feel quite as safe with their enslaved population.
Dr Rad 1:02:39
No, and presumably, they've lost a lot of slaves out of this whole thing. If
Dr G 1:02:44
at least the ringleaders who got scourged and crucified.
Dr Rad 1:02:48
Yeah. Okay. So there's that, then you've got this military defeat, which doesn't sound good. And the only good thing I can say about it, is that you're not panicking. Because you're being told not to panic.
Dr G 1:03:04
I was gonna say, does the lavender oil?
Dr Rad 1:03:07
I don't know, the paper bags and the lavender oil are enough to actually get an eagle.
Dr G 1:03:11
I mean, that's a real shame, because somebody in the city was working hard to make sure everybody was calm. There's some great mental health strategies happening right now.
Dr Rad 1:03:23
But is being told to be calm when there's been a military defeat. Is that actually meaning that it's great to be a citizen of Rome?
Dr G 1:03:32
I mean, would you rather be panicking?
Dr Rad 1:03:34
Well, yeah, but like, I'm saying, is it enough to get an eagle like, No, I wouldn't. But is it enough to get an eagle?
Dr G 1:03:39
I think the bigger problem? I don't think it is I I'm just arguing for the sake of it. I think the bigger problem is that there has been what essentially sounds like two levys of the population. There's been the partial levy for the initial military foray in 418. And then there has been the secret – or the additional – the dictatorship levy, that happens to raise the additional force that's going to, that's on the cusp of doing something now. So the citizens have been pressed twice.
Dr Rad 1:04:14
They have but on the other hand, I feel like I mean, the whole reason why Servilius obviously got his son to hold back some of the forces is because he knew that there was going to be a problem between these military tribunes and, presumably, that means he's might he might have lived to save some lives, from people who didn't get close, like definitely there.
Dr G 1:04:32
So we can't give people points for hypotheticals.
Dr Rad 1:04:35
No, no, but I mean, I think that lives probably have been saved here. I mean, there were a lot of guys who were like jack and jilling it down that hill. I'm not gonna I'm not gonna get Yeah, no, I'm not gonna give them points for it. But I'm just saying that like, I think holding back some of the forces was actually a good idea in retrospect.
Dr G 1:04:58
So but we're still giving them a zero.
Dr Rad 1:04:59
Were still giving them a zero. So that means strategy that the Romans had finished for two years together on a grand total of one golden eagle and even that eagle was given begrudgingly.
Dr G 1:05:13
Oh Rome.
Dr Rad 1:05:14
Showing your best you know, like who would have thought like I honestly…
Dr G 1:05:17
We gave them two years so they at least had a chance.
Dr Rad 1:05:20
God wow, I really didn't think the early Republic was going to have so many grim moments.
Dr G 1:05:26
We are not at the height of Rome's power yet. It's pretty clear.
Dr Rad 1:05:29
But even internally, like “Come on, Rome, get it together.”
Dr G 1:05:34
Lavender oil, spread it everywhere.
Dr Rad 1:05:37
Indeed,
Dr G 1:05:37
Bathe in it.
Dr Rad 1:05:39
I will be till next time because I just don't know what's gonna happen. Will Servilius manage to extricate the Romans from this difficult situation?
Dr G 1:05:48
Will the Labici hold their ground?
Dr Rad 1:05:51
Giiirl.
Dr G 1:05:53
Tune in for the next edition of The Partial Historians.
Dr Rad 1:05:56
Indeed. And before we sign off, I'd like to give a special shout out to the Bella Vista Hotel who have a free podcast studio that we are using today.
Dr G 1:06:06
It's very exciting.
Dr Rad 1:06:07
Very fancy.
Dr G 1:06:07
We feel very professional right now.
Dr Rad 1:06:09
We do. It took us ages to figure out how to use equipment. It's like a proper studio.
Dr G 1:06:14
Oh my god.
Dr Rad 1:06:15
Oh my god.
Dr G 1:06:17
I'll catch you next time. Dr. Rad.
Dr Rad 1:06:20
You will.
Dr G
Thank you so much for joining us for another episode of The Partial Historians. We would like to send a huge thank you to all of our supporters across our various social medias, and particularly to our Patreon supporters. This episode we're giving a big shout out to the following patrons Lex, Spacefloozy, Rihanna, Maple Leaf Aussie, Dr. Kate, Jonathan, AJ, Sheila, and Marie-Eve. Thank you to you and to all of our supporters. We look forward to having you with us next episode.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/
Support the show
Patreon
Ko-Fi
Read our books
Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome
Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Content warning for this episode: violence, sexual violence, removal of children
We sit down to chat with Genn and Jenny, the fabulous cohosts of the Ancient History Fan Girl podcast. They have recently published Women of Myth: From Deer Woman and Mami Wata to Amaterasu and Athena which examines fifty women and femme presenting figures from cultures across the globe.
While Women of Myth is the centre of this conversation, there’s no way to discuss ancient ideas about women without considering how that might reflect upon the contemporary issues that women face. This also leads into consideration of the challenges faced by women throughout history.
We wrap up with a discussion of looking beyond the ancient Greco-Roman world – the value of doing that and what that can look like in podcasting.
Special Episode – Women of Myth with Ancient History Fan Girl
What makes a book?In this interview, we explore some of the details of the book including
Consider these retailers:
The book cover!
Sound CreditsOur music was composed by Bettina Joy de Guzman.
An illustration by Sara Richard from Women of Myth of Ītzpāpālōtl, the Aztec Skeletal warrior goddess.
She appears as a crown skull with green feathered hair surrounded by flames.
Dr Rad 0:16
Welcome to The Partial Historians.
Dr G 0:20
We explore all the details of ancient Rome.
Dr Rad 0:23
Everything from the political scandals, the levels as the battles waged, and when citizens turn against each other. I'm Dr. Rad.
Dr G 0:34
And I'm Dr. G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it, by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 0:43
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city. Welcome to a very special edition of The Partial Historians. I am Dr. Rad.
Dr G 1:00
And I'm Dr. G.
Dr Rad 1:02
And Dr. G, we are joined today by two extra special guests. I know this is very exciting for us two extra special people are with us. And the mystery of way shall soon be revealed. I know what I mean, this is this is really a treat because we are joined by two members of the unofficial lady pod squad. And that is right we are joined by Jenny and Genn, who are the hosts of the extremely popular Ancient History Fan Girl podcast. And we are both fan girls of that podcast. Are we not Dr. G?
Dr G 1:39
We are so it's like super, super exciting. It's like ancient history girls unite.
Dr Rad 1:43
Exactly, exactly.
Jenny 1:45
The feeling is mutual.
Genn 1:46
Very mutual.
Dr Rad 1:50
It's actually it's actually really shocking that we have not had you on our show before this because it was many, many moons ago that we recorded Spartacus together. And I feel like it's because we're constantly in contact in terms of I constantly see what you guys are up to on Instagram and constantly listen to your show. And I kind of forget that we haven't actually talked in real life for quite some time.
Jenny 2:11
It's a parasocial relationship.
Dr Rad 2:15
It's indicative of this sad social media world that we live in. It's like, oh, I'm totally caught up with this person's life.
Jenny 2:21
Yes, we are in meshed. I have I frequently have that as well.
Dr Rad 2:28
And we are having them on the show today. Because extra excitingly, they have just written a book.
Dr G 2:37
Oh, my God.
Dr Rad 2:39
That's right. That's right. They are now not only the cohosts of an excellent Ancient History podcast, but they are the coauthors of Women of Myth: From Deer Woman and Mami Wata to Ama – oh see, I'm going to screw this up. Amaterasu and Athena your guide to the amazing and diverse women from World Mythology.
Jenny 3:05
Yay. That's our book. Thank you so much for having us on. This is so exciting.
Genn 3:13
Yeah, we're so excited to be here.
Dr Rad 3:15
No problems at all. And we probably should give a bit of a shout out because not only are you guys co authored this, but you also have some amazing illustrations by Sarah is it? Is it Rashad or Richard Richard
Jenny 3:25
Richard
Dr Rad 3:25
Richard, by Sarah Richard, which really do make the stories I think come alive.
Jenny 3:31
Absolutely. And Liv Albert wrote our forward canvas that
Dr G 3:35
I know. Oh, yeah. For people who might still be unaware – and that must be so few people out there – Liv Albert is the host of “Let's Talk About Myths, Baby”, which is an incredibly popular podcast from the unofficial lady pod squad.
Jenny 3:50
Indeed. I think it's just official at this point.
Genn 3:55
I think so. I think I'm going to have badges made.
Dr Rad 3:58
I know, I'm like how have we missed the opportunity to have matching T shirts made I don't know.
Jenny 4:05
We should all have a T shirt.
Dr Rad 4:07
Yeah, absolutely.
Genn 4:08
Okay. I'm on it.
Dr Rad 4:10
Done, there's our project. Alright, so let's get into it. Dr. G.
Dr G 4:14
Yes. So we're very excited about this book. And I imagine that many people who listen to our podcasts are going to be excited about it as well. So I'm wondering, just to get us started, what's the basic premise? I feel like the title gives a little bit of a hint. But I imagine there's more to be said on this front.
Jenny 4:32
Do you want to hit that one, Genn?
Genn 4:35
Oh, I'm gonna let you start.
Jenny 4:37
I mean, the basic myth, it's women and world mythology. It's, it's um, it's about women and also, you know, feminine presenting characters figures from mythologies around the world. And that includes, we had 50 different slots. And, you know, it's, it's actually there are many Goddesses in the book, but it's divided into three categories goddesses, heroines and monsters. So um, yeah, that's basically And
Genn 5:05
And put those monsters in quotation marks, please.
Dr Rad 5:07
Yeah.
Jenny 5:08
Monsters, quote unquote. And we definitely go into what is coded monstrous in the book and talk about that a lot. So, um, so yeah, that's that's basically what the concept is.
Dr Rad 5:20
Excellent. Yeah, no, I must admit, I was really interested, by the way that you chose to set out your book. And I found it very, very fascinating. So you've got, as you say, those three categories of mighty goddesses, both heroines and formidable monsters using flesh rabbits, they're jumping, they're jumping all over my screen. Can you tell us how did you decide upon those categories when you were setting about writing this book?
Genn 5:45
So those categories were actually something that our publisher wanted. So it was it came down from, from the publishing gods.
Dr Rad 5:54
Yeah.
Genn 5:55
And that was, it might seem like that could be limiting. But actually, it was really fun. And it forced us to really look at who looked at how we were gonna break up the book and make sure that we had not just a whole bunch of goddesses, or not just a whole bunch of really great mortal heroines who did incredible stuff, or not just focus on some of my favorites and mythology, the monsters, because the monsters are just so fascinating and tell you so much about a culture. It's, you know, it tells you what people are afraid of. It also tells you about how people, the things people valued the things they didn't value. So, you know, there's a whole book that could be made of each of those sections. So it was kind of nice to have the publishing Gods on higher say, you know, what, could you give us a little taste of each?
Jenny 6:48
Yeah, it was, I think it provided some good structure.
Dr Rad 6:52
Yeah, definitely. Well, I must admit, I was particularly interested in it because I am a teacher, as I think some people might know. And in my Year 11, course, I get to teach a unit called “Women in Greece and Rome”, which is a comparative study of that. And I will actually always have a section on female monsters from mythology, because I think it's a great way to actually start off the unit, because, as you say, by looking at what a culture is afraid of, I think that actually tells you a huge amount about their attitudes to various things. But if you want to look at gender, for example, it gives you real insight into that.
Jenny 7:27
Oh, yeah, huge amounts.
Genn 7:30
Spoiler, it's almost always women with sexual agency, almost always.
Jenny 7:34
Frequently, it's not only that, there's, there's kind of a subcategory that's like, you know, medical fears, we found a lot of monsters who are kind of, you know, spirits or beings that interfered with, for example, childbirth, and you know, what we might call today, sudden infant death syndrome. You know, like, if this monster attack, they attack a woman in in birthing, or they attack a baby, it's as it's just born. And this is a way to explain deaths that might not be easily explained otherwise, in pre modern cultures. There's also monsters like, for example, there was one an Inuit monster that was basically like her, her. Her basically what she was, was a monster that tempted children out onto the ice. So she would like if a child wandered out onto the ice, she would grab it and take it underwater. So you know, that just speaks to a real fear about the environment and about, you know, children wandering away from their parents and winding up in dangerous situations, which I'm sure was, and still is, in a lot of places. A real danger, right. So..
Dr G 8:41
Yeah, I think that I think that's a really important point, because one of the things that you can see a connection with here is how sexual agency sort of leads into the childbearing aspect. And then the consequences of the childbearing fall upon the mother and the child in various ways.
Jenny 8:58
Oh my gosh, yeah, absolutely. Like there's there's all these like, kind of revolving fears around women, childbirth, child rearing that, that exists across many cultures.
Genn 9:08
And then you get it on the other end as well. You get a lot of older women characters are also monsters. I mean, famously Baba Yaga, right, the, the Slavic witch, the deep forest, whose house is on spindly chicken legs that can move around and she's kind of a chaotic, chaotic, and all fairy tales. Sometimes she'll do good things. Sometimes she'll do real bad things. Sometimes she'll put your head on one of her D posts. You also have like there's a cannibal ogress who also takes an age children. So there's a lot of like women who are not within the family unit who are older, maybe past childbearing years, also being dangerous, particularly if they have any kind of knowledge.
Jenny 9:50
Demonized, literally. Yeah.
Dr Rad 9:52
I feel like that's speaking to so many things as a person who's decided not to have children, mostly because I am massively afraid or the idea that I'm like, Yes, this resonates and also living in a culture where we're terrified of aging and women are just like not supposed to age. I think this can definitely hit home with a lot of people in our audience.
Jenny 10:15
Yeah.
Dr G 10:18
I want to be a crone. I'm looking forward to that part of my lifestyle.
Jenny 10:22
Listen, we're all gonna wind up on Team Cannibal Ogress eventually like we all know that.
Genn 10:30
Do we have to be cannibals though like I'm here for ogress, but do I need to be accountable?
Dr G 10:34
You can be a vegetarian if you so desire that is fine.
Jenny 10:37
You can be a vegan cannibal ogress.
Dr Rad 10:41
I'm actually I'm actually seeing our future now. You know, soon soon we'll all be of an age where society no longer wants to look at us and has no use for us. So we may as well just buy an apartment building that's entirely soundproof where our matching lady pod squad T shirts, and we'll just lock ourselves up in individual spaces and record sounds like basically what I'm doing now.
Genn 11:02
Overlooking the sea please.
Jenny 11:05
Genn can have a window in hers.
Dr Rad 11:08
You can have that, old crone.
Jenny 11:10
Her teeth are long; her windows are glorious.
Dr Rad 11:16
Yeah.
Genn 11:18
How else am I gonna warn people not to approach sometimes by like putting a head in the window. Like I need to have something to warn people.
Dr Rad 11:25
Yeah. We'll be an interesting version of the sirens. You know,
Jenny 11:28
Stop scaring the food away.
Genn 11:32
Alright, look, I'll be able to manipulate like you have the low lighting. We've got a few good years. Yeah.
Dr Rad 11:38
It's good to have a plan, you know, eventually, you know, society will cast you out.
Jenny 11:45
It's called retirement.
Genn 11:46
There's only so many Tik Tok filters, right. Like, we can't make the Tik Tok filters reality yet.
Dr Rad 11:51
Yes, exactly.
Genn 11:54
Yet.
Dr G 12:00
So I'm thinking about bringing things back to the to the topic at hand. I just sort of went out on a little imagination of being like, what would it be like to live in a giant apartment complex with ladies by the sea? And I was like, I think it would be good. I'm looking forward to that. So the illustrations in this book by Sara Richard, they're amazing. I have to say like, so evocative. And I'm really interested in your perspective. One, what was that like working together on this sort of stuff? And how do these illustrations in your view really enhance the themes that are coming out in the work?
Jenny 12:35
Oh my gosh, there's so much to say about that. Like, there's so much to so much like the it was very collaborative, you know, like we would – we would receive kind of line drawings Sarah and Sarah would do these like really funny line drawings and like kind of put little notes in them like skulls here and look at the little arrow you know, like more skull children hiding in the woods. Usually it was skulls though she'd there's like skulls and stories that actively don't have skulls, which I love. So many, I love that this as a as a fan of the cult of the severed head. I just love skulls, and so to Sara, so I think it really worked. But um, yeah, so like, she would send it in, you know, like line drawings, we would take a look and go back and forth on things and kind of collaborate on what the final result would be. And she so frequently just absolutely knocked it out of the park with very little communication, because she had her own process that was always like really in line with ours, because I think she had like really a similar kind of aesthetic to what we were thinking of, and what we were going for in the writing, you know, like, I'm not shying away from the gory details, for example.
Genn 13:46
So one of the things that, you know, we found when we were doing when we were doing the mythology, history, everything for this book is there's one word that comes up again and again, when you when you talk about women in, in these stories, and it's a word that I personally hate because it's such a loaded word. And we couldn't erase it from the book, because it's oftentimes integral to the, to the plot, and that word is beautiful. And so one of the things that we had to contend with was, how are we going to, you know, we've got this wonderful collection of stories about diverse women, how are we going to show beauty in a way that isn't just a westernized beauty standard? And you know, what, what we did with Sara was we worked really closely to be clear about how some of these women could look how, you know, they could not necessarily look Western, like you know, we have we have gender non binary characters. We have larger characters, which for me is always important. You know, I grew up in the era of Disney princesses, where they're literally their heads or, you know, their hands are bigger than their waist. So, it was super important to me that we have have a full body diversity, full, you know, diversity of gender identity. And we didn't just want like larger people. I also wanted to see women who are super athletic women who are, you know, slender women who look like every other woman looks. And also, you know, one of the things Sara does is you'll see a lot of gorgeous women with, you know, very big noses or, you know, beautiful, bright eyes or, you know, the hair textures, everything she's just so good at so that when you look at these women, they are all beautiful, and they're not all uniform.
Jenny 15:38
They all look different. Yeah. Yeah.
Genn 15:41
Yeah, they all look great.
Dr Rad 15:43
Yeah, no, I really love to. I really love that aspect of your illustrations, the fact that you had given the thought of, as you say, not just thinking about the ethnicity in terms of skin tone, and that kind of stuff, which is obviously, still a big issue these days, sadly, as we can see, because at the time of recording, we're recording in the midst of this Netflix fewer about the casting of Cleopatra for their Docu drama, and what she looked like. And I'm sure we all remember a few years ago, when there was debate about the casting of for Troy full of a city. And you know, the casting of people of color to play various mythological characters. So I love that aspect. But I think as you say, particularly for gender, people might not automatically think about it, but having that diversity of body type is so important.
Jenny 16:26
Absolutely. Yeah. And that was a big priority of ours. And I think Sara really knocked it out of the park there, too.
Genn 16:32
Yeah, I wanted to see women who if they were like, riding an elephant or swinging a sword could swing that sword. I was here for that. And one of the one of the one of the illustrations, that's my favorite is the Morrigan, who is the Celtic goddess of the battlefield, she has Genn hair, which is a very fluffy braid hair. I was so excited that Sara did that. But also, she just looks terrifying. She looks like she would stalk a battlefield. With her cape made of feathers and viscera. She looks like she belongs there. And she's got this really terrifying beauty to her. Like, I don't think anyone would, you know, can traditionally call her the most beautiful like person, but she's really scary. Pretty.
Jenny 17:21
Yeah.
Dr G 17:23
Yeah, that's it. It's just a sign, we need to expand our scope of what includes is in beauty, like those narrow standards that come through, particularly online and through like dominant cultural paradigms. And it's like, books like this become really important because they provide that counterpoint. And you're not just challenging culture, you're also expanding it by doing this kind of work. So kudos to you guys.
Jenny 17:46
Absolutely. Thank you.
Genn 17:47
Thank you.
Dr Rad 17:47
And I know my students are always disappointed even though they don't want to say it, I can see it on their faces. Because when I am when I am teaching Troy, and we start by watching the Hollywood version, then when I show them like the Bettany Hughes documentary, and they see that approximation of what how long or short, it might actually look like, given the cultural beauty standards, that their faces always kind of fall because they're just like, oh my god, like it's so confronting the different to like my, you know, Kim Kardashian view of what, you know what a beautiful woman looks like.
Jenny 18:28
It's like, I feel like I've seen Helen of Troy depicted as blonde so often and where does that come from? I mean, why, why is she blonde? You know?
Dr Rad 18:36
Yeah,
Dr G 18:37
Like, what are the chances? It's like, slim to none guys.
Jenny 18:39
Exactly.
Genn 18:40
Well that's, that's, that's the othering, right? That's like we see the red hair pop up all the time. Right as as a ginger, like, who has Mediterranean roots. The only reason you see that is to say this person doesn't belong, like they're from somewhere else.
Dr Rad 18:53
Yeah,
Jenny 18:53
The odds are very high.
Genn 18:54
There were not genders or there were not blondes. I mean, yes, I'm sure there were like, statistically, but realistically, you know, the Bettany Hughes adaptation is much closer to what it would have been, you know, you're seeing those hair colors because it's supposed to be a divine sort of thing to this person, as opposed to an actual reality of what they would have looked like. Sorry.
Dr Rad 19:13
Yeah. 100% 100%.
Genn 19:15
Sorry, gingers out there.
Dr G 19:18
Before we move on from illustrations, I just have to say that the one that really stood out to me was I'm going to try to pronounce the name and hope I get it right. Ītz-pāpā-lōtl, the skeletal warrior goddess.
Jenny 19:31
Yeah, Ītzpāpālōtl.
Dr G 19:34
Yeah. The warrior goddess of the Aztecs, who also has this skeletal aspect about her. Just amazing.
Jenny 19:41
So she was one of my absolute favorites. So if you ask me, you know who's my favorite. There are like dozens of them that I could say but she's one that really stood out to me. And we discovered her like one of the she was one of the first ones that I found that was kind of outside of the scope of what I already knew. And I was just so excited about her. She's a skeletal warrior goddess of the Aztecs. She has butterfly wings lined with obsidian knives and her mythology includes you know, sleeping with a man and then ripping out his heart and eating it, which is pretty awesome.
Dr G 20:12
I mean all round she sounds like the kind of woman I'd want to hang out with.
Jenny 20:15
Hardcore.
Genn 20:18
She has some great stories to tell you over and over like a nice bottle of like, white zinfandel. Yeah, like how did we get to this part where we had to rip the guy apart?
Dr G 20:27
Tell me how we got there.
Jenny 20:28
I mean, I think it's not a white zinfandel. Kind of. I think she drinks blood red wine.
Genn 20:34
All right. Well, listen, I don't – she would make an exception for me. She just put some hearts in hers. It'd be fine.
Jenny 20:40
I don't think she's a “hearts in the wine” kind of gal. That's just you know, blood clots in the wine, sure. Hearts in the wine. Literal hearts perhaps?
Genn 20:50
That's what I meant literal heart.
Jenny 20:52
Oh, I thought you meant like little gummy hearts.
Genn 20:54
No.
Jenny 20:58
Okay, I could see why zinfandel or red zinfandel with with literal hearts in it that she would she would probably drink that. Yeah.
Dr Rad 21:06
Tasty.
Jenny 21:07
She works. Like our whole cannibal plan I think she would fit in.
Dr Rad 21:13
So, I really intrigued because Dr. G and I have also just written a book together, it seems really weird that you know, you guys were publishing your book, publishing our book, and we're like, Oh, my God, we know a little bit about like, what it's like to try and write a book, you know, together, not just on your own, you know, locked in your own thoughts and that sort of thing. Tell us what are the biggest challenges that you encountered when you were writing this book?
Jenny 21:37
Um, I don't know. Like, I feel like for me, the most challenging parts were because there there were, I know, Jenna's gonna have a different answer to this. But for me, the the challenging parts were writing about, you know, women in cultures and mythologies and stories that I wasn't already familiar with, because I'm pretty familiar with certain aspects of, you know, Greek and Roman culture and Celtic mythology and things because we had covered that in the podcast. But we were expanding a whole lot beyond what we had already covered. So I always wanted to approach those topics, like really well, and with the same, you know, thoroughness of research that I did for stuff I had done, you know, a two and a half hour, like, episode series on or something. So, I felt like that, you know, like, I felt a little stressed about it, sometimes I was just like, I want to make sure I get this right, I want to make sure I'm not just, you know, applying a Western lens, or equating something to things that I had already heard about that it actually has nothing to do with, you know. So I was really careful in that and thinking about that a lot. So I would say that, for me, that was the most challenging part. But it was also really fun, because I got to just get outside of my comfort zone and learn about things that I had not known about before. And that's really the fun part for me. So.
Genn 22:53
So everything Jenny said is also how I felt I also, one of the things just to add to this, before I go on to what I found really, equally difficult. One of the things were really careful about was because these weren't, were non western cultures and cultures that we were experiencing for the first time, we really wanted to try to find sources, telling the mythology in sort of from that culture, absolutely important to us that we make sure that you know, we looked at sort of, you know, we looked at the starting point, which is a collection or wherever you would find it in English, a lot of times, we also you know, we are, we are a bit you know, handy, we know we are a bit limited as we only speak English and read English, I read a tiny bit of Latin, Jenny can read and write a little bit of French, but with the with the the exception of that we are not fluent in any other languages. So, you know, we can't read something in Mandarin. And that does limit the opportunities you have when you're looking into other cultures. So we were really careful to make sure that where possible, we found sources that were outside of Western cultures and use them to tell these stories of these women. The thing that and that was tricky. But the other thing that I found really scary and anxiety inducing was I tended to cover some of the really big characters from Western and non western cultures like I covered. I wrote the entry, Mulan and Athena and Medusa. And these are all stories that are so ingrained in Western culture and other cultures. Like we have certain images of what we're expecting. And I found like, Well, what do I have to say that's new? That's also true to the story and how do I continue to make that engaging and not just be the same thing you've read before? I found that really intimidating. I think we got there in the end.
Jenny 24:51
I think so. Yeah. I hope so.
Genn 24:55
I don't know about you got a you both but like, I found writing this book with Jenny. We each took different entries that we edited the other person's entries. But from having the podcast for so long, I didn't find it like our voices I think meld really well, in the writing of the book, like, I don't think it seemed like two different people wrote stuff. And I don't know if you had a similar experience, because like, I kind of felt like it was easy to keep our tone and our voice really consistent. So it felt like one unified project, like what was it like for you?
Dr G 25:25
Oh, that's a good question. I feel we did a similar thing in terms of like dividing up who would take which chapter and then co editing and, and reversing that and things like that. And I think part of the beauty for us is that we do have two distinct voices, we share a sense of humor. But you would I think, for the astute listener of our podcast, they'd be able, they'd be able to identify who wrote which chapter as well. And it might not necessarily be the case for somebody who hadn't encountered our work before, because we do have really similar touch points. But it's really interesting to me, because Fiona has all of these sort of popular cultural references, that I don't get. And then what I think are popular cultural references are still historical, so. And that was something that I was like, Oh, this doesn't come up so much when we're chatting with each other. But it was really distinctly clear in the writing. And I was like, oh, that's fascinating to me. So it was like, I felt like we got to know each other a little bit better through the process, even though we know each other so well.
Dr Rad 26:26
I agree. I agree. When I was editing Dr G's chapters, I always break out to a cold sweat whenever I read anything that she's written, because I'm like, she's just so effortlessly, effortlessly academic. Like, I can only I can only aspire to have this kind of tone to my work. And then I start rethinking everything I've ever written. But yeah,
Genn 26:51
I frequently feel that way as well.
Dr Rad 26:54
But yeah, but you, but you have to just have Yeah, I have. The good thing is I know that if she's the one editing my work, I'm like, I feel at ease. Because if she can write this way, and she can edit my work, I know she'll tell me if I'm being an idiot.
Dr G 27:09
I can't confirm she is not.
Dr Rad 27:15
But yeah, no, it was it was I agree that I think for someone who doesn't know us, if they probably just be like, oh, yeah, this kind of reflects the podcast. But for people who know us, well, people who listen to the podcast, I think they would be able to tell which chapter was written by which person and it is mostly because I can't restrain myself. The publisher actually forced me to cut massively back on the pop culture references saying that I wasn't, I wasn't dating the book to some of them.
Dr G 27:41
I had to put footnotes in for my chapters, because he was like, Is that a thing? And I was like, that's a thing. And I'm not cool. But you're even more uncool than me. So I'm not going to delete it. I'll put a footnote in for you and others of your ilk.
Jenny 27:56
Yeah, we included pop culture references when we could find them as well, because not all of the figures and characters that we found had like extensive pop culture references, but there were some who were kind of emerging and and were appearing in more like kind of manga and video games and more modern pop culture. And it was cool to kind of track that down a little bit. Yeah, definitely.
Dr G 28:20
And I think that's useful as well for people who are approaching these sorts of stories because they like they do have a whole wealth of reception as well. So, you know, anything that might be a touchstone for somebody, I think is useful for bringing them in further into that knowledge. And anything that they come across that they haven't encountered, but the story appeals to them, they've got an avenue to pursue to explore it further.
Jenny 28:41
So absolutely, yeah. For example, like Ītzpāpālōtl has, I think she's inspired at least one monster in a horror film, the name of which escapes me and she's also inspired, I think, a Disney plus cartoon character from there. And I also the name escapes me as well. But I know that she's appearing in pop culture recently. And it's really fun to it's really fun to see that and track it down.
Dr G 29:06
Yeah, so thinking about you've covered 50 women and this is like, like a huge range. Is there any standouts? Oh, the question that we've written down is like, who ended up being your favorite and I'm always a little bit I always back away a little bit when people ask me favorite questions because I really dislike having to place one thing on a pedestal so I appreciate that you might not want to go there. But if so one sort of stand out for you that that may be struck you along the way that hit you differently from what you thought it would or surprised you in some way.
Jenny 29:41
Genn, you want to go first on that?
Genn 29:43
No, I'm gonna let you go first because I love hearing you tell this story and I know what you're gonna say.
Jenny 29:47
Yeah, I always say the same one. And I always preface this by saying that they're they were all my favorite like having done this book. I was always just super excited about whichever one I was covering and I would be texting Genn these little details and if you asked me what my favorite was that week, it would be whatever when I was working on that week, so I really did fall in love with all of them genuinely. And they're all They're all my favorite, I feel very strongly about all the ones that I covered even all the ones that Genn covered because I also helped her edit her entries, and she helped edit mine. So it was really kind of a joint project in that way.
Genn 30:21
And then we recorded the audiobook. So then we, we didn't record necessarily our entries, we recorded each other sometimes based on the flow of the book. So they do really all feel like they are ours, you know, absolutely.
Jenny 30:35
But I would say that one that has stuck with me that I really just kind of love fell in love with and and felt like I maybe identified with or, you know, just just really loved was this goddess named Oya, who is she is like an Eastern African and also African diaspora goddess who I think she may have like, she's like a goddess at the Niger River. Originally, she's a water gout goddess, but also a goddess of like lightning and whirl winds and wind. And she's a warrior goddess, but she's also a goddess of commerce. And she has so many disparate aspects to her. But one of the things about her that I just really loved is that she I think her name means if I'm getting this right, I might be messing this up. But I think her name means the “tearer”, as in the t e a r e r, the “tearer”. And part of her one of her aspects is that she is a goddess of like, the destructive force that comes before transformative change. So she would like, you know, kind of rip into your life like, like a strong wind and just rip everything up by the roots. And you have to start again. And I found that to be like a really interesting and important message to me, because I know that I see this in a lot of my female friends specifically. And also I have done this extensively in my own life. Just holding on to a situation that is not good for me, because I had hoped that it would change, you know, and that has been, I've done this in several different relationships. I've done this with jobs, I've done this with, you know, goals that I had, that no longer worked for me, like just holding on to something so hard, when what I really needed was some of that oil energy, just sweeping in there turning everything upside down and shaking it and just letting me start unburden myself and start over again. And I think you know, many of us can do with a little bit more of that energy. So, so I just, I just love her. And I really appreciate that I got to learn about her in this project.
Dr G 32:38
Oh, thank you for sharing.
Genn 32:41
Super uncontroversial. But like she's also my favorite that I was super surprised by like, I'm very basic. Like I usually say my favorites Atlanta, because when I was 10 years old, finally able to read on my own, I had a long process to reading. I read this book of Greek myth, and there she was, you know, Atlanta, took no shit did what she wanted to do. Wasn't going to marry anyone who wasn't her equal. But I knew going in that that was the standard of what I was looking for. Right? When I was looking at these women's stories, and a lot of the women whose stories we tell our warriors, but some are moms, some are children, some are goddesses of of tearing things up and starting over. But the one who really surprised me the most is also Oh, yeah. Because I don't know. Like, they just as Jenny describes it every time every time I get to hear her say it. I'm like, Yeah, we all need more of that in our life. You know, like, we just let go or be dragged and I was like, okay.
Dr G 33:40
Yeah, don't get stagnated, change is on its way.
Jenny 33:43
Don't get stagnated. Exactly.
Dr Rad 33:46
Yeah, that definitely resonates. Because I think that we we do tend to be scared of change, and we kind of enjoy the comfort, even if bad situation is just that familiarity.
Jenny 33:56
Exactly. And like how it takes so much courage to change your situation, you know, in so many in so many ways. And so like having, like, I kind of see her as embodying that courage, you know?
Dr Rad 34:09
Yeah, absolutely. So this one might be a little bit easier to answer because we're not asking you to rank your your women. But we were interested to hear because so many of these stories were actually unfamiliar to us because those were also sort of starting from a place of being more familiar with Greco-Roman traditions. But which woman in myth is you find had the most complex back story in your view?
Jenny 34:34
Oh, that's a good one. Um, do you want to go first, Genn? Do you want me to go first?
Genn 34:40
Um, you go first because I'm thinking
Jenny 34:43
Okay,
Genn 34:44
That's my like far away thinking face.
Jenny 34:50
Well done, Genn. Yeah. I would say for me, there's this character. It's actually two characters in one Amba and Shikhandi from the Mahabharata in India. The ancient Indian epic. And I this is one of the trans characters that I just completely fell in love with trans or you know non binary perhaps it's a little bit hard to tell it depends on the source. But this character, I think, if I recall, right, I don't exactly remember the order, but I saved them for either last or very close to last because I felt that it was a very complex topic to handle. And I wanted to really make sure that I did it right. And some of the complexity of it was talking about Shikhandi's gender. So this is a story about reincarnation, basically. And it starts off with this woman, a cisgender woman named Amba, who is in love with this man and gets kidnapped by another man and basically has her life ruined by by this guy who kidnaps her because her original boyfriend or you know, lover wouldn't marry her after she had been kidnapped, and then the guy who did the kidnapping wouldn't marry her, because I guess he had a vow of some kind. And, you know, just kind of he just sort of casually destroyed this woman's life. So she really just wanted to get revenge. But this was a renowned warrior, and nobody would side with her and help her get revenge on him. So she prayed about it in the forest, and one of the gods came to her and said that she would be able to successfully get revenge, but only in another lifetime. So she immediately built herself a funeral pyre and jumped into it so that she could hasten her own reincarnation. And eventually, depending on the sources, she may have gone through a number of lives before eventually being reborn as this character, Shikhandi, who their their gender is, either you could look at them as a transgender man or a transgender woman, or perhaps a non binary person, or perhaps a sis woman who just really doesn't conform to expectations of cisgender women in that time, you know, like that. It's very complicated, writing about it. But I really enjoyed learning about Shikhandi, and learning about, you know, gender, as told and described in this epic, and also like more modern depictions of Shikhandi and how their gender has been depicted throughout the years. And eventually, like, the cool thing about Shikhandi is that they become eventually the charioteer of this other really renowned warrior in the current shutter of war, which is featured in the Mahabharata. And they wind up just finding this this original person who had ruined his life and riddling them with arrows and taking epic revenge. And it's just such a really great harrowing and gripping tale. And that just happens to involve a gender queer character from 1000s of years ago. And I really enjoyed that. And I found it, you know, a complex and challenging topic to cover. And for me, because I just wanted to make sure I was getting it right, but also just really, really fun to learn about.
Genn 37:52
Yeah, so mine is a little more recent, La Llorona, who is the Mexican wailing woman of mythology is super fascinating. And her history is so deeply rooted in the colonization of the of Mexico. And us, you know, her story stretches back to when, when Mexico was colonized by the by the Spanish, she started out her life as a, an Indigenous woman who is has a love affair with a Spanish guy. And at this particular point in time, this was very common. And a lot of Indigenous women had these, they were sort of like second spouse, spouses or relationships with these Spanish, Spanish men. And so what happens is this guy who has been professing his love for her, they have two children together, all of a sudden is like, hey, so I have to marry this other woman. And in addition to that, I'm going to take our kids because I think that it would be better for me to raise them and like, you can totally visit them and stuff, but I'm done with you. And so the, you know, the choice that is left to this woman, you know, is is not great. She out of grief and despair, drowns her children and usually kills herself. She's usually found by a body of water. And a lot of her history is, you know, then she comes back and is sort of a, you know, a spectral spirit who, you know, takes children or, you know, will will drown you in the water. But all of that is so deeply tied to colonization and how women were treated. Like it was very common that comedy and Spanish conquerors would be conquerors. You know, Spanish colonizers would have affairs with Indigenous women and then take their children from them, because they didn't believe that they were able to raise their own children. And the treatment of women was absolutely appalling and indigenous people in general and one of the other things about this mythology that Jenny helped me understand, because I didn't know this, is that some of that folklore which now it has, like, its own sort of operas and its own sort of like place in the Day of the Dead celebrations, but some of it goes all the way back to the Aztec conquest. I'm gonna let you talk about that, Jenny, because you know it a lot more clearly than I do, even though I wrote the entry.
Jenny 40:21
Yeah.
Genn 40:22
I always confuse it.
Jenny 40:23
Well, I mean, I think just that that part of it is that there were Aztec goddesses that may have that that law, Your Honor, may have also had her roots in like, goddesses that involve child sacrifice in some way, or goddesses that were tied to water in some way. Some of this comes, like was written about in, you know, codices that record people who had lived through the siege of Tenochtitlan, for example, like accounts of, you know, signs importance of, of this siege, and some of them involved, you know, wailing women, for example, showing up at the streets of Tenochtitlan the night before, and wailing about their children, you know, dying or being in harm's way. Some of this is less than trustworthy, because it comes from through a Spanish lends there were all these, you know, Spanish priests running around at a certain time, you know, in the decades after the conquest, interviewing Indigenous survivors of the of these events and writing these things down, but it was the priests writing them down. So how, and this also goes for some of the mythology around Ītzpāpālōtl too and we talk about that in her entry. how trustworthy that some of this stuff is, is a little bit up for interpretation, you know, and, like, questionable, but there, there is some, some documentation of that. So it's possible that there that there were goddesses that, that lie, you're gonna call us back to that have indigenous roots as well.
Genn 41:52
Yeah, as a foretelling of this doom, right?
Jenny 41:55
Yeah, like a doom foretelling. And that has to do with, you know, either death of children and death in the water, you know?
Dr G 42:03
Yeah, I look, I think you see those similar parallels coming through in like the tale of Medea, for instance. And it's like, you know, this story of conquest, and people coming in and taking ownership of a place or assuming that somehow they, they, it's theirs now, and what are the fallout consequences of that, and there is a long, long history of that kind of colonial violence. And it's really good to see these stories coming through, because it emphasizes just how common it is, and also puts us situates us in the fight to going forward? Like, how do we do the processes that undo some of the problematic consequences of this kind of history as well? Like, how do we do it well, and I feel like there's a long way to go. But I think there's inherent value in the, in sharing these kinds of stories, just to reiterate just how common this kind of violence is, and also situating us in a in a position of action, what to do next.
Genn 43:00
And also, like, you know, one of the things you see is that it's very much this mythology in particular is a psychic scar that you have on people who after, you know, after the horrors of colonization, they don't there's a lot of things we don't have anymore as a result, but this story comes through, and it is one of those things that remains with us. And, you know, should be a way of telling us like, you know, this, the there's just so much there that I'm not I'm not making any sense at the moment. It's just it is like a psychic scar that does come through in the folklore that is, is there to, you know, continually remind us of the horrors of colonization?
Jenny 43:37
Yeah, like how these women were treated. And you know, how basically how the Spanish colonizers treated Indigenous women that they had relationships with?
Dr Rad 43:47
Definitely no, like, I think that that actually is a really good place to start to wrap up, because one of the things I was very impressed by when I looked inside instead of reading my copy of your book is that you guys were very restrained in that, even though I think when you probably started your podcast, you were focusing more on sort of Greco Roman world topics. And I've seen with your episodes that I've been listening to that you've gradually move beyond the sort of Greco Roman world and certainly in this book, I was very impressed that you were very restrained in the in the use of Greco Roman mythology, because I mean, you really could, you could easily populate, you know, 50 women from Greco Roman mythology if you wanted to in a book like this, but I was I was really blown away by the array of cultures that were on display. Is that something that you were exploring the podcast, and that sort of gave you the idea for the book or did the book kind of inform where you've taken the podcast?
Jenny 44:44
I think that Jen and I had both really wanted to move beyond Greco Roman stuff for a long time. I mean, our podcast is called Ancient History Fan Girl, not just Ancient Greco Roman History Fan Girl and yet for our first you know, couple years, we really stayed in that realm because and I think that it wasn't something we did as a conscious decision, we just kept falling down these rabbit holes and like, the more we learned, the more we wanted, we found things we wanted to cover. And the more we got confident in this one area, and we get excited about things, and, you know, it was just really hard to wrench ourselves away. And we had, we realized, like, we had to make this conscious decision to do that. And we had been talking about how we were going to do it for a while when the opportunity to write this book came about. So it felt like a natural extension of expanding our horizons in that way, you know, but we had planned to do that already on the podcast, and we would have done it whether the book had happened or not. But I'm really glad we did it, because I think it gave us both, you know, kind of more of a, like, more of a global view on history as well as mythology because we talked about history, and how how the history and the mythology kind of meld in a lot of the entries that we did anyway. So
Genn 45:53
Yeah, everything that Jenny said, I think our podcast, because I have a deep and abiding love of Greco Roman mythology, sometimes stays in Greece in Rome a little too long. Not that Jenny doesn't also but like that's, that feels like my home to me. But one of the great things about this book is it forced us outside of that. And we had always planned to do that. And I think it really, it really broaden our horizons. And it sort of gave us a lot of confidence to be able to continue doing it. I also know that we did a season a couple of couple of seasons ago about gender in the ancient world. And when we finished that season, I was like Jenny, I am now broken. I need to leave Greece and Rome for a little bit of time. What can we do to get out of Greece and Rome? Because like,
Jenny 46:39
Yeah, we were both feeling a little bit like we just needed a scene shift, you know? So
Genn 46:46
Just watching the patriarchy be built. You're like, yeah, no, I got it. What can we do that's gonna just bring joy back to my life.
Jenny 46:52
And then we decided to cover ancient mysteries, which was basically like a lot of natural disasters and skeletons where they shouldn't be so I don't know how light that was?
Genn 47:06
Well, I think one of the things we did in the ancient mystery series that I'm incredibly proud of, I say it every time we talk about it is our first episode in that series is about the dating of the Sphinx, how old is this things? And we spent a lot of time in that series really digging into stuff that were actual mysteries, and then also stuff that maybe some TV channel or streaming service would like you to believe are mysteries for ancient alien reasons that aren't. And I think it's really easy for people who are sort of who follow things on those places to think like, Oh, I found this mystery because aliens built it or whatever, and not unpack the actual reality of the good work that archaeologists and historians and scientists and its ographers are doing to show you real mysteries and ask questions that aren't about of colonization. Yeah, well, they are about colonization, but aren't about you know, white washing other people's history? Because,
Dr Rad 48:04
Yeah, that's my biggest thing. I absolutely cannot stand it when my students come in and go, didn't aliens build the pyramids and I'm like, shut your mouth right now. That is racist propaganda, whether you realize it or not.
Yeah.
Genn 48:18
We started with that episode. Jenny did such an amazing job of it of showing you how you can watch a documentary and you can listen to that very smart sounding documentary, and start going down this rabbit hole of, “Wait a minute aliens built this?”. Wait a minute, during a minute, have I just fallen down a racist rabbit hole? What happened? Yeah, I mean, that's, that's kind of like when we started doing ancient mysteries, like, you can look at something like Göbekli Tepe, or, you know, different different, like, you know, monuments around the world. And if you recall, peyote makan is absolutely one of these Cahokia is one of these where you look at that, like, there, there are obviously extremely legitimate and fascinating mysteries around around these monuments, but there's also, you know, kind of all this pseudo historical stuff built up around it. And we didn't realize the extent to which we'd have to pick through that in that season. So the there's an app, the first episode we dropped was the Sphinx 10,000 years old. And it's kind of just talking about like, starting starting with like, how easy it is to if you are a lay person like Jen and me and you you are not like a scholar yourself in this stuff. And you're just like, well, I don't know, this guy has a PhD in the front of his name and he's in all the same journals as the other guys. And so why is why is this illegitimate? You know, how would you know and you know, talking about how, how easy it is to to be sort of drawn in by that and then where you wind up is basically, the people who actually built this thing didn't build these things. Maybe it was white people who are also from Atlantis. From Atlantis, racist Atlanta and also originally from Mars, and for some reason, all the Martians are white. Go Go big here. You know?
Dr G 50:01
It would explain a lot though, let's face it, yeah, if the aliens were white.
Jenny 50:06
God. I mean,
Dr Rad 50:09
I think it's also this very seductive idea that we have about humankind in that we have this idea that our story is one of progress that people 1000s of years ago couldn't have done something super advanced because it was 1000s of years ago, and we must be smarter and you know, have come such a long way from then, that they can't possibly have done these things, because that doesn't make any sense. You know, like, we have to have this chronology and it's like, no, they have the same capacity as us to reason to think to create, and because they're from a different time and a different culture. Maybe they come up with different ideas and different solutions to problems. But yeah, humans are capable of pretty much the same thing. If they're of the, you know, the same type of, you know, of humankind.
Jenny 50:59
Absolutely.
Genn 51:00
Yeah like the fact that we had flushing toilets in Skara Brae, which is a tiny little island village on the sort of falling into the sea on a Scottish island called, I don't know if it's on Stromness. Or if it's up in the Orkneys. They have flushing toilets.
Jenny 51:16
Yeah.
Dr Rad 51:17
And I think that's a great place to finish up. Because realistically, we can finish up by saying that by talking to Ancient History Fan Girl –
Genn 51:24
I should say it's a it's a new I should say it's a Neolithic settlement. So like super super, super old.
Dr Rad 51:30
Yeah, no, definitely. No, I think I think it shows us that you know, all throughout our history humans have been like, what to do with shit. What to do with it?
Genn 51:37
Oh!
Dr Rad 51:39
We don't like it.
Dr G 51:41
Where am I gonna put it, guys? I made some more.
Dr Rad 51:48
And so on that very sophisticated note, we're going to wrap up this absolutely wonderful conversation with the fabulous co hosts of Ancient History Fan Girl – if you haven't listened to it, and I can't imagine that you haven't. Please go and check it out. I'm going to a pass over to Genn and Jenny so they can tell you all about where to find them and also how to purchase this amazing book of theirs.
Jenny 52:09
Thank you so much. Our podcast is Ancient History Fan Girl. You can find us at Ancient His Fan on Twitter at Ancient History Fan Girl on Facebook and Instagram. We're not really we're on at oh, what's our Tiktok name?
Genn 52:24
Ancient History Fan Girl.
Jenny 52:25
There we go. We're also on TikTok.
Genn 52:27
Keep that brand consistent when they give me characters.
Jenny 52:29
Heck yes, you can find us on Tik Tok. And, yeah, our book “Women of Myth” is available basically wherever books are sold. If your indie bookstore doesn't happen to have it, ask them to order it, I suppose. Is that how it works? I think so.
Genn 52:48
Yeah. And ask your library libraries are great. They're free. Ask your library to order it in. They should be able to
Jenny 52:54
Interlibrary loan.
Genn 52:57
Exactly. It's also available on audiobook we read it. Yeah. And as an ebook.
Jenny 53:03
You get to hear the dulcet tones of our voices.
Genn 53:07
We encourage physical copies because Sara's illustrations are just incredible.
Dr Rad 53:12
Yeah, very vibrant. I can't tell you how much we've enjoyed chatting to you today. And the thing that's really put it over the top of me is that there's actually been a pod cat in the background. I've just seen paws appearing at random times.
Dr G 53:27
Having a great little stretch. It's been a wonderful show of, you know, napping and relaxation in the background.
Jenny 53:35
That's exactly it. You know what's so funny about that too, is that when we did our Spartacus episode one of your cats I don't know which one it was was nuzzling up to the microphone and murmuring little cat sounds into it. And we kept it in there.
Dr G 53:50
I feel like that would have been Hamish.
Dr Rad 53:52
Yeah, I have. I have a cat that is deaf like me. And he does not respect boundaries.
Jenny 54:00
Fair and who would want him to I mean he's a cat.
Dr Rad 54:06
Yeah, yeah, exactly. Well, thank you so much for joining us. We won't leave it so long in between episodes next time I think.
Jenny 54:12
Absolutely.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/
Support the show
Patreon
Ko-Fi
Read our books
Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome
Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Another decade is gone and it's time for a Partial Recap! We run through what the ancient sources tell us about this decade. There are some real highs and lows!
The Partial Recap 420s BCE
If you are keen to for some more detail, you can jump into our narrative episodes at 134 – A Dry Period.
A view to the East over the Roman Forum with the Temple of Saturn on the left and the Palatine Hill on the right, showing the Temple of Castor and Pollux, the Arch of Titus, Santa Francesca Romana, and the Colosseum. Detail from the photograph by Nicholas Hartmann, June 1976. Image Source: Wikimedia Commons. Used under license.
Sound CreditsOur music was composed by the fabulous Bettina Joy de Guzman.
Automated TranscriptDr Rad:
Welcome to the Partial Recap for the 420s BCE!
Dr G: I’m Dr G
Dr Rad: and I’m Dr Rad
Dr G: and this is our highlights edition of the 420s in Rome. We’ll take you through from 429 to 420 in an epitome of our normal episodes.
Dr Rad: Perfect for those mornings when you don’t want some lengthy rhetoric with your coffee – but please be warned – the Roman world is a violent one.
Dr G: Get ready for a recappuccino.
429 BCE
428 BCE
427 BCE
426 BCE
425 BCE
424 BCE
423 BCE
422 BCE
421 BCE
420 BCE
Dr Rad: And that was the 420s in Ancient Rome… or was it?
Dr G: Remember, this has just been the highlights from the ancient sources, so if you want to delve into the complexities of the different evidence from this period, check out our narrative episodes. Jump in at Episode 134: A Dry Period to join us for a deep dive into the 420s BCE.
Dr Rad: Thanks for turning in to this Partial Recap!
For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/
Support the show
Patreon
Ko-Fi
Read our books
Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome
Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
The Partial Historians are back in the 420s BCE and we are wrapping up the decade with some first-class DRAMA! At the centre of it all are the trials of Sempronius and Postumia. The only question is, can you handle it?
Episode 139 – The Trials of Sempronius and Postumia
Fake ElectionsThe year began with some classic conflict between the patricians and the plebeians. The tribunes of the plebs were FURIOUS when their relatives did not get elected as quaestors. There was only one possible explanation – election fraud!
There was clearly one man to blame: Aulus Sempronius Atratinus. He had been in charge of overseeing the elections and he had rigged the results. Unfortunately, he was also a military tribune and therefore immune from prosecution. But that didn’t mean that his relatives were…
The Trial of SemproniusThe tribunes set their sights on Atratinus’ cousin, Gaius Sempronius. Sempronius was the perfect target. He had been in charge of a DISASTROUS military campaign in 423 BCE. Time for vengeance!
Jean Lemaire c. 1645-1655. Roman Senators and Legates.
The picture shows senators walking though a square attended by lictors. Maybe they're on their way to a trial!
Sempronius was not the only person to find themselves on trial in 420 BCE. A Vestal Virgin named Postumia was accused of incestum. Apparently, her clothing was a bit too sexy, and she had a sense of humour. What a horrible combination! Think of the children!
However, incestum was a very serious charge as it put the Romans’ relationship with the gods in jeopardy. It was no joke for Postumia either. Charges like this could lead to live burial for a Vestal.
Tune in to find out whether Sempronius and Postumia manage to emerge victorious from their respective trials.
A modern imagining of Vestal Virgin by sculptor Joseph-Charles Marin 1791-95.
Courtesy of Mary Harrsch on Flickr.
Need a recap on Sempronius? Check out our previous episodes on 423 BCE and 422-21 BCE.
Our Players 420 BCEMilitary Tribunes with Consular PowerSound Credits
Our music was composed by Bettina Joy de Guzman
Sound effects thanks to Pixabay, Fesliyan Studios and BBC Sounds.
A statue of a Vestal Virgin in the atrium Vestae (house of the Vestals) in Rome.
Courtesy of Carole Raddato via Wikimedia Commons.
An automated transcript of this episode has been provided thank to Otter AI.
Dr Rad 00:16
Welcome to the partial historians,
Dr G 00:20
we explore all the details of ancient Rome.
Dr Rad 00:23
Everything from the political scandals, the love of ours, the battles waged, and when citizens turn against each other. I'm Dr. Rad.
Dr G 00:34
And I'm Dr. G. We consider Rome as the Roman Sword by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 00:43
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr G 01:06
Hello, and welcome to a brand new episode of the partial historians. I am Dr. G.
Dr Rad 01:16
And I am Dr. Red and I'm in a very special t shirt today. Dr. G. My All, roads lead to Rome t shirt.
Dr G 01:26
Are you hoping to sneak into my suitcase to come on a certain trip?
Dr Rad 01:30
I'm just dropping subtle hints.
Dr G 01:34
If I can fit you, I'll take you.
Dr Rad 01:36
Excellent. Excellent.
Dr G 01:37
So we have been tracing the history of Rome from the foundation, the traditional foundation date of 753 BCE. And in our last episode, I think if I remember rightly, we were dealing with 422 BCE, (and 421) and 421. So yeah, go we covered a lot of ground, because I remember the four horsemen being very- they were stand out for me. So this means that we're going to be talking about we're starting at 420. So real shame that we didn't record this in April.
Dr Rad 02:15
Yes, yes, that's absolutely right. We are recording about 420 today. So to briefly recap, 422 and 421, which is our previous episode, we're interested in good ol conflicts of the orders. Dr. G.
Dr G 02:30
Oh, yes. Well, I love a good conflict of the orders. hasn't this been going on for centuries now?
Dr Rad 02:36
Not quite centuries, almost a century I think. Only there were nearly there. We still got, you know, a couple of centuries to go. It'll fly by the flyway. We won't, we won't be dead at all. By the time we finish.
Dr G 02:51
Everything seemed to swill around the situation with Sempronius, one of the guys that's been sent out with some troops, and he's done seemingly a poor job. And he's then been taken on to trial for being such a bad general. And all of his, all of his lower down cavalry commanders have come to his aid being like, this guy was great. And he did the best he could in a tough situation.
Dr Rad 03:16
Yeah, absolutely. So we do have the situation with Sempronius, which is fallout from seemingly a not great military encounter that Rome had with the Volscians in 423 Sempronius, the unfortunate and perhaps incompetent leader of said military effort, and we're dealing with the fallout of that. And definitely we saw that some of his men came to his assistance when it looked like he was going to be in danger of being prosecuted or something like that. And then we had even more conflict of the orders. I mean, that wasn't really conflict for the orders, except that it was interesting that it was this fight happening with Tribune's of the plebs who were our four horsemen, and they'd been involved in the battle in the previous year. And then Sempronius, who was a patrician, we then got more explicitly into the conflict of the orders in the following year, where we had this debate about could a plebeian become a quaestor? And we had so many interreges, they were coming out of our ears, Dr. G.
Dr G 04:18
And it's been a really weird time. Rome is definitely trying to figure itself out politically, militarily. It's been a rough ride.
Dr Rad 04:27
Yeah, it really has. But there was the resolution was they ended up coming full circle. And going back to the compromise that was put forward, right at the beginning of this debate, which was that you can have a plebeian quaestor. Sure, as in they can run for election, but Will anybody vote for them? Time will tell Dr. G.
Dr G 04:49
Are they gonna be able to put together a sophisticated and well funded campaign? Doubtful. No.
Dr Rad 04:55
All right, we'll see yeah that's really all we need to know about 421 So let's go into 420 V c
Dr G 05:30
so 420 BCE for key listeners who enjoy the smoking of the green leaf now is your time to light up because this is happening all year. We have military tribunes with consular power and many of them I might add our first cab off the rank is Lucius Quinctius Cincinnatus a family we know well, yes, the lineage is continuing. And he's had a couple of positions ahead of this one so we've seen this guy before. He is not a surprise. Now. We also have Lucius Furius Medullinus, also previously has appeared and most recently served together with Cincinnatus as another military Tribune in 425. Yeah, so they've been buddies before and here they are, again, five years later.
Dr Rad 06:33
Lovely. It's cute. Yeah,
Dr G 06:36
We also have Marcus Manlius Vulso, a man for which I don't have any more detail than his name.
Dr Rad 06:43
No, that is that's an unusual name that level so isn't it?
Dr G 06:48
Yeah, I'm not sure it is. I've heard before Yeah. Well, so it's not standing out for me one way or the other. We might have encountered one in the past but I'm not sure.
Dr Rad 06:56
Yeah, the Manlius I recognise.
Dr G 06:59
The Manlius gens, they're doing well for them. Yeah, very manly all the way down their line. Yeah. And then Aulus Sempronius Atratinus. Also, previously a consul in 428. And also apparently a military tribune in the same year.
Dr Rad 07:18
Excellent. So getting the gang back together.
Dr G 07:21
Yay. So there are military Tribune's and then I also have some tribune of the plebs as well. Oh, we have Aulus Antistius, potentially a relation of Tiberius Antistius, the plebeian tribune of 422. So we get another one of the same gens coming through Sextus Pompilius. Yep. Most famous because of the Pompilius gens, which means you definitely of Sabine extraction. Yeah. And Marcus Canulinus, and this is known as a plebeian gens.
Dr Rad 08:05
Why ,I have him as Marcus Canuleius.
Dr G 08:09
it might just be my mispronunciation. I mean, I have clearly two variant spellings in my notes. Now that I know that I'm looking closely at them. So apparently the most famous bearer of the Canuleius name was Gaius Canuleius who was tripped into the plebs in 445. So somebody that we have encountered before, and is the one who introduced the plebiscite on a marriage the repeal to ban the marriage between patricians and plebeians.
Dr Rad 08:46
Well, that's right. I was like I was looking at that name going, it's so familiar. That's a huge thing to have in your family.
Dr G 08:53
He's Yeah, so this guy seems to be a comes from the same gens as that really famous tribune of the plebs from a couple of decades ago at this point, and the family seems to lose prominence after that. So this I don't know if this is the last Canuleius we're gonna see but-er, You heard it here first.
Dr Rad 09:14
Well, they're hanging in it. They've got they've got a fingernail
Dr G 09:19
clutching on to the tribune of the plebs for dear life.
Dr Rad 09:22
Yeah, this is where I think 421 and 420 get a bit blendy because I also have an interrex listed for this year, which is Lucius Papirius Mugillanus who we talked about in our last episode, because he's the one that came in and like, stop this madness. We can't keep having all these interreges. This is crazy.
Dr G 09:45
This is madness. I indeed also have Mugillanus down as interrex for this year. But also, and I have to say, most excitingly, I also have a Pontifex Maximus and a Vestal virgin.
Dr Rad 09:58
I know I have not bothered to do any reading about this because I know that I've got the world leading expert on Vestals and I was like, I don't need to do anything.
Dr G 10:11
I'm happy to take the reins on this tale of woe such as it is.
Dr Rad 10:15
Exactly. Which means you finally have you know, source material. Very exciting.
Dr G 10:20
Look, you'd be surprised about how little I have even.
Dr Rad 10:25
I'm on board whenever you have.
Dr G 10:26
It is a tough year. I'm in a really fellow section in terms of source material. As you know, Dionysius of Halicarnassus is perenially missing and even Diodorus Siculus, who is unreliable at the best of times, but we do like him is also currently unavailable. So
Dr Rad 10:42
that's okay, you know, it's actually this year is actually structured well for us in that most of the action that you wouldn't be aware of happens first, then we get to the Vestal.
Dr G 10:52
Okay, that's exciting. So I'll just tell you the names of these characters and yeah, well let you get into like the the main action for the year which I'm completely at, like lacking. So we've got Spurius Minucius is our Pontifex Maximus. Yeah, and our festival virgin is Postumia.
Dr Rad 11:14
Okay, exciting times. Alright, so let me tell you about 420 BC Dr. G. Nobody remembered anything because of all that stuff they were smoking – no, I'm just kidding.
Dr G 11:27
that explains a lot about what's going on with my source material.
Dr Rad 11:31
So allegedly, we had this period, unfortunately, we're on there where there are and maybe the 420. Who knows where there were lots of interreges, but they managed to resolve that situation. And at the end of that whole process, they come out with military tribunes with consular power. And it's all patricians all the time, Dr. G.
Dr G 11:51
Colour me surprised. I'm shocked. I'm really shocked.
Dr Rad 11:55
I know. So one of these military tribunes with consular power Atratinus Atratinus What do we prefer?
Dr G 12:03
Oh, look, I like Atratinus. But that's just me really. Don't feel wedded the fact that we learned Latin in Australia, it's probably means that we're butchering it a lot. Certainly, I know others would pronounce it differently.
Dr Rad 12:21
Like there's nothing I enjoy more than butchering an ancient language. All right, I'll go to Atratinus or Atratinus then oversees the election of quaestors which had been the sore point the previous year in terms of who gets to be a quaestor and that sort of thing. So there were some keen for plebeians in the race so the tribunes finally be like Yes, finally someone's actually running for something – amazing!
Dr G 12:47
they got up and said like we're going to abolish the whole thing because you none of you are even trying what's the point of view even having a chance
Dr Rad 12:55
Exactly. You're embarrassing us you're embarrassing the whole day in class, whatever that is. One of them was a guy called Aulus Antistius. Son of a tribune of a pleb No, son of a tribune of the plebs.
Dr G 13:13
Okay, so the Antistius that I have listed down as the tribune of the plebs is quite possibly either running for quaestor as well, or running for quaestor instead?
Dr Rad 13:25
I would say it's probably his son. Yeah, I would say it his son.
Dr G 13:31
Okay. Somebody lower down on our hypothetical cursus honorum that we don't exist.
Dr Rad 13:36
And then and then we also have a brother of a tribune of a tribunes of the plebs, the brother of Sextus Pompilius.
Dr G 13:43
Oh, what's his name?
Dr Rad 13:44
I don't know. Actually, it just says it's just as his brother. I mean, yeah.
Dr G 13:50
Pompilius the other one, we'll call him Pompilius Secundus.
Dr Rad 13:54
Bro Pomp. Bro Pompey, that's what we're going to call him. Yeah, so though these guys are obviously connected to people in power, because you know, they have these connections with guys who have either held the office of Tribune or are currently holding the office of Tribune. The people still couldn't resist the lure, the glow, that was coming off the patrician candidates because they have the blood of mighty consuls running in their veins. I mean, you can see it in their blue veins.
Dr G 14:30
When I get a wound on the front, little consuls come out instead of blood drops.
Dr Rad 14:38
That's exactly right. So as a result, they don't get to look in. They ran and they fail.
Dr G 14:44
Damn, what are we going to see some power to the people around you is
Dr Rad 14:48
what kicks off the problem because the tribune of the plebs are ropable, particularly Antistius and Pompilius understandably, because they like
Dr G 14:59
yeah They were pretty invested
Dr Rad 15:01
the hell like our guys are just as connected as the other guys. This is actually a burn to us. We feel it we feel it because it's like an insult that their connections to us is somehow not the same as a console we're not good enough for you. Like you only have to have certain kinds of connections in this world deaths guesting Okay, so they're not happy at all that like the tribune of the plebs have done so much for Rome. They serve so well. And what about the politicians? They are douchebags they've done nothing.
15:42
They screw up all the time.
Dr Rad 15:44
The patricians were such douchebags How could no plebeian ever be chosen military military tribute with concealed power? And now also not be chosen as frickin quaestor? What, I'm not good enough to do your paperwork?
Dr G 16:00
Look, I think this might in part be related to the way voting is conducted in the ancient Roman world. And I'll caveat this being like, like everything with this period of Roman history, we don't know much, for sure. But the voting system as it develops, seems to really be a top down approach. So everybody who's there, who is a citizen who is male gets to have a vote, and that's fine, but you're voting in groups. And those groups are voted from the most senior, and hence the most patrician down, and it's first pass the post. So by the time anybody might even be thinking about bringing in a vote for a plebeian candidate, chances are all the positions have been filled by patricians voting in their buddies.
Dr Rad 16:48
Yeah, exactly. That's exactly it. So I don't know why there's no outrage. It's like the system's rigged against you
Dr G 16:52
guys. Yeah, the system is rigged. That's that's entirely the point. Yeah, exactly. But
Dr Rad 16:56
they, they just can't get over it. Because they're like, they obviously had campaigned hard on behalf of their relatives. So like, we were personally campaigning, personally asking people for them to vote for our relatives, our son, our brother. Okay. How is this possible that after everything we've done for the people, it hasn't worked? And their conclusion is this strategy. There is no doubt about it. Aulus Sempronius Atratinus has done something dodgy, in fact, a fake election, someone called fake election here.
Dr G 17:35
I'm here to tell you that these results will not stand because they cannot. Somebody made them up.
Dr Rad 17:42
I was. So it actually, I laughed. And then I felt sad when I read this because I was like, Oh, my God, the fact that painful? Yeah, like fake elections is
Dr G 17:53
it's kind of like the oldest trick in the book, which is why you have to have a rigorous independent body overseeing electoral process. The only way to get it done right. Yeah.
Dr Rad 18:01
And to be fair, it's not that in the past, there haven't been people who have tried to fake elections or people who have successfully faked elections.
Dr G 18:11
Are you telling me that corruption is baked into the human condition?
Dr Rad 18:14
I just thought I should caveat that with the fact that I'm more sceptical of claims to fake elections, because I live in the age of Trump just in case anybody's listening to this in 15 years. And I don't for a second believe that elections in America have been faked. Like now. But I acknowledge that Sure. There have in the past been such things.
Dr G 18:36
Yeah, historically, there have been cases of fraudulent elections and, you know, not dissimilar to things that we've seen across the 20th and even the 21st century, in some situations, but not we would note in the US,
Dr Rad 18:51
yeah, I just think that Trump is a very dangerous person, and that's probably why it's not getting elected. God, God can only hope that it continues that way.
Dr G 19:00
Time will tell Yeah.
Dr Rad 19:03
political stance over
Dr G 19:07
Just a little excerpt on our own leftism again.
Dr Rad 19:10
You know, these days, I don't even think it's leftism, I just think it's called being sane and recognise, recognising a dangerous precedent when you see them, Ah judgments, judgments, judgments. Anyway. So unfortunately, the tribunes couldn't really do anything about this situation. They can't go after Atratinus. Not just because he's smugly, sitting there pretending that he's innocent, blah!, but also because he is a military tribune with consular power, and therefore his office affords him some protection.
Dr G 19:44
Oh, does it now. Well, he should have Imperium, but it doesn't mean that he's body's inviolable. Now somebody could run up to him and punch him in the face.
Dr Rad 19:53
If only someone would do that to Donald Trump. No, don't make him a martyr, leave him untouched. Anyway, so instead, the tribunes decide to go to go after Atratinus' cousin who is our old friend Gaius Sempronius from 423.
Dr G 20:17
When in doubt return to the guy that failed on the battlefield as if he hasn't experienced enough humiliation.
Dr Rad 20:23
He thought he got away with it but not this time. So they decided they're going to prosecute him with the help of another Tribune, one Marcus Canuleius for his conduct in the war against the Volsci. The Tribunes also decided they're going to bring up the way that the Senate is splitting up the public lands because Gaius Sempronius had always been against this – shocker. Against the splitting up of public lands in a particular way – what?
Dr G 20:57
Yeah, I mean, we're really playing into the stereotypes this year out, we goodness me patricians. What are you doing to yourselves?
Dr Rad 21:04
Well, the reason why they brought this up, it's very strategics. Very clever, actually very devious. They know that he's held this stance on public lands. And so what they're hoping is it'll be like a red rag to a bull. They're thinking he's going to either act a certain like he's going to a couple of ways he could either maintain his attitude that he's historically held, and therefore, piss off the plebeians, which will obviously probably not work in his favour with this whole prosecution thing, right,
Dr G 21:33
considering they're coming after him because they're already annoyed. Yes, yeah,
Dr Rad 21:37
exactly. Or he would back down on this issue, and the patricians would be like class traitor, and stop caring about him.
Dr G 21:46
I see the own political wedge. All right. Yeah. I'm excited to see which way he goes.
Dr Rad 21:52
Okay. So Sempronius decides that it's most important to do right by Rome. To hell with his own future.
Dr G 22:03
That is not revealing about what his stance is going to be
Dr Rad 22:06
okay. So you basically says To hell with my own future, I'm going to stick to my guns over the land issue. So he goes with Option A. He doesn't want the tribunes to get any credit for anything that they're doing here. So he points out that the tribunes actually have been very cynical themselves. They're actually care about the division of public lands. They're just using this to get him so he sees through their plan because he's also deviously clever.
Dr G 22:37
I mean, he would say that though, but historically, the tribune of the plebs have always been interested in land redistribution. So there's an easy comeback for that claim.
Dr Rad 22:46
I know. I'm like well, okay, like maybe maybe they are being very clever in the way that they use this issue. But there's a reason that they bring it up because you've spoken on this issue in the past. It is an ongoing issue, Sempronius. Anyway, so he decides I'm not going to be cowed. He says they can try all their dirty tricks, stupid tribunes. I think they're so clever. But I I am brave. I am patrician. I will not back down not for one second.
Dr G 23:17
A man's asking for a punch in the face.
Dr Rad 23:20
Exactly. Well, I mean, yes, but of course the patricians are just like we're falling even more in love with you. Sempronius
Dr G 23:27
Oh, no,
Dr Rad 23:28
I just gonna gaze into those cold, lacking in empathy eyes and
Dr G 23:34
be like, That's my man. That's my patrician right there.
Dr Rad 23:38
And he says the Senate should not value me or any individual so much that they aren't making the right choices for Rome. They should always be acting in Rome's best interests. Okay. So getting even more selfless by the second.
Dr G 23:57
Well, and there's a nice sort of didacticism built into that. I shouldn't say didacticism get all of my syllables out. Well, I'm gonna say something. Because part of what is happening here is this is kind of like a training manual for patricians, in some respect, this kind of source material, because it's, it's like, well, if you want to be in this very elite group, part of what you have to do is you have to decide what's best for Rome. And they don't make this sort of critical distinction that maybe what's best for Rome might also just always be what's best for them as as the elite, but this idea that somehow the way that you frame things rhetorically is around what is best for the city, and hence for
Dr Rad 24:42
everything. Yeah, exactly. So Sempronius then has to trot off to his trial. Let's see how this works out for him. So he decides to defend himself naturally. I mean, who could do a better job clever? Yeah. Although of course, this is not a is not necessarily super unusual in ancient Rome and standards like usually, if you're watching a television show these days, and a character makes a choice to defend themselves. It's either because they're a hero and a genius, or they're the villain.
Dr G 25:14
Yeah, they either know everything about the law and they gotta be fine. Or they do nothing about the the law and it's going to be a spectacular failure.
Dr Rad 25:23
I mean, obviously, as you say, we can't really speak to what's going on in room at this point in time in terms of exactly what it patricians education looks like. But if I'm using what I know from later on, he would be trained in public speaking, and he would have some experience with rhetoric. So
Dr G 25:38
he would Yeah, he would not only have that rhetorical training, one would assume but also be well versed in the laws at play. So that's part of that's part of the elite education if you like, so. Yeah,
Dr Rad 25:52
yeah, exactly. So the senators, of course, because they love him so much, because he's just been super honourable and selfless throughout this whole affair. As far as they're concerned. They tried very hard to soften the plebs up before a vote, you know, for his verdict is rendered, however, it doesn't work. Yay. And so he ended up being fined 15,000. mighty fine asses.
Dr G 26:21
Yes, a, it sounds like a significant sum, but it is. I guess. Maybe it is.
Dr Rad 26:30
A decent sum if we think that we don't sound like a reasonable amount of money to be fine. Yeah, it is a decent sum. If we think about we actually had a trial not that long ago, when again, when we were dealing with the aftermath of 423 in the spectacular mess that Sempronius made, there was another patrician who found themselves on trial, Postumius for his conduct in battle from a few years before 423. And he was fined 10,000 assets, so
Dr G 26:54
Okay. All right. So there's more it is this is this is upping the ante in terms of fining?
Dr Rad 27:00
Yeah, yeah, it definitely is. Anyway, so that is I hope the last we hear Sempronius Because he has been haunting us.
Dr G 27:10
He's had a rough trot these last few years. Yeah, I guess we'll he will have to pay his fine. Either that or he runs away to try and find a way out of it. Stay tuned.
Dr Rad 27:19
Yeah, exactly. Now, this is where I segue to a Vestals story, huh? Yeah. So thank you. Thank you. Yeah, so we've got a Vestal virgin being charged with unchastity and I'm not gonna say any more, I'm gonna let you tell me.
Dr G 27:37
All right, so our key characters at play here is the Pontifex Maximus, Spurius Minucius, and a Vestal virgin Postumia. So we can assume that she comes from the Postumius gens. So one of these elite patrician families, and that's fine. But she finds herself and we don't know, quite initially, like how that might happen. It doesn't seem to be attached necessarily to the other politics that's going on. But it is often the case that the way that Vestal virgins are treated, does link in to the other politics that their family members and gens colleagues are experiencing
Dr Rad 28:16
Well, funnily enough, I mean, we were just talking about whatever we do have a Postumius. Yeah, yeah. And he was just he was just found himself in trouble and was fine, like, not long before. And I actually think I think we were talking about the fact that it seems like there actually are some problems with the Postumius family, at this point in the republic in terms of they seem to be, I think it's them in and the other family that they're allied to, which I think is the Sempronii. Maybe it's one of them. But anyway, yeah, it seems like the Postumii and their their allies might have been going through a bit of a tough time and potentially been involved in some sort of rivalry for who's going to be the preeminent patrician ganz in Rome at this point in time.
Dr G 28:58
Yeah. And it seems like one of the things that can happen to Vestal virgins is that they get dragged into that broader politics, which makes sense. They're elite women, drawn from elite families, and they have a legacy of continuity, that is not the same as what happens for the male members of their family. So what we what we tend to see in the political arena directly is that people hold posts for about a year. They get brought in, they do their thing, and they flew back out again, and there's a new set of elections and some new patricians come in. Yes, and you can have repeats of people over the years, that's fine. But there is always a system of choosing them. Again, it's not like they have a legacy where they just keep going, not in this period of Rome's history, but for vestals. It's quite different because they're selected for ritual purposes. And even though ritual purposes is always sort of in a relationship with political purpose, their choosing is done very differently and The length of time that they're in their role is very different as well. So they're chosen quite young, between the ages of six and 10. And they serve for a minimum of 30 years in the role. And these are visibly public women in the sense that they have things that they are tasked to do that they have to be present in the public space for. And this is not to suggest that Roman women in general weren't in the public space. They definitely were. But people are expecting to see the Vestals at certain events, they have
Dr Rad 30:34
a they have an actual public role to perform. And then
Dr G 30:38
they're not just out and about doing some shopping or going from place to place and things like that, you know, they're, they've got a place to be, and I've got a task to do. And their relationship to the gods is an important one for ensuring the broader Pax deorum that Rome subscribes to, which is to be in right relationship with the divine. Yeah, and
Dr Rad 31:00
certainly compared to other elite women. And like, I think we can agree that obviously, the lower down the class you go, the less anybody cares, like what you do in terms of what that you know, how you're conducting yourself in public. But for our leet women of this time, it would seem that the ideal is for them to be quite circumspect with their behaviour in public and certainly to have a level of seclusion to their lives, in terms of who they're interacting with, what time of day, they're interacting with people and that kind of stuff.
Dr G 31:30
Yeah, definitely. And women sort of fall under the protection of their partner familiarise, generally speaking. So this means that those women are under the power of a broader father figure that might be their direct father, it might be the grandfather further up, whoever is the chief man of the family at that point in time, or is the oldest guy, but the Vestals it's a little bit different, because once they are brought into the Vestal virgin fold, they are removed from their natal family in a technical sense, which is interesting. But it's obviously an also an incomplete kind of process, because it's not like they changed their name or anything. They retain the name that is suggestive of the gins they belong to. So everybody knows which family they come from. Sure, but there's a sort of technicality where they no longer fall under the potestas of their pater familiarise. They now fall under the potestas of their Pontifex Maximus.
Dr Rad 32:27
Yes. Still a man in the picture.
Dr G 32:30
There's always a man in the picture.
Dr Rad 32:32
Yeah, certainly, as you've highlighted, particularly as we go later, in time in Rome's history, we still see them having family loyalty and being, as you said, being caught up in family affairs, and I checked it, it was the Postumius and the Quinctii that I was talking about. But yeah, as you say, they do still have those ties to their birth families. Yeah.
Dr G 32:56
Yeah, definitely. I mean, you can take the kid out of the family, but can you take the family out of the kid? So Postumia is going around doing her business, but she does find herself accused of this crime that's very particular called in incestum, which is often translated as unchastity, because we really don't have a good word to describe the semantic field, for incestum in English. Unchastity sounds unwieldy? And indeed it is. So incestum, this covers both sort of behaviours, it covers appearance, and there's a sense in which it ties into broader social concepts about morality, basically, and it's like, are you behaving in the right kind of way? Are you appearing in the right kind of way? Do you seem to have a modest connection between the way you are in the world and the way that people perceive you, and it sort of functions as covering everything from the thoughts of the person involved, to the way in which they behave with their body in the physical realm, right, so it covers all sorts of things. So in custom is often thought about as just being a loss of virginity, but it covers much more than that, okay. And we can see that instantly when it comes to Postumia, because what she's accused of is basically adorning herself in a way that suggests that, you know, she's a little bit open and free in her demonstration of her personality. She has she is described in Plutarch as having a ready laugh and over bold talk when she's in men's company. Now, it might be the case that she also has already laugh, over bold talk when she's in women's company, but the men aren't paying attention to that. So that's not what she's accused of. It may just be her personality,
Dr Rad 34:53
a woman having a personality I don't think so. That's not appropriate. Please put that away. Nobody wants to see it here.
Dr G 35:01
that personality, she seems to be having a good time at this party and I cannot abide by that something must be going wrong. Exactly. Yeah. So the other thing that she's got going on is that she has a push on for dressing attractively goodness knows what that means. Chances are she's just dressing the way that's comfortable for her. And much like in the modern day, a woman's dress does not tell you anything about what's going on with her personally. Not an invitation.
Dr Rad 35:30
Is she wearing a miniskirt? I don't know.
Dr G 35:33
I don't know. I don't know. But somebody's found her attractive and that this becomes her problem then because she gets accused of this crime of incestum. And the problem within custom is because it's it sort of covers everything from inappropriate dress, you know, being a little bit of a vivacious all the way up to lost virginity. The ultimate punishment for incestum is being buried alive.
Dr Rad 36:04
And oh my goodness, it seems like an overreaction to some red lipstick. I mean,
Dr G 36:08
For that mascara, you must die? Yes. Yeah, it's a real problem. The Romans, they sort of they go a bit overboard with this kind of stuff. So the problem from the Roman perspective, and the way that they sort of understand these things, is that if, indeed Postumia is guilty of incestum, that means that the relationship with the gods is not right. It has been severed in a particular way because her behaviour in the physical realm, the things she thinks, what she wears, how she does things, all of those sorts of things contribute to her maintaining her responsibility within that broader sense of the Pax deorum. Right. So there are six Vestals, they all have to behave as appropriately as possible from the Roman perspective of what is appropriate for them. And heaven forfend. You should have a ready laugh or some over bold talk.
Dr Rad 37:07
I do actually like the translation of the view that I was reading it says that she got into trouble because of her clothing as you've highlighted, but also the amazing freedom of her wit.
Dr G 37:20
Yeah, like she likes she likes a good sneaky joke. So yeah, I
Dr Rad 37:25
think this for me was like a code of if either you or Dr. G wherever transported back to ancient Rome to become Vestals, you would definitely die.
Dr G 37:35
immediately be buried alive. This is why you do not time travel. Okay.
Dr Rad 37:43
Yeah, exactly. Sounds like a great idea. But before you know it, you're in a chamber somewhere to to any station.
Dr G 37:49
Yeah, terrible, terrible. Yeah, she has apparently an easygoing character more easygoing than the fits a young woman. And so this accusation of in costume is raised against her. Now, the thing with these kinds of accusations is that any Roman citizen can make them. So it really doesn't take a Yeah, it really doesn't take much for them to happen. If somebody has decided that, you know, they've got an issue with your family, or they genuinely have a suspicion that, you know, maybe they've done something that they shouldn't have. Anyone can come up to the Pontifex Maximus and be like, Oh, gee, I don't know about that. Sheila. A. So that a little bit outrageous. Yeah, so that situation can happen. Anyway. I mean, the good news, yes. For Postumia Is that Spurius Minucius, the Pontifex Maximus, seems to be like a genuinely reasonable dude. And this is good news. So rather than finding her guilty, he does not. He takes the case to the Pontifical college. So there's a group of lower pontificates underneath him. They go and take the case to a vote. And they find in her favour.
Dr Rad 39:03
Yay. miniskirts? Red lipstick, here we go. Yes.
Dr G 39:10
Postumia wins the day. Yeah. Now unfortunately, there are some stipulations that they make to her on the result. She is no longer able to make jokes. Wow. She must abstain from jokes. No more of that.
Dr Rad 39:29
Just lay off right. Just lay off the comedy. Leave. The patricians and the plebeians. I mean, I think you can say that we're unintentionally hilarious.
Dr G 39:37
We know what's funny. You don't know what's funny. Class Warfare.
Dr Rad 39:41
That's what's funny. Yeah.
Dr G 39:42
You know, I think it's like the classic scenario where, you know, women in comedy have found it really hard to break through for a long time. A lot of stigma and his costume. Yeah. Postumia is on the front line of that being like but guys, I'm hilarious. And then like, I don't think so. No more. Yeah. The other thing is that she is asked to dress with sanctity rather than elegance.
Dr Rad 40:09
Oh, yeah, she has to put away the sexy clothes.
Dr G 40:14
Yeah, no more showing off the figure in a way that appeals to you. You must dress like you're wearing a hash and bag and preferably, just put on a hash and back. In fact, we've got one here, here it is. Go for it.
Dr Rad 40:26
And go for neutrals. You know, beige, beige, beige. We're all about the beige.
Dr G 40:31
Oh, we love a good beige. There's nothing that says like upper middle class aspirational than beige.
Dr Rad 40:37
Yeah, off white. Eggshell, ecru.
Dr G 40:42
I also kind of like what Plutarch has to say about this. So Spurius Minucius reminded her that the language she used should have no less dignity than her life.
Dr Rad 40:55
Oh, wow. That is a good one. I'm going to remember that actually, I'm going to use that against my students.
Dr G 41:04
Basically saying like, you're a Vestal virgin, you really have to act like one.
Dr Rad 41:09
Well, okay. Like, I mean, yes, I do understand that this, you know, certain standards of behaviour that are professional. But then again, when you consider that being a vessel is a 24/7 gig. And when you consider the kind of workplace requirements, it's like the fact that I find it increasingly ludicrous that all around the world, we force people to have these uncomfortable and restrictive unflattering office clothes. I mean, actually, I shouldn't say unflattering. Sometimes they are very attractive, but nobody likes to wear them. Why do we force ourselves to? Like there is no, I increasingly baffles me that we don't just dress to be comfortable, to be weather appropriate, and to be sustainable.
Dr G 41:55
This is like the, like the whole concept of the man's tie. Yeah. And it's like, like, I love a good 19th century career that, but yes, nobody can give me a good reason why anybody in the modern world has to wear the kind of ties that currently exist.
Dr Rad 42:09
I agree. Yeah, that's, I mean, I'm just like, Look, if people want to wear office wear, because that's their jam, go for it. But I will never understand why workplaces are like, Oh, no, you have to take this seriously. You really need to wear something made from you know, polyester and union. You know, you need to wear a suit, you know?
Dr G 42:28
No, I think this relates to possibly the distinction that has emerged over time that there is a dichotomy to be had between your private self and your Public Self. Yeah. And in a way, this ties in very nicely to what the Romans are doing throughout their whole sort of time as well. Because what Minucius is saying to Postumius, in this moment, is that actually, your job is a 24/7 job, being a vessel version is not about getting downtime, it is about always adhering to the principles that brought you into this space. So you joking around, and you wearing something that looks alright, is not doing the role justice. It is it is in fact, trying to bring something about your private self, if you like, into this public sphere. And we can't have that. So it's like, you know, she's now in a situation where I'm pretty sure what happens to Postumia just gonna write my historical novel. Now. Postumia starts, she does take up this advice, and she does curtail her Public Self, because we certainly don't hear about her coming back for another accusation of intestine, thank goodness. But I imagine she goes on with the body jokes. And she goes on with a dress ups in the safe space of the house of the Vestals, where she's hanging out with her sisters during the business.
Dr Rad 43:50
Well, one can only hope. I do understand that being a Vestal is I suppose, kind of like the way we think of certain professions as being a vocation, not just a job. And so I can kind of understand that the difference is, of course, that she was forced to take this position as a child before she was maybe able to fully comprehend the way that her life was going to, you know, be shaped and changed by this very lengthy commitment.
Dr G 44:21
Yeah, this is a massive commitment to take on. And it's one that invariably I would say, the candidates don't choose for themselves. It's about their physical ritual fitness to be chosen. It depends on them coming from an elite family. And if you're an appropriate candidate, and the time is right, that we need a new Vestal virgin, chances are, you're going to end up in a life situation that you did not choose for yourself, but happen to have been the chosen candidate for so the idea that Postumia might be railing against some of these pressures, just trying to be yourself and enjoy a little bit of life while she also has to do this thing that goes for years and is at is, is not surprising to me at all. And but I'm really pleased that Minucius allows that to be a disciplinary action rather than a live burial situation.
Dr Rad 45:13
Yeah, definitely. And look, I also should say, I'm not being naive here, I do understand that when you put on certain outfits, it does help you to get into a certain mindset. And I do also appreciate that whether we like it or not, humans are kind of superficial visual creatures at the best of time. So I do understand that there is a certain way that you present yourself, obviously, in certain scenarios, which are going to be expected whether you like it or not, I'm not naive, I just made I guess, it's because I because I work in a profession where we're quite active a lot of the time and our work is very unpredictable. And some schools I've been at not all schools, and certainly not the school that I'm currently at, very restrictive with what you're allowed to wear as a teacher. And it's kind of weird, because you're wearing these, like quite expensive, fancy clothes, when you're like running around, and you might be walking through mud, and you might be kneeling down all the time. And sometimes it just makes sense to have freedom of movement, and not to be worried about ruining these expensive clothes. And, you know, and and also, because I you know, because I'm a person that's very concerned about climate change, and that sort of thing, I'm increasingly a fan of clothing that is sustainable. And to me clothing is sustainable. It's clothing that you can wear in your private life and your public life so that you don't have to have so many clothes, and are also made from certain fabrics. So I guess that's why I'm a bit lighter. But I know that more more and more workplaces I know are being Freer with what employees can wear.
Dr G 46:40
And hopefully, if Postumia is ever coming back into this world reincarnated, she would be having a great time as well with a lot more freedom to express herself as she pleases and to wear whatever she wants.
Dr Rad 46:53
Exactly, exactly. I guess what I'm trying to say is that Postumia should be the woman I use on my logo for more sustainable workplace clothing.
Dr G 47:03
Done and Well, I reckon this is probably a good place to wrap up. Well, no. Oh, wait. Whoa,
Dr Rad 47:11
I do have a little bit to add to that. So as I said to you, when we spoke about the trial of Postumius and his colleague a few episodes ago from their own misconduct in battle, alleged misconduct, I should say, although I think Postumius was found guilty. So he can't sue me for saying that. We talked about the fact that there was potentially this rivalry going on amongst the patricians. And I just wanted to add that I was reading up a little bit on this. I said, I didn't read up on it, but I unintentionally did, I stumbled across something that that Postumii and the Sempronii were often very closely connected families through marriage. So whilst this Vestal case may seem to come out of nowhere and Livy's narrative, if we think about the fact that we've got Sempronius, who's had seen to escape prosecution earlier, now, he finds himself on the chopping block. If we put those cases together, it's possible that these families were being attacked. And what this also is reading suggested was that possibly what we're seeing is not only rivalry for like, who's the greatest patrician gens, like that, but that maybe certain patrician families are advocating particular policies. So for example, the Postumii may have been on the side of more aggressive expansion to Rome, whereas other families like the Furii and the Manlii, we might remember our families represented as military tribunes with consular power in this year. We're not as keen to to expand Rome at quite that pace. And in quite that way, so might be a matter of policies, I suppose. And factionalism, I think,
Dr G 48:56
yeah, I think family factionalism, we can definitely see as a an ongoing thread when festivals pop up in the narrative history. So thinking about what is that broader political context, which we've navigated very deeply or as deeply as we can give in our source material? Yeah. It seems to me like these sorts of things don't come out of nowhere. And the, the idea that the thing that they're the Vestals are accused of, it's always the same crime, and it's always a subjective kind of situation. So there's very, very few ways to be able to verify that an in custom has happened, you know, you've gone and done it and cast it. Oh, no. No, it's very, it's very hard to back something like that up with actual evidence. So you can see the political thread underpinning that kind of situation because it's a question That's always related to the idea of Roman morality, and particularly how it functions for women through that patriarchal lens.
Dr Rad 50:10
Yeah, definitely. And I think we can't obviously know for certain what exactly was going on within the patrician class at this point in time. We don't even know if there is really a patrician class at this time. But I think shining into what we've been talking about in the last couple of episodes about this idea that the idea that the Roman state really wasn't formalised at this point in time, if we go back to what you and I both alluded to, which is this theory that we've really just got, like warlords who have particular control over maybe certain areas, and they have clients and people who are loyal to them. And this is kind of more of a situation we've got going around rather than elections and consuls and that sort of thing. If we tie that together, I think we can definitely say whilst we don't know what they're fighting about, it obviously makes total sense that there is this constant rivalry because that's how I kind of warlord era works like, you might have kind of divided up turf between particular families. And there might be pieces of you know, there might be periods of stability. But there's also going to be those times when they you don't agree or you can't work together or you decide you want more.
Dr G 51:23
I gotta eliminate this whole family and all of their influence in order to increase my own.
Dr Rad 51:29
Now, I do have one final detail from Liddy for this year, which is a little side note that he loves to finish on these very anticlimactic side notes. Which is that the Greek control city of Cumae was taken by the Campanians.
Dr G 51:45
Oh, yeah, very interesting. So there was a Cumae in Italy. And it's on the West Coast, and it is in Campania. So this is all making sense. This is all this is supposed to be where the Sibyls are. The cave, the cave at Cumae, interesting power dynamics happening in the South.
Dr Rad 52:05
Yeah, well, I thought I'd give a little bit of background to this detail. Because I realised that I just sort of went Oh, yeah. But then I thought, actually, I don't really know what he's talking about. So I'm going to look up, look it up. So the Campanian region, as you alluded to, it is below where the Volscians are positioned. So it's a bit further afield, and the Romans generally then share with their military campaign. Yeah,
Dr G 52:27
you're thinking if you're if you're thinking modern Italy, you're thinking more Naples, and south.
Dr Rad 52:32
Exactly, yes. And this is like the region where Spartacus wreaks havoc eventually. But at this point in time, it's actually probably kind of like a more distant place for rowing, because they're really, really interacting with the people that are directly around them.
Dr G 52:49
And it's also on the other side of Volscian territory. So it's like, you know, in order to get there, you have to get through the Volsci, you and it's like, I mean, that's what's always a nightmare, because they kind of always up for a fight instead. So
Dr Rad 53:01
there have been these Campanian and Greek settlements to the south, really all the way back to in the ninth century. Right. That's when we started to see these, these peoples moving into the area and taking over. And it seems that they were even more powerful than Rome, in between the sort of ninth and sixth century. So we're talking about probably very early room like technically before, you know, the traditional date of 753. But that that period, yeah.
Dr G 53:31
This this region that is known as Magna Grecia has been continuously colonised by the Greeks for centuries before we see the rise of Rome further to the north. And so there is a sense in which there is the the native italic peoples and the Greek colonisers have been in this sort of push and pull with each other for quite some time in the southern regions of it.
Dr Rad 53:59
Yeah, absolutely. So that these areas are powerful in the sort of regal period of Rome's history, I suppose we'd say, and then we see a bit of a decline. And it's interesting because there had been, we think, actually relatively strong connections between the Etruscans and the people in Campania, even though they are in different regions. So it does seem to have been connection between them in this regal period of Rome, let's say. But then there had been two major events that had limited interest and power in Campania. And this is where we start to see I suppose the the gradual decline of the Etruscans as a major power in Italy. So one of them we have talked about, which is we going back to early republic, allegedly 505-504 There was
Dr G 54:50
five or five that is
Dr Rad 54:54
overhead occurred near Aricia where the Cumaens and the Latins were victorious against the Etruscans
Dr G 55:02
Interesting. Yeah, so this is where these are the kinds of stories that sort of really put into play this idea of like how far south were the Etruscans? And how independent are the Romans as a people from Etruscan culture? Because if the Etruscans and Cumae are fighting over Aricia like that is already more south than Rome itself. It Yeah, well,
Dr Rad 55:26
I mean this because it's true. The reason why I looked into this is because I remember that a couple of episodes ago, I also mentioned a takeover Capua. And atrocities have been mentioned in that story as well. So that's why I was like, I'm gonna look into this a little bit. Anyway, the other event was in 474. So again, still kind of earliest Republic, where a combination of Cumaean and Syracusan ships had won a battle against the Etruscans.
Dr G 55:52
Well, well, well. Syracuse is now in
Dr Rad 55:56
Syracuse. That's right. Yeah. So we start to see the limitation of Etruscan power in the south. And increasingly, we see Oscan influence. Now, I think we've probably mentioned Oscan, before, but
Dr G 56:11
we have we have so this is one of the italic language groups of Italy. And I, if I'm remembering rightly and maybe correct me on this, because I'm just going off the top of my head. I think the Oscan language is sitting to the
Dr Rad 56:27
east are correct. Yes. And it's generally most associated, I think, and again, this is off the top of my head. I think it's mostly associated with the Samnite people. That's correct.
Dr G 56:39
Yes, I think so. So
Dr Rad 56:42
and we still see traces of Oscan in in like Pompeii, for example, like when we look at the ruins, there are so often inscriptions in Pompeii. So it's definitely, as you say, a language group. And it definitely has deep ties to Italy, and the various people that live there. So it seems that if we look at the bigger picture for a moment, that what we're looking at, potentially in the for 20 years, and probably also to be honest, for decades before as well. a tonne of movement of people stopped to GE
Dr G 57:15
Hmm. There was a great movement and shift going on of people either pulling away as their power wanes, and then people coming in as their power starts.
Dr Rad 57:25
Yeah. And I mean, there's possibly a range of reasons why people are moving, but particularly we see we start to see the movement of people from the central app unknowns into the region of Campania. And this is this ties into the story that I told about Capua being captured in 423, which seemed to come out of absolutely freaking nowhere. But it's probably because we're so focused on Rome, that we're forgetting that there is this broader movement happening around Rome. And this will have an impact, of course, because one of the rooms, major entities on the horizon are the Samnites.
Dr G 57:59
Ah, yes. So I think part of this ties in nicely to some of the events that have come up in our narrative episodes previous to this one, where we've been looking at the way in which is a difficult climactic period, in Italy, where there's been a whole bunch of sort of failed harvests, there's been various pestilences come through. And this has really shaken up things. For the Romans, they've had some real problems around this. So if we take that as a broader sense of, there might be some like shifting, climactic interferences happening in the natural environment, that are changing the way that people are having to find food. In particular, if you're from a mountainous region, it's probably affecting you quite differently to people who live in a more Plains area where you can do a more sophisticated sort of harvest and organise sort of planting of crop and the mountainous regions. While you can do some of that you're more limited because of the geography. So if the consequences that are having these negative impacts for the people who are not in the mountains in these plains regions, are also affecting people in the mountains, it's going to lead to shifts of population as they have to find new sources of food, they have to find like food security is massive. So if you've got people who are awakening and power, part of that waning in power is directly tied to can we sustain a population in these regions? Or do we need to pull back? Yeah,
Dr Rad 59:32
absolutely. And this is the problem. We don't have enough information about exactly what is causing this movement of people. And we don't really know exactly what's going on. Because if we look at the written sources, from rooms perspective, we have the southern random mentions from Livy where it seems like it's a really violent takeover that happens, you know, sudden spurts or you know, there's a sudden moment where a city is captured and you know, That's the that's the way that it appears. But if we look at the archaeology, it seems like there actually wasn't really a sudden violent change where the Samnites suddenly came into power in this region, as you say, kind of to the east and a bit to the south, but actually quite a gradual shift, as we start to see more remnants with, you know, vestiges of often language churning up. So that's a bit of a sign there. And it's possible that what we're dealing with is, you know, any number of situations like it could be that there were issues in campaign Yeah, between an increasing Oscan populace and uninterested elite, okay, it could be that we're dealing with maybe an oppressed population fighting against their rulers, it's really hard to tell exactly what's going on between the Oscans, Etruscans and the Greeks and whether it's even anything to do with ethnicity at all. It might just be, you know, the, the class nature of it, and where we're dividing them up into the ethnic groups or the language groups or whatever. But certainly, it testifies to the fact that this is not just a tough period for Rome to go through, which we've mentioned before, but there are definitely some interesting and difficult changes happening in the broader Italian area.
Dr G 1:01:23
It's really fascinating, isn't it? Thank you so much for delving into that. That's a I think that's going to be good context for us as we move forward in time.
Dr Rad 1:01:31
Well, I never really thought about it cuz I was like, oh, yeah, that campaigns and then I'm like, wait a second.
Dr G 1:01:37
What do you mean Campania?
Dr Rad 1:01:39
Yeah, I suddenly realised that I actually, I probably should look that up. And the more I looked it up, I'm like, Oh, this is actually more complicated than I thought. Oh,
Dr G 1:01:48
good times. Good times. All right. We are at the official moment.
Dr Rad 1:01:55
It's time for the Partial Pick. Thank you Igor, not Dr. G impersonating Igor
Dr G 1:02:08
Igor is currently on leave.
Dr Rad 1:02:13
All right. So tell me what is the partial pick a little about?
Dr G 1:02:16
Oh, look, it is a great time, Rome can win 50 Gold eagles. There are 10 possible eagles in each category up for grabs. Our first category is military clout.
Dr Rad 1:02:31
Who know there's none of that going on in this episode.
Dr G 1:02:36
Yeah, we've got a lot of politics, but we don't have a lot of fighting. Such.
Dr Rad 1:02:41
Yeah. Purely domestic politics. You're all round. All right.
Dr G 1:02:45
Well, how about diplomacy?
Dr Rad 1:02:49
Hmm. I don't think so.
Dr G 1:02:53
I mean, it's kind of diplomatic of Minucius to you know, allow Postumia to not be buried alive.
Dr Rad 1:02:59
Okay. Okay. This is where I always get stuck. Yes. Okay. You could say it's diplomatic. But isn't diplomacy? I don't think so. I mean,
Dr G 1:03:07
I'm trying to help. I'm trying to help Rome out to get some kind of score really?
Dr Rad 1:03:11
Let Rome suffer. It deserves it.
Dr G 1:03:14
Didn't they put that guy on trial and charge him a whole bunch of these that diplomatic?
Dr Rad 1:03:22
Definitely no, decidedly.
Dr G 1:03:25
All right. All right. We shall move on. So far. It's zilch from two. Expansion.
Dr Rad 1:03:32
Again, no, you generally don't get expansion without military action. So very nice. What if they
Dr G 1:03:38
expanded their minds? I don't
Dr Rad 1:03:41
think that there's much evidence of that.
Dr G 1:03:46
Just what I try, just,
Dr Rad 1:03:48
I mean, I mean, sure somebody else is expanding. We've got this takeover q&a, but that's not the Romans.
Dr G 1:03:54
All right. Well, I you know, yeah. The Campanian is doing all the heavy lifting this year. Yeah, exactly. All right. Nothing for expansion.
Dr Rad 1:04:02
No, we're twos. No. I gave it long and hard thought. I mean, look, okay. I don't know how do we feel about Sempronius? I despise him. But that was a rhetorical but
Dr G 1:04:20
it is very weird to us, for the patrician to take the rest of rhetorical stance that he's going to be hard line for the good of Rome.
Dr Rad 1:04:31
It is Is it a thing? Is it weird to us or is it just
Dr G 1:04:35
attrition stubbornness at its finest?
Dr Rad 1:04:39
It is a patrician. It is
Dr G 1:04:42
more No, I know. I'm gonna I'm gonna say no, I was playing devil's advocate. It's okay. The answer is no, that's not weird to us. I think we chose also has to involve the physical in some way if the body is not on the line. I don't think we're really talking about we're towards here. I agree. I just thought a very specific type vibe. value within masculinity for the moments
Dr Rad 1:05:02
I'm fighting against my own bias against the patrician, so I want to make sure I am giving them the benefit of the doubt even though they are the Royalist of douchebags most of the time.
Dr G 1:05:17
So good. It's all good. So, our subtotal currently still zero. All right, so everything hinges on this final category. Absolutely. All right, the citizens school, was this a good time in Rome to be a citizen?
Dr Rad 1:05:31
It doesn't sound like the worst time in that we think about absence of evidence. Okay. So there's no military action going on. So even though we don't have anyone testifying that the citizens are doing cartwheels in the streets, it's gotta be a benefit to them that they're not, you know, risking death, risking destitution, that's got to be of us. Yeah, they're
Dr G 1:05:53
not suffering under a levy and then having to gather their equipment and head off into the sunset, never to be sure if they'll see their families again. It's a great time to be a citizen in that respect.
Dr Rad 1:06:03
You're not being treated terribly. Well done. Yeah, yeah. So there's that. But there's also the fact that guys Sempronius, is actually finally held accountable. Because I mean, look, I can understand that sometimes things just don't go the way they're supposed to when you are the commander. And it's not necessarily fair to put you on trial, just because it didn't work out in a way that you couldn't necessarily control.
Dr G 1:06:31
I do kind of love that the Romans do that, though, being like you failed the battle. That is a crime.
Dr Rad 1:06:38
behaviour was criminal, though, they're really I'm going to put you on trial.
Dr G 1:06:42
criminal negligence, I tell you, that's it.
Dr Rad 1:06:47
I believe our sources. And to be honest, I don't see why I wouldn't in the sense of Livy's, clearly on a patrician side 99% of the time. So if he is willing to say that Sempronius did not prepare for battle and was just like, if Fortuna will take care of it, then you know, what you actually are liable to that like that, actually, is criminal negligence. That's like the definition of criminal negligence. You just listen, you've just wasted everybody's time. You've also put a lot of people's lives on the line and cause death and heartache for people and their family. So yeah, you actually should be held accountable for that. So I actually think that this is a good thing. And the fact that the people aren't swayed by the Senate trying to sweet talk them. I think that's a positive. So I'm willing to maybe give a two for the citizen.
Dr G 1:07:42
Wow, all right. Yeah, I can't imagine it could even possibly get up higher than like, to me the maximum ceiling would be five, because it's not, it's not like things went really well. It's just that things didn't go badly. So I'm like, we're dealing with a glass half full or half empty situation. So five would be the maximum, and I'm happy to settle for two.
Dr Rad 1:08:06
Yeah. And I mean, actually, when you think about it, I mean, it's not great that no perbanas get elected. But you see Livy's puts the blame for that. On the for the audience. He doesn't tell I think
Dr G 1:08:17
I feel like that's misplaced and Livy's should know better. No,
Dr Rad 1:08:21
I know. But when you think about it, this is actually you know what, Livy's a frickin genius. Because when you think about the way he spun this narrative is artwork. He's first of all blamed the plebeians for not electing their own as quaesters because the consular relatives are just so amazing. They're falling all over themselves to get to the ballot box. When we fall know that if the if the voting system is anything like what we've got later on, or you know, anything like they say it's so it's totally us and whatever, set it up, as they are absolutely cut out of the voting system, if they are truly, you know, lower down. Now, look, there are wealthy beings out there. I know this is an entirely
Dr G 1:09:05
Yeah, but they're gonna be sued. But like best case scenario, they're sitting in one of the lower down voting groups, and they don't get a chance. I mean, they should be rising up and getting angry about that, but they have to change the whole system. It's not it's not enough to try and get somebody elected. And it's like, they actually need to overthrow the systemic issue in order and I can see how they're like, Okay, well, we need to get in there so we can change it. And the problem is that the system is designed to keep them out. So it's, it's a massive issue.
Dr Rad 1:09:34
I mean, it's genius, like the system designed to keep them out and yet it's their fault when their own candidates don't get elected. That's genius. Point number one. Second of all, living in sets this up as this is the excuse that the tribunes are using to go against Sempronius when actually he absolutely should have his ass nailed to the wall because he absolutely did the wrong One thing, he is a dick, and there's no getting around it like, and yet he set it up. So like, oh, the tribunes are being so diabolically clever, and they're totally using this situation, as you know this pathetic front for going against him when they absolutely should have prosecuted and when they had the chance previously, and I don't know why they didn't. And then to add insult to injury, it's Postumia fault that she's dressing inappropriately and laughing too much, Dr. G. So he is blaming Oh, did she have a good time? Yeah, if ever there was an episode, systematic unfairness, this is the
Dr G 1:10:39
thank you so much for listening to the partial historians where it's clear what our partiality
Dr Rad 1:10:45
is in the name Don't get mad.
Dr G 1:10:49
We did try to warn you we did.
Dr Rad 1:10:52
I just think it's actually it is actually artwork, the way that he's written this particular account reading against what he's telling me.
Dr G 1:11:00
Yeah. And I think it's really useful to come to the source material with this kind of mindset, because it encourages you to question why are we being told these things? And these are good questions for historians to always ask? And I'm thinking of you listeners, because you two are historians, if you approach the material with the with the critical questions in mind, that's doing history. So when you look at this sort of stuff, and you think to yourself, Well, why are they positioning it this way? Who is the real target audience here? Who is getting the benefit? And who is missing out on benefit? And how is that being leveraged against them? All of these kinds of questions really help you sort of see through some of the very clever rhetorical structuring that is at play.
Dr Rad 1:11:48
And that's the thing like if I were busy researching something, and I was just dipping in and out of Livy, like, you know, reading the bits that were applicable to me, as you do when you're researching, you don't sit there and read Livy covered a cover because you need a section of Livy, what I'm getting such insight into the academic process here, but you don't do that. So you dip in and out, right? If I were just to dip in, and I was on a deadline, and I was just researching this, I would absolutely just read that and be like, okay, yeah, that's what happened. Cool. But the reason why I kind of love the fact that we move slowly, even though I'm sure everyone's like, move faster.
Dr G 1:12:23
We literally can't, because there's too many things to analyse. So
Dr Rad 1:12:28
when you actually slow down and look at it year by year, you're like, Oh, my God, this is genius. I mean, the line that this thing is really set
Dr G 1:12:38
up a trap, haven't they?
Dr Rad 1:12:41
And you wouldn't necessarily question it, because it's just seems so matter of fact, it's just like, oh, yeah, they did that. And they did that. And look, obviously, I'm not saying that I'm right. I can't prove that I'm right, because it's a theory. But certainly, I think as you say, it's worth questioning why Livy has or who worked with, you know, whatever he sought before him was, Why have they position the events in this flow? You know, like, why, why have them connecting in this way? And why be attributing certain motives to people in this way. And I, personally, I think you can see our revenue only perspective at play 100% of the time in the year 420.
Dr G 1:13:22
I would agree humbly, based on the beautiful interpretation of Livy's that you've provided.
Dr Rad 1:13:33
Maybe I'm just too suspicious, but you know, what the hell, as you say, we need to go on the boat closer to nothing people are here for our takes on things.
Dr G 1:13:42
Well, it has been an absolute pleasure. I've been very excited to talk about some Vestal virgins, and to learn so much about the year 420 BCE from you, Dr. Rad. Indeed. I'll see you next time. Dr. G. Oh, and before we go, I'd like to thank our Patreons for their ongoing and beautiful support. You guys make this podcast even better than it already is. And so we appreciate that very much. And also, just doing a bit of a shout out for our book you want to hear about Rome and how it all began. We got you covered. We wrote a book on the Roman kings.
Dr Rad 1:14:18
We certainly did. There's lots of interesting things that happen lots of conquest, lots of phalluses appearing when you least expect them.
Dr G 1:14:30
Until next time.
Dr Rad 1:14:41
Thank you for listening to this episode of the partial historians. You can find our sources, sound credits and an automated transcript in our show notes. Our music is by Bettina Joy De Guzman, you too can support our show and help us to produce more engaging content about the ancient world by becoming a Patreon. In return you receive exclusive early access to our special episodes and some bonus content. Today we'd like to send a special shout out to our newest Patreon, Steve Roger space for Luzi domesticate and Maple Leaf Ozzy. You could also support us by buying us a coffee on Kofi. However, if all of these avenues are beyond your means, please just tell someone about the show or give us a five star review. Be partial! Until next time, we are yours in ancient Rome.
For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/
Support the show
Patreon
Ko-Fi
Read our books
Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome
Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
This episode we return to the ‘Golden Age of Hollywood’ with a classic sword and sandal epic, Quo Vadis (1951). This film is available through many streaming platforms and we highly recommend revisiting it.
In Part Two of two episodes on Quo Vadis, we delve into our analysis of the film. If you have not listened to Part One, you might want to check it out for the context.
Special Episode – Quo Vadis (1951) – Part Two
The Wars That Shaped the MovieHollywood loves a sure bet and MGM started working on their own adaption after WWII. The legacy of that war can be seen in the depiction of Nero and the Roman people. Nero seems to be a mixture of Mussolini and Hitler, and the use of eagles, fasces and the ‘Roman salute’ must have also dredged up unpleasant memories.
The newly emerging Cold War also had an impact on this movie, with the plot dealing largely with the clash of freedom (Christians) vs tyranny (Romans). The immoral, irreligious Romans could easily be seen as the ‘godless Communists’, whereas the Christians and converts stand for the American way of life. The film was made during the hunt for Communists in Hollywood itself. The first round of the House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC) had started in 1947 and round two was destined to begin in 1951. These were dark days for many in the industry.
Black and white portrait photo of Peter Ustinov as Nero in Quo Vadis.
He sits in a thoughtful pose and appears unhappy about something.
Source: Pinterest.
The head of MGM (Louis B. Mayer) and the male lead of Quo Vadis (Robert Taylor) were intimately connected with the HUAC hearings. Mayer had testified in 1947. Robert Taylor may not be a familiar name, but he was a massive star for MGM in the 30s and 40s. He was also known for his conservative politics and would be the only prominent Hollywood star to name names in front of the Committee. This might all seem to add up, but his testimony had just as much to do with his loyalty to Mayer, a fellow conservative, and MGM as his anti-communism.
Taylor had been forced by MGM and the Office of War Information to star in Song of Russia (1944), a pro-Russian film designed to promote friendly feelings about wartime alliance. Taylor had been dead against starring in the film in the first place, but he eventually went through with it so that he could be released by the studio to fulfil his military service.
Taylor's TestimonyTaylor was asked to testify in closed door sessions in front of HUAC early in 1947. He was quite frank regarding his political views, and Song of Russia might have come up. Taylor did not hold back as he thought this testimony would be kept private. When it was used to bolster the presence of HUAC, Taylor was less than pleased. Taylor and his wife Barbara Stanwyck were conservatives, but they did want to abuse their position as celebrities. They never wished to discuss politics in public again.
Black and white portrait photo of Robert Taylor as Marcus Vinicius in Quo Vadis.
He wears a Roman style military brestplate and gazes into the middle distance thoughtfully.
Source: Pinterest
Taylor would have to make one more notable exception on that front. Louis B. Mayer, like so many other studio heads, wanted to protect the movie industry. This was business, and with television on the rise and the 1948 ruling against studio-owned theatres, the ‘biz’ was facing enough obstacles in the late 1940s and early 1950s. They did not need the public thinking that Hollywood was spreading Communist ideology. More significantly, there is a distinctly antisemitic tone to the HUAC hearings, which must have made the largely Jewish heads of studios nervous, no matter how politically conservative they were.
Specifically, Mayer needed Taylor to testify a second time so he could back up MGM’s official line regarding Song of Russia. It was just a romance! Certainly not wartime propaganda…. HUAC also really wanted Taylor to appear again, purely for the publicity. They were correct: the press (and a lot of female fans) flocked to see Taylor’s testimony.
Taylor seemed to be uncomfortable when asked to name any suspected Communists in the industry. He was hesitant, but he did it. In the atmosphere of Hollywood at the time, Robert Taylor was celebrated by most for his patriotism. Whilst the best days of his career would soon be behind him after Quo Vadis and his testimony, this had nothing to do with his appearance before HUAC. However, these days, Robert Taylor is largely forgotten or remembered as a ‘friendly witness’.
Join us for our take on this rollicking ride through Neronian Rome and 20th century politics!
Sound CreditThanks to the fabulous Bettina Joy de Guzman for our theme music.
Our SourcesLygia and Marcus Vinicius posed against a pink and blue clouded sky. This looks like an official promo shot for Quo Vadis.
Source: ievenn
Dr Rad 0:18
Welcome to this special episode of The Partial Historians. I'm Dr. Rad and normally Dr. G and I discuss the history of Rome from the founding of the city. But today we begin a deep dive into Quo Vadis in 1951. We ended up talking for so long about this epic that we have split the episode into two parts. Seems appropriate given the original film had an intermission. This is part two of our coverage of Quo Vadis, in which we will focus more on our analysis, the film and its betrayal of history. We hope you enjoy this sword and sandal classic as much as we did.
So in a previous episode, we've covered the background and plot to quiver strategy. Let's now try and get a little bit more analytical and delve into the film in more detail. So I'm going to change gears a little bit dodgy because I feel like I had enough narrow for a moment. So first of all, I'm going to mention something which I have mentioned before when we've been talking about these films like “The Robe” and “Demetrius and the Gladiators”, we have to think about why Quo Vadis. Why now. And that is very much to do with the threat of a television you.
Dr G 1:34
Oh yes. How dare they don't watch things on the small screen when you could watch things on the big screen?
Dr Rad 1:40
Yes. So as we talked about before, the 1950s is going to be the era of the widescreen technology that is officially however, launched with the robe in 1953. Now Quo Vadis is a large scale film in the sense that it's long, it's saturated with colour and excess. It's the kind of thing that you're not going to get on a small square black and white screen in your suburban home. So it is the kind of film that Hollywood believes is going to encourage people to come to the movies. And they're right. Because they're really running scared because it's not just television, as I am sure I hope you've again mentioned before, it's also the fact that they have lost a lot of power in 1948. With the anti monopoly laws, were they the movies used to control everything, you know, from the production of the film to the editing to the distribution. And monopoly laws of 1948 means that they lose their grip on the distribution. Oh, no, yeah. And so that's a significant chunk of their business. They're really, you know, it's only a few years later, and this has been the model for quite some time. So they want movies like Quo Vadis, which they feel sure are gonna get people to come and watch them because that's how they're going to make them money. So that's a bit of the movie business stuff. Now, specifically, the context of the 1951 film being one of the earliest sword and sands films. I need to throw this at you. World War Two.
Dr G 3:10
Oh, yeah. Well, I mean, it's definitely a thing. I mean, it's over. By the time we get to this film it is and, like, there must be filming, I guess in 1950. So we're not far out. I was kind of surprised. But also like pleasantly surprised by just like, it's all on location in Cinecitta. And you can see from the shots in and around when they're doing sort of like chariot work and things like that. Yeah, they're definitely in Italy.
Dr Rad 3:40
And doing chariot work?
Dr G 3:42
Yeah, like Mediterranean pines, like they're definitely in the right place. They're on location.
Dr Rad 3:48
Yeah, definitely.
Dr G 3:49
It's pretty impressive.
Dr Rad 3:50
Yeah. I mean, look, they're often parallels drawn between Roman emperors and the dictators of the 20th century. However, this film, I think, more than most was, I think, trying to lean on that. Okay, I think that it's meant to be a bit of a weird blend of both like Mussolini, the fascists, and also the Nazis that we see here. Because the Nazis, of course, had been very anti religion. So I think you can kind of see the persecution of Christianity that's happening here and the seeming decadence of Rome as being you know, tying into that a little bit. But also, of course, Mussolini himself had tried really hard to draw a connection between his Rome and the Rome of the ancients. How awkwardly phrased was that
Dr G 4:40
Ancient Romans and the modern Italy usually were Yeah,
Dr Rad 4:44
yeah. So the point where he put on an exhibit in 1937, called the Augustan exhibition of the Roman spirit. So he was really dwelling on that. And she had she had her course also had been constructed by Mussolini. So there's an age interesting parallels there. Obviously, there's a lot of Roman symbolism which the fascists use, like the eagles and the fasces. And they think the salute, although that's been pretty much debunked by Martin Winkler as being a bit of a misunderstanding.
Dr G 5:15
Yeah. But the Roman salute that's given in this film is visually resonant. Like there wouldn't be many audience members who, who hadn't seen some Nazi propaganda, you'd be like, oh, oh, I see what you did there.
Dr Rad 5:28
Yes, exactly. Yes. And there's also a very clear accent divide as often is the case in these films we've talked about so a lot of the heroic Christian freedom fighting liberty loving characters are American. And the evil people, evil imperialist bastards. British. So of course, we have Peter Ustinov playing, or very memorably playing the role of Nero, whereas we've got people like Robert Taylor, very American, playing the heroic person. Now, I know he is a Roman character, but we know he's all you can.
Dr G 6:07
You can tell from his accent that he's going to switch sides.
Dr Rad 6:09
Exactly, exactly. And then the plan that Nero outlines the way that he says he's going to kill all the Christians is very Hitler-esque, in that he says, he's going to eradicate them from the face of the earth to the extent where people will doubt they ever existed.
Dr G 6:28
Yeah.
Dr Rad 6:29
Yeah. Which is creepily like a genocidal plan. And also the model of Rome that you mentioned. So you know, you said that Nero was going to burn Rome to the ground and rebuild it.
Dr G 6:40
Well, there is a model displayed in this film.
Dr Rad 6:42
Yes, yes, yes. And the shot of Nero standing over, I think, was very much meant to recall shots of Hitler, looking at Albert Spears plan for Germania.
Dr G 6:55
Oh, interesting,
Dr Rad 6:56
like the New Berlin
Dr G 6:57
because I was really interested in the map of Rome itself, because I was like, the reason map, there is a 3D map of Rome, right? Yeah, that looks very much like this model. And I'm wondering if it's the same one, and I haven't been able to, I haven't had enough time to look into that.
Dr Rad 7:11
I actually probably could have found the answer for you if I had known beforehand, but I forgot to check that out.
Dr G 7:17
But I'm fascinated. So I'm gonna keep investigating that.
Dr Rad 7:21
Yeah. And they're all these lines that Nero delivers throughout the film, which I think are really playing on those Hitleresque sort of things like he says to Petronius at one point, the world is mine and mine to end. Oh, yeah. And also we know that he is someone who has murdered his own father. So we already know that he is a monster. And therefore he from the beginning comes across as a tyrant like he's obviously very amusing because it's pretty used. But he is meant to be a monster. But
Dr G 7:57
I think there is something amazingly believable about Ustinov's performance, though, which
Dr Rad 8:02
Oh, yeah.
Dr G 8:02
Which makes this film stand out, as opposed to some others where the Imperial figure is designed to be the ultimate bad guy. Yeah. But is played in such a way as to not make it sympathetic enough to believe that a real human could be that way. Yeah, was something about Ustinov's performance is very naturalistic in the way that you like you can you get the sense that this is a mind that is maleable, that that he has particular drives and he's trying to figure out how to best bring them to life?
Dr Rad 8:37
Yes.
Dr G 8:37
And he doesn't conceive of himself as evil he conceives of himself as misunderstood.
Dr Rad 8:43
Yeah and also that idea of him having to be like on a larger scale again is almost not to like yeah,
Dr G 8:51
He sees himself as removed from the common people in part because the position that he has to fulfil is like as Emperor, I have this kind of duty to be very different from everyone else. So we talked a lot about how things have to be uncommon.
Dr Rad 9:05
Yes, I was gonna say I actually have the exact quotes I think it's such a good one Peter Ustinov says I seek because I must exceed the statue of man in both good and evil I seek because I must be greater than man for only then will I be the supreme artists, let it be wonderful. Or let it be awful so long as it is uncommon? Yeah.
Dr G 9:29
This this is incredible sort of rationale in that Yeah. Which is I think if it was just read off the script, it might not you might not buy it. It's like it's very much the performance of Ustinov that brings back
Dr Rad 9:42
He's just yeah, he's performance stands the test of time, but you can't always say about the circumstance. But yeah, the whole idea and the way that the other characters talk about the Christians like prepare saying, give room not one victim but hundreds. Who are these people, they just spies, our temple and our gods, they prophesied that the end of the world shall be caused by fire. Well then let it come true. Let it in for them, like it is that kind of idea of like scapegoating people, just like the Nazis do with the Jews, like it's all very creepily there. Yeah. And also, then you've got Petronius coming in, of course, and being the warning of history, you do this, you make the murders, and you will suffer for it, which, of course, is exactly what has happened in your he has to be particularly bad reputation, because I think he has been seen as like the Antichrist, or at the very least an enemy of the Christian people, which for, you know, subsequent civilizations which pride themselves on being Christian, doesn't make you a good guy. Now, gender is something I thought you might like to talk about a little
Dr G 10:52
Oooh,
Dr Rad 10:52
yeah. And that also ties in with World War Two. So tell me, what do you know about women's role during World War Two?
Dr G 11:00
Oh, women's roles in World War Two? Well, my understanding is and correct me if I'm wrong.
Dr Rad 11:05
Yeah.
Dr G 11:06
Is that because the men were away fighting? Yeah, it was incumbent upon women to really get behind the war effort in ways in which they possibly wouldn't have been the first in line for if there was a non war time. So you have this shift of women into the workforce in different ways. It's not the case that women weren't working before the war. They definitely were. But the kinds of jobs that women were asked to do, or put themselves forward to do because the labour was needed. It was now all across the board. Yeah. And it was kind of like, if it had to be done. It had to be done. Yeah. So you know, the pictures of women on factory lines was not something that people were used to, but it's something that definitely happened during the war, for instance.
Dr Rad 11:49
Yeah, absolutely. And that's exactly how we need to say these sorts of films, and Quo Vadis is no exception, this idea that women had stepped up, gone into these roles, which were unusual. But now the men were back back to the private sphere with you, missy? Yeah. So it's this idea of, I think, women as domesticate the need to have stable families. So Romans very rarely, in the 1950s and early 1960s have stable family. They're generally somehow twisted, like, for example, mentoring your mother like Nero does, or can the wife as Nero. It's the kind of you know, the cheating, the adultery is all that kind of stuff that the Romans partake in. And it's this idea that will the the core of 1950s, America has to be proper Christian religious sentiment, family, and domesticating. femininity, and I am quoting directly from someone who I will reference in our sources.
Dr G 12:50
Ah domesticating femininity.
Dr Rad 12:55
Yeah. Yeah. So good. Women are shown as domesticating influences I see. Yeah. And they need to find someone to pair up with and convert.
Dr G 13:05
Well, well, well, Lygia, step forward.
Dr Rad 13:09
Yes, exactly. Here is obviously classic. She's an entirely fictional character, obviously, for all the others adaptations. The interesting thing is, though, that there is a bit of a remnant of those women that didn't want to go back into the private sphere after World War Two with literature, because in the 1950s version, she has moments of being kind of feisty, and knowing her in mind, which in the novel, she is not, she's entirely passive interest. Yeah, she just does what she's told to do by either her parents, her adoptive parents, or Vinicius or whatever. She's really just like a chess piece to be moved around. It's about possessing her obviously.
Dr G 13:48
Okay, so she's been slightly rewritten for the 1950s audience.
Dr Rad 13:52
I think so. Yeah. Like they they know that you don't want someone who's a complete pushover. But the values that she stands for, nonetheless, like,
Dr G 14:01
well, actually, this kind of makes sense. So she gets accused of like, you know, filling your head with philosophies and things like that. Why would you do something like that? But that's also Yeah. Well, it's kind of also the thing that happens to you, you have this sort of like, narrative of the 1950s. And particularly in America, where it's like, Sure, by all means, go to a good school and get an education but like your number one priority is to settle down with a husband and have some children. Yeah, so like, by all means, get that degree, but hidden for fun if you would attempt to use it.
Dr Rad 14:33
Yes. For anyone who wants to get a vibe for what he is talking about. Mona Lisa smiles, excellent.
Dr G 14:41
Also Mad Men, which I know is very rude now, but I still love it.
Dr Rad 14:45
Yeah, no true true true. Now bad women, of course, are the kind of women that want public power.
Dr G 14:50
Oh, I love Poppaea this film, though. Yes. So you know she enters with two cheetahs on a leash
Dr Rad 15:00
Like Bad Girl table of one
Dr G 15:01
Oh glorious. And you know, it's like it's all the makeup. It's the dress. It's the it's the sultry gaze. It's the one of the things I notice from a cinema cinematography perspective. Yeah. Is that Lygia is tends to be always shot on the three quarters. You don't get front on shots because I was like, what is it? I just want to know what Deborah Kerr's nose is like from the front, you know, but I do
Dr Rad 15:32
You'll have to watch “An Affair to Remember” to get that.
Dr G 15:35
Definitely, I would didn't get it in this film. But Poppaea is often shot front on
Dr Rad 15:39
Yeah,
Dr G 15:40
and there's a real so there is choices being made artistically about how these women are shown. And the angles that you get of them, to sort of set them apart from each other as well because Poppaea is front and centre. Next to Nero in public. But also somebody who is given space to be a decision maker about certain things. So she does make decisions publicly.
Dr Rad 16:05
Yes.
Dr G 16:06
And people just go along with it. And it's not like she defers to Nero, when she does that.
Dr Rad 16:11
No, and that's exactly she's meant to be obviously showing, like, this is what happens when not only women want public power, but when they get it, it's terrible. They don't know how to exercise it properly. They should be focusing on me why?
Dr G 16:25
She's like, ridiculous, get over here.
Dr Rad 16:29
But this is, you know, this is the thing about how passive and so Poppaeas Sabina is a real person, obviously, like Nero, or she was a real person, I should say.
She is a historical figure. She is a historical figure.
And I feel terrible, that she always comes across so badly, because she's a murder victim, guys. She's a victim of domestic violence. Yeah, what really happens to her is that Nero supposedly loses his temper and kicks her kicks her in the stomach while she's pregnant with their child, and she dies because of complications to do with that injury. I mean, added to that way to go. Now, look, the sources are not kind to Poppaea Sabina either. So I'm not saying there's not some basis. I think, I think Sienkiewicz did his research. You know, I think he read up about this. And I think the best way to sum this up is this little line from Tacitus. This is what he says about Poppaea. She was a woman possessed of all advantages, but a character.
Dr G 17:26
Oh snap.
Dr Rad 17:28
yeah, exactly. And so he goes on and on about how awful she is in that she's beautiful, and she's witty, but she is depraved and gives into luxury. And she sleeps around and all that kind of stuff. So look, all of that may be true. Whatever I get it. It's not what the Romans are looking for in wives either. But part of the also wonders how much of this has been exaggerated, because Nero is a bad guy. And we know that when you've got a bad guy, he must be not controlling this woman properly. He's hassled, you know, in disarray. He'll be associated with a woman who has all the stereotypical bad qualities.
Dr G 18:08
Yeah, this becomes part of the political invective that you level against. Right? Yeah. And so part of the way that you bring him down is to bring down everybody who is connected with him. So there is no way it's very tricky, I think for somebody like prepare to be able to come out well from this, particularly when the previous wife Octavia has had was so publicly popular. So people even in the historical record, following Nero aren't willing to openly criticise her because, by comparison, she was the bee's knees.
Dr Rad 18:42
Yeah, and in all the ways it will for all the reasons that near apparently find her boring was that she was loyal, dutiful, quiet, just went about her business, like being private, not in public, you know, no ambition, that kind of stuff. So yeah, anyway, look, I just thought I had to mention that. So there's a bit of like, World War Two gender stuff going on. Also for the men. I think it's no accident. Again, we often talk about the issues with masculinity that are shown on screen and these sorts of movies. And I think it's no accident that Peter Ustinov Nero is highly effeminate in the way that he's played, whereas Robert Taylor, our hero, super masculine, yeah, willing to be domesticated. So it's kind of almost like how the soldiers come home from World War Two and the woman's like leaving the literary crap at the door. You're entering the domestic sphere now baby. So all about, you know, pumping out the little ones and putting up white picket fences.
Dr G 19:37
And there is a moment later on in the film where Vinicius kind of has a realisation that he was being pretty boorish at the start of the film.
Dr Rad 19:46
Yes, exactly.
Dr G 19:47
So there is a sense in which that narrative is being perpetuated and they've sort of put him into a bit of a domesticated situation and he's agreed to go along with it because, well, you know, Lygia, she is just so freakin hot. Yeah,
Dr Rad 20:02
Deborah Kerr as in star. Okay, so the other bit of context that we have to mention and I think I know we mentioned this is all these sorts of movies is, of course, another war Dr. G, but the Cold War
Dr G 20:14
Ah, feel that shiver in the room.
Dr Rad 20:18
It's not getting hot in here.
Dr G 20:21
I'm putting on more clothes even as we speak.
Dr Rad 20:23
Yeah. Now I'm just gonna very briefly mentioned that of course, you've got the classic freedom versus tyranny dichotomy going on in this film, which is exactly how President Truman had explained the situation that America found itself in 1947. So it's no accident. And of course, in 1950, when Quo was being shot, as you mentioned, this is where we see the ramping up of the anti communist crusades within America, the second red scare 1947 had been the first round. That was when we had the Hollywood 10. People like Dalton Trumbo being on trial, but because they did string out their defence for such a long period of time, and it put everything on pause, and so no one else had really been charged. But 1951 is when we're really going to see that whole more classic, I think, better known part of the second Red Scare taking place, which is where you see a lot of people go down. You see a lot of people doing the whole naming names or not naming names.
Dr G 21:27
Yeah. Well, I mean, on naming names, I mean, that feeds in quite nicely to ideas about the deletores in ancient Rome. Fun. Also, there is this film does a very good job of having the people which could be construed through a communist lens, if you wanted to. Yeah, really quite far removed from anything that's going on. Yeah, they kind of at the peripheral, and we only see them through the perspective of Nero. And essentially, yeah, they're a mob. And again, I think it's meant to be very Mussolini and Hitler is key. Yeah. But any, there's no focus on like farming or like the idea of like, well, a quasi proletariat that emerges out of the agrarian society, you know, all of those sort of, like classic elements of Yeah, that could build a foundation for a communist narrative within a Christian narrative. Yeah. None of that is happening.
Dr Rad 22:23
They were very self conscious about it. The 1951 campaign book for Quo Vadis, said, this movie, the fact that was being made, it's basically like the world could well use the message of quo and the dark days are threatening us. The storyline cries out a creative non violence and adjust resistance to a godless aggression. Take that Stalin. Yeah. So whilst whilst Nero was meant to be somewhat, I think Mussolini and Hitler. So there's also these stolen Soviet things happening.
Dr G 22:55
Take a bad guy, put your Nero on stage and you're done and dusted. Yeah.
Dr Rad 22:59
And again, very briefly going to mention of course, this comes back to the fact as well that religion in this time period for America, it's a patriotic thing. It's about American godliness triumphing over the godless communists.
Dr G 23:15
Yeah, it is one of these really interesting characteristics of 20th century America, where the there's a tacit freedom of religion, like it, or maybe even a spoken freedom of religion. But when they embrace religion, it is very much a very particular type of Christianity. And that Christian symbolism is imbued into a lot of their public symbolism.
Dr Rad 23:41
Yeah and I think I think it's also worth mentioning with Quo Vadis, in particular, that Robert Taylor, and Louis B. Mayer, who was the MGM chief executive, and MGM made this film were both friendly witnesses, which basically means that they volunteer their information. And we're very cooperative in supplying details about the inner workings of Hollywood for the committee, and they both had got involved with us and testified really early on in 1947.
Dr G 24:12
He's not so good looking to me now.
Dr Rad 24:14
I know. So Robert Taylor, I'm gonna tell you a little bit about Robert Taylor.
Dr G 24:16
Yeah, please.
Dr Rad 24:17
So he was part of this right wing group called The Motion Picture Alliance for the Preservation of American Ideals. They had been the ones that had actually invited the house on American activities to come to Hollywood and investigate Hollywood specifically because they were worried about his communist propaganda and co working in the industry. So Robert Taylor is a part of that. Now, Louis B. Mayer, I kind of feel like he's one of those guys. I've talked about in a previous episode, where I think he's just concerned about like, protecting his business.
Dr G 24:50
Yeah, fair enough. Things have gonna run guys.
Dr Rad 24:53
Yeah, absolutely. Now, Robert Taylor was married to Barbara Stanwyck. Okay, now they share had an interest in conservative politics?
Dr G 25:02
Well, I mean, it's a solid foundation for our marriage, I suspect.
Dr Rad 25:06
Yeah. He's the only big studio star to name names in an open session to HUAC.
Dr G 25:13
Wow.
Dr Rad 25:14
Yeah. And they use his initial testimony to publicise your work. And Robert Taylor had no idea that this was going to happen. He was furious about this basically, like, basically,
Dr G 25:28
Did that ruin his career?
Dr Rad 25:29
No, but I don't think I don't think he's a well known name. Now, let's put it that way. Yeah, certainly, he just wants out of politics after this, but he kind of has no choice because he is a studio star and MGM is like, you are going to testify, they specifically want him to testify in order to present a strong front with Mayor about this film they had made called the song of Russia. Now that was made at the time when the alliance between the allies and Russia was first being formed to try and promote this, you know, during World War Two.
Dr G 26:08
So he's got a vested interest in perhaps coming forward and coming forward openly. In order to counterbalance some of that, I think he
Dr Rad 26:15
was incredibly reluctant to name names. And yet he is kind of forced into it. The sad thing is that his appearance was a massive deal. And it's possible that these 1950s HUAC hearings became a big deal, because of Robert Taylor, because he was a big star at the time.
Dr G 26:32
Wow.
Dr Rad 26:34
So I just thought that was worth noting, because whilst we've talked about some of the other Cold War connections to some of the other films, the fact that this one comes about at this particular time with these particular people.
Dr G 26:46
Yeah, really, really interesting.
Dr Rad 26:48
Yeah. I mean, obviously, like we're talking about 1951 hearings that yeah, obviously being the year of release of Quo Vadis but it would have been filmed before then, but I think everyone obviously knew that HUAC was in their midst because of the Hollywood 10. So yeah,
Dr G 27:05
yeah. It's not necessarily something that's clouding the performance of actors in this film with each other. But it's definitely going to have an effect after
Dr Rad 27:13
I yeah, I just I just think it's it makes I think Quo Vadis, even more interesting to me contextually, like this kind of stuff. And I, I kind of feel sorry for Taylor in a way that you know, you wouldn't expect me to necessarily because I hate people who name names. I hate people who are on the right. Politics. Now. I shouldn't say I hate right wing politics. But yeah, I kind of feel like his. He's often a person, you'll see, as you'll hear, like a soundbite from him, or you'll see an image of him testifying. And you don't necessarily have the nuance of exactly how his appearance came to be in front of us exactly how he was used. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Because it seems like something he would do. But he I'm not saying
Dr G 27:53
But there might be some more complications.
Dr Rad 27:54
I think it's the more complicated factors there. So yeah, I just thought that was interesting, given him being the title role and all so yeah. Anywho, you want to talk about Nero?
Dr G 28:03
Nero. Yeah. Look, I mean, there's a lot of things that you could say about neuro in this film. And I mean, I've said some of those things already, in terms of like the performance and stuff like that. I think this is the kind of film it's off the same sort of stature in my mind as something like “I, Claudius” in the way that it kind of sets people up to think that there is a very simple read for this period of Rome's history. And it's because the performance is so good. Yeah. And because the things that happened, some of these events are verifiable. That was a fire in Rome. It did happen during the late period of Nero's reign. He did have a rebuilding programme. There are some sources that benefited. Definitely, there are some sources that talk about his connection with the Christians. Yeah. All of that is true. Yes. Now this narrative, this particular film makes it seem like there that is a really smooth story that we can understand Nero and his reign and how it comes to an end. And I would urge you, as a human with an interest in history to keep in mind that this is a film that is so persuasive. But there are some real questions to be asked about the source material for this period and what they might be trying to do with Nero. He is the last of the Julio-Claudians. This is an end point in the first dynasty of Roman imperial power. Yeah, it has ended badly. There's lots of good reasons for it ending badly and there are a lot of people with their noses out of joint by the way that the Julio-Claudians have developed over time, so there's lots of people in a position to write really negative histories as well. And that some of the source material that is survived and come down to us.
Dr Rad 30:05
Yes.
Dr G 30:06
Does this mean that he was terrible and all bad? Probably not. But the stories that we do have a pretty horrifying I don't think I'm not going to excuse things like domestic violence, which leads to complications of a pregnancy which leads to death. You know, all of that is terrible. But this film does make it an easy package to swallow and just be like Nero was this crazy manipulative human being. And we that's all we can say about him.
Dr Rad 30:36
Yeah. And I completely agree, because this is the thing I agree with you I don't think Nero probably was a great person, let's face it. He grew up with a mother who was probably quite rightly traumatised, and paranoid. He grew up in a family that was even worse. And he was only a teenager when he came to power. And whilst teenagers weren't really a thing in ancient Rome, I certainly don't think his brain was fully mature.
Dr G 31:01
They do have a classification for the young man as a young person the “adulescens” which teenager sort of comes out of that string. And that that isn't a period that goes up to the age of 25.
Dr Rad 31:01
Yes. Is that as I mean, the Romans know that youth equals trouble.
Dr G 31:15
Yeah, they do see them as useful. And they position them as such. And certainly, all of the Republican positions are set up to be open and available to people who are beyond that age group.
Dr Rad 31:28
Yeah, absolutely. But this exactly, I think, yes, I think there was a problematic person. I think some of the stuff that's come down to us is most likely true, like the fact that he was behind the murder of Agrippina, and that he probably was responsible for the death of Octavia and Poppaea Sabina.
Dr G 31:45
It's just good politics, isn't it? Yeah. Gotta get rid of them rivals.
Dr Rad 31:49
However, as you said, there is this intriguing snippet from Josephus, where he says, there have been a great many who compose the history of Nero, some of which have departed from the truth of facts out of favour, as having received benefits from him, while others out of hatred to him and the great ill will which they bear him have so impudently raved against him with their lies that they justly deserve to be condemned. So seeming to imply that there were positive accounts out there, they weren't necessarily any more trustworthy, but they were there. And like, the fact that none of this seems to have come down to us is staggering. So definitely, I think there were some people who were more in favour of Nero, the people of room seem to have been a bit more fond of Nero than I think the elite of Rome were.
Dr G 32:36
Yeah. And this is something that the film tends not to capture yet is he does seem to have been quite well loved, for most of his rule by the people of the city, not necessarily the leads, but like the man on the street kind of thing. Yes. And definitely he's rebuilding programme, or post fire. Yes, does a lot of sort of accommodation of people who have lost their homes and things like that. So there are elements of good leadership mixed in amongst the the horror stories. And yeah, the political mayhem.
Dr Rad 33:09
I think he was basically a very selfish person, which is no big surprise, and not particularly dedicated to rule at a time when Rome really needed him
Dr G 33:21
and also somebody who's probably not that trusting now, given the situation that he's grown up in, been surrounded by his whole life. So you know, somebody who is naturally suspicious.
Dr Rad 33:21
I mean, he's his own father, supposedly, ran over children in the street just kicks. So yeah. But again, you don't know whether that's actually true, or whether that's just trying to trash talk his reputation, because Nero turned out to be so horrible, but again, you gotta wonder, like, has to come from somewhere. But definitely, I think it's worth mentioning when we talk about a film like Quo Vadis. Our sources are actually fairly clear, I think, at least in terms of reliable sources that Nero was not responsible for the fire.
Dr G 34:02
No, the evidence suggests he wasn't in Rome. So the film does get that right interestingly.
Dr Rad 34:08
Yeah, he's not personally responsible.
Dr G 34:10
You didn't Yeah, he wasn't there, like, you know, with a little match, throwing it onto the bonfire. But he wasn't there. So it seems unlikely. Also, despite the fact that there's this building programme afterwards, I don't think there are many people who believe that they he anticipated the fire or created the fire in order to produce this buildingwork. Well, yeah. Like there's plenty of space already. If he buys a private property on the Palatine to do the kinds of things he wants to do.
Dr Rad 34:40
Yeah, again, I think he's just a bit selfish in the way he goes about some of the rebuilding, and therefore it makes people suspicious, which does make him turn to the Christians are scapegoats. Like that's one thing that yes, you can say, yep, Nero deserves to be blamed for that. Again, the sources I think, are fairly clear that he does pinpoint the Christians as a group that he can target because nobody
Dr G 35:01
cares about them. Yeah. And this is political expedience at its worst. Yes, exactly.
Dr Rad 35:07
Although he's so horrible to them. I mean, I believe one of the punishments is that, and again, it's kind of like that poetic justice things that the Romans like every now and then he likes the city of Rome by setting the Christians on fire.
Dr G 35:21
Oh, yeah. So like, this is like the classic source reference where it's like, you know, he lights up Rome with Christians bodies. Yes. Yeah. And that's pretty disgusting. If true.
Dr Rad 35:31
Exactly. Like it could be exaggeration, of course, or whatever. But certainly the idea that people I think it testament says, Look, nobody really cared about the Christians until Nero started to persecute them so horribly. And well, then people started to go, Hmm, that is really awful, even by our standards, so I don't think they were like, Oh, we love the Christians. But it's more the idea of people started to feel even more simple. People started feeling sympathetic.
Well, they suddenly registered that these people were around to being like, Oh, I didn't know that they were here. They were really copying. That doesn't seem okay.
Yeah, definitely. So I thought one final thing I might end on finances very long episode. But such a long movie. It's so hard not to just like
Dr G 36:14
we're not even up to the halfway point of the film yet.
Dr Rad 36:17
Yeah, I know. I thought we had to also maybe register, maybe Petronius. Yes, as a real figure. And I also wanted to highlight Lygia's adoptive mother Pomponia Grecia. Yeah.
Dr G 36:29
Oh, I haven't looked into her.
Dr Rad 36:31
Well, okay. There is actually a passage about her, she was loosely connected to the Julio-Claudians like, she's not super something in the inner circle. But as more of them die, her connection probably becomes more significant. She actually does seem to have been rumoured to be a Christian, there is a passage preserved in Tacitus, which talks about her being accused of a alien superstition, which has been taken to mean Christianity. And that having to be dealt with in like a private family disciplinary sort of way.
Dr G 37:01
I feel like this is a testament to our original author's research. Surely,
Dr Rad 37:06
I know. And so I just thought I thought it was worth mentioning that because we've said some stuff about other female characters, and you might not think that she actually is based on a real person.
Dr G 37:14
Yeah, I just assumed that she was made up for the film. No, no, she's not.
Dr Rad 37:17
And and also, she apparently, very publicly will morning as a statement when one of her relatives, a female that Messalina was jealous off was bumped off. So she was kind of like, daring, you know, but Claudius refused to punish her for obviously making like a bit of a statement about miscellaneous behaviour, what she was doing. So she's kind of an interesting character. And the way that she has been represented in different versions is quite different. Like, if you go back to the 1925 version, I think that's where you see more of a storyline about her being caught up in persecution, and managing to escape through her mother's love, because her child is like, about to watch her be executed. And again, that seems maybe a little bit tying into like, the fascist ideology about motherhood and like, once mention her, but also Petronius I thought he was maybe a fun note to end on.
Dr G 38:09
Yeah, look, Petronius I mean, he is he is a figure that gets sort of like bandied about in this period. But because he's lampooned and to see Petronius brought to life in a way that is quite intelligent, quite serious. But then being there's, there's kind of like a visual homage to the satire that he is generally known for in the final feast, which I quite enjoyed. And I was like, well, well, this is where it gets dramatic, isn't it.
Dr Rad 38:39
Yeah, I think he might have been the author of this work, which we now call the Satyricon, which is a bizarre work and we don't have it in its complete form. Of course, we never do. But one of as you say, like the key moments is like the feasts. Yeah. At the house of Trimalchio who I think is a freedman, right.
Dr G 38:39
I can't remember,
Dr Rad 39:01
Okay, yeah, he's maybe he's meant to be this like lower class person who's aping the upper class. Yeah, he's got money. He's really trying. He's aspirational. Yeah. And so Trimalchio is supposedly partly meant to be inspired by Nero, which is maybe one of the reasons why he is found himself in hot water. Because he does end up getting caught up in these conspiracies in Nero's reign, as far as we can tell, like the real historical character. So I think it's, it is interesting the way that he as you say, is turned into like, kind of like the conscience sweet like, like a weird.
Dr G 39:39
He kind of becomes this figure that Nero bounces off and Petronius provides this opportunity just just to gently nudge him in a slightly different direction.
Dr Rad 39:50
Yeah. And he does have like the real Petronius did have official positions as we'd be fit. A man of his status. You know, he does servers console and that sort of thing. And he apparently had this title amongst Nero's inner circle that he was the arbiter of elegance, oh, which I think has been very much played upon in this particular adaptation. He's not always as likeable because there is this whole another subplot romance between him and one of his slave girls. Eunice.
Dr G 40:25
Oh, yes, yeah.
Dr Rad 40:26
And in this film, it's kind of
Dr G 40:28
why is that subplot even there?
Dr Rad 40:30
Oh, well, it gets a lot more disturbing another version, okay. In some versions, I can't remember which one, but there's a version where apparently, he orders units to be beaten for something she's done wrong. And it's while she's being beaten that he realises he's in love with her too. Because the whole storyline is that Eunice is in love with him to a point that is like the range.
Dr G 40:51
Yeah, this is I mean, the Euncie subplot, everyone doesn't make any sense. I'm like, again, this is one of those
Dr Rad 40:57
It's drawn from the novel.
Dr G 40:58
Yeah, it's one of these sort of classic like, it's, there's no women in the writers room, you know?
Dr Rad 41:04
Yeah.
Dr G 41:04
And it's like they're under what circumstances would a slave just be like kissing the statue of the of their own? No. And it's like, there's we're giving no rationale for why she might be interested in him now,
Dr Rad 41:18
apart from the fact that he seems to be like, super intelligent.
Dr G 41:22
But she doesn't.
Dr Rad 41:23
It's weird. It's weird, because he's so refined in this film. And yet this, the Satyricon is like, it's so gross, like, ,
Dr G 41:30
Well and I think this is one of the things where, like, the parallel that you might see with the historical Petronius, and the sort of the satirical one is that the way that things are written, and that, that idea of being very good with words, being very clever. And then we have Petronius is final letter to Nero, where is like six where he reveals the truth and like, I always thought you were a subpar singer. Yeah. It's like, I would never want to hear anything come out of your lips ever again. You know? Yeah. All of this kind of stuff. So he gets to this moment where he does the reveal. Yeah. When he knows he's going to take his own life. He's already got that planned out. Yeah. And to me, that's the kind of the literary echo coming in of like, you know, the person who's got that incisive way with language.
Dr Rad 42:22
Yeah and it's, it's interesting, though, as well there in terms of characterization, because Petronius is really the only person who's a Roman, who is sympathetic, but never becomes Christian. He is sympathetic to the Christians.
Dr G 42:40
Are you telling me that Tigellinus is not sympathetic? There's only one man with a moustache in this film who is also a Roman.
Dr Rad 42:48
Whip out some wax as well. Yeah, no, exactly. He's easy, only Roman who doesn't convert to Christianity, even though he might be kind of trying to temper Nero's actions with the Christians, but that seems to be more because he's concerned about Rome's reputation like, and ridiculous as you say, like it's not really like, because he cares so much for these people. But yet he is the only person who doesn't convert. You know, so it's just it's just inevitable. Yeah, it is easy these sorts of films and that sort of thing happens. All right. Finish up on a very light note. Let's talk about the promotion of Quo Vadis I have mentioned this before but Quo Vadis really takes the cake.
Dr G 43:31
Okay, how did they promote this film?
Dr Rad 43:33
How do you sell a film like Quo Vadis? Well, of course, you know, there's lots of tie in products.
Dr G 43:40
Look, I would you take that shot from the film where they've recreated Leonardo da Vinci's The Last Supper, part by part and put it on a postcard and be like, do you want to see how it happened? Yeah. Because we bring it to life.
Dr Rad 43:54
Obviously, there's the usual stuff like you shop windows and that kind of stuff. But there was also a real estate company that use the shot of nearer pointing to the model of Rome. They used it to sell houses Chris mana I'm looking at you. They also sold raincoats, sports shirts, wallpaper, tablecloth, flippers, pyjamas, boxer shorts, tie clips, and my favourite one. Fire Insurance.
Dr G 44:28
Wallpaper?
Dr Rad 44:30
Yeah, no. And not only that, but they received the Pope's blessing on the directors copy of the script.
Dr G 44:38
Wow. Yeah. Well, you know once the Pope has blessed the script, I think you're good to go.
Dr Rad 44:43
Yeah, I think so. And I think that's a perfect note on which to end this very long episode. But you know what, for long film guys, what can I say? recommend that you go and see it? Yeah, definitely – look Peter Ustinov alone is worth it. Thank you for listening to this special ed said of The Partial Historians. We'd like to thank all of our patrons for their support and allowing us to make these additional episodes, especially Nick, who's specifically requested Quo Vadis. This has been part two of two episodes on Quo Vadis. And so that's a wrap folks. Our sources and credits can be found on our website. And as a side note, if you'd like to learn more about Robert Taylor and his involvement with HUAC, we suggest you check out one of our major sources for this episode, which is the fabulous you must remember this podcast which has a whole series on the blacklist including an entire episode dedicated to Robert Taylor, and his wife, Barbara Stanwyck. Until next time, we are yours in ancient Rome.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/
Support the show
Patreon
Ko-Fi
Read our books
Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome
Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
This episode, we are dealing with 422 and 421 BCE. The previous year had been a very dramatic for Rome. They seem to have come perilously close to a disastrous military defeat. Luckily, they had the four horsemen on their side…
“The Four Horsemen” is our affectionate name for the group of cavalry commanders who dismounted and led the Roman army on foot when everything turned against them during the battle against the Volsci in 423 BCE. The most notable amongst them was a plebeian hero Sextus Tempanius.
In 422 BCE, these men were elected to serve as plebeian tribunes. But will they continue to be exalted by the Roman people? Or will they demand change from the patricians and become just as troublesome as many of their predecessors?
Join us as we explore the fallout from the Volscian conflict.
Episode 138 – The Four Horsemen
Things to Listen Out For:Need a more detailed recap of Sempronius' misdeeds? Check out our previous episode on 423 BCE.
Our Players 422 BCEMilitary Tribunes with Consular PowerThe “Horses of Saint Mark”, also known as the “Triumphal Quadriga” or “Horses of the Hippodrome of Constantinople”. The bronze sculptures are thought to date to the second or third centuries CE and modelled on much earlier statues from classical Greece c. fourth century BCE. The precise date is uncertain. Photo credit to Tteske via Wikimedia Commons.
Our SourcesOur music was composed by Bettina Joy de Guzman. Sound effects are courtesy of Pixabay and Orange Free Sounds.
Automated TranscriptDr Rad 0:16
Welcome to The Partial Historians,
Dr G 0:19
we explore all the details of ancient Rome.
Dr Rad 0:23
Everything from the political scandals, the levels as the battles waged, and when citizens turn against each other. I'm Dr. Rad.
Dr G 0:33
And I'm Dr. G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories.
Dr Rad 0:43
Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city. Hello, and welcome to a brand new episode of the Partial Historians. I am one of your hosts, Dr. Rad.
Dr G 1:12
And I am Dr. G. And we are following the history of Rome from the founding of the city.
Dr Rad 1:19
Boy, are we and you know what? We're getting so close to 100 years of the Republic.
Dr G 1:25
Maybe we should do a special episode 100 year reap recap on the early republic.
Dr Rad 1:29
Totally doable. It's only taken us what seven years to get here. That's gonna be fine. Yeah, stay tuned. Watch this space. Yeah. So Dr G, in our grand narrative of Rome's history. Last episode, we were up to 423 BCE, and it was actually kind of a memorable year.
Dr G 1:47
Yeah, some things happened, particularly with Sempronius Atratinus, who was one of the consuls for that year.
Dr Rad 1:55
He was groped into waging a military campaign, and it didn't go so well for him against the Volscian strategy.
Dr G 2:04
And he seems to have come into a bit of a cropper with the cavalry in some regard, maybe not paying attention to where they are maybe getting cut off from them. Yeah. And anyway, one of the military tribunes saves the day, Tempanius.
Dr Rad 2:17
Yeah, one of the cavalry decuriones.
Dr G 2:21
I love a good decurio.
Dr Rad 2:22
Yeah, yeah, he is the saviour of the day. And it really looked for a second like Rome was going to be slaughtered. And instead Tampanius Very unusual name managed to turn the tide, at least to the extent that it was a draw, that it was safe to run away, and find a nice place to get another day as they like to say so. And then, of course, when they got back, everyone was like, what happened out there and they tried to work Tempanius into testifying against Sempronius for like his gross incompetence, but he refused, Dr G. A man of honour through and through.
Dr G 3:00
And I think what we're gonna see as a bit of foreshadowing for what's coming up is some of the fallout from 423 in this year coming up.
Dr Rad 3:07
Yeah, I think the tribune of the plebs are gonna like walk away from such a ripe case of patrician incompetence. How could they?
Dr G 3:16
Stand firm tribunes of the plebs! Stand firm.
Dr Rad 3:20
Yeah. So, with that under our belts, let's dive in to 422 BCE
Dr G 3:32
422 BCE! What are time to be alive for a Roman.
Dr Rad 3:37
Is it though? Do you have any source material?
Dr G 3:42
I mean, it's been thin on the ground for a while. Let's just say that the Fasti Capitolini has a little bit of information.
Dr Rad 3:52
Okay.
Dr G 3:53
I have a little excerpt from Valerius Maximus, which might be exactly the same excerpt as I had for the previous year.
Dr Rad 3:59
I was gonna say!
Dr G 4:00
Diodorus Siculus is missing. And Dionysius of Halicarnassus who can say who can say?
Dr Rad 4:07
Siculus is missing now?
Dr G 4:08
Well yeah, yeah.
Dr Rad 4:10
You know what, I'm starting to think that the sources aren't missing, you're just careless.
Dr G 4:16
I've decided to no longer prep for episodes. I'm just rocking up.
Dr Rad 4:20
Alright, well, with that in mind, shall we perhaps just start with the magistrates? And then I will give you what Livy has to offer.
Dr G 4:28
Yeah, yeah, I'm super excited. So what I've tried to do to compensate for my absolute lack of source material is, first of all, consult Broughton, who has the list of who's in what position is the year that we even have any idea about-
Dr Rad 4:40
Raunchy.
Dr G 4:43
Me and Broughton. I mean, it might be 1950, but I'm happy. And from that point onwards, I might just interject every now and then with a little bit of tidbit about names.
Dr Rad 4:56
You know, my Latin is subpar. So let's do it.
Dr G 5:02
Alright, so we've got some military tribunes with consular power.
Dr Rad 5:06
Okay.
Dr G 5:07
Sometimes you might hear if these, listeners, as referred to as “consular tribunes”, that's fine. Those two titles are interchangeable. We've got Lucius Manlius Capitolinus. We've got Quintus Antonius Merenda. And Lucius Papirius Mugillanus.
Dr Rad 5:27
You got my hopes that for a second there, Dr. G, when you said that we had military tribunes with consular power, and yet, I feel like every name on that list is patrician.
Dr G 5:37
Yes, yeah. Although Antonius is a plebeian name, so Quintus Antonius Merenda, “Antonius” is a plebeian gens,
Dr Rad 5:46
Right.
Dr G 5:47
But there is like problems with this because our literary sources – unreliable though they may be and controversial for their record rejections into the past, etc, etc, all the usual caveats. The feeling from the ground from those writers looking back at this period is that the first plebeian tribute with consular power doesn't get elected until 400 BCE, so we're a little ways away from that at the moment. Yeah, so who is this Antonius? I don't know.
Dr Rad 6:18
Hmm. I wonder if he's a distant relative of Mark Antony.
Dr G 6:22
Surely. Does he have the nose? Let's check for the nose. So they are our military tribunes.
Dr Rad 6:30
Yeah.
Dr G 6:30
Then we've got a nice little list of tribunes of the plebs.
Dr Rad 6:35
I thought you might say this.
Dr G 6:36
Yeah. Which is pretty exciting. We've got a guy called Tiberius Antintius, so we're expecting plebeian names in this section.
Dr Rad 6:43
For sure.
Dr G 6:44
Marcus Asellius. Tiberius Spurillius
Dr Rad 6:49
Sounds like a pasta
Dr G 6:49
or Spurillus.
Dr Rad 6:51
Less like a pasta.
Dr G 6:53
And a name that may be familiar to you, Sextus Tempanius.
Dr Rad 6:57
Well, of course, I mean, you know, he was the hero of the previous year, of course, he's gonna wind up being a tribune of the plebs.
Dr G 7:03
The hero of the previous year now in charge on a political front, not a military front.
Dr Rad 7:08
There is a real pattern with these plebeians that rise to the top in our sources, and that is they have this moment in the sun and they always end up being a tribune afterwards.
Dr G 7:19
Yeah, it's a classic crossover. It's the – what would be the modern equivalent – the influencer to twitch host? I don't know.
Nice
I'm not sure
Dr Rad 7:30
I didn't even know what half those words meant. So good job.
Dr G 7:33
I'm not going to pretend I understand any more than what I just said. There are other notables for this year, obviously, Gaius Sempronius Atratinus, consul of the previous year, is going to have a bit of a feature, and somebody called Lucius Hortensius. And you may think to yourself, well, you might know what's going on the narrative. I've got no idea what's going on with Hortensius in the narrative. But apparently, this guy is also a plebeian, or at least that's what the name suggests.
Dr Rad 8:04
It does. It does.
Dr G 8:06
But I'll go into the etymology of that later.
Dr Rad 8:09
Good. Good, because I also have something to say about that name. Okay, so the narrative of all of this, whilst the consuls are away, the plebeians decide to elect this array of tribunes, according to Livy. So this is where we get our Tempanius, our Asellius, our Antistius, and our Spurillus, okay. Now, all of these men, not just Tempanius had allegedly been chosen to lead the cavalry, when they had been forced to dismount from their horses and therefore quite frankly, become infantry against the Volscians.
Dr G 8:43
So all of these troops and some of the plebs are former cavalry leaders? Okay.
Dr Rad 8:49
Yeah
Dr G 8:49
Oh boy.
Dr Rad 8:50
In fact-
Unknown Speaker 8:51
The four horsemen
Dr Rad 8:51
I was gonna say, the four horsemen.
Dr G 8:53
Is there an apocalypse coming to Rome.
Dr Rad 8:55
It was almost an apocalypse, let's be honest. So, I have actually looked into this a little bit. And the commentary that I'm consulting Ogilvie says that this is such a weird detail for Livy to have included it must be true.
Dr G 9:12
So strange.
Dr Rad 9:13
Yeah, I think I think he's referring to the whole idea of obviously them, you know, dismounting and being chosen to lead in some capacity. And that would make sense because Tempanius couldn't possibly I don't think have been the only person who was in charge of the cavalry that particular day.
Dr G 9:29
Ah, he was the only one who turns up in the story.
Dr Rad 9:31
Until this moment, Dr G. And he was surrounded by people anyway. The senate sensed – because they've so got their finger on the pulse of the people – but there's some negativity in Rome after the whole Sempronius affair.
Dr G 9:47
The vibes are off
Dr Rad 9:48
The vibes are off. And they're like you know what? Let's just not have consuls. It'll make them feel better.
Dr G 9:58
I mean, we'll just put patricians in power. But not consular power.
Dr Rad 10:03
That would be an insult too great. Salt, wounds, bad idea. So they decide instead on military tribunes with consular powers and it's thus that we get the names that you mentioned earlier, some of which are very familiar like Capitolinus.
Dr G 10:21
Capitolinus is a pretty familiar name. We've come across those a few times. This is the first time I think we've come across an Antonius Merenda
Dr Rad 10:27
Agreed, that is a weird name.
Dr G 10:29
But Lucius Papirius Mugillanus, he was consul in 427.
Dr Rad 10:34
Totally,
Dr G 10:35
And seems to have been related to a guy who was consul in 443 and another Papirius.
Dr Rad 10:42
Yeah, we've heard the name Papirius. We've definitely heard Mugillanus before.
Dr G 10:46
Yeah, so there is also a generational legacy here where it's like there is a flow through of patricians from certain famines coming into power, apparently, according to our sources.
Dr Rad 10:56
Yeah. And therefore, this makes it an entirely meaningless gesture on behalf.
Dr G 11:03
Put all our friends into power to keep you happy. Are you happy?
Dr Rad 11:07
We'll just label it differently. Anyway, so at the start of the year, one of the tribune of the plebs, who was not mentioned as being part of the Four Horsemen gang – Lucius Hortensius – decides he's going to go after Gaius Sempronius, the idiot of the previous year who had been such a terrible commander, take the floor, Dr. G.
Dr G 11:30
So Lucius Hortensius is also a tribune of the plebs?
Dr Rad 11:33
He is, but he's not from the original gang.
Dr G 11:37
Okay, so he's not one of these four horsemen
Dr Rad 11:40
He is not.
Dr G 11:42
And this may explain why he's doing the prosecution, because he represents a slightly different political faction, maybe?
Dr Rad 11:48
Oh, he definitely does. Like there's a whole narrative around this, but I thought you might want to say something about his name.
Dr G 11:54
Yeah, I do. I do. Yes. So the temptation is always to be like, Hortensius, it must come from “hortus” “garden”.
Dr Rad 12:03
Ah!
Dr G 12:04
Yeah, a beautiful Latin word
Dr Rad 12:06
Didn't even occur to me because my Latin is so poor.
Dr G 12:08
But that is apparently not where this name comes from. It is thought to come from an ancient Roman town called Hortense or Hortenses.
Dr Rad 12:18
Okay.
Dr G 12:20
That is somewhere in central Italy. But, sadly, location unconfirmed.
Dr Rad 12:26
Typical. Well, I have a little bit more to add to that, which is that although the name Hortensius probably sounds very familiar to you, and I, because this family becomes quite well known in the later Republic.
Dr G 12:41
These – this family will make a reappearance. This particular Hortensius seems to be the earliest mention of a Hortensius we get in our sources, but scholarship generally discounts this guy as being real.
Dr Rad 12:55
I was gonna say, to say, I know how you feel when I say that these people aren't real. Is that to make reality? You know, bend. But yeah, there is no other Hortensius mentioned in the sources for hundreds of years.
Dr G 13:09
Yeah. So scholars tend to err on the side of caution here and be like, this guy might not be real.
Dr Rad 13:17
Well, I mean, especially because we know what the Romans are like with their names.
Dr G 13:21
Well, yeah. So the Romans have this idea, much like in the way that they assume people's characters based on their their appearance. They also assume character based on family. So there's this idea that there's hereditary elements of personality that come through. So the acts of this guy might be just a retrojection of the sorts of things that Hortensii are thought to do later on.
Dr Rad 13:46
Yes. Well, the interesting thing is there will eventually be a connection between the Sempronii and the Hortensii in the later Republic. So it's possible that the reason this particular name has been selected is because there's this interesting thing happening –
Dr G 14:06
Are you telling me this is all just foreshadowing?
Dr Rad 14:10
Foreshadow, foreshadow. I was like, for centuries for centuries. Okay, so what basically ends up happening in Livy's account is that the four horsemen (of the apocalypse, I can't stop it) beg Hortensius not to persecute Sempronius.
Dr G 14:26
He's our man. We love him. Just doing his best. It was really tough thing. You weren't there on the battlefield. You didn't see how this was going down? How dare you step in? He's not incompetent. He tried his best – it was difficult circumstances. And we know we didn't prepare before the battle, but it's not his fault. It's not his fault!
Dr Rad 14:42
That's exactly what they say. Literally word for word. Like it's just bad luck. Anybody could have bad luck on a battlefield. It's a battlefield, man. You weren't there. You didn't see.
Dr G 14:52
The plan is only as good as the first moment of combat.
Dr Rad 14:55
Yeah.
Dr G 14:56
Shhh, we didn't have a plan.
Dr Rad 14:58
We were fighting at midnight. I mean, sure by then it'll all gone to hell. But come on!
Dr G 15:03
You can't even see what you're doing under those conditions.
Dr Rad 15:05
It is black as night. The enemy just appeared out of nowhere man. Anyway Hortensius refuses to give way. He's like, nah man, I don't believe any of it. I think you're just worried about the appearance of all of this. You're just thinking about the optics.
Dr G 15:25
Oh, well, these guys are definitely thinking about the optics. This is where Valerius Maximus ends up going.
Dr Rad 15:30
Okay, tell me about the optics.
Dr G 15:32
The optics are that these four who are the tribunes of the plebs – not Hortensius – get together and they're like, oh, no, if you're going to persecute and prosecute Sempronius, we're going to turn up every day at the rostra in mourning. Wearing mourning garb as an intense performative display of loyalty for the man who was and shall always be our commander.
Dr Rad 15:58
Exactly. I mean, the loyalty is bizarre, because I swear, there's like-
Dr G 16:02
It did sound like they really lost that battle. And it was just a nightmare.
Dr Rad 16:05
Exactly. And I don't see I don't have there is no mention of any personal connection between these men before this particular battle.
Dr G 16:15
Look, just because we don't know about it doesn't mean it wasn't there.
Dr Rad 16:18
This is true, but also, wouldn't you mention if it was? Anyway Sempronius is clearly counting on the other tribunes using their veto to stop anything bad from happening to him. However, Hortensius calls him out. You're hiding behind the tribunes! How dare you? What kind of ex-consul are you anyway? Hortensius also turns to the Four Horsemen and says, So what are you going to do? What are you going to do if I continue after Sempronius? Are you just going to undermine the whole idea of the tribunate? How's that gonna work out for you and all the other random people, if you guys undermine this position that we all hold as tribune of the plebs seems like you're going to be stripping the people of their rights, am I right?
Dr G 17:14
I don't know if this feels logical to me. But please continue.
Dr Rad 17:18
Well, the tribune say, We certainly did not intend to overrule whatever the people decide. They're allowed to vote on things. However – and this is where your story comes in – if you're going to ignore our pleas for Sempronius' wellbeing then we are just going to dress in mourning, and as like a show of solidarity, as he's like, our dad.
Dr G 17:49
Oh, wow.
Dr Rad 17:49
Because he was our commander.
Dr G 17:53
Oh, no, mixing up filial piety with the command structure of the military forces. This is getting messy.
Dr Rad 18:02
I know. It's really sickening. Now Hortensius, is convinced by this. Yeah, he's like, okay, okay, put the morning away. We don't need to get unpleasant.
Dr G 18:13
Let's not get emotional about it.
Dr Rad 18:16
We don't need to get fabric involved. Sempronius is free to go. I'm not going to touch him. Because if you guys are so dedicated to him, then he must be worth it. And I was wrong the whole time.
Dr G 18:32
This is – I mean -it just feels the whole thing feels implausible. What kind of story is this?
Dr Rad 18:38
The endnote is the best part because everyone is for once thrilled with the tribune of the plebs – all of them. They're like, You know what you guys were like super loyal and dedicated. And you, Hortensius, showed yourself to be flexible, reasonable, logical. I think I've ever had such a high rating. It's like five stars across the board for all of the tribunes.
Dr G 19:05
You guys haven't agreed at all, but you got there in the end.
Dr Rad 19:07
Yeah.
Dr G 19:07
Good job.
Dr Rad 19:08
Yeah. Now, this is where things get really weird in Livy's account, because it's like he, most people agree that he abruptly switches his source material, like the main source that he's consulting, one of the earliest sources. But the one thing that kind of does stay similar all throughout this little next period, is that it seems that maybe Livy's is dwelling on a theme of moderatio. And this would be a good moment to flag that obviously, because everyone's being, well, reasonably reasonable. You know.
Dr G 19:46
I don't think our four horsemen are necessarily demonstrating any moderatio. Like all they've done is step up each time. Yeah, and gone. Well, if you're going to do that, I'm going to do this
Dr Rad 19:59
I guess. I guess
Dr G 20:00
But Hortensius has apparently shown some moderatio.
Dr Rad 20:05
Yeah, he has. I don't know that everybody is, as you say, but I guess you could say that the other tribunes kind of are in the sense that they don't use their veto. They're like we'll make this a personal show of solidarity. A private-public protest if you will. Yes, anyway. And and now this is where it becomes like an abrupt shift because all of a sudden, out of nowhere, we've got this mansion of the Aequians coming in to claim some sort of victory over the Volscians. It seems really weird.
Dr G 20:37
Oh, so when the when the Romans ran away, the Aequians were their being like, Well, I see the Volscii are not quite ready.
Dr Rad 20:48
Well, I don't even know if it's like, you know, fresh combat, or if it's actually what just happened.
Dr G 20:54
Wasn't there some kind of – I didn't know the Aequians were involved, but it seems like maybe they inserted themselves when the opportunity arose.
Dr Rad 21:01
I think they did. But also, I think Livy's also just like, really quickly changed horses, and it doesn't have the nice flow that I've come to expect from Livy's narrative.
Dr G 21:13
Maybe, yeah, it sounds like Livy's might be struggling.
Dr Rad 21:16
Indeed. And that's where he ends the year, which is why it's even stranger.
Dr G 21:21
P.S. the Aequians. The end.
Dr Rad 21:23
That's basically what it reads like he's like, Aequians, and we're like, wait, what, have we talked about the Aequians? Anytime recently?
Dr G 21:30
Yeah, nothing in any of the material that I've been able to scrounge together in preparation has mentioned the Aequians.
Dr Rad 21:35
Exactly. And so without further ado, Dr. G. That means that I am ricocheting into 421 BCE.
Dr G 21:41
Oh, okay. Well, before we head into that direction, I'll give you some lowdown on some the name Asellius. So we've got these tribune of the plebs. One of them is Marcus Asellius. Now, this is the only one for which there is more history attested for the family name.
Dr Rad 21:58
Okay.
Dr G 21:59
So, but not until the second century CE.
Dr Rad 22:04
Once again, we've got these later names.
Dr G 22:07
Yeah. So I think this is really interesting, because this is a family that crops up into prominence well after the source material that even we're consulting. And but so this family is hanging around, but it seems that there are long threads that go back quite a long way for that particular gens. And that is that's it. That's my other my other little tidbit of detail.
Dr Rad 22:32
Love it.
Dr G 22:32
And I'm ready to move on
Dr Rad 22:33
I would not have known that without you. And that's the whole point of the fixes.
Alright, so 421 BCE. We're back to consuls, I'm afraid.
Dr G 22:42
Oh, yeah. Yeah. Look, my source material. I'm glad you asked.
Dr Rad 22:48
I didn't. I just assumed.
Dr G 22:52
Didorus Siculus – still missing.
Dr Rad 22:54
Right. Yeah.
Dr G 22:54
Dionysius of Halicarnassus? Missing.
Dr Rad 22:57
Yep.
Dr G 22:58
I've got a little bit of Festus.
Dr Rad 23:00
Yeah, so. There is a little bit of Festus that is relevant here. But I'll let you take that.
Dr G 23:04
And I've also got a little bit of Tacitus' Annals.
Dr Rad 23:07
Yes, I think I know you're coming. But again, I'm not going to tread on your toes for that. I'm going to let you, I'm gonna let you take that. But do you want to tell us the names of the consuls for this year?
Dr G 23:16
All right. There's some controversy.
Dr Rad 23:18
Okay.
Dr G 23:19
So it's Gnaeus or Numerius
Dr Rad 23:22
That is what Livy prefers
Dr G 23:24
Yeah, but nobody else prefers that really. So but we'll come to that.
Dr Rad 23:29
Well, everyone else has disappeared. So I think they can take a flying leap.
Dr G 23:32
As a praenomen “Numerius” is a little bit a bit unusual.
Dr Rad 23:37
I'll give you that.
Dr G 23:37
So Gnaeus or Numerius Fabius Vibulanus
Dr Rad 23:43
Definitely heard this name.
Dr G 23:45
Yeah. The Fabii. Well, one of our favourite gens-es at this point in time. Yeah. Well attested, yeah, dramatically, almost dead. And then we also have Titus Quinctius Capitolinus Barbatus.
Dr Rad 24:01
Definitely a name we recognise.
Dr G 24:04
Sound familiar.
Dr Rad 24:05
I mean, for heaven's sakes, there's just the previous year it was we've had a Capitolinus didn't we?
Dr G 24:09
Yeah, yeah, the beardy ones.
Dr Rad 24:11
Yeah, I particularly like the way that Livy introduces this guy to me because he says the consuls are Numerius Fabius Vibulanus and Titus Quinctius Capitolinus, the son of Capitolinus, and I was like, thanks so much for clearing that up Livy, it's super clear now who this guy is and who he's related to.
Dr G 24:28
Nothing quite like those details to really lock you into the narrative.
Dr Rad 24:31
Now, of course, we start in this random place that we finish where – by a lot – Fabius is chosen to be the commander against the Aequians. What?
Dr G 24:42
Well, fair enough.
Dr Rad 24:43
Like what is happening? but nothing is really achieved. So it's not a glorious battle, because what happens is that Fabius goes off to war with the Aequians. The Aequians, having come in maybe claiming someone else's victory. I don't know what's going on there. They also give a very half hearted effort against the Romans. And so the Romans just super easily managed to triumph over them. It's a completely shameful defeat from the Aequians. You have to retreat and therefore Fabius is left with nothing to brag about.
Dr G 25:15
So, no triumph?
Dr Rad 25:16
No triumph, but he does get an ovatio (or an ovation), because he had somewhat helped to waft away the stench of Sempronius' behaviour on the battlefield.
Dr G 25:32
You didn't lose, and that was good.
Dr Rad 25:34
Yeah. And it wasn't, you know, disastrous and shameful. We like that. Yeah. More of that.
Dr G 25:43
An ovatio is like a lesser triumph.
Dr Rad 25:46
Yeah, I mean, like, to be honest, it sounds like more than I feel like he deserved.
Dr G 25:49
Yeah, it is still quite a substantial celebration, but the commander walks through the city as part of the procession, rather than being in a chariot.
Dr Rad 25:56
Yes. Obviously, walking in
Dr G 26:00
Walking is not as prestigious.
Dr Rad 26:02
It's really not. So it's a bit of a win. But I think everyone feels very ambivalent about this, because everyone is expecting more from the Aequians. Although we certainly didn't, because the Aequians seem to be randomly placed. So they do. Yeah, it's it just seems like such a non affair. But then, Dr. G, Mawhahaha the peace was shattered with unexpected and serious quarrels between the plebeians and the patricians. And to that I say, Livy, really? You don't need to be Cassandra to see this one coming.
Dr G 26:36
I was like, unexpected, surprising?
Dr Rad 26:39
Like, surely this is the most predictable thing in the history of the world.
Dr G 26:44
It has been happening for a while, according even to Livy.
Dr Rad 26:47
Yeah. And of course, it could only happen over a truly hot button issue, which is the doubling of the quaestors.
Dr G 26:57
I wondered where this was going. I was like, is land allotment back on the agenda? No. Okay. Wait, I have a source for this. Excellent.
Dr Rad 27:05
Wait, before you go into it. Are you going to tell us what quaestors are, to begin with? Because we might need to remind people, it's been a while since we mentioned them.
Dr G 27:12
I'm not sure that I am going to I mean, I, it's tricky. Quaestors end up being in charge of things. Like, what the treasury?
Dr Rad 27:23
Yeah, like that. What they ended up being in charge of much like aediles is very little, like related to what they do now. Yeah, they are mentioned, actually all the way back in the regal period, as being in charge of helping out with cases of parricidum. So where a family member has killed a family member.
Dr G 27:42
See, I'm glad you're here, because it's like of all of the things I decided to look up looking at what the quaestors was did in the early republic was not one of them,
Dr Rad 27:50
Typically, of all the magistracices of this time period, we don't really know what they do. But because they actually predate-
Yeah, they have a quasi legal function.
Yeah. And they are mentioned in the Twelve Tables. They are mentioned as the quaestores parridici no no, I know that
Dr G 28:10
Parricidium
Dr Rad 28:10
Para-kid-i-ii – quaestores parricidii! Yeah, I don't know why I'm saying it in Italian
Dr G 28:18
Every time an Italian dies.
Dr Rad 28:18
I just had to do it.
Dr G 28:25
Right. I enjoyed it. So the quaestors. So yeah, we get Tacitus weirdly, as a source for this. This is a guy that's writing in the like, early second century and late first century CE. So he's like, you know, a while away, even from Livy, like, over a century later, definitely. And he talks about the quaestors going back to Brutus in 509 BCE. But also notes that two are added to take care of things at Rome, in 421 BCE. So the idea is that they were supposed to accompany the military chest. So that's Tacitus' read. So that's a really interesting sort of progression for where the quaestorship is going to maybe end up.
Dr Rad 29:20
Exactly. Treasury money.
Dr G 29:21
Yeah, treasury and money. And so that's where Tacitus is. And he's like, Well, he assumes that in this very early period of the republic that they've had two, to look after the war booty essentially like, like the really precious stuff that's picked up in the battlefield, the quaestors are in charge of like managing that and the security around that. Yeah. And then they decide in this moment that they need to more in Rome itself. Yes. I don't know who's been stealing the booty to suggest that that might be necessary.
Dr Rad 29:52
It's not actually that per se. Basically how this all comes about, is that the consuls say there's too much paperwork. And you know what? I'm sick of hearing the constant complaint about that. This has been like what?
Dr G 30:04
Red tape, man, red tape – all I want to do is go out and kill people with an army. Come on, come on, come on. I know round up, round up, round up.
Dr Rad 30:11
It's like every job has a glamorous side and a not so glamorous side guys but anyway.
Dr G 30:16
Guys, I need a PA.
Dr Rad 30:18
Oh, they completely say that. They say, look, there's a lot of conflict going on. We're being drowned in admin.
Dr G 30:27
Between the levee; between having to like clean my own leather. It's a nightmare, I tell you what.
Dr Rad 30:34
What I mean, quite frankly, look at Sempronius. Why didn't he prepare? Too busy with admin.
Dr G 30:40
I just couldn't get through the emails. The backlog was shocking.
Dr Rad 30:43
It was choking me. So they want two more quaestors because they just can't cope. There's just too many wars going on. And the Senate like totally, completely reasonable, of course, for a number that we need. Now the tribunes of course get wind of this. And they say, well, whoa, whoa, look, while we're adding two quaestors. I mean, that would make a total of four. Why don't we say that 50% have to be plebeian, because traditionally quaestors have always been patricians.
Dr G 31:14
Mm hmm. Well, cat amongst the pigeons right there.
Dr Rad 31:18
Well, it seems like a fairly simple request. But the consuls and the senate, of course, have their default reaction of, “I would rather die than see that happen.” And they put up a huge fight, absolutely refused. They're like no way. No How. However, finally, they decided to make a compromise. They're going to apply the same rule that they used for military tribunes with consular power, which is that the people can elect whoever they want, maybe to be patricians, maybe to be plebeians. Good luck. That compromise is rejected.
Dr G 31:57
Well, fair enough. I mean, we've yet to see any evidence of some real plebeians inside the military tribunate with consular power.
Dr Rad 32:05
Precisely. So they decide we're just going to have to let go of the whole idea of having more quaestors. We'd rather like neither of us are going to have any more quaestors because we can't agree where they're coming from.
Dr G 32:21
So they're not going to increase them?
Dr Rad 32:23
No, they're like, You know what,
Dr G 32:24
We'll just stick with two.
Dr Rad 32:25
Let's just drop it
Dr G 32:26
Two is fine. The consuls are like, I'll do my paperwork. Yeah, I hate emails, whatever.
Dr Rad 32:30
Yeah. However, the tribune of the plebs is less keen to kind of let this all go. And their like, you know, all of this has reinvigorated me, refreshed me. And so I'm now going to pursue all these other dangerous and revolutionary ideas that tribunes typically do, such as pushing for an agrarian law.
Dr G 32:57
Uh oh
Dr Rad 32:57
Yeah, instead of like, Whoa, how did this happen? We were just talking about, like, trying to reduce our admin and now we're back at an agrarian law??
Dr G 33:06
All we said was, if you're gonna have more quaestors, we want two of them to be us. Not gonna give it to us? Fine. I want all of the public land re allotment to be fixed up yesterday.
Dr Rad 33:18
So the senate like okay, well, clearly, we can't risk having military tribunes with consular power. We're going to need to organise consular elections for the next year because we need things to be you know, super stable, really under lock and key. Patricians only. The tribunes however, say, You know what? No, we're gonna use our vetoes. And so they stop consular elections from being held. Apparently, this is something they can do.
Dr G 33:45
It seems a little bit too early.
Dr Rad 33:49
I know. And also, this is where it starts get really murky. Clearly, I think there is some overlap between the events of 421 and 420 is really unclear. Like when all of this is going down, and how, and that's because the fricking tribunes stop the consuls being elected and therefore I don't have a clear end date here.
Dr G 34:06
This is the year that goes forever.
Dr Rad 34:08
Yeah. And so instead of having consuls coming in instead, we have an interrex, and not just an interrex, we have lots of them.
Dr G 34:19
Oh, yes. We're about to enter very baffling period.
Dr Rad 34:23
It is so weird. So weird
Dr G 34:25
Because an interrex – as the name would suggest – is somebody who comes between kings.
Dr Rad 34:31
Exactly, exactly right. But look, we have heard them use this before in the Republic, but yeah, the fact that it's still hanging around almost 100 years later, it's like guys
Dr G 34:43
As a stop gap solution. Yeah. When things really go wrong.
Dr Rad 34:46
You got rid of the kings, you're designing the new system, be better
Dr G 34:52
At least give people new titles
Dr Rad 34:54
Exactly, like Jesus Christ, like we've given you 100 years like freshen up the place a bit. But anyway, so there's this whole series of interreges apparently taking place. And even this did not happen smoothly because the tribunes are apparently trying really hard to stop the patricians from meeting at all. So when they have to meet to talk about,
Dr G 35:12
They start together in public and patricians just run out them to disperse the crowd.
Dr Rad 35:16
In private as well, like they just seem to be stopping them from having meetings everywhere, because they're trying to gather so they can appoint the next interrex, because – we probably should remind our listeners of this strategy – the whole idea of an interrex is that the idea is that elite men each take turns holding the ultimate imperium for short periods of time.
Dr G 35:37
Yes, it's kind of like it's done by a lot. Or it's done by time. That's kind of like there are different systems for measuring it. But the idea is, it's rotational and everybody understands the nature of the rotation.
Dr Rad 35:48
Yeah, it's like a patrician hot potato basically. And so they are using their veto to stop them from gathering, to stop them from appointing people, to stop them from ordering consular elections. Exhausting.
Dr G 36:02
Yeah, I mean, it's been very confusing. I mean, I've got I'm just overwhelmed by the confusion of it all. I've got no narrative. So I've got nothing to base my response on.
Dr Rad 36:11
I'm winding it up, don't worry. So eventually, we get a guy called Lucius Papirius Mugillanus, who's made the interrex. Now he decides he's going to have a go with everyone. So he tells off the senators, he tells off the tribunes of the plebs. He's like, hello. You're lucky that the gods have been looking out for Rome because you guys sure as hell haven't been. You just freaking lucky. I mean, what if? What if they decided once again, to call off the truce? What if the Aequians weren't complete losers, as they seem to be right now, for the sake of this narrative? Things could go south really quickly for us, guys. We're not preeminent yet. Okay, what happens in case of an emergency? What happens if you don't have patricians in charge? Are you mad? No army, no generals to conduct a levy? Oh, my God, you all need to compromise. You all need to give in just a little bit. Just a little bit.
Demonstrate some moderatio, guys.
Oh, yeah, no, that's exactly what happens. The Senate agree that the whole military tribunes with consular power thing can happen. And the tribunes allow for quaestors provided that they are chosen at the will of the people and can be either patrician or plebeian. Yes, that's right.
Dr G 37:41
We're back at square one.
Dr Rad 37:42
That's right, we're back at square one, where they could have been months ago, maybe years ago. Who knows how much time has passed while I've been dealing with this incompetence?
Dr G 37:50
So many dinner parties broken up and for nothing, just to get back to the beginning again.
Dr Rad 37:54
I know, I know. Now, look, this is one of those episodes in the whole struggle of the orders that definitely some scholars have been like, really? Did this really happen? It also doesn't seem like the tribunes could actually stop the patricians from eating?
Dr G 38:11
No, I don't think so. That does seem rather suspect at this point in time.
Dr Rad 38:15
And yeah, but it could be potentially a way of explaining something that really happened, which is a lot of these interreges.
Dr G 38:23
Yes, yeah. Interesting. So that sounds is that is that the wrap up? Okay.
Dr Rad 38:30
I mean, that's it for 421. Maybe part of 420?
Dr G 38:34
Fair enough, fair enough. So to put things – different spin on things. Okay. One of the things I've been doing while I've lacked source material is just to read some scholarship, you know, everybody loves a good time. And one of those books is Drogula's, “Commanders and Command in the Roman Republic and Early Empire”. Not interested in the early empire at this point, but I'm glad the book covers that as well.
Dr Rad 38:56
Can we get this person on the show? That's like the second article we've read.
Dr G 38:59
Yeah, I Well, first, first name Fred. So I think, well, but I wouldn't presume gender. But “Commanders and Command in the Roman Republic in Early Empire” is looking at what do we think might have been realistically going on in this very early period, and-
Dr Rad 39:19
Nothing.
Dr G 39:21
History was a blank slate, Rome was a tabula rasa. And it only came into being with the Punic Wars. Before then, it didn't exist at all.
Dr Rad 39:31
There was some huts, that's about all I feel confident saying.
Dr G 39:34
There were some huts, they definitely were huts. We've got some archaeological evidence for huts, which is great.
Dr Rad 39:39
Yeah, there were some temples.
Dr G 39:40
There were some temples. And one of the theories that Drogula is sort of exploring this early period is that you've got prominent families and politics operating through prominent families. Sure, which makes sense. Yeah. And so the Fabii – going back to them for a minute and their disastrous, sort of like private war with Veii. Yeah, that's going back a little ways now. But seeing that as an example of what might actually be happening, instead of having elections, instead of having formal people coming into positions of power, what you've got is a kind of like, yeah, it's warlords and bandits. And people are raising private armies, and going around the place to defend their property. So Rome has this sort of feature about it. And we see it later on as well, where they kind of don't ever really get to the spot where they have like a proper sort of like, police force or things like that. It's kind of like the onus is on the individual to look after themselves
Dr Rad 40:36
Oh definitely
Dr G 40:37
And how you go about that. It's kind of up to you. And if we take that sort of idea, right back into this early period, you've got your land holdings, you've got the people who are dependent on that land who are loyal to you. You're divided up into tribes, you're a prominent family, you're a tribune, because you're a leader of a tribe in some respects, or you've been drawn from a tribe. So we've talked about this idea of where does the name tribune come from? Coming out of that tribal system? Yeah, some kind of leader. And then you've got this idea that we've also got not consuls, but praetors. Praetor being kind of like a default name for a leader as well.
Dr Rad 41:16
Yeah.
Dr G 41:17
You've got people who are like, well, I need to defend my property, because we're about to get raided by those guys. And I could see him coming over the hill, who's with me? Yeah. And there's everybody's got a vested interest in the local area to get on board with that, because better to defend it together than not, you got this smelly slaughters individual. Yeah, this swilling mix of people rising to prominence, who are able to raise their own armies. And that driving the politics in this central meeting area of these tribes, which is these little hills that are getting more and more populous, that becomes Rome. Yeah. And this idea, I think, is really useful and interesting for understanding some of this stuff, because Livy has to navigate and Dionysus – whenever, whenever I have him – have to navigate this idea that Rome gets rid of the kings, and is, in their mind kind of already a fully fledged Republic, before it would be really possible for them to have figured out how they're going to do it.
Dr Rad 42:17
Yes.
Dr G 42:17
And part of what we're seeing is this ongoing process as I'm trying to figure it out, not really getting it right. Sometimes it working. Sometimes it's not. Sometimes you got to have interreges. What does that even mean if you're dealing with a period of like war bands or warlords, and like roving armies?
Dr Rad 42:34
I'm down to this idea of the Rome of this period actually being a chaotic mess-
Dr G 42:40
I think it might be
Dr Rad 42:41
-where they haven't figured out what they're doing exactly in place of the kings. I mean, you know, you think about the period that's better documented, like when Rome collapses in the “West”, that whole idea that, you know, feudalism springs up to take its place, because people, as you say, need to defend their local area. And there are some people that are better equipped to be the leaders in that scenario, whether it's because they already have more people that are pledged to them, or they have more material wealth of some kind. Like, it's totally clear that that is probably what is happening here. Not necessarily in the sense of, “You, sir, if you pledge yourself to me,”
Dr G 43:17
“I shall advance you.”
Dr Rad 43:19
“Bow down before me.” But in that sense of, “I'm the strongest guy in this area.”
Dr G 43:24
“Better to be on my side, then against me. You on my side?” And you're like, “Yes, sir. Yes, I am.”
Dr Rad 43:31
And it would explain so much.
Dr G 43:33
“I'm not gonna burn down your farm … yet.”
Dr Rad 43:37
“Those guys might if I don't help you.”
Dr G 43:40
“If you pay me a little bit of cash, I'll make sure that I come back if they ever return.”
Dr Rad 43:44
Yeah, exactly. It's I mean, it makes complete sense that when you get rid of a system, like the kings, that this would be exactly what takes place.
Dr G 43:52
Yeah. And it might also help explain why we've got these periods where – and because we're in the middle of this period now, and it's going to go on for quite some time where we've got military tribunes with consular power, not consuls – And this is part of like this chaotic time where it's like, there is clearly more than a couple of people who are holding imperium. And running around with an armed force. And this period of Rome sort of chaotic, coming together and trying to figure out who they are while also facing off against just about everybody else in the region.
Dr Rad 44:25
Yeah.
Dr G 44:25
We're right in the middle of the drama now.
Dr Rad 44:29
100% I love it. All right. Well, should we wrap up there Dr. G?
Dr G 44:32
Let's.
Dr Rad 44:33
Okay. That means that it's time for the Partial Pick!
Uhhh, I'm just gonna cut that out.
Dr G 44:47
Why? I'm still so sad
Dr Rad 44:49
Because you're stealing Igor's gig. Have you thought about that? He's in a union.
Dr G 44:53
Wow. Igor. If you're listening. I want you to know that I'm not trying to steal your job.
Dr Rad 45:02
All right, Dr G., tell us about the Partial Pick.
Dr G 45:04
Well, it is time to see if Rome can win 50 Golden Eagles.
Dr Rad 45:10
I'm not betting anything on it.
Dr G 45:13
They're up for 10 Golden Eagles across five categories.
Dr Rad 45:16
All right, give me the categories with the first one?
Dr G 45:18
Military clout.
Dr Rad 45:21
Look, I mean, maybe, I guess the whole Aequians thing, something that's a very confused narrative. And it's even then, like, even Livy's like, “look, it's not great.”
Dr G 45:32
How many points are you going to give it an ovatio?
Dr Rad 45:35
I mean, it's an ovatio. It's a pity ovatio. I mean, let's let's be real. It's a patrician pity party, because they're trying to distract people from the fact that Sempronius really stuffed up. So I feel like I cannot give it more than a three.
Dr G 45:50
All right, fair fair. All right, diplomacy.
Dr Rad 45:54
Hmm.
Dr G 45:55
Well, there was some moments of acquiescence that come through when we get four quaestors that could be elected, two of whom could be plebeian perhaps.
Dr Rad 46:10
And there's also the whole, you know, Hortensius and the four horsemen of the apocalypse thing.
Dr G 46:15
They do have a moment where they come together and find an accord.
Dr Rad 46:21
Yes. Damn you, Livy, and your theme of moderatio. So I guess I don't feel like it's much because there was a lot of fighting before that one that you mentioned. And it was a lot of fighting before the one that I mentioned. So I feel like I don't know maybe again, another three.
Dr G 46:36
Oh, I feel like a four.
Dr Rad 46:38
Okay, fine.
Dr G 46:38
You know, give them two each.
Dr Rad 46:39
Right. Okay, done.
Dr G 46:43
Expansion.
Dr Rad 46:44
No. Feels like a really long time since we had some fresh territory.
Dr G 46:51
Oh, Rome, Rome, Rome. When shall you'll be great? Never. That's a zero. Okay, the fourth category is virtus.
Dr Rad 47:00
Hmmm. Look, there's some interesting behaviour going on here, I'll give you that. But I don't think any of it qualifies as virtus.
Dr G 47:07
I would say that perhaps the very selfless defence of Sempronius by the four tribune of the plebs who served under him under a disastrous campaign, and that filial parallel that they make? That the commander is akin to their father.
Dr Rad 47:25
Yeah.
Dr G 47:25
Fascinating stuff. I feel like that's got a bit of virtus in it.
Dr Rad 47:28
Okay. Okay. I'm not gonna give them a lot. Maybe like a two? I don't know. It seems like an empty gesture.
Dr G 47:38
Yeah. Look.
Dr Rad 47:39
Hortensius was fake anyway!
Dr G 47:41
Talking you into it, aren't I? But I do think there is some element of virtus there because of that parallel with with pietas, so yeah, I don't mind if it's low. I'm not wedded to a number on this one. I don't, I don't have a strong feeling one way or the other. But yeah, I think something,
Dr Rad 47:57
I think it would make a mockery of all Romans who threw themselves into the heat of battle-
Dr G 48:03
gained their wound on the front-
Dr Rad 48:04
and got slaughted. And these guys just said, “Hey, maybe we'll wear some different clothes.” So I feel like a two is fair.
Dr G 48:13
He threw on his best black dress, and I'm calling that virtue. And our final category is the citizen score.
Dr Rad 48:24
Citizens remarkably absent from all this bickering going on, but I feel like it can't be pleasant for them.
Dr G 48:32
Look, they've had some maybe they've been involved in this Aequian situation.
Dr Rad 48:37
They would definitely had to have been.
Dr G 48:38
That would have wouldn't have been great, but they did win. So that could have been worse.
Dr Rad 48:42
Yeah, exactly. Yeah.
Dr G 48:43
But then also, if we've got now for quaestors, and two can be drawn from the plebeian class. That seems like there's the potential for greater representation.
Dr Rad 48:53
True. Always the potential though, isn't it?
Dr G 48:57
I'm emphasising the potential. I've been reading a little bit of Rome's history. And I'm not feeling confident that we're going to see two quaestors.
Dr Rad 49:06
Maybe a three. Like, you know, I mean, it's not they're not really explicitly mentioned, which makes me think that nothing particularly out of the ordinary is happening, either good or bad.
Dr G 49:19
All right. All right. I'm happy to go with that.
Dr Rad 49:21
Okay. That means, Dr G., that we ended up with a grand total of 12 Golden Eagles for Rome, and that's over two years, so that's even more pathetic than it sounds.
Dr G 49:34
Oh, Rome. Well, okay.
Dr Rad 49:38
I am very excited though, for you. Because if you join me next episode, Dr. G.
Dr G 49:43
Oh, boy, I'm very excited. There are things on the horizon. Stay tuned listeners.
Dr Rad 49:48
I just gonna say one word: Vestals.
Dr G 49:51
Yes. Hold that thought in your mind. Yeah. Well, before we go, I'd like to thank all of our patrons who are are marvellous and wonderful, and encourage anybody who enjoys our work to think about supporting us as well. We'd love to have you.
Dr Rad 50:08
Why not? Why not? Why not make this a full time gig so that we can really speed through Rome's history at a much faster pace than we have so far.
Dr G 50:17
But also, if you're fiscally doing it tough, which I totally understand, and, you know, podcasts are a fabulous free resource. We'd love to have a review written by you if you enjoy our work, because those reviews actually make our day every time we see them.
Dr Rad 50:33
They absolutely do. And you can also just tell someone old school style about the show and say, “Give it a listen.”
Dr G 50:40
“See what you think.”
Dr Rad 50:42
Exactly, yes.
Dr G 50:44
All right. Well, it has been, as always an absolute pleasure to chat with you, Dr. Rad.
Dr Rad 50:50
Agree Dr. G. Now for anyone who wants to know all that our sources for this episode and our credits, please check out our website. That's where we post it all. And our music is by Bettina Joy de Guzman.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/
Support the show
Patreon
Ko-Fi
Read our books
Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome
Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
This episode we return to the ‘Golden Age of Hollywood’ with a classic sword and sandal epic, Quo Vadis (1951). This film is available through many streaming platforms and we highly recommend revisiting it.
In Part One of two episodes on Quo Vadis, we examine the context for the film and the plot.
Quo Vadis (1951) helped to ignite Hollywood’s passion for ancient epics in this decade. It was a smash hit with some of the legendary stars of the era, including Robert Taylor, Deborah Kerr and Peter Ustinov. This film is not only epic in terms of length, but in terms of all the aspects that you could discuss in connection with it.
Special Episode – Quo Vadis (1951) – Part One
ResistanceThe tale itself has a lengthy backstory which takes us all the way back to 19th century Poland. Henryk Sienkiewicz wrote the book in a serialised format between 1894-1896. Poland had been going a through a tough time over the course of the preceding century, in the sense that it did not exist independently between 1795 and 1918. During this period, the Catholic Church was crucial in preserving Polish culture. Sienkiewicz often wrote historical novels that would lift the spirits of his fellow poles, and Quo Vadis was no exception. For Sienkiewicz, the triumph of Christian characters such as Lygia and Ursus (meant to be from Lugii, i.e. Poland) represent the ultimate triumph of Poland over its cruel oppressors, with Nero representing nations such as Russia, Austro-Hungary and Prussia.
Sienkiewicz’s novel was well-received, and was therefore adapted into toga plays, operas, and several films. The earlier film versions were made in Europe, including the notable 1912 silent classic.
Join us for the fascinating background of the 1951 film and stay tuned for Part Two!
Quo Vadis – Roll Call!There are a LOT of characters to keep track of in a film of this length, so if you need a handy reference, check out the cast list on IMDB.
The main people that you need to know for our episode include:
LygiaFictional main lady love interest. Christian, hostage-turned-adoptive daughter of Roman general Aulus Plautus, and his wife, Pomponia Graecina.
Marcus ViniciusFictional main manly love interest. Roman, not Christian (yet). Militaristic, aggressive to start, turns all moral as the film progresses.
Lygia (Deborah Kerr) and Marcus Vinicius (Robert Taylor) in the courtyard of her adoptive parents' home in Rome.
Source: FilmAffinity.
Historical figure. Really was Roman emperor from 54-68 CE. Known as the last emperor of the Julio-Claudian dynasty. Really was terrible, although maybe not quite as unrelentingly awful as many suggest – including this film. Probably not as amusing as Peter Ustinov!
A gold coin showing the obverse portrait of Nero.Bust of the historical NeroPeter Ustinov as Nero in Quo Vadis (1951)Poppaea SabinaHistorical figure. Elite Roman lady. Complicated love life. Winds up as Nero’s second wife. Called beautiful but awful in the surviving sources. We say – the jury is out on that one. Typical fun, adulteress type character used to contrast to the ‘good girl’, Lygia. Historically, she is murdered by Nero while pregnant with their child. In Quo Vadis, Nero strangles her. An awful demise in reality and in film.
Statue of the historical Poppaea Sabina found in Olympia, GreecePatricia Laffan as Poppaea Sabina in Quo Vadis (1951)Petronius (Gaius Petronius Arbiter)Historical figure. Served as governor of Bithynia and was consul in either 62 or 63 CE. Did a decent job, but in his personal life seems to have made pleasure his main goal. Dubbed the ‘Arbiter of Elegance’ by Nero. Accused of being part of a conspiracy against Nero and suicided whilst chatting casually to friends. Thought to be the author of the novel, The Satyricon, which is a very unusual piece because it does NOT focus on the elite and is pretty … eye-opening. Possibly makes fun of Nero through the gross figure of Trimalchio, a freedmen who has become a wealthy show-off with no taste. Close associate of Nero. In the movie, Petronius is Vinicius’ uncle and an elegant, witty, intelligent member of Emperor Nero’s inner-circle. He also has a weird obsession with the enslaved Eunice…
From left: Petronius (Leo Genn) attempting to advise Nero (Peter Ustinov) in a scene from Quo Vadis (1951).
Image source: FilmFanatic
Fictional character. Bodyguard of Lygia, Christian convert. Super strong.
PeterThat’s St Peter to you! Follower of Jesus Christ. Christian (to state the obvious). Supposedly was crucified upside down, making him a martyr, which Sienkiewicz worked into his novel. Has a very famous domed building named after him.
Pomponia GraecinaHistorical figure. Elite Roman lady who was related to the Julio-Claudian dynasty. Mentioned by Tacitus for her ballsy behaviour. She wore mourning for DECADES after Julia was bumped off by Messalina, which could have led to her own downfall, but Claudius did not punish her. (Julia Livia, granddaughter of Tiberius, daughter of Livilla and Drusus Caesar – mother of Rubellius Plautus). Her husband was told to deal with her privately after she was charged for believing in an “alien superstition”, which some have taken to mean she dabbled in Christianity. Good choice to turn into a character with Christian leanings in Quo Vadis! Adoptive mother of Lygia in the film. V V Virtuous.
Aulus PlautiusHistorical figure. Really was a Roman general who won an ovation for a campaign in Britain. Really married to Pomponia Graecina.
ActeHistorical figure. An imperial freedwoman that teenage Nero fell for HARD, much to his mother’s displeasure. Suetonius reports that she was one of the few to attend the interment of his ashes, so her devotion in the film tracks. In the film, not a Christian but still a good woman as she is virtuous and loyal. As the movie is set late in Nero’s reign, it makes sense that he has moved on from her by now. Sympathetic to Christians, so that’s something. Is in love with Nero but keeps it real with him. Helps him to commit suicide when everyone else has abandoned him. A good choice, as Nero’s suicide was supposedly aided by his slave.
EuniceFictional enslaved woman. For reasons that make absolutely no sense, she has a crush on her master, Petronius. He eventually loves her back – depends on the version of Quo Vadis that you consult as to how that happens. It's fair to say, we're not keen on her storyline.
Sound CreditsThanks to the fabulous Bettina Joy de Guzman for our theme music.
Our SourcesThe classic film poster for Quo Vadis, the Roman and Christian epic!
Image course: Wikipedia.
Interested in how Rome is depicted on screen? Check out our back catalogue where we cover films and television.
Automated TranscriptEdited for clarity! The AI does seem to have challenges with both Latin and Australian accents!
Dr Rad 0:08
Welcome to this special episode of The Partial Historians. I'm Dr. Rad and normally Dr. G and I discuss the history of Rome from the founding of the city. But today we begin a deep dive into Quo Vadis 1951. We ended up talking for so long about this epic that we have split the episode into two parts. This is part one of our coverage of Quo Vadis, in which we will examine the context and the plot. We hope that you enjoy this sword and sandal classic as much as we did.
Dr G 0:54
Hello, and welcome to this very special episode of the Partial Historians. I am Dr. G
Dr Rad 1:03
And I am Dr. Rad.
Dr G 1:05
And we are so excited because we're going to be talking about the film, the film,
Dr Rad 1:12
Indeed
Dr G 1:13
Quo Vadis.
Dr Rad 1:14
Yes. And now we have talked about this on someone else's podcast before but it was years ago really a long time ago. We've never done it just the two of us. So we thought we would revisit because as our time of recording it is Easter.
Dr G 1:29
It is Easter. And we did have a special request come through from one of our supporters. So shout out to you.
Dr Rad 1:37
Yeah
Dr G 1:38
This is Quo Vadis
Dr Rad 1:40
Indeed
Dr G 1:40
From us.
Dr Rad 1:41
So Quo Vadis is one of the biggest blockbuster films – sword and sandals – of the 1950s it really kicks off the decade.
Dr G 1:53
I was gonna say this is 1951.
Dr Rad 1:55
Exactly.
Dr G 1:56
And boy is the bar set high. Because this film is probably what just as long as “The Fall of the Roman Empire”. But better, like I didn't get bored.
Dr Rad 2:04
Ah, that's good to hear! Well see, I never know how people are going to respond to all these different ones. But yes, it was definitely I think the film that kind of set the tone for the decade you know, had Hollywood chasing the ruins constantly like this is where we're going to make money people. This is how we're going to save our industry. But it didn't just come out of nowhere, Dr. G. So I thought before we actually talk about the 1951 film, we have to acknowledge some of the background.
Dr G 2:35
Ah a true historian you are
Dr Rad 2:37
Can't help myself, because this is actually based on a blockbuster novel.
Dr G 2:44
Yes. And the success of the novel is part of what engenders the film.
Dr Rad 2:48
Exactly, exactly. So it was written in the 19th century like right at the end, it was appearing in sort of a serialised version between 1894 and 1896. Originally written in Polish, because the author was Polish. And unsurprisingly, so far makes sense. Yeah, his name was Henryk Sienkiewicz. I think that's how you pronounce it anyway. And he he was known for writing quite a few novels, basically historical novels, generally ones that I think, showed the Polish people in a way that was going to lift morale for the people of his own time. And that I think, has a lot to do with what Poland was dealing with at this point in time. And I'll come to that in a moment. But essentially, in this particular book that he was writing, it's meant to be that the Christians kind of stand for, like the very earliest version of the Catholic Church, which had come to be very important for representing Polish interests against the other nations that wanted to control Poland at this point in time.
Dr G 2:48
Fair enough. Fair enough.
Dr Rad 3:58
Yeah. But I think also, it was also maybe sparked by the fact that there were large scale excavations going on in Rome at around the time that he was writing as well, from about 1870 to 1914.
Dr G 4:14
There's lots of things being uncovered. And lots of exciting finds being shared across Europe.
Dr Rad 4:19
Indeed, yeah, because Poland, Poland has such a sad history, there is no independent Poland between 1795 and 1918, essentially, but resistance continues throughout this entire time. And the Catholic Church is just crucial for trying to preserve Polish culture, when it's going through one of those classic periods of oppression where, you know, occupying powers are saying, “Hey, you can't speak your language. No, not even in school”, you know, so they're trying to preserve their identity and that sort of thing. So, one of the main characters of the novel is a girl called Lygia.
Dr G 4:57
And would I be right guessing that this is supposed to be a stand-in for Poland?
Dr Rad 5:00
Yes. As well as the blonde hair, yeah, as well as her kind of servant Ursus. So both of them are meant to be representing Catholic Poland and the Polish people.
Dr G 5:15
Nice. All right.
Dr Rad 5:17
And the fact that Nero does not end well in this novel is meant to be a bit of a threat, I think, against the various countries that are exploiting Poland at this point in time, namely, Russia, Austro-Hungary, and Prussia, not to be confused with Russia.
Dr G 5:37
All of whom would be utilising Roman symbolism as part of their regalia as part of their politics. So this is not a huge jump for the imagination of the Polish reader to be like, “Oh, I see where you're going here.”
Dr Rad 5:52
Yeah, definitely. So I just thought that was really interesting to note and Quo Vadis, did become an international bestseller was published in many different translations. So lots of people end up becoming familiar with this particular work. In fact, in 1905, Sienkiewicz, our author, was awarded the Nobel Prize for Literature
Dr G 6:12
Well, but not for Quo Vadis? For something else?
Dr Rad 6:15
I actually feel like it was for Quop Vadis, but now I'm doubting myself. Maybe it's just the way I've organised my notes where I'm like Quo Vadis, international bestseller, awarded Nobel Prize. Either way, he's a good writer.
Dr G 6:31
He's doing well for himself.
Dr Rad 6:32
Yeah, people are captured by the story. And it ends up being adapted many times into plays into operas. And eventually, there are multiple film versions of this particular novel. I thought it might be a good point, however, to pause and talk a little bit about when this is supposedly set. The context.
Dr G 6:54
Yeah, so we've got – we're in the late period of Nero's reign, from what we can tell.
Dr Rad 7:02
Yeah.
Dr G 7:03
There is the story of Agrippina, his mother, already having been knocked off.
Dr Rad 7:09
Yes.
Dr G 7:09
He's also gotten rid of Octavia.
Dr Rad 7:13
First one.
Dr G 7:13
Yes. And he's now married to somebody called Poppaea.
Dr Rad 7:19
Yes. So Nero, Nero is someone who's pretty infamous. But just in case you don't know who the Emperor Nero is – and that's completely fine – he is part of the Julio-Claudian dynasty, draw their descent from well, I mean,
Dr G 7:33
Julius Caesar, ultimately, but most people leverage the connection to Augustus.
Dr Rad 7:38
I was going to say, it's really Augustus they're concerned about and one of the Claudian gens.
Dr G 7:43
One of those Claudians. One of them in there somewhere.
Dr Rad 7:47
That blended together in this amazing McFlurry of a family. And Nero when he comes to power in 54. See, he is a teenager, about 16 years old about to turn 17 when he comes into power. And if you're thinking to yourself, I don't think I trust teenagers with that much power. You'd be correct.
Dr G 8:10
Yes, you shouldn't. And we don't recommend putting them into power that young because, well, there's plenty of historical evidence to suggest they cannot handle the heady heights of power at that age.
Dr Rad 8:21
Yeah, particularly when you have a mother who, whilst amazing is extremely dominating, like Agrippina the Younger, who may very well have committed murder of her awn uncle slash husband, in order to make you emperor.
Dr G 8:35
Oft!
Dr Rad 8:36
Yeah. So in spite of all of this, allegedly, the first few years of Nero's reign started. Yeah, well, I suppose you could say.
Dr G 8:46
There is talk of the five good years of Nero.
Dr Rad 8:50
Yeah.
Dr G 8:50
Where he's following his advisers. He's got a few: Seneca is probably the most famous of them.
Dr Rad 8:56
Yeah.
Dr G 8:57
And Agrippina seems to also be a moderating maternal force. She may be quite domineering, but Nero seems to –
Dr Rad 9:06
Sometimes it's a good thing
Dr G 9:06
Dr Rad 9:09
Yeah. And Burrus head of his Praetorian Guard set. Yeah, absolutely. All these people seem to be actually the ones calling the shots. And that's from the good thing, because I don't think Nero is particularly interested in the reality of politics. He's okay with the benefits, but I don't think he's super interested in ruling per se. Unless it's like, get me another eunuch.
Dr G 9:38
Yeah, look, he's young. He's got a lot to learn and maybe he steps into leadership in a slightly bigger way as time goes on. Certainly he makes a play to be the one who gets to decide things ultimately, and we see the shift away from what is thought of as the five good years into like, “Oh, Nero's in charge now.”
Dr Rad 9:59
Yeah,
Dr G 10:00
“Oh, well then!”
Dr Rad 10:01
How's that gonna go for everyone? Not Great.
Dr G 10:04
Look, if this film is anything to go by: pretty terribly.
Dr Rad 10:09
The historical accuracy we will get to that in a sec. But yeah, the major I think signs of like a turning point is that number one in 59 CE Agrippina the Younger is murdered by Nero. And I don't think anybody disputes that.
Dr G 10:23
Everybody seems to credit him as being the killer. Yeah, there are various methods and when the collapsible boat doesn't work out, he moves on to more fatal measures.
Dr Rad 10:35
More straightforward, certainly. And then a few years after that, Burrus dies. And Seneca also appears to take a step back, maybe because he's losing influence. And this is around the time that his marriage falls apart with Octavia, his first wife is very popular with the people and also one of his relatives. Creepy. Yes, but let's not dwell on it.
Dr G 11:00
Pretty normal for the Julio-Claudians.
Dr Rad 11:02
Yeah, exactly. They could look they could be closer related, let's just say, and he starts hanging out with this other elite woman who's apparently far more depraved Poppaea Sabina. Eventually, she will become his next wife. But he starts making more audacious moves after 62 – not just because he gets rid of Octavia and when I say it gets rid of her he doesn't just divorce her. He also puts her to death in a really terrible way, which does not win him any friends. But in 64, we start to see Nero performing publicly on stage which is a real no-no for anyone in the elite, but particularly the emperor.
Dr G 11:40
Ah, yeah. So Nero has this reputation as somebody who enjoys the arts, enjoys the theatre. And while you might think to yourself, well, they're innocent diversions, and many people enjoy the theatre and the arts
Dr Rad 11:54
Without being raving psychopathic murderer and mother.
Dr G 11:57
It's not quite the same in ancient Rome, some forms of entertainment are considered very low brow. And for Nero himself to be a stage performer is considered well outside the bounds of what is morally and socially acceptable for somebody of an elite stature.
Dr Rad 12:19
Oh, definitely. And I think it also has to do with the idea of putting yourself publicly on display in that way, like using your body in that kind of a way
Dr G 12:28
Oh, hello.
Dr Rad 12:29
Yeah, it just it just ugh.
Dr G 12:31
But apparently, he counted himself as being quite the artiste. Yeah, a bit of a singer. Yeah, a bit of a instrumentalist.
Dr Rad 12:37
Oh, what can't you do, Dr. G, is really the question? Or at least what won't he pretend he can't do.
Dr G 12:44
The other problem with this kind of thing is from a Roman perspective is these kinds of pursuits are also seen as being a little bit too Greek.
Dr Rad 12:52
Yes. And we know that Nero seems to have been very fond of Greek culture.
Dr G 12:56
And yes, for the Romans, this is concerning because they feel the Greeks are a little bit too effeminate for their liking.
Dr Rad 13:04
Way too soft. That's not how you conquer the world – can be tough. The Romans, apparently, yeah. Anyway, it's in at 65 that we have the Great Fire of Rome, we'll get to that. I'm not going to talk about the accuracy of this event right now. I mean, there is a fire. Don't get me wrong. That's true.
Dr G 13:20
Rome definitely suffers from a fire and there's definitely a rebuilding programme which Nero leads.
Dr Rad 13:25
Yeah. So there's a very big fire very damaging, not uncommon to have a fire and we're in but a fire on this scale is unusual. And then of course, we have one of the largest and probably better known conspiracy against your in that same year, the Pisonian conspiracy. However, Nero still –
Dr G 13:46
He survived!
Dr Rad 13:47
Yeah, he performs at the Neronia, a Greek festival he throws.
Dr G 13:53
Named after himself, Oh, how sweet!
Dr Rad 13:55
I think we're getting a bit of a feel for him so far. And then we see a real degeneration. I think after this point, you see the death of Poppaea also, allegedly, because of Nero's actions, he murders her, with the plague in Rome in 66 CE, which, again, is not Nero's fault, but it's not great. And many people are being put to death in this year. On top of that, nothing to do with the plague, just because of the conspiracy of the previous year. And if that weren't enough, there's another conspiracy in 66. Nero still goes on holiday in Greece. And there's a revolt in Judea.
Dr G 13:55
Ah yes.
Dr Rad 13:58
Yeah, which isn't great. And then in 67 CE, we start to see the execution of very competent and popular generals like a guy called Corbulo, which doesn't again, win Nero any friends, and finally in 68, this is where we're going to see one of the more notable revolts against Nero, mostly because it's successful and near will eventually be ousted from power and commit suicide.
He comes to a sticky end.
Yeah. So that's just a bit of a rough context. For those of you who don't know Nero particularly well about when Quo Vadis is set because Quo Vadis is taking place in these latter years as you said.
Dr G 15:15
Yeah, we're definitely in the post five good years by the time we see Nero on screen in Quo Vadis. He is married to Poppaea Sabina. Yeah. And that is where all of this is heading. And we also see the way that Nero was constructed in this film is very much in service of the broader Christianizing narrative, which is the dominant narrative for this whole film.
Dr Rad 15:41
I'm so glad you said that Dr. G, because one of the things I wanted to mention is that, I think one of the forms of adaptation that has a real legacy in the films that we see toga plays. Now toga plays were very popular in the 19th century, and even I think, into the early 20th century, to be honest, the Quo Vadis versions were not necessarily themselves, like huge smash hits like they did, okay. But the hallmarks of a toga play, I think you can see in the film version, so for example, the fact that you have to have this kind of generic Christianity, because you don't want to specialise or get specific, because that way, everyone who's even remotely Christian can endorse the film as being, you know, leading the way with Christianity and that sort of thing. But perhaps more important than that, even are the female characterizations that you tend to see spring up in toga plays. So you often have a Christian female in these productions, who is self-sacrificing, domestic, and she has a interesting influence over the more aggressive, perhaps bolder, smarter, even funnier, perhaps even more attractive male in the story.
Dr G 17:03
Well, well, well, I think there's also some interesting parallels to be drawn between the way that these kinds of films and it sounds like these toga plays as well, that I'm less familiar with, are also doing a very similar thing to the way that Christian philosophical literature from the second and third century CE are doing in terms of building a convincing case for why it would be good for you to also be Christian.
Dr Rad 17:29
Yes, definitely. Well, I think that's the interesting thing about toga plays, and then sword and sound type films or, you know, just films about Rome in general, in that Rome, for both the British and North Americans in the Victorian age, they're often the bad guys in these sorts of things, you know, these toga plays in the early films, and even the later films, to be honest. But even though they're the bad guys, and therefore they are the other, because of course, Britain and North America see themselves as being on the side of Christianity. But at the same time, there's obviously got to be a lot that they recognise in themselves in terms of empire: wanting power wanting conquest, you know, the pillars of civilization.
Dr G 18:16
Oh, it's the duelling sides of the soul, isn't it? It's that desire for the material gain that Rome represents so well. Yeah. And I think spiritual richness of the Christian soul.
Dr Rad 18:28
Yeah. And I always have this phrase in my head, which I didn't actually need you to write it down, even though I have to because it really stood out for me when I was doing my research into this kind of stuff from Mayer and he says Rome and its empire were painfully familiar. I think that always sums up very well the kind of relationship that the British and American audiences are going to continue to have with Rome. Now, of course, Quo Vadis, does make it to the screen very early, in fact, and it has been adapted many times. We're focusing on the 1951 version, but there are a couple of silent versions and there was a version from 2001. That was a mini series in 1985. You know, Quo Vadis is one of those ones that people keep going back to, like Ben Hur. And as we know, Hollywood likes to repeat success story.
Dr G 19:16
They certainly do.
Dr Rad 19:17
Hey, this works. And I think it has a lot to do with the fact that Nero's reign really works on a Hollywood level, because it allows you to have this extravaganza of consumption and excess and lavishness on the screen whilst also being like it's not cool.
Dr G 19:40
Oh, guys, don't do do this. Look on but a heaven forfend that you do this?
Dr Rad 19:49
Yeah, exactly. So there was a very famous version in 1912, directed by Enrico Guazzoni. And this is generally seen as a pretty spectacular early film, you know, because they're still experimenting with the the medium and that sort of thing. So it's seen as having some really interesting technological innovations, which makes the story I think, much more powerful. And then we have another version in 1925, which is also interesting, because of course, it's like the rise of fascism is happening in that at that point in time. So it's not overly influenced by that. But anyway, but we do want to focus on the 1951 version today. So let's skip ahead to that. Shall we talk about the general plot of the 1951 version is a bit different to the novel.
Dr G 20:38
All right. So Quo Vadis, 1951. So we've got essentially a cast of our Roman characters and our Christian characters. Yes. And we start with our Romans, we've got a Roman commander coming back to Rome, yeah, as you should, after successfully leading these legions over in Britain or whatnot. And where this sort of takes off is that he's not allowed to go into the city straightaway, he's got to camp outside. And he finds out later that this is for good reasons. Nero wants to put on a proper display with a whole bunch of legions and commanders coming back soon. But this means that our main character Marcus Vinicius has to end up staying with a friend, rather than popping home and doing his own thing.
Dr Rad 21:25
Awkward crashing on the triclinium.
Dr G 21:27
Yeah. And it's a guy that he's known for a long time, used to be a Roman commander himself. So they've got a history there. And that's nice. But what seems to have happened that maybe Vinicius has hasn't picked up on between the last time he saw this guy is that this family has become Christian.
Dr Rad 21:43
Gasphow disgusting!
Dr G 21:47
You know, he kind of doesn't come into this knowledge for quite some time. He's –
Dr Rad 21:51
They're secretive!
Dr G 21:52
Yeah, he's pretty oblivious and they're really not being overt about it. They're not being like, “Ooh, something new in town. Have you tried Christianity?” They've been very calm, very quiet. And it's during this moment that Vinicius is also runs into their daughter, the daughter of this guy and his wife, Lygia, in the household. And he's like, you know, every time the camera pans to her, it's a Vaseline moment. She is. It is incredible. But he immediately starts to deploy his – what I think he thinks is charismatic charm – but is really Roman boorishness.
Dr Rad 22:32
Well for particularly someone like her and she's, she's an interesting character because she is meant to be a hostage of the Lygian king, but she's become like a daughter to these people.
Dr G 22:42
Well, she's – they say – that she's been adopted.
Dr Rad 22:45
Yes, exactly.
Dr G 22:46
And they've taken her in as their own.
Dr Rad 22:48
Yeah
Dr G 22:48
But she is a hostage of a foreign kingdom. And she does have a bodyguard, who's also from a kingdom who also lives in the household. Yeah, and this whole arrangement is very interesting. But also Vinicius is kind of like just sort of like tramples all over things, tries to do a bit of a clumsy seduction. After he's just seen her for the first time. And she's not having a bar of that.
Dr Rad 23:12
Yeah.
Dr G 23:12
Which is fair enough. Smart move, lady. But this means that a friction has been set up where because Vinicius has been denied, in this very sort of materialistic Roman way that they're being characterised, you start to develop this thing, “Well, if I can't have it, I really want it.” And, and this colours, a whole bunch of things.
Dr Rad 23:32
Yeah.
Dr G 23:33
So this leads him to create a scenario through his contacts with Nero to have Lygia transferred out of that household. He finds out that she's the hostage. Yeah, he's like, what do we know about how hostage law works? And they're like, well –
Dr Rad 23:49
Sneaky bastard!
Dr G 23:50
Yeah, if the emperor says so. I mean, the hostage can be transferred to a different household. Yeah. So Vinicius sets this up. So Lygia is first of all ripped out of the home that she has come to know
Dr Rad 24:02
Totally going to win her over. 100%.
Dr G 24:04
Definitely. Yeah. She gets gussied up at the Imperial Palace into some fancy dress.
Dr Rad 24:08
I think you mean, she gets slut-ified.
Dr G 24:12
They put her in a very nice gown.
Dr Rad 24:15
Yeah, I don't think she's too comfortable in it. It's too revealing.
Dr G 24:18
Too revealing and maybe a little bit too shiny. Yeah. And they put her on display in front of the emperor at a sort of a dinner party situation where Vinicius is like, “you look ravishing”, and she's like, “What? Why am I even here? Like, I've just been ripped from my family, like, whatever.” Yeah. And he's like, “Oh, well, the good news is I did that.” And she's like, “Excuse me?. And he's like, “So your mine now by imperial decree. Did you know?” And she's like, “Oh. My. God.”
Dr Rad 24:49
This guy can't take a hint!
Dr G 24:52
She finds a way to escape essentially from that situation. Yeah. Nero is kind of oblivious and doing his own thing in the meantime, and I think this is an important subplot, Poppaea has spotted Vinicius and she's like, “Well, he looks pretty hot.”
Dr Rad 25:07
Oh, yes.
Dr G 25:08
And her reputation for debauchery knows no bounds. So everybody's kind of like they're not really surprised when she tries to sort of she calls him over for a bit of a chat. Yeah. Nero doesn't seem perplexed about this kind of thing at all, like Poppaea is being Poppaea. She's an interesting one.
Dr Rad 25:24
This is just how women act. Yeah. May want me?
Dr G 25:28
My tiger, my cheetah. So she does a bit of a thing where she makes sure Vinicius knows that she's interested in him. Yes. And he's like, Okay, that's cool. But my chick's over there. Then she disappears. Lygia is sort of whisked away. And secreted away. And it turns out –
Dr Rad 25:47
This has something to do with Acte, doesn't it?
Dr G 25:49
Yes.
Dr Rad 25:49
Yeah. Acte is actually a historical person. Yes. Yeah. Actually, as her [Lygia's] adoptive parents, I should say. Yeah. Acte is mentioned in connection with Nero.
Dr G 26:01
Yeah. Acte is somebody who is written about in the source material as being one of these people that he has a relationship with. And she's an actress. I think
Dr Rad 26:11
I actually thought she was a freed woman or a slave?
Dr G 26:15
Yeah, there's something going on there. She has, she loves she has very low status, but they have a connection. And she is written about. And in the film, she sort of running the sort of the ladies of the household. She's kind of like a high up sort of servant it would seem.
Dr Rad 26:31
Yeah. And but she's obviously madly in love. With Nero.
Dr G 26:35
Still in love with Nero. Nero no longer seems to care. He's moved on – Poppaea is where it's at.
Dr Rad 26:40
Yeah, hashtag move on.
Dr G 26:43
And Acte is very implicated in the escape of Lygia. Yes. From the imperial palace. She shows Lygia the sign of the fish.
Yeah. But she's not a Christian herself?
No, but she she's sympathetic.
Dr Rad 26:56
Yeah. And again, this kind of ties in with what we know about early Christianity in that it does seem to been something that I think appeals to those lower down the social scale, rather than those at the top.
Dr G 27:09
And so we find out that the Christians are sort of getting together in the caves on the outskirts of the city. Maybe they're catacombs, maybe they're not, but they're getting together underground. And it's in this sort of moment. That Peter turns up.
Dr Rad 27:28
As in St. Peter, not Dr. G.
Dr G 27:30
I didn't turn up. You can look for that cameo You shall not find it. St. Peter turns up and he gives a bit of a sermon. And at that sermon, Marcus Vinicius, by this point, has figured out that she's been taken by the Christians and whisked away and he's found a way to infiltrate into the cave and the meeting. So he gets gets to hear this sermon as well. He doesn't really buy into the Christianity stuff, but he's certainly hearing some different material –
Dr Rad 28:00
Yeah
Dr G 28:01
Dr Rad 28:27
She's easily spotted.
Dr G 28:29
Ursus the, which lighting Latin for Bear, which is beautiful, because he's a big, tall, strong guy. He's like, “I can hear people following us.” And she's like, “Whaaat?”, and he's like, “No, seriously. You go. Yeah, you go ahead, and I'll wait here.” And so he catches them unawares manages to kill the gladiator that Vinicius has hired to be his strong man for the night. He's Greek friend who helped him infiltrate the cave runs away.
Dr Rad 28:58
Of course.
Dr G 28:58
And Vinicius gets sort of a smoosh on the head and Ursus takes him to where they're hiding Lygia. So they're staying in somebody else's place. Yeah. And it's pretty clear from the architecture that this is a bit of step down for her. Yeah, this is not the former general's household
Dr Rad 29:16
But she's cool with it because she's Christian.
Dr G 29:17
She's very Christian. She doesn't mind. They've created a cross out of two sticks tied together. And that's good enough for her. And this moment, this is kind of one of these really pivotal scenes in this film.
Dr Rad 29:29
Such a Florence Nightingale thing.
Dr G 29:32
So pivotal, because Vinicius is like, “Why did you not kill me?”
Dr Rad 29:37
Yes.
Dr G 29:37
And Ursus is like, “Well, it's sin.” Even though he just killed a gladiator.
Dr Rad 29:41
Yeah. Yeah, him I'll kill. You on the other hand…
Dr G 29:45
“That guy was trying to kill me. So that's self defence.”
Dr Rad 29:47
Yeah.
Dr G 29:48
“Wheras you, you're already out for the count.”
Dr Rad 29:50
Yeah.
Dr G 29:51
“So anyway, so it didn't kill you.” And so there's this moment of exchange. And then Vinicius is like, “Well, you know, all of this trouble. I – I don't understand it. I'm just going to leave you to it. You're not a hostage of me anymore, Lygia, I don't care. I don't want anything to do with it anymore.” And as soon as he rejects her, yeah, this is also opening up the pathway for her to be open and honest about how she feels because she's no longer in a position of coercion. And immediately
Dr Rad 30:20
She's secretly got the hots for him!
Dr G 30:22
She's like, “but I've always loved you.” It is baffling.
Dr Rad 30:28
Yeah.
Dr G 30:29
And one can only assume it's because he's so good looking.
Dr Rad 30:32
Yeah, look, I mean, obviously, Lygia is played by Deborah Kerr, you know, she's obviously big star at this point in time. And Vinicius is paid by Robert Taylor, also a big star of the time known to be quite attractive.
Dr G 30:48
So yeah, so apparently, he's hot enough. And even though he's silly. I mean, he's really he's really only revealed himself to be very silly up until now to her, you know, it's like, you know, he's tried to seduce her by being rude to her. And then he's stolen her from her hostage family taht she likes living with.
Dr Rad 31:09
Yeah.
Dr G 31:10
And then he's trying to follow a home from a Christian gathering, like he's done nothing –
Dr Rad 31:15
But cause her pain
Dr G 31:15
Dr Rad 31:18
Yeah.
Dr G 31:19
And she's like, “But I've always…” So I think she might be talking with her downstairs rather than her upstairs at this point in time.
Dr Rad 31:25
Well, isn't that what women think with?
Dr G 31:27
Oh. Oh! And that's exciting because Vinicius is then immediately back in. He's like, “Let's do this.” Yeah.
Dr Rad 31:37
“I was just kidding. I take back everything I just said.”
Dr G 31:39
Really? Really? You're? Now you're into it? Cool. And so you can see how the, sort of like the people who play The Game, those sort of like, yeah, those pointed like, sort of those dating gurus that are sort of like quite popular in the late 90s- early 2000s. Yeah, about all of that kind of stuff like Mystery and things like that. You can see how they might have watched a film like this and being like, negging her was the thing that worked.
Dr Rad 32:08
Yeah.
Dr G 32:08
Like, that's just like, No, but you're always a terrible person. And a guy wrote this script. It's really, really clear.
Dr Rad 32:15
Yeah yeah.
Dr G 32:16
Because Lygia is just a little bit unbelievable in this moment, but they have a discussion about you know, how they're going to stay together and how it's gonna be amazing and she's like, “well, if you stay with me, you've got to believe in my faith”, and Vinicius is like “I could just be with you – you can bring whatever gods you want. I don't mind. You do you.”
Dr Rad 32:34
“The more the merrier, I'm Roman”
Dr G 32:35
Yeah, he's like “I don't mind, there's heaps of Gods – there's enough for all of us.”
Dr Rad 32:38
Yeah
Dr G 32:38
And she's like, “that's not good enough. No, you actually have to really try to buy in here.” And he's like, “What is wrong with you?” He snaps the wooden cross.
Dr Rad 32:49
“I thought we were together! Now you're saying there's all these conditions?!”
Dr G 32:53
Yeah. And he gets really mad has a temper tantrum breaks the cross throws it on the ground storms off,
Dr Rad 32:59
Like these people haven't suffered enough. For goodness sake, their cross is made of out sticks.
Dr G 33:04
So anyway, it's a that's kind of like this moment of crisis for these two.
Dr Rad 33:10
Absolutely.
Dr G 33:11
And then it kind of switches to this more Nero focused side of the story.
Dr Rad 33:17
Now we're gonna set it alight, Nero and the fire of Rome.
Dr G 33:23
In the background, while this story has been playing out between Vinicius and Lygia in the background, we've been seeing Nero doing little quirky things here and there. And he's starting to get a little bit inspired by this idea that he can't be a true artist unless he experiences the things that he wants to talk about
Dr Rad 33:42
Which to be fair,
Dr G 33:44
Is method, very method.
Dr Rad 33:45
I was gonna say kind of what some people have actually said and still practice to this day.
Dr G 33:50
Yeah, method acting never out of fashion. Nero's buying in big time.
Dr Rad 33:54
Yeah.
Dr G 33:54
There's been –
Dr Rad 33:55
You know Stanislavski, tell me about it.
Dr G 33:59
For Nero, there's this really interesting dynamic that is playing out across this whole film with his relationship with one of his advisors, Petronius, and Petronius is kind of like this – like hilarious, quasi-historical, like there is a Petronius in history.
Dr Rad 34:16
Yes. And he was a friend of Nero's. Yeah. But in this version, he's also the uncle of Marcus Vinicius.
Dr G 34:22
Yeah, they've taken some liberties and that's okay. Yeah, but Petronius is this kind of really intelligent figure who is able to say the right thing at the right time, even when it doesn't seem like it's going to be the right thing to bring Nero around to a certain perspective.
Dr Rad 34:40
Yeah. And he's definitely on damage control. Like his whole mission seems to be that I mean, very much looking at himself like
Dr G 34:48
and also looking out for his nephew, Vinicius, as well. Like Nero does have a moment where he spots Lygia and he's like, oh, wait a minute. Maybe I gave away too good a prize.
Dr Rad 34:57
Yes, exactly. Yeah. So Petronius is a all about damage control in the sense that he wants to have a pleasant life, he wants to look after his family. Standard. And then he also seems to be trying to make sure that Rome is not governed too stupidly. So he tries to always talk Nero around to something that would actually be not terrible.
Dr G 35:18
Yeah. But unfortunately for Petronius, he also seems to make maybe a slight error, where he kind of suggests that Nero needs to focus more on his art and things like that.
Dr Rad 35:27
Yeah.
Dr G 35:28
And Nero takes that up seriously, and runs with that. And the problem with that is that Nero then gets into his mind that he needs to see Rome burn in order to be able to create the Rome of his vision.
Dr Rad 35:45
Yeah. And also, you know, that idea of like, reciting a song about Troy, and, you know, writing about that, and that sort of thing, he needs to see it.
Dr G 35:54
Yeah. And it's like, so Petronius is trying to get him to sort of exceed his own capacity as an artist being like, “you know, you know, you could go beyond Homer, you know, you could go beyond Virgil.” And Nero is kind of like, “how will I do it?” Petronius is like, “you've got to live it.” And Nero's like, “well, if I have to live it, let's burn the city, so I can live the emotion of it. And then I can build it from the ground up.” And he kind of has this relationship with the people where he needs them. But he kind of dislikes them at the same time. It's kind of this sort of, they feed his sort of need for attention. But he's also kind of annoyed with the fact that they're always there and in the way.
Dr Rad 36:41
Yeah, definitely. And in this version, I think it's probably clear, there is no doubt that Nero is responsible for lighting a fire. Not personally…
Dr G 36:50
No, but they make it Yeah, yeah. And this is something that is in contradistinction to the real complexities of the ancient evidence.
Dr Rad 36:58
Yeah, which we will, we will get into
Dr G 36:59
Yes so hold that thought. But the film definitely blames Nero. He's the architect of the fire. He also has an architect with a new plan for Rome constructed for what will be built after the city has burned. So realistically, Nero is to blame here.
Dr Rad 37:13
Definitely. But he soon realised that I mean, I think only all his elite hangers-on they seem to be willing to tolerate Nero's behaviour, I think up until this point, that this is something else. And so Nero is, you know, obviously feeling very unpopular from multiple angles, and he's like, I need to do something about this, and therefore, he's going to pin it on the Christians.
Dr G 37:40
Yes. So this idea in the film comes from Poppaea.
Dr Rad 37:44
Yes, that's right.
Dr G 37:45
So we have this moment where Rome is on fire at that time, most of Nero's court is in Antium. Vinicius hears that Rome is burning, realises that Lygia is still there. And even though they've had this thing where it's like they're clearly not together and it's not working out. He's had a chain, he's realised that he has to go and save her –
Dr Rad 38:06
Of course.
Dr G 38:07
Dr Rad 38:32
Breastplates all the way.
Dr G 38:33
Yeah, and he's never thought to take them off. Even though he's not leading an army right now.
Dr Rad 38:37
Apart from that first scene there's been no reason to do so.
Dr G 38:41
There's been no, no soldiers under his command. He's just chilling out in Rome.
Dr Rad 38:44
It's for good posture.
Dr G 38:45
Yeah, look, he loves it. Yeah. And he turns up, and people are sort of like trying to push him away. But he manages to save people by redirecting them into the sewage system. That's clever. Yeah. And then he does spot Lygia. And so this is a moment of reunion and all of this sort of thing. Finally, sadly, it does not last, he does end up getting arrested as does Lygia as does Ursus as, as do a whole bunch of people
Dr Rad 39:14
who are Christian
Dr G 39:15
because they're rounded up because they are considered to be Christian.
Dr Rad 39:18
Yeah.
Dr G 39:18
Because Vinicius is hanging out with Lygia that, that doesn't help his cause at all. So he gets lumped in with them.
Dr Rad 39:18
Yeah.
Dr G 39:20
So Poppaea has had this amazing idea that the Christians will be blamed.
Dr Rad 39:24
Yeah
Dr G 39:28
For the fire. And then they will set up a whole bunch of games and put them on display in the arena.
Dr Rad 39:40
Sounds like a fabulous evening.
Dr G 39:42
It's a good Roman time out. You know what I'm saying?
Dr Rad 39:44
Yeah, totally, man.
Dr G 39:47
So there were some very dramatic scenes with a lot of lions.
Dr Rad 39:51
Yeah, well, you know, you don't want to do things half hearted.
Dr G 39:55
No, but like in terms of I'm just thinking from a like a film perspective, like they were a lot of lions showed on screen,
Dr Rad 40:02
Let's be real, I don't want to, I've never looked into it because I don't want to know what may or may not have happened on that set. This is before, really strict regulations are in place about how animals, you know, be treated by the entertainment industry. And given that we're still in an era where factory farming is somehow okay. I just don't want to look back. It's not going to be good news for anybody.
Dr G 40:25
It's fair enough. But yes, I have some concerns about how many lions were involved. Yeah. Anyway, they bring out the Christians in kind of like groups, and part of what happens in this moment of the film is Nero becomes increasingly agitated because the Christians start singing as he's, yeah, finding a moment of peace between like the moments where they're getting slaughtered.
Dr Rad 40:48
Yeah.
Dr G 40:49
And this discomforts him greatly.
Dr Rad 40:51
He doesn't understand it.
Dr G 40:52
Doesn't understand it, doesn't like it. And you know, other people are singing and he's the singer, really.
Dr Rad 40:58
Yeah. So no, I don't like living under your spotlight.
Dr G 41:09
I could see him standing up and doing that. Doing doing a sing back. A dramatic scene,
Dr Rad 41:15
Don't tell me not to live, just sit and putter.
Dr G 41:20
This kind of thing is going he's not very happy. He kind of wants to get them all out all at once and just get rid of them all. Yes. And Poppaea is like no, no, wait. And he also does an inspection of the bodies. At the end of the first day of the Christian sort of
Dr Rad 41:35
Always this creepy inspection of bodies in these films, I've realised.
Dr G 41:39
He wants to see what's going on, because a lot of them have died with smiles on their faces.
Dr Rad 41:44
Yes.
Dr G 41:45
And this creeps him out.
Dr Rad 41:46
Yeah, well,
Dr G 41:46
And fair enough. I mean people don't die with smiles on their faces usually.
Dr Rad 41:50
Not horribly in an arena, they don't.
Dr G 41:52
No.
Dr Rad 41:53
Now he has also managed to round up St. Peter as being a part of
Dr G 41:57
Well, yeah. And so I was just about to get to that. Because parallel to this, yeah. we had Peter, giving a sermon in the caves underneath Rome. Yeah. But then he seems in a an assigned plot kind of element. He seems to be leaving Rome with a young boy,
Dr Rad 42:14
Busy guy.
Dr G 42:14
yeah, busy guy, young kid, and they're on the road together, and they're heading out of the city. And Peter is in this moment where he does the famous line, “Quo Vadis, Domine?” Because he doesn't know where to go next. He doesn't know what to do next. He's seeking some guidance, and a light. The light of the sun shimmers through the trees. And it seems that the Lord speaks through the child tells him that he needs to go back to Rome. And that is how he has to save people, otherwise – either Jesus has to come back down, and then do another thing where he gets killed in Rome. And Peter's like, oh, well, we can't have that.
Dr Rad 42:58
No.
Dr G 42:58
And he also talks to the child being like, say it again. And kid's like, “I didn't say anything.”
Dr Rad 43:06
“So shut up, Mr.”
Dr G 43:07
So we know it's a miracle. So they turn around and go back to Rome. And Peter appears in the arena, and gives us a speech again, and that's when he's arrested. So he speaks on behalf of the Christians. And the crowd is kind of like laughing at him. And he gets arrested and he gets trapped in with the Christians, which is great, because that means that Peter is in the same cell as Lygia and Vinicius. And those two finally get married.
Dr Rad 43:34
What better place to tie the knot? Again, it's a bit of a trope of the genre. I mean, you know, you think about Diana, Marcellus in “The Robe” True, I don't think they actually ended up getting married per se. But you know, they got together in their moment of absolute desperation.
Dr G 43:51
Everybody gets together when they're locked up when you're on death row.
Dr Rad 43:54
Yeah.
Dr G 43:55
Like this is my best option.
Dr Rad 43:56
Yeah.
Dr G 43:57
And so they are now married, and this makes Poppaea's plan for them – because she said to Nero save those two, I've got something special,
Dr Rad 44:09
I'm sure
Dr G 44:10
And he's like, “Oh, I love your –
Dr Rad 44:11
“That man is no longer my sexual toy.”
Dr G 44:14
She's like, “Yeah, I'm feeling rejected by Vinicius. I'm definitely gonna kill him the hard way.” Yeah, she's like, “Just you wait.” They bring out Lygia all dressed up in this beautiful sort of diaphanous purple robe actually, looking gorgeous. So much Vaseline. Tie her to a post. They bring out Ursus – don't tie him to a post – and they bring Marcus Vinicius up to the imperial stage tied and chained to a metal post so he can't get down into the arena.
Dr Rad 44:43
Yeah, he's gonna have to watch her die.
Dr G 44:45
He's gonna have to watch her die. And they send out a bull.
Dr Rad 44:49
Sounds nasty.
Dr G 44:50
It's, it is nasty. I do wonder what happened to the bull. So I hope that the bull was okay.
Dr Rad 44:55
Again, I don't want to know,
Dr G 44:55
I don't really want to know either. Ursus takes down the bull. That's the essence of it.
Dr Rad 45:02
Which is an amazing feat. And obviously not what Nero was expecting. Oh, yeah.
Dr G 45:06
And somebody had said to Nero, while they were like sort of watching on, “Look, if Ursus is able to take out the bull. I mean, you'll have to let you have to let Lygia off.”
Dr Rad 45:17
Yeah. And then you know that that's in keeping with what we know about it, how the arena works. If the crowd are wowed by a particular performance, they'll probably ask the patron of the games to please spare the person. Yeah.
Dr G 45:28
And as predicted, the crowd is wild for Ursus' success. And they're like, they're all – they're all like, “yes, you have to let him off!”
Dr Rad 45:36
“Set him free! Her too! Set the, both free!”
Dr G 45:41
And Nero has his most dramatic moment of doing – almost as if he's going to go one way and with the support of the crowd, and then goes the other way. And everybody turns and it's chaos. And it's at this moment, where the other subplot that I have not mentioned, really comes into play. Yeah, so in parallel to some of this stuff happening, before Vinicius is arrested, he and Petronius are colluding together with others to get Galba into power. And so I'm finding it I'm getting emotional. I'm getting emotional. So they've organised for Galba to come with some other legions and basically depose Nero with enough signatures Galba will accept the imperial leadership.
Dr Rad 46:37
And wouldn't you know, they turn up right about now.
Dr G 46:40
Right at the moment, where Nero has decided that Ursus will have to die.
Dr Rad 46:45
Yeah.
Dr G 46:46
The army turns up.
Dr Rad 46:47
Yeah.
Dr G 46:48
In support of Galba. Are they're like, “Galba is your new emperor!” Vinicius is down there yelling to everybody, “It's over!”. And Nero has to run away. Poppaea runs away. Yeah, they go back. They retreat back to the palace. Yeah, that doesn't go well for either of them.
Dr Rad 47:05
No, because Nero blames Poppaea for this whole mess.
Dr G 47:09
Yeah, he's like, “You were the one who wanted to blame the Christians for the fire. And now look where we are.”
Dr Rad 47:13
Yeah.
Dr G 47:14
And then proceeds to strangle her, which she was not expecting.
Dr Rad 47:17
No, but is somewhat historically accurate in that Nero did murder Poppaea, but not for that reason, or in that way.
Dr G 47:25
Yes. And so Poppaea's then dead, and he sort of retreats further into the palace. And then there is this shadow in his room. And he's, like, clearly, clearly scared. Like, this. Is it? Somebody's gonna kill me? And it turns out that it's Acte.
Dr Rad 47:45
Loyal to the end. Yeah, yeah.
Dr G 47:48
She's like, “I told you, I'd be here at the end.” And he's like, “I didn't believe you. I thought I told you to go away?”
Dr Rad 47:56
Yeah. But of course, she's not there because she's gonna make everything goes away. I mean, she is just a freed woman slash slave woman slash something.
Dr G 48:07
She gives him the opportunity to take his life with dignity, rather than being trampled down by
Dr Rad 48:15
The Roman way.
Dr G 48:16
Yes. You know, do something honorable with your life.
Dr Rad 48:19
Yeah.
Dr G 48:19
He's not able to do it.
Dr Rad 48:21
No.
Dr G 48:22
He asks her to do that. And she does.
Dr Rad 48:25
Yeah.
Dr G 48:26
So that's, I think devastating for her because she's still in love with him.
Dr Rad 48:30
Yeah. But a fitting end for Nero. But of course, we do get a happy ending, because Vinicius and Lygia have managed to come out unscathed, basically, apart from maybe being traumatised, but
Dr G 48:43
And they seem to be heading out of Rome with Ursus and the kid.
Dr Rad 48:43
Yeah, they're heading to live on Vinicius' property in Sicily. The remainder of their lives undisturbed. In spite of their Christianity, I'm basing that on what the novel says.
Dr G 49:02
Nice.
Dr Rad 49:03
Yeah.
Dr G 49:04
And that's the film.
Dr Rad 49:06
Wow. And we didn't even mention that Petronius committed suicide in the midst of all that.
Dr G 49:10
Yeah. And has Seneca deliveries letter which is scathing to Nero.
Dr Rad 49:15
Yeah.
Dr G 49:15
I love the weeping vessel, “Bring the weeping vessel.” And Nero puts one tear from each eye into the jar and he's like, “Seal this, to memorialise my feelings for Petronius.”
Dr Rad 49:15
And look this is the issue with Quo Vadis. It's a it's a massive novel. It's a massive film every time you do it.
Thank you for listening to this special episode of The Partial Historians. We'd like to thank all of our patreons for their support and allowing us to make these additional episodes especially Nick, who requested a discussion of Quo Vadis. If you too would like early access to our bonus shows, please consider becoming a patreon. This has been part one of our coverage of Quo Vadis so stay tuned and Part Two. We'll be with you shortly. Our sources and credits for the episode can be found on our website. And until next time, we are yours in ancient Rome.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
For our full show notes and edited transcripts, head on over to https://partialhistorians.com/
Support the show
Patreon
Ko-Fi
Read our books
Rex: The Seven Kings of Rome
Your Cheeky Guide to the Roman Empire
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.